- #1 Cases from the Murder Wagon
97% matchNo user reviews2027
Dev: UTOPIA
Windows
Take control of the Murder Wagon investigation team and cooperate to solve the world’s strangest cases in this asymmetrical co-op horror game.
Why similar: Supernatural 25.5%, 1990's 19.8%, Horror 18.2%, Investigation 14.3%, Retro 5.9%
- #2 What You Don't See
96% matchMostly Positive77% of 13 reviews2026
Dev: Maroon Moon Studio
Windows
A first-person horror game that has you explore the surreal mindscape of a murder victim. Armed with your trusty flashlight, you must gather evidence to try and piece together the details of the murder and free them from their suffering.
Why similar: Supernatural 27%, Collectathon 23.3%, Horror 17.7%, Investigation 14.2%, First-Person 11.6%
- #3 SPIRITGRAPHER: THE ASYLUM 99
96% matchMostly Positive77% of 13 reviews2024
Dev: GamesFromTheOtherSide
Windows
This first-person horror detective. You are a spiritgrapher, your camera can see what is beyond the reach of the human eye. Head to an abandoned hospital and shoot a report about supernatural events.
Why similar: Supernatural 22.4%, 1990's 20.9%, Horror 15.5%, Hidden Object 12.1%, Thriller 7.5%
- #4 Spiral
95% match4 user reviews100% of 4 reviews2025
Dev: 小林 悠Pub: Morpheus
Windows
A letter and a floppy disk arrive—from a friend who died six years ago. Inside is a strange game: a distorted replica of your old apartment. Spiral is a 1st/3rd-person horror adventure where you bend gravity, explore broken space, and gather forgotten fragments of the past.
Why similar: Collectathon 27.3%, 1990's 23.4%, Horror 16.8%, Hidden Object 8.1%, Stealth 7.4%
- #5 Sightless Mind
94% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2024
Dev: ScarabDev
Windows
Sightless Mind is a short single-player horror experience. You get a message from your pal Paul to pick up a few books from his lab after a power outage, but things aren't as they seem. Never forget: Out of sight, out of mind.
Why similar: Supernatural 29.4%, Collectathon 27.7%, Horror 18.8%, Investigation 14.3%, Simulation 4.4%
- #6 The Overseer
94% matchPositive100% of 16 reviews2024
Dev: mars
Windows
You work for an agency containing supernatural threats. A monitored subject with unusual abilities drew anomalies to his former sites, along with a figure codenamed “Eric.” The subject is being moved to a Safe House. Secure every location and prevent further spread.
Why similar: Supernatural 27.8%, Hidden Object 25%, Horror 21.2%, Investigation 18.2%, Simulation 5.3%
- #7 Victor's Video Vault
93% matchNo user reviews2027
Dev: Stingbot Games
Windows
It's 1995. The video store is alive. When the last customer leaves, the final rental rewrites reality.
Why similar: Horror 22%, Supernatural 20.9%, 1990's 16.3%, Investigation 14.1%, First-Person 12.9%
- #8 Death Education
92% matchMixed70% of 33 reviews2024
Dev: cirtisPub: No father corporation
Windows
Immerse yourself in the atmosphere of an old abandoned Soviet school and find out what's going on inside its walls from the first person in the new psychological horror Death Education. But be careful, something is already watching you.
Why similar: Supernatural 30.1%, 1990's 25%, Horror 21.8%, Hidden Object 11.5%, First-Person 6.9%
- #9 Silent Signal
91% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Vermilion Bird Studio
Windows
You play as a rescue team member sent to investigate an offshore drilling platform that has been out of contact for seven days. But danger awaits at every turn. As you uncover the truth behind its disappearance, can you escape alive—or were you already part of it the moment you stepped aboard?
Why similar: Supernatural 29.7%, Horror 24.1%, First-Person 14.6%, Stealth 10.5%, Investigation 10%
- #10 The House of Toys
90% matchVery Positive91% of 58 reviews2025
Dev: Old School Bros
Windows
The House of Toys is a horror game in which the player ventures into an old mansion filled with seemingly harmless toys. His mission is to explore each room, searching for clues to discover which of the toys is cursed. To free the soul trapped in this toy, the player must solve intricate puzzles.
Why similar: 1990's 21.7%, Horror 18.2%, Investigation 16.8%, Stealth 15%, Supernatural 14.2%
- #11 Mbembe Radio
91% matchPositive86% of 43 reviews2024
Dev: Gattorocco
Windows
This is a horror adventure game. Let's take on the challenges presented by the radio and make the journey home enjoyable. Fun may also include some fear.
Why similar: Horror 26.2%, 1990's 22.1%, Hidden Object 20.1%, Retro 13.2%, Action-Adventure 8.2%
- #12 BARABIZNA
89% match5 user reviews60% of 5 reviews2025
Dev: CepSoft
Windows
BARABIZNA is a atmospheric horror game set in a creepy old house. Find and collect all the hidden items before it's too late. But beware... you're not alone.
Why similar: Collectathon 24.5%, Hidden Object 17.9%, Horror 16.8%, Supernatural 12.5%, Physics 8.1%
- #13 The Hag
89% match3 user reviews67% of 3 reviews2025
Dev: TheLonelyGameDev
Windows
A missing engineer must be found. The communication towers must be restored. When the lights go out, the Hag will find you.
Why similar: Supernatural 28.9%, Collectathon 20.8%, Horror 20%, Investigation 8.8%, Stealth 8.5%
- #14 Dead Stop - No Vacancy
87% matchMostly Positive79% of 47 reviews2026
Dev: Camel 101
Windows
One night at the Paradise Motel. One reporter who took a wrong turn. One thing certain: nobody checks out clean. A short retro horror inspired by 80s slasher films.
Why similar: 1990's 27.3%, Horror 21.8%, Investigation 14.5%, Retro 12.3%, First-Person 10.8%
- #15 Periphery
88% matchNo user reviews
Dev: EvE Games
Windows
Periphery is a psychedelic action-horror game. Uncover the truth about your workspace, get introduced to the locals and their gnostic fascination. Warp into the pixelated world of Periphery and experience surreal world built on mystery.
Why similar: Supernatural 27.5%, 1990's 23.1%, Horror 17.1%, First-Person 10.4%, Retro 10%
- #16 Dead Exposure
86% match2 user reviews0% of 2 reviews2026
Dev: Rotwired Studios
Windows
Use an instant camera to reveal hidden realities and shape the house itself. Not everything stays where it belongs.
Why similar: Supernatural 29.5%, Horror 21.3%, Investigation 15.4%, 1990's 11.1%, Hidden Object 11%
- #17 Wendigo
86% matchPositive82% of 17 reviews2023
Dev: Noah Artime
Windows
A stealth horror game in the woods, investigate and progress while drawing as little attention to yourself as possible.
Why similar: Horror 24.3%, Supernatural 23.7%, 1990's 19.1%, Stealth 18.3%, First-Person 11.8%
- #18 The Consumed
85% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: OTR HVN STUDIO
Windows · Mac
Play as a Night-Shift Mall Security Guard in this first-person analog horror game. Check, secure, and attempt to survive the haunted shops in this dying mall.
Why similar: Horror 27.3%, Supernatural 25%, First-Person 14.5%, Simulation 11.2%, Retro 8.1%
- #19 [ANOMALY TAPES]: Beyond Reality
84% matchMostly Positive79% of 24 reviews2024
Dev: PANIX
Windows
Uncover the truth in '[ANOMALY TAPES]: Beyond Reality'. Navigate through haunting levels, survive deadly anomalies with unique mechanics, and piece together a chilling mystery hidden within the tapes. Dare to uncover the secrets?
Why similar: Supernatural 21.4%, 1990's 21%, Horror 14.8%, Hidden Object 10.3%, Stealth 9.3%
- #20 Final Footage
84% matchNo user reviews
Dev: M Productions
Windows
Find what doesn't belong. Capture the evidence. Survive what finds you. Final Footage is a psychological horror game where you investigate anomalies, hide from the Knocker, upgrade your equipment, and unlock increasingly dangerous locations.
Why similar: Horror 18.9%, Supernatural 18.1%, 1990's 17.4%, Investigation 16.2%, First-Person 11.9%
- #21 Hacksaw Massacre
83% match2 user reviews50% of 2 reviews2026
Dev: Catacomb Games
Windows
Hacksaw Massacre brings you to the house of the corrupt mayor of a small Canadian town who died many years ago. Set in the 1980's this indie horror game has you investigating what happened, and what is still happening in this cursed mansion.
Why similar: Supernatural 35.3%, Horror 25.7%, First-Person 9.8%, Hidden Object 9.4%, Physics 9%
- #22 PNG Mall
82% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Derndeff
Windows
Trapped in a sprawling liminal realm, you must explore, run, and hide in order to escape. Utilize nostalgic 90s toys, raid cash registers to buy items from vending machines, and sprint to safe zones when danger is near!
Why similar: Supernatural 23.3%, 1990's 23%, Horror 18.7%, Stealth 16.9%, First-Person 10.1%
- #23 The House: A Maple Street Story
82% matchMixed67% of 15 reviews2024
Dev: Krondak Studio
Windows
Explore a cursed house where a family was driven to madness by a dark presence. In The House: A Maple Street Story, uncover a terrifying mystery through enigmatic puzzles, an engaging narrative, and a psychological horror atmosphere that holds your every move captive.
Why similar: Supernatural 34.4%, Horror 24.9%, First-Person 13.4%, 1990's 12.5%, Investigation 7.5%
- #24 Ghost Scout
81% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Gradient Games
Windows
Identify invisible ghosts using strange objects. Find the Anchor without getting killed, reveal the ghosts true form and attempt to get out alive.
Why similar: Supernatural 26.6%, Horror 17.3%, Stealth 11.8%, Investigation 10.9%, Hidden Object 10%
- #25 House of Mimics
80% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Squrio Games
Windows
In a house of identical rooms, you are trapped with a lurking Mimic that disguises as household objects. It thrives on deception, toying with your mind and senses. Observe your surroundings, expose the mimic, and escape - alone or with friends.
Why similar: Supernatural 17.8%, Horror 17.1%, Investigation 16.6%, Hidden Object 16.2%, Stealth 13.4%
- #26 Twelve Sticks
81% matchMixed50% of 10 reviews2024
Dev: Beshbarmak gamesPub: Beshbarmak games
Windows
Play hide-and-seek with friends online, hide from the monster, or play as a monster and catch other players. Get scared, have fun, collect points, buy upgrades, and most importantly, have fun.
Why similar: 1990's 20.9%, Supernatural 18.4%, Hidden Object 16.8%, First-Person 10.7%, Stealth 8.7%
- #27 6days
79% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2025
Dev: TechAzy
Windows
In 1979, a man named Masao Satomi was involved in an accident. He was taken to the hospital and woke up safe and sound, but had amnesia. When he wonders if there is any memory he can recall, he recalls an intense childhood memory from 16 years ago.
Why similar: Collectathon 26.3%, Horror 18.3%, 1990's 18.3%, Supernatural 16.8%, Hidden Object 14.3%
- #28 Late Night with Ken Hayes
79% matchNo user reviews
Dev: SludgePup Games
Windows
Host the graveyard shift at a small-town radio station in 1998. Callers keep describing the same pale man—and every time someone talks about him on air, he seems to get closer.
Why similar: Horror 24.5%, Supernatural 23.5%, 1990's 22.2%, First-Person 13.3%, Thriller 6.1%
- #29 Beyond the Red Door
78% match5 user reviews20% of 5 reviews2025
Dev: Crimson Door Games
Windows
A first-person walking simulator horror (60 mins). As a desperate father, explore a nightmare hospital to retrieve the red skull—the only key to breaking the barrier trapping your daughter's soul. But the building remembers you... and your dead wife walks here.
Why similar: Supernatural 45.8%, Horror 29.9%, First-Person 24.3%
- #30 The Fox Hare Disaster: Chapter One
77% matchPositive95% of 43 reviews2024
Dev: Dream OniPub: Valorware
Windows
Prepare to explore an abandoned mall from the 90’s in this first-person, psychological horror! Tackle puzzles and come face to face with the haunting creatures that lurk inside. Will you be able to make it out alive, or will you suffer the same fate as those who came before you…?
Why similar: Supernatural 21.2%, Collectathon 18.7%, Horror 15.9%, 1990's 13.4%, Investigation 11.6%
- #31 Cassette
77% matchNo user reviews
Dev: ZhuravlevX
Windows
Cassette – An atmospheric analog psychological horror game in the spirit of old VHS tapes, where you will have to face the unknown and the secrets hidden in the tapes you find.
Why similar: 1990's 27.2%, Horror 20%, Hidden Object 13.7%, Retro 11.9%, First-Person 10.8%
- #32 Mindless Breakpoint
76% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Itamde
Windows
Mindless Breakpoint is a first person horror adventure with puzzles and some action elements. The game is set inside a huge mental asylum in which terrible things have happened.
Why similar: Collectathon 21.3%, 1990's 17.7%, Hidden Object 13.7%, Investigation 10.9%, Horror 10.6%
- #33 The Warehouse
76% match5 user reviews60% of 5 reviews2024
Dev: Matt CunhaPub: Matt Corp
Windows
A simple horror collection game set in a warehouse outside of space and time
Why similar: Collectathon 29.3%, Hidden Object 17.9%, Horror 12.6%, Investigation 11.2%, First-Person 11%
- #34 Killer Vegetable
75% match9 user reviews78% of 9 reviews2024
Dev: 鬱薔薇檸檬(UtuBaraLemon)
Windows
Girl VS Vegetables「crisp and fresh」A horror game aiming to conquer vegetables
Why similar: Collectathon 31.6%, Horror 25.1%, Hidden Object 19.3%, Stealth 8.5%, First-Person 7.5%
- #35 The Caretakers
74% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Filip Pantic
Windows
Infiltrate contaminated residences and deal with their mutant pests using the most advanced tech of the 1960s. Set up a base and observe, probe, and most importantly, survive the grotesque creatures in this online co-op horror game.
Why similar: Supernatural 30.6%, Horror 23.5%, Investigation 19.7%, Retro 9.1%, First-Person 8.3%
- #36 Haunted Ghost Hunters
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Not Cursed Games
Windows · Linux
Become a ghost hunter! Enter forbidden places crawling with paranormal activity. 🦇 Lost mansions, abandoned asylums, forgotten graveyards, decaying castles... Grab your gear. Enter the fog. Reveal what hides within.
Why similar: Supernatural 34%, Collectathon 21.8%, Horror 17.5%, 1990's 7.8%, Simulation 7.7%
- #37 Project Horror Tales
75% match7 user reviews86% of 7 reviews2023
Dev: ShuyuralPub: ShuyInteractiveGames
Windows
When Travel plans go awry, the only way out is to face the darkness and find a way to survive to make it home alive. With something Lurking in the Dark. You are not alone.You will Have to Face the Darkness to Survive. The question is - Can you Survive?
Why similar: Hidden Object 17.8%, Supernatural 17.4%, Horror 14.5%, Sandbox 12.7%, Investigation 11.6%
- #38 The Curse of Beatriz
73% matchPositive93% of 14 reviews2025
Dev: DarkPlayerGAMES
Windows
Your parents are out celebrating their wedding anniversary. Alone at home, you decide to test the legend of Beatriz, a spirit that haunts those who summon her in front of the bathroom mirror. What seemed like just a joke soon turns into a terrifying nightmare.
Why similar: Horror 28.1%, First-Person 22.3%, Supernatural 19.6%, Hidden Object 17.6%, Retro 6.6%
- #39 Akairo No Kaii - 赤色の怪異
74% matchMostly Positive69% of 16 reviews2023
Dev: HedronDog
Windows
The only way home is through that tunnel... The only way to survive is to run away...
Why similar: 1990's 31.2%, Supernatural 20.8%, Horror 15.9%, First-Person 15.8%, Retro 9.3%
- #40 Echoes
72% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Jorge Oliveira
Windows
You’re a security guard assigned to protect the entrance to an abandoned mine. You’re not supposed to go beyond your post, but you keep on hearing odd noises coming from within. Investigate their source – and stay alive.
Why similar: 1990's 25.5%, Horror 18%, Stealth 15.2%, Hidden Object 14.8%, First-Person 11.7%
- #41 Liminal Explorer
71% matchPositive91% of 11 reviews2025
Dev: compact
Windows
Wander through a variety of eerie liminal spaces whilst completing puzzles and discovering secrets. Each level is designed to be explored to its fullest, packed with hidden details and objectives for true Liminal Explorers.
Why similar: Collectathon 31.6%, 1990's 24.3%, Horror 15.2%, First-Person 12.2%, Retro 5.6%
- #42 Dollmare
71% matchVery Positive94% of 2,183 reviews2024
Dev: Alex GradePub: Almost Done Games
Windows
Median: 3.0 hrsMean: 3.5 hrs≥1hr: 89%
You've accepted a shady job offer at a doll factory. Inspect dolls for defects and anomalies. Follow strange protocols. Don't get fired and stay alive.
Why similar: Supernatural 30.7%, Horror 22.1%, First-Person 14.1%, Hidden Object 12.3%, Simulation 9.5%
- #43 Elevator 25
73% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2024
Dev: Iovino Kristian
Windows
You are trapped in an office on the 25th floor. Observe your surroundings carefully to reach the exit on floor 0.
Why similar: Hidden Object 25.2%, Supernatural 23.6%, Horror 16.7%, First-Person 14.3%, Action-Adventure 9.3%
- #44 Highland Trip
72% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: James Muirhead
Windows
A first-person psychological horror game where you explore the remote Scottish Highlands, gather resources to survive the night, and evade a stalking presence that blurs hallucination and reality. The game is voice acted in Scottish Gaelic with subtitles in English or Gaelic.
Why similar: 1990's 33.2%, Horror 25.1%, Hidden Object 20.3%, First-Person 8.9%, Action-Adventure 5.5%
- #45 Valley of Shadows
71% matchMostly Positive79% of 24 reviews2024
Dev: BadTaste Studio
Windows
Valley of Shadows is a short psychological horror set in an ordinary American suburb. Players navigate as James, a family man seeking answers about his missing family, while grappling with paranoia and supernatural forces.
Why similar: Supernatural 24.1%, 1990's 20.2%, Horror 18.5%, Investigation 14%, First-Person 12%
- #46 Cursed Baby
70% matchPositive90% of 10 reviews2024
Dev: NanningsGamesPub: Yahaha Games
Windows
The once #1 horror game on the Horror list of Itch is back! Join now and use a variety of repair tools to experience life as a handyman in a haunted house, uncover the terrifying past of this old house and face the terrifying demon baby head-on!
Why similar: 1990's 23.9%, Supernatural 19.2%, Horror 15.6%, Investigation 13.8%, Retro 11.3%
- #47 Graveyard Report
69% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Poltergeist Games
Windows
Collect evidence by capturing photos of anomalies. Monitor security footage for areas inhabiting strange activity, objects, or entities. Meet your hourly evidence quota and fulfill requests or you'll be fired! Solve puzzles, find answers, and uncover the truth, all while trying to survive the night.
Why similar: Supernatural 21.6%, Horror 21.3%, Hidden Object 19.8%, 1990's 13%, Investigation 9.8%
- #48 The Overseer: Field Trials
70% matchPositive93% of 14 reviews2024
Dev: mars
Windows
Step into the role of a paranormal agent. It's time for field trials where you’ll identify anomalies firsthand. The trials are held in a partially controlled environment, but stay alert—unexpected threats may arise. Successfully report anomalies multiple times to earn your Field Agent badge.
Why similar: Supernatural 30.3%, Horror 19.7%, Hidden Object 16.6%, First-Person 10.7%, Investigation 8.8%
- #49 Paranormal Footages : Supervisor
69% matchNo user reviews
Dev: OPAQUE
Windows
Ethan Cole takes on a temporary night shift at the "Ravenhill" warehouse. What begins as a routine package sorting gradually turns into something far more disturbing. Before long, Ethan realizes that some shipments were never meant to be delivered.
Why similar: Supernatural 33.9%, Horror 24.5%, First-Person 10.3%, 1990's 9.6%, Thriller 9.4%
- #50 Souls That Wait: Penunggu
69% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Starpixel Studios
Windows
Step into the shoes of a new security guard at a Malaysian school with a dark history in this first-person, realistic supernatural thriller. Encounter spirits rooted in Malaysian folklore, make critical choices to free trapped souls, and uncover the truth behind the eerie manifestations.
Why similar: 1990's 21.8%, Hidden Object 16.7%, Supernatural 13.7%, Horror 12.5%, Investigation 11.4%
- #51 No God No Heaven
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: José Rodrigues
Windows
You’re in hell for reasons you might not even understand yourself. But if this has happened before, it shouldn’t affect you anymore… right?
Why similar: Supernatural 37%, Horror 27.4%, Hidden Object 14.5%, First-Person 14.2%, Action-Adventure 3.7%
- #52 Backrooms: The Game
70% match2 user reviews0% of 2 reviews2023
Dev: Yiğit Yamaç TOPKARAPub: TPKDEV
Windows
Backrooms is a creepypasta that contains randomly generated office rooms that seem endless. The walls are mono yellow in color. It is also an eternal paradox.
Why similar: Supernatural 34.9%, Horror 27.6%, First-Person 15.6%, Sandbox 11.8%, Simulation 7.1%
- #53 Cursed Places: Hotel Floor 13
68% matchPositive88% of 17 reviews2024
Dev: AlmeritGames
Windows
Cursed Places: Hotel Floor 13 is an observation game where you are trapped on the Cursed Floor 13. Reach the first floor to escape from this cursed endless loop
Why similar: Supernatural 33.5%, Horror 22.4%, First-Person 17.6%, Hidden Object 15.4%, Simulation 9.9%
- #54 Granny's House
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Trinity Games Studio
Windows
Summer vacations were always the same. But this time, as João travels to visit his grandmother, he realizes something is wrong. What begins as an ordinary visit soon turns into a journey of fear, mystery, and survival against the unexplainable.
Why similar: 1990's 30.2%, Horror 23.5%, Hidden Object 17.4%, First-Person 14.8%, Supernatural 6.4%
- #55 HANGAR 8
67% matchPositive92% of 49 reviews2024
Dev: Twin Tail Digital
Windows · Linux
HANGAR 8 is a psychological horror set within the unsettling confines of a derelict space station. Brave the looping corridors to get to level 8, discover all anomalies, collect key items, and escape the nightmare!
Why similar: Supernatural 21.1%, Collectathon 17.6%, Hidden Object 15.8%, Investigation 14.8%, Horror 14%
- #56 UFOPHILIA
65% matchMostly Positive73% of 93 reviews2026
Dev: k148 Game StudioPub: JanduSoft
Windows
UFOPHILIA is a first-person psychological horror game where you explore areas marked by alien phenomena. Use specialized equipment to detect, identify, and photograph aliens—but do so at your own risk... They are watching you too.
Why similar: Supernatural 32.1%, Horror 22.7%, Investigation 15.7%, First-Person 12.6%, Simulation 6.4%
- #57 School Paranormal Laboratory
67% matchMixed56% of 39 reviews2024
Dev: KIMIDORI SOFT
Windows
To those who will become investigators at our research institute, Our institute conducts research on mysterious phenomena and grudges that occur in schools. As an investigator, you will carry out field surveys, but it is a simple job that even those with no experience can perform.
Why similar: Collectathon 30.6%, Hidden Object 20%, Horror 15%, Supernatural 13.8%, First-Person 10.9%
- #58 Creatures of the Night
66% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Torchlight Studio
Windows
Inspired by classic horror and the VHS generation of movie rentals. Creatures of the Night aims to be an immersive and fun experience putting players inside some horror classics to solve mysteries, lift curses and try to survive either solo or multiplayer
Why similar: Supernatural 21.2%, 1990's 20.1%, Horror 14.8%, Investigation 13.2%, Hidden Object 13%
- #59 İBLİS2:sorcery
68% matchMostly Negative34% of 141 reviews2022
Dev: Bulut ULUPub: FND GAME
Windows
Demon sorcery2 is a first-person psychological horror game. The events, the voiceovers are scary and completely real. Explore a mysterious village with ever-changing passwords in an atmospheric world and enjoy the terrifying joy of horror. Don't forget.. the demon is a production based on realism.
Why similar: Supernatural 27.7%, 1990's 16.2%, Hidden Object 12.3%, Stealth 11.1%, Horror 9.7%