Nodal

Games Like Don't Be Afraid - The First Toy

60+ similar titles based on shared tags and player behavior. Themes include Horror, Adventure, Indie, Psychological Horror.

Don't Be Afraid - The First Toy header art

Don't Be Afraid - The First Toy, is an introduction to the dramatic story of a boy kidnapped by a psychopath. Exploring the giant house of your torturer you will soon discover things worse than your childish nightmares. Take on the role of Jamie and see what phrase “The First Toy” actually means.

Reviews: Very Positive — 90% — of 867 reviews
Released: 2020-07-02
Developer: Broken Arrow Games
Publisher: Eneida Games
Genres: Adventure, Free To Play
Platforms: Windows

Similar Games

View all 59 recommendations
  1. #1 Don't Be Afraid
    97% matchVery Positive83% of 944 reviews2020
    Dev: Limo GamesPub: Eneida Games
    Windows
    Median: 3.2 hrsMean: 4.3 hrs≥1hr: 86%

    Don't Be Afraid is an adventure horror game, that allows you to personate a boy, kidnapped by a psychopath. You have to survive, escape and find out how you were kidnapped. Exploring the gigantic, mysterious house of your torturer, you will soon reveal many secrets, hidden inside it’s walls…

    Why similar: Horror 36.5%, Violent 20%, Gore 18.6%, Adventure 13%, Realistic 5.4%

  2. #2 Devil's Toy
    96% matchMostly Positive72% of 54 reviews2018
    Dev: Blueplant Entertainment
    Windows · Mac · Linux

    Devil's Toy is a first person horror game, is set in the middle of a cornfield, with you as the protagonist of a terrifying experience where you face the role of a child who is alone at home with a doll of unknown origin and does not give a good vibes.

    Why similar: Adventure 52.7%, Horror 47.3%

  3. #3 Don't Be Afraid 2
    96% matchMostly Positive72% of 249 reviews2024
    Dev: Eneida Games
    Windows

    Descend deep into the nightmare that seamlessly blends with reality in this uncanny horror escape room game. Can you find your way out of the horrid mansion or will you succumb to your fears? Can you face and overcome your past, or will it break you?

    Why similar: Horror 47.3%, Gore 24.8%, Adventure 19.2%, Singleplayer 4.4%, First-Person 4.3%

  4. #4 Lights Off!
    95% matchVery Positive85% of 1,843 reviews2022
    Dev: TheDollarGameStore
    Windows

    Play through a common childhood fear about turning the lights off and going to bed.

    Why similar: Horror 74.8%, Adventure 22.2%, Singleplayer 3%

  5. #5 Child Phobia: Nightcoming Fears
    94% matchMostly Positive73% of 56 reviews2016
    Dev: 2B_GAMES
    Windows
    Median: 3.6 hrsMean: 3.9 hrs≥1hr: 99%

    "Child Phobia: Nightcoming Fears" is a 2D psychological thriller, horror. We will tell you a story about a little boy, that has problem in family – and this problem converts in fear during the night. You will be able to explore various locations during the nightmares, and watch the family drama during the day.

    Why similar: Violent 39.6%, Gore 35.5%, Adventure 24.9%

  6. #6 MUZY
    93% matchMostly Positive77% of 215 reviews2024
    Dev: Andrew RybisPub: Galactic Crows
    Windows

    Explore the mystery behind a once-loved and hugely popular children's toy, also known as MUZY, in this terrifying horror adventure game. Several reports detail frightening incidents connected to accidents. Your job is to solve the puzzles and find the cause of these unsettling occurrences.

    Why similar: Horror 53.9%, Adventure 39.1%, Singleplayer 3.9%, First-Person 3.2%

  7. #7 Fear in Hospital
    94% matchMixed48% of 504 reviews2019
    Dev: IO Games
    Windows

    Fear in Hospital is a short survivor horror in hospital where you should find a occult path to escape alive!

    Why similar: Horror 38.6%, Gore 18.7%, Violent 17.4%, Adventure 15.9%, Realistic 4.5%

  8. #8 Cursed Feed
    92% matchMostly Positive80% of 83 reviews2025
    Dev: Playstige Interactive
    Windows

    In first-person horror game "Cursed Feed," players embark on a chilling journey with the Thornvale family as they confront a malevolent force unleashed by their own patriarch's archaeological discoveries.

    Why similar: Horror 44.3%, Adventure 24.4%, Violent 15.1%, Gore 12.9%, Singleplayer 3.3%

  9. #9 Infliction
    91% matchVery Positive81% of 936 reviews2018
    Dev: Caustic Reality
    Windows
    Median: 3.8 hrsMean: 9.0 hrs≥1hr: 88%

    Wander through an interactive nightmare set within the confines of a once-happy household. Piece together the mystery behind a harrowing series of events while struggling to survive encounters with an entity that relentlessly stands in the way of finding absolution.

    Why similar: Horror 39.5%, Gore 19.6%, Violent 18.9%, Adventure 13.4%, Realistic 3.9%

  10. #10 The Last Job
    91% matchMixed66% of 386 reviews2022
    Dev: DefinitelyNotScaryGames
    Windows

    What seemed like an easy job, descends into something horrifying. Explore mysterious house, that holds dark secrets, in this first person horror experience.

    Why similar: Horror 57.3%, Gore 25.7%, Adventure 10.3%, Singleplayer 3.6%, First-Person 3%

  11. #11 RAVENOUS
    88% matchVery Positive95% of 148 reviews2025
    Dev: RAVENOUS TEAMPub: ESMA - Ecoles Creatives
    Windows

    Ravenous is a psychological horror game in which you play as Louis, a child trapped in a monster's basement. Explore the mysterious abode, solve puzzles to save your little sister and survive the psychological nightmare prepared for you.

    Why similar: Horror 63.9%, Adventure 24.5%, First-Person 5.5%, Realistic 3.7%, Singleplayer 2.4%

  12. #12 AfterHours
    89% matchMostly Positive71% of 607 reviews2022
    Dev: Runway Studios
    Windows

    Experience psychological horror in a large abandoned hospital. Hide, explore and survive from a mysterious creature living in the ruins of this hospital.

    Why similar: Horror 64.6%, Adventure 16%, Gore 10.9%, Singleplayer 3.1%, Realistic 2.9%

  13. #13 Don't Drop The Cake: Prologue
    87% matchVery Positive87% of 143 reviews2024
    Dev: Midoriyama
    Windows

    Let’s deliver the cake. To reach your goal, you must cross a space crawling with monstrous creatures. If fear makes you tremble or you panic and drop the cake, it’s all over. This challenge isn’t for cowards. Only the brave and composed will make it through. Are you up for it?

    Why similar: Horror 56.3%, Adventure 21%, Violent 16.7%, First-Person 3.5%, Singleplayer 2.5%

  14. #14 I Must Kill: Fresh Meat
    90% matchMostly Negative29% of 264 reviews2015
    Dev: Gaming Cats Studio
    Windows
    Median: 2.9 hrsMean: 47.0 hrs≥1hr: 57%

    I must kill...: Fresh Meat is a light horror story adventure game based on a sad story of a butcher. One day, one night and one accident will bring his misty past and memories to light.

    Why similar: Horror 73.1%, Adventure 26.9%

  15. #15 Nightmare House: The Original Mod
    86% matchOverwhelmingly Positive96% of 2,319 reviews2024
    Dev: We Create Stuff
    Windows

    Wake up, it’s time for the real nightmare to begin. Make your way through a terrorizing house, uncover the secrets of a haunted hospital, fight through hordes of the undead, and try to escape Nightmare House.

    Why similar: Horror 64.9%, Violent 27.3%, First-Person 4.4%, Singleplayer 3.3%

  16. #16 REALITY
    86% matchMixed68% of 106 reviews2016
    Dev: Grey Reality Studios
    Windows

    REALITY is a FREE short First-Person horror game, it uses a graphical style to represent the present mood of the game. It gives the player the ability to choose and get slightly different results. The game has many mysteries you might want to uncover.

    Why similar: Horror 72.1%, Adventure 27.9%

  17. #17 Minds Eyes
    84% matchMixed70% of 1,826 reviews2016
    Dev: Stanislaw TruchowskiPub: TurnVex
    Windows
    Median: 36 minMean: 2.6 hrs≥1hr: 22%

    You venture through your mind, trying desperately to wake up from your nightmares. Will you make it out?

    Why similar: Horror 83.2%, Adventure 11%, Co-op 3%, Singleplayer 1.9%, First-Person 1%

  18. #18 Evil Inside - Prologue
    84% matchMixed68% of 1,036 reviews2021
    Dev: JanduSoft
    Windows
    Median: 24 minMean: 1.2 hrs≥1hr: 11%

    Evil Inside is a first-person psychological horror game. After the death of his mother and the arrest of his father for it, Mark decides to contact her using the Spiritual board. But it fades away, and here is when all begins... Mark will face his greatest fears to discover the truth.

    Why similar: Horror 64.9%, Adventure 19.1%, Co-op 6.8%, Realistic 4.7%, First-Person 2.8%

  19. #19 Blackbay Asylum
    85% matchMixed57% of 552 reviews2014
    Dev: TAD Productions ABPub: KPL
    Windows
    Median: 2.7 hrsMean: 3.9 hrs≥1hr: 94%

    In Blackbay Asylum, you take on the role of a confused psychopath who finds himself able to leave his cell one day. Explore the hospital grounds, solve mind shattering puzzles, survive relentless horrors and follow the story of Doug Dunheiw as he tries to find some clarity in what goes on at Blackbay Asylum.

    Why similar: Gore 27.7%, Horror 27%, Adventure 26.5%, Violent 18.8%

  20. #20 The House of Toys
    82% matchVery Positive91% of 56 reviews2025
    Dev: Old School Bros
    Windows

    The House of Toys is a horror game in which the player ventures into an old mansion filled with seemingly harmless toys. His mission is to explore each room, searching for clues to discover which of the toys is cursed. To free the soul trapped in this toy, the player must solve intricate puzzles.

    Why similar: Horror 67.5%, Adventure 21.1%, Singleplayer 6.2%, First-Person 5.2%

  21. #21 Trap welcome to Beryl Part 1
    83% matchVery Positive85% of 221 reviews2018
    Dev: JucarPub: Il Pleut
    Windows
    Median: 1.0 hrsMean: 10.4 hrs≥1hr: 53%

    After receiving a disturbing letter from his brother, our protagonist decides to go looking for him at the hotel Beryl. He will soon discover the strangeness of the places, the objects, the paintings, the shadows and the terrifying models moving, speaking, living of their own will.

    Why similar: Horror 30.8%, Violent 26.8%, Gore 23%, Adventure 17.3%, Singleplayer 2.1%

  22. #22 Jack Holmes : Master of Puppets PROLOGUE
    81% matchMostly Positive78% of 100 reviews2023
    Dev: @TonyDevGame
    Windows

    In this prologue you will step into the shoes of little Eddie, a 12 year old boy who goes to the amusement park with his parents until what would be a fun day out turns into a nightmare. Experience the terrifying atmosphere of what awaits you in Jack Holmes: Master of Puppets!

    Why similar: Adventure 53.1%, Horror 38%, First-Person 5.7%, Singleplayer 3.2%

  23. #23 FLIGHTMARE
    82% matchMostly Negative28% of 58 reviews2023
    Dev: Van Studios
    Windows

    Indie horror game that will take your adrenaline to another level.

    Why similar: Horror 30.2%, Violent 26.1%, Gore 22.4%, Adventure 16.5%, First-Person 2.8%

  24. #24 The House [zebaxx]
    81% matchMixed64% of 70 reviews2023
    Dev: zebaxx
    Windows

    You are an 18-year-old Spanish boy called Antonio who one day went shopping, and when he returned home he noticed things that were somewhat strange...

    Why similar: Adventure 55.8%, Horror 41.1%, Singleplayer 3.1%

  25. #25 Traumada
    80% matchVery Positive93% of 55 reviews2022
    Dev: James Horn
    Windows

    Welcome to the horrific altered memories of my childhood home.

    Why similar: Horror 61.9%, Adventure 28.9%, First-Person 5.3%, Singleplayer 3.8%

  26. #26 Stanley Says
    78% matchMostly Positive80% of 70 reviews2025
    Dev: Luke Patti
    Windows

    A first-person puzzle horror game set in a defunct children's nursery from 2001. Uncover dark secrets, solve mascot-themed puzzles, and survive the twisted games of Stanley—an animatronic who never stopped playing.

    Why similar: Horror 37.8%, Adventure 29.1%, Violent 20.7%, Realistic 6.4%, First-Person 3.6%

  27. #27 Fears to Fathom - Home Alone
    77% matchVery Positive90% of 10,232 reviews2021
    Dev: Rayll
    Windows
    Median: 30 minMean: 3.0 hrs≥1hr: 14%

    Fears to Fathom is an episodic psychological horror game where each episode unveils a short story narrated by the ones who survived.

    Why similar: Horror 76.3%, Adventure 12.8%, Singleplayer 4.1%, First-Person 3.6%, Realistic 3.3%

  28. #28 Just Ignore Them
    79% matchMostly Positive74% of 1,464 reviews2017
    Dev: Stranga GamesPub: GrabTheGames
    Windows
    Median: 2.4 hrsMean: 7.1 hrs≥1hr: 68%

    One night can feel like a lifetime of pain, suffering and horror to a child...do you have what it takes to survive the night? Play as an 8 year old child who is tormented by monsters in his house. Your choices make his future which lives can be saved or ended.

    Why similar: Horror 41.5%, Gore 21.3%, Adventure 18.2%, Violent 16.9%, Singleplayer 2.2%

  29. #29 Palmyra Orphanage
    78% matchVery Positive89% of 705 reviews2019
    Dev: Steppe Hare Studio
    Windows
    Median: 2.5 hrsMean: 4.3 hrs≥1hr: 84%

    Paranormal first-person horror, which takes place in an abandoned orphanage. Walk through the corridors of your childhood, but do remember that you're not only one here.

    Why similar: Horror 46%, Violent 27.8%, Gore 14%, Adventure 7.6%, Singleplayer 2.3%

  30. #30 Silent Residence
    76% matchVery Positive93% of 94 reviews2025
    Dev: Woyboy
    Windows

    Experience Harry's story of battling multiple personalities and his severe case of schizophrenia. In this First-person horror game, you battle the hallucinations and illusions your mind creates. You misjudge reality and quickly lose control over yourself.

    Why similar: Horror 61.9%, Adventure 30.6%, First-Person 5%, Singleplayer 2.5%

  31. #31 Poppy Playtime
    74% matchVery Positive88% of 132,662 reviews2021
    Dev: Mob Entertainment
    Windows
    Median: 1.0 hrsMean: 8.8 hrs≥1hr: 51%

    You must stay alive in this horror/puzzle adventure. Try to survive the vengeful toys waiting for you in the abandoned toy factory. Use your GrabPack to hack electrical circuits or nab anything from afar. Explore the mysterious facility... and don't get caught.

    Why similar: Horror 82.8%, Adventure 8.1%, Singleplayer 5.4%, First-Person 3.7%

  32. #32 Lights Off: Director's Cut
    76% matchVery Positive91% of 162 reviews2024
    Dev: Insanctum Games
    Windows

    Play through a common childhood fear about turning the lights off and going to bed. This time extended, remastered, and re-imagined.

    Why similar: Horror 67.4%, Adventure 27.3%, Singleplayer 2.9%, First-Person 2.4%

  33. #33 Dementium II HD
    79% matchMixed50% of 1,263 reviews2013
    Dev: Memetic GamesPub: Missing Link Games
    Windows
    Median: 3.7 hrsMean: 5.2 hrs≥1hr: 93%

    The visage of doctors and patients alike fade in and out of these nightmarish visions of tortured memories. This eggshell reality is fractured by experiments conducted in the ward. Blood, flesh and screams surround as you put together the pieces of your story and make your escape from the Bright Dawn Treatment Center while the dark...

    Why similar: Horror 75.5%, Adventure 22.8%, First-Person 1.8%

  34. #34 Psychopath Massacre
    77% matchMixed69% of 78 reviews2024
    Dev: Tarba Paul CornelPub: Galactic Crows
    Windows

    George Dinescu kidnapped you in his home in Romania. Get out alive while utilizing a V.H.S camera to film everything that happens inside. Torture, murder, and dismemberment take place inside the house, exposing the frightening legacy of a serial killer's decade of terror.

    Why similar: Horror 62.8%, Adventure 20.7%, Realistic 10.5%, First-Person 6%

  35. #35 Forbidden Terror: Board Game
    73% matchVery Positive93% of 152 reviews2025
    Dev: Elite Lords Studios
    Windows

    A psychological horror game where you take the role of Jonah, an 18 year old trying out a new board game, The Ouija Board, with his friend Emily. Little did they know, it was far from a simple board game.

    Why similar: Horror 68.8%, Adventure 18.5%, Realistic 8.5%, First-Person 4.2%

  36. #36 Christmas Mutilator
    75% matchMixed64% of 86 reviews2024
    Dev: Tarba Paul CornelPub: Galactic Crows
    Windows

    Inspired by 80s slasher films, Christmas Mutilator™ is an immersive horror and home invasion game. Your husband and children are trapped in the storm, you are stuck in a cabin for the holidays. Use every tactic you can to stay alive and get out of your house as a vicious psychopath breaks in.

    Why similar: Violent 31.3%, Gore 26.9%, Adventure 19.1%, Horror 16.8%, Realistic 2.8%

  37. #37 Dirty Room
    75% matchMixed63% of 51 reviews2023
    Dev: Tactic Forge
    Windows

    First person shooter horror adventure game. As detective C, you arrived at an old friend's home and try to find out what's going on.

    Why similar: Horror 48.4%, Adventure 19.5%, Violent 14.8%, Gore 12.7%, First-Person 2.6%

  38. #38 Happy Game
    72% matchVery Positive90% of 3,400 reviews2021
    Dev: Amanita Design
    Windows · Mac
    Median: 2.6 hrsMean: 3.4 hrs≥1hr: 84%

    A little boy falls asleep to a horrible nightmare. Can you make him happy again?

    Why similar: Horror 57.6%, Violent 13.9%, Gore 12.9%, Adventure 12.6%, Singleplayer 3.1%

  39. #39 Sparky Marky: Episode 1
    74% matchMixed64% of 246 reviews2023
    Dev: Clapperheads
    Windows
    Median: 48 minMean: 3.4 hrs≥1hr: 39%

    Explore an abandoned children's recreational camp and uncover the dark secrets covered up by its founders. Find clues and apply specific commands in the Discord channel to find out what truly happened. But be careful: Sparky has been activated and the monster inside of it never sleeps…

    Why similar: Horror 68.5%, Adventure 19.8%, Singleplayer 6%, First-Person 5.7%

  40. #40 Analog - Skin off
    71% matchVery Positive95% of 295 reviews2025
    Dev: Adouson
    Windows

    Skin Off is an analog horror game where you play as a teenager spending a summer night alone at your uncle’s house. As you wait for your friends to arrive the next day, a strange message is broadcasted on national television, signaling the start of a nightmare you can’t escape.

    Why similar: Horror 68.1%, Adventure 22.5%, First-Person 5.8%, Singleplayer 3.6%

  41. #41 Baby Blues Nightmares - Toddler Horror Game Prologue
    73% matchVery Positive83% of 52 reviews2024
    Dev: Steelkrill Studio
    Windows

    Baby Blues Nightmare - Prologue is a small taste of the horrors that awaits in this survival horror game where you play as a toddler going into a little adventure with your tricycle which you can fix, maintain and customize. Paddle, hide and survive but remember; try not to cry when you are scared..

    Why similar: Horror 69.8%, Adventure 30.2%

  42. #42 9 Childs Street
    71% matchVery Positive91% of 759 reviews2023
    Dev: N4bA
    Windows
    Median: 1.1 hrsMean: 1.2 hrs≥1hr: 59%

    This is a first-person indie horror game. In 9 Childs Street you will find the terrifying atmosphere of a recently abandoned house, and its captive inhabitants, through the eyes of a curious little boy in a red cap.

    Why similar: Horror 61.8%, Adventure 19.8%, Violent 5.2%, First-Person 4.8%, Realistic 4.7%

  43. #43 Mr. Hopp's Playhouse
    71% matchVery Positive93% of 1,810 reviews2019
    Dev: Moonbit
    Windows

    Every kid has that one toy that scares them, imagine if it came to life. You play as Ruby, a young girl who has a fear of her handmade toy called Mr. Hopp. Things take a dark turn when Ruby sees that Mr. Hopp, who usually sits motionless in the corner of her room, is gone.

    Why similar: Horror 94.5%, Singleplayer 5.5%

  44. #44 廃病院探索
    72% matchVery Positive81% of 86 reviews2023
    Dev: カニお@VtuberPub: vkanio_game
    Windows

    This is a horror game that asks a friend to find out what happened in an abandoned hospital.

    Why similar: Horror 53.6%, Gore 29.6%, Violent 15.1%, Singleplayer 1.7%

  45. #45 Terroro
    69% matchVery Positive82% of 1,655 reviews2024
    Dev: Melt
    Windows

    In this psychological horror game about a famous TikToker, you take on the role of her boyfriend to discover that behind their perfect life, nothing is as it seems. Duration 30 minutes.

    Why similar: Horror 74.3%, Adventure 16.9%, First-Person 4.8%, Singleplayer 4%

  46. #46 Locked Fears
    73% matchMixed67% of 66 reviews2016
    Dev: dekoga.d
    Windows
    Median: 2.5 hrsMean: 2.9 hrs≥1hr: 71%

    Locked Fears is a first person puzzle/horror game with platforming elements and creepy atmosphere. You play as Samuel Custer, a late worker at UNIVERS HORIZONS, when things at the office start to drift into a dreadful situation. With the help of an unknown Individual you try to survive and escape this nightmare.

    Why similar: Horror 44.7%, Gore 31.2%, Adventure 24%

  47. #47 Lurk in the Dark : Prologue
    69% matchVery Positive89% of 2,162 reviews2019
    Dev: IDEA FRUITION
    Windows

    A town flourished with woodworking and mining, "Babel's Hill Top". A Ruggles family who contributed greatly to the development of this town several centuries ago. The tragedy that happened at the residence of them. In this residence where blood and hatred are ingrained, their nightmare begins.

    Why similar: Horror 84.9%, Co-op 7.1%, Adventure 3%, Singleplayer 2.9%, First-Person 2.1%

  48. #48 The Nightmare Chronicles - Horror In Da Hood
    68% matchVery Positive83% of 72 reviews2024
    Dev: Bluethunder
    Windows

    Mason is assigned a new job from the big boss when strange things start happening and he discovers the true meaning of fear... Horror in Da Hood is a gripping first-person horror game set in the hood, where the supernatural lurks around every corner. Are you brave enough to face the real terror?

    Why similar: Horror 77.1%, Realistic 12.1%, Adventure 6.9%, Singleplayer 3.9%

  49. #49 Nyctophobia: Devil Unleashed
    70% matchMostly Positive71% of 63 reviews2021
    Dev: Solitary GamesPub: Lamina Studios
    Windows

    A single-player psychological horror game that will take you to the deepest and darkest secrets of the asylum.

    Why similar: Horror 58.7%, Gore 18.4%, Adventure 11%, Singleplayer 6.3%, Realistic 5.6%

  50. #50 Blameless
    68% matchVery Positive84% of 5,079 reviews2016
    Dev: Vaclav HudecPub: Blameless Games
    Windows · Mac
    Median: 48 minMean: 3.2 hrs≥1hr: 36%

    Blameless is a mysterious first-person adventure with primary focus on puzzle solving and short story. The player will appear in a role of an architect trying to investigate strange happenings, after discovering evidence of an act of violence.

    Why similar: Horror 75.4%, Adventure 18.5%, Singleplayer 3.4%, First-Person 2.8%

  51. #51 First Session
    69% matchVery Positive81% of 89 reviews2021
    Dev: Lappi Soft
    Windows

    First Person Psychological Horror. Addicted to virtual ecstasy, trapped in digital hell. Navigate glitchy dreamscapes and a city that never sleeps. Every mission brings you closer to your next dose, but will you follow your protective AI, or the man behind a liberating new drug?

    Why similar: Horror 55.3%, Gore 27.8%, Adventure 9.9%, Singleplayer 3.5%, First-Person 3.4%

  52. #52 Dollmare
    65% matchVery Positive94% of 2,009 reviews2024
    Dev: Alex GradePub: Almost Done Games
    Windows
    Median: 3.0 hrsMean: 3.4 hrs≥1hr: 87%

    You've accepted a shady job offer at a doll factory. Inspect dolls for defects and anomalies. Follow strange protocols. Don't get fired and stay alive.

    Why similar: Horror 72.5%, Adventure 13%, Realistic 6.9%, First-Person 6.2%, Singleplayer 1.5%

  53. #53 Amygdala
    67% matchMostly Positive74% of 181 reviews2024
    Dev: Stigma Studios
    Windows

    Welcome to Amygdala, seeker of nightmares. In the presence of the Absolute Judge, you are assigned a task that only you can accomplish. Immerse yourself in this place made of emotions. Discover unique creatures called 'lords of nightmares' and uncover the beauties of horror in this unique adventure.

    Why similar: Horror 41.7%, Adventure 19.9%, Violent 14.2%, Gore 11.6%, Singleplayer 4.9%

  54. #54 HORSE
    70% matchMixed54% of 189 reviews2019
    Dev: cornthea
    Windows

    HORSE is a short psychological horror game about a man tormented by his recent past and his sexual alienation. Hiding from the world, his familiar surroundings turn hostile and do their utmost to eat him alive.

    Why similar: Horror 64.8%, Adventure 35.2%

  55. #55 Dark Fracture: Prologue
    67% matchVery Positive83% of 1,356 reviews2020
    Dev: Twisted II Studio
    Windows

    Dark Fracture is a psychological horror experience in which you explore an ever-changing world where reality and nightmares collide. Walk on the edge of madness in the shoes of a tormented soul as you descend into the darkest depths of the human psyche, and question everything you see.

    Why similar: Horror 68.1%, Adventure 26.4%, First-Person 5.5%

  56. #56 [Nightmare Files] Clap Clap
    63% matchOverwhelmingly Positive96% of 5,034 reviews2024
    Dev: Raycastly
    Windows

    Clap Clap is a short indie horror game that puts you in the shoes of a house sitter, experiencing strange occurrences in a seemingly ordinary home.

    Why similar: Horror 72.6%, Adventure 20.4%, Singleplayer 4%, First-Person 3.1%

  57. #57 Darkness Under My Bed
    67% matchVery Positive90% of 92 reviews2021
    Dev: Desert Fox
    Windows

    Wander through intricate maze under the bed, and discover the secrets hidden in the long, dark tunnels. Document the existence of monsters. Retrieve the stolen treasures and memories.

    Why similar: Horror 56.4%, Adventure 20%, Gore 15.4%, First-Person 4.8%, Singleplayer 3.5%

  58. #58 Welcome to Hanwell
    70% matchMixed47% of 363 reviews2017
    Dev: Steel Arts
    Windows
    Median: 2.8 hrsMean: 6.7 hrs≥1hr: 79%

    Open world horror set in a city in which your worst nightmares have become an everyday part of life. Explore a dense open world of terror, every building a unique location with it's own story to tell. Strung together by the remenants of Hanwell.

    Why similar: Horror 48.6%, Adventure 24.1%, Gore 14.1%, Violent 13.1%

  59. #59 Freaky Clown : Town Mystery
    68% matchMixed64% of 72 reviews2020
    Dev: Z & K Games
    Windows · Mac

    Can you solve the evil mystery of this town and face the freaky clown and his horrors alone? Take on this horror adventure and play and discover the evil plans of the clown.

    Why similar: Horror 54.1%, Adventure 43.1%, Singleplayer 2.8%

Don't Be Afraid - The First Toy cover art

Games Like Don't Be Afraid - The First Toy

Based on tag similarity + player behavior
Loading graph...