Games Like Victor's Video Vault

Valley of Shadows is a short psychological horror set in an ordinary American suburb. Players navigate as James, a family man seeking answers about his missing family, while grappling with paranoia and supernatural forces.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 14.7%, Horror 13.4%, Investigation 13.1%, Supernatural 13%, Mystery 9.6%

The once #1 horror game on the Horror list of Itch is back! Join now and use a variety of repair tools to experience life as a handyman in a haunted house, uncover the terrifying past of this old house and face the terrifying demon baby head-on!

Why similar: Psychological Horror 13.6%, Investigation 12.9%, Horror 11.2%, 1990's 10.4%, Supernatural 10.3%

A psychological horror adventure where you explore shifting dream worlds, solve immersive environmental puzzles, and unravel the mysteries of your fractured mind inside a surreal facility.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 23.1%, Horror 17.9%, Mystery 11%, Investigation 10.9%, First-Person 9.7%

Explore a cursed house where a family was driven to madness by a dark presence. In The House: A Maple Street Story, uncover a terrifying mystery through enigmatic puzzles, an engaging narrative, and a psychological horror atmosphere that holds your every move captive.

Why similar: Supernatural 19.7%, Psychological Horror 19.3%, Horror 19.1%, First-Person 9.9%, Investigation 7.5%

Can you tell the difference between truth and tale? Experience three short horror stories and gather clues as to which are true and which are just part of our imagination. Immerse yourself in the protagonist's perspective and discover eerie tales from around the world.

Why similar: Horror 20.9%, Mystery 16.7%, Psychological Horror 14.9%, Supernatural 13.5%, Atmospheric 8.5%

Escape a distorted version of your own newly rented apartment in this interactive nightmare.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 25.6%, Horror 16.7%, Supernatural 15.4%, First-Person 12.1%, Atmospheric 10.2%

Explore an old mansion full of paranormal dangers alone. Find clues, identify ghosts, collect their dossiers and exorcise them.

Why similar: Investigation 15.9%, Horror 14.8%, Psychological Horror 13.5%, Supernatural 13%, First-Person 10.2%

Veil of Sanity: Echoes of the Carnival (Chapter 1) combines psychological horror with intense gameplay. Keep your sanity intact as you explore a forsaken carnival. More chapters coming soon!

Why similar: Psychological Horror 17.7%, Horror 16.8%, Investigation 13.7%, First-Person 11.3%, Mystery 8.2%

DREAM LOGIC is a story driven first-person atmospheric horror game which takes place in liminal spaces. Explore various nostalgic, dreamlike, uncanny environments. But don't feel too safe, there's a sneaky creature watching your every move.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 18.7%, Horror 15.3%, Mystery 12.6%, Atmospheric 8.5%, First-Person 7.8%

A first-person horror puzzle game about solving cryptic puzzles and surviving a deadly night inside an abandoned drive-in theater.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 24.7%, Horror 19%, Investigation 15.2%, First-Person 11.9%, Mystery 9.7%

COLD CALL is a first-person retro horror game based on a dying Earth full of unexplained mysteries. Escape Northbridge's research facility as you explore and uncover the truth behind a dying world.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 18%, Horror 17%, First-Person 12.2%, Mystery 10%, Exploration 9.2%

Your brother's unexpected death leads you to unsettling locations in search of floppy disks with cursed retro games.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 21.6%, Horror 19.4%, Retro 9.5%, Mystery 9.3%, Atmospheric 8.7%

Use an instant camera to reveal hidden realities and shape the house itself. Not everything stays where it belongs.

Why similar: Supernatural 18.6%, Psychological Horror 18.2%, Horror 17.9%, Investigation 16.8%, First-Person 7.3%

You were with her. Then you weren't. Push an elderly woman's wheelchair through the shadowed halls of a Croatian monastery turned hospice. She is dying. She sees what you cannot. What do you owe the truth?

Why similar: Psychological Horror 21.3%, Horror 17.2%, Mystery 11.5%, Supernatural 10.2%, Investigation 10%

Delve into a dark tale marked by an ancient curse. Explore a forgotten cabin, uncover the truth behind Henrietta Morrigan, and confront a presence that should never have been awakened. Every secret revealed brings you closer to the darkness… and to your destiny.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 22.5%, Horror 17.6%, Supernatural 13.8%, First-Person 11.1%, Mystery 10.6%

Your parents are out celebrating their wedding anniversary. Alone at home, you decide to test the legend of Beatriz, a spirit that haunts those who summon her in front of the bathroom mirror. What seemed like just a joke soon turns into a terrifying nightmare.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 23.9%, Horror 22.5%, First-Person 17.2%, Supernatural 11.8%, Exploration 6.2%

A Single Player Ghost Hunting Game. Unlockable & Upgradeable Equipment, and multiple Unique Locations to investigate.

Why similar: Supernatural 24.3%, Investigation 23.8%, Nonlinear 9.9%, First-Person 9.4%, Atmospheric 9.2%

A first-person supernatural thriller where you explore a manor overtaken by darkness. Wield a mysterious power to confront an ancient evil, unravel the truth, and save your brother.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 16.8%, Horror 15.7%, Supernatural 14.8%, Investigation 12.5%, First-Person 9.5%

In Don’t Remember, some things are better left forgotten. Fight your amnesia in this atmospheric, first person psychological horror game. Solve the mystery of the old mansion in 1900’s England through the use of your lantern’s various colors and face its hidden grotesque visage.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 26.4%, Horror 20.9%, Investigation 11%, Mystery 10.4%, Atmospheric 9.5%

UFOPHILIA is a first-person psychological horror game where you explore areas marked by alien phenomena. Use specialized equipment to detect, identify, and photograph aliens—but do so at your own risk... They are watching you too.

Why similar: Supernatural 18.8%, Psychological Horror 18.2%, Horror 17.8%, Investigation 16%, Mystery 9.6%

BLOK is an Orwellian psychological horror game set in post-communist Poland. You play as a political exile who fled during the communist regime. Years later, after the system’s collapse, a strange letter from your mother draws you back home. But something is deeply wrong.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 24.8%, Horror 19%, Mystery 15.6%, Atmospheric 8.3%, 1990's 7.7%

Abandon hope and delve into the core of an old nuclear power plant in this psychological survival horror experience. Trust your map and radiation detector to navigate the irradiated plant... And be forced to discover the monstrous cause of its sudden reawakening.

Why similar: Supernatural 17.5%, Psychological Horror 17.2%, Horror 14.6%, Mystery 12.1%, First-Person 8.6%

Atmospheric first-person horror game where you carry an old Polaroid camera. Take the right picture and a way forward emerges.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 23.7%, Horror 17.6%, First-Person 12.5%, 1990's 8.2%, Atmospheric 8.1%

Three friends known as The Ghost Hunters are documenting abandoned locations. What begins as a normal episode suddenly turns into a nightmare inside The Holloway Mansion. Something terrifying happens, leaving Jack to survive alone in the mansion and face the horrors.

Why similar: Horror 19.9%, Psychological Horror 19.2%, Supernatural 15%, Mystery 13.3%, First-Person 10.6%

A first-person atmospheric horror experience where hidden clues and impossible spaces draw you deeper into a place that should not exist.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 22.8%, Horror 22.7%, Investigation 15.7%, Mystery 14.2%, Atmospheric 8.9%

🏠 Embark on a captivating journey through the Silent Forests, treacherous sewers, and a mysterious house. Solve puzzles, face monsters, and unravel hidden truths in this adrenaline-packed adventure with a wacky narrator! 🌲🚪✨

Why similar: Psychological Horror 18.9%, Horror 18.8%, Supernatural 11.6%, 1990's 10.9%, Mystery 9.8%

Unfinished horror games by missing developers. A diary written from inside the code. Fragments that decay in real time. Your keyboard is a weapon. Hesitation is deadly.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 18.4%, Horror 17.9%, Mystery 12.9%, 1990's 9.4%, Atmospheric 7.9%

Your car ran out of gas in the wrong place... Escape a bloodthirsty werewolf in an abandoned factory deep in the forest, where darkness is your worst enemy. Survive this night... if you can.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 26.2%, Horror 18.7%, Mystery 11.6%, Supernatural 11.3%, Exploration 7.3%

Trapped in a bazaar that twists with every turn, you are a lost child searching for your mother. Watch for subtle anomalies in the shifting environment to survive the loop. In this retro-inspired world, nothing is as it seems. Can you find her before the cycle swallows you whole?

Why similar: Investigation 22.9%, Psychological Horror 17.9%, Mystery 15.2%, Horror 12.4%, First-Person 12.2%

Infiltrate contaminated residences and deal with their mutant pests using the most advanced tech of the 1960s. Set up a base and observe, probe, and most importantly, survive the grotesque creatures in this online co-op horror game.

Why similar: Investigation 20.9%, Horror 19.2%, Supernatural 18.7%, Psychological Horror 8%, Mystery 6.9%

A first-person psychological horror game set in a looping hospital, where each cycle changes reality, escalates tension, and brings you closer to something that should not be there.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 21.6%, Horror 21.3%, Supernatural 12.1%, First-Person 10.3%, Atmospheric 9.2%

Navigate through claustrophobic, completely dark world illuminated only by scans you manage to create; listen carefully to sounds coming from the darkness, and don’t let dread and paranoia get to you.

Why similar: Supernatural 19.5%, Psychological Horror 19.3%, Horror 18.2%, Mystery 9.6%, First-Person 7.8%

A delivery job turns into a nightmare as you enter a two-story haunted mansion where something hunts you from the shadows. A short, intense first-person horror experience with jump scares, atmosphere, and a relentless enemy.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 22.2%, Horror 18.1%, Supernatural 15.9%, First-Person 11.2%, Atmospheric 9.1%

A wrong turn leads investigative reporter Nancy to the Paradise Motel. Explore its dark corridors, solve environmental puzzles, and uncover the disturbing secrets hidden beneath.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 18.1%, Horror 15.2%, Investigation 12.6%, First-Person 11.2%, Mystery 8.3%

Project Apparition is a 4 player cooperative paranormal investigation game currently in development. The aim of the game is to take on missions to investigate and remove ghosts from haunted buildings.

Why similar: Investigation 17.3%, Horror 14.2%, Supernatural 14.2%, Psychological Horror 14.1%, First-Person 13.4%

Embark on a journey as private investigator Richard in this atmospheric story-rich psychological horror. Enter the spirit world to relive the past of the Moriarty family and ultimately discover your own truth.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 18.2%, Supernatural 16.1%, Investigation 13.6%, Horror 12.2%, First-Person 9.2%

Find your way out of the sewers while fighting off an unstoppable monster and slowly succumbing to a mysterious illness.

Why similar: Investigation 15.2%, Horror 12.6%, Psychological Horror 10.6%, Supernatural 10.1%, Mystery 9.6%

A terrifying VHS-style horror game. You're trapped in a cursed house haunted by a failed ritual. Stay silent, your microphone is always listening. Speak, and something will hear you.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 27.9%, Horror 18.3%, First-Person 14.3%, 1990's 10.6%, Adventure 8%

Children have been vanishing while playing with the brand new Room2Room handheld gaming system. You have been contracted to monitor playtest sessions, document any unwanted quirks, and help young testers play safely.

Why similar: Investigation 17.1%, Horror 15.2%, 1990's 14%, Psychological Horror 13.9%, Mystery 10.3%

Trapped in an endless Roman corridor, you must observe carefully, solve eerie puzzles, and survive horrors in this roguelite puzzle-adventure.

Why similar: Investigation 20.4%, Psychological Horror 15.2%, Supernatural 13.1%, Mystery 11.3%, Horror 10.3%

This game is a psychological horror in which the main character wakes up in an unfamiliar house and must pass all the levels by solving puzzles.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 19.9%, Horror 18.4%, Supernatural 16.3%, Mystery 10.7%, First-Person 9.2%

A PS1-style psychological horror game about a student pulled into a surreal hub of locked doors and broken memories, where each step deeper reveals the town’s buried secrets and the truth behind what everyone chose to ignore.

Why similar: Horror 27%, Psychological Horror 24.7%, Mystery 21.3%, Atmospheric 15.8%, Adventure 5.8%

The Maze Project is a psychological horror game set in a dark, creepy maze. Unaware of how you found yourself here, you must escape from this twisted nightmare. Survive from the dark manifestations that lurk around the maze waiting for every opportunity to get you, and uncover the hidden secrets.

Why similar: Supernatural 19%, Psychological Horror 18.8%, Horror 16.9%, Mystery 13%, First-Person 8.4%

You play as Samuel Whittaker, a 19 year old college student who likes to get into trouble. How will he handle the situation when his friends go missing and he is the only one that can find them. Will he find them alive or will he be too late..

Why similar: Investigation 18.7%, Psychological Horror 15.7%, Horror 12.2%, First-Person 10.2%, 1990's 9.1%

You, a normal working Joe, decide to try to solve the mystery of the missing girl... Will you make it out alive? A horror game filled with mystery!

Why similar: Psychological Horror 22.8%, Horror 21.4%, First-Person 12.2%, Investigation 9.7%, Adventure 6.5%

A first-person psychological horror game about detecting anomalies and subtle environmental changes. Work the night shift in a secluded museum, carefully observe your surroundings, and stabilize disturbances before they spread.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 20.3%, Horror 14%, Supernatural 13.6%, Mystery 11.7%, Investigation 10.9%

On April Fool’s Day, the protagonist is caught in eerie supernatural events! As you investigate, uncover the truth behind a past tragedy. Explore chilling scenes, solve mysteries, and face unknown fears—can you survive?

Why similar: Horror 25.4%, Psychological Horror 23.8%, Mystery 16%, Adventure 8.7%, Atmospheric 7.7%

ICU – Intensive Care Unit 8 is a single-player horror game where you’re trapped in a looping hospital corridor and must spot anomalies to find a way out.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 22.3%, Horror 22.2%, Supernatural 19.4%, Investigation 13.3%, Exploration 7.2%

Investigate the strange town of Nightfall Hollow, and see if you can get to the truth. Enjoy the opening chapter of our game, meet some of the residents, solve a selection of puzzles, and have your first glimpse into Nightfall Hollow. There's plenty to discover, and the odd Easter-egg or two as well

Why similar: Supernatural 19%, Psychological Horror 17.8%, Investigation 17.4%, Horror 16%, Mystery 11.5%

You will play as office worker who was left to finish the job. While working on last documents you starting hearing strange sounds. How could this be? You are pretty sure that you are alone in the office.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 18.3%, Horror 18.2%, Supernatural 17.2%, First-Person 11.4%, Mystery 9.8%

The Marson Home is a single player, mystery-thriller. Explore the home, find the pieces to the ritual, and rid the place of the tormenting spirit. Keep in mind - your not alone...

Why similar: Investigation 25.7%, Horror 22.2%, Supernatural 11.5%, Mystery 9%, First-Person 7.9%

Follow the Rules is an immersive 1-4 player co-op horror experience. As a night shift guard, your mission is to protect haunted locations. The key to survival lies in strictly following a set of vital rules. Will you make it through the night?

Why similar: Supernatural 18.5%, Psychological Horror 17.6%, Horror 16.6%, Investigation 14.8%, Mystery 12.8%

In this horror game, you will follow the story of Andrew as he embarks on a journey to reconnect with his past, revisiting childhood memories of searching for his missing father - a passionate UFO researcher and enthusiast.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 17.6%, Horror 16.9%, 1990's 14.3%, First-Person 10.9%, Investigation 9.4%

Investigate a mysterious old museum as an agent of the Anomalous Research Bureau. Identify strange anomalies, file accurate reports, and endure the nights until your investigation is complete.

Why similar: Investigation 20.8%, Psychological Horror 20.3%, Horror 14.6%, Mystery 13.9%, First-Person 9.2%

A first person horror adventure game where you play as a timid protagonist- experiencing a near death experience caused by his bullies sending him to a ghost realm. To reduce your character's fear, take all necessary steps, such as covering your ears.

Why similar: Horror 22.2%, Psychological Horror 19.5%, First-Person 13.2%, Supernatural 12.3%, Atmospheric 9.6%

A first-person psychological horror game where you play as Hugo, a young boy searching for his missing brother, Jimmy, in an eerie mansion. Solve puzzles, explore haunted halls, and uncover dark secrets while facing supernatural threats.

Why similar: Supernatural 20.7%, Psychological Horror 19.5%, Horror 18%, Mystery 14.4%, First-Person 11.7%

An anonymous email leads you to your recently deceased grandmother's house, asking you to find something hidden inside. Someone wanted you there. Something else was already waiting. Investigate, solve disturbing puzzles and survive the horrors lurking in the shadows.

Why similar: Investigation 26.8%, First-Person 18.8%, Psychological Horror 17.9%, Horror 17.3%, Mystery 17%

Unfound Footage is a short, atmospheric psychological horror game where you must survive inside a mysterious mansion after a strange disappearance.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 25.3%, Horror 25.2%, Mystery 12.2%, Retro 9%, First-Person 8.5%

A first-person psychological horror set in a late-night 1990s video rental store. As disturbing tapes begin to surface, reality distorts and your decisions shape how the night unfolds.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 23.4%, Supernatural 18.7%, Horror 18.3%, First-Person 11.6%, Mystery 10.9%

Play as the socially rejected host of ETRadio, desperate to discover alien life while being mocked for answering hoax sighting calls - until one turns out to be terrifyingly real. When the call comes in, will it be the air that goes dead - or will it be you?

Why similar: Investigation 21.5%, Psychological Horror 19.4%, Horror 17.4%, Mystery 10.8%, First-Person 9.7%