- #1 [Chilla's Art] Parasocial | パラソーシャル
97% matchVery Positive94% of 1,621 reviews2023
Dev: Chilla's Art
Windows
Median: 1.9 hrsMean: 2.2 hrs≥1hr: 89%
Parasocial | パラソーシャル is a Japanese horror game about a live streamer.
Why similar: Horror 22%, Psychological Horror 21.5%, Thriller 17.4%, Female Protagonist 9.4%, Anime 9%
- #2 Blinding Oversight
96% matchPositive93% of 15 reviews2025
Dev: MustangDev
Windows
You play as Emma, who wakes up in an abandoned house without any prior memory of how she ended up there. Investigate your surroundings, uncover the mysteries of the house and connect memories from your past as you try to escape in this short, first person atmospheric horror game.
Why similar: Thriller 17.7%, Female Protagonist 15%, Horror 13.7%, Psychological Horror 12.6%, Linear 12.6%
- #3 Another Day
96% matchMixed67% of 36 reviews2023
Dev: TrivioraGames
Windows
Ivan sets out for the abandoned hospital in the town of Olkhov, where his brother Tolya disappeared after witnessing something horrifying, causing him to stop communicating and eventually vanish.
Why similar: Psychedelic 25.8%, 1990's 14.3%, Emotional 12.2%, Psychological Horror 9.1%, Thriller 9.1%
- #4 No Customers Left
95% matchMixed65% of 31 reviews2025
Dev: Mave DevelopmentPub: Mave Studios
Windows
Andy, a night shift security guard at a game console store, expected a quiet shift in the nearly empty mall. But as the hours passed, an unsettling presence made itself known. Flickering lights, and distant echoes—something was watching. Little did he know, the night was just beginning.
Why similar: Thriller 31.8%, 1990's 16.9%, Horror 15.7%, Linear 9.5%, Retro 7.7%
- #5 Devi5e: FEARS
94% match4 user reviews50% of 4 reviews2026
Dev: Susachiman
Windows
Devi5e: Fears is a psychological horror game. You play as Diti who is now exploring a convenient store where she has to face the fears of someone else's past experiences. Gather answers regarding incidents that took place which were deemed inhuman or even supernatural.
Why similar: Female Protagonist 23.7%, Thriller 17%, Psychological Horror 16.8%, Horror 14.6%, Linear 12.3%
- #6 Hulzuyot: Horror Game
94% matchMixed50% of 12 reviews2024
Dev: Holitass
Windows
You are a salary man who will experience terrifying situations due to a special illness, all while carrying out household chores.
Why similar: Thriller 23.3%, Psychedelic 17.8%, Psychological Horror 16.1%, Horror 13.7%, Linear 11.4%
- #7 EarWorm
93% matchVery Positive96% of 149 reviews2025
Dev: TOR2
Windows
You are an Earworm. You are an underworld contractor who hacks memories for a living. Dive into the memories of your victims in order to unlock the security questions to their bank account.
Why similar: Psychedelic 17.1%, Psychological Horror 16.2%, 1990's 16.1%, Thriller 15.5%, Linear 10.1%
- #8 Fragments of Dread - Late Lines FM
92% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Domnaier
Windows
Late Lines FM is a first-person, story-driven psychological horror experience. Your night shift at 107.9 FM turns into a nightmare with the forbidden 99.9 frequency. When the cursed song plays, you should cover your ears but to find the radio, you must listen.
Why similar: Psychedelic 21.3%, Thriller 18.1%, Psychological Horror 15.8%, 1990's 13%, Horror 11.9%
- #9 Who am I?
91% matchVery Positive86% of 92 reviews2025
Dev: Redsroll
Windows
A man named Mark, who struggles to make ends meet, receives a letter informing him that his aunt has passed away. Despite their troubled past, Mark decides to investigate what happened, hoping to uncover the truth and perhaps find a chance for a better life.
Why similar: Thriller 20.8%, Psychedelic 18.6%, Psychological Horror 15%, Horror 12.6%, Linear 11.1%
- #10 Analog - MIRROR
91% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Adouson
Windows
MIRROR is an analog horror game where a quiet evening alone in your family house takes a disturbing turn. You discover an old video game left by a relative — a forgotten gift with a history. What starts as nostalgia slowly unravels into something you were never meant to find.
Why similar: Nostalgia 19.1% ★, 1990's 17.2%, Thriller 16.3%, Horror 14.2%, Psychological Horror 12.3%
- #11 Family Manners
90% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Ronney
Windows
Light caresses every corner of the home, and the clock marks the first heartbeats of the morning. It’s just another typical day in the wonderful life of the Evans family… right?
Why similar: Thriller 23.1%, Psychological Horror 18.9%, Cartoon 16.4%, Horror 14.3%, Atmospheric 7.5%
- #12 RESTORER
89% matchMostly Positive78% of 54 reviews2025
Dev: Beshbarmak games
Windows
RESTORER is a classic walking simulator set in an old, atmospheric mansion. Something roams the halls… It wants to share its secret—with the price being your sanity.
Why similar: Psychedelic 28.5%, Psychological Horror 19%, Thriller 16.3%, Linear 12.7%, Horror 10.5%
- #13 Love Me
89% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Rooster Syndicate
Windows
Kimino sneaks into her highschool late at night under the pretense that there, she can finally find happiness through love. What she finds instead, is a labyrinthine assortment of lockers sprawling with inexplicable horrors.
Why similar: Psychedelic 26.9%, Female Protagonist 13.7%, Thriller 12.8%, 1990's 8.5%, Anime 8.4%
- #14 The Stalked 2
88% matchVery Positive80% of 235 reviews2025
Dev: Korvinrular
Windows
"The Stalked 2" is a standalone horror sequel to "The Stalked", where you play as Rachel, an avid hiker. What begins as a relaxing hike to a cabin turns into a nightmare filled with eerie interactions and unsettling events. Will you survive?
Why similar: Thriller 25.9%, Psychological Horror 16.2%, Horror 15.6%, Linear 13.2%, Immersive 8.6% ★
- #15 Sanity Loops
87% matchMostly Positive80% of 59 reviews2025
Dev: 375 Games
Windows
Caught in a strange series of events, you find yourself stuck in a job you never expected. What started as a simple way to earn money for a gift soon spirals into something much darker. As you navigate your new reality, the boundaries between what’s real and what’s not become harder to distinguish.
Why similar: Thriller 25.6%, Psychedelic 25.2%, Psychological Horror 17.5%, Horror 14.5%, Atmospheric 7.1%
- #16 Obsessed : Night Shift
86% matchVery Positive89% of 133 reviews2025
Dev: arydkPub: Akhir Hayat Studio
Windows
A PSX Inspired horror game where you must work and cook at a shop late at night and the horrors that comes with it.
Why similar: Thriller 29.6%, Horror 21.7%, Psychological Horror 21.3%, Female Protagonist 10.6%, Retro 10%
- #17 Shadows Show
86% matchNo user reviews
Dev: VladEv1LPub: VladEv1l.Art
Windows
Are you ready to face the mysteries of the past? The player will explore the gloomy environment of the hospital, encountering creepy phenomena and supernatural creatures. Uncover the story of the disappearance of all the inhabitants of the "Red Forest" sanatorium.
Why similar: Psychedelic 22.5%, Thriller 18.3%, Psychological Horror 18.2%, Horror 15.6%, Linear 8.8%
- #18 Reconciliation
85% matchNo user reviews
Dev: GalaxyAstro
Windows
Psychological horror where you play as a young high schooler seeking reconciliation with an old friend. Unfortunately it won't be so easy, a perilous journey awaits you before you'll be able to reunite as friends once again.
Why similar: Thriller 26.2%, Psychological Horror 26%, Female Protagonist 18.2%, Horror 11.2%, Linear 10.8%
- #19 Olivia
84% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Struggle Games Studio
Windows
Once a family home, now stands silent. The past still whispers through every room. You are looking for inspiration for a film, but you will find much more than just a story. Whether the lights are on or off... it doesn't matter. Olivia will find you.
Why similar: Psychedelic 22.2%, Horror 17.6%, Cartoon 16.8%, Thriller 15.7%, Psychological Horror 13.7%
- #20 Bleeding Roots
84% matchVery Positive93% of 421 reviews2024
Dev: Mechanikoi
Windows
Bleeding Roots is a free fifteen minute horror game about a man taking care of his plants throughout the seasons.
Why similar: Horror 21.7%, Linear 20.3%, Thriller 19%, Psychological Horror 16.7%, Atmospheric 10.4%
- #21 Creeping Clark
83% matchMostly Positive79% of 34 reviews2025
Dev: NeroGameDev
Windows
After escaping her abusive brother, Sophie seeks a fresh start in a remote house in Hawthorn's forest. But strange events unfold, and her unsettling housemate, Elise, may be hiding something. Is it just her anxiety, or is there something more sinister lurking in the shadows?
Why similar: Thriller 25.5%, Psychological Horror 18%, Horror 15%, Female Protagonist 14.8%, Linear 12.8%
- #22 Screaming In The Basement (2025)
82% matchMixed67% of 24 reviews2026
Dev: Massbolt Games
Windows
Screaming In The Basement is an inspired-by P.T. psychological horror game with an immersive atmosphere. You play as Mike, a fearless journalist determined to expose the truth, as he investigates a family brutally killed by a serial killer.
Why similar: Thriller 20%, Psychedelic 19%, Psychological Horror 15.1%, 1990's 12.2%, Linear 9.2%
- #23 Lair of Torment
82% matchMostly Positive73% of 183 reviews2023
Dev: Admia
Windows
This is an indie horror game with first-person puzzles. Terror and fear have enveloped the city. The maniac has returned. You sneak into his lair to try and stop him before he goes too far...
Why similar: Psychedelic 19.2%, Psychological Horror 17.8%, Thriller 17.1%, Horror 14.7%, Linear 12.7%
- #24 OakRidge Research
81% matchNo user reviews
Dev: JacobPub: Elekna Labs
Windows
A SCP inspired horror game with psychological horror. Set in an non-official Foundation research facility where you are hired as a junior lab researcher. A company called OakRidge Research has started doing questionable and risky research on a top secret object unknown to the public
Why similar: Psychological Horror 27.5%, Emotional 19.8%, Horror 16.3%, Linear 13.9%, Atmospheric 9.6%
- #25 Dead Tapes: Fading Father
80% matchPositive89% of 45 reviews2025
Dev: Nektogone
Windows
Fading father is a man consumed by addiction and memories
Why similar: Psychological Horror 24.1%, Horror 21.8%, 1990's 14%, Retro 11.1%, Linear 8%
- #26 Scare: Fatal Picture - The Other Side
81% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Daniel Henriques
Windows
Scare: Fatal Picture – The Other Side is a psychological horror game in which you must take pictures of ghosts to destroy them.
Why similar: Psychological Horror 20.7%, Female Protagonist 20.1%, Horror 17%, Thriller 16.5%, Linear 12.5%
- #27 It Happened At Night
79% matchMixed69% of 54 reviews2024
Dev: Davidcrosdev
Windows
It Happened At Night is a short horror game where the player must complete basic objectives to advance the story and immerse themselves through the eyes of the protagonist.
Why similar: Thriller 15.9%, Horror 15.7%, Female Protagonist 15.7%, Psychological Horror 13.4%, Linear 12.9%
- #28 Gravenfall
79% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Silver Falcon
Windows
Specter Trail is a gripping horror game where you play as Fares, a private investigator unraveling the dark secrets of the Vanderbilt family. Immerse yourself in a linear narrative filled with unexpected twists, eerie specters, and challenging puzzles.
Why similar: Thriller 31.4%, Linear 21%, Horror 20%, 3D 13.3%, Atmospheric 7.2%
- #29 Delirium
78% matchVery Positive88% of 89 reviews2025
Dev: IndividualKex
Windows
Delirium is a psychological horror game set in a suburban house. After a mysterious explosion, reality begins to unravel.
Why similar: Psychedelic 23%, Psychological Horror 20.4%, Horror 15.2%, Linear 12.7%, Thriller 9.7%
- #30 ANGLE
78% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: V.B.BPub: C.O.T.E
Windows
A disturbing psychological horror experience that unfolds as only the echo of your footsteps accompanies you through the dark corridors, where you move along the fragile edges of your own perception.
Why similar: Thriller 27.6%, Psychedelic 27.2%, Psychological Horror 19.7%, Horror 17.7%, 3D 4.5%
- #31 Lobotrypo
77% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Skaar Game Productions
Windows
Rumors of a serial killer stalking your local town are all over the news, and you have a meeting with your counselor in an hour. The problem is, the walk there is long and dark.
Why similar: Psychedelic 20.9%, Horror 20.5%, Psychological Horror 19.5%, Retro 9.8%, Atmospheric 9.6%
- #32 The Stalked 3
77% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Korvinrular
Windows
A late-night thrill turns into a nightmare. Olivia sneaks into Creepwood Wonderland Carnival with her boyfriend, expecting a fun night alone in the park. But something feels off. Distant footsteps. Faint whispers. Someone else is here… Watching.
Why similar: Thriller 25%, Horror 14%, Immersive 13.5% ★, Linear 13.1%, Psychological Horror 11.5%
- #33 The Red Window
76% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Hijinx, Inc.
Windows
A first-person body-cam horror game where reviewing your own recordings is the key to progression and uncovering a haunting truth.
Why similar: Thriller 22.1%, Psychological Horror 19.2%, Immersive 14.4% ★, Horror 13.7%, Linear 12.7%
- #34 Crime Detective: Red Flags
75% matchMixed61% of 249 reviews2025
Dev: Wizard Team
Windows
Confined under house arrest, Cody Harper begins observing his neighbors out of boredom. But what starts as an innocent pastime soon descends into a real nightmare. A true crime horror inspired by the case of a notorious serial killer.
Why similar: Thriller 22.7%, Psychological Horror 19%, Horror 14.3%, 1990's 12.4%, Emotional 10.2%
- #35 RE.wired
76% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Atelier Lumina 3D
Windows
A story of loneliness in a connected world set in 90s Japan. Control high schooler Kazami through a psychological explorative visual novel horror to uncover the truth of garbled messages and student disappearances. Featuring 2D hand drawn anime sprites in an explorable 3D techno-horror world.
Why similar: Psychedelic 20%, Psychological Horror 16.2%, Anime 13.8%, Female Protagonist 12.8%, Horror 11%
- #36 Cave Crawler
75% matchVery Positive85% of 576 reviews2023
Dev: Technomancy Studios
Windows · Linux
Median: 42 minMean: 1.5 hrs≥1hr: 26%
Cave Crawler is a short horror game where you pilot a drone into a cave and discover something horrible.
Why similar: Horror 22.1%, Psychological Horror 17.5%, Thriller 16.1%, Linear 13.1%, 1990's 9.2%
- #37 The Sunday
74% matchMostly Positive72% of 18 reviews2024
Dev: carb
Windows
The Sunday is a short walkthrough horror game where the idea of being alone will hunt you, until the drakness settles in your brain. The line between reality and nightmare is razor thin.
Why similar: Psychedelic 38.1%, Psychological Horror 24.4%, Horror 21.1%, 3D 8.9%, Adventure 5.1%
- #38 Out of Place: Origin
72% match8 user reviews88% of 8 reviews2025
Dev: Karma Studio
Windows
Out of Place: Origin is a survival game built on attention and observation. In a diner where reality quietly collapses, notice the anomalies, capture them on camera, and survive… Because sometimes, the thing watching you isn’t a mistake.
Why similar: Thriller 31.4%, Psychological Horror 23%, Horror 19.9%, 3D 13.1%, Atmospheric 7.3%
- #39 Unsettled : NIGHT SHIFT
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Bongduck Games
Windows
Unsettled: NIGHT SHIFT is a horror game about the terrors of daily life experienced by someone who has moved to a new city to live alone.
Why similar: Psychological Horror 25.6%, Horror 23.3%, Thriller 16.8%, Linear 12.5%, Atmospheric 7%
- #40 Kevurah Horror Tale
73% matchMixed45% of 29 reviews2024
Dev: Holitass
Windows
You must organize a funeral in a remote location while witnessing strange events.
Why similar: Thriller 26.4%, Psychedelic 19.5%, Psychological Horror 18%, Horror 14.9%, Atmospheric 7.9%
- #41 Millennium Dream
70% matchVery Positive93% of 2,248 reviews2026
Dev: LucidDreamLab
Windows
Median: 1.2 hrsMean: 1.9 hrs≥1hr: 57%
Wander through dreamscapes woven from memories of the millennium. Use your camera to freeze tender fragments of days gone by, collecting lost shards of childhood. In an atmosphere where Chinese Dreamcore and Liminal Space intertwine, savor a warmth that feels both familiar and strange.
Why similar: Emotional 17.1%, Thriller 16.7%, 1990's 16.4%, Psychological Horror 14.8%, Linear 9.8%
- #42 Grandma's Coloring Book
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: SimpleShutIn Productions LLC
Windows
GRANDMA'S COLORING BOOK is a psychological horror journey through the dark, tangled history of the Hooklock family using sewing needles and steam.
Why similar: Psychological Horror 22.9%, Horror 20.5%, Female Protagonist 20.4%, Thriller 11.7%, Atmospheric 8.6%
- #43 Analog - Skin off
71% matchVery Positive95% of 295 reviews2025
Dev: Adouson
Windows
Skin Off is an analog horror game where you play as a teenager spending a summer night alone at your uncle’s house. As you wait for your friends to arrive the next day, a strange message is broadcasted on national television, signaling the start of a nightmare you can’t escape.
Why similar: Thriller 21.8%, 1990's 17.7%, Psychological Horror 16.1%, Horror 14.5%, Linear 14.3%
- #44 Unseen
71% matchVery Positive84% of 68 reviews2025
Dev: Redsroll
Windows
It’s an indie horror game where John, a forensic photographer, after an unexpected and exhausting shift, is forced to spend the night away from home. What seemed like a temporary rest soon begins to turn unsettling.
Why similar: Psychological Horror 23.1%, Thriller 20.7%, Horror 16.4%, Psychedelic 13.9%, Linear 8.9%
- #45 HOLES
71% match4 user reviews50% of 4 reviews2025
Dev: Waves Games
Windows
In this horror game, mysterious hands drag the hero underground, and the player's task is to get out to the surface to return to your usual work. All the action of the game takes place in dark and stuffy tunnels, in the absence of light.
Why similar: Thriller 22.4%, 1990's 17.1%, Horror 14.2%, Immersive 12.2% ★, Psychological Horror 10.3%
- #46 My Sleeping Girlfriend
70% matchVery Positive95% of 105 reviews2025
Dev: Fancy Dog Games
Windows
Your girlfriend’s sleepwalking is getting worse each night. Find her and bring her back to bed safely.
Why similar: Thriller 24.9%, Psychological Horror 17.3%, Horror 14.5%, 1990's 11.7%, Linear 8.5%
- #47 Death in the Family
74% matchMixed52% of 27 reviews2021
Dev: Semka
Windows
"Death in the family" is a horror game about how the dead can confuse, frighten and even kill those they don't like.
Why similar: Psychedelic 34.4%, Psychological Horror 18.6%, Horror 17.4%, Linear 9.6%, Adventure 7.4%
- #48 Relight The Dark
72% matchPositive93% of 15 reviews2023
Dev: TaleHammer
Windows
Dive deep into a chilling and emotionally charged short horror experience that tells a story about a girl living with her abusive mother.
Why similar: Psychological Horror 25.9%, Horror 23.5%, Female Protagonist 22.8%, 3D 9.3%, Retro 6.2%
- #49 Shifting Lunacy
70% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Hulucats Games
Windows · Mac · Linux
A psychiatrist begins her first night shift during apocalyptic rumors. Patients with severe and varied conditions demand constant attention, while unexpected incidents push the nights into strange, surreal chaos.
Why similar: Psychedelic 36.8%, Horror 18.3%, 1990's 14.2%, Female Protagonist 8.1%, Adventure 8.1%
- #50 Late Homework | 遅れた宿題
69% matchVery Positive95% of 410 reviews2024
Dev: sodaraptorPub: Raptorsoft Games
Windows
Highschool student Haneko has forgotten her class assignments and must retrieve them by traversing a world of haunted horrors. Explore the dilapidated halls, find your missing homework, and avoid whatever's lurking around the corner in this bite-sized, retro survival horror experience.
Why similar: Thriller 21.3%, Psychological Horror 19.3%, Horror 16.1%, Female Protagonist 14.5%, Retro 10.5%
- #51 Ashes of Memory
69% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Visual Framework Studios
Windows
Ashes of Memory is a psychological horror game where players awaken in a burning house and must make choices to save their family—or fail, looping back into an increasingly distorted reality. Navigate a surreal dream world, collect symbolic items, and uncover the truth behind the fire.
Why similar: Psychedelic 35%, Psychological Horror 22.1%, Horror 20.3%, Female Protagonist 16.2%, Adventure 2.5%
- #52 The Stalked
68% matchVery Positive92% of 389 reviews2024
Dev: Korvinrular
Windows
Escaped from Liam's obsession, Kate seeks refuge in her grandpa's mansion. Strange occurrences raise questions about Liam's presence or another figure. Unraveling mysterious letters, Kate embarks on a journey, seeking peace.
Why similar: Thriller 24.5%, Horror 15.2%, Immersive 13.7% ★, Linear 12.1%, Psychological Horror 11.8%
- #53 The Archivist
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Archivist GamesPub: Olympos Games
Windows
A VHS-themed psychological horror where each tape drags you into a new nightmare. Explore haunted hospitals, schools, forests, and liminal spaces. Solve puzzles, uncover the Archivist’s secrets, and survive a house that grows darker with every tape you watch.
Why similar: Psychological Horror 20.9%, Thriller 20.3%, Horror 18%, Linear 17.5%, 3D 11.7%
- #54 Ode to a Moon
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Colorfiction
Windows
≫∦𝕲∭∄∂⋥ ⊶≋⧉ ⨇⩈𝕸 𝛙ℵ⪌⟁ ⟆⦆⌘𝛴⦻⎈
Why similar: Psychedelic 30.5%, Thriller 21.3%, Psychological Horror 14.2%, Horror 13.2%, Adventure 8.5%
- #55 Bite Size Terrors: see no FEAR
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: anOVERTHINKER
Windows
A roadtrip ends abruptly, causing yourself to go down a spiral of horror.
Why similar: Thriller 32.6%, Horror 21.1%, Emotional 19.6%, Atmospheric 10%, Linear 6.3%
- #56 The Nightmare Escape
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: HALbot Studios
Windows
Navigate through your nightmares in this immersive first-person horror game. Explore a mysterious abandoned apartment building and unlock four unique interconnected short stories and piece together the puzzles to escape your nightmare.
Why similar: Psychological Horror 24.8%, Horror 22.3%, Thriller 19.4%, Female Protagonist 15.5%, Atmospheric 9.9%
- #57 Timber trail
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Diotoons
Windows
An immersive horror set in a forest feared for its disappearances and the Timber Trail murders. Uncover the truth behind your grandfather’s fate.
Why similar: Psychological Horror 21.8%, Thriller 21%, Horror 18.3%, Linear 11.2%, Retro 9.2%
- #58 The Shift
66% match7 user reviews86% of 7 reviews2025
Dev: HTY
Windows
The Shift is a first-person 3D psychological horror game where you play as a night shift cashier in an isolated gas station, performing routine tasks while uncovering disturbing, unexplained events.
Why similar: Thriller 30.2%, Psychological Horror 21%, Horror 14.5%, Linear 11.3%, Female Protagonist 8.7%
- #59 Bad Faith
68% matchVery Positive92% of 63 reviews2022
Dev: Mado
Windows · Mac · Linux
Sanctuaries. Secrets. Serious consequences. A solo-developed psychological horror/drama visual novel.
Why similar: Thriller 20%, Psychological Horror 16.6%, Emotional 15.5%, Horror 13.5%, Anime 13.3%
- #60 Color Fear
66% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: West View
Windows
The Scariest Horror game you will ever experience. Today on The Color Fun Coloring Show they want viewers to help them find out who is breaking into their house! Survive each night against the Intruders and the Horror that comes from The Color Fun Coloring Show!
Why similar: Psychedelic 22.7%, Thriller 20.2%, Horror 16.7%, Linear 16.4%, 3D 9.4%