Games Like Tomato Way

Known for deep frying his victims, Potato Man is the most notorious serial killer out there...

Why similar: Illuminati 35.8% ★, Psychological Horror 25.2%, Horror 17.1%, Adventure 7%, Action 6.8%

Why You'll Like It: Developed by the same creator, this game shares the exact same brand of bizarre, meme-centric, and surreal horror.

Tomato Way is the only way.

Why similar: Blood 44.1% ★, Gore 22.1%, Horror 13.3%, Action 5.5%, Adventure 5.3%

Why You'll Like It: The direct sequel continues the absurd, gore-filled, and surreal journey of the original.

Tomato Way is the only way.

Why similar: Horror 35.7%, Psychological Horror 29%, Action 14.2%, Adventure 14.2%, FPS 2.1%

Why You'll Like It: The third installment expands on the franchise's signature blend of action, horror, and bizarre character-driven moments.

An immersive power fantasy simulator with tactical stealth elements set in a sewage infused garbage world

Why similar: Psychological Horror 75.6%, Action 11.8%, Psychedelic 6.5%, FPS 4.2%, First-Person 1.8%

Why You'll Like It: This game is the pinnacle of surreal, janky, and intentionally disturbing FPS design that mirrors the chaotic energy of Tomato Way.

This Strange Realm Of Mine is a First Person Shooter mixed with poetry and psychological horror. Graphic style is 3D mixed with pixel art.

Why similar: Blood 38.9% ★, Gore 19.5%, Psychological Horror 17.8%, Horror 12.3%, Action 3%

Why You'll Like It: It combines surreal psychological horror with FPS mechanics and a unique, philosophical, and unsettling narrative.

Putrefaction is a First Person Shooter with horror elements, lots of enemies and weapons, heavily inspired by old-school shooter classics.

Why similar: Blood 33.3% ★, Gore 28.4%, Horror 19%, Action 9.7%, Indie 5.5%

Why You'll Like It: A gritty and janky indie FPS that leans heavily into horror and gore elements similar to the seed game.

Gorytale is a fast-paced, adrenaline-rushed FPS shooter set in a candy land, that is so damn sweet it could be called someone’s Hell

Why similar: Blood 35.7% ★, Gore 34.5%, Psychological Horror 8.4%, Action 7.4%, Indie 6.9%

Why You'll Like It: Focuses on the same visceral gore and indie-horror aesthetic found in the seed game.

The world's most advanced soda drinking simulator.

Why similar: Illuminati 56.7% ★, Psychological Horror 28.2%, Horror 5.7%, Action 5.1%, Memes 1.8%

Why You'll Like It: An intentionally bizarre and surreal simulation game that shares the same 'meme-game' DNA as Tomato Way.

In Bitardia you will experience all the rules of the Internet in action, and venture on a journey in the spirit of classic low-budget shooters, making your way through the obstacles of the fantastic world of an imageboard.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 29.3%, Gore 22.2%, Horror 17.7%, Adventure 8.7%, Action 8%

Why You'll Like It: A bizarre, meme-heavy adventure that captures the same internet-culture-infused psychological horror vibe.

The game is a cheerful shooter with a user-friendly gameplay in an original setting.

Why similar: Action 70.2%, Psychological Horror 17.6%, Indie 12.1%

Why You'll Like It: An action-heavy indie horror title that prioritizes gore and psychological tension in a first-person perspective.

Live a week in the life of "The POSTAL Dude"; a hapless everyman just trying to check off some chores. Buying milk, returning an overdue library book, getting Gary Coleman's autograph, what could possibly go wrong?

Why similar: Gore 68.4%, Action 10.7%, Adventure 8.2%, Singleplayer 5.4%, Comedy 3.2%

Why You'll Like It: A classic for fans of janky, violent, and meme-filled first-person shooters that don't take themselves too seriously.

Smuggle contraband VHS tapes across the border. Discover the remnants of illicit industry. Prepare for an assassination. This is Paratopic, an atmospheric retro-3D horror adventure through a cursed fever dream.

Why similar: Horror 41.8%, Psychological Horror 30.1%, Indie 13.1%, Adventure 11.9%, Singleplayer 1.6%

Why You'll Like It: This low-poly horror game delivers a deeply disturbing and surreal experience that feels like a fever dream.

Only You Can Be The Future Racer 2000

Why similar: Psychological Horror 55.5%, Horror 31.7%, Adventure 8.3%, Racing 3.2%, First-Person 1.3%

Why You'll Like It: A surreal and dark-humored experience that shares the bizarre, experimental nature of the seed game.

Emotional horror about survival in a gym.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 27.6%, Horror 18%, Action 15.2%, Adventure 12.8%, Indie 12.5%

Why You'll Like It: Directly leans into the meme-horror genre with a focus on funny, low-budget, and action-oriented scares.

Action adventure with an apocalyptic touch. In Aztecalypse you explore a newly discovered area with remnants of an ancient culture. If you like First Person Action games set in mystic places, in an Open World with neat places to visit aside the story, you will definitely love this game!

Why similar: Gore 44.9%, Horror 19.9%, Indie 13.5%, Action 11%, Adventure 10.7%

Why You'll Like It: A violent, indie-developed action game that shares the gore-focused and chaotic nature of the seed.

Sad Satan is a horror and mystery game that takes you on a terrifying journey through dark corridors and locations filled with secrets

Why similar: Psychological Horror 46.1%, Gore 17.5%, Indie 10.2%, Adventure 9.7%, Singleplayer 6.6%

Why You'll Like It: An experimental and disturbing indie horror game that explores dark, psychological themes in a first-person setting.

Get prepared for the FIRST EVER shooter game based on Rage Comics ! Rage Wars is a well-made action game with a variety of weapons, worlds and enemies to challenge with.

Why similar: Gore 36.7%, Illuminati 30.7% ★, Psychological Horror 23%, Adventure 3.7%, Indie 3.2%

Why You'll Like It: Combines meme culture, psychological horror, and violent action in a way that mirrors the seed's chaotic design.

A horror game that challenges you to play three different games and diagnoses your tolerance for fear. “Surprise fear,” “hiding fear,” “escaping fear”—are you tolerant of all types of fear?

Why similar: Horror 42.4%, Gore 32.7%, Action 12.7%, Singleplayer 5.8%, Indie 5.2%

Why You'll Like It: A straightforward, first-person indie horror experience designed to test the player's nerves.

"A Demon's Game" is a very unique title, but keeps true to its horror roots, the game focuses on creating a terrifying atmosphere, rewarding exploration, and engrossing players in the rich lore of its world, moving away from the trend of incessant jump scares and low production quality is our main goal.

Why similar: Blood 34.9% ★, Gore 20.3%, Psychological Horror 16.4%, Horror 13.6%, Action 5.2%

Why You'll Like It: Offers a blend of psychological horror and puzzle-solving within a first-person indie framework.

Blame Him is true first-person survival horror. A game about surreal atmosphere and dark challenges. A bone-chilling experience made by 2 people from Japan. Loved by and scared many YouTubers and Streamers.

Why similar: Horror 30.5%, Psychological Horror 19.4%, Gore 17.2%, Action 10.5%, Adventure 10.2%

Why You'll Like It: An indie horror title that emphasizes atmosphere and tension, similar to the psychological aspects of the seed game.

At its heart The Long Reach is an adventure game. Closer inspection also reveals it’s a thrilling horror story, flavoured with sci-fi ideology, psychological context and a skeptical view on the human psyche.

Why similar: Gore 38.8%, Psychological Horror 16.1%, Horror 14.2%, Adventure 11.7%, Action 10.9%

Why You'll Like It: Features pixelated gore and a psychological narrative that aligns with the darker themes of the seed.

Cargo 3 is a futuristic action game set in science-fiction horror world, which links the best features of the genre: unusual dynamics and thrilling high intensity of the gameplay.

Why similar: Gore 37.3%, Horror 35.1%, Action 14.1%, Indie 10.7%, FPS 1.3%

Why You'll Like It: A janky first-person shooter that relies on horror tropes and a gritty, low-budget atmosphere.

A horror game like no other with a crazy plot. So many characters that make you laugh. With great sound effects and eerie atmosphere of FishStop, labyrinth, atmospheric music, jokes and more!

Why similar: Horror 48.2%, Adventure 22.5%, Indie 12.7%, Singleplayer 8.3%, Memes 6%

Why You'll Like It: A funny, meme-centric, and bizarre 3D adventure that feels like a spiritual cousin to the seed's humor.

You've inherited a small house. The documents say that you will only have a right to own it once you manage to live there for at least few days. But you must not go outside at night and shouldn't open the cellar door. Is there a chance to meet the conditions? Only time will show!

Why similar: Illuminati 40.9% ★, Gore 18.5%, Psychological Horror 14.6%, Horror 13%, Adventure 4.4%

Why You'll Like It: An atmospheric indie horror game that focuses on a cinematic, unsettling experience.

The main hero of the game was alone. All of his family died. He continued to cling to the life... but Death... seems trying to pick him up... Throughout the game something have been chasing and wants to send you to the other world to meet his family... and as if you were trying to hide it finds you...

Why similar: Gore 57.7%, Horror 18.6%, Adventure 14.2%, Indie 9.5%

Why You'll Like It: An indie adventure that incorporates gore and horror elements in a surreal, first-person environment.

Easy game for easy life. Enjoy.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 34.6%, Horror 28%, Adventure 10.3%, Indie 7.6%, Action 6.5%

Why You'll Like It: A psychological horror game that uses atmospheric, maze-like design to build tension.

DOOMED is a First Person Shooter with horror elements, heavily inspired by old-school shooter classics.

Why similar: Blood 42.2% ★, Gore 19.2%, Horror 12.9%, Action 9.6%, Adventure 8.5%

Why You'll Like It: An action-adventure title that utilizes horror themes and indie-style combat mechanics.

Oldschool FPS. Hardcore classic gameplay action. Huge hordes of monsters. Blood. Horror. Fun. Each level is unique and not similar to the previous. You need to survive in this dangerous world and become the best evil shooter.

Why similar: Horror 38.3%, Blood 30.6% ★, Action 12.5%, Adventure 11.5%, FPS 2.7%

Why You'll Like It: A fast-paced, retro-style FPS that shares the raw, action-oriented roots of the seed game.

Indie horror game that will take your adrenaline to another level.

Why similar: Gore 42%, Horror 20%, Action 18.7%, Adventure 8.7%, Indie 6.6%

Unique horror with a Deep plot, a lot of characters, great sound effects and a creepy atmosphere of Real Dungeon. Locker Room, Gym, Various Monsters, Atmospheric Music, Meme Scrolls, The Lash of the Spain King and much more! Right Version Included.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 42.4%, Horror 31%, Action 7.9%, Adventure 7.5%, Indie 6.1%

Strap it on and lock 'n' load in Grass Simulator, where you will Shoot, Loot and MOO! your way through multiple game modes revolved around...GRASS! Grass Simulator will revolutionize the way you look at grass.

Why similar: Illuminati 56% ★, Gore 14.6%, Indie 11.5%, Adventure 9.4%, Memes 4.1%

Why You'll Like It: An absurdist, meme-heavy simulation game that captures the same 'so-bad-it's-good' energy.

Ray of Light is a horror game with awesome graphics, perfect sound and unexpected twists of plot. This game never lets you get bored.

Why similar: Horror 43.1%, Indie 32.2%, Action 10.9%, Adventure 10.1%, FPS 2%

Why You'll Like It: A survival-focused FPS that leans into horror and action, fitting the general gameplay loop of the seed.

Casual & Hard FPS. Be careful with jam.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 36.9%, Horror 34.8%, Action 9%, Indie 8.9%, Singleplayer 6.2%

DOPAMINE - NON STOP KILLING - BLOOD - BUNNY HOPPING - HIGH SKILL CEILING - MORE BLOOD - NO HAND HOLDING - STOCK TRADING - EVEN MORE BLOOD - ODDLY SENSUAL

Why similar: Psychological Horror 63.7%, Action 16.4%, Singleplayer 9.1%, Psychedelic 5.4%, FPS 3.4%

Fast-Paced ULTRAKILL and DOOM like game where you are playing as the last Cameraman, who has to fight off the army of Skibidi Toilets using various weapons and cheerful music 🚽 (And little bit of pure brainrot)

Why similar: Psychological Horror 54.4%, Action 20.7%, Singleplayer 9.4%, Memes 5.7%, Indie 4.1%

Super hardcore first-person game.

Why similar: Illuminati 55.1% ★, Psychological Horror 16.8%, Action 13.3%, Indie 10%, Singleplayer 2.5%

Old school classics with the new twist.

Why similar: Gore 31.9%, Blood 25% ★, Action 18.1%, Indie 14%, Horror 7.3%

Octave is a point 'n click horror-adventure game with elements of action. Dark woods, monsters, paranormal activity, nice puzzles - all this is present in the game.

Why similar: Gore 60.7%, Indie 24.2%, Adventure 15%

Twilight Town: A Cyberpunk FPS is a brutal, funny, bloody FPS game with an advanced gore system. Featuring 15 beautiful levels, a variety of weapons and a deeply engaging story that follows the journey of a young man and his friend tackling on a criminal underground to give his AI wife a real body.

Why similar: Action 43.6%, Gore 28.9%, FPS 7.4%, Anime 4.9%, Comedy 4.5%

Red Lake - horror shooter with elements of quest.

Why similar: Indie 28.9%, Horror 18.7%, Psychological Horror 14.8%, Gore 14.5%, Action 9.9%

PSYCHO - is an exciting 3D shooter with hardcore elements where you will explore an abandoned psychiatric hospital playing as a fighter SWAT.

Why similar: Horror 46.5%, Adventure 17.5%, Action 16.9%, Indie 12.3%, Gore 4.4%

Doorways: Holy Mountains of Flesh is an Immersive Horror Adventure, featuring a Complex Story and Deep Atmosphere.

Why similar: Gore 31.3%, Psychological Horror 22.8%, Horror 21.3%, Adventure 7.3%, Action 6.9%

A psychological first-person horror game where you enter a memory-erasing protocol and relive a trauma. Uncover dark secrets, and experience fear through immersive atmosphere.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 32.9%, Horror 27.5%, Gore 21.4%, Singleplayer 5.2%, Adventure 5%

Interactive novel, survival horror, psychological thriller - you can find in Mistfal, what you're interested in.And when you pass the game, I'm sure it will not leave you indifferent.Welcome to Mistfal !

Why similar: Horror 35.6%, Adventure 25%, Indie 19.6%, Action 17.6%, First-Person 1.5%

Bloody Glimpse will take you on a immersive journey through bloody and dark world, the one that you always dreamed of.

Why similar: Gore 64.8%, Action 15.7%, Indie 11.8%, Memes 3.5%, FPS 2.7%

Probably the most colorful horror game you've ever played. Hide from moaning disembodied eyeballs while facing existential dread, ambient music, and alternative medicine.

Why similar: Adventure 40.5%, Horror 30.3%, Indie 29.2%

A unique take on the popular genre of battle royales. Multiple fast pace rounds that rewards kills just as much as being the last alive. Team up, take revenge, and be the last bean standing.

Why similar: Horror 40.8%, Action 28.3%, Indie 21.8%, Memes 6.3%, FPS 1.2%

Limitless Hunger is a high-adrenaline retro FPS single-player experience.

Why similar: Gore 39.7%, Horror 32.4%, Action 17.3%, Singleplayer 3.7%, FPS 3.7%

FPS/3rd Person Genre Shooter. Fight your way through an Alien Invasion not only on earth but on other planets.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 50%, Action 15.1%, Indie 11.1%, Adventure 8.1%, Singleplayer 5.3%

Hello Comrades ! You think you got what it takes to be tru slav? Then we have game for you ! Prove to all your gopnik friends that you are the superior alpha slav your babushka always wanted you to be.

Why similar: Illuminati 70.3% ★, Psychological Horror 15.9%, Action 5.6%, Indie 3.3%, Singleplayer 2.9%

This Co-op Shooter , has Day and Night levels, multiple maps, players will take on 25 enemy types and numerous bosses, like Gargantuan Monsters and Minibosses every 10 days as you explore, shoot and run for your life against the onslaught of porcine monstrosities.

Why similar: Blood 31.4% ★, Gore 26.4%, Illuminati 17.4% ★, Horror 10%, Psychological Horror 5.4%

♂ Unique Furry Horror with Muscular Mister Furries, Deep Plot, Great Sound Effects and Creepy Atmosphere of Furry Dungeon. Hot Milk, Dungeon Items, Gym, Gay-Bar, Pool, Locker Room, Atmospheric Music and much more! Will you be able to escape punishment from Mister Furry? ♂

Why similar: Psychological Horror 41.2%, Horror 28.5%, Action 9.5%, Adventure 9%, Indie 6.9%

A horror game that tests your wits, courage and dark sense of humor. Solve puzzles to survive in a world full of dark secrets, but beware - there could be something waiting around every corner!

Why similar: Psychological Horror 56.7%, Horror 29.5%, Indie 9.8%, Thriller 1.7%, Atmospheric 1.2%

Psychopathy Assessment is a retro-80s V.H.S PS1 style analog horror game that blurs the line between reality and delusion. Step into a universe where you're not just playing a game; you're taking a psychopathy test, but the stakes are considerably higher than a straightforward diagnosis.

Why similar: Gore 50.8%, Psychological Horror 17.2%, Horror 11.6%, Indie 8%, Action 7%

WARNING! This game has an Age Restriction of 18. Vapour is an experimental horror game, that fuses elements of both old school and modern horror titles with the frantic game play of classic First Person Shooter titles. Blending horror, shooter, action, puzzle and platformer in a dynamic yet cohesive combination.

Why similar: Gore 43.8%, Horror 20.6%, Indie 12.6%, Adventure 9.4%, Action 9.2%

Dynamic, hardcore and explosive action on the passage with a bunch of weapons, enemies and bosses.

Why similar: Gore 37.3%, Action 21.6%, Adventure 19.1%, Indie 15.4%, Singleplayer 5.3%

It's a retro horror game featuring eerie black, white, and red visuals. Embark on an exciting adventure across 18 suspenseful levels while evading "The Shadow" and discovering five possible endings. Immerse yourself in a chilling atmosphere with haunting environments and unsettling sounds.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 39.2%, Horror 29.1%, Adventure 8.5%, Action 7.4%, Singleplayer 5.7%

Fortuito: Lost History is an indie adventure first-person horror, face the unknown with classic fps mechanics, solve puzzles and immerse in this bad trip!

Why similar: Horror 32.8%, Psychological Horror 29.5%, Adventure 26.5%, FPS 4%, Action 2.7%

GLOWCOMA: chapter 1 is a Sci-Fi FPS survivor horror game.

Why similar: Gore 56.3%, Action 16.2%, Adventure 15.6%, Indie 11.9%

Embark on a touching and creepy journey about sacrifice and how sometimes a person pays for the sins of another

Why similar: Blood 29.9% ★, Adventure 15.1%, Action 14.8%, Horror 13.5%, Indie 11.9%