- #1 The Mountain
97% match4 user reviews100% of 4 reviews2025
Dev: Jakob Johansson
Windows
Slow paced puzzle game
Why similar: Cartoon 25.3%, Cartoony 16.7%, Casual 10.4%, Stylized 10.1%, 3D 8.9%
- #2 Animal Water Pang!
96% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2024
Dev: AFTERTIME.INCPub: CFK Co., Ltd.
Windows
Combine cute animal plushies to earn points and create even larger plushies! Create a large teddy bear as your final goal. However, be careful not to let the plushies spill out of the claw machine on your quest for a high score.
Why similar: Cartoon 24.4%, Puzzle 13.2%, Logic 12%, Family Friendly 10%, Casual 10%
- #3 Mochi's Cosy Quest
95% match8 user reviews88% of 8 reviews2025
Dev: Sylvie Sweet
Windows
Mochi’s Cosy Quest is a cute cosy 3D puzzle game where you lead a cute little capybara to its goal of eating fruit. Make use of the environment to get to the fruit as you are completely unable to jump. Relax and solve unique puzzle levels alongside Mochi the capybara.
Why similar: Cartoon 19.8%, Cartoony 13.4%, Puzzle 11.9%, Stylized 11%, Logic 10%
- #4 Sweet Collector
95% matchMostly Positive73% of 11 reviews2022
Dev: Invoke Games
Windows · Mac
Cute 2d puzzle game with sweets and cakes will make you relax! If you just want to have a bit of time for yourself. Arrange your 50 sweet friends on the grid of 100 levels.
Why similar: Cartoon 19.5%, Logic 11.9%, Puzzle 10.3%, Family Friendly 8.9%, Cute 8.4%
- #5 Combine 2 Pumpkins
94% matchPositive100% of 20 reviews2024
Dev: 2Z
Windows
Combine 2 similar pumpkins into a new larger one! Use special pumpkins to achieve crazy combos and compete for the highest score!
Why similar: Cartoon 19.1%, Cartoony 11.1%, Strategy 10.7%, Puzzle 9.5%, Stylized 8.6%
- #6 Hammer Penguins
93% matchPositive100% of 14 reviews2024
Dev: Muffin Man Games
Windows
Hammer Penguins is a cute tile-matching game where the goal is to clear the board by selecting matching tiles.
Why similar: Cartoon 24.4%, Cartoony 16.2%, Puzzle 13.2%, Casual 10.7%, Family Friendly 8.7%
- #7 ToyBox Puzzle
93% match5 user reviews100% of 5 reviews2023
Dev: JoyRobot
Windows
These toys are all over the place! Arrange and organize the mess by fitting everything inside the grid in this relaxing and colorful puzzle game with over 100 levels that will test your critical thinking skills.
Why similar: Cartoon 19.4%, Logic 17.1%, Puzzle 13.8%, Cute 11%, Family Friendly 10.8%
- #8 Sinister Sodies
92% matchPositive96% of 28 reviews2025
Dev: Goblin Laundromat
Windows
Sinister Sodies is a bite-sized arcade puzzle game where you must strategically box in mischievous frooblies to cleanse your carbonated concoction before time runs out.
Why similar: Cartoony 11.3%, Strategy 10.3%, Puzzle 10%, Cute 8.2%, Logic 7.8%
- #9 1001 Jigsaw. World Tour: Australian Puzzles
91% matchMixed53% of 15 reviews2019
Dev: Somer GamesPub: 8floor
Windows · Mac
1001 Jigsaw World Tour: Australia. A puzzle game and tour guide!
Why similar: Cartoon 22.6%, Cartoony 14.9%, Puzzle 12.1%, Logic 10.4%, Family Friendly 8.7%
- #10 QB Planets
91% match4 user reviews100% of 4 reviews2021
Dev: Madowl Games
Windows
Get your spaceship and embark on an amazing astral adventure of engaging puzzles into the final frontier. Overcome challenges and earn rewards that will let you discover more incredible puzzle planets in the farthest reaches of outer space.
Why similar: Cartoony 17%, Puzzle 14.7%, Logic 10.9%, Stylized 9.7%, Family Friendly 9.2%
- #11 Puzzling Wild IQ Test
90% matchVery Positive91% of 53 reviews2023
Dev: Paul BirdPub: Marjupi Games
Windows
Puzzling Wild introduces this IQ Test of logic and visual reasoning. These IQ Tests were developed by a Professor to try to test the intelligence of AI robots. Can you solve all 400 by your self? The puzzles are introduced by our good friends Ginger the Giraffe, and Hugo Hippo.
Why similar: Strategy 19.9%, Puzzle 16.1%, Cartoon 15.4%, Family Friendly 13.8%, Logic 13.5%
- #12 Dotu
89% match8 user reviews100% of 8 reviews2025
Dev: Chicken Undercover
Windows
Whether you’re a math enthusiast, a puzzle fanatic or just looking for a fun challenge, Dotu will keep you entertained for hours with its challenging puzzles! Are you ready to become a dot-solving mastermind?
Why similar: Logic 17.2%, Puzzle 13.1%, Strategy 12.7%, Cartoony 11.1%, Family Friendly 11%
- #13 Squiggle Drop
88% matchPositive87% of 39 reviews2024
Dev: Snickerdoodle GamesPub: Noodlecake
Windows · Mac · Linux
Draw shapes to solve physics puzzles! Over 250 levels each with their own unique objective. Put your brain to the test by making bridges, levers, weights and more. Iterate on your solutions again and again until you complete the goals.
Why similar: Cartoon 22.4%, Cartoony 13.9%, Puzzle 13.6%, Casual 10.5%, Stylized 8%
- #14 Castle Crumble
88% matchPositive93% of 14 reviews2025
Dev: Orbital Knight
Windows · Mac
Mysterious castles appeared all over the world. Use powerful weapons to destroy them in creative ways. Shoot projectiles, plant explosives and wreck havock in the world where every brick is physically simulated.
Why similar: Cartoony 16.4%, Strategy 14.2%, Puzzle 12.1%, Stylized 10.3%, Family Friendly 9.4%
- #15 Minesweeper Ultra Turbo Deluxe
87% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: pin kitten
Windows
Minesweeper, but a roguelike. Solve classic minesweeper puzzles with the help of many unique items. Create explosive combos, fight bosses, unlock characters, and overcome Michael Sweeper's Minefield.
Why similar: Cartoon 18%, Strategy 13.1%, Puzzle 12.4%, Cartoony 12.1%, Casual 7.5%
- #16 Newbinis!
86% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2025
Dev: Chris's Games
Windows
Escort a group of Newbinis as they escape captivity and head to a peaceful valley by solving various logic puzzles as you traverse the breadth of the land. The puzzles are related to the group's composition as well as other combinatorics ideas.
Why similar: Cartoon 21.2%, Logic 15.6%, Old School 11.2%, Puzzle 11%, Family Friendly 9.4%
- #17 Inky & Blinky
86% match2 user reviews50% of 2 reviews2023
Dev: Working Title StudiosPub: Working Title Studios LLC
Windows · Mac
Join Inky & Blinky and all their friends in this addictive little puzzle game where your goal is to get Blinky back to Inky.
Why similar: Cartoony 16.6%, Cartoon 14.3%, Logic 14.2%, Strategy 11.4%, Puzzle 11.2%
- #18 Murder at Midnight
85% matchPositive93% of 15 reviews2021
Dev: Maaz BaigPub: Jovius Studios
Windows
Sneak, hunt, and discuss in this thrilling game of predator vs. prey! Murder at Midnight is a game that pits people against each other in a race to finish objectives before they can be hunted and will leave you wondering who you can trust.
Why similar: Cartoon 22.4%, Cartoony 14%, Stylized 10.6%, Cute 10.1%, Family Friendly 9.6%
- #19 Rollo Pollo
84% matchNo user reviews
Dev: First Wave Games
Windows
The evil robots want to eat all the baby chickens! Plan your strategy by placing the arrows and blocks on the correct tiles and solve the puzzles. Move your chicken around the map and save all the chicks in each of the 100 levels.
Why similar: Strategy 20.5%, Cartoony 15%, Puzzle 14.8%, Cute 10.6%, Casual 10.1%
- #20 The Way of Knight
83% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2026
Dev: froggyrs
Windows
The Way of Knight is a chess-like puzzle game where you think your way through various enemies, boards, and hazards.
Why similar: Puzzle 18.5%, Strategy 16.9%, Logic 10.9%, Cartoony 10.7%, Cute 9.6%
- #21 Nonograms 22
84% match5 user reviews40% of 5 reviews2021
Dev: Studio Tomego
Windows
A jam packed nonograms game with beautiful pixel art and a slick UI. Over 216 puzzles to solve, achievements and a relaxing audio soundtrack wrapped up in 20+ hours of gameplay!
Why similar: Strategy 21.9%, Cartoony 18.4%, Puzzle 14.5%, Casual 12.7%, Logic 11.4%
- #22 Cat & Farm Pals
81% matchVery Positive95% of 274 reviews2025
Dev: Teneke Kafalar Spotlight
Windows
Cat & Farm Pals is a simple and fun pull & throw game that you can enjoy playing at your own pace. Spend fun moments with cats and farm animals, compete in weekly tournaments, and collect trophies!" 😸🐮
Why similar: Cartoon 19.3%, Strategy 12.7%, Family Friendly 12.7%, Puzzle 12.4%, Logic 12%
- #23 Interlocked: Puzzle Islands
82% matchNo user reviews
Dev: PuzzleDevPub: Armor Games Studios
Windows · Mac
Solve tactile three-dimensional burr puzzles on cozy Puzzle Islands. Twist, pull and dismantle handcrafted puzzles in immersive VR or with mouse & keyboard… alongside one curious little bird friend.
Why similar: Cartoony 16.4%, Puzzle 13.9%, Strategy 13.8%, Stylized 8.5%, Colorful 7.5%
- #24 Terra Ninfa
82% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Pyralis Studio
Windows · Linux
A cozy picturesque 3D exploration puzzle game about reviving ancient forgotten dried up gardens. Manipulate water, irrigate all the plants and enjoy poised landscapes.
Why similar: Puzzle 16.3%, Casual 13.7%, Colorful 11.9%, Cute 11.4%, Nature 11.2%
- #25 Mizi NO!
79% matchOverwhelmingly Positive99% of 2,744 reviews2024
Dev: DU&I
Windows
Median: 1.2 hrsMean: 3.6 hrs≥1hr: 66%
In this free 2D puzzle game, you must reassemble broken objects that your cat has knocked over.
Why similar: Cartoon 21.2%, Cartoony 15.6%, Puzzle 15.1%, Casual 9.9%, Cute 8.9%
- #26 Block & Shot
81% matchPositive100% of 16 reviews2024
Dev: Limansia Games
Windows
Block & Shot will immerse you in the captivating world of logical puzzles, where you will have to control various weapons to overcome obstacles in your path and reach the main goal - the golden cartridge
Why similar: Logic 17.9%, Puzzle 13.2%, Strategy 11.7%, Cartoony 11.3%, Stylized 9.2%
- #27 Gnomes Garden Lifeseeds Collector's Edition
79% matchMixed54% of 13 reviews2023
Dev: ToymanPub: 8Floor
Windows
The subjects came to the Gnomes Queen with alarming news. All gardens, forests and meadows began to fade. And so throughout the gnomes land!
Why similar: Strategy 19.5%, Cartoony 14.1%, Puzzle 12.8%, Casual 11%, Logic 9.1%
- #28 Room to Breathe
78% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Spyra_Labs
Windows
Room to Breathe is a cozy space-planning puzzle game where you arrange furniture to meet client needs, balance comfort and function, and turn empty rooms into spaces that truly feel right.
Why similar: Puzzle 16.3%, Casual 13.7%, Logic 12.8%, Colorful 11.9%, Cute 11.4%
- #29 Featherbound
78% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Aspen Games
Windows · Mac
A flightless bird named Pip wants to prove the world wrong and summit the top of the tree he calls home. Help Pip solve physics-based puzzles and navigate the tree's seemingly endless branches all the way up. Can you make it to the top of the tree?
Why similar: Strategy 12.2%, Puzzle 11.9%, Logic 11.1%, Stylized 10.2%, Family Friendly 8.9%
- #30 Fenced In
77% match3 user reviews67% of 3 reviews2025
Dev: Caesoose Studios
Windows · Mac · Linux
An arcade-puzzle game inspired by Zoo Keeper, Fenced in has you managing 10 different animals into 4 pens, making sure carnivores don't eat herbivores and filling up the pens as much as possible to get the highest score possible!
Why similar: Cartoony 15.2%, Cartoon 14.6%, Puzzle 13%, Management 12.2%, Family Friendly 11.1%
- #31 Bulbs 2.0
76% matchPositive90% of 10 reviews2024
Dev: Error 300
Windows
Mix colors and light in Bulbs 2.0, a challenging puzzle game where your logic skills are key to turning the entire board white.
Why similar: Cartoon 31.5%, Logic 20.5%, Puzzle 16.3%, Casual 11.3%, Cute 5.2%
- #32 LumbearJack
75% matchVery Positive93% of 329 reviews2022
Dev: FinalBoss GamesPub: Armor Games Studios
Windows
Median: 2.3 hrsMean: 5.7 hrs≥1hr: 82%
Grab your axe and save the environment by chopping and recycling every man-made thing in your path and solving puzzles with your charming animal friends!
Why similar: Nature 12.8%, Cartoony 12.5%, Family Friendly 11%, Stylized 10.2%, Puzzle 10%
- #33 Nino Maze LOFI II
76% matchPositive100% of 17 reviews2021
Dev: Carlos JunioPub: Pixizora
Windows
Following Nino Maze LOFI line of cute graphics and LOFI music, we now bring Nino Maze Lofi II, a new adventure!
Why similar: Cartoon 21.1%, Strategy 17.4%, Puzzle 11.8%, Casual 10.3%, Logic 9.8%
- #34 Block Plop
75% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2025
Dev: Clever Loon
Windows · Mac · Linux
Pick colors, plop down blocks, and conquer territory! Relax solo or challenge your friends locally in this delightful puzzle-strategy game.
Why similar: Strategy 20.4%, Puzzle 16.1%, Logic 14%, Family Friendly 10.3%, Casual 8.9%
- #35 Hogoworm Dungeon
77% matchNo user reviews2022
Dev: Hogo Company
Windows
Gather coins, harness magical spells, and outwit mechanical spiderbots through 100+ puzzling levels
Why similar: Logic 17.2%, Family Friendly 15.6%, Puzzle 15.4%, Strategy 13.6%, Cute 11.4%
- #36 Squeakross: Home Squeak Home
72% matchOverwhelmingly Positive99% of 1,869 reviews2025
Dev: Alblune
Windows · Mac
Median: 11.4 hrsMean: 27.7 hrs≥1hr: 89%
In Squeakross: Home Squeak Home, solve and transform puzzles into furniture to decorate the perfect home for your rodent friend. Collect hundreds of decorations, accessories and stickers in this cozy game full of charm!
Why similar: Cartoony 14.7%, Logic 14.2%, Puzzle 13.2%, Cute 10.5%, Stylized 10.4%
- #37 Project: Autumn
74% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Vultive Entertainment
Windows
Join Oakley and Elmer on their whimsical adventure through a stunning archipelago filled with people to befriend and secrets to uncover. Though simply tasked with finding a strange mythical creature, the two robots are distracted by the beauty of the islands.
Why similar: Cartoon 20.9%, Cartoony 14.5%, Puzzle 11.1%, Stylized 9.2%, Nature 7.7%
- #38 Catch the Skunk
74% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2024
Dev: SmartGames
Windows
Will you be the hero who gets rid of that heavy smell? Catch those skunks in this stinky SmartGames adventure!
Why similar: Cartoon 20%, Family Friendly 12.9%, Cartoony 12.7%, Puzzle 11.5%, 3D 6.9%
- #39 Benny The Blob
73% match8 user reviews88% of 8 reviews2024
Dev: Anthony LaVigna
Windows
This is a tricky puzzle game with cute little blobs, sparkly gems, 50 levels, and the ability to load and create custom levels. Benny The Blob features some difficult and headache-inducing levels that will challenge even the most experienced puzzle fans.
Why similar: Cartoony 16.9%, Puzzle 14.6%, Strategy 14.1%, Logic 12.3%, Cute 12%
- #40 Hare 136
72% matchPositive100% of 19 reviews2024
Dev: Haremonic Games
Windows · Linux
Drag adorable coin-riding rabbits and slide them across the board. Solve engaging cozy puzzles. Help our little fluffy friends get back to their home!
Why similar: Cartoon 13.5%, Logic 11.9%, Cartoony 10.1%, Family Friendly 9.5%, Nature 9.1%
- #41 Merge Jam
73% matchNo user reviews2025
Dev: VectorUp Games
Windows
Merge balls to complete puzzles in this fun and addictive physics-based game! Fun, colorful and relaxing - good for hours of gameplay!
Why similar: Strategy 22.6%, Puzzle 13.3%, Casual 12.8%, Logic 11.6%, Stylized 9.8%
- #42 Professor Watts Memory Match: Cute Animals
73% matchMixed51% of 43 reviews2018
Dev: Ripknot Systems
Windows
Hello Professor Watts here and I have some research to do on memory skills. I have assembled a wide variety of cute animals to put our memory to the test. We can see how we're doing by completing matches in a specific amount of time and earning points to track our overall progress.
Why similar: Cartoon 19%, Casual 15.6%, Cartoony 15.1%, Logic 13%, Puzzle 11.6%
- #43 The Minesweeper
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Stephan Royer
Windows
The classic game of minesweeper from a fresh new perspective. Play alone or with a friend in this third person puzzle game, where you toss grenades, plant flags, and math a path to victory. Enjoy the calm of nature, chill tunes and chaotic reveals.
Why similar: Puzzle 15.4%, Nature 13.4%, Strategy 12.8%, Logic 12.2%, Family Friendly 10.3%
- #44 Landon's Puzzle ParTAY
69% match8 user reviews89% of 9 reviews2025
Dev: Adventure Camp GamesPub: Adventure Camp
Windows · Mac
Landon's Puzzle ParTAY™ is a game where you complete puzzles as fast as you can without running out of time! Enjoy all of the fun and wacky minigames with a C.I. Puppet Friends™ flair! Create your own profile and compete for the high score!
Why similar: Strategy 20.7%, Cartoon 20%, Cartoony 13.9%, Puzzle 12.6%, Casual 11.8%
- #45 Slice Surge
71% matchNo user reviews2025
Dev: Boogygames Studios
Windows
Unleash your slicing skills in Slice Surge! Cut through dragons, fries, treasure, and more in 100+ fun and challenging levels. With colorful cartoon visuals and satisfying slice effects, this one-touch puzzle game is easy to learn but hard to master!
Why similar: Cartoon 24.9%, Cartoony 19.3%, Family Friendly 12.3%, Strategy 10.7%, Casual 10.1%
- #46 Pilie Pals
71% match5 user reviews100% of 5 reviews2021
Dev: Keyreal
Windows
Lead a group of adorable creatures known as Pilies and help them climb and stack their way to the goal in this unique and family-friendly puzzle game!
Why similar: Cartoon 15.9%, Logic 12.2%, Puzzle 11.3%, Family Friendly 11.1%, Cartoony 11.1%
- #47 My Suika – Kyo’s Fruit Merge
68% matchVery Positive93% of 1,927 reviews2023
Dev: Watashi Games
Windows
Median: 3.6 hrsMean: 8.0 hrs≥1hr: 82%
A fun watermelon merge puzzle game! Combine various matching fruits to help Kyo gather watermelons in four different game modes!
Why similar: Cartoon 17.4%, Strategy 16.8%, Puzzle 14.1%, Casual 11.1%, Family Friendly 10.6%
- #48 Cubiverse
70% matchPositive97% of 33 reviews2021
Dev: Cubinauts
Windows
Go on a brain-twisting journey through a colorful galaxy of planets based on the magic cube. You'll have to twist and turn whole planets and solve tricky puzzles.
Why similar: Nature 15.8%, Puzzle 13.6%, Cartoony 11.9%, Family Friendly 11%, Colorful 10.6%
- #49 Lucky Tabi
69% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Beyond Abyss Productions
Windows
You start off with a fishing rod, with this fishing rod you can pull objects in place to finish the puzzles that get increasingly more difficult. The goal is to bring the bubble to the portal to activate the new level.
Why similar: Cartoony 14.5%, Strategy 13.9%, Puzzle 13.6%, Nature 11.8%, Colorful 9.9%
- #50 One Line Coloring
70% matchVery Positive92% of 53 reviews2020
Dev: MythicOwl
Windows
A vibrant world of colorful shapes awaits! Connect the dots to uncover charming objects in this colorful take on a classic paper puzzle game. Complete lively dioramas and relax yourself in the pastel world of One Line Coloring.
Why similar: Family Friendly 12.8%, Puzzle 12.5%, Logic 11.6%, Nature 11.5%, Colorful 10.4%
- #51 Nonogram Piggy Valley
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Chubby Horse Games
Windows · Mac · Linux
Nonogram Piggy Valley is a classic logic-puzzle game with a special farm twist. Solve picross puzzles, adopt cute pigs, build your farm, collect all pigs and themes.
Why similar: Cartoony 24.5%, Puzzle 16.7%, Colorful 13%, Cute 13%, Logic 10.2%
- #52 Suika game 3D
69% match2 user reviews50% of 2 reviews2023
Dev: Doky
Windows
What is better than a 2D watermelon? A 3D one! The evolution of the watermelon game with a new level of depth! Suika game 3D.
Why similar: Strategy 21.6%, Logic 16.8%, Puzzle 16.8%, Management 16.3%, 3D 9.5%
- #53 1001 Jigsaw. World Tour: London
70% matchMixed55% of 11 reviews2019
Dev: CreobitPub: 8floor
Windows · Mac
1001 Jigsaw. World Tour: London Puzzles – feel the spirit of London in jigsaws
Why similar: Cartoony 19.8%, Puzzle 16.1%, Logic 12.9%, Casual 11.6%, Colorful 10.2%
- #54 Fill the Cat Box!
68% match7 user reviews100% of 7 reviews2023
Dev: Ancient Newt Games
Windows · Mac · Linux
A casual 3D physics puzzle game, similar to Suika Game, Watermelon Game, where you combine cats of the same size and color to create larger cats. Fit as many cats into the box as you can before letting a cat fall out! Try to break your old high scores! Watermelon in background.
Why similar: Cartoon 17.6%, Cartoony 12.4%, Puzzle 9.7%, Logic 9%, Stylized 8.2%
- #55 Cookie Flipper
66% match4 user reviews100% of 4 reviews2026
Dev: 0100010 Industries
Windows · Mac
A casual, nostalgic puzzle game with a delicious twist! Has 72 preset levels, and near infinite custom levels. Tired of Match 3, and want a change? Try Cookie Flipper, wish list it today!
Why similar: Puzzle 18.5%, Cute 14%, Logic 11.9%, Stylized 10.8%, Family Friendly 10.6%
- #56 Flowerdrops
65% matchPositive100% of 15 reviews2025
Dev: Studio Cozy Zone
Windows
Take in the wistful beauty and uncover lost secrets as you restore life to a quiet and forgotten world in this meditative physics puzzle game. The Universe is Your Garden.
Why similar: Nature 17.3%, Strategy 14.3%, Puzzle 13.9%, Cartoony 10.6%, Colorful 8.3%
- #57 Poke ALL Toads
64% matchVery Positive100% of 260 reviews2026
Dev: SpaceMatra
Windows
A puzzle game starring mischievous fairies. Complete levels by working as a team, operating dangerous machinery and manipulating local wildlife.
Why similar: Cartoon 23.9%, Logic 18.3%, Cartoony 15.1%, Puzzle 13%, Strategy 12.3%
- #58 Once Upon a Page
67% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Team Strawberry
Windows
Once Upon a Page is a fun educational game made for a younger audience and casual gamers. Drag & Drop cards, complete puzzles, and explore the character's world of imagination!
Why similar: Cartoony 17.4%, Puzzle 13.1%, Casual 10.9%, Logic 9.9%, Stylized 9%
- #59 Asian Food Cart Tycoon
67% matchMostly Negative24% of 21 reviews2023
Dev: Nexvel EntertainmentPub: CRX Entertainment Pte Ltd
Windows
Grow your satay business and become the most successful satay entrepreneur in the world!
Why similar: Cartoon 23.4%, Strategy 19.1%, Cartoony 14%, Casual 11.3%, 3D 8.3%