- #1 The Painscreek Killings
97% matchVery Positive91% of 6,246 reviews2017
Dev: EQ Studios
Windows
Median: 5.1 hrsMean: 6.4 hrs≥1hr: 88%
Investigate an infamous cold case in the eerie, abandoned town of Painscreek. Search for evidence, connect the dots and uncover who killed Vivian Roberts. Can you expose the truth behind this town’s dark secrets?
Why similar: Investigation 22.1%, Detective 17.7%, Supernatural 14.9%, Mystery 9.9%, Story Rich 5.7%
- #2 Incident Reports: Millers Residence
96% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Faint Signal Games
Windows
A late-night call sends you to the Millers Residence. What begins as a routine investigation turns into a descent through buried records, missing evidence, and a house arranged to hide something far worse.
Why similar: Investigation 19.1%, Supernatural 16.3%, Detective 13.5%, Psychological Horror 13.2%, Mystery 8.1%
- #3 Little Big Ghost Hunter
96% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Kipinami Studio
Windows
Your mission? PISS OFF GHOSTS! You're Momo, a reckless kid ghost hunter with janky gadgets and a camera that captures ghosts. Provoke spirits, survive their violent tantrums, expose their true form and capture them with a snapshot! But push too far, and your childhood ends here.
Why similar: Supernatural 20.4%, Investigation 19.4%, Detective 12.7%, Psychological Horror 10.3%, Female Protagonist 10.2%
- #4 Frequency of Fear : Chapter 1
95% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Sekoci
Windows
Play as Maya, an aspiring urban explorer, and unravel the truth behind every rumor and myth that haunts every dark corner. Traverse the shadows, survive the horrors, and keep your sanity intact as you uncover the secrets buried within.
Why similar: Supernatural 21.2%, Investigation 16.9%, Psychological Horror 12.1%, Female Protagonist 9.4%, Mystery 8.5%
- #5 Liar’s Line
94% matchNo user reviews
Dev: PexeliesPub: Aroko Game Studio
Windows
A monster is hiding behind one of the voices on the line. Identify the liar before you reveal your location. One wrong judgment, and it comes to your door. Each playthrough changes who's lying.
Why similar: Supernatural 20.1%, Detective 16.7%, Investigation 15.6%, Psychological Horror 11.7%, Mystery 8.5%
- #6 The Final Witness
94% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Gamalone
Windows
The Final Witness is a first-person psychological horror detective game where every case tells a different story. Explore a haunted family mansion, uncover hidden truths, analyze conflicting evidence, and identify the true killer before the darkness consumes your sanity.
Why similar: Detective 20.3%, Investigation 20.1%, Supernatural 16.6%, Psychological Horror 12.7%, Mystery 8.5%
- #7 SOMBRAS: negative frames
93% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Maboroshi ArtworksPub: Entalto Publishing
Windows
‘SOMBRAS: negative frames’ is a first person narrative game with a focus on photography and light horror elements. Follow Shiomi, a Japanese-Spanish photography student, as she is spirited away in a dark mirror of her 2000s Japanese town and must confront fragments of her own psyche.
Why similar: Supernatural 23.7%, Psychological Horror 16.2%, Female Protagonist 13.9%, Investigation 13.1%, Story Rich 7.4%
- #8 The Nightwal Legacy
92% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Quantum Division
Windows
A first-person supernatural thriller where you explore a manor overtaken by darkness. Wield a mysterious power to confront an ancient evil, unravel the truth, and save your brother.
Why similar: Supernatural 18.3%, Detective 15.3%, Investigation 13.1%, Psychological Horror 12.7%, Mystery 7.8%
- #9 Unwelcome Guest
91% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2025
Dev: BalNaurPub: BalNaur Horror Studio
Windows
You find yourself in a house that the owners have long since abandoned. But something lurks in the shadows, watching your every move. Explore the rooms, solve the mysteries, and find a way to banish the evil... Before it gets to you.
Why similar: Supernatural 23.3%, Investigation 16.7%, Psychological Horror 12%, Detective 11.1%, Thriller 8.8%
- #10 Curse of the Crimson Stag
91% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: ONE-O-ONE GAMESPub: Daedalic Entertainment
Windows
Curse of the Crimson Stag is a story-driven mystery thriller in which you explore a blurred line between supernatural occurrences and past tragedy. Uncover what led to the abandoning of the once luxurious Whiteroot Hotel. Local myth tells of a wrathful spirit known as the Crimson Stag…
Why similar: Investigation 27.5%, Supernatural 16.5%, Psychological Horror 13.1%, Thriller 7.5%, Story Rich 6.7%
- #11 Reaplaced
90% matchVery Positive91% of 56 reviews2023
Dev: Mystery Gamedev
Windows · Mac · Linux
A supernatural Halloween whodunnit. Solve a chilling locked-room mystery before the grim reaper reveals the answer!
Why similar: Detective 19.1%, Supernatural 13.6%, Investigation 13.4%, Psychological Horror 12.4%, Female Protagonist 12.2%
- #12 Bad Omens: 8th Apartment
89% matchVery Positive89% of 74 reviews2024
Dev: Neon Flamingo Games
Windows
You play as a student named Lisa, who has just moved in with her university friend. But instead of a carefree student life, Lisa faces events full of despair and fear when she is left alone in her apartment number 8...
Why similar: Supernatural 16.5%, Psychological Horror 14.4%, Investigation 12.6%, Female Protagonist 9.5%, Mystery 8.4%
- #13 Utter a Name
89% matchVery Positive90% of 227 reviews2025
Dev: evilalbert
Windows · Mac · Linux
Disembodied souls linger in this old estate. To each one, utter their name.
Why similar: Detective 20.1%, Investigation 20.1%, Supernatural 19.8%, Female Protagonist 10.8%, Mystery 10%
- #14 UFOPHILIA
88% matchMostly Positive73% of 91 reviews2026
Dev: k148 Game StudioPub: JanduSoft
Windows
UFOPHILIA is a first-person psychological horror game where you explore areas marked by alien phenomena. Use specialized equipment to detect, identify, and photograph aliens—but do so at your own risk... They are watching you too.
Why similar: Supernatural 26.5%, Investigation 19.2%, Psychological Horror 15%, Detective 13.7%, Horror 9.1%
- #15 Two Sisters
87% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Bad Room Studio
Windows
Witness the obscure scenario of a massacre, in the shoes of the photographer Bárbara, who received an unusual proposal: To photograph a village with bizarre secrets from decades ago.
Why similar: Supernatural 20.8%, Investigation 20.6%, Female Protagonist 12.3%, Psychological Horror 10.8%, Mystery 9.4%
- #16 LATHOS
86% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Vylon X Games
Windows
A teacher wakes to an empty lecture hall where time stands still. Each loop reveals fragments of truth through questions, memories, and whispers of the past. The only way out is to remember what should have never been forgotten.
Why similar: Supernatural 20.3%, Investigation 19.1%, Detective 19.1%, Psychological Horror 11.3%, Thriller 7.6%
- #17 Empty Village (Part 1)
85% matchPositive90% of 20 reviews2026
Dev: 트리니티 소프트웨어Pub: PASSWORLD
Windows · Mac
"Loved by Korean streamers and gamers alike, this hit K-horror visual novel officially launches in the U.S. on Summer"
Why similar: Supernatural 21%, Investigation 19.3%, Psychological Horror 15.3%, Female Protagonist 14.2%, Horror 9.1%
- #18 Supernormal
86% matchMostly Positive73% of 1,216 reviews2024
Dev: Hitori de Productions
Windows
Median: 1.5 hrsMean: 1.8 hrs≥1hr: 64%
Inspired by Allison Road. SUPERNORMAL is a psychological horror game set in a seemingly ordinary apartment harboring dark secrets. Play as Detective Wyatt, tasked with unravelling the disappearance of Masato Sakamoto's daughter. Search for clues and unravel the sinister truth.
Why similar: Supernatural 20.8%, Investigation 15.9%, Detective 15.6%, Psychological Horror 11.3%, Mystery 7.9%
- #19 Scaredy Cat
84% matchNo user reviews
Dev: aeio
Windows · Mac
Henny has been worn to the bone by a soul-sucking corporate career that has gifted her with heart problems. After she rage quits and starts pet sitting, she discovers her new gig will be just as horrifying as her last.
Why similar: Investigation 18.8%, Supernatural 18.6%, Detective 12.1%, Female Protagonist 11.3%, Mystery 8.6%
- #20 Casting Whispers
84% matchPositive90% of 41 reviews2025
Dev: Lantern Bay Entertainment
Windows
Sound is your only hope for survival in this first-person psychological horror game. Investigate the mysteries of an apartment block in 1960s America terrorized by a cosmic horror, as you try to save your lost mentor… and yourself.
Why similar: Supernatural 20.2%, Investigation 19.2%, Psychological Horror 12.4%, Female Protagonist 10.6%, Mystery 8.2%
- #21 The Occultist
82% matchMostly Positive76% of 357 reviews2026
Dev: DALOARPub: Daedalic Entertainment
Windows
The Occultist is a first-person narrative thriller. You play as Alan Rebels, a paranormal investigator who travels to an abandoned British island after his father's disappearance. Explore Godstone island, face supernatural entities, and uncover long-buried occult rituals.
Why similar: Investigation 24.4%, Detective 21.6%, Supernatural 16.1%, Psychological Horror 9.8%, Mystery 6.8%
- #22 WITHER
83% matchNo user reviews
Dev: KemsynPub: Kemsyn Games
Windows
Wander the halls of an eerie 1920s mansion as haunting visions torment you and the line between reality and nightmare begins to blur. Step into the role of grieving widow Eleanor Hartfield and uncover the chilling truth behind your husband’s mysterious death.
Why similar: Supernatural 26.9%, Mystery 13.5%, Horror 10.5%, Female Protagonist 9.2%, Psychological Horror 8.3%
- #23 HAUNTED STREAMER -呪われた配信者-
82% matchNo user reviews
Dev: PrankMaker
Windows
Stream Japan's most haunted ruins — in a horse mask. Film every ghost you meet: the closer you get, the more views you earn, and the less of your mind you keep.
Why similar: Supernatural 22.4%, Investigation 20.8%, Psychological Horror 12.9%, Mystery 8.9%, Horror 7.5%
- #24 Gaze of Dread
81% matchPositive100% of 41 reviews2025
Dev: Just Sauce Studio
Windows
Mary Thorne retreats to Valley View Escape to focus on her project while waiting for her friend Carly. What begins as a calm week starts to feel… off.
Why similar: Supernatural 22.8%, Investigation 20.7%, Psychological Horror 9.8%, Mystery 8.6%, Thriller 8.5%
- #25 Shroud of Gloom
81% matchNo user reviews
Dev: MadChirpy
Windows
Shroud of Gloom is a point-and-click horror adventure. Investigate an old manor, gather items and clues to solve environmental puzzles and discover dark secrets. Can you uncover the mystery… and make it out alive?
Why similar: Detective 15.6%, Investigation 15.2%, Supernatural 13.4%, Psychological Horror 12.2%, Mystery 9.8%
- #26 Conrad Stevenson's Paranormal P.I.
80% matchVery Positive93% of 984 reviews2023
Dev: D&A Studios
Windows
Median: 2.6 hrsMean: 10.2 hrs≥1hr: 71%
I made this first-person single player ghost hunting simulation game, trying to take an authentic approach at investigating ghosts. Use essential paranormal tools to help your community alleviate their concerns and put their minds at ease.
Why similar: Supernatural 23%, Investigation 18.6%, Detective 15.1%, Psychological Horror 12.6%, Thriller 7.7%
- #27 CLeM
79% matchVery Positive91% of 295 reviews2024
Dev: Mango ProtocolPub: Iceberg Interactive
Windows
Median: 3.5 hrsMean: 4.2 hrs≥1hr: 93%
CLeM is a narrative-driven puzzle adventure game with a dark twist. Wake up in a world where puzzles intertwine with exploration, weaving a unique narrative rooted in alchemy. A voice awakens you. It gives you purpose. To guide you, you find a notebook with mysterious entries and a house to explore.
Why similar: Supernatural 16.2%, Investigation 15.6%, Detective 12.2%, Psychological Horror 11%, Female Protagonist 10.7%
- #28 Herald of Moira
79% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Icelot Project
Windows
Explore the region of Rosevale, craft potions through alchemy, lead an investigation against five suspects, and uncover the truth behind a massacre in this semi-open world gothic fantasy RPG.
Why similar: Supernatural 18.6%, Investigation 17.1%, Detective 14.8%, Psychological Horror 10.3%, Female Protagonist 9.5%
- #29 Phobic Nightmares
77% matchMostly Positive79% of 19 reviews2025
Dev: ClusterFame Games
Windows · Linux
Phobic Nightmares is a psychological horror game where you experience nightmarish realities to uncover what happened to your sister. Find notes from your sister and use the sacrifices of those who came before you to uncover what’s hidden and avoid ending up like them.
Why similar: Supernatural 28.4%, Psychological Horror 16.1%, Investigation 13.5%, Horror 9.6%, Detective 8.6%
- #30 We Are Alive
78% matchMixed53% of 17 reviews2024
Dev: Faceless Bear Games
Windows
We Are Alive is a Co-Op horror game, that can be played with at least 1 and up to 4 players. You are a detective and your mission is to investigate the old psychiatric hospital and find out the truth. Your standard equipment is a flashlight and a gun.
Why similar: Supernatural 24.7%, Investigation 16.9%, Detective 16.9%, Psychological Horror 13.7%, Mystery 8.4%
- #31 HouseWarming
76% matchVery Positive83% of 65 reviews2026
Dev: Neskorobok GamesPub: Setone Games
Windows
Brian Lewis buys an old house, hoping for a quiet and orderly life. But on the very first night, the house begins to behave strangely... What starts as a harmless incident slowly turns into something far more terrifying... What if someone else is inside?
Why similar: Supernatural 20%, Investigation 15.6%, Psychological Horror 15.6%, Detective 14.4%, Horror 8.9%
- #32 Bump in the Night
77% matchPositive100% of 24 reviews2024
Dev: ElzolabsPub: Elzolabs
Windows
Bump in the Night is a single player game where strategy meets psychological horror. Confined to one room, you'll use cameras and commands to direct NPC investigators and collect evidence. Each environment offers unique challenges and frights. Can you survive what goes bump in the night?
Why similar: Supernatural 28%, Investigation 22.7%, Psychological Horror 14.2%, Horror 7.2%, Detective 6.7%
- #33 Sherlock Holmes The Awakened
76% matchVery Positive82% of 2,952 reviews2023
Dev: Frogwares
Windows
Median: 3.7 hrsMean: 8.6 hrs≥1hr: 81%
Experience a nerve-racking Lovecraftian adventure, rebuilt from the ground up with modern graphics and gameplay. Become Sherlock Holmes, and find yourself at the heart of the terrifying Cthulhu Mythos as you investigate a series of mysterious disappearances in Europe and the US.
Why similar: Detective 20.2%, Investigation 16.2%, Supernatural 15.1%, Psychological Horror 10.8%, Mystery 9.6%
- #34 Fragmented Memories - Arc One
78% matchPositive86% of 21 reviews2022
Dev: PlatomentiPub: YSY Softworks
Windows · Mac
Immerse yourself in the Psychological horror adventure of James Charouz on his way to find his missing wife and uncover the dark secret of his hometown.
Why similar: Investigation 19.4%, Psychological Horror 13.5%, Detective 12.6%, Supernatural 10.3%, Mystery 9.7%
- #35 Deadly Match
75% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Belba Games PTY LTD
Windows
Deadly Match is a single‑player third‑person murder mystery. Investigate the deaths of two young women in a small, seemingly peaceful town.
Why similar: Detective 31.4%, Supernatural 16.5%, Female Protagonist 16.4%, Mystery 13.9%, Story Rich 10.5%
- #36 BrokenLore: LOW
74% matchMostly Positive76% of 509 reviews2025
Dev: Serafini Productions
Windows
Median: 1.6 hrsMean: 2.6 hrs≥1hr: 82%
BrokenLore: LOW is a psychological horror game set in a mist-covered, beautiful Japanese village, blending hyper-realistic graphics with low-poly elements. The main enemy is the Gashadokuro, a yokai from Japanese folklore.
Why similar: Female Protagonist 17.2%, Investigation 16.2%, Psychological Horror 16%, Supernatural 9.1%, Horror 8.9%
- #37 Mockbuster Video
75% matchNo user reviews
Dev: 0XP Game Studios
Windows
A first-person psychological horror set in a late-night 1990s video rental store. As disturbing tapes begin to surface, reality distorts and your decisions shape how the night unfolds.
Why similar: Supernatural 26.7%, Psychological Horror 19.6%, Horror 9.4%, Mystery 8.9%, Thriller 8.8%
- #38 Shadow Mansion 2
74% matchPositive84% of 25 reviews2025
Dev: NEBULA NOVA GAMES
Windows
The mansion your grandfather left you is more than an inheritance. When the power comes on, not only the lights awaken, but the darkness buried inside. Shadow Mansion 2 is a first-person psychological horror focused on atmosphere, exploration, and stealth.
Why similar: Detective 22.1%, Investigation 18.7%, Supernatural 12.1%, Thriller 10.4%, Psychological Horror 9.3%
- #39 We need a doorman.
73% matchPositive86% of 22 reviews2026
Dev: Broken Toilet Games
Windows
You are the hotel doorman and a demon hunter. Check each guest, and if you find an anomaly, exorcise it without hesitation. After guarding the hotel for 10 days, you will face him on the final day.
Why similar: Supernatural 23.2%, Investigation 21.3%, Detective 14.1%, Psychological Horror 13.6%, Horror 7.9%
- #40 Sisters of Solitude
73% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: nanonimo
Windows
Explore a haunted convent with your EMF detector, tape recorder, and camera. Uncover the fate of four ghostly sisters and the mystery behind the murder they commited. Every room hides a clue, every shadow a warning, and the truth waits for those who dare to seek it.
Why similar: Investigation 22.6%, Detective 22.2%, Supernatural 19.4%, Psychological Horror 17%, Exploration 6%
- #41 The Haunting of Joni Evers
73% matchVery Positive90% of 168 reviews2025
Dev: Causeway Studios
Windows · Mac
The Haunting of Joni Evers is a dark supernatural mystery about a broken family from small-town Oklahoma. Haunted by a specter that's hunted her family for generations, Joni must uncover the mysteries of the Cunningham House, dig through lost memories, and face the past to break the curse.
Why similar: Supernatural 22.7%, Investigation 19.8%, Female Protagonist 12.2%, Psychological Horror 11.8%, Mystery 10%
- #42 Dread Neighbor
70% matchVery Positive83% of 591 reviews2026
Dev: GhostcasePub: Erabit
Windows
Dread Neighbor is a first-person, multi-perspective psychological horror game. Play as a young woman living alone in an unusually cheap apartment. As the days pass, combat the overwhelming sense of unease, malice, and the unshakable feeling that you’re being watched from every crack in the room.
Why similar: Supernatural 23.9%, Psychological Horror 14.3%, Investigation 14.3%, Female Protagonist 13%, Thriller 8.3%
- #43 Abnormality
72% matchMostly Positive74% of 307 reviews2024
Dev: Nightmare Studios
Windows
Explore haunted locations, collect paranormal evidence, and survive the revenge of the former residents still haunting them. Team up with up to 3 friends to figure out the ghost, however, what begins as an investigation quickly turns into a desperate struggle to stay alive.
Why similar: Supernatural 26.3%, Investigation 19.3%, Psychological Horror 14.3%, Detective 10.4%, Horror 8.2%
- #44 Victim Complex: Part 1
72% matchMostly Positive74% of 27 reviews2024
Dev: 5ive Bullet Games
Windows
Use your wits and iconic ghost hunting equipment to uncover the mystery of what happened to the residents of an abandoned apartment complex in this narrative-driven horror experience.
Why similar: Supernatural 26.5%, Investigation 16.2%, Detective 14.3%, Psychological Horror 11.9%, Mystery 10.4%
- #45 污水危机:起源 Sewage Crisis: Origins
71% matchMostly Negative30% of 10 reviews2025
Dev: 水淼水
Windows
Sewage Crisis: Origins is a first person horror game adapted from human experiments, which exposes the truth behind human experiments buried in hospitals through a terrifying supernatural event.
Why similar: Supernatural 26.9%, Investigation 25.4%, Psychological Horror 12.4%, Thriller 11.7%, Horror 9.3%
- #46 NightFall Hollow
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Lee HallPub: Deadlyspud Productions
Windows
Investigate the strange town of Nightfall Hollow, and see if you can get to the truth. Enjoy the opening chapter of our game, meet some of the residents, solve a selection of puzzles, and have your first glimpse into Nightfall Hollow. There's plenty to discover, and the odd Easter-egg or two as well
Why similar: Supernatural 28%, Investigation 21.7%, Psychological Horror 15.3%, Mystery 9.7%, Horror 8.4%
- #47 Local Opera
71% matchMostly Negative33% of 12 reviews2024
Dev: Dreamy_Chat
Windows
Welcome to the mysterious village of "Folk Show"! This is a domestic plot-oriented micro-horror game that will take you into a rural story full of suspense and thriller.
Why similar: Investigation 20.2%, Detective 19%, Psychological Horror 16.5%, Mystery 12.3%, Thriller 10.1%
- #48 Victor's Video Vault
70% matchNo user reviews2027
Dev: Stingbot Games
Windows
It's 1995. The video store is alive. When the last customer leaves, the final rental rewrites reality.
Why similar: Supernatural 21.3%, Investigation 21.2%, Psychological Horror 18.1%, Mystery 11.5%, Horror 10.9%
- #49 The Gretlow Tapes
69% matchVery Positive92% of 123 reviews2025
Dev: Aegon Games
Windows
Armed with nothing but your camera, investigate the abandoned Gretlow House in this short, atmospheric horror game. Uncover a chilling mystery through a realistic found-footage lens.
Why similar: Supernatural 27%, Investigation 18%, Psychological Horror 15.8%, Horror 8.8%, Mystery 7.6%
- #50 Rubbings
69% matchVery Positive89% of 253 reviews2025
Dev: 午夜说书人
Windows
《诡拓》是一款中式民俗微恐风的悬疑推理游戏。你将扮演一名民俗杂志编辑,根据匿名信件中的拓片线索,深入封闭、神秘的睖睁村,这里多年来流传着失踪旅人和诡异祭祀的传说。通过亲历村志中的诡异故事,并在村庄中展开调查,你将逐步揭开埋藏数十年的真相。
Why similar: Detective 15.5%, Supernatural 15.5%, Investigation 15.3%, Psychological Horror 10.8%, Mystery 7.5%
- #51 System Says Normal
70% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: KovalGames
Windows · Mac
You were hired to watch. Not to ask questions. Night shift. Corporate building. Cameras, reports, anomalies. Your predecessor left no final report. Now you're going to find out why. Please proceed.
Why similar: Investigation 17.4%, Supernatural 15.4%, Psychological Horror 14.2%, Detective 12.5%, Mystery 8.7%
- #52 Shadowed Halls
69% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Vidribute
Windows
Survive in a haunted colonial mansion in Bengal. Complete daily chores to keep order by day, then face supernatural anomalies at night. Explore, uncover secrets, and fight for your sanity in this first-person survival horror experience.
Why similar: Investigation 20.7%, Supernatural 16.7%, Detective 15.2%, Psychological Horror 15%, Horror 8.9%
- #53 Clown House: Lunacy
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Aslan Game StudioPub: (TBA)
Windows · Mac
A narrative horror experience where violence is a trap. Unravel the secrets of a derelict mansion and its uncanny clown residents. Solve puzzles. Observe the clowns, deduct their needs and what angers them to survive. And never harm the residents of the Clown House. It has eyes.
Why similar: Investigation 19%, Supernatural 18.1%, Psychological Horror 13%, Female Protagonist 10.1%, Mystery 9.6%
- #54 Rudravati: Curse of Bhankilla
67% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: LeZit Games
Windows
A first-person supernatural horror inspired by the legends of Bhangarh Fort. Explore India’s most haunted place, uncover your brother’s disappearance, and survive the ancient curse that still haunts the ruins.
Why similar: Supernatural 34.4%, Psychological Horror 15.8%, Horror 9.2%, Lore-Rich 8.9%, Story Rich 7.3%
- #55 Who Am I
67% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: PantsSmell
Windows
Lost in amnesia, face a horrific past rising from nightmares. Uncover the truth hidden in a diary. In this psychological horror where reality and hallucination blur, piece together memories before madness consumes you. When the truth is out, ask yourself: Who was I?
Why similar: Supernatural 24.2%, Investigation 14.2%, Psychological Horror 13.9%, Mystery 9.3%, Horror 8.2%
- #56 The Game Maker: A Carol Reed Mystery
67% match8 user reviews88% of 8 reviews2025
Dev: MDNA Games
Windows
Follow detective Carol Reed in this colorful mystery, made with real-life photographs. The game features a classic adventure game interface, plenty of puzzles, and a series of minigames as an integrated part of the story.
Why similar: Detective 26.6%, Investigation 25.5%, Mystery 12.9%, Female Protagonist 11.4%, Adventure 7.4%
- #57 Tapes of Fear: Smile
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Infinity Green Game Studio
Windows
A first-person psychological horror that evolves based on your behavior. Uncover the atrocities within this mansion as you struggle to hold onto your sanity. Something is stirring inside the walls. If you hear eerie laughter, run as fast as you can. You are not safe
Why similar: Supernatural 19.6%, Investigation 17.9%, Psychological Horror 14.5%, Mystery 9.3%, Thriller 8.2%
- #58 Dead Exposure
66% match2 user reviews0% of 2 reviews2026
Dev: Rotwired Studios
Windows
Use an instant camera to reveal hidden realities and shape the house itself. Not everything stays where it belongs.
Why similar: Supernatural 29.3%, Investigation 22.5%, Psychological Horror 16.8%, Horror 10.2%, Mystery 6.2%
- #59 Haunted Record
66% matchPositive97% of 37 reviews2024
Dev: Heathersward
Windows
A 20 minute story about a mysterious ghost and an even more mysterious journalist.
Why similar: Supernatural 27.7%, Investigation 26.6%, Female Protagonist 14.7%, Mystery 12%, Exploration 5.2%