- #1 Aquatica
97% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Dark Geo
Windows
Aquatica is real-time RPG in the scenery of a secret underwater base. Explore the environment, find out who real its inhabitants and why you got rescue. Become one of them or escape.
Why similar: RPG 29.3%, Violent 29.3%, Action 15%, Adventure 14.9%, Indie 11.5%
- #2 Mutagen Extinction
96% match8 user reviews50% of 8 reviews2019
Dev: CyOEntertainmentPub: CyO Entertainment
Windows
Live unlimited adventures with your friends in an incredibly beautiful and extensive world, build your future and unravel the ancient arcane arts of the elderly, defend your home from mutated creatures and other survivors.
Why similar: RPG 30.4%, Violent 24.3%, Action 16.9%, Adventure 16%, Indie 12.4%
- #3 Purgatory Ashes | 炼狱灰烬
94% matchNo user reviews
Dev: BlackNoiseStudio
Windows
Purgatory Ashes is a third-person locked-in action game, and tells a story of medieval adventure
Why similar: Violent 29.5%, RPG 28.6%, Action 15.1%, Adventure 15%, Indie 11.7%
- #4 Warehouse attack
96% match5 user reviews60% of 5 reviews2020
Dev: Klubnika
Windows
This is a first person shooter game, the player ACTS as a special forces soldier.Control keys:Surrounded by enemies, the player has a variety of weapon technologies to use, and is free to explore the surrounding area or kill enemies.Players need to keep their health alive for as long as possible.
Why similar: RPG 29.5%, Violent 25.8%, Action 16.5%, Adventure 15.8%, Indie 12.5%
- #5 Cowboy
95% matchMixed40% of 25 reviews2019
Dev: Focus Entertainmen
Windows
This is a third person role-playing game,Players have swords, bows and arrows, and guns(You need to be on a horse to use it),Players are free to explore the surrounding area,Players must maintain health,Players can kill nearby monsters or dodge attacks from monsters.
Why similar: RPG 32.4%, Action 18.9%, Violent 18.1%, Adventure 17%, Indie 13.6%
- #6 Helwyr
94% match5 user reviews60% of 5 reviews2020
Dev: Samuel Wilson
Windows
Embark on an adventure traversing the town of Nevstell and its surrounding areas to uncover the dark secrets behind this world and uncover the truth behind your past.
Why similar: RPG 29.9%, Violent 25.7%, Action 16.4%, Adventure 15.7%, Indie 12.4%
- #7 The Psychic
90% matchNo user reviews2032
Dev: MuppetGame
Windows
Be a Psychic to experience a larruping adventure. Living in the foggy place and exploring the unknown. Collecting resources and discovering magic treasures. Build and expand your own castle.
Why similar: Violent 38.2%, RPG 25.1%, Action 13.3%, Adventure 13.2%, Indie 10.2%
- #8 Desert attack
92% match5 user reviews60% of 5 reviews2020
Dev: ASSEMBLY
Windows
It's a first-person shooter, and you're in a military base full of enemies,Players are free to explore the surrounding area,Players can kill enemies or evade enemy attacks,Survive as long as possible.
Why similar: Violent 30%, RPG 28.1%, Action 15.4%, Adventure 14.8%, Indie 11.8%
- #9 World Apart
93% matchMixed44% of 16 reviews2018
Dev: Eutopia Studios
Windows
World Apart is an Episodic VR Adventure. Every World Apart episode will deliver a new world to explore, each with it’s own unique story and interact-able environment. Delve deep into the conspiracy, uncover the secrets as you aid scientists, and save your world.
Why similar: RPG 30.2%, Violent 24.2%, Adventure 16.7%, Action 16.4%, Indie 12.6%
- #10 City Sniper
91% match5 user reviews40% of 5 reviews2020
Dev: Interactive
Windows
This is a first person shooting game. The player plays a soldier,Players are surrounded by enemies, and they are free to explore the surrounding areas,Players can dodge the enemy's attack, or kill the enemy to survive as much as possible.
Why similar: Violent 38.7%, RPG 24.6%, Action 13.4%, Adventure 12.9%, Indie 10.3%
- #11 Forest Woodman
91% matchMixed67% of 15 reviews2020
Dev: Frosted Wings Studio
Windows
Immerse yourself in the everyday life of a simple forester in a large northern country.
Why similar: Violent 31%, RPG 27.1%, Action 15.1%, Adventure 14.6%, Indie 11.3%
- #12 Jack troubles
89% match8 user reviews13% of 8 reviews2019
Dev: Edition
Windows
This is a first person shooter game,The player is a shooter with multiple weapons,Players are free to explore the surrounding area,Enemies are scattered around the player and inside buildings,Players can kill enemies or avoid enemy attacks and maintain health,Players can also grab enemy weapons.
Why similar: Violent 39%, RPG 24%, Action 14%, Adventure 12.6%, Indie 10.4%
- #13 Vicious Gambling Agreement
88% matchMixed42% of 12 reviews2020
Dev: FANG
Windows
Vicious Gambling Agreement,Dark and fantastic style,The difficulty has a degree of challenge,evil open punishing system to players in the fighting.It is subject to relying on weapons and fighting with many BOSS many times and then approaching to evil step by step and challenge the world governed by evil.
Why similar: Violent 35.6%, RPG 33%, Action 18%, Indie 13.4%
- #14 Heavily Armed
89% matchMixed44% of 78 reviews2017
Dev: Figurehead StudiosPub: CRASS Infotech
Windows
Median: 4.1 hrsMean: 4.8 hrs≥1hr: 99%
Heavily Armed is a 3rd person shooter with unrelenting gun battles. You play an amnesiac cyborg in the futuristic metropolis of Grid City. The goal of the game is to discover your identity and uncover the mystery of your hidden human past.
Why similar: Violent 41.2%, RPG 28.3%, Action 15.6%, Adventure 14.9%
- #15 Задолбали! (Unstoppable Man)
81% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Versus Studio
Windows
Fire started!
Why similar: Violent 44%, RPG 28.9%, Action 15.3%, Indie 11.8%
- #16 an Orc's Tale: Kriegsruf
85% matchMostly Positive80% of 40 reviews2021
Dev: Deydrihm
Windows
Die Geschichte eines jungen Orks in den Wirren eines Krieges, der zu gross für einen einzelnen Krieger ist. Storylastiges RPG im Stil der alten Klassiker, mit modernen Mitteln dargestellt, ohne den alten Charme zu verlieren mit etlichen handgestalteten Grafiken und Effekten.
Why similar: Violent 35.8%, RPG 32.9%, Adventure 17.8%, Indie 13.4%
- #17 Destiny Hunter
86% match5 user reviews40% of 5 reviews2019
Dev: TheMasterGames
Windows
Destiny Hunter is a story based RPG game in which you can control two characters, a female warrior and a female Archer. The story is about searching a better place to live and of course find your Destiny. You need to pass through cold places and reach into a better place to finish the game.
Why similar: Violent 42.3%, RPG 27.8%, Action 16.1%, Adventure 13.9%
- #18 Captured King
79% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Moin Moin Games
Windows
Follow Bjorn the Red in his jurney to rescue King Ivar and his army, in this new RPG with Roguelike elements. Epic weapons, lots of different enemies , boss battles and diferents levels awaits you in Captured King.
Why similar: Violent 38.2%, RPG 25.1%, Action 13.3%, Adventure 13.2%, Indie 10.2%
- #19 The Glade
87% match5 user reviews60% of 5 reviews2017
Dev: Kelly Studios
Windows
The Glade is an immersive first-person survival shooter game built exclusively for VR. Fight to survive increasing waves of attacking giant spiders while earning points to upgrade your weapons.
Why similar: Violent 38.4%, RPG 24%, Adventure 13.9%, Action 13.4%, Indie 10.3%
- #20 The Scarlet Chaos
80% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2024
Dev: Daydreamer
Windows
Detective Haerrison and his partner investigate a case involving a supernatural killer and a haunting entity called The Hat Man. The Scarlet Chaos is a semi-open world detective RPG with Lovecraftian mysteries to be explored.
Why similar: Violent 44.1%, RPG 28.9%, Adventure 15.2%, Indie 11.8%
- #21 A Grim Tale of Vices
77% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Born of the Mind Studios
Windows · Mac
A dark fantasy journey where you get into the shoes of a simple man, one whose life was taken and body left to rot in the wastelands... A dark goddess offers you a chance for vengeance, an evil armor and unholy magic at a very high price. Things will get violent!
Why similar: RPG 33.1%, Violent 18.9%, Action 17.5%, Adventure 17.1%, Indie 13.5%
- #22 Knights of the Drowned Table
86% matchMostly Negative33% of 12 reviews2017
Dev: RillyBoss Studios
Windows
Knights of The Drowned Table is a fully immersive Virtual Reality game releasing for both Oculus and Steam with an emphasis on humor. Players will be transported into a fantasy tavern, where they will encounter the local bar flies. Bring them a drink and they will tell you a tale.
Why similar: Violent 38.7%, RPG 24.2%, Action 13.4%, Adventure 13.3%, Indie 10.3%
- #23 zombie variant
84% matchNegative0% of 11 reviews2020
Dev: CubeJJJ
Windows
This is a first person shooting game,Players are surrounded by zombies,Players are free to explore the surrounding areas,Players can avoid zombie attacks or kill zombies, and live as long as possible.
Why similar: RPG 35.6%, Action 19.5%, Adventure 18.7%, Indie 15%, Violent 11.1%
- #24 Skautfold: Moonless Knight
83% matchVery Positive87% of 61 reviews2020
Dev: Steve GalPub: Pugware
Windows
Skautfold: Moonless Knight is a very open-ended Metroidvania, featuring a totally unique battle system. Set in an alternate history Japan in 1900, Lovecraftian horrors have plagued the world, as our very Moon opens up and becomes our end.
Why similar: RPG 34.7%, Action 18.6%, Adventure 18%, Indie 14.5%, Violent 14.2%
- #25 80S escape
84% matchNegative9% of 11 reviews2020
Dev: Studios
Windows
This is a first person shooting game,The player is a pathfinder soldier, who is free to explore the surrounding area to collect intelligence,Players can kill the enemy or avoid the enemy's attack, so as to ensure that the health value can survive for as long as possible.
Why similar: RPG 32.8%, Violent 18.3%, Action 17.9%, Adventure 17.2%, Indie 13.8%
- #26 Redneck Rampage: Possum Bayou
74% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Xatrix EntertainmentPub: Interplay
Windows · Mac
Redneck Rampage is back in Possum Bayou. this "sampler" of the game Redneck Rampage has less levels but it is more than a demo, with 7 levels of Redneck mayhem. in Possum Bayou enjoy these different types of weapons that exist including crowbars, dynamite, shotguns, electric saw, bowling ball, and others.
Why similar: Violent 35.2%, RPG 30.5%, Action 17.2%, Adventure 17.1%
- #27 Me Smart Orc
82% matchPositive93% of 14 reviews2018
Dev: Bill Ricardi
Windows
Me Smart Orc is a short Choose Your Own Adventure (CYOA) text game, set in the world of Panos. You play Lizzy, the flying lizard. Your master has tasked you with protecting Dunwart, a pain-in-the-butt apprentice mage who gets dumber every time he casts a spell. Good luck, you'll need it!
Why similar: Violent 42.9%, RPG 29.5%, Adventure 15.5%, Indie 12%
- #28 Zoroastra
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Kyrus
Windows
Zoroastra the Game is an open world action-adventure, puzzle-platformer, survival-RPG. Dive into the vast ancient mediterranean world and determine the faith of mankind. Fight for freedom, survive for salvation and solve the mysteries of Zoroastra.
Why similar: Violent 29.5%, RPG 28.6%, Action 15.1%, Adventure 15%, Indie 11.7%
- #29 UldreVoid
81% matchPositive85% of 39 reviews2020
Dev: Byron Dunwoody
Windows
UldreVoid is an action game created by a solo South African developer. Set out alone in a chaotic world to discover what lies in the Void, a monumental orb-like energy growth that changes the world around it. You must face the conflict of supernatural change while part of humanity tries to take advantage of it.
Why similar: RPG 36.1%, Action 19.5%, Adventure 18.8%, Indie 14.8%, Violent 10.8%
- #30 Orogenesis
82% matchVery Positive83% of 52 reviews2018
Dev: Samu
Windows
Orogenesis, an RPG with the twist of exploring a nightmarish and funky universe!
Why similar: Violent 43.1%, RPG 31%, Adventure 14.9%, Indie 11%
- #31 Organism8
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Derek Duong
Windows
Explore an alien planet that has been colonized by a supreme devout cyborg race that seeks dominance over existence. Organism 8 follows one of the most feared bounty hunters in the galaxy in her mission against the never ending Nekril. Take what's yours in this wolves vs wolves epic.
Why similar: Violent 29.5%, RPG 28.6%, Action 15.1%, Adventure 15%, Indie 11.7%
- #32 Seas of Fortune
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Trym Studios
Windows
Seas of Fortune is a first-person Single-player PC game that blends simulation, adventure and role-playing in an age of sail setting. Seas of Fortune captures the highs and lows of the 16th and 17th centuries.
Why similar: Violent 38.2%, RPG 25.1%, Action 13.3%, Adventure 13.2%, Indie 10.2%
- #33 patter warrior
79% match5 user reviews20% of 5 reviews2020
Dev: ElectronicPub: Electronic
Windows
This is a first person shooting game,The player plays a special soldier in a small town full of enemies,Players are free to explore the surrounding areas,Players can kill the enemy or avoid the enemy's attack, and try to keep their health value alive for a long time.
Why similar: RPG 37.2%, Action 19.9%, Adventure 19.5%, Indie 15.5%, Violent 7.9%
- #34 Purgatory Guardian
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Gamut team
Windows
In the corrupted depths of Purgatory, demons and forgotten gods rule the damned. Rise as a guardian, hunt the darkness alone, gather souls to forge powerful weapons, unlock supernatural abilities, and face creatures born from ancient sins and hidden horrors ready to strike.
Why similar: RPG 30.6%, Violent 23.8%, Action 16.2%, Adventure 16.1%, Indie 12.4%
- #35 FIL
78% matchPositive86% of 14 reviews2020
Dev: CartMart
Windows · Mac
Gallivant through the Solar System in a journey of stellar proportions in FIL to save the planets from destruction!
Why similar: RPG 37%, Violent 21.2%, Adventure 19.1%, Indie 15.3%, Action 7.3%
- #36 Eldarune: Tides of Existence
78% matchPositive85% of 13 reviews2019
Dev: Quantum Existence
Windows
Eldarune: Tides of Existence is an action game in a medieval setup. The player can use weapons, skills, dragons, and warships to defeat enemies. As the player proceeds through the story, new challenges have to be handled and many mysteries have to be illuminated.
Why similar: RPG 29.1%, Violent 29.1%, Action 15.9%, Adventure 14.4%, Indie 11.5%
- #37 Blind Blade II
77% match9 user reviews89% of 9 reviews2020
Dev: Beijing Weimo Tech
Windows
BlindBlade II is a sequel to the first-generation product. In this generation, the game has 21 extremely difficult levels. Players can only pass all the challenges if they stay focused and brave and persevering like a real samurai.
Why similar: RPG 32.6%, Violent 18.9%, Action 17.9%, Adventure 17.1%, Indie 13.5%
- #38 Heroes Of Avranche
76% matchMixed68% of 25 reviews2019
Dev: Kumova Slama
Windows · Linux
Enjoy the endless fun in endless dungeons! Uncover the truth about the destruction of the Guild and rebuild it from the ashes. Embark on epic, hand-crafted adventures as well as the random ones! Gather the best gear and defeat the toughest monsters and become the Hero of Avranche!
Why similar: RPG 30.1%, Violent 29.1%, Action 14.9%, Adventure 14.4%, Indie 11.5%
- #39 Asterion
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Glass Bear Studio
Windows
ASTERION is a 3D action and adventure game with puzzle elements, very much in the vein of Zelda games with a dash of Souls-like. You are Asterion, last in a long line of minotaurs bred to brave the dangers of the Labyrinth of Crete: an ancient, enigmatic, massive structure.
Why similar: RPG 40.1%, Action 21.9%, Adventure 21.1%, Indie 16.9%
- #40 Goodnight Succubus
66% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Nyanko Games
Windows
Aid a bedridden Succubus on her hopeless quest to live forever. Play as a young man with a call to action. Or, maybe he has other intentions? Goodnight Succubus is a nostalgia trip to the past, boasting enjoyable game play in a story-rich setting.
Why similar: RPG 40.1%, Action 21.9%, Adventure 21.1%, Indie 16.9%
- #41 Alienautics
76% match8 user reviews75% of 8 reviews2020
Dev: Imran ArafatPub: Reality Gameware
Windows
Play as a bionic supersoldier to destroy the underground colony of the Octylian regime on an alien planet. Alienautics is a cinematic third person sci fi action shooter.
Why similar: Violent 30%, RPG 28.1%, Action 15.4%, Adventure 14.8%, Indie 11.8%
- #42 Hellpoint: The Thespian Feast
74% matchMostly Positive70% of 774 reviews2020
Dev: Cradle GamesPub: tinyBuild
Windows
Median: 36 minMean: 3.9 hrs≥1hr: 37%
This is a standalone story in Hellpoint universe, a dark and challenging action RPG set in the world where the line between science and occultism is blurred. The Thespian Feast tells the story of an investigator arriving at Irid Novo station 50 years after the Hellpoint events.
Why similar: RPG 36.6%, Action 19.8%, Adventure 18.9%, Indie 14.9%, Violent 9.8%
- #43 Spartan Commander Realtime
75% matchMixed47% of 19 reviews2020
Dev: Warrior
Windows
You hold the fate of Sparta in your hands. Stand as a humble Hoplite and earn your way through the ranks as you become King of Sparta and all of Greece. Change the fate of History as you fight against Xerxes oncoming hordes and fight to win the day!
Why similar: RPG 37%, Action 19.8%, Adventure 19.4%, Indie 15.3%, Violent 8.5%
- #44 Giant Slayers
64% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Renan Reis
Windows
Who will survive the end of the world? Only the giants... and their slayers.
Why similar: RPG 39.8%, Action 22.5%, Adventure 20.9%, Indie 16.8%
- #45 Godsend
63% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Saga City Games
Windows
Godsend is an action-adventure melee slasher set during the Crusades.
Why similar: RPG 39.8%, Action 22.5%, Adventure 20.9%, Indie 16.8%
- #46 Primordium - Day Zero
73% matchMostly Negative29% of 17 reviews2019
Dev: Behron GeorgantasPub: Fractum Innovations
Windows
Fight for survival in a sci-fi RPG! Take control of the Nexus' Commander and gather companions to grow your team, build bases using a vast array of AAA quality models, and customize your arsenal using countless combinations of modular attachments, items, armor, and weapons!
Why similar: Violent 29.8%, RPG 28%, Action 15.3%, Adventure 15.2%, Indie 11.8%
- #47 Cave Brawlers
75% matchMostly Negative28% of 18 reviews2018
Dev: Samuel Arminana
Windows · Mac · Linux
Cave Brawlers is a 2D hack 'n slash which takes inspiration from games like Castle Crashers, Wonder Boy in Monster Land, and Shovel Knight. The game requires the player to use different moves and combinations to take down enemies and succeed.
Why similar: RPG 28.7%, Violent 28.3%, Action 16.2%, Adventure 15.1%, Indie 11.7%
- #48 GuildBound
62% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Pugscape
Windows
Guildbound, an immersive open-world Story RPG. Embark on epic quests, conquer dungeons, craft, build, recruit companions, and shape your character's destiny in a vast seamless world.
Why similar: RPG 40.6%, Action 21.5%, Adventure 21.3%, Indie 16.5%
- #49 Deep Dungeon: Gym
72% matchMostly Positive75% of 12 reviews2019
Dev: NORSKA
Windows
Your grandfather left you an old, abandoned gym. Can you become new Dungeon Master? Prove your strength, destroy hordes of evil men in enemy gyms
Why similar: Violent 30.5%, RPG 28.3%, Action 14.9%, Adventure 14.4%, Indie 11.9%
- #50 nan
61% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Elliott Krauts
Windows
Why similar: RPG 40.6%, Action 21.5%, Adventure 21.3%, Indie 16.5%
- #51 尸如潮水
73% matchMostly Negative29% of 17 reviews2019
Dev: 十一游戏
Windows
开放世界探险解谜类游戏(末日丧尸,第三人称射击游戏)
Why similar: Violent 30.1%, RPG 28.7%, Action 15.2%, Adventure 14.6%, Indie 11.3%
- #52 希望之星
61% matchNo user reviews
Dev: 超级无敌大鹏雕Pub: 待定
Windows
本游戏目前的游戏内容开发完成度很低,本人正在持续开发更新中,如果您期望购买后立即体验到完整的游戏体验,那么您不应该在此时购入。这是一款独立制作的横版动作角色扮演类单机游戏,玩家通过控制主角及其同伴在架空的异世界大陆中进行冒险。
Why similar: RPG 40.6%, Action 21.5%, Adventure 21.3%, Indie 16.5%
- #53 Believe: Paranormal Psychic Adventure
60% matchNo user reviews
Dev: C. Thomas PinnickPub: Nerd Overload
Windows
Believe: Psychic Paranormal Adventure is an RPG with real-time twin-stick shooting action battles! Unravel the mysteries of the universe as Todd Black, who gets abducted by aliens, given incredible psychic powers, and is the only one who can save our world from total dimensional meltdown!
Why similar: RPG 40.6%, Action 21.5%, Adventure 21.3%, Indie 16.5%
- #54 Zombie Barricades
60% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Barricade Entertainment
Windows
Zombie Barricades is a 3rd person, multiplayer RPG featuring customizable weapons, vehicles and physics! Work alone or as a team and mission through the wastelands and construct Barricades to protect yourself from the horde!
Why similar: RPG 40.6%, Action 21.5%, Adventure 21.3%, Indie 16.5%
- #55 Die Young: Prologue
70% matchMostly Positive78% of 430 reviews2019
Dev: IndieGala
Windows
Median: 1.1 hrsMean: 4.3 hrs≥1hr: 52%
Die Young: Prologue narrates events that occurred a few hours before the main story of Die Young. You play as Nehir, a field agent on a mission to kill Brother No.1. The mission failed and now you have only one desperate attempt to reach the extraction point.
Why similar: Violent 41%, Action 21.4%, Adventure 21.2%, Indie 16.4%
- #56 暴走熊孩
60% matchNo user reviews
Dev: 冰雨火独立游戏工作室
Windows
As you can preview, this game involves some cool features, such as action, adventure, rogue-like and other RPG features. By immersing yourself in the game, you might experience the adventures, build a town, gather resources, upgrade technologies, and even recruit new heroes.
Why similar: RPG 40.6%, Action 21.5%, Adventure 21.3%, Indie 16.5%
- #57 Nightmare Simulator
72% match4 user reviews0% of 4 reviews2018
Dev: INDIEPLAY
Windows
3D Horror FPS Based On Korean Folklores & Free FPS RPG DLC
Why similar: Violent 30.1%, RPG 27.3%, Action 15.4%, Adventure 15.3%, Indie 11.9%
- #58 Cold Winter Morning
70% match5 user reviews100% of 5 reviews2020
Dev: Progress GamePub: Progress Programme
Windows
"Is this justice?"
Why similar: RPG 44.3%, Adventure 23.5%, Indie 18.2%, Violent 13.5%, Singleplayer 0.5%
- #59 Deserted
63% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2023
Dev: Zebik Media Interactive Ltd.
Windows · Linux
Deserted is a stylized 3D action adventure with light RPG and narrative elements. Inspired by the alien atmosphere of Out Of This World, Deserted combines narrative storytelling with survival and fast paced strategic combat to deliver a thrilling adventure.
Why similar: RPG 39.8%, Action 21.8%, Adventure 21.6%, Indie 16.8%
- #60 Big Day
70% matchMixed57% of 148 reviews2018
Dev: Sonic ShieldPub: Zodiac Interactive
Windows · Mac
The Big Day has arrived. Blast your way through the apocalypse in this bloody pixel-art ARPG, riding through the ruins of the last days on Earth following a devastating zombie outbreak. Uncover the truth behind the crisis, find your missing daughter, and blow holes in every zombie who crosses your path!
Why similar: Violent 30.6%, RPG 27.9%, Action 15.2%, Adventure 14.2%, Indie 12.1%