- #1 MAZE-Psychic App
97% matchNo user reviews
Dev: KPJ
Windows · Mac
Through the psychic app "MAZE", user can face directly the "ghosts" who cause the paranormal activities on campus. Fortunately, you have been selected as a tester for this app "MAZE"...
Why similar: Collectathon 32.8%, Clicker 24.9%, Hidden Object 21.8%, Exploration 14.6%, Adventure 5.1%
- #2 Super Egg Simulator
96% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Surprisia Games
Windows
Chickens lay surprise eggs—open them, collect toy parts, and build toys! Sell eggs and toys in your store, satisfy customers, and expand into the most exciting toy store in town.
Why similar: Collectathon 38.8%, Hidden Object 13.9%, Management 12.3%, Sandbox 8.8%, Simulation 7.4%
- #3 My Name is Mayo: Remayo
96% matchPositive100% of 12 reviews2026
Dev: Green Lava Studios
Windows
In My Name is Mayo: Remayo, the real-life tapping, clicking adventure of a Mayo Jar returns!
Why similar: Clicker 31.3%, Collectathon 29.8%, Life Sim 15%, Physics 12%, Simulation 5.7%
- #4 Lumber in Space
95% matchNo user reviews
Dev: KenshiDev
Windows
A relaxing game about cutting weird types of trees in space. Whack space trees, collect drops, send them to space HUB and upgrade your gear.
Why similar: Clicker 28.4%, Sandbox 20.3%, Hidden Object 17.7%, Exploration 11.2%, Simulation 10.7%
- #5 Kiwi Clicker - Juiced Up
94% matchVery Positive94% of 1,787 reviews2022
Dev: Dimitri Kipper
Windows
Median: 10.6 hrsMean: 43.0 hrs≥1hr: 94%
Deliver more and more kiwis to satiate the kings' hunger - sacrifice their pulp and transcend beyond your fruital form!
Why similar: Clicker 24.9%, Collectathon 24.6%, Economy 16.2%, Management 12.2%, Life Sim 9.9%
- #6 Balloon Hater
93% matchMixed62% of 13 reviews2025
Dev: Nikorych
Windows · Mac
Balloon Hater is an incremental clicker game. Pop balloons, buy weapons, explore new areas, unlock new abilities, find special balloons to gain temporary boosts, and upgrade your gear to increase your rewards.
Why similar: Collectathon 28.3%, Clicker 26.7%, Economy 13.7%, Physics 9.4%, Management 9%
- #7 Sandbox
94% match3 user reviews100% of 4 reviews2023
Dev: Game SunlightPub: STuNT
Windows
The goal of the game is to collect 22 bills. To collect them, you need to press the "play" button and move to the sandbox level.
Why similar: Clicker 30.4%, Hidden Object 22.3%, Sandbox 19.7%, Exploration 15%, Adventure 4.6%
- #8 Monslice
92% matchNo user reviews
Dev: zowlf
Windows
Monslice is a short incremental game about slicing monsters, collecting resources, expanding your skill tree, and unlocking and buying more monsters!
Why similar: Clicker 33.5%, Collectathon 27.1%, Economy 16.2%, Management 11.2%, Casual 5.1%
- #9 Wrath of Anias
91% matchMixed65% of 83 reviews2022
Dev: Blue Ocean Games
Windows
Explore the sandbox, collect treasures, and find your way off of the island.
Why similar: Collectathon 30.7%, Sandbox 22.5%, Exploration 17%, Hidden Object 16.7%, Adventure 9%
- #10 Virtual Families 3
91% matchMixed64% of 127 reviews2023
Dev: Gogii Games Corp.
Windows
The sequel to the smash hit mobile game “Virtual Families 2” is here!
Why similar: Clicker 29.7%, Life Sim 21.9%, Hidden Object 18.5%, Simulation 11.8%, Exploration 11.7%
- #11 Blob
89% matchMixed61% of 89 reviews2025
Dev: Avidar
Windows
Embark on a chemistry-packed adventure! Collect elements, combine them into compounds, and generate Atoms (clicks per second). Use Atoms to level up compounds, unlocking noble gases and new rows as you build the ultimate periodic table collection!
Why similar: Clicker 44.7%, Collectathon 21%, Economy 13.2%, Hidden Object 10.2%, Casual 5.4%
- #12 Snake Robot
90% matchPositive82% of 22 reviews2023
Dev: Gamesforgames
Windows
Times are changing.
Why similar: Collectathon 27.8%, Clicker 26.3%, Hidden Object 17.3%, Exploration 10%, Simulation 7.4%
- #13 Worm in horror place
89% match9 user reviews90% of 9 reviews2026
Dev: Kendall StudiosPub: Valkeala Software
Windows
Walking simulation and survival game as player worm and mission to find stars and avoid traps in this third person gothic themed walking game
Why similar: Collectathon 22.4%, Life Sim 18.4%, Sandbox 17.8%, Hidden Object 17.1%, Simulation 9.8%
- #14 Infinite Food Factory
86% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2026
Dev: Zanick Sage
Windows
The world is in famine and people are starving to death. Your job is to make food out of nothing and help the starving.
Why similar: Clicker 30.2%, Sandbox 20.9%, Economy 16.8%, Simulation 11.1%, Management 10.7%
- #15 New York Rat Simulator
88% matchVery Positive83% of 152 reviews2021
Dev: Firebug Games
Windows
In a world bound by the very laws of traffic, one Rat has been chosen.... Roam the streets of New York, imbued with unnatural jumping abilities, you can now disrupt the very fabric of society and collect pizza slices in the name of the glorious Rat King to summon the dark eldritch being of New York.
Why similar: Collectathon 22.2%, Hidden Object 15.8%, Sandbox 13.1%, Life Sim 12.7%, Mystery 9.5%
- #16 A Game About Being A Parrot
86% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Grunge Studio
Windows
Annoy people, Steal their stuff, break their things,ruin everyone's day & Be a real Parrot
Why similar: Collectathon 29.5%, Sandbox 18.3%, Exploration 10.5%, Arcade 8.9%, Action-Adventure 8.5%
- #17 Unlocked
87% matchPositive93% of 15 reviews2021
Dev: James Smart
Windows
Time is locked. As an interstellar being, you must visit the four seasons of earth and get time running again. Collect items, uncover secrets and right the wrongs in the universe! Includes a second bonus game, 'Blue Sky on Mars'. Journey to the red planet and enjoy a cosmic Sci-Fi adventure!
Why similar: Collectathon 39.9%, Hidden Object 29%, Exploration 16.9%, Simulation 5.6%, Adventure 4%
- #18 All In
85% matchNo user reviews
Dev: ABSRD Studios
Windows
Nine to five isn’t a life — it’s a sentence. Start with a few chips and a burning drive to escape the grind. Take your shot at blackjack, roll the dice at craps, play the roulette wheel, and chase jackpots. The city runs on risk, and every gamble could be your last. Are you ready to go All In?
Why similar: Clicker 18%, Economy 16.1%, Life Sim 12.2%, Sandbox 12.2%, Management 10.8%
- #19 Find Cats 6 像素猫
84% match6 user reviews67% of 6 reviews2026
Dev: Happy Fish
Windows
Pixel World's Hide-and-Seek Cat Challenge! Eight magical realms hide cute fluffy kittens. Solve interactive puzzles, unlock hidden maps, use your wisdom to bring all the furry little rascals home, and enjoy a healing and stress-relieving cat-hunting experience.
Why similar: Hidden Object 27.3%, Collectathon 24.6%, Clicker 20.4%, Exploration 11.7%, Casual 6.8%
- #20 Moose Diver
82% matchPositive86% of 43 reviews2025
Dev: Lingon Studios
Windows
You’re a moose on a diving adventure. Swim into the ocean and vacuum coins from the seabed. Sell the coins and earn money to upgrade and buy new gear. Swim deeper and find treasure chests to collect power boosting artefacts, but don’t forget to keep an eye on your oxygen level.
Why similar: Collectathon 28.4%, Economy 18.8%, Clicker 18%, Exploration 11.4%, Hidden Object 10.2%
- #21 Silent Waters
82% matchNo user reviews
Dev: CogiMachine
Windows · Mac
Horror Escape Game (POV) You run away from the monster and look for items and run away and collect six rings and run away and escaped. What on earth was that monster? Would you please create the storyline with me?
Why similar: Collectathon 39.9%, Hidden Object 26.7%, Exploration 17.1%, Action-Adventure 7.1%, Adventure 5%
- #22 Claw Crane Company
84% match9 user reviews78% of 9 reviews2020
Dev: Rusimitu
Windows
Claw crane store management game. Make machines, arrange the prizes well, and aim for the world's best claw crane store. It's not only manage, you can also play, and must play yourself on the machines!! You can also create original prizes and publish them at the workshop.
Why similar: Collectathon 33.4%, Economy 21.1%, Management 14.3%, Physics 13.2%, Simulation 7.4%
- #23 Alchemistry
83% matchMostly Positive77% of 26 reviews2022
Dev: Dysnomia
Windows · Mac · Linux
Practice Alchemistry, aka the art of merging elements to discover new ones! Solve challenges or play freely to discover every element. Craft the entire world from fire to life.
Why similar: Collectathon 24.2%, Clicker 21.7%, Hidden Object 17.1%, Exploration 14.3%, Sandbox 13.5%
- #24 Wind Peaks 2
81% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Actoon Studio
Windows
Join the boy scouts in their newest adventure of treasure hunting to free Wind Peaks of a poisonous spell.
Why similar: Collectathon 28.3%, Clicker 25.9%, Hidden Object 19.3%, Exploration 10.5%, Comedy 7%
- #25 Infploria
81% matchNo user reviews2025
Dev: S19Games
Windows
Infploria is a game about infinitely mining and collecting ores. Upgrade your pickaxe, delve deeper to rarer Ores and attempt to reach to the Core of the Earth to mine Coresium.
Why similar: Collectathon 27.7%, Hidden Object 22.6%, Sandbox 14.9%, Exploration 11.4%, Action-Adventure 6.8%
- #26 Eggz - Collectible Eggs Clicker
80% matchMixed44% of 78 reviews2024
Dev: Cervinz
Windows · Mac
Click on the Egg: after 100 clicks, the egg will crack open, and you'll unlock a unique skin. Collect all the skins and become the master of eggs! Unlock legendary skins and enrich your collection!
Why similar: Clicker 49.1%, Hidden Object 30.5%, Casual 10.6%, Simulation 7.7%, Singleplayer 2.1%
- #27 Beer Onsen Resort
79% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Green Tea Bee Studio
Windows · Mac
Welcome to Beer Onsen Resort! As both Brew Master and Resort Manager, you’ll concoct extraordinary brews, infuse them into steaming hot springs, and pamper wandering spirits from every corner. Rack up gold, unlock arcane recipes, and turn this retreat into the spirit realm’s hottest getaway!
Why similar: Collectathon 31.4%, Clicker 29.8%, Management 13.9%, Simulation 10.5%, Life Sim 9.5%
- #28 Liquor And Wine Shop Simulator - Store Simulator
79% matchMixed40% of 35 reviews2025
Dev: Mascot Bro Studio
Windows
Liquor and Wine Shop Simulator is a store management game that takes place in the charming streets of France where you run your own Liquor shop! Start small as a cashier, scanning items and giving the correct change to your customers, then work your way up to managing a full-fledged business.
Why similar: Collectathon 22%, Economy 17.8%, Management 13.4%, Life Sim 11%, Sandbox 10.9%
- #29 Your Lil' Cow
78% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Somia Games
Windows
Handle your cow—the world's most "straight" bovine. Your Lil' Cow is a cute, pixel-art desktop companion that lives for your touch. Drag to build momentum, trigger explosive "Milking Frenzies," and spend your hard-earned milk on gacha draws to collect a wide variety of cute accessories.
Why similar: Clicker 29.8%, Collectathon 29%, Life Sim 13.1%, Simulation 10.1%, Casual 6.3%
- #30 Retro GameShop Simulator
78% matchMixed45% of 11 reviews2025
Dev: Sly Game Studios
Windows
Build and manage your dream retro video game store! Buy, sell, and stock games, consoles, and collectibles. Set your own prices, hire staff, and expand your shop to become the ultimate gaming destination.
Why similar: Collectathon 36%, Economy 23.4%, Life Sim 16.1%, Management 15.9%, Simulation 7.7%
- #31 Panic Sell
77% matchMostly Positive72% of 18 reviews2025
Dev: Serhii KhramovPub: General Script Studio
Windows
Would you like to feel like a trader? Try to earn crazy capital in this game or lose everything! Buy cheaper and sell more expensive. That's all you need on your way to wealth. Good luck!
Why similar: Clicker 29.9%, Economy 19.6%, Management 15%, Exploration 13.9%, Life Sim 12.6%
- #32 Doomsday Dealer
77% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Imaxon Games
Windows
Step into the role of a shopkeeper in a world ravaged by the zombie apocalypse. You’ll manage a haven of hope amidst the ruins, providing essential survival items to the struggling remnants of humanity. Can you build a thriving business and help your community rise from the ashes?
Why similar: Collectathon 26.6%, Hidden Object 18.8%, Economy 16.8%, Management 12%, Life Sim 11.4%
- #33 Clothing Supermarket Store Simulator
76% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Midnight Games
Windows
Dive into the glamorous world of fashion retail with Clothing Supermarket Store Simulator! Design stunning stores, stock the hottest trends, and build your fashion empire from a tiny boutique to a global powerhouse. Are you ready to dominate the style scene?
Why similar: Clicker 30.6%, Hidden Object 24.1%, Exploration 13.3%, Management 10.8%, Economy 9.4%
- #34 AI Clicker
76% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Afk Pixel Studio
Windows
Click Your Way to World Domination (Or Doom) Welcome to AI Clicker, the only game where mindless clicking actually makes you smarter! … or a future where it replaces you!
Why similar: Clicker 35.9%, Collectathon 22.6%, Economy 16.9%, Management 14.8%, Casual 5.6%
- #35 Another Game About Digging A Hole
75% match6 user reviews83% of 6 reviews2025
Dev: myownyose
Windows
A game about digging in the mines of an unknown and unclaimed planet. Collect resources, sell them and upgrade your equipment - discover all available resources!
Why similar: Collectathon 18%, Economy 17.4%, Hidden Object 17%, Sandbox 16.9%, Management 11.5%
- #36 Catgirl Simulator
74% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2025
Dev: Superfantastic Productions
Windows
After dreaming of catching a fish in the clouds, a hungry catgirl wakes with a craving only the perfect fish can satisfy. With none in sight, she sets off on an epic, puzzle-filled journey through space and time—meeting quirky friends and chasing a fish worthy of her feline desires.
Why similar: Collectathon 46.7%, Exploration 19.7%, Comedy 12.4%, Adventure 9.4%, Simulation 4.4%
- #37 Junkyard Empire Simulator
75% matchNo user reviews
Dev: BronStudio
Windows
Manage a junkyard and turn scrap into wealth! Buy cars, dismantle them, sell the parts, and build your scrap empire.
Why similar: Economy 20.1%, Sandbox 18%, Life Sim 16.9%, Management 16.2%, Physics 9.4%
- #38 RAIN KILLS
74% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2025
Dev: Screenshakes
Windows · Mac · Linux
Smash crystals, dodge rain, make money, upgrade your equipment, keep going.
Why similar: Collectathon 22%, Economy 20.1%, Clicker 19.3%, Sandbox 11.7%, Exploration 10.4%
- #39 Cookie Clicker
73% matchOverwhelmingly Positive96% of 89,166 reviews2021
Dev: OrteilPub: Playsaurus
Windows · Mac
Median: 89.4 hrsMean: 370.6 hrs≥1hr: 97%
An idle game about making cookies! Originally released in 2013 on the web, and actively developed since then. This is the official version for Steam.
Why similar: Clicker 39.2%, Collectathon 20.6%, Economy 15.1%, Management 11.7%, Comedy 5.7%
- #40 Sad Virus Western
73% matchMixed50% of 20 reviews2025
Dev: DIG Games
Windows
Walking simulation in open world where player controls virus whose mission is to find beer bottles so he can be happy again
Why similar: Collectathon 36.7%, Hidden Object 30.1%, Life Sim 17.9%, Simulation 7.2%, Adventure 5.3%
- #41 Flea Market Simulator '24
73% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2024
Dev: vadsl05
Windows
Flea Market Simulator '24 Work, Bargain&Buy, Repair&Sell Take care of antique or fake items. Adding this game to your wishlist allows me to improve my game further. If you care about my project, add it to your wishlist to improve the game together with me.
Why similar: Economy 18.8%, Hidden Object 17.6%, Management 13.2%, Life Sim 13%, Physics 10.6%
- #42 Sad Virus Castle
72% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Kendall StudiosPub: Valkeala Software
Windows
Sad Virus is back in new walking simulation version. Now mission to find beer bottles in castle themed area
Why similar: Collectathon 22%, Life Sim 20.1%, Sandbox 19.4%, Hidden Object 17%, Simulation 11%
- #43 Froggy Brews
72% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Komodo Range Studio
Windows
Froggy Brews is a gentle narrative adventure game, where you play as a tea-loving frog returning to your old neighborhood — it has changed over time, and so have you. You brew delicious tea, try to connect with unfamiliar faces, and help others heal as you rediscover your place in this world.
Why similar: Collectathon 23.3%, Hidden Object 15.4%, Emotional 13.1%, Life Sim 11.9%, Exploration 11.1%
- #44 Sad Virus Winter
71% matchMixed47% of 19 reviews2025
Dev: DIG Games
Windows
Second part of sad virus game series. Now mission to find beer bottles in winter themed maps and by collecting beer bottles level finished
Why similar: Collectathon 36%, Hidden Object 24.2%, Sandbox 18.5%, Arcade 7.1%, Simulation 5.8%
- #45 Tabletop Shop Simulator
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: ByteForce
Windows
Tabletop Shop Simulator is a simulation game where you manage your store by offering tabletop gaming experiences to customers and selling collectible figures. Complete collections through your sales to earn rewards and grow your shop!
Why similar: Collectathon 37.2%, Management 14.8%, Life Sim 14.7%, Economy 14.3%, Simulation 11.5%
- #46 Your Own Constella
70% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2026
Dev: Kirin Sakaname
Windows
「Your Own Constella」 is a relaxing game where you create your very own constellations in a real night sky. Using a star map based on real-world time and location, you can freely edit and place your favorite images—or choose from roughly 270 illustrations—as constellations.
Why similar: Clicker 29.4%, Collectathon 27.6%, Sandbox 22.8%, Simulation 12%, Casual 7.5%
- #47 30 DAYS. ALONE. ADRIFT.
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Saito Soki
Windows
You are the only engineer on board an autonomous cargo ship drifting in the South China Sea 🌊 after a system failure. Explore containers, craft tools, repair mechanisms, furnish your cabin, and survive among dangers, strange finds, and self-irony.
Why similar: Hidden Object 20.9%, Sandbox 20.4%, Life Sim 19%, Exploration 11.6%, Simulation 8.2%
- #48 Oh No! UFO!
70% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Blunderjack
Windows · Mac · Linux
Join Cosmo and P.E.A. as they write the first intergalactic planetary guidebook about the Earth. Explore the planet, meet interesting life forms, lend a tentacle when you find trouble, and get up to a lot of shenanigans along the way.
Why similar: Collectathon 27%, Sandbox 17.8%, Exploration 13.1%, Physics 13.1%, Comedy 10.3%
- #49 Rubber Duck
69% match4 user reviews50% of 4 reviews2026
Dev: dot dot dot
Windows
Ever had to spend your working hours staring at screen clicking and pretending in order to gain for living? Now you've a Rubber Duck that can make your (and my) miserable working day much more fun!
Why similar: Clicker 43.7%, Collectathon 22%, Economy 16.3%, Casual 5%, Simulation 3.9%
- #50 Roadside Reseal
70% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Alkame Games
Windows
A roadside store where the night never feels safe. Flickering lights, endless aisles, whispers from the dark. Each task feels like research into fear—you restock, you lock, you fight to keep the seal closed.The silence breaks, the air is heavy, and every moment is research into survival.
Why similar: Economy 22.6%, Sandbox 20.3%, Management 15.8%, Life Sim 14.4%, Physics 12%
- #51 Sad Virus Shitcoin
69% matchMixed67% of 12 reviews2025
Dev: ZERO5GAMES
Windows
Sad virus is back again. Now in futuristic space land virus must find crypto called shitcoins
Why similar: Collectathon 22.2%, Life Sim 20.1%, Sandbox 19.4%, Hidden Object 17.1%, Simulation 10.9%
- #52 Trap Golf
67% matchMostly Positive75% of 12 reviews2025
Dev: ZERO5GAMES
Windows
Minigolf game with 2 levels. Avoid different obstacles and traps
Why similar: Collectathon 27%, Clicker 22%, Sandbox 20.7%, Exploration 8.8%, Adventure 8.6%
- #53 Escape Game Sleepless
68% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2025
Dev: nicolet.jp
Windows
A popular escape game with lots of cute animals. Even if you are not good at solving puzzles, this is an escape game that you can enjoy casually.
Why similar: Collectathon 42.7%, Hidden Object 28.5%, Exploration 18.4%, Adventure 6.8%, Casual 2.4%
- #54 Hold Me Still
66% matchVery Positive84% of 56 reviews2025
Dev: Zeroshade123
Windows
"Hold Me Still" is a point-and-click puzzle mystery game where you investigate your friend's disappearance by exploring their house, collecting clues, solving puzzles, and uncovering the truth.
Why similar: Clicker 33.7%, Hidden Object 21.2%, Exploration 12%, Emotional 9.6%, Adventure 8.8%
- #55 Fish Lab
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: stonecodes
Windows · Linux
A short incremental game where you collect fish for your lab. Upgrade by making discoveries and writing grants. Synced to music.
Why similar: Collectathon 32.6%, Clicker 31.3%, Arcade 9.3%, Economy 8.4%, Casual 6.6%
- #56 CAN ANDROIDS SURVIVE
69% match8 user reviews100% of 8 reviews2022
Dev: aPriori Digital
Windows
You are a battlefield courier, sent to an active warzone on the Moon to deliver supplies to Starbound Alliance bases--even if it costs your life in the process. Battle a draining fuel gauge, hordes of mechanized hazards, and a treacherous lunar surface to unravel the nature of your existence!
Why similar: Collectathon 40.1%, Sandbox 25.6%, Exploration 13.9%, Adventure 11.3%, Action 7.9%
- #57 Ananas - Pineapple Idle Game
67% matchMixed48% of 57 reviews2024
Dev: Miro Yang
Windows
Ananas is free Play-to-earn relaxing clicker game where you're gonna get pineapples to trade! Dropped/bought items has their use and have a fair chance to get bought for random value by dev on upcoming live streams, that's where Ananas differs!
Why similar: Collectathon 24.1%, Clicker 23.2%, Economy 17.4%, Hidden Object 14.6%, Management 12.2%
- #58 SEARCH ALL - CHRISTMAS
68% matchVery Positive90% of 59 reviews2022
Dev: Laush Dmitriy SergeevichPub: Laush Studio
Windows
Is a game in the genre of "hidden object", in which you need to find all the Christmas candy in the form of a cane (caramel cane) on a large location drawn in the style of "doodling".
Why similar: Collectathon 35.5%, Clicker 35.2%, Hidden Object 24.3%, Casual 4.4%, Singleplayer 0.8%
- #59 Dumpster Diving Simulator
66% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Emre ŞahinPub: Survivillage
Windows
Search dumpsters for hidden treasures in this realistic first-person simulation. Load heavy furniture onto your truck, separate materials, and sell to scrap dealers. Start with nothing and build your urban scavenging empire.
Why similar: Hidden Object 20%, Life Sim 19.1%, Economy 16.8%, Exploration 11.3%, Simulation 10.1%
- #60 Gamer Stop Simulator
64% matchMostly Positive70% of 261 reviews2026
Dev: Red Axe Games
Windows
Gamer Stop Simulator is a simulation game where you manage a video game store. Buy games and consoles from customers, repair broken devices, test games, and add rare items to your collection. Negotiate prices, expand your store, and grow your business in this exciting retail experience!
Why similar: Collectathon 31%, Sandbox 19.2%, Life Sim 18.1%, Economy 15.1%, Simulation 7.4%