Nodal

Games Like Pony Island 2: Panda Circus

60+ similar titles based on shared tags and player behavior. Themes include Horror, Singleplayer, Psychological Horror, Puzzle.

Pony Island 2: Panda Circus header art

Pony Island 2: Panda Circus is a phantasmagorical voyage through time, myth, divinity, and video games. Escape the lordly deities of the underworld with your soul, and your sanity, intact. This is not a game about ponies.

Reviews: No user reviews — 50%
Released: To be announced
Developer: Daniel Mullins Games
Genres: Adventure, Indie
Platforms: Windows

Similar Games

View all 59 recommendations
  1. #1 Subject Breach
    97% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Dreamfold
    Windows

    Subject Breach is a hand-drawn psychological thriller about identity, control, and the quiet horror of being observed. Solve surreal puzzles, question self recognition, rethink human connection as reality fractures around you.

    Why similar: Surreal 25.1%, Psychological Horror 24%, Point & Click 22.9%, Puzzle 10.9%, Horror 9.7%

  2. #2 Rusty Lake Hotel
    96% matchOverwhelmingly Positive96% of 10,008 reviews2016
    Dev: Rusty Lake
    Windows · Mac
    Median: 2.4 hrsMean: 6.6 hrs≥1hr: 80%

    Are you ready to serve the guests in the Rusty Lake Hotel? Solve all mysteries in this dark and eerie puzzle game. Rusty Lake Hotel is a point-and-click adventure by the creators of the Rusty Lake & Cube Escape series.

    Why similar: Point & Click 28.4%, Puzzle 17.6%, Surreal 17.3%, Psychological Horror 14.8%, Horror 10.6%

  3. #3 Lost in Voice
    96% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: beforeyouknowgames
    Windows

    A psychological horror where reality fractures around musician John Hale. Explore a non‑linear story, haunting memories, and immersive sound as you slip between truth, delusion, and the darkness of your own mind.

    Why similar: Surreal 22.1%, Psychological Horror 22%, First-Person 12.2%, Horror 10.7%, Demons 9.9%

  4. #4 Whisper Of The Curse
    95% match4 user reviews50% of 4 reviews2024
    Dev: Amonesus Games
    Windows

    "Whisper of the Curse" is a 4-player online co-op psychological horror game where you and your team will perform various rituals and spells to eliminate the curse and fend off cursed entities. At the same time, you'll need to avoid being hunted by these malevolent entities.

    Why similar: Surreal 23.2%, Psychological Horror 15.9%, Demons 12.9%, Puzzle 11.9%, First-Person 11.3%

  5. #5 Confabulation
    94% matchVery Positive91% of 103 reviews2023
    Dev: Authogin
    Windows

    Your memory is fading. Things around your home keep changing; they are not what they appear to be. Find what is wrong, take pictures to restore your memory. Try to remember. Learn what you have forgotten, learn what has happened. It is not what it seems to be.

    Why similar: Surreal 17.4%, Psychological Horror 17%, Demons 15.8%, Horror 10.5%, Puzzle 10.2%

  6. #6 Left By Angels
    93% matchVery Positive87% of 134 reviews2025
    Dev: Street Art Studios
    Windows

    Based on the real Left By Angels Mansion! After your wife vanishes, a strange sighting draws you to an abandoned mansion. Trapped inside, haunted by the past, and hunted by truth, you must survive a looping nightmare where light is your only ally. She’s here—and she remembers everything.

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 23.8%, Demons 18.1%, Horror 16.7%, First-Person 12.2%, Realistic 7.5%

  7. #7 Rusty Lake Paradise
    94% matchOverwhelmingly Positive95% of 6,942 reviews2018
    Dev: Rusty Lake
    Windows · Mac
    Median: 4.1 hrsMean: 6.1 hrs≥1hr: 93%

    Rusty Lake Paradise is set on a small remote island which is cursed by the ten plagues of Egypt. Solve all the mysteries of this dark, macabre puzzle adventure. Paradise builds upon the distinctive atmosphere and excitement from the Rusty Lake series.

    Why similar: Point & Click 32.5%, Puzzle 21.7%, Psychological Horror 17.4%, Horror 8.4%, Surreal 8.2%

  8. #8 The Gray Man
    92% matchPositive86% of 28 reviews2023
    Dev: Richard Haraším
    Windows

    The Gray Man is a surreal first-person point-and-click adventure about a serial killer who confronts the player, as the murderer's conscience, with interpretations of his internal conflict.

    Why similar: Surreal 18.9%, Point & Click 18.8%, Psychological Horror 16.4%, Horror 8.6%, Puzzle 7.7%

  9. #9 Rusty Lake: Roots
    91% matchOverwhelmingly Positive97% of 8,536 reviews2016
    Dev: Rusty Lake
    Windows · Mac
    Median: 4.6 hrsMean: 6.5 hrs≥1hr: 92%

    Experience the beginning and end of characters' lives and build your own family tree! Rusty Lake: Roots is the second premium point-and-click adventure by the creators of the Cube Escape series and Rusty Lake Hotel.

    Why similar: Point & Click 27.9%, Puzzle 21.5%, Psychological Horror 19.4%, Horror 9.5%, Surreal 8.1%

  10. #10 The New Apartment
    90% matchMostly Positive74% of 76 reviews2025
    Dev: Paul Thomas Games
    Windows

    A man living in his new apartment finds himself in the center of something much more sinister.

    Why similar: Surreal 28.2%, Horror 18.2%, Puzzle 14.7%, First-Person 12.2%, Realistic 8.5%

  11. #11 I dream of you and ice cream
    91% matchVery Positive95% of 57 reviews2020
    Dev: Emilios Manolidis
    Windows

    A sinister creature has enslaved mankind. Solve puzzles, gather components for a machine you are building, find comfort in your dreams.

    Why similar: Point & Click 28.2%, Puzzle 16.8%, Psychological Horror 14.5%, Horror 9.8%, Pixel Graphics 9%

  12. #12 Drawn Tale
    89% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Sour Kingdom
    Windows

    After taking a life, a boy is killed and awakens in a twisted, nightmarish Purgatory. Explore a world of horror, solve eerie puzzles, evade lurking monsters, and fight to keep your soul intact before it’s devoured by the Void.

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 17.5%, Point & Click 15.1%, Surreal 13.8%, Demons 11.6%, Horror 9.8%

  13. #13 Mirrored Phantoms
    89% matchMixed68% of 212 reviews2025
    Dev: SMU Guildhall
    Windows · Linux

    Trapped in a nightmarish mannequin factory where reality itself is shattered, unravel the secrets of Mirrored Phantoms. Explore a deeply atmospheric world, solve the mystery of the mirror shards, and survive the terrors that await in this slow-burning, first-person horror experience.

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 25.3%, Horror 18.1%, First-Person 14.1%, Surreal 10.7%, Puzzle 8%

  14. #14 Wake Up: Liminal
    88% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: TheVladORPub: TheVladOR GDS
    Windows

    How far are you willing to go?

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 23.7%, Horror 16.2%, Surreal 14.2%, Demons 12.9%, Puzzle 8.4%

  15. #15 Phantoms
    87% matchMostly Positive72% of 43 reviews2023
    Dev: Solitude SoftwarePub: TheGamePublisher.com
    Windows

    "Phantoms" is a retro-styled first-person horror game that takes place on a strange train. Fix an electric box to escape from a level that is random every time... but you're not alone in here. And these "things" will do anything to stop you.

    Why similar: Demons 18.6%, Surreal 15.5%, Puzzle 13.6%, First-Person 12.8%, Horror 9.3%

  16. #16 Dreamstate
    86% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2024
    Dev: 8:95games
    Windows

    Dreamstate, can you survive your worst nightmare? In a point-and-click sit-and-survival psychological horror game, you fight off your nightmares throughout multiple nights to make it to the end of the week, with each night getting more challenging.

    Why similar: Point & Click 20.2%, Psychological Horror 16%, Demons 14.7%, Puzzle 11.1%, First-Person 10.5%

  17. #17 Cat Got Your Tongue
    86% matchMostly Positive78% of 32 reviews2024
    Dev: Dima Fyuriy
    Windows

    Cat Got Your Tongue is a horror point-and-click game where you have to escape from the Home Cat by exploring the darkest corners of the house.

    Why similar: Point & Click 24.7%, Psychological Horror 23.5%, Horror 16.1%, First-Person 11.9%, Puzzle 7.6%

  18. #18 Bite Size Terrors: Erobos Heaven
    85% matchVery Positive88% of 82 reviews2023
    Dev: anOVERTHINKER
    Windows

    Unsettling & Disturbing Events Quickly Rise After Being Saved By God.

    Why similar: Surreal 27.4%, Psychological Horror 22.9%, Horror 16.8%, Realistic 9.2%, First-Person 7.5%

  19. #19 Sterling Shroud
    84% matchPositive97% of 37 reviews2025
    Dev: Squid Snooze Studio
    Windows

    Sterling Shroud is a point-and-click atmospheric horror game with a focus on navigation and puzzle solving. Can you escape the forest alive?

    Why similar: Point & Click 25.2%, Psychological Horror 24.7%, Puzzle 14.2%, Horror 9.1%, Pixel Graphics 8.7%

  20. #20 The Paradixion: Exhibition
    83% matchPositive100% of 21 reviews2026
    Dev: GomPangGames
    Windows

    [The Paradixion: Exhibition] is a point-and-click adventure game with a mysterious atmosphere.Solve a variety of puzzles, uncover hidden details, and piece together clues to the story.With simple controls and no complex mechanics, anyone can jump in and play with ease.

    Why similar: Surreal 21.8%, Point & Click 19.9%, Psychological Horror 15.8%, Puzzle 13.5%, Horror 12.4%

  21. #21 LUDUS VETITUS
    82% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Bulderme
    Windows

    LUDUS VETITUS is a strategic point-and-click style horror game where you hide from a demon hunting you down while you search for candles. The candles are what you used to summon the demon and now it is used to banish it. Hide in closets and under beds to evade the demon, but don't let it see you!

    Why similar: Demons 22.5%, Point & Click 21.8%, Psychological Horror 20.7%, Horror 12.8%, Puzzle 8.2%

  22. #22 Fran Bow
    82% matchOverwhelmingly Positive97% of 21,826 reviews2015
    Dev: Killmonday Games AB
    Windows · Mac · Linux
    Median: 7.4 hrsMean: 10.3 hrs≥1hr: 91%

    Fran Bow is a creepy adventure game that tells the story of Fran, a young girl struggling with a mental disorder and an unfair destiny.

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 28.4%, Point & Click 24.4%, Puzzle 12.5%, Surreal 11%, Horror 11%

  23. #23 Mom Where Are You
    81% match2 user reviews50% of 2 reviews2025
    Dev: twins_creators_studio
    Windows

    "Mom, Where Are You?" is a psychological horror game that tests your observation, memory, and courage. You play as a little girl left alone by her mother, trapped in a familiar yet terrifying room where reality begins to twist.

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 25%, Point & Click 21.6%, Horror 13.3%, First-Person 9.6%, Puzzle 7.5%

  24. #24 The Charity Shop
    81% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Figglewatts
    Windows · Linux

    The Charity Shop is an atmospheric, surreal, first-person puzzle game where you use your camera to capture the essence of a life lived. To this end, you have been delivered to The Charity Shop, the place where people donate unwanted belongings—each carrying an imprint of the time they once shared.

    Why similar: Surreal 40.3%, Puzzle 16.5%, Horror 13.8%, First-Person 12.9%, Atmospheric 7.1%

  25. #25 Obscura Protocol
    80% matchNo user reviews2025
    Dev: OneTwoSecond
    Windows · Linux

    An "spot the difference" horror game inspired by "I'm on Observation Duty" by Notovia. Analyze, detect, and report anomalies using high-tech surveillance cameras. Utilize specialized tools like night vision and thermal vision to reveal hidden dangers.

    Why similar: Point & Click 24.3%, Surreal 18.5%, Psychological Horror 15.4%, Puzzle 14.6%, Horror 11.2%

  26. #26 Panelak
    78% matchVery Positive91% of 237 reviews2024
    Dev: Pajos games
    Windows

    Panelak is an old socialist-era building where strange things happen. Can you make it to the roof and help the helpless man?

    Why similar: Surreal 22.5%, Point & Click 19.7%, Psychological Horror 18.6%, First-Person 11.1%, Puzzle 9.3%

  27. #27 CoRoT
    78% matchMixed67% of 52 reviews2025
    Dev: Azteck Game Studios
    Windows

    CoRoT is a first-person psychological meta-horror game. Search for cassettes in a transforming house, unraveling its macabre past. A sinister atmosphere surrounds you as you try to understand what's happening and where you really are. Can you discover the truth hidden in its walls?

    Why similar: Surreal 24.6%, Psychological Horror 20.3%, Puzzle 11.1%, Horror 10.5%, Realistic 9%

  28. #28 Isolomus
    79% matchVery Positive95% of 397 reviews2020
    Dev: Michael Rfdshir
    Windows · Linux

    Bite-sized surreal horror with multiple choices. Make your own way through the claymation madness!

    Why similar: Surreal 26.2%, Psychological Horror 21%, Point & Click 18%, Puzzle 11.1%, Horror 10%

  29. #29 Quest room
    79% matchMostly Positive75% of 44 reviews2022
    Dev: Dusty Game
    Windows

    The quest room is a location from which you need to get out by interacting with objects and using various clues. But be careful, you are not alone in this room.

    Why similar: Surreal 20.5%, Demons 19.1%, Psychological Horror 17.9%, Horror 11.9%, First-Person 7.7%

  30. #30 20 Doors
    77% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2023
    Dev: Leeroy GysiPub: Malingoh Studios
    Windows

    20 Doors is an exploration, action and puzzle solving adventure where strange events and environments make you question your sanity.

    Why similar: Surreal 24.8%, Psychological Horror 19.5%, First-Person 12.1%, Horror 11.2%, Puzzle 10.9%

  31. #31 Endacopia
    76% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Andyland
    Windows · Mac

    Endacopia is a Point-and-Click Puzzle Adventure that is visually reminiscent of early computer edutainment games... with underlying horrors.

    Why similar: Surreal 22.1%, Point & Click 19.8%, Psychological Horror 16.8%, Puzzle 10.4%, Horror 9.9%

  32. #32 Game For Anna
    77% matchMostly Positive80% of 127 reviews2021
    Dev: Desert Fox
    Windows

    Hello Anna. I made a game for you. We can play together as we used to.

    Why similar: Surreal 21%, Point & Click 19.7%, Psychological Horror 17.1%, Horror 11.1%, First-Person 8.4%

  33. #33 THE LAST PORTRAIT
    75% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: LOCKDOWN Adventures
    Windows

    THE LAST PORTRAIT is a spooky adventure that takes you to the abandoned Ashwood Manor. You're on a mission to steal a supposedly cursed painting from the old villa. Solve the difficult puzzles that secure the house and escape the ghost that guards the property!

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 21.8%, Horror 15.5%, Puzzle 14.9%, First-Person 13.8%, Realistic 11.8%

  34. #34 Pony Island
    76% matchVery Positive95% of 17,910 reviews2016
    Dev: Daniel Mullins Games
    Windows · Mac · Linux
    Median: 3.0 hrsMean: 15.5 hrs≥1hr: 88%

    Pony Island is a suspense puzzle game in disguise. You are in limbo, trapped in a malevolent and malfunctioning arcade machine devised by the devil himself. It is not a game about ponies.

    Why similar: Hacking 24.5%, Psychological Horror 21.4%, Demons 15.5%, Puzzle 14.1%, Pixel Graphics 8.1%

  35. #35 Station 117
    75% matchMostly Positive79% of 24 reviews2022
    Dev: Glitch Games
    Windows · Mac

    In an undisclosed location, somewhere on the floor of the Pacific ocean, is Station 117 - a classified research facility doing totally secret work. What you discover will change everything.

    Why similar: Point & Click 35.1%, Puzzle 18%, First-Person 15.1%, Realistic 10.9%, Adventure 7.8%

  36. #36 just a dream
    74% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: akhsotoen
    Windows

    "just a dream" is a realistic first-person walking simulator in the style of a body-cam, presenting a psychological horror experience based on the aesthetics of liminal spaces.

    Why similar: Surreal 30%, Psychological Horror 26%, Realistic 13.9%, Horror 11.6%, 3D 6.5%

  37. #37 Go To Sleep
    73% matchPositive80% of 35 reviews2025
    Dev: YuRo Games
    Windows · Mac

    What began as a fun dream has turned into a waking nightmare. Now trapped in your room, you are stalked by a relentless demon. You must keep it at bay. Your only way through this nightmare? Close your eyes... and go to sleep.

    Why similar: Point & Click 20.5%, Surreal 19.3%, Psychological Horror 16.5%, Demons 12.1%, Horror 10.1%

  38. #38 Droste Detective
    73% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Figmenthol
    Windows

    You're stuck in an office corridor with no exit that has a framed picture of the same corridor on the wall. But then you notice the corridor in the picture is not quite the same. You decide to inspect the picture...

    Why similar: Surreal 27.6%, Psychological Horror 22.5%, Horror 14.5%, First-Person 12.4%, Realistic 7.2%

  39. #39 SnaPaul 2 : Anomalies
    72% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Maus
    Windows

    After a prank gone horribly wrong, you're ensnared in a nightmarish loop crafted by your own mother. As you delve into her twisted past, the boundaries between reality and madness blur. Unravel the sinister secrets and confront the malevolent forces that bind you.

    Why similar: Point & Click 18.2%, Psychological Horror 17.9%, Demons 14.5%, Horror 11.3%, First-Person 11.1%

  40. #40 Freedom's eye
    73% matchMixed61% of 23 reviews2022
    Dev: ColdBones
    Windows · Mac · Linux

    You have found yourself within this god forsaken prison. The people around you don't seem human... They don't look good or trustworthy... But you share the same goal, freedom.

    Why similar: Point & Click 20.3%, Surreal 19.5%, Psychological Horror 18.4%, Horror 11.2%, First-Person 8.3%

  41. #41 Decay: The Mare
    74% matchMostly Positive76% of 2,029 reviews2015
    Dev: Shining Gate SoftwarePub: Daedalic Entertainment
    Windows · Mac · Linux
    Median: 3.3 hrsMean: 20.7 hrs≥1hr: 87%

    Sam is an addict who ends up in an institution named “Reaching Dreams”, hoping to kick his drug problem and sort out his miserable life. But during the first night, something goes horribly wrong and he gets stuck in an endless nightmare…

    Why similar: Point & Click 33.4%, Psychological Horror 20.5%, Horror 20.5%, Puzzle 10%, Adventure 5.3%

  42. #42 The Hauntings: Dark Passenger
    71% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Broken Cuff Studio
    Windows

    Dive into Alex Mercer's twisted reality. Navigate eerie landscapes, solve cryptic puzzles, and uncover the 'Dark Passenger' mystery. Will shadows consume you or will truth emerge?

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 25.6%, Horror 17.6%, Puzzle 16.7%, First-Person 14.3%, Realistic 11.3%

  43. #43 Swaddle
    71% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: REVVALUTION Studio
    Windows

    You are a young intern in the maternity ward, and your job is to watch over the newborns on the second floor every night. But something very hungry wants to reach these children and devour them. Stop it immediately. Save the babies.

    Why similar: Demons 22.2%, Horror 15.1%, Psychological Horror 14.9%, Surreal 14.6%, First-Person 11.3%

  44. #44 Deprived
    71% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Burning Minds
    Windows

    “Trapped in a loop, you must capture anomalies and find the red door to escape the house. But beware... something else lurks within these walls. Can you break the cycle?”

    Why similar: Surreal 34.4%, Psychological Horror 28.8%, Horror 19.9%, First-Person 10.6%, 3D 4.9%

  45. #45 Untold Memories: Potter's Field
    69% matchMostly Positive76% of 34 reviews2026
    Dev: Huseyin OnurPub: Tyrosine Games
    Windows

    After a tragic accident, Mark struggles to recover, battling debt and deep psychological scars. One day, a mysterious job offer appears and seems like hope. As the night begins, everything changes. Is this his chance to start over, or his first step into the heart of darkness?

    Why similar: Surreal 19.9%, Psychological Horror 16.2%, Demons 16%, First-Person 10.6%, Horror 9.9%

  46. #46 Withered Haven
    69% matchPositive80% of 25 reviews2026
    Dev: Dark Snow Games
    Windows

    Withered Haven is a first-person psychological horror game. After the tragic loss of his wife and daughter, a broken man struggles to endure a collapsing reality. Familiar apparitions drift closer, echoing memories that mask a darkness beyond comprehension.

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 22.2%, Surreal 18.2%, Horror 14%, Realistic 11.4%, First-Person 10.8%

  47. #47 Lover
    70% match6 user reviews17% of 6 reviews2024
    Dev: Triple E Games
    Windows

    Lover is a first-person psychological horror game. Presented in a nostalgic and retro environment, player will uncover the cause of the illness through reincarnation and overcome psychological issues. Before darkness consumes your world, find those unspeakable secrets as you face shattered reality.

    Why similar: Surreal 20.7%, Psychological Horror 16.6%, Demons 13.4%, Puzzle 11.5%, First-Person 10.7%

  48. #48 Backrooms:The Exit
    70% match6 user reviews50% of 6 reviews2024
    Dev: XXE Games studio
    Windows

    Backrooms: The Exit is a single-player adventure game based on theme of backrooms.Inside the game you will need to avoid all threatening entities and find the cutscenes (exits) for each level, and perhaps many unexpected ways out of a level.

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 28.4%, Horror 19.7%, Surreal 17.9%, First-Person 11.6%, Puzzle 8.8%

  49. #49 The Lecture: Classroom 1.09
    69% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: Goat Tower Games
    Windows

    You are trying to reach classroom 1.09. Nobody is around, and the atmosphere feels wrong. Trapped in looping corridors, your only way out is to observe carefully, spot anomalies, and choose the right door… or remain trapped.

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 24.6%, Surreal 19.8%, Horror 12.5%, First-Person 12%, Puzzle 11.3%

  50. #50 Virtually Real Life
    72% match3 user reviews67% of 3 reviews2020
    Dev: Freedom Software
    Windows

    "Reality. A term concocted by creatures to give worth to their version of reality..." What happens if a 2D being is dragged into a 3D realm? Follow the "hero" through a world he/she barely understands and survive the demonic beings who brought our hero into this realm.

    Why similar: Demons 23.9%, Psychological Horror 22%, Surreal 20.7%, Horror 11.6%, Point & Click 7.7%

  51. #51 Ignis Dei
    67% matchPositive96% of 46 reviews2025
    Dev: Jam Bell Games
    Windows

    Heralded by a comet, seen as a harbinger of doom, the Black Death arrived in Florence in 1348. Wander through the woods to escape the plague, face various riddles and encounter mysterious creatures.

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 17.4%, Demons 14.4%, Horror 11.8%, Puzzle 11.6%, Surreal 10.3%

  52. #52 Office 8
    67% match9 user reviews89% of 9 reviews2026
    Dev: ChronoQuill
    Windows

    "Office 8" is a psychological walking simulator exploring the unsettling nature of liminal office spaces. Pay close attention — your sanity depends on it.

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 25.8%, Surreal 19.4%, Horror 12.9%, First-Person 12.3%, Puzzle 11.4%

  53. #53 Spamware
    68% match8 user reviews38% of 8 reviews2025
    Dev: Artificial Entertainment
    Windows · Mac · Linux

    You are sentenced to 30,000 hours in prison. Earn your freedom by identifying and reporting spam.

    Why similar: Surreal 22.2%, Point & Click 20.5%, Psychological Horror 15.2%, First-Person 12.1%, Puzzle 10.6%

  54. #54 Squeaky Clean
    70% matchMixed60% of 47 reviews2021
    Dev: Carrion Wave LLC
    Windows

    Psychological horror set in your favorite place: a nice hot shower.

    Why similar: Surreal 22.2%, Demons 18.6%, Psychological Horror 16.4%, Puzzle 9.7%, First-Person 9.2%

  55. #55 The Demon's Exorcism
    68% match4 user reviews75% of 4 reviews2024
    Dev: Snow Star Games
    Windows

    "The Demon's Exorcism" is a first-person psychological horror game that reveals the story of a family trapped in a haunting curse. Immerse yourself in the chilling narrative as you exorcise the demon and break the curse.

    Why similar: Demons 22.6%, Psychological Horror 21%, Horror 12.8%, Surreal 11.4%, First-Person 10.3%

  56. #56 Smiglee's Statues: The Cursed Curation
    67% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: WoollyOne Games
    Windows · Mac · Linux

    A short first-person narrative puzzle horror game about cataloging and restoring museum statues while uncovering unsettling inconsistencies.

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 21.8%, Surreal 15.6%, Horror 14.4%, First-Person 10.5%, Demons 10.3%

  57. #57 Gallery : Moa's Room
    68% match4 user reviews60% of 5 reviews2022
    Dev: Lee Geon Jae
    Windows

    Gallery: Moa's Room is a puzzle first-person single horror game. Wandering through the museum, you were trapped in a hidden room. You should find a way to escape the room by following some precautions prepared by the museum.

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 27.3%, Puzzle 22.8%, Horror 17.8%, Realistic 14.3%, 3D 11.1%

  58. #58 Night Fright
    67% matchMixed47% of 19 reviews2025
    Dev: HassaanAsif
    Windows

    Explore a haunting tale of a father, who driven by madness, tragically killed his daughter. Set in a bleak, atmospheric house, you experience the father's deteriorating mind.

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 24.4%, Demons 22.8%, First-Person 18.5%, Horror 15.7%, Realistic 12.9%

  59. #59 Hui-Shuo
    65% matchVery Positive93% of 68 reviews2025
    Dev: 时光茶馆TeaTimePub: 黎羽科技LICOGAME
    Windows

    Don't wait any longer, escape from school before night falls. This game is a point and touch horror decryption game with the theme of escape. Players will be transported into a fictional high school campus, unable to leave the teaching building restroom with rumors of strange stories on a dark day

    Why similar: Psychological Horror 23.3%, Surreal 18.8%, Horror 14.7%, First-Person 12.2%, Pixel Graphics 9.1%

Pony Island 2: Panda Circus cover art

Games Like Pony Island 2: Panda Circus

Based on tag similarity + player behavior
Loading graph...