Games Like Unnatural: Benighted

Horror Story: Hallowseed is a story-driven psychological horror game. An obscure event causes two of your friends to disappear while you were camping in the woods. Left alone and stranded in an unknown place, you need to seek the answers about what happened, face the horror and find your friends.

Why similar: Supernatural 26.6%, Gore 16.8%, Horror 14.7%, Psychological Horror 10.1%, Realistic 9.3%

An ancient evil has descended upon the rural town of Rabbit Hole. Now Shaun Turner not only has to untangle a twisted web of supernatural events and mysteries to save his family but also escape from the hellish remains of his hometown.

Why similar: Zombies 20.8%, Gore 19.5%, Third-Person Shooter 15.6%, Horror 10.3%, Shooter 9.7%

Supernatural phenomena are on the rise. In MetaPhysical you and up to 5 other friends can go on the hunt for eerie creatures to put an end to their sinister activities! Whether it's an ordinary ghost or a demon, your task is to identify the rumbling creature and then finish it off.

Why similar: Supernatural 38.9%, Horror 17%, Shooter 12%, Psychological Horror 11.3%, Atmospheric 9.3%

Open the doors between your everyday reality and a dark unholy world to unveil the mystery of the disappearance of your child. Explore both worlds to find clues, solve puzzles, decide whether you infiltrate or fight brutal enemies and stand up to an aberrant establishment.

Why similar: Gore 29.2%, Horror 16.7%, Realistic 16.3%, Survival 11.8%, Psychological Horror 11.5%

Protagonist of the game is investigating the disappearance of people. The investigation leads him into an old house, and then it becomes a party to the strange and dangerous events.

Why similar: Zombies 27.9%, Horror 15.7%, Shooter 15.4%, Survival 12.9%, Psychological Horror 9.9%

Batu, tormented by nightmares, is lured to a nameless village via cryptic letters. Investigating the village's secrets with just one friend, he wakes one night to discover his ally gone. He must now locate his friend and elude the village's dark mysteries.

Why similar: Supernatural 21.1%, Horror 19.2%, Realistic 14.6%, Psychological Horror 13.1%, Action-Adventure 9.6%

A Day Out is a monster-hunting and case-solving co-op third person shooter. Capture monsters and discover a new supernatural world with your friends!

Why similar: Supernatural 48.2%, Psychological Horror 13.3%, Gore 12.9%, Third-Person Shooter 12.4%, Third Person 11.9%

Are you ready to uncover the secret of the cursed town? Immerse yourself in the ambiance of the Wild West and its mysterious events, and discover the truth about what lurks on the grim streets of this town.

Why similar: Supernatural 20.7%, Zombies 16.9%, Gore 16.8%, Horror 9.6%, Shooter 7.3%

Survival Horror in first person where you must manage your ammunition well, explore varied scenarios and face nightmarish beings, while investigating the macabre experiments with children, the result of a mind unhinged by madness and family loss.

Why similar: Gore 17.9%, Supernatural 16.9%, Shooter 13.7%, Horror 12.5%, Psychological Horror 9%

Witch Hunt is a challenging horror themed hunting game that takes place in the 18th century. Main focus of the game is on exploration, non-linearity, and atmosphere.

Why similar: Supernatural 27.9%, Horror 15.7%, Survival 11.8%, Gore 11.3%, Shooter 11.1%

Third person shooter action adventure game with post-apocalyptic theme. Witness the adventures of Victor and his friends in this abandoned world.

Why similar: Third-Person Shooter 19.6%, Shooter 17.6%, Realistic 12.9%, Atmospheric 9.1%, Third Person 8.2%

Detective Wyatt confronts a chilling mystery as he investigates a housemaid's disappearance. Unearth sinister secrets as you navigate through a haunted house, where every shadow hides a lurking terror.

Why similar: Horror 30.9%, Psychological Horror 19.9%, Story Rich 14.1%, Atmospheric 12.9%, Action-Adventure 10.9%

Fortuito: Lost History is an indie adventure first-person horror, face the unknown with classic fps mechanics, solve puzzles and immerse in this bad trip!

Why similar: Supernatural 43.8%, Horror 16.1%, Zombies 15.3%, Action-Adventure 14.7%, Psychological Horror 8%

Inspired by Allison Road. SUPERNORMAL is a psychological horror game set in a seemingly ordinary apartment harboring dark secrets. Play as Detective Wyatt, tasked with unravelling the disappearance of Masato Sakamoto's daughter. Search for clues and unravel the sinister truth.

Why similar: Supernatural 33.2%, Horror 15.9%, Realistic 14%, Psychological Horror 10.5%, Emotional 10.1%

Explore abandoned locations, collect paranormal evidence, and survive the wrath of the former residents still haunting them. Team up with up to 3 friends to investigate by day, and hide for your life by night. What begins as an investigation quickly turns into a desperate struggle to stay alive.

Why similar: Supernatural 49.1%, Horror 23.6%, Psychological Horror 15.7%, Atmospheric 9.4%, Action 2.2%

Cryptid is a single-player horror fps game that chronicles an experienced hunter and a creature's encounter from the perspective of the Body Cam.

Why similar: Supernatural 37.6%, Realistic 19.4%, Action-Adventure 10.7%, Atmospheric 10.5%, Horror 10.4%

As a YouTuber investigating supernatural events, explore the mysterious and terrifying happenings in an abandoned location. Your camera is your only ally, but can you uncover these dark secrets?

Why similar: Supernatural 36.4%, Horror 18.1%, Realistic 16.6%, Psychological Horror 11%, Atmospheric 8.7%

Explore terrifying liminal spaces. Horror walking simulator with reality-bending platforming and supernatural threats. Get lost between dimensions.

Why similar: Shooter 36.4%, Realistic 22.9%, Action 16.4%, Atmospheric 11.8%, Psychological Horror 8.8%

A first-person horror game Incoming Evil, you will explore an unsolved event about 3 missing people. Nobody knows what happened to them, the police could not solve the case. You are an experienced detective; the case handed over to you.

Why similar: Horror 38.7%, Psychological Horror 25.8%, Atmospheric 15%, Indie 9.7%, Action 6.7%

Experience Halloween Horror in PC or VR. You go out with your friends, trick or treating, entering haunted attractions, as you make your way to the big party, but this year's holiday of the afterlife brings something sinister.

Why similar: Gore 22.7%, Horror 17.4%, Survival 11%, Shooter 10.8%, Atmospheric 9.6%

Skinwalker Hunt is a horror themed hunting game from the creator of Witch Hunt. Main focus of the game is on exploration, non-linear gameplay, and atmosphere.

Why similar: Supernatural 28.5%, Horror 16.8%, Shooter 16%, Survival 11.2%, Atmospheric 8%

Unmourned is a first-person psychological horror game where Jason moves into a new house only to be haunted by escalating paranormal events. Driven by fear, he must uncover the truth behind the previous owners' disappearance. Can he solve the mystery before it's too late?

Why similar: Supernatural 31.5%, Horror 18.5%, Realistic 15.2%, Psychological Horror 13.1%, Action-Adventure 7.8%

Experience the story of a Private Detective and find out what happened on the day of the accident in this First Person horror Adventure. play solo or with up to five friends using unique features from solving puzzles, buying equipment to stun the monsters and progress through the story.

Why similar: Blood 45.1% ★, Horror 21.5%, Third Person 13.5%, Action-Adventure 11.5%, Action 5.9%

You find yourself in the center of inexplicable nightmare. Make your way through the horror, come face to face with terrible events. Immerse yourself in the dark mystery of the events in which you found yourself an unwitting participant.

Why similar: Horror 24.9%, Psychological Horror 16%, Shooter 14%, Atmospheric 13.1%, Realistic 8.1%

NEDRA is a story-driven, atmospheric action-adventure blending survival horror with cosmic terror. Set in a Soviet-era Antarctic station, all the explorers have vanished without a trace, leaving you to uncover the chilling truth.

Why similar: Horror 20.5%, Shooter 15.1%, Realistic 14.2%, Psychological Horror 13.3%, Story Rich 10.4%

Curse of Anabelle is a story driven adventure-horror/puzzle game which players can experience in the first person perspective. The storyline is based on real world myths and legends.

Why similar: Indie 28.4%, Action 22.1%, Horror 19.4%, Survival 10.9%, Atmospheric 9%

Wounded is a first-person survival horror game, bringing you the old-school indie horror vibe through a detailed and eerie environment.

Why similar: Gore 22.2%, Blood 21.8% ★, Horror 15.3%, Zombies 14.9%, Survival 9.9%

In 1947, hard-boiled private eye Ben O'Hara is searching for a missing girl in an abandoned hotel. Investigate room by room, piece together clues, and give the living dead lead poisoning in this noir horror. Can you push through your fear and discover what became of her?

Why similar: Supernatural 27.6%, Horror 17.6%, Psychological Horror 11.1%, Third Person 9.2%, Atmospheric 8.1%

You, a normal working Joe, decide to try to solve the mystery of the missing girl... Will you make it out alive? A horror game filled with mystery!

Why similar: Horror 32.9%, Psychological Horror 21.6%, Realistic 14.4%, Action-Adventure 9.2%, Action 9%

You have arrived in a forest where people are rumored to disappear and strange things happen... Locals often see bright flashes and hear strange sounds...

Why similar: Supernatural 35.9%, Horror 19.9%, Realistic 17.3%, Psychological Horror 13.6%, Atmospheric 10.6%

The Familiar Stranger is a 3D psychological horror game where twisted memories and nightmares blur. Uncover dark secrets while evading a relentless entity that watches from the shadows. Can you escape the horrors of the past, or will they consume you?

Why similar: Supernatural 28.4%, Horror 16.7%, Realistic 16.3%, Action-Adventure 14.3%, Psychological Horror 10.3%

An online co-op horror game featuring unique playable characters and RPG mechanics. Exorcise ghosts using your special abilities and tools while surviving the supernatural onslaught

Why similar: Supernatural 46.2%, Horror 26.5%, Psychological Horror 16.8%, Action 4.3%, Indie 3.9%

In this game you have to fight your way through hordes of zombies in search of a safe place.

Why similar: Zombies 31.5%, Shooter 16.9%, Gore 12.8%, Survival 9.1%, Horror 7.6%

First-person survival horror with ghosts and demons. Find yourself smack in the middle of a haunted forest in the dead of night. Talk to spirits through your Spirit Board. Capture evidence of the paranormal, but beware, fiercely aggressive demons are on the hunt.

Why similar: Gore 37.9%, Horror 30.8%, Atmospheric 10.5%, Indie 6.7%, Survival 5.4%

A psychological horror game where a police officer investigates a cold case in a decaying house, uncovering a strange and haunting tape recorder that reveals a terrible secret.

Why similar: Supernatural 21.9%, Realistic 21.3%, Horror 19.5%, Atmospheric 11.8%, Action 9.2%

It has been -̷̯͙̔̈́-̴̱̽̓͝-̷̍̊̕͠ days without incident. Your investigation has brought you to an old metalworks factory, abandoned after a series of mysterious deaths. But something’s been growing in the quiet. A short first-person survival horror experience.

Why similar: Horror 31.1%, Zombies 20.9%, Action 10%, Psychological Horror 9.5%, Atmospheric 8.4%

The year is 1990. It’s been two years since the mysterious disappearance of Edward Crow and the abrupt closure of his theme park, Crow Country. But your arrival has broken the silence, Mara Forest. If you want answers, you’ll have to venture deep into the darkness of Crow Country to find them…

Why similar: Supernatural 21.4%, Third-Person Shooter 18.3%, Gore 16.2%, Horror 14%, Psychological Horror 9.1%

Shadows Peak is an atmospheric, open-world horror game focused on exploration that doesn't hold your hand. You play as a writer who has decided to visit a mysterious place called Shadows Peak to gather materials for a new book about legends.

Why similar: Supernatural 29.7%, Horror 16.7%, Shooter 12.8%, Gore 9.7%, Atmospheric 8.6%

A small town is being taken over by ghouls. Solve puzzles, carefully read notes and use various weapons against horrific and evolving enemies to uncover what is behind this gruesome event. Eternal Evil is an old-school survival-horror game.

Why similar: Zombies 24.2%, Gore 19.9%, Horror 14.5%, Survival 8.3%, Shooter 8.1%

Hunt the chupacabras alone or with your friends, explore the map and find the weapons to kill the monster.

Why similar: Shooter 26.4%, Realistic 20.7%, Horror 18.8%, Action-Adventure 12.5%, Atmospheric 11.5%

The Beast Inside is a unique, gripping twist on thriller and survival horror. Immerse in the story of long-buried secrets, personal tragedies, and madness. Play as two protagonists bounded by dark heritage. Combat the enemies, solve riddles and experience real terror in the 3D-scanned environment.

Why similar: Horror 33.5%, Gore 17.5%, Survival 10.6%, Psychological Horror 9.4%, Realistic 6.9%

Autumn, 1992. Anton, a 14-year-old boy, moves with his parents to a small town and is left alone in his grandmother's apartment. Meanwhile, children are disappearing across the town — the police are powerless, and no one knows who's behind it…

Why similar: Gore 33.3%, Horror 28.1%, Psychological Horror 16.2%, Story Rich 9.6%, Atmospheric 8.8%

A psychological first-person horror experience. Set in California, USA, blurring the line between game and reality. Confront the events which completely changed Zane Zaminsky´s life.

Why similar: Horror 33.1%, Psychological Horror 22.7%, Gore 18.1%, Action-Adventure 11.1%, Indie 8.2%

You've been tasked to observe supposedly haunted locations. Observe and log paranormal events and use the tools at your disposal to gather data on any potential paranormal threats and exterminate them if necessary.

Why similar: Supernatural 43.9%, Horror 20.2%, Psychological Horror 13.6%, Zombies 13%, Realistic 8%

Puzzle Horror game inspired by PS2 era classics. Navigate environments, tackle threats, and meet other lost characters in the depths of the Gloom.

Why similar: Blood 31% ★, Zombies 17.6%, Gore 15.4%, Horror 9.3%, Action-Adventure 7.3%

Bigfoot Forest - a first-person indie horror game. While traveling in your car, you run out of gas and find yourself far away from any civilized locations at night, with only woods and a small town nearby.

Why similar: Horror 30.5%, Survival 26.4%, Action 14.3%, Psychological Horror 11.8%, Atmospheric 11%

Try to escape with your life in a first-person survival horror adventure. Play through the eyes of four distinct characters as you evade and confront terrifying ghosts, unravel mind-bending puzzles, and unearth a sinister conspiracy…

Why similar: Supernatural 39.4%, Psychological Horror 15.9%, Horror 13.3%, Atmospheric 12.1%, Story Rich 12%

Game represents detective thriller from the first person with elements of my mysticism. Action takes place in 1996 in Denwood, player personates as its original resident. Suddenly cattle began to disappear on the island. Animals disappeared at nights absolutely without a trace, and, it seems that nobody could prevent it.

Why similar: Action 51%, Indie 49%

UFOPHILIA is a first-person psychological horror game where you explore areas marked by alien phenomena. Use specialized equipment to detect, identify, and photograph aliens—but do so at your own risk... They are watching you too.

Why similar: Supernatural 43.9%, Horror 23.2%, Psychological Horror 14.5%, Realistic 8.2%, Atmospheric 3.2%

Prepare to question what is reality, and what is insanity in one of the scariest psychological horrors in years. The tenants are going missing, screams echo and blood seeps through the walls of Clover Hill.

Why similar: Horror 27.8%, Psychological Horror 17.4%, Realistic 16.5%, Atmospheric 13.4%, Action-Adventure 9.9%

The protagonist, Ethan, heads into the forest with his dog, Ranger, for a simple hunting trip. At first, nothing seems out of the ordinary—but as the time goes on, the hunt slowly turns into a nightmare. Something strange and unexplainable lurks deep within the woods...

Why similar: America 33.3% ★, Horror 27%, Atmospheric 12.5%, Realistic 12%, Psychological Horror 11.2%

You awaken in a cold unfamiliar building crawling with grotesque creatures. Stave off terror using your wits and anything you can find, then try to make it out alive in this highly atmospheric environmental horror game.

Why similar: Supernatural 40.2%, Horror 20.5%, Psychological Horror 13.9%, Third Person 11.7%, Atmospheric 10.6%

SURVIVAL HORROR in first person. We incarnate an investigator of paranormal events that only with the help of a paranormal activity detector (EMF DETECTOR) and a small oil lamp, we will try to perform an EXORCISM.

Why similar: Supernatural 39.2%, Horror 24.7%, Action 9.2%, Psychological Horror 8.7%, Indie 8%

Death Below - is a third-person action adventure with elements of survival horror. The plot of the game is based on the legend of the Soviet experiment of the 1940s.You will plunge into a dark world, and begin an exciting investigation, fighting on your way with thousands of distraught people

Why similar: Zombies 26.7%, Third-Person Shooter 18%, Shooter 13.5%, Horror 11.8%, Survival 9.4%

Take part in a one-man investigation and solve the mystery of your brother’s disappearance. Find out the truth by exploring unsettling liminal locations. Discover the story chapter by chapter, with each one unveiling their common tragedy.

Why similar: Blood 34.5% ★, Horror 23.6%, Gore 17.1%, Survival 9.6%, Psychological Horror 9.4%

"INHUMAN" is an independent horror game. The story takes place in the conspiracy of an ancient clan, and the protagonist is in a psychedelic state and can't even distinguish herself. With further exploration and confrontation with all kinds of ghosts, the puzzle will be solved step by step...

Why similar: Horror 30.8%, Psychological Horror 20.7%, Story Rich 13.9%, Atmospheric 10.8%, Action-Adventure 7.7%

Your memory is fading. Things around your home keep changing; they are not what they appear to be. Find what is wrong, take pictures to restore your memory. Try to remember. Learn what you have forgotten, learn what has happened. It is not what it seems to be.

Why similar: Supernatural 31.3%, Horror 22.6%, Psychological Horror 15.4%, Realistic 14.9%, Atmospheric 9.5%

Play as Nikolas, a 20-year-old guy who found himself lost in an abandoned city... or so he thought it was at first. Explore the city, defend yourself from monsters, and find answers to what is really going on.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 19.6%, Horror 19.3%, Gore 18.8%, Indie 9.6%, Action 9.4%

A former special forces operative is sent to uncover a government cover-up tied to a secret viral experiment. As he explores a hidden underground lab and tracks the last two survivors, he realizes the facility conceals even darker secrets.

Why similar: Third-Person Shooter 20.3%, Horror 14.3%, Realistic 13.1%, Shooter 9.8%, Psychological Horror 9.2%

DESOLATE is a first person horror survival experience. Form a research team with up to 4 players and explore an open world filled with mysteries and unsolved questions, or do it all on your own.

Why similar: Zombies 28.8%, Horror 21.7%, Survival 21.7%, Gore 18.4%, Action 3.3%