- #1 GYLT
97% matchOverwhelmingly Positive95% of 1,230 reviews2023
Dev: Haven MediaPub: Parallel Circles
Windows
Median: 3.8 hrsMean: 5.7 hrs≥1hr: 68%
Shape your fears… Fear the shapes. Embark on a journey where you face your worst fears and are confronted with the emotional impact of your actions in this narrative adventure game with puzzles, stealth and action.
Why similar: Stealth 18%, Supernatural 17.3%, Horror 11.2%, Female Protagonist 8.8%, Mystery 8.7%
- #2 Ranger Danger
96% matchMostly Positive71% of 59 reviews2022
Dev: Reid Annin
Windows
A park ranger's life is changed forever as they discover what really lurks in their national park. A first-person horror, exploration, and stealth-based game.
Why similar: Supernatural 26.3%, Stealth 19.4%, Horror 16.9%, Atmospheric 8.8%, Nature 7.9%
- #3 I AM RIPPER
96% matchNo user reviews
Dev: White Paper Games
Windows
I AM RIPPER is a British Thriller set in the brutality and economic decline of the 1980's. You are a forensic investigator called on to solve one of the UK's most prolific crimes.
Why similar: Stealth 18.9%, Detective 14.8%, Interactive Fiction 13.5%, Multiple Endings 9.5%, Choices Matter 8.6%
- #4 Saraab: Beyond The Veil
95% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Rooted Elevation
Windows · Mac · Linux
A psychological horror visual novel about healing, where saving your brother means facing your own demons. Elham’s search forces her to confront haunting visions, buried family secrets, and dark entities. Will you help her embrace the light, or let her fall into the darkness?
Why similar: Supernatural 17.2%, Horror 10.9%, Emotional 10.9%, Multiple Endings 10.2%, Choices Matter 10.1%
- #5 Oxenfree
94% matchVery Positive91% of 12,063 reviews2016
Dev: Night School Studio
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 3.6 hrsMean: 5.3 hrs≥1hr: 88%
Oxenfree is a supernatural thriller about a group of friends who unwittingly open a ghostly rift. You are Alex, and you’ve just brought your new stepbrother Jonas to an overnight island party gone horribly wrong.
Why similar: Supernatural 25.5%, Story Rich 12.3%, Choices Matter 12.2%, Mystery 10.6%, Horror 9.2%
- #6 Victim Complex: Part 1
93% matchMostly Positive73% of 26 reviews2024
Dev: 5ive Bullet Games
Windows
Use your wits and iconic ghost hunting equipment to uncover the mystery of what happened to the residents of an abandoned apartment complex in this narrative-driven horror experience.
Why similar: Supernatural 23.6%, Interactive Fiction 16.2%, Horror 12.5%, Detective 11.6%, Mystery 10.9%
- #7 The Novelist
94% matchMostly Positive75% of 1,036 reviews2013
Dev: Orthogonal Games
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 1.9 hrsMean: 3.0 hrs≥1hr: 88%
The Novelist asks one central question: can you achieve your dreams without pushing away the people you love? The game focuses on Dan Kaplan, a novelist struggling to write the most important book of his career while trying to be the best husband and father he can be.
Why similar: Stealth 25.5%, Interactive Fiction 14.6%, Supernatural 11.6%, Choices Matter 10.7%, Multiple Endings 10.4%
- #8 Eclipsed Memories
92% matchNo user reviews
Dev: SheepGamesStudios
Windows
Every town is unique. Liddy's town has a lot of supernatural activity and it is her job to find and free entities stuck on our realm. Join her and her friends on their adventures, finding clues and ways to banish the creatures that shouldn't be here.
Why similar: Supernatural 29%, Interactive Fiction 13.7%, Horror 13.1%, Female Protagonist 9.5%, Emotional 8.9%
- #9 Dead Dreams
91% matchMostly Positive75% of 67 reviews2020
Dev: Aiaz Marx
Windows
"DEAD DREAMS" is a 2D psychological horror game focused on puzzle-solving and atmosphere with a complex non-linear story in which every element has a meaning...
Why similar: Supernatural 18%, Detective 13.8%, Horror 10.9%, Multiple Endings 9.4%, Mystery 9.2%
- #10 Cursed Mansion
91% matchVery Positive90% of 68 reviews2023
Dev: Dragon Emperors
Windows
Rose must escape the Cursed Mansion - a demonic space that preys and feeds on fear and despair. In this horror RPG you'll solve puzzles and learn the mansion’s history. Mystery, malignant spirits, and misery everywhere. Cursed Mansion brings an eerie atmosphere which leaves one with goosebumps.
Why similar: Supernatural 20.7%, Multiple Endings 12.5%, Horror 12.4%, Mystery 10.9%, Choices Matter 10.3%
- #11 Runway 66
90% matchPositive86% of 36 reviews2025
Dev: NEBULA NOVA GAMES
Windows
A weaponless psychological thriller. Become trapped in the dark simulation within Gabriel’s mind after surviving a deadly plane crash. Run, hide, and piece together your memories to wake from this dystopian nightmare before Protocol 66 is activated.
Why similar: Supernatural 19.2%, Detective 17%, Horror 12.3%, Interactive Fiction 11.2%, Emotional 8.6%
- #12 Kindred [High Tide]
89% matchPositive95% of 19 reviews2026
Dev: Victoria RafaelianPub: Captain Edge Studios
Windows
In this detective horror visual novel, investigate a seabound anomaly. Explore areas of interest, uncover clues, and piece together evidence before time runs out — and before this mission becomes your last. Choose a side; don't look back.
Why similar: Detective 18.7%, Interactive Fiction 13.9%, Supernatural 12.1%, Mystery 11.9%, Horror 11.5%
- #13 Paranoia Vol I
89% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Oh KAY Gamers
Windows
Fate is in your hands as you play Clark Turner, a man with a troubling past who now finds himself in a strange facility. He has no memory as to how or why he is there. Dive into this psychological narrative horror game driven with one single question – are you sure you are making the right choice?
Why similar: Supernatural 30.7%, Horror 13.9%, Stealth 12.1%, Multiple Endings 9.5%, Story Rich 8.7%
- #14 Out of Sight
87% matchVery Positive95% of 905 reviews2025
Dev: The Gang
Windows
Median: 3.5 hrsMean: 4.2 hrs≥1hr: 77%
You’re Sophie, a young blind girl who sees through her teddy bear’s eyes. Escape your captors and uncover the evil history of the dark mansion you desperately seek to escape in this unique, atmospheric horror puzzle/adventure game.
Why similar: Stealth 24.5%, Horror 12.5%, Female Protagonist 9.5%, Linear 8.2%, Emotional 7.4%
- #15 The Missing Parts of Maria Gwozdek
88% matchVery Positive96% of 136 reviews2023
Dev: Senokos Games
Windows · Linux
The Missing Parts of Maria Gwozdek is a dark fantasy visual novel about fulfilling your aspirations by sacrificing parts of yourself. Literally.
Why similar: Supernatural 22.5%, Multiple Endings 11.9%, Horror 9.8%, Mystery 9.3%, Female Protagonist 8.2%
- #16 Murdered: Soul Suspect
86% matchVery Positive86% of 17,211 reviews2014
Dev: Airtight GamesPub: Square Enix
Windows
Median: 4.4 hrsMean: 8.2 hrs≥1hr: 91%
MURDERED: SOUL SUSPECT™ takes players into a whole new realm of mystery where the case is personal and the clues just out of reach, challenging gamers to solve the hardest case of all… their own murder.
Why similar: Detective 30.8%, Supernatural 22.7%, Mystery 11.3%, Horror 10.8%, Stealth 6.2%
- #17 White Day 2: The Flower That Tells Lies - Complete Edition
86% matchMixed45% of 680 reviews2023
Dev: Rootnstudio Ltd.Pub: PQube
Windows
Return to Yeondu High School and uncover the dark truth that remained hidden in this direct sequel to the Korean horror classic. Investigate bizarre phenomena, evade bloodthirsty killers, and unravel a twisting narrative spread across three unnerving episodes.
Why similar: Stealth 20.1%, Supernatural 16.9%, Horror 10.2%, Multiple Endings 10%, Mystery 8.9%
- #18 Willow's Paper House
85% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Blooming Bats Studio
Windows · Mac · Linux
A dark fairytale point-and-click adventure game that follows 13-year-old Willow as she tries to escape a living hospital made of memories while searching for her lost brother.
Why similar: Supernatural 17.4%, Mystery 14%, Interactive Fiction 13.1%, Story Rich 9.6%, Multiple Endings 9.5%
- #19 Lone Pine
84% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Bang Bang Bang Interactive
Windows · Mac · Linux
Lone Pine is a single-player, 2D adventure set in the fictional Lone Pine National Park. You play as Izzie, who has come to Lone Pine to try to photograph some of its mysterious, undiscovered 'cryptids'.
Why similar: Supernatural 27%, Story Rich 9.7%, Female Protagonist 9.4%, Mystery 9.3%, Nature 8.9%
- #20 Cult of the sons
84% matchNo user reviews100% of 1 reviews2026
Dev: SIENTURE
Windows
In a remote manor house in England, a series of murders came to an abrupt end never solved, never explained.Every trace leads back to this place.Now you return. Not as a visitor, but as an investigator.
Why similar: Interactive Fiction 20.1%, Stealth 18.8%, Detective 15.6%, Horror 11.7%, Linear 9%
- #21 Tale of Serendipity
83% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Criminal Makers
Windows
Tale of serendipity is a third person survival horror with multiple endings, in which the search of your lost feline will make you question yourself the limits of reality and obsession When facing danger is not an option, the only thing left is survive.
Why similar: Stealth 22.7%, Interactive Fiction 12.7%, Mystery 12.6%, Horror 11.4%, Choices Matter 10.2%
- #22 Sabbatical In Merzouga
82% match1 user reviews0% of 1 reviews2025
Dev: Feeling Potion
Windows · Mac
You went to the desert to rest. You crushed a worm. Now it talks to you in dreams.
Why similar: Supernatural 21.4%, Interactive Fiction 15.4%, Multiple Endings 13.4%, Horror 12.3%, Choices Matter 10.8%
- #23 The Haunting of Joni Evers
81% matchVery Positive91% of 162 reviews2025
Dev: Causeway Studios
Windows · Mac
The Haunting of Joni Evers is a dark supernatural mystery about a broken family from small-town Oklahoma. Haunted by a specter that's hunted her family for generations, Joni must uncover the mysteries of the Cunningham House, dig through lost memories, and face the past to break the curse.
Why similar: Supernatural 21.7%, Interactive Fiction 13.9%, Mystery 11.2%, Emotional 9.8%, Linear 9.2%
- #24 Wendigo
82% matchPositive82% of 17 reviews2023
Dev: Noah Artime
Windows
A stealth horror game in the woods, investigate and progress while drawing as little attention to yourself as possible.
Why similar: Stealth 33.7%, Supernatural 22%, Horror 18.1%, Mystery 14.8%, Puzzle 3.8%
- #25 A Night at Ashmere Manor
81% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Bandaloop Games GmbH
Windows
When your father goes missing with little more than a letter to clue you in, it's up to you to find him. His last known whereabouts? Ashmere Manor. Will you succeed in solving the mystery at the heart of the house and find your father, or will you succumb to its phantom call?
Why similar: Supernatural 15.7%, Horror 12.6%, Interactive Fiction 12.3%, Multiple Endings 11%, Mystery 9.8%
- #26 Threads of Karma
79% matchMixed55% of 62 reviews2025
Dev: 萝卜不长毛线公司Pub: Hawthorn Games
Windows
Lin Yue'an embarks on a journey home, but unsettling events soon disrupt her ordinary life. Strange dreams, lost memories, and eerie occurrences lead her to uncover hidden truths. Can she trace everything back to its true origin and escape the net of fate that has already been woven around her?
Why similar: Supernatural 25.2%, Interactive Fiction 13.9%, Mystery 13.5%, Horror 12.6%, Emotional 8.8%
- #27 Bound Beyond
79% matchNo user reviews2027
Dev: Ananta Studio
Windows
A dark, mystical first-person adventure. Investigate the disappearance of a renowned archaeologist. Explore locations where shadows may hide a threat, and every sound can be your final mistake. Solve immersive puzzles and use sound, physics, and tools to survive before an ancient secret consumes you
Why similar: Stealth 25.2%, Horror 14.3%, Mystery 11.2%, Female Protagonist 10.8%, Story Rich 10%
- #28 Crimson Ranch
80% matchPositive82% of 33 reviews2020
Dev: Aiaz Marx
Windows
Classic 2D horror game about a lone roamer decides to retrieve a satanic book for mysterious Mr. Grey and face anthropomorphic demons in order to fulfill his childhood dream.
Why similar: Supernatural 17.3%, Horror 12.7%, Multiple Endings 11.9%, Linear 11.9%, Mystery 11.7%
- #29 Supernormal
78% matchMostly Positive73% of 1,164 reviews2024
Dev: Hitori de Productions
Windows
Median: 1.4 hrsMean: 1.7 hrs≥1hr: 63%
Inspired by Allison Road. SUPERNORMAL is a psychological horror game set in a seemingly ordinary apartment harboring dark secrets. Play as Detective Wyatt, tasked with unravelling the disappearance of Masato Sakamoto's daughter. Search for clues and unravel the sinister truth.
Why similar: Supernatural 21.4%, Stealth 14.9%, Detective 14.7%, Horror 11%, Mystery 9.6%
- #30 Chester
78% matchMostly Positive78% of 23 reviews2022
Dev: Daniel George
Windows
After a tragic accident, you find yourself trapped in a nightmare, and hunted by a monster. With your best friend Chester at your side, you'll have to stay alive, and find a way to wake up.
Why similar: Stealth 16%, Interactive Fiction 14.6%, Detective 13.8%, Supernatural 13.7%, Horror 9%
- #31 Antrabhara
77% matchVery Positive90% of 186 reviews2023
Dev: Nekoday
Windows
在人类与妖怪共存的世界中,三个身份迥异的少年少女在荒废古宅中相遇。结伴冒险的过程中收集道具、推敲讯息、解开谜题,逃离不可名状的生物,并揭开古宅家族背后的血色历史,最终发现“中阴”的秘密。
Why similar: Supernatural 20.7%, Interactive Fiction 20.7%, Detective 15.3%, Emotional 10.6%, Female Protagonist 10.2%
- #32 ABIDE
77% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Talha and Jack Co
Windows · Mac
ABIDE is a psychological first person horror game using prosthetic gore effects, stop motion and dolls scanned into 3D models. A peaceful retreat where people go to get better. A place for people to air their demons.
Why similar: Stealth 24%, Multiple Endings 11.8%, Horror 10.4%, Choices Matter 10%, Emotional 8.1%
- #33 The Case of Arcadia Springs
75% match4 user reviews80% of 4 reviews2026
Dev: K-20 Studios
Windows · Mac
A short, story-driven, detective-mystery game where you are tasked with solving a deceptively simple break-in case. Meet the citizens of Arcadia Springs, find and follow the clues, make the right choices, and you may unlock a dark secret kept under lock and key.
Why similar: Detective 27.2%, Interactive Fiction 15.2%, Story Rich 14.8%, Mystery 11.9%, Multiple Endings 8.7%
- #34 Poltergirl
76% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Robert Stephenson
Windows
Make your choice! Are you an ally or enemy of the monsters living right beneath your feet? Take control of a brother and ghostly sister to discover the mystery of your town, as well as life and death itself.
Why similar: Stealth 34.4%, Detective 15.8%, Choices Matter 15.2%, Multiple Endings 14.1%, Puzzle 6.2%
- #35 Gaung
76% match8 user reviews50% of 8 reviews2024
Dev: Berdua Studio
Windows
Experience the spine-chilling horror game where you explore the haunted depths of an ancient cave shrouded in mystery. As Rani, you will navigate cryptic puzzles, eerie spirits, and survive the supernatural to uncover dark secrets and escape with your life.
Why similar: Supernatural 28.1%, Horror 16.8%, Stealth 15.3%, Mystery 10%, Linear 8.7%
- #36 Peek A Doom
75% matchNo user reviews
Dev: ENIGMA STUDIO Sarl
Windows
Your teachers are monsters, the school is their hunting ground, and your sister is next. Explore Willby School in this first-person horror adventure, solve dangerous puzzles, and survive long enough to stop the cult’s ritual.
Why similar: Stealth 23.9%, Horror 19.6%, Story Rich 10.8%, Supernatural 10.8%, Adventure 6.6%
- #37 Screamboat Willie
74% matchMixed68% of 44 reviews2024
Dev: Platte ClarkPub: Neumont Game Studios
Windows
Do you LOVE Steamboat Willie? Great! He's in this game! Do you HATE Steamboat Willie? great! He's gross and scary and you are trying to dodge him and ultimately get away from him! So basically no matter what this game is for you!
Why similar: Stealth 30.3%, Horror 14.7%, Multiple Endings 12.9%, Mystery 12.1%, Atmospheric 8.2%
- #38 Woodside
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Paper Flower Games
Windows
Welcome to Woodside, a haunting survival horror adventure. Explore, investigate and survive as Grace, confronting supernatural terrors that plague a seemingly quaint British village. Experience dynamic horror as spirits react to the way you play. Can you find the truth before it's too late?
Why similar: Supernatural 30.1%, Detective 17.1%, Female Protagonist 11.5%, Mystery 10.8%, Horror 9.1%
- #39 Brood Year
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Wurm Fud
Windows
Stuck in a dead-end town with plans that go nowhere, Jackie feels as if her life is doomed to stagnancy forever. Getting by with her friends, she is resigned to her fate in a small town- until a chance encounter with a deadly life-form sets in motion a deadly chain of events
Why similar: Supernatural 17.8%, Interactive Fiction 13.7%, Detective 13.7%, Horror 11.9%, Multiple Endings 10%
- #40 Momo is Here
74% matchMostly Positive72% of 57 reviews2022
Dev: Laplace Games
Windows
The doors are locked, no one answers and definitely won't help. Your task is to get out and not let yourself be caught! Solve puzzles, escape from Momo's persecution and get out of this nightmare!
Why similar: Horror 22.3%, Supernatural 21.8%, Multiple Endings 18.3%, Atmospheric 8.9%, Linear 8.3%
- #41 The House of E.
73% matchVery Positive90% of 69 reviews2023
Dev: Gamenastica Studios
Windows
The House of E. is a story-driven puzzle game with horror elements and a creepy atmosphere.
Why similar: Supernatural 27.6%, Horror 15.8%, Mystery 13.8%, Multiple Endings 9.7%, Atmospheric 8.7%
- #42 The Hat Man
72% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Black Lantern Entertainment
Windows
A first-person psychological horror game inspired by The Hat Man urban legend, focusing on sleep paralysis, fear, and the terror of being unable to move.
Why similar: Supernatural 21.9%, Horror 17.7%, Interactive Fiction 12.1%, Mystery 10%, Atmospheric 9.2%
- #43 Where The Weather Takes You
71% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: FathomQuest Games
Windows · Linux
Elliot Thunder embarks on an adventure of self-discovery and exploration. Travel between towns, explore dungeons, solve puzzles, and use your weather-related powers to help those in need.
Why similar: Supernatural 21.6%, Mystery 12.2%, Emotional 12%, Multiple Endings 9.4%, Story Rich 9.2%
- #44 DARKROOM
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: LS
Windows
DARKROOM is a mystic novel. You wake up in complete darkness and you don’t know where you are or how you got there. Yet, there is someone else in this dark room.
Why similar: Supernatural 24.1%, Horror 18.4%, Interactive Fiction 14.7%, Mystery 10.7%, Choices Matter 9.1%
- #45 Lying Souls
72% matchMostly Positive73% of 11 reviews2022
Dev: Troxy Studios
Windows
Lying Souls is an atmospheric, mysterious single player story horror game. You'll dive into a story in which nothing is as it seems. Find out the reasons behind what happened to your family back then. Your decisions will guide the course of the story.
Why similar: Interactive Fiction 17.3%, Horror 13.9%, Linear 11.4%, Mystery 11.4%, Multiple Endings 7%
- #46 The Sleeping Sickness
71% match4 user reviews75% of 4 reviews2024
Dev: Paper Scrap LLC
Windows
The Sleeping Sickness is an interactive short story that allows the player to guide the main character's actions. The player’s choices will lock and unlock future locations, change dialogue, and alter the story. Choices matter in The Sleeping Sickness. It is an excellent choice for horror fans.
Why similar: Supernatural 15.5%, Interactive Fiction 12.2%, Detective 11.8%, Horror 11.7%, Mystery 9.9%
- #47 The Blackwood Legacy
70% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2024
Dev: Connor Elsworth
Windows
Step into the unsettling world of The Blackwood Legacy, a first-person puzzle horror game set in the eerie halls of Blackwood Manor. Solve intricate puzzles, unveil long-held secrets, and decipher the mystery surrounding your father's disappearance.
Why similar: Supernatural 32.3%, Interactive Fiction 17%, Mystery 16.8%, Detective 7.5%, Puzzle 6.3%
- #48 A Bad Christmas Story
69% matchPositive100% of 14 reviews2026
Dev: S&J Games
Windows · Mac
Christmas lights, winter snow, and a serial killer on the loose. Follow a gifted detective through a twisted holiday night in this story-driven, interactive horror game. Your choices determine who lives, and who dies. Can you outsmart the killer?
Why similar: Interactive Fiction 21.3%, Horror 19%, Detective 15.9%, Choices Matter 14.1%, Multiple Endings 13.6%
- #49 Mockbuster Video
70% matchNo user reviews
Dev: 0xp Games
Windows
A first-person psychological horror set in a late-night 1990s video rental store. As disturbing tapes begin to surface, reality distorts and your decisions shape how the night unfolds.
Why similar: Supernatural 27%, Horror 15.8%, Mystery 10.5%, Story Rich 10%, Multiple Endings 6.9%
- #50 Shade
70% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Kazira GamesPub: Judatone Studios
Windows
A top-down stealth immersive sim set inside fractured memories. Stay hidden, manipulate light and shadow, uncover story-rich mysteries, and make choices that shape the truth behind your death.
Why similar: Stealth 35.8%, Mystery 12.7%, Choices Matter 11.5%, Story Rich 10.1%, Multiple Endings 7.2%
- #51 WITHER
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: KemsynPub: Kemsyn Games
Windows
Wander the halls of an eerie 1920s mansion as haunting visions torment you and the line between reality and nightmare begins to blur. Step into the role of grieving widow Eleanor Hartfield and uncover the chilling truth behind your husband’s mysterious death.
Why similar: Supernatural 28.5%, Horror 18.6%, Mystery 16.7%, Atmospheric 8.9%, Female Protagonist 7.4%
- #52 Dreamwalker
69% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2023
Dev: JayzonBHPub: JayzonBH Games
Windows · Mac · Linux
A visual novel about a man who discovers the existence of another dimension hidden in dreams. Explore and learn the rules of a new reality, meet fellow dreamwalkers and solve the mystery of a disaster in the past. Make decisions, build relationships and strive to reach the best ending!
Why similar: Interactive Fiction 26.8%, Supernatural 22.2%, Choices Matter 15.3%, Mystery 11.8%, Story Rich 11.6%
- #53 NOITABIL
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Airgames
Windows
A first-person psychological horror game about identity and what you give up to keep going. You wake up somewhere you don't remember. You go through different rooms. Each one wants something from you. You make choices, and the game watches you back.
Why similar: Interactive Fiction 22%, Multiple Endings 9.9%, Choices Matter 9.4%, Supernatural 8.9%, Horror 7.6%
- #54 NIGHTGUARD : SCHOOLHUNT
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: LumenArcadia
Windows
In NightGard, you’re a night guard in a cursed school, where a deadly entity with a goat skull mask hunts after 2 AM. Uncover dark secrets, solve mystical puzzles, and escape the nightmare before it’s too late. Survival is your only chance.
Why similar: Stealth 22.6%, Supernatural 21.4%, Horror 13.3%, Mystery 12.6%, Atmospheric 9.2%
- #55 Evil Spirits
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: NVORON
Windows · Mac · Linux
Evil Spirits is a nonlinear psychological horror visual novel inspired by Slavic folklore. Uncover the secrets of a forgotten village, trust no one, and remember: true evil sometimes hides not in the shadows of a hut, but in the darkness of the human soul.
Why similar: Supernatural 20.2%, Interactive Fiction 15.7%, Horror 13%, Choices Matter 10.8%, Mystery 10%
- #56 Good Bones
67% matchMostly Positive76% of 34 reviews2023
Dev: RETCON Games
Windows · Mac · Linux
Your new house has old secrets in this haunting point-and-click mystery, where you'll search for clues about a mysterious death, solve narrative puzzles, and make heartbreaking choices to navigate amnesia, grief, and revenge.
Why similar: Supernatural 18.8%, Interactive Fiction 15.7%, Mystery 11.9%, Choices Matter 10.4%, Female Protagonist 9.4%
- #57 Goosebumps: Terror in Little Creek
66% matchPositive91% of 44 reviews2025
Dev: PHL CollectivePub: GameMill Entertainment
Windows
Enter the chilling world of Goosebumps in Goosebumps: Terror in Little Creek! Unravel eerie mysteries, confront sinister monsters, and navigate haunted locations inspired by R.L. Stine’s legendary books —all while experiencing the Goosebumps signature blend of spooky adventure and playful twists
Why similar: Stealth 22.9%, Horror 18.2%, Multiple Endings 15.6%, Choices Matter 14.1%, Mystery 8.9%
- #58 Whiteside
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Frosty Games Studios
Windows
"Reality is which, when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away" Whiteside is a first-person survival horror game. As an investigator of the Common European Asylum System, explore an island where they keep the mentally insane that are beyond help, uncover the truth, but don't believe everything.
Why similar: Stealth 28.9%, Horror 14.4%, Multiple Endings 11.7%, Linear 10.7%, Choices Matter 10.2%
- #59 Kamilia
67% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: RQ play
Windows · Mac
Kamilia is a story-driven, choices-matter detective mystery. Follow a talented painter who finds himself wrapped up in an unsolved case, as he tries to unveil a hidden truth that has been buried for years.
Why similar: Detective 15.4%, Mystery 14.2%, Interactive Fiction 13.1%, Choices Matter 11.4%, Emotional 11%