- #1 White Wolf - Treasure Hunter
97% match1 user reviews0% of 1 reviews2023
Dev: AXR-STUDIOS
Windows
Action-Adventure & Strategy saving your world from Dark world that you unleashed. Quest though 5 element temples, collect items, and throw items. Unlock the hidden treasure shadow card castle.
Why similar: Strategy 32.6%, 3D Platformer 23.5%, Action 17.4%, Action-Adventure 16%, 3D 6.5%
- #2 Clowny The Great Escape
96% match5 user reviews80% of 5 reviews2026
Dev: Stazz Studio
Windows
Trapped in a nightmare house, you must escape Clowny, a blind but sound-sensitive stalker. Restore power, solve puzzles with realistic physics, and find multiple security codes to unlock the exit. Customize your experience with a deep Custom Mode. Stay quiet—he's listening.
Why similar: Strategy 24.6%, Action 16.5%, Action-Adventure 14.1%, 1990's 13%, Investigation 9.1%
- #3 Strange day
95% match1 user reviews0% of 1 reviews2025
Dev: lss
Windows
Nick must solve various challenges within the events of the past. Can you solve these mysteries? Most people probably can't solve it. Play and journey into Nick's memories!
Why similar: Strategy 33%, 3D Platformer 26.6%, 1990's 15.1%, First-Person 8.8%, 3D 7.5%
- #4 カミゴロシ
94% matchMixed60% of 20 reviews2024
Dev: Vantan Game Academy
Windows
とある事件の調査の帰りに、見えない何かによって街に閉じ込められてしまった主人公たち。 主人公をサポートする、妖刀に宿る神「八島童子」と共に、街から脱出を図る主人公たちですが……。 果たして貴方は街から脱出できるのか。そしてこの怪事件の真相に辿り着けるか……!
Why similar: 3D Platformer 33.3%, Action-Adventure 18.1%, Action 13.5%, Horror 11.5%, Investigation 9.2%
- #5 Nexus Warfare
94% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Ertugrul KindansPub: Metacortex
Windows
Embark on a thrilling adventure through mysterious worlds, conquering obstacles and unraveling intriguing puzzles. Immerse yourself in minimalist graphics and uncover secrets in this unique gaming experience. Get ready for surprises!
Why similar: 3D Platformer 25.5%, Strategy 19.1%, Action-Adventure 15.3%, Action 9%, Horror 8.8%
- #6 My neighbor stinks
93% matchMixed67% of 18 reviews2026
Dev: VericuGames
Windows
A 3D first-person horror-comedy where players explore spooky environments, solve quirky challenges, and encounter bizarre, funny, and frightening moments.
Why similar: Strategy 24.6%, 3D Platformer 22.7%, Action 16.6%, Investigation 9%, First-Person 6.4%
- #7 Cosmo Player Z
92% match8 user reviews88% of 8 reviews2022
Dev: SOMMIT GAMES
Windows
A Sci-Fi action game for a single player bringing you to fight rebellions, level up your character and choose new skills, dress up your character in the epic space wars.
Why similar: Strategy 29.4%, 3D Platformer 24.5%, Action 19.2%, Action-Adventure 16.5%, 3D 6.9%
- #8 Toony's Daycare
91% matchPositive80% of 10 reviews2025
Dev: Little Ghost Games
Windows
Children have vanished without a trace inside Toony’s Daycare. Beneath its playful surface lies a hidden world of science and shadows. Uncover the secrets of the twisted experiments within, piece together the fate of the missing kids, and confront the dark figure who rules the daycare.
Why similar: Strategy 19.1%, Action-Adventure 18.1%, Investigation 12.9%, 3D Platformer 12.8%, Mystery 11.1%
- #9 Ravens Rest
91% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2026
Dev: Bryce DensmorePub: The Kongs Studios
Windows
A horror adventure game following Rosanna, a thief tasked with breaking into Ravens Rest state park and retrieving and experiment. Things quickly take a turn however, as she discovers what the true nature of the experiment had in store.
Why similar: Strategy 28.2%, Action 18%, Action-Adventure 16.5%, Investigation 10.9%, First-Person 7.2%
- #10 Arnie's Maze
90% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Szymon KrawczakPub: Kinga Żegota
Windows
Relaxing retro-inspired maze game focused on calm, satisfying gameplay. Explore completely unique levels packed with surprises, solve varied challenges, and complete tasks to unlock new stages.
Why similar: Strategy 28.1%, Action 18.9%, 3D Platformer 17%, Action-Adventure 15.5%, First-Person 5.4%
- #11 Around - The Game
89% match8 user reviews67% of 9 reviews2025
Dev: TecshieldPub: Story Czar
Windows
Step into a haunted mansion where reality bends. Solve chilling puzzles, offer cherries to speak with the Fiend, and escape before you're consumed by the nightmare.
Why similar: Strategy 35%, 3D Platformer 26.7%, Action 19%, 3D 7.5%, Adventure 5.5%
- #12 HASHIRU
89% matchNo user reviews
Dev: OrbitPub: Orbit's Studio
Windows · Mac
A game about exploring your own mind. Escape the harsh world of stress and anxiety, solve puzzles, explore more about yourself, figure out your own consciousness. But most importantly - don't get too attached. After all, it's just a dream.
Why similar: 3D Platformer 26.4%, Action 20.1%, Action-Adventure 17.7%, 1990's 14.5%, First-Person 7.9%
- #13 SilentWard
88% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Pavan
Windows
Play as a journalist drawn into a forgotten asylum. Solve puzzles, hide from threats, and piece together the truth.
Why similar: Action-Adventure 21.7%, Strategy 21.7%, Investigation 11%, Horror 10.6%, First-Person 10.5%
- #14 Escape of the school
87% match1 user reviews0% of 1 reviews2025
Dev: Silverfox studios
Windows
Explore an abandoned Brazilian school, escape from the murderous teacher, and uncover the secrets behind a massacre that happened 20 years ago in this first-person horror filled with cultural references. Survive, hide, and escape.
Why similar: Strategy 26.9%, Action 16.5%, Action-Adventure 15.5%, Investigation 12.1%, First-Person 6.8%
- #15 Cat in Temple
86% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2026
Dev: amugames
Windows
On a quiet night, a lone cat wanders into an old temple and suddenly finds itself unable to leave. The same night repeats over and over, trapping the cat in an endless loop. Within the temple grounds, time twists unnaturally, and strange yokai and eerie anomalies appear and vanish like shadows.
Why similar: 3D Platformer 30.2%, Action 22.3%, Action-Adventure 20.4%, Horror 8.8%, Mystery 8.3%
- #16 SISTER RED
86% matchNo user reviews
Dev: bAd Bunny Games
Windows
This is a horror observe game. You’re trapped on the same floor, repeating it again and again. Strange things keep happening, so you start recording these weird moments. To find your way out, you must notice the small changes around the floor.
Why similar: 3D Platformer 18.5%, Action 17%, Action-Adventure 14.8%, Horror 14.5%, 1990's 12.1%
- #17 Dog Go To The Moon
85% matchNo user reviews
Dev: SatDaddyPub: n/a
Windows
A fast, bite-sized 3D action-platformer. Play as DOG of Bitcoin—bark-blast grifters, dodge traps, and free the Degens in quick, replayable stages with boss fights, secrets, and speedrun medals.
Why similar: Strategy 30.4%, Action 20.6%, 3D Platformer 19.8%, Action-Adventure 16.4%, Adventure 5.7%
- #18 Luck and Fear
84% match7 user reviews86% of 7 reviews2025
Dev: ASSIST STUDIO
Windows
A tense survival horror game where you must explore a dark, ever-changing hotel, solve puzzles, and evade a relentless killer. Every playthrough is unique, with randomized environments and unpredictable dangers.
Why similar: Action-Adventure 22.9%, Action 16.8%, Horror 12%, First-Person 11.6%, Strategy 11.2%
- #19 InHouse
84% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Mdrakynho
Windows
A survival horror game where you scavenge, craft tools, barricade doors, and make bullets to fight off a relentless entity hunting you in your grandfather’s abandoned house. Will you survive the night?
Why similar: 3D Platformer 19%, Survival Horror 16%, 1990's 14%, Action 12.8%, Action-Adventure 12.7%
- #20 Backrooms: Lost Signal
83% match3 user reviews0% of 3 reviews2026
Dev: NoSignal Games
Windows
A terrifying 1-4 player co-op horror game. Explore 10+ handcrafted Backrooms maps, survive against 8+ unique entities, and use proximity voice chat to coordinate or panic. Your decisions shape the story with multiple endings. Discover optional lore that reveals the truth behind these Backrooms.
Why similar: Strategy 26%, Action 17.9%, Action-Adventure 15.3%, Investigation 10.4%, First-Person 7.1%
- #21 I'm blocked
82% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2026
Dev: V.A.R
Windows
In this game you have to survive 14 days while being hunted by a monster that will try to break your jams to get at you.
Why similar: Strategy 30.5%, Action 20.8%, Action-Adventure 17.5%, Survival Horror 11.6%, Horror 6.5%
- #22 [ MURMUR ]
82% match2 user reviews0% of 2 reviews2025
Dev: Room 14 Studio
Windows
[ MURMUR ] is a psychological horror game about anomaly detection. Observe, listen, and survive within a house that constantly shifts… But beware: sometimes, a single whisper is enough to seal your fate.
Why similar: Action-Adventure 24.5%, 1990's 16.4%, First-Person 13.4%, Horror 12.5%, Action 11%
- #23 Quintus and the Formidable Curse
81% match4 user reviews50% of 4 reviews2024
Dev: Wreck Tangle Games
Windows
‘Quintus and the Formidable Curse’ is a Horror-Adventure game with a difference; the protagonists are a Man and Mouse duo!
Why similar: 3D Platformer 24.1%, Action 18.2%, Action-Adventure 16.3%, Horror 14.8%, Survival Horror 8.2%
- #24 Toxic Harvest
80% match9 user reviews78% of 9 reviews2025
Dev: Overthrown Interactive
Windows
Trapped on Halloween night in a chemical plant after a deadly spill, you’re hunted by a mutated creature. Your only escape is blocked, and every push toward freedom alerts your position. Time your movements, manage your stamina, and survive the night.
Why similar: Strategy 30.9%, Action 21.6%, Action-Adventure 16.5%, First-Person 10.1%, Horror 8.4%
- #25 My Neighbour Mr.Ghost
81% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Payanii
Windows
Exploratory action-adventure game. Shoot the ghosts in the trapped school and escape! Can you escape from mysterious events?
Why similar: 3D Platformer 37.1%, Action-Adventure 20.5%, Action 15.3%, Horror 10.9%, 3D 8.5%
- #26 OOZEBORNE
79% matchNo user reviews
Dev: NBGames
Windows
OOZEBORNE is a 3D platformer that puts your skills to the ultimate test. With physics-based madness and precision platforming, wiping out isn't failure... it's part of the fun!
Why similar: 3D Platformer 33.2%, Action 28.4%, Strategy 28.1%, 3D 9.2%, Singleplayer 1.1%
- #27 Into The Unknown
79% match3 user reviews67% of 3 reviews2024
Dev: Universal_official
Windows
In a small city, a man was struggling to save his business from failure. Despite his best efforts, he was unable to find a solution. One day, while searching for a document in his room, he stumbled upon a dusty book that he had never seen before. The title of the book was “Into The Unknown”.
Why similar: 3D Platformer 21.3%, Strategy 18.6%, Action-Adventure 17.8%, Action 13.1%, First-Person 6.9%
- #28 Junkyard Fury 3
77% matchPositive90% of 29 reviews2025
Dev: Dhood Gaming
Windows
The anomaly vehicles are back and more aggressive than ever. Each area now features unique experiments and goals. Choose your approach—pick your starting items, vehicles, upgrades, and mods. One experiment won’t cut it anymore. Time to get to work.
Why similar: Strategy 31.5%, Action 20.2%, Survival Horror 10.4%, First-Person 10.3%, Horror 8.8%
- #29 STARDOME
78% matchNo user reviews
Dev: BugFix Games
Windows
You have only one mission in the STARDOME: TO GET BACK HOME. As the darkness rises, so too does the threat of danger. Flesh-hungry, nightmarish creatures will come for you. Immerse yourself in a first-person action survival game, where resource management is key to your survival.
Why similar: Strategy 30.3%, Action 19.4%, Action-Adventure 17.4%, Survival Horror 9.2%, First-Person 7.9%
- #30 Nine Days
78% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Pansus Studio
Windows
9 Days brings a psychological horror experience where you play as a father. One time, someone kidnaps your child, and The kidnapper asks for money if he wants his child safe. In the end, you must find a way to make money as fast as possible and try to survive by hiding from them.
Why similar: Strategy 30.7%, Action 16.6%, Horror 14.7%, First-Person 14%, Survival Horror 8.5%
- #31 Junkyard Fury 2
77% matchPositive94% of 48 reviews2022
Dev: Daniel HoodPub: Dhood Gaming
Windows
A horror first person strategy game! Shut down the killer cars before it's too late!
Why similar: Strategy 20.5%, Action-Adventure 17.9%, Investigation 16.1%, Survival Horror 10.5%, First-Person 9.3%
- #32 Deep Sleep: The Beggining
76% match3 user reviews67% of 3 reviews2024
Dev: wilssiiPub: WS Studio
Windows
Discover the truth about winderfield, the ghost town and solve the mysteries.
Why similar: Strategy 27.3%, Action 16.8%, Horror 14.3%, 1990's 14.2%, First-Person 7.2%
- #33 Jack - The Puppet
75% match8 user reviews63% of 8 reviews2025
Dev: Gamesoft Studios
Windows
Step into a haunted mansion in search of the legendary golden Shiva statue. Solve mind-bending puzzles, face the menacing Jack the Puppet, and survive a deadly 150-second showdown. Can you claim the treasure and escape, or will Jack seal your fate?
Why similar: Strategy 20.8%, Action-Adventure 16.1%, Action 12.8%, Investigation 12.3%, First-Person 8.9%
- #34 Corridor Geodesic
76% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Liz MiyunaPub: Neverway Studio
Windows · Linux
Corridor Geodesic is a steampunk style puzzle game all about collapsing and expanding the level around you to descend deeper into an ominous facility.
Why similar: 3D Platformer 25%, Strategy 22.1%, Action 20.6%, Action-Adventure 18.2%, First-Person 6.4%
- #35 消失的妹妹(The Vanished Sister)
74% matchMixed56% of 18 reviews2024
Dev: LCGaming
Windows
This game delivers classic horror gameplay with innovative additions like an AI emotional system and variable item generation. It has a one-death rule, numerous escape methods, and levels with unique designs.
Why similar: Action 19%, Action-Adventure 18.4%, Survival Horror 15.1%, 3D Platformer 14.4%, Horror 12.4%
- #36 Subject 95
75% matchMixed53% of 19 reviews2021
Dev: LtWashiPub: Nebula One
Windows
Become a daring lab escapee and navigate through a multitude of challenging levels in Subject 95!
Why similar: 3D Platformer 26.2%, Action 22.7%, Action-Adventure 18.4%, Strategy 11%, First-Person 7.4%
- #37 祟り坂 | TATARI Curse road
73% matchPositive87% of 46 reviews2025
Dev: STUDIO DYD
Windows
A simple survival horror set in a hilly town where you must escape from a ghost. There are no puzzles, item usage, or complex controls. If you fail, try again, memorize the roads, and find your way to the goal.
Why similar: Survival Horror 19.8%, Horror 18.3%, Action 16.2%, 3D Platformer 15.2%, Action-Adventure 10.2%
- #38 The Haunting Eyes
73% matchPositive81% of 21 reviews2025
Dev: vivmaxPub: Large Lake Team
Windows
The Haunting Eyes is a game in which you have to break into an abandoned mansion and solve its mystery by collecting bags of gold.
Why similar: 3D Platformer 26.1%, Action 19.9%, Action-Adventure 17.6%, Survival Horror 8.5%, First-Person 8.1%
- #39 KEM Alpha 1
73% match9 user reviews80% of 10 reviews2023
Dev: MissingGames
Windows
You get a call to go to your friend's house, but then things start to take a horrible turn....
Why similar: Strategy 25.1%, Horror 16.3%, Investigation 14.4%, Mystery 13.5%, First-Person 11.1%
- #40 Broken Masks
74% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Cool Studios
Windows
Enter an abandoned orphanage, solve disturbing puzzles, and uncover its terrible secrets. Living toys, dark presences, and haunted corridors will test your sanity. Can you survive the horror that lies within?
Why similar: Strategy 31.2%, 3D Platformer 25%, Action 20.1%, Survival Horror 7.7%, Horror 6.4%
- #41 Eclipsed Realms
72% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Nathan N.
Windows
Journey through fractured realms in a rich, immersive world. Solve intricate puzzles, battle deadly foes, and uncover lost lore. Teleport between parallel realities to alter environments, unlock secrets, and conquer challenges across shifting, surreal landscapes.
Why similar: 3D Platformer 21.5%, Action 20.6%, Action-Adventure 18.6%, 1990's 13.3%, First-Person 7.4%
- #42 Chuck Nolemland: The Starving Kid
70% match9 user reviews89% of 9 reviews2025
Dev: Miloš LužnjaninPub: Red Cap Games
Windows
Very STRANGE Indie Rage Horror Game...
Why similar: Strategy 30.4%, Action 18.7%, Action-Adventure 17.1%, First-Person 7.3%, Horror 6.8%
- #43 Party House
71% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2024
Dev: Milan RaijmakersPub: Novixx Systems
Windows · Linux
It's your friend Bab's birthday! Collect all cakes in all 4 levels to win!
Why similar: Strategy 33.6%, Action 22.9%, Survival Horror 9.4%, Horror 8.6%, First-Person 8.6%
- #44 P.I.D.
72% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2020
Dev: João Victor da SilvaPub: AMDI Studios
Windows
Without memories, all you have is your medicine. What happened to the world? What happened to you? P.I.D. is a first-person puzzle and suspense game in which you must survive 5 chapters in one house. Good luck!
Why similar: Investigation 22%, Survival Horror 14.3%, Narration 14.1%, Horror 13.5%, Action-Adventure 13.2%
- #45 Strange Waveforms
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: PWFPub: Play With Fire Studio
Windows
You're a late-night radio host. The callers? Not all of them are human. Take the call… if you dare.
Why similar: Investigation 21.4%, Survival Horror 16.1%, 1990's 15.3%, Action 14.9%, Horror 14%
- #46 Question Mark 2
71% match4 user reviews50% of 4 reviews2024
Dev: Rangel OblivionPub: Gurunga Games
Windows · Linux
Question Mark 2 is a first/third person game, where you can walk, run, jump and interact with objects and mechanisms to solve puzzles. With new items and more enemies. The game has a HUB level that unlocks new levels, similar to Turok Dinosaur Hunter.
Why similar: Strategy 23.2%, 3D Platformer 22.3%, Action-Adventure 16.8%, Action 13.9%, First-Person 7.2%
- #47 Sea Balloon
69% matchPositive83% of 12 reviews2025
Dev: Red Balloon
Windows
Explore a variety of islands with a red balloon! An ode to the art of taking it slow.
Why similar: 3D Platformer 39.2%, Action 29.2%, Action-Adventure 26.5%, 3D 3.8%, Singleplayer 1.2%
- #48 Island
70% match1 user reviews0% of 1 reviews2023
Dev: The First
Windows
Island is a TPP survival running game which is Satisfying and full of Adventures.But watch out!Try not to fall from the moving platform or islands.Aware of your foot steps and don't forget to jump at the right time.Feel freedom.Adventure is wating for you.Can wait you to see.Try out Now!!!
Why similar: Strategy 30.1%, 3D Platformer 20.3%, Action 20.3%, Action-Adventure 16.6%, Adventure 5.6%
- #49 Locomotive 115
67% matchVery Positive93% of 133 reviews2024
Dev: Bucket of Fish
Windows · Mac
It's difficult to know how many locomotives have been swallowed by the suffocating blizzards of the Widow's Run. Cursed with creeping tales of things that lurk in the dark and overshadowed by frequent casualties, it now stands as your only path forward. Will you be able to survive?
Why similar: Strategy 22.8%, Action-Adventure 18.4%, Action 14.9%, Horror 12.3%, First-Person 11.3%
- #50 Deep In The Snowy Night 2
70% matchNo user reviews2023
Dev: L42 STUDIOSPub: Latitude 42
Windows
After drunkenly passing out on a sidewalk, Christopher wakes up in yet another nightmare. Venture through the many different zones to uncover the truth behind these strange nightmares.
Why similar: Action 21.3%, Action-Adventure 19%, 1990's 18.2%, First-Person 10.3%, 3D 8.7%
- #51 Chilli Con Valley
68% matchVery Positive91% of 153 reviews2022
Dev: Knesti
Windows
Chilli con Valley! Help the Bean reach its chilli con Carne pot as fast as possible. Jump over Obstacles and dangerous objects just like lava and knives. Who doesn't want to help a poor little bean? Chilli con valley is a game for people with a lot of persistence and a mentally strong head.
Why similar: 3D Platformer 35%, Strategy 32.9%, Action-Adventure 21.1%, Adventure 7.8%, Indie 2.2%
- #52 Ironsphere
69% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Jemie
Windows
Ironsphere is a fast-paced top-down mech shooter set on a hostile moon. Fight giant insects and deadly machines, pilot 20+ customizable mechs, and balance speed, armor, and energy. Equip weapons, shields, and modules to survive brutal battles and claim victory.
Why similar: Strategy 38.7%, Action 26.4%, Action-Adventure 20.2%, 3D 9%, Adventure 4.8%
- #53 PIEN & PAON plus
67% matchVery Positive96% of 80 reviews2022
Dev: くそいサイト
Windows
Run away from the mysterious monsters "PIEN" and "PAON"! A pop and cute 3D horror game!
Why similar: 3D Platformer 28.8%, Action 23.1%, Action-Adventure 19.5%, Horror 11.6%, First-Person 10.3%
- #54 PIO
66% matchVery Positive83% of 206 reviews2025
Dev: Star of Star
Windows
The game "PIO" is a game created by Korean university students! Prove your strength in a world of stars and become the brightest star! In PIO, you will take on trials to prove your light and challenge yourself to become the most radiant star.
Why similar: 3D Platformer 32.8%, Action 24.9%, Action-Adventure 22.1%, 3D 9.8%, PvE 5.6%
- #55 Funset Studios
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Naughty Clogs
Windows
The Funset Studios Studio Tour is finally open. Try your luck on the Jungle Jammer's Jungle Gym. Get your own Golden Gaia Medallion And meet everyone's favorite TV Hippo: FUMBO!
Why similar: 1990's 18.8%, 3D Platformer 18.4%, Survival Horror 17.4%, Action 12%, Horror 12%
- #56 Asteroad
69% match3 user reviews33% of 3 reviews2020
Dev: EllGames, LLC
Windows
It's the story of a girl in the world anyone can transform into a constellation. With meteor showere, the girl's favorite "star" has fallen apart. The girl collects pieces of star to return the star to the night sky.
Why similar: 3D Platformer 35.4%, Action 28.4%, Action-Adventure 24.7%, 3D 10.5%, Singleplayer 1.1%
- #57 Virus X
68% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: IcekingPanda
Windows
A brilliant yet unhinged scientist has engineered a revolutionary virus intended to cure humanity’s greatest limitations… beginning with the inability to regenerate damaged limbs. As Andrew, you must track down the doctor and stop his experiments before they spiral into a global catastrophe.
Why similar: Strategy 23.2%, Survival Horror 16.8%, Action 16%, Horror 14.4%, Action-Adventure 11.8%
- #58 Wheretheskyis
67% match8 user reviews0% of 8 reviews2025
Dev: SmileForeverStudio
Windows
Relax and enter the world of calming blue. A gentle little sky adventure that blends into the blue of the sky with a flowing quiet sound "Where the sky is"
Why similar: 3D Platformer 36.5%, Action 27.6%, Action-Adventure 24.7%, 3D 10.2%, Singleplayer 1.1%
- #59 Nightmare Crew
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Lucas Brouwers
Windows
You are a film crew tasked with proving the existence of a monster. Collaborate with up to three friends and escape with enough evidence (that's the hard part) to prove it!
Why similar: Investigation 19.3%, 1990's 15.7%, Horror 11%, Mystery 9.3%, Action-Adventure 8.9%