Games Like The Midnight Exorcist

A wrong turn leads investigative reporter Nancy to the Paradise Motel. Explore its dark corridors, solve environmental puzzles, and uncover the disturbing secrets hidden beneath.

Why similar: Thriller 14.2%, Investigation 12.5%, Supernatural 8.9%, Puzzle 8.6%, Exploration 7.5%

Lost in amnesia, face a horrific past rising from nightmares. Uncover the truth hidden in a diary. In this psychological horror where reality and hallucination blur, piece together memories before madness consumes you. When the truth is out, ask yourself: Who was I?

Why similar: Supernatural 18.4%, Thriller 14.9%, Investigation 11.3%, Mystery 10.3%, Surreal 6.8%

Night Plane is a thrilling airborne hospitality simulator that costs way less than a plane ticket! It's your first night on the job: Board passengers, assist with their struggles, and resolve emergencies all by yourself. Also, please don't let the psychopomp fly the aircraft.

Why similar: Thriller 16.6%, Supernatural 13.1%, Investigation 12.7%, Mystery 9.3%, Logic 7.9%

Silent Surveillance is a horror puzzle game where you monitor multiple security cameras to find anomalies. Stay vigilant—you wouldn't want to succumb to the lurking terror waiting for a single moment of distraction. Can you survive the night?

Why similar: Investigation 18.7%, Thriller 17%, Mystery 12.2%, Supernatural 8.4%, Logic 8.3%

A first person perspective horror game for finding anomalies. This realistic style of 'Escape from 30 Day Cycle' may be suitable for you. You will play the role of a stay at home man. One day, the player is trapped by a mysterious force and needs to explore secrets and find ways to escape

Why similar: Supernatural 22.2%, Investigation 22%, Thriller 15%, Puzzle 6.3%, Horror 6.2%

This is a first-person Chinese horror game, players will go to a murder building, uncover the truth of the murder, find the missing people..

Why similar: Supernatural 19.3%, Thriller 18.9%, Mystery 10.9%, Investigation 10.5%, Horror 7.5%

You find yourself in a house that the owners have long since abandoned. But something lurks in the shadows, watching your every move. Explore the rooms, solve the mysteries, and find a way to banish the evil... Before it gets to you.

Why similar: Supernatural 20.6%, Thriller 20.5%, Investigation 15.9%, Mystery 10.5%, Dark 8.5%

Phobic Nightmares is a psychological horror game where you experience nightmarish realities to uncover what happened to your sister. Find notes from your sister and use the sacrifices of those who came before you to uncover what’s hidden and avoid ending up like them.

Why similar: Supernatural 22.5%, Thriller 16.7%, Investigation 11.6%, Dark 9.5%, Horror 7.9%

Dread Neighbor is a first-person, multi-perspective psychological horror game. Play as a young woman living alone in an unusually cheap apartment. As the days pass, combat the overwhelming sense of unease, malice, and the unshakable feeling that you’re being watched from every crack in the room.

Why similar: Supernatural 18.9%, Thriller 17.9%, Investigation 11.6%, Crime 9.6%, Mystery 9.5%

No Return is a first-person psychological horror game set in modern-day China. With a focus on family tragedy, the story unfolds as our protagonist is mysteriously prevented from returning home by an unseen force. Can he navigate a nightmarish maze of hallways and uncover the disturbing truth?

Why similar: Thriller 17.1%, Supernatural 16%, Investigation 11.5%, Crime 8.8%, Mystery 7.8%

first-person 1-4 multiplayer horror game. The game will allow players to take on the role of a spirit liberator who will be able to freely choose missions based on the difficulty and readiness they like or want to do. Players will encounter the supernatural and find the truth in that place.

Why similar: Supernatural 16.6%, Thriller 16.3%, Investigation 12.4%, Mystery 10.3%, Dark 8.4%

Bump in the Night is a single player game where strategy meets psychological horror. Confined to one room, you'll use cameras and commands to direct NPC investigators and collect evidence. Each environment offers unique challenges and frights. Can you survive what goes bump in the night?

Why similar: Supernatural 22.7%, Investigation 19.8%, Thriller 13.2%, Dark 8.7%, Mystery 7.2%

A narrative supernatural horror set in the enigmatic Meridian Hotel. Players investigate through exploration, puzzles, and encounters with human and supernatural threats.

Why similar: Supernatural 18.2%, Investigation 16.5%, Mystery 9.9%, Dark 8%, Puzzle 7%

You’re in over your head… try not to lose it. In Victim Complex, you're a fraud - a ghost-hunter who pretends to be able to commune with the dead. For the first time, you seem to have encountered the real deal– a nightmarish entity haunting an apartment complex. Can your fake tools help you survive?

Why similar: Supernatural 24.1%, Thriller 20.9%, Mystery 12.9%, Horror 7.9%, Surreal 6.7%

Strange noises echo through empty rooms, shadows seem to shift, and it feels like you’re never truly alone. To feel safer, you’ve installed a smart monitoring system, allowing you to watch every room. But in a place like this, will that be enough?

Why similar: Supernatural 23.7%, Mystery 13.5%, Thriller 13.3%, Surreal 9.5%, Dark 7.6%

Sewage Crisis: Origins is a first person horror game adapted from human experiments, which exposes the truth behind human experiments buried in hospitals through a terrifying supernatural event.

Why similar: Thriller 24.7%, Investigation 21.8%, Supernatural 21.5%, First-Person 7.7%, Horror 7.6%

An audio-deduction horror game where the best way to play is to close your eyes. Listen to the sounds of the ritual room, track a restless spirit across a ritual grid using sound alone, and place the correct relics to complete the exorcism.

Why similar: Investigation 17.7%, Supernatural 16.2%, Logic 10.7%, Thriller 10.7%, Mystery 9.8%

Ramona is a first-person psychological horror set in the 1970s. Use a camera to reveal the invisible, follow Ramona’s rules, and explore rooms filled with puzzles and disturbing memories in a house haunted by secrets and remorse.

Why similar: Thriller 20.2%, Investigation 11%, Supernatural 10.3%, Psychological 7.2%, Logic 7.2%

Scauage is a short horror experience where you play as a scavenger looting an abandoned house, uncovering its dark secrets and collecting hidden treasures while facing what lurks within.

Why similar: Supernatural 16.7%, Thriller 16.7%, Investigation 14.2%, Mystery 8.8%, Dark 7%

Curse of the Crimson Stag is a story-driven mystery thriller in which you explore a blurred line between supernatural occurrences and past tragedy. Uncover what led to the abandoning of the once luxurious Whiteroot Hotel. Local myth tells of a wrathful spirit known as the Crimson Stag…

Why similar: Investigation 26.7%, Thriller 18.3%, Supernatural 15.2%, Puzzle 9.2%, Mystery 8.2%

Through His Eyes is a psychological horror game where a father, trapped in a haunting time loop, must uncover the truth and escape from his house to find his daughter but a dark presence won’t let him go. Unlock doors, solve puzzles and break the cycle.

Why similar: Thriller 17.3%, Investigation 16.3%, Mystery 9.9%, Adventure 8.2%, Dark 7.6%

Witness the obscure scenario of a massacre, in the shoes of the photographer Bárbara, who received an unusual proposal: To photograph a village with bizarre secrets from decades ago.

Why similar: Thriller 19.8%, Investigation 19.3%, Supernatural 18.1%, Mystery 11.5%, Psychological 7.8%

The mansion your grandfather left you is more than an inheritance. When the power comes on, not only the lights awaken, but the darkness buried inside. Shadow Mansion 2 is a first-person psychological horror focused on atmosphere, exploration, and stealth.

Why similar: Thriller 22.4%, Investigation 17.5%, Supernatural 11.8%, Mystery 9.1%, Puzzle 7.7%

Cursed Bet is a horror game where you play from a body camera perspective. Enter the abandoned preschool, the subject of terrible rumors, in the midnight. Struggle the cursed doll Ebeleen as you investigate the school's dark past. Will you be able to destroy him and his curse?

Why similar: Supernatural 23.9%, Thriller 19.8%, Mystery 12.3%, Dark 10.3%, Horror 7.8%

Investigate the sleepy town of Lakewood as you follow the trail of numerous missing person cases and the mysterious cause of the disappearances. Unravel the secret of Lakewood and try to survive its tightening grip.

Why similar: Investigation 19.4%, Thriller 19.1%, Supernatural 13%, Mystery 11.6%, First-Person 6.4%

A first-person horror puzzle game about solving cryptic puzzles and surviving a deadly night inside an abandoned drive-in theater.

Why similar: Investigation 17.9%, Thriller 16.2%, Mystery 10.1%, Puzzle 9.7%, Horror 9.1%

A state machinery plant is haunted by a dismemberment murder. A girl's vanishing and a fatal plunge fuel ghost rumors. Years later, cop Wang Nan uncovers the truth: fates interwoven over a decade reveal human guilt and redemption—not spectral revenge.

Why similar: Thriller 18.7%, Supernatural 17.1%, Crime 15.2%, Puzzle 9.4%, Mystery 9%

Inspired by Allison Road. SUPERNORMAL is a psychological horror game set in a seemingly ordinary apartment harboring dark secrets. Play as Detective Wyatt, tasked with unravelling the disappearance of Masato Sakamoto's daughter. Search for clues and unravel the sinister truth.

Why similar: Supernatural 18.1%, Investigation 14.9%, Thriller 13.2%, Crime 11.1%, Mystery 9.7%

A psychological horror experience about returning to a place that never forgot you.

Why similar: Supernatural 20.2%, Thriller 17.2%, Mystery 12.2%, Surreal 7.5%, Horror 7.2%

This is an indie horror game in which you have to face your fear and escape from house by solving puzzles and escaping from a ghost. Find out the story of a serial killer...

Why similar: Supernatural 19.7%, Thriller 14.1%, Puzzle 11.8%, Dark 11.4%, Mystery 10.6%

Return to Yeondu High School and uncover the dark truth that remained hidden in this direct sequel to the Korean horror classic. Investigate bizarre phenomena, evade bloodthirsty killers, and unravel a twisting narrative spread across three unnerving episodes.

Why similar: Thriller 17.1%, Investigation 15.8%, Supernatural 14.9%, Mystery 9.4%, Dark 7%

The once #1 horror game on the Horror list of Itch is back! Join now and use a variety of repair tools to experience life as a handyman in a haunted house, uncover the terrifying past of this old house and face the terrifying demon baby head-on!

Why similar: Investigation 16.4%, Supernatural 14.3%, Mystery 10.9%, Logic 9.4%, Puzzle 9.1%

Venture into the enigmatic Luminora Hospital, where, as an investigator on the brink of ruin, you take on a case that will test your courage. Amidst dark rumors, you'll uncover terrifying secrets that have caused those who ventured too far to disappear.

Why similar: Thriller 25.5%, Investigation 19.2%, Mystery 11.3%, Puzzle 8.9%, Dark 7.9%

Moved mind is a first person narrative psychological horror game, where you will be the subject of a psychological experiment where you will have to face your fears and differentiate reality from the symptoms of your illness.

Why similar: Supernatural 17.9%, Investigation 15.3%, Thriller 15.2%, Mystery 10.9%, Crime 10.1%

A first-person psychological horror that evolves based on your behavior. Uncover the atrocities within this mansion as you struggle to hold onto your sanity. Something is stirring inside the walls. If you hear eerie laughter, run as fast as you can. You are not safe

Why similar: Thriller 17.6%, Supernatural 16%, Investigation 15.8%, Mystery 10.7%, Dark 8.1%

A teacher wakes to an empty lecture hall where time stands still. Each loop reveals fragments of truth through questions, memories, and whispers of the past. The only way out is to remember what should have never been forgotten.

Why similar: Investigation 18.3%, Supernatural 18%, Thriller 17.7%, Mystery 9.1%, Dark 7.3%

A monster is hiding behind one of the voices on the line. Identify the liar before you reveal your location. One wrong judgment, and it comes to your door. Each playthrough changes who's lying.

Why similar: Supernatural 19.7%, Thriller 18.6%, Investigation 16.5%, Mystery 11.7%, Horror 6.7%

Psychological horror experience where exploration, tension, and environmental storytelling guide you through a decaying world full of secrets best left buried. What was meant to be just another exploration quickly unravels into something far more disturbing.

Why similar: Investigation 21.3%, Thriller 17.5%, Mystery 12.2%, Dark 10.3%, Psychological 8.4%

A first-person supernatural thriller where you explore a manor overtaken by darkness. Wield a mysterious power to confront an ancient evil, unravel the truth, and save your brother.

Why similar: Supernatural 18.9%, Investigation 14.5%, Thriller 12.8%, Mystery 9.4%, Horror 7.4%

An immersive wandering simulator through the endless Backrooms. Explore empty corridors, listen to their whisper, and lose yourself in the depths of dark spaces. A subtly oppressive atmosphere, meditative strangeness, and the feeling of an alien, silent world.

Why similar: Thriller 23.5%, Investigation 19.9%, Mystery 12.4%, Puzzle 8.6%, Exploration 6.6%

The Nefargad is a thriller, puzzle, storytelling and horror game that offers a true first-person perspective. The game narrates the story of an archaeologist named Mert, who is kidnapped and imprisoned in a dungeon and his efforts to escape.

Why similar: Thriller 24.5%, Supernatural 17.1%, Mystery 10.7%, Puzzle 8.5%, Surreal 7%

Miles McDaniel, a police officer, is sent to the Darkvale Motel to investigate the troubling disappearance of a resident. What begins as a routine case quickly descends into a far darker and more terrifying story.

Why similar: Investigation 23.3%, Thriller 17.5%, Crime 16.9%, Mystery 11.6%, Dark 9.6%

Alex wakes up at his grandmother’s, left alone in a silent house. Unsure where his family is, he begins to uncover a dark mystery in an attempt to escape. Facing his fear in an endless nightmare, Alex must survive the dead of night, a cursed forest, and paranormal activities before daylight arrives.

Why similar: Thriller 22%, Supernatural 14.7%, Investigation 12.8%, Mystery 10.8%, Dark 9.4%

You play as a student named Lisa, who has just moved in with her university friend. But instead of a carefree student life, Lisa faces events full of despair and fear when she is left alone in her apartment number 8...

Why similar: Thriller 20.4%, Supernatural 15.2%, Investigation 12.5%, Mystery 10.9%, Dark 9.4%

Uncover the truth in this story-driven game about a teenage boy recalling the tragedies of his family. Explore a house, solve puzzles and gather items. All while fighting the eerie ghosts from your past...

Why similar: Supernatural 20.2%, Thriller 18%, Mystery 10.5%, Dark 10%, Puzzle 8.5%

Beyond the Evil is an psychological horror game that places the player to a hard experience to find who created one supposed plague that might doom the world.

Why similar: Investigation 21.5%, Thriller 18.9%, Mystery 12.6%, Logic 11.4%, Puzzle 9.7%

Alone in a dark castle, you must find a way to escape. You will have to explore the castle grounds, find keys, solve puzzles, and if push comes to shove, you will have to use your gun. Be careful however. Your gun only fires one bullet at a time.

Why similar: Investigation 25.8%, Mystery 14.7%, Supernatural 12.4%, Puzzle 11.8%, Dark 9%

Gnarly Hike is a first-person psychological horror game. Explore an eerie forest in a slow-paced, atmospheric world combining beautiful and horrifying scenery along with the constant fear of being hunted, and enjoy a genuinely terrifying experience. Uncover secrets, expel spirits and ...stay alive!

Why similar: Supernatural 18.9%, Investigation 17.1%, Thriller 16.3%, Mystery 8.9%, Dark 8.3%

Unknowingly revealing a great secret about human history, will Edmond be able to live with this secret? 13:ORIGIN is a story-based adventure and puzzle game full of suspense and excitement, where you can progress by solving puzzles. Here is the first chapter of the journey.

Why similar: Thriller 18.8%, Supernatural 14.1%, Investigation 13.7%, Mystery 10.6%, Dark 7.4%

The Marson Home is a single player, mystery-thriller. Explore the home, find the pieces to the ritual, and rid the place of the tormenting spirit. Keep in mind - your not alone...

Why similar: Investigation 29.1%, Supernatural 14.3%, Horror 10.2%, Mystery 9%, Thriller 7.9%

Spectre Vigil is an Observation-Duty style horror game with a unique twist: Detecting ghosts! Spot many different abnormalities and handle terrifying entities, all whilst keeping track of what happens and figuring out what ails this location!

Why similar: Investigation 23.3%, Supernatural 22.2%, Logic 12%, Puzzle 8.6%, Mystery 8.3%

Your memory is fading. Things around your home keep changing; they are not what they appear to be. Find what is wrong, take pictures to restore your memory. Try to remember. Learn what you have forgotten, learn what has happened. It is not what it seems to be.

Why similar: Supernatural 15.1%, Mystery 12.4%, Investigation 11.5%, Dark 9.2%, Puzzle 8.6%

The Apartment Lies is a first person anomaly horror game where you must spot altered objects in a seemingly normal apartment. Observe carefully, choose the correct door, and survive psychological tension, sudden jumpscares, and brutal horror.

Why similar: Supernatural 20%, Investigation 18%, Dark 9.7%, Logic 8.5%, Puzzle 8.3%

As a journalist, you travel to an abandoned village to investigate a dark event that occurred years ago. As you progress through missing babies, hidden diaries, and forbidden rituals, you will be forced to perform a dangerous ritual yourself to uncover the truth.

Why similar: Supernatural 18.8%, Thriller 17.8%, Mystery 8.7%, Exploration 8.3%, Adventure 8%

The House Dreams Along With Them is a first person puzzle adventure with an emphasis on interactivity and logic. Sleep and dream in the rooms of a mysterious house. Solve the puzzles to make the dreams real and take a step towards the enigmatic reification of night.

Why similar: Investigation 18.6%, Mystery 16.4%, Logic 12.5%, Puzzle 11.8%, Exploration 9%

We Are Not Alone is a new twist on horror that combines first person exploration and third person point and click adventure. As a member of a "safe" isolation experiment you'll explore an underground facility, solve puzzles and uncover the mystery of an unknown creature. Just don't make eye contact.

Why similar: Thriller 17.4%, Investigation 14.8%, Mystery 11.2%, Dark 11%, Logic 10%

Find the violent stalker hiding inside an abandoned school. Piece together broken lore and solve a long lost mystery. What happened here and who's to blame?

Why similar: Thriller 18.4%, Investigation 14.7%, Mystery 10.2%, Puzzle 8.9%, Psychological 7.9%

One Late Night: Deadline continues the story of One Late Night, a horror/mystery game where you play the role of an office worker caught in the middle of the paranormal activity that has broken out in a seemingly ordinary office building. Freely explore the 5 story office complex that houses several different companies.

Why similar: Supernatural 19%, Investigation 14.4%, Thriller 13.1%, Mystery 9.4%, Dark 7.7%

A short, single-sitting VHS-style psychological horror game. Work the night shift at a remote gas station, return home to uncover disturbing clues, and reach one of three endings.

Why similar: Investigation 22.1%, Thriller 18.5%, Mystery 13.9%, Dark 7.8%, First-Person 6.9%

Trapped in an endless Roman corridor, you must observe carefully, solve eerie puzzles, and survive horrors in this roguelite puzzle-adventure.

Why similar: Investigation 23.6%, Supernatural 16.6%, Mystery 11.4%, Puzzle 9.4%, Surreal 8.3%