Nodal

Games Like Ollie's After Midnight

60+ similar titles based on shared tags and player behavior. Themes include Horror, Psychological Horror, Supernatural, Mystery.

Ollie's After Midnight header art

Welcome to Ollie's Odd Show! a beloved family entertainment and food place where kids and parents alike come from as far as the eye can see! during the day it's a place of joy were the star attractions, Ollie Oddity, and his band of misfits wow the crowd with their charm!

Reviews: No user reviews — 50%
Released: Coming soon
Developer: Purple Guy Sprite
Genres: Action, Adventure, Casual, Indie
Platforms: Windows

Similar Games

View all 60 recommendations
  1. #1 The Host's deadly games
    97% match9 user reviews56% of 9 reviews2026
    Dev: DaV Studios
    Windows

    The Host's deadly games is a first-person psychological horror game where you explore a mysterious house, uncover its dark past, and solve puzzles to survive.

    Why similar: Supernatural 26.1%, Psychological Horror 23%, Horror 16.6%, Mystery 10.4%, First-Person 9.4%

  2. #2 Face of Another
    96% matchVery Positive96% of 158 reviews2025
    Dev: MadBug Studio
    Windows

    Use your phone to survive the horrors, capture clues, and solve puzzles in this first-person psychological horror experience. Trapped inside a warped digital nightmare by a mysterious entity, you must navigate a world where technology distorts reality.

    Why similar: Supernatural 26.2%, Psychological Horror 15.8%, Horror 14.1%, Mystery 14%, Realistic 9.1%

  3. #3 Dark Notes
    96% matchMostly Positive75% of 132 reviews2024
    Dev: HeartBeat Plus
    Windows

    Dark Notes is a dark suspense puzzle game . You will play as the two protagonists, traveling through time and space to explore the secrets hidden in Happiness Mall!a secret concerning both protagonists surfaces... ...Anything can be a perfect fairytale as long as you believe it.

    Why similar: Supernatural 19.9%, Incremental 17.5%, Psychological Horror 13.2%, Horror 12.8%, Mystery 12.2%

  4. #4 House Of Nowhere
    95% match3 user reviews75% of 3 reviews2026
    Dev: Glassroot Interactive
    Windows

    Survive a merciless hunt in the House of Nowhere. Alone in a haunting home that no longer feels like your own, you must solve puzzles to escape into a vast, silent forest. Scavenge for your life and uncover the truth before the ancient thing hunting you turns your story into a forgotten legend.

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 17.2%, Horror 15.4%, Supernatural 13.8%, Puzzle 12.5%, Mystery 10.9%

  5. #5 Echoes of Absence
    94% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Crimson Robin Studios
    Windows

    A narrative psychological horror game where you'll explore different environments and fragments of your past. Solve puzzles and uncover a truth some would rather forget.

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 22.8%, Supernatural 17.1%, Horror 16.7%, Mystery 11.4%, First-Person 9.5%

  6. #6 Victim Complex: Part 1
    94% matchMostly Positive74% of 27 reviews2024
    Dev: 5ive Bullet Games
    Windows

    Use your wits and iconic ghost hunting equipment to uncover the mystery of what happened to the residents of an abandoned apartment complex in this narrative-driven horror experience.

    Why similar: Supernatural 24.3%, Interactive Fiction 16%, Horror 13.3%, Mystery 12.3%, Psychological Horror 12.3%

  7. #7 Echoes Of Fear: Whispers in the Abyss
    93% match8 user reviews38% of 8 reviews2024
    Dev: Michael LapinskiPub: DarkByte Studios
    Windows

    Embark on a spine-chilling journey, wielding a dimensional camera to unveil occult mysteries. Decrypt ancient runes as you traverse the enigmatic horrors within. Can you escape the abyssal whispers that echo through the darkness?

    Why similar: Supernatural 29.9%, Psychological Horror 23.6%, Horror 10.7%, Mystery 8.6%, Story Rich 7.4%

  8. #8 Can't revert
    92% matchMostly Positive80% of 236 reviews2024
    Dev: Metaphor
    Windows

    Can't revert is a first-person psychological horror game. You repeatedly find yourself in a house where your wife and son are dead. Discover hidden clues in the house and uncover the secrets of their deaths. Experience the constant tension and fear in the repetitive space.

    Why similar: Supernatural 41.4%, Psychological Horror 13%, Mystery 11.5%, Horror 10.7%, Realistic 7.5%

  9. #9 The Hat Man
    91% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: Black Lantern Entertainment
    Windows

    A first-person psychological horror game inspired by The Hat Man urban legend, focusing on sleep paralysis, fear, and the terror of being unable to move.

    Why similar: Supernatural 20.5%, Psychological Horror 18.9%, Horror 17.1%, Interactive Fiction 10.8%, Mystery 10.3%

  10. #10 August Night
    91% matchMostly Positive72% of 86 reviews2025
    Dev: Sahl Ibrahimi
    Windows

    Escape a distorted version of your own newly rented apartment in this interactive nightmare.

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 25.5%, Supernatural 23.4%, Horror 15.7%, First-Person 10.4%, Realistic 10.1%

  11. #11 Mockbuster Video
    90% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: 0XP Game Studios
    Windows

    A first-person psychological horror set in a late-night 1990s video rental store. As disturbing tapes begin to surface, reality distorts and your decisions shape how the night unfolds.

    Why similar: Supernatural 25.6%, Psychological Horror 21%, Horror 15.5%, Mystery 11%, First-Person 8.9%

  12. #12 Echoes of the Lost
    89% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Kostaz Games
    Windows

    A first-person psychological horror game where you play as Hugo, a young boy searching for his missing brother, Jimmy, in an eerie mansion. Solve puzzles, explore haunted halls, and uncover dark secrets while facing supernatural threats.

    Why similar: Supernatural 28.4%, Psychological Horror 17.6%, Horror 15.3%, Mystery 14.6%, First-Person 9.1%

  13. #13 The Butler
    88% matchVery Positive86% of 101 reviews2026
    Dev: TSGAMES LLC
    Windows

    A psychological horror spin-off of the acclaimed game Claire. You play as Deacon, a man searching for his missing father, but the deeper you dug, the darker the truths you uncovered, secrets you wish you’d never found, and that will haunt you forever.

    Why similar: Supernatural 26.4%, Psychological Horror 16.6%, Horror 15.4%, First-Person 10%, Puzzle 9%

  14. #14 Tarpit
    89% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: Koivu Games
    Windows

    Tarpit is a psychological indie horror game where you have to make TAR to rescue your friend from danger. Beware of the forces in your surroundings. The forces definitely see you... but do you see them?

    Why similar: Supernatural 29.4%, Psychological Horror 18.6%, Horror 17.6%, Mystery 13.3%, Realistic 7.3%

  15. #15 Tales of Fear - Episode Zero
    86% matchVery Positive96% of 467 reviews2026
    Dev: MediaTale
    Windows

    Can you tell the difference between truth and tale? Experience three short horror stories and gather clues as to which are true and which are just part of our imagination. Immerse yourself in the protagonist's perspective and discover eerie tales from around the world.

    Why similar: Supernatural 22.5%, Horror 19.4%, Mystery 18.1%, Psychological Horror 16.5%, Realistic 6.9%

  16. #16 Late Night with Ken Hayes
    87% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: SludgePup Games
    Windows

    Host the graveyard shift at a small-town radio station in 1998. Callers keep describing the same pale man—and every time someone talks about him on air, he seems to get closer.

    Why similar: Supernatural 21.2%, Psychological Horror 19.8%, Horror 18.4%, Mystery 10.6%, First-Person 8.7%

  17. #17 Dread Disc
    86% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: MadBug Studio
    Windows

    A strange game disc appears at your door. Every difference you spot changes your apartment while something unknown tries to find a way inside.

    Why similar: Supernatural 27.1%, Psychological Horror 18.8%, Horror 14.5%, Mystery 11.6%, Realistic 6.9%

  18. #18 The House: A Maple Street Story
    85% matchMixed67% of 15 reviews2024
    Dev: Krondak Studio
    Windows

    Explore a cursed house where a family was driven to madness by a dark presence. In The House: A Maple Street Story, uncover a terrifying mystery through enigmatic puzzles, an engaging narrative, and a psychological horror atmosphere that holds your every move captive.

    Why similar: Supernatural 31.5%, Psychological Horror 20.3%, Horror 18.9%, Realistic 9.5%, First-Person 8.9%

  19. #19 COS-249
    84% matchMostly Positive77% of 13 reviews2024
    Dev: Void Ink
    Windows

    Welcome to your new job. You will be viewing a recording of COS-249. The test subject's is E-376 he will be recording his full experience in the room.The room is full of anomalous objects and entities. The only objective is to stay alive.But don't worry there is cake at the end.

    Why similar: Incremental 25.9%, Psychological Horror 22.8%, Horror 21.5%, Mystery 10.3%, Story Rich 5.8%

  20. #20 The Blackwood Legacy
    84% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2024
    Dev: Connor Elsworth
    Windows

    Step into the unsettling world of The Blackwood Legacy, a first-person puzzle horror game set in the eerie halls of Blackwood Manor. Solve intricate puzzles, unveil long-held secrets, and decipher the mystery surrounding your father's disappearance.

    Why similar: Supernatural 31.3%, Mystery 17.9%, Interactive Fiction 15.9%, Puzzle 9.3%, Stylized 7.5%

  21. #21 Purgatorial Learning
    83% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Niwaessence
    Windows

    Purgatorial Learning drags you deep into dreams and nightmares that weave through each other, capturing you into its otherworldly web. Explore this nightmare, find the cracks within and escape from a dream that isn't yours!

    Why similar: Metroidvania 22.9%, Psychological Horror 15.5%, Interactive Fiction 11.6%, Mystery 11.5%, Horror 11%

  22. #22 SIX FINGERS الأصابع الستة
    82% match5 user reviews60% of 5 reviews2024
    Dev: WALEED
    Windows

    Six Fingers is a psychological horror game where you solve puzzles, face obstacles, and experience Jump scares in a terrifying environment that tests your psychological strength

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 24.1%, Supernatural 22.5%, Mystery 16%, Horror 13.7%, Puzzle 10.8%

  23. #23 Eclipsed Memories
    81% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: SheepGamesStudios
    Windows

    Every town is unique. Liddy's town has a lot of supernatural activity and it is her job to find and free entities stuck in our realm. Join her and her friends on their adventures, finding clues and ways to banish the creatures that shouldn't be here.

    Why similar: Supernatural 31.3%, Psychological Horror 17%, Horror 14.6%, Interactive Fiction 14.2%, Story Rich 6.4%

  24. #24 The Off-Season
    81% matchNo user reviews2027
    Dev: 3Cats Studio
    Windows · Mac · Linux

    You are the winter caretaker of a seaside hotel nobody visits between October and March. The owner's rules are pinned above the desk: no guests, no exceptions. Then somebody knocks — off the last bus, in the rain, with cash and no booking. You decide who gets a key, and which room.

    Why similar: Supernatural 23.3%, Psychological Horror 15.6%, Mystery 12.9%, Horror 12.3%, Interactive Fiction 9.9%

  25. #25 Alone in the Office
    82% matchMixed50% of 12 reviews2021
    Dev: OKONNAYA RAMA
    Windows

    You will play as office worker who was left to finish the job. While working on last documents you starting hearing strange sounds. How could this be? You are pretty sure that you are alone in the office.

    Why similar: Supernatural 24.6%, Psychological Horror 17.2%, Horror 16.2%, Mystery 10.4%, First-Person 9.2%

  26. #26 Unsainted
    79% matchNo user reviews2027
    Dev: CreakGames
    Windows

    Dva roky po zmizení svých přátel se mladý Lucas vrací na místo, kde je naposledy viděl. Místo toho však odhalí temné tajemství, které propojuje minulost s přítomností. Ponořte se do hluboce psychologického příběhu odehrávajícího se na opuštěném panství uprostřed amerického lesa.

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 20.6%, Horror 19.1%, Supernatural 15.4%, Mystery 12.7%, Realistic 10.5%

  27. #27 Nocturia The Game
    78% matchMostly Positive76% of 57 reviews2025
    Dev: BrossLab
    Windows

    Trapped in the pitch blackness of your own home, you’re a helpless child, alone and pursued by a sinister entity lurking in the shadows. Solve puzzles, brave ever-shifting environments, and uncover a terrible secret. Your worst nightmares come to life. Can you survive the night?

    Why similar: Supernatural 25.5%, Psychological Horror 14.6%, Mystery 13.5%, Horror 13%, Interactive Fiction 8%

  28. #28 The Visitor
    80% matchMostly Negative28% of 32 reviews2022
    Dev: Raining Glass Studios
    Windows

    In 'The Visitor' you will play as an author named Rachel. Your goal is to complete your book chapter by chapter before the deadline that is coming up. The longer you sit and type, the more you will slip into a schizophrenia state of mind. Complete the chapters and return to a normal average life!

    Why similar: Supernatural 28.7%, Psychological Horror 21.4%, Horror 20.5%, Realistic 13.1%, First-Person 7.2%

  29. #29 The Chant
    79% matchMostly Positive75% of 1,272 reviews2022
    Dev: Brass TokenPub: Prime Matter
    Windows
    Median: 3.9 hrsMean: 8.6 hrs≥1hr: 72%

    A single-player, third person horror action-adventure game set on a remote spiritual island retreat. To survive you must craft, fight, and escape the psychedelic horrors set loose when a spiritual ritual goes wrong and awakens a dimension of cosmic terror.

    Why similar: Supernatural 24%, Psychological Horror 15%, Horror 12.3%, Mystery 12%, Third Person 10.5%

  30. #30 Paranormal Night Shift
    77% matchVery Positive97% of 205 reviews2025
    Dev: Wheeler Whale Games
    Windows

    Paranormal Night Shift is an observation and spot the anomaly game set in a haunted house in the 1980s.

    Why similar: Supernatural 26.3%, Psychological Horror 17.9%, Interactive Fiction 12.8%, Mystery 12.4%, Puzzle 9%

  31. #31 Victim Complex
    78% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: 5ive Bullet Games
    Windows

    You’re in over your head… try not to lose it. In Victim Complex, you're a fraud - a ghost-hunter who pretends to be able to commune with the dead. For the first time, you seem to have encountered the real deal– a nightmarish entity haunting an apartment complex. Can your fake tools help you survive?

    Why similar: Supernatural 29.9%, Psychological Horror 18.6%, Horror 16.4%, Mystery 14.6%, First-Person 6.1%

  32. #32 Obfuscation
    76% matchMostly Positive75% of 53 reviews2025
    Dev: mid1224
    Windows

    Escaping from a car trunk, you find yourself in the garage of a mysterious house, with no memory of what happened. Step inside this first-person psychological horror experience and uncover the truth hidden inside.

    Why similar: Supernatural 25.5%, Psychological Horror 18.8%, Horror 16.4%, Mystery 12.5%, Realistic 7.6%

  33. #33 Eclipse
    77% matchNo user reviews2027
    Dev: HNStudios
    Windows

    Three friends known as The Ghost Hunters are documenting abandoned locations. What begins as a normal episode suddenly turns into a nightmare inside The Holloway Mansion. Something terrifying happens, leaving Jack to survive alone in the mansion and face the horrors.

    Why similar: Supernatural 22.5%, Psychological Horror 18.9%, Horror 18.5%, Mystery 14.7%, First-Person 8.9%

  34. #34 Obscuroid
    76% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: Five Clover Games
    Windows

    Obscuroid is a psychological horror puzzle game where you use a changing non-Euclidean environment to solve puzzles. Venture through a mind-bending liminal realm, use Polaroids to manipulate your surroundings, conjure your escape, or be consumed by whatever might wander the realm's vacant halls.

    Why similar: Supernatural 29%, Psychological Horror 19.5%, Horror 13.1%, Mystery 9.6%, Puzzle 9.4%

  35. #35 Threads of Karma
    75% matchMixed54% of 72 reviews2025
    Dev: 萝卜不长毛线公司Pub: Hawthorn Games
    Windows

    Lin Yue'an embarks on a journey home, but unsettling events soon disrupt her ordinary life. Strange dreams, lost memories, and eerie occurrences lead her to uncover hidden truths. Can she trace everything back to its true origin and escape the net of fate that has already been woven around her?

    Why similar: Supernatural 26.1%, Mystery 15.5%, Interactive Fiction 13.9%, Horror 13.5%, Psychological Horror 11.1%

  36. #36 Phobic Nightmares
    74% matchMostly Positive79% of 19 reviews2025
    Dev: ClusterFame Games
    Windows · Linux

    Phobic Nightmares is a psychological horror game where you experience nightmarish realities to uncover what happened to your sister. Find notes from your sister and use the sacrifices of those who came before you to uncover what’s hidden and avoid ending up like them.

    Why similar: Supernatural 29%, Psychological Horror 18.4%, Horror 16.9%, Puzzle 7.9%, Mystery 7.7%

  37. #37 The Hauntings: Dark Passenger
    75% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Broken Cuff Studio
    Windows

    Dive into Alex Mercer's twisted reality. Navigate eerie landscapes, solve cryptic puzzles, and uncover the 'Dark Passenger' mystery. Will shadows consume you or will truth emerge?

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 22.6%, Horror 21.6%, Puzzle 12.5%, Mystery 11.1%, First-Person 10.5%

  38. #38 Unknown Call: Ohio
    74% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: Arachnocoder
    Windows

    You wake up in an empty forest in Ohio. A voice calls you. Says you're friends. Says you need to get out. But the signal keeps breaking, and so does your memory. Your friend will guide you from a distance, but he can't save you. Escape the creatures in the dark and find your friend.

    Why similar: Supernatural 19.4%, Psychological Horror 16.5%, Interactive Fiction 15.3%, Mystery 15%, Horror 11.1%

  39. #39 Son Of The Exorcist
    73% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2026
    Dev: TRA-J-D STUDIO
    Windows

    You play as a son looking for his missing father, after he does not return from a job, you visit a mysterious mansion in his neighborhood to uncover what happened. Explore rooms, solve puzzles and face tense moments as you try to uncover the secrets inside relating to his disappearance.

    Why similar: Supernatural 23.8%, Horror 19.9%, Psychological Horror 17.1%, Mystery 16.4%, Story Rich 8.3%

  40. #40 Paranormal Tales
    73% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Digital Cybercherries
    Windows

    Paranormal Tales is a next-gen horror game based on found footage built in Unreal Engine 5. You experience and play through each tragic tale of those who went missing from the viewpoint of bodycams, phones, and VHS cameras. Do you have what it takes to play through the end of the footage?

    Why similar: Supernatural 30.4%, Horror 22.1%, Psychological Horror 21.1%, Realistic 11.4%, Mystery 7.5%

  41. #41 They See You
    71% matchPositive82% of 28 reviews2026
    Dev: MengEXE
    Windows

    A computer engineer arrives in a remote mountain village, where tech failures and missing residents put him face to face with an unsettling force lurking behind the screen.

    Why similar: Supernatural 20.1%, Psychological Horror 19%, Horror 14.2%, Mystery 11.4%, Puzzle 7.3%

  42. #42 Late Night Mystery
    73% matchMostly Positive77% of 13 reviews2025
    Dev: Angel Hidalgo
    Windows

    A terrifying story that immerses you in a dark world full of horrific surprises that will leave the player frozen in fear.

    Why similar: Supernatural 25.6%, Psychological Horror 14.4%, Mystery 14.2%, Horror 13%, Interactive Fiction 12.3%

  43. #43 In Silent Walls: Origines
    72% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: Hollow Signal Games
    Windows

    In Silent Walls: Origins is a narrative psychological horror game where you investigate an abandoned mansion through disturbing visions and mysterious objects linked to the past.

    Why similar: Supernatural 34.8%, Psychological Horror 22.5%, Horror 21.2%, Third Person 6.1%, Story Rich 5.7%

  44. #44 Amanda the Adventurer 3
    70% matchVery Positive87% of 750 reviews2025
    Dev: MANGLEDmaw GamesPub: DreadXP
    Windows
    Median: 3.9 hrsMean: 4.4 hrs≥1hr: 89%

    In the thrilling conclusion of the Amanda the Adventurer trilogy, follow Riley as they uncover the ultimate secrets behind Amanda, Hameln, and mysteries that have plagued Kensdale for decades.

    Why similar: Interactive Fiction 20.7%, Horror 14.7%, Psychological Horror 14.6%, Supernatural 14.2%, Puzzle 10.6%

  45. #45 The Maze Project
    72% match5 user reviews60% of 5 reviews2025
    Dev: Denis Schreiner
    Windows

    The Maze Project is a psychological horror game set in a dark, creepy maze. Unaware of how you found yourself here, you must escape from this twisted nightmare. Survive from the dark manifestations that lurk around the maze waiting for every opportunity to get you, and uncover the hidden secrets.

    Why similar: Supernatural 28.2%, Psychological Horror 18.3%, Horror 15.6%, Mystery 14.2%, First-Person 7%

  46. #46 Blind Exposure
    71% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Shy Games
    Windows

    Navigate through claustrophobic, completely dark world illuminated only by scans you manage to create; listen carefully to sounds coming from the darkness, and don’t let dread and paranoia get to you.

    Why similar: Supernatural 29.5%, Psychological Horror 19.2%, Horror 17.1%, Mystery 10.8%, Puzzle 8%

  47. #47 Observation Protocol
    69% match6 user reviews100% of 6 reviews2026
    Dev: Pulsar One
    Windows

    A first-person psychological horror game where you monitor a liminal office space for anomalies from an external observation post. When the power cuts, protocol requires you to enter and continue your work from the inside. You're not alone in there.

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 24.3%, Supernatural 24%, Horror 22.9%, Mystery 13.8%, First-Person 10.5%

  48. #48 Cursed Bet
    71% matchMixed57% of 102 reviews2024
    Dev: LIGHTWORKER GAMES
    Windows

    Cursed Bet is a horror game where you play from a body camera perspective. Enter the abandoned preschool, the subject of terrible rumors, in the midnight. Struggle the cursed doll Ebeleen as you investigate the school's dark past. Will you be able to destroy him and his curse?

    Why similar: Supernatural 29.6%, Horror 16.2%, Psychological Horror 14.1%, Mystery 14%, First-Person 8.5%

  49. #49 THE SUSPENSE
    70% matchNo user reviews2027
    Dev: M8 WORKSHOP
    Windows

    Discover the story of a man tortured by the hardships of life among “endless rusty walls”. Explore the world of a terrifying alternative future, overcome challenges, and maybe you'll be saved (or at least learn a hint of the truth).

    Why similar: Metroidvania 29%, Psychological Horror 17.7%, Horror 16.2%, Mystery 11.5%, Puzzle 7.7%

  50. #50 Let Me In
    69% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Union State Games
    Windows

    Let Me In is a psychological indie horror game with a realistic visual style and intense atmosphere. The main character finds himself in an abandoned house on one of the scariest nights of his life. Will he be able to survive? The answer remains unknown...

    Why similar: Supernatural 24.1%, Psychological Horror 19.9%, Horror 18.5%, Realistic 10.8%, First-Person 8.2%

  51. #51 海宴:潮汐
    69% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: 漫森游戏工作室
    Windows

    "The Bait:Tide" is a 3D first person action adventure narrative game. An ancient portrait of unknown origin, let An Xin return to the eastern fishing hometown.And across the sea, on the magnificent waves, we meet again for a century of engagement.

    Why similar: Mystery 19.7%, Supernatural 19.1%, Horror 17.7%, Psychological Horror 13.5%, First-Person 10.5%

  52. #52 Dreamstate
    70% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2024
    Dev: 8:95games
    Windows

    Dreamstate, can you survive your worst nightmare? In a point-and-click sit-and-survival psychological horror game, you fight off your nightmares throughout multiple nights to make it to the end of the week, with each night getting more challenging.

    Why similar: Incremental 22.6%, Psychological Horror 15.7%, Horror 13.4%, Puzzle 9.2%, Mystery 8.8%

  53. #53 Unread
    68% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: MogzDev
    Windows

    Undergo intellectual exercises that push your mind to its psychological limits. As the eerie silent night ticks the mind, you wake up and survive every hour as you find your way back to sleep. Some ways you sleep may be puzzling, uneasy, or even horrifying.

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 32.5%, Mystery 20.7%, Horror 12.2%, Puzzle 9.4%, First-Person 8.7%

  54. #54 Haemu Station: The Last Announcement
    68% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: NION
    Windows

    A first-person horror puzzle game set in an abandoned Korean railway station. Follow your lost sister’s voice, examine forgotten belongings and operate strange devices. Hide when footsteps draw near. In the dark, the voice guiding you may be the one you should fear.

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 22.8%, Horror 21.4%, Supernatural 12.9%, Puzzle 10.9%, First-Person 9.9%

  55. #55 A Night at Ashmere Manor
    67% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Bandaloop Games GmbH
    Windows

    When your father goes missing with little more than a letter to clue you in, it's up to you to find him. His last known whereabouts? Ashmere Manor. Will you succeed in solving the mystery at the heart of the house and find your father, or will you succumb to its phantom call?

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 17.3%, Supernatural 16.9%, Horror 14%, Interactive Fiction 12.7%, Mystery 11.6%

  56. #56 The 7th Guest Remake
    65% matchVery Positive88% of 300 reviews2026
    Dev: Vertigo Games
    Windows

    The iconic game The 7th Guest has been brought back to life with modern technology, delivering an atmospheric story like no other. Explore a foreboding mansion, solve mind-bending puzzles, and uncover its dark secrets. The 7th Guest is the ultimate mystery adventure, reimagined for modern platforms.

    Why similar: Interactive Fiction 23%, Supernatural 22.7%, Mystery 18.3%, Puzzle 12.3%, First-Person 5.8%

  57. #57 UNIVERSAL WEIRDNESS
    65% matchVery Positive90% of 51 reviews2026
    Dev: Cotton Game
    Windows

    A 2D hand-drawn puzzle adventure that spans multiple dimensions and universes. Encounter a diverse cast of characters and unravel mind-bending mysteries as you embark on unique adventures across different worlds.

    Why similar: Supernatural 28.3%, Incremental 19.4%, Psychological Horror 16.3%, Mystery 10.6%, Horror 10.4%

  58. #58 Letsss Play
    67% match2 user reviews50% of 2 reviews2025
    Dev: Alexander ZmeevPub: ZMV Studio
    Windows

    A blogger investigates disappearances at a mall built on the ashes of a circus. Posing as a night guard, he must uncover the truth behind the tragic fire and learn whose restless souls now haunt the halls. Gather clues and survive before the past consumes you.

    Why similar: Supernatural 35.7%, Horror 20%, Psychological Horror 12.8%, First-Person 8.8%, Puzzle 7.5%

  59. #59 Shadow Of The Abyss
    66% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Jimmybear Studios
    Windows

    Shadow Of The Abyss is a psychological horror game where you play through the eyes of a bodycam. As a security guard, your job is to survey an office building during a night shift, until you fall into the hands of fate.

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 31.6%, Horror 22.7%, Realistic 14.7%, First-Person 11.7%, Story Rich 8.2%

  60. #60 The Silent Forests
    67% match4 user reviews0% of 5 reviews2025
    Dev: ABMKF Studio
    Windows

    🏠 Embark on a captivating journey through the Silent Forests, treacherous sewers, and a mysterious house. Solve puzzles, face monsters, and unravel hidden truths in this adrenaline-packed adventure with a wacky narrator! 🌲🚪✨

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 19.3%, Horror 18.1%, Supernatural 18%, Mystery 11.2%, Puzzle 10.2%

Modeli
Ollie's After Midnight cover art

Games Like Ollie's After Midnight

Based on tag similarity + player behavior
Loading graph...