- #1 Mouthwashing
97% matchOverwhelmingly Positive95% of 36,697 reviews2024
Dev: Wrong OrganPub: CRITICAL REFLEX
Windows
Median: 2.8 hrsMean: 3.4 hrs≥1hr: 90%
The five crew members of the Tulpar are stranded in the empty reaches of space, shrouded in perpetual sunset. God is not watching.
Why similar: Psychological Horror 18.8%, Psychological 17.6%, Narrative 13.4% ★, Horror 11.1%, Retro 10.2%
- #2 Plastomorphosis
96% matchMostly Positive79% of 80 reviews2024
Dev: VidyGames
Windows
Evacuated from their hometown due to dangerous bursts of dark energy, the ordinary citizen is trying to overcome and survive a series of events in a new reality where living as a human is no longer possible as it once was. 3rd-person horror with fixed camera angles and retro-styled graphics.
Why similar: Old School 15.8%, Psychological Horror 15.3%, 1990's 14.3%, Horror 12.4%, Retro 11.5%
- #3 Wild Dose
96% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Lappi Soft
Windows · Mac · Linux
In a fractured world where virtual drugs are used to escape reality, you’ve found the best. Or the worst. Hard to say. But your choices will have very real consequences.
Why similar: Psychological 20.3%, Psychological Horror 15.6%, Narrative 11.5% ★, Horror 11.4%, Retro 11.3%
- #4 REST STOP
94% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Ant Parade Interactive LLC
Windows
Abandoned and alone at a highway rest stop in the middle of the Appalachian Mountains, the night breeze begins to caress your cheek. The scent of wet pine whispers that you’re home. The taste of iron in your mouth reminds you that you can’t stay here forever.
Why similar: Psychological 25.1%, Psychological Horror 19.6%, Narrative 17.8% ★, Horror 13.3%, Retro 8.8%
- #5 First Session
95% matchVery Positive81% of 89 reviews2021
Dev: Lappi Soft
Windows
First Person Psychological Horror. Addicted to virtual ecstasy, trapped in digital hell. Navigate glitchy dreamscapes and a city that never sleeps. Every mission brings you closer to your next dose, but will you follow your protective AI, or the man behind a liberating new drug?
Why similar: Psychological 18.9%, Psychological Horror 15%, Narrative 14.3% ★, Horror 10.9%, Retro 10.7%
- #6 Vineyard
94% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Sitting Elephant
Windows
A short, first-person horror game where you play as a desperate man seeking a cure for his sick wife in a mysterious vineyard. Harvest, crush and ferment grapes as you uncover the secret beyond the basement doors.
Why similar: Psychological 21.5%, Psychological Horror 17%, Horror 14.3%, Mystery 11.3%, Retro 10%
- #7 Fire in the Dark
93% matchNo user reviews
Dev: MirrorForge
Windows · Mac · Linux
"Fire in the Dark" is a psychological meta-horror where the eerie game on the heroine’s computer and her room merge into one world, revealing each trauma through your actions.
Why similar: Psychological 20%, Narrative 15% ★, Psychological Horror 14.5%, Retro 10.9%, Horror 10.7%
- #8 BRAINSHELL
92% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: BRAINSHELL Team
Windows
Have you ever wondered what it would be like to become an Intercontinental Ballistic Missile? A psychological horror experience focusing on immersion, storytelling and audiovisual torment.
Why similar: Alternate History 18.1%, Psychological 17.6%, Psychological Horror 13.6%, Retro 10.7%, Horror 10.1%
- #9 Judgment: Ankara 01
91% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Syrion Interactive
Windows
Truth is a binding consequence. Can you escape the truth?
Why similar: Psychological 21.7%, Old School 15.5%, Psychological Horror 14.2%, Retro 11.5%, Horror 10.8%
- #10 Ware's Laboratory
91% matchNo user reviews
Dev: VNDI
Windows · Linux
Anti-piracy measures are now active. Your game has turned into a surreal nightmare. Crawl through corrupted levels, read notes from a malicious developer, and confront the dark past in multiple realities.
Why similar: Narrative 15.5% ★, Psychological Horror 14.9%, Psychological 14.7%, Horror 11.9%, Surreal 9.4%
- #11 Taisho Taxi Service
90% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Not Dead Yet
Windows
Experience a first-person retro horror journey in rural Japan. Navigate in your taxi, picking up sketchy passengers, while vigilantly monitoring your map, rear-view mirror, and the treacherous road. Confront your deepest fears in this open-world nightmare where survival is far from certain.
Why similar: Psychological 15.6%, 1990's 15.5%, Psychological Horror 13.4%, Old School 12.5%, Alternate History 12%
- #12 Fragments of Dread - Late Lines FM
89% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Domnaier
Windows
Late Lines FM is a first-person, story-driven psychological horror experience. Your night shift at 107.9 FM turns into a nightmare with the forbidden 99.9 frequency. When the cursed song plays, you should cover your ears but to find the radio, you must listen.
Why similar: Narrative 20.4% ★, 1990's 16.5%, Psychological Horror 16%, Horror 11.5%, Retro 11.1%
- #13 Empty Heaven: Liminal Dream
89% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Deep One Games
Windows
A narrative psychological horror settled in dreamlike spaces. Explore, observe, and listen as strange entities, cryptic clues, and discoveries pull you deeper. Inspired by Backrooms and Dreamcore. No jumpscares or chases, only the empty feeling that the world is a dream that you forgot to wake up.
Why similar: Psychological Horror 21.9%, Psychological 19%, Retro 11.3%, Mystery 11.2%, Story Rich 11.1%
- #14 Jamie's Dream
88% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Cartonbox Studio
Windows · Mac · Linux
Jamie's Dream is a short, emotional, experimental, psychological horror narrative experience. Walk through nightmares, facing fears and memories as they are revealed going deeper and deeper into the abyss of Jamie's mind.
Why similar: Psychological 21.3%, Narrative 16.4% ★, Psychological Horror 15.9%, Horror 11.3%, Surreal 10%
- #15 Lake Haven - Chrysalis
87% matchVery Positive97% of 499 reviews2023
Dev: Encrypt Games
Windows
This game serves as a prequel chapter for the upcoming game 'Lake Haven'. Detective Zeke Reynold is called to investigate what he assumes will be another case he'll quickly forget, but what he finds will be sewn into the fabric of his existence forever.
Why similar: Old School 19.7%, Horror 13.5%, 1990's 8.9%, Surreal 8.8%, Story Rich 8.2%
- #16 Amanda the Adventurer
86% matchVery Positive94% of 7,110 reviews2023
Dev: MANGLEDmaw GamesPub: DreadXP
Windows
Median: 3.0 hrsMean: 4.7 hrs≥1hr: 90%
Join Amanda and her pal Wooly on a series of adventures as they explore and learn about our wonderful world! With several NEW play-along, laugh-along, learn-along episodes there's always fun to be had! Just make sure to do everything Amanda says or she might get angry.
Why similar: 1990's 19.9%, Horror 16.8%, Old School 16.2%, Mystery 10.1%, Psychological 9.9%
- #17 Ghostprint
86% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: DevRoids
Windows
Atmospheric first-person horror game where you carry an old Polaroid camera. Take the right picture and a way forward emerges.
Why similar: Psychological Horror 22.7%, Horror 14.6%, 1990's 12.8%, Psychological 10.5%, Retro 9.3%
- #18 FATHER
85% matchNo user reviews
Dev: wetboxteam
Windows
The family lives in isolation, following the strict rules of the father. But the attempt to escape evil turns into a horror that grows from within.
Why similar: Psychological 22.8%, Psychological Horror 17.5%, Retro 12.7%, Horror 12.7%, Story Rich 9.6%
- #19 Knock On The Window
84% matchVery Positive91% of 182 reviews2025
Dev: Tropical Games
Windows
Martin has been given an urgent assignment at work. However, for this he had to go to the house of his Boss. And so Martin found himself alone at home, in the middle of a vast field of sunflowers. Everything was going well until there was a knock on the window.
Why similar: Psychological Horror 17.5%, Psychological 15.9%, 1990's 14.7%, Horror 14.5%, Story Rich 9%
- #20 BLOK
84% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Pyotr Vozniak
Windows
BLOK is an Orwellian psychological horror game set in post-communist Poland. You play as a political exile who fled during the communist regime. Years later, after the system’s collapse, a strange letter from your mother draws you back home. But something is deeply wrong.
Why similar: Psychological Horror 24%, Horror 15.9%, Mystery 13.3%, Retro 12.1%, 1990's 12.1%
- #21 Fragments
83% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Lazar VaragicPub: Dangly Dango Studio
Windows
Your mind is shattered. Step into a first-person psychological horror where you must relive your deepest trauma, uncover fragments of your past, piece them back together and face the tormentors that haunt your mind.
Why similar: Psychological Horror 22.4%, Psychological 15.6%, Horror 15.2%, Narrative 11% ★, Story Rich 10%
- #22 PECADO
82% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Solid Neon SD
Windows
PECADO is a first-person folkloric horror experience set in the “España profunda”. Listen to the word of God.
Why similar: Narrative 25.1% ★, Psychological Horror 15.8%, 1990's 13.6%, Horror 12.8%, Retro 9.9%
- #23 Dad left me in the car
81% match9 user reviews44% of 9 reviews2025
Dev: MA
Windows
Survival horror game about a girl trapped in a car
Why similar: Psychological 19.2%, Psychological Horror 18.5%, Narrative 17.1% ★, Retro 11.1%, Story Rich 8.7%
- #24 Valley of Shadows
81% matchMostly Positive78% of 23 reviews2024
Dev: BadTaste Studio
Windows
Valley of Shadows is a short psychological horror set in an ordinary American suburb. Players navigate as James, a family man seeking answers about his missing family, while grappling with paranoia and supernatural forces.
Why similar: Psychological 21.1%, Psychological Horror 16.2%, 1990's 15.7%, Horror 12.7%, Mystery 9.3%
- #25 Cryptica
79% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Graham Uhelski
Windows
Cryptica is a narrative-based psychological horror game where the apocalypse is just the beginning. Explore the enigmatic lands of Antarctica and find the missing film crew.
Why similar: Narrative 20.4% ★, Alternate History 17.7%, Psychological 15.9%, Psychological Horror 11.9%, Horror 9.1%
- #26 Seybul Tech
80% matchVery Positive91% of 135 reviews2023
Dev: Seybul Tech
Windows
Seybul Tech is a walking simulator. Navigate as an office employee, confronting peculiar encounters while in search of an exit from this enigmatic abyss.
Why similar: Psychological Horror 19.2%, Psychological 17.7%, 1990's 14%, Surreal 12.3%, Horror 11.1%
- #27 Football Game
82% matchVery Positive92% of 319 reviews2018
Dev: Cloak and Dagger Games
Windows
Median: 1.4 hrsMean: 2.5 hrs≥1hr: 75%
You are Tommy, a local high school football hero in the town of East Bend. It’s game night for the Purchase County Turbines and your sweetheart is waiting in the bleachers. Join Tommy for a night you won’t forget...
Why similar: Psychological 22.5%, Narrative 13.5% ★, Psychological Horror 13.4%, 1990's 11.8%, Horror 11.1%
- #28 A Horror Story - The Trailer Park
78% match8 user reviews88% of 8 reviews2026
Dev: Yeray Gómez
Windows
A Horror Story: The Trailer Park is a first-person psychological horror game where players explore a mysterious trailer park, uncover secrets, and face tense, immersive moments driven by narrative and player choice.
Why similar: Psychological Horror 22%, Psychological 20.9%, Horror 15.1%, Retro 14.3%, Old School 11.8%
- #29 BUTLER GUILLOTINE
77% matchPositive100% of 22 reviews2026
Dev: GOODBYE STATICPub: NECRONOMISOFT
Windows
Butler Guillotine is an absurdist point & click horror about flesh filled puppets in a mishapen hotel. Follow different characters' intertiwining paths and unearth forgotten events from a time long gone. Bring the ceremony to a halt.
Why similar: Psychological 16.8%, Psychological Horror 16.7%, Horror 11.8%, Surreal 11.3%, Retro 10.5%
- #30 Goodnight, Sweetie
79% matchPositive83% of 12 reviews2024
Dev: The Queen
Windows
One day, the protagonist begins to have strange dreams. He’s chased by bizarre dolls, and the cozy attic from his childhood feels unrealistically large. He must navigate between dream and reality to understand why this happens. Always treat Teddy with respect; he loves you and remembers everything.
Why similar: Psychological 24.3%, Psychological Horror 16.1%, 3D Platformer 15%, Horror 12.5%, Mystery 10.8%
- #31 Zeizen
78% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Sonoshee
Windows · Mac · Linux
Ultra-violent point & click set in Shanghai, China.
Why similar: Psychological 18.6%, Narrative 15.8% ★, Psychological Horror 13.7%, Horror 10%, Retro 9%
- #32 The Lies We Tell Ourselves
76% matchMostly Positive71% of 119 reviews2025
Dev: Poopsy
Windows
The Lies We Tell Ourselves is an episodic first person psychological action-adventure game with introspective/horror elements and a focus on subtle storytelling and atmosphere. Explore, solve puzzles, survive and uncover truths buried deep within a castle of lies.
Why similar: Psychological Horror 17.8%, Narrative 17.1% ★, Psychological 17%, Horror 10.9%, Story Rich 9%
- #33 Hotel Investigation 09
76% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Squeaks D'CorgehPub: Cogware Games
Windows
An archival of a strange game that cropped up online. Play as Howlz, explore the hotel's halls, and rescue the captive under the building.
Why similar: Psychological 24.7%, Psychological Horror 16%, 1990's 14%, Retro 13.7%, Horror 13.3%
- #34 Cassette
75% matchNo user reviews
Dev: ZhuravlevX
Windows
Cassette – An atmospheric analog psychological horror game in the spirit of old VHS tapes, where you will have to face the unknown and the secrets hidden in the tapes you find.
Why similar: 1990's 22.1%, Old School 15.1%, Retro 14.4%, Horror 14.3%, Psychological Horror 9.8%
- #35 Secret Agent No. 6
75% matchNo user reviews
Dev: ByteHyve
Windows
An unreleased 90s first-person shooter, remastered for PC. Discover various worldwide locations, enemies, weapons, and more. It looks fine on the surface.
Why similar: Psychological 20.4%, Psychological Horror 15.5%, 1990's 13.2%, Retro 12.9%, Old School 10.8%
- #36 Room Escape: Mark's Room
74% matchPositive92% of 24 reviews2025
Dev: G.S. Studio
Windows · Mac
Mark’s Room is an old school hardcore room escape game with intuitive puzzles yet minimum hints, it is designed for puzzle lovers who desire a proper challenge. Collect items, combine or dismantle them, unlock containers, find passwords, solve puzzles, until you find the key to escape the room.
Why similar: Psychological 17.8%, Psychological Horror 14.5%, Old School 14.5%, Horror 10.9%, Retro 10.3%
- #37 The Meaning
77% matchMostly Positive72% of 25 reviews2022
Dev: Ember Eye Studio
Windows
"The Meaning" is a first-person psychological horror game focused on tense exploration and immersive storytelling. You are Ethen Daniels, a man who is struggling with the loss of his family and is now pursuing the meaning of life once again.
Why similar: 1990's 21.9%, Psychological 17.9%, Psychological Horror 17.7%, Horror 14.1%, Mystery 10.6%
- #38 The Facility
74% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Veinstone Studios
Windows
Trust no one. In this PSX-inspired horror game, anomalies are hidden among the subjects. Your task is to identify them before making any decisions. If you fail to detect an anomaly, things may spiral out of control. Which ending will your choices lead to, when reality is not reliable?
Why similar: Psychological 23.6%, Alternate History 19.2%, Psychological Horror 14.8%, Horror 10.9%, Mystery 8.3%
- #39 LucidDynamics
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: HogarthDreams
Windows
Welcome to LucidDynamics, a company where everything is confidential. Analyze and validate audio files without asking questions. But the further you go, the more anomalies appear and reality begins to distort. What is this company really hiding?
Why similar: Psychological 35.8%, 1990's 27.8%, Psychological Horror 27%, Atmospheric 6.1%, Indie 2%
- #40 [Bober Bros] It's Just A Prank
73% matchVery Positive88% of 396 reviews2024
Dev: BOBER BROS
Windows
Median: 48 minMean: 1.4 hrs≥1hr: 27%
It's Just A Prank is a first-person horror game about kids playing pranks on each other until a PRANK GOES WRONG. Experience suspense, fear, and unexpected twists as a simple joke becomes a nightmare.
Why similar: Psychological 22.6%, Psychological Horror 17%, Horror 13.2%, Surreal 10.5%, Old School 8.6%
- #41 KEROGEN
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Zartbitter Games
Windows
Dredge up corpses from an oil-drenched nightmare. Lost at sea, the small crew of the 𝐀𝐓𝐋𝐀𝐒 calls for aid. Elmsfire dances in the clouds above while black beasts stir in the waves beneath. Take your meds. Hold your breath. The black sea won't let go.
Why similar: Narrative 21.3% ★, Psychological 17.9%, Psychological Horror 13.4%, Surreal 9.2%, Mystery 8.8%
- #42 Something Took Her
72% matchMostly Positive75% of 20 reviews2025
Dev: Retrobot
Windows
Within the rural town of Oakview, students are vanishing. One is Amy Morrison, a troubled friend of yours. People say she made a pact with something in the vents of the school. Unravel the mysteries surrounding the town's past, survive the supernatural trauma, and search for traces of your friend.
Why similar: 1990's 21.5%, Psychological Horror 16.4%, Old School 14.8%, Horror 13.5%, Retro 12.7%
- #43 Department of Missing Persons
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: CosmoJão
Windows
In this GeoGuessr-like game, work at Mili Co. using GeoFinder to track missing persons. Stay safe inside the office, cooperate with coworkers, and survive in a world where only the workplace offers security.
Why similar: Psychological Horror 20%, Horror 17%, Retro 15.5%, Psychological 12.4%, Narrative 11.5% ★
- #44 Fatberg
70% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Lilou Studio
Windows
You, a lowly janitor, have been forced to go into the sewers to remove blockages that will cause a flood. But the inhabitants of this dark, slimy, stinking, writhing underworld do not like to be disturbed and will not let you leave alive.
Why similar: Psychological Horror 24.8%, Retro 17.7%, Psychological 14.3%, Horror 13.5%, Old School 13.3%
- #45 The Heart Of Delly
70% matchNo user reviews2027
Dev: RoberttPub: Games Hearlity
Windows
Um jogo de terror psicológico em que Luck, um adolescente, terá que entrar em um laboratório abandonada com um objetivo em mente. Ajude Luck a passar por este desafio, e descubrir todos os misterios da Delly.
Why similar: 1990's 29.9%, Psychological Horror 26.7%, Psychological 19.5%, Story Rich 12.2%, Puzzle 4.5%
- #46 No, I'm not a Human
67% matchVery Positive93% of 28,177 reviews2025
Dev: TrioskazPub: CRITICAL REFLEX
Windows
Median: 3.8 hrsMean: 5.8 hrs≥1hr: 92%
WARNING. Stay inside. Lock your doors. Close the blinds. Only let humans in. Eliminate all Visitors. An anxiety horror about paranoia in the End of Times.
Why similar: Psychological 18.4%, Narrative 17.6% ★, Psychological Horror 16.9%, Horror 14.2%, Story Rich 8.3%
- #47 Birdwatching
70% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Harpia Lab
Windows · Mac
You came to photograph birds at Kûarasy Park. The deserted park, dead birds, and the locals with secrets suggest something darker lurks in the wilderness. Use your camera to uncover the truth behind the folklore.
Why similar: Psychological 27.2%, Psychological Horror 19.2%, Horror 15.6%, Mystery 10.6%, Surreal 6.7%
- #48 The Bunker Freak
69% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Haunted Vision
Windows
You're trapped in an abandoned bunker with no way out. Collect items and solve puzzles to escape, but be careful, because The Bunker Freak is always watching...
Why similar: 1990's 23.1%, Psychological Horror 20.9%, Horror 18%, Retro 15.7%, Old School 15%
- #49 Lotta
69% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Yabuco Games
Windows
Derek Morgan is a 29-year-old watchman who works at a garage complex. One night, he enters an abandoned carpenter's workshop. Inside, he comes across an old wooden puppet. But soon he realizes that his curiosity has brought nothing good with it.
Why similar: 1990's 20.4%, Psychological 19.7%, Psychological Horror 18.1%, Retro 13.5%, Mystery 12.1%
- #50 oneway.exe: Module 1.0
68% matchVery Positive86% of 95 reviews2025
Dev: Disordered Media
Windows
You’re stuck inside an abandoned video game, haunted by its own digital decay. In oneway.exe, uncover the mystery of UNTITLED.exe, its three developers, and the evolving Internet eras that once shaped their love. How does your story end? How did it ever begin?
Why similar: Game Development 25.8% ★, Narrative 22.1% ★, Psychological Horror 13.8%, Horror 12.7%, Mystery 10%
- #51 PHOBOS Project
71% matchMixed67% of 24 reviews2022
Dev: Antoine Aubin
Windows
Phobos Project is a first-person psychological horror adventure exploring the depths of psychological horror. In this experiment you have to find a way out and keep your sanity level up through different hostile environments. Face your dread and try to find the source of the nightmare !
Why similar: Game Development 28.9% ★, Psychological 23.2%, Psychological Horror 15.4%, Horror 11.8%, Mystery 7.6%
- #52 [Chilla's Art] The Convenience Store | 夜勤事件
72% matchVery Positive82% of 3,227 reviews2020
Dev: Chilla's Art
Windows
Median: 1.8 hrsMean: 2.1 hrs≥1hr: 78%
The Convenience Store | 夜勤事件 is a J-horror game about a college girl on a night shift.
Why similar: Horror 28.9%, Psychological Horror 20.9%, Psychological 17.7%, Surreal 7.7%, Mystery 6.9%
- #53 Carrot Cake
69% match6 user reviews83% of 6 reviews2025
Dev: Luna Apps
Windows
In this Easter Horror Game compete in the mini games, solve puzzles, and escape the Easter Bunny. PS1 style survival horror!
Why similar: Psychological 24.8%, Psychological Horror 19.1%, Retro 13.9%, Horror 13.9%, Story Rich 10.4%
- #54 Chaos The Devil
68% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: AccipitusLtd
Windows
A Ps1 era inspired 3D platformer. Run, jump and fly your way through a new adventure, done the old way.
Why similar: 1990's 27.8%, 3D Platformer 26.5%, Retro 16.4%, Cartoony 13.9%, Old School 9.5%
- #55 The Fridge is Red
71% matchMixed56% of 230 reviews2022
Dev: 5WORD TeamPub: tinyBuild
Windows
Median: 3.3 hrsMean: 5.1 hrs≥1hr: 85%
What is inside the Red Fridge? Collection of six episodes of psychological analog horror. Tour through liminal spaces filled with surreal events and uncanny strangers. Inspired by retro horrors of the PSX era.
Why similar: 1990's 16%, Psychological Horror 14.6%, Retro 12.3%, Horror 11.8%, Mystery 10.8%
- #56 Dead Stop - No Vacancy
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Camel 101
Windows
A wrong turn leads investigative reporter Nancy to the Paradise Motel. Explore its dark corridors, solve environmental puzzles, and uncover the disturbing secrets hidden beneath.
Why similar: Psychological Horror 18.2%, Psychological 15.4%, Horror 13.2%, Surreal 10.2%, Old School 9.4%
- #57 Christmas Story
66% matchVery Positive92% of 155 reviews2025
Dev: ZV GAMES
Windows
Christmas Story is a horror game filled with Christmas warmth and coziness, where every festive light hides darkness, and the sense of comfort fades with every step you take.
Why similar: Game Development 34.2% ★, Psychological 16.3%, Psychological Horror 12.6%, 1990's 12.5%, Horror 9.9%
- #58 PISO 6
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: NostalgyStudios
Windows · Mac
PISO 6 is a first-person psychological horror game with a low-poly aesthetic. After his father’s death, Tomás returns to the apartment where he grew up. What seemed like a simple search for a will turns into a nightmare that pulls him back into the past.
Why similar: 1990's 25.4%, Psychological Horror 18.5%, Retro 17%, Horror 12.1%, Story Rich 8%
- #59 Penguin Colony
67% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: ORIGAME DIGITALPub: Fellow Traveller
Windows
Cosmic horror, through the eyes of a penguin. Rival human factions have come to your home in the Antarctic, seeking an ancient and inconceivable being. Observe their descent into insanity in this faithful re-imagining of H.P. Lovecraft’s At the Mountains of Madness, and other stories.
Why similar: Narrative 20.2% ★, Alternate History 17.4%, Psychological Horror 11.9%, 3D Platformer 11.7%, Old School 10.1%
- #60 Shadows of Midnight - They Watch Me Sleep
66% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Punga
Windows · Linux
The game is a narrative-driven horror experience inspired by the Silent Hill and Fears to Fathom franchises. Live through two terrifying stories: a man’s summer getaway turns into a nightmare at a shady hotel, and a child grows up knowing something watches from the forest—always waiting.
Why similar: 1990's 24.4%, Psychological Horror 19.6%, Horror 15.4%, Psychological 13.4%, Old School 11.4%