- #1 Lost Hammer
97% matchMixed44% of 25 reviews2022
Dev: Max Pedro
Windows
Lost Hammer - This is a 3D adventure with puzzle elements and first person view. You have to take on the role of a city dweller who dreams of becoming a blacksmith's apprentice.
Why similar: Adventure 26.5%, Casual 16.9%, First-Person 15.5%, 3D 11.9%, Atmospheric 9.4%
- #2 The Ritual
96% match3 user reviews67% of 3 reviews2025
Dev: Brian Benitez
Windows
A exploratory based game in where you find a key to be able to leave the room. Avoid that monster and see clearly.
Why similar: First-Person 19.6%, Adventure 19.5%, Horror 17.2%, 3D 14.9%, Mystery 12.2%
- #3 The Marson Home
96% match6 user reviews67% of 6 reviews2022
Dev: Dylan W
Windows
The Marson Home is a single player, mystery-thriller. Explore the home, find the pieces to the ritual, and rid the place of the tormenting spirit. Keep in mind - your not alone...
Why similar: Investigation 27.1%, Adventure 17.9%, Horror 16.3%, Casual 9.9%, First-Person 9%
- #4 Bite Size Terrors: Reverse Blue
95% matchNo user reviews
Dev: anOVERTHINKER
Windows
The Bright Blue Sky... Is Hiding Something.
Why similar: Investigation 24.6%, Horror 14%, Mystery 13.9%, Adventure 11.3%, Atmospheric 10.1%
- #5 House Party 8
94% match2 user reviews50% of 2 reviews2026
Dev: Pedro Verpha
Windows
A short first-person anomaly horror game set inside a looping house party. Observe carefully, trust your memory, and escape only when everything feels normal.
Why similar: Adventure 22.3%, Investigation 15.2%, First-Person 12.8%, 3D 9.8%, Horror 8.8%
- #6 Minerva (2015)
94% matchNo user reviews
Dev: davidh
Windows
first-person exploration game, explore the forbidden planet, uncover the dark secrets.
Why similar: Investigation 21.3%, First-Person 14.4%, Horror 12.6%, Mystery 12.2%, Adventure 9.5%
- #7 隔離病院
93% matchNo user reviews
Dev: ASINOURA
Windows
「隔離病院」は、閉鎖された病院の廊下を歩きながら異変を探す一人称ホラーゲームです。あなたは病棟の一角に閉じ込められ、同じ通路を何度も繰り返し歩くことになります。壁の掲示、扉の位置、天井の照明、耳に届く音。前に通ったときと何かが違っていないか、些細な違和感を見逃さずに進まなければなりません。異変を見つけたら引き返す。何も無ければそのまま進む。判断を誤れば、また最初の廊下へ戻される。静寂に包まれた病院で、あなたはどこまで正しく見極められるでしょうか。
Why similar: Adventure 23.2%, Horror 13.4%, Investigation 11.9%, 3D 10.5%, First-Person 9.5%
- #8 Recovered Occurrence
92% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Dylan MacDonaldPub: Repentant Minds Interactive
Windows
A new home owner begins to experience and capture unsettling occurrences around his property.
Why similar: Adventure 24%, Investigation 17.8%, First-Person 15%, Horror 10.2%, Mystery 9%
- #9 Ocularis
91% matchNo user reviews2027
Dev: Studio 127Pub: JVKK
Windows
An ancient intelligence can no longer learn so it made you. Enter a sequence of abstract chambers, decipher an unfamiliar visual language, and solve the puzzles it created. As you learn through its carefully constructed experiences, it studies how you learn...and begins to understand again.
Why similar: Investigation 16.3%, Adventure 16.2%, Casual 14.8%, First-Person 12.4%, 3D 10.4%
- #10 Forest Lookout
90% matchMixed44% of 18 reviews2026
Dev: Olcaval
Windows
Forest Lookout is a first-person horror game where you navigate a lost person in a forest to safety. You can choose beetween options in dialogs to them. Listen to them, keep track of them, use your map and lead them out of the woods.
Why similar: First-Person 21.9%, Adventure 21.7%, Horror 19.3%, 3D 17.9%, Linear 14.8%
- #11 Gloamroot
91% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Dkabes
Windows
Gloamroot is a first-person adventure set in a small, surreal village. Tasked to finish chores for your sick father, you uncover unsettling details hiding beneath the town’s calm surface. Something else is watching.
Why similar: Adventure 36%, First-Person 23.8%, Horror 18.9%, Atmospheric 16.5%, Indie 2.6%
- #12 Echoes From The Past
89% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Cookie Games
Windows
Join Cerys Baker in the gloomy Oak Sanatorium, discover its secrets and keep your sanity. Solve puzzles, resist dark forces and experience suspense, horror and mystery in this captivating exploration game. Are you strong enough?
Why similar: Investigation 27.4%, Horror 16.2%, Linear 14.3%, Mystery 13.5%, 3D 13.4%
- #13 Extinction
89% match7 user reviews43% of 7 reviews2021
Dev: Royal Games Studio
Windows
Extinction is a singleplayer horror game where you explore The valley of Extinction. Your job is to explore it while also keeping yourself alive from monsters who want to end your life. Made this game when I was 16 :)
Why similar: Adventure 26.2%, Horror 22.7%, Atmospheric 14.1%, First-Person 13.1%, Linear 9.4%
- #14 Ancient Scroll
88% matchPositive88% of 17 reviews2024
Dev: Daniel Li
Windows
Ancient Scroll - the game is a mixture of an adventure game and classic quests. You have to go to an abandoned ranch in search of an ancient scroll. Where an exciting adventure awaits you, hiding many mysteries!
Why similar: Adventure 27.4%, Casual 17.8%, First-Person 13.4%, 3D 12%, Linear 9.6%
- #15 SCOOMART
87% match9 user reviews67% of 9 reviews2023
Dev: Chase Wilburn
Windows
SCOOMART is a INDIE-HORROR game created from an inside joke about a pet! As the protagonist, you get stuck working the night shift at a local gas station. What begins as a normal shift quickly turns into a very confusing night.
Why similar: First-Person 15.8%, Adventure 14.8%, Horror 14%, 3D 11.9%, Linear 9.9%
- #16 Backrooms: Found Footage
86% matchVery Positive82% of 381 reviews2024
Dev: HNStudios
Windows
Backrooms: Found Footage is a single-player horror game where you are the main character trying to survive the Backrooms. Curiosity wins and you decide to explore this weird place that you got trapped in. What could go wrong?
Why similar: Adventure 21.5%, Investigation 14.8%, First-Person 14.6%, Horror 12.8%, 3D 11.1%
- #17 Terror Mansion
86% matchMostly Negative25% of 12 reviews2024
Dev: Domynyo SRL
Windows
Terror Mansion is an exciting first person Horror video game that catapults you into a frightening Mansion. Your main objective is to escape the infested Mansion, finding objects and challenging riddles while exploring incredible scenarios.
Why similar: Adventure 23.9%, Investigation 13.5%, Casual 12.7%, First-Person 11.3%, Horror 8.7%
- #18 Seclusion: Islesbury
85% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Silent Game House
Windows
Seclusion: Islesbury is a mystery/horror adventure game with a focus on creating an absorbing journey. In this journey, you will explore various locations with countless mysteries to solve while trying to stay out of the madness that surrounds the town.
Why similar: Adventure 28.6%, Investigation 19.8%, First-Person 12.1%, Mystery 11.9%, Horror 10.6%
- #19 The Somnus Fracture
84% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Adhiraj Bhagawati
Windows
A psychological horror adventure where you explore shifting dream worlds, solve immersive environmental puzzles, and unravel the mysteries of your fractured mind inside a surreal facility.
Why similar: Adventure 19%, Horror 16.2%, Investigation 14.2%, First-Person 13.6%, Mystery 11.4%
- #20 Christmas Supermarket Simulator
83% match8 user reviews0% of 8 reviews2025
Dev: Stybite
Windows
Run your own Christmas supermarket, serve customers, stock products, and enjoy a warm, festive holiday experience.
Why similar: Adventure 34.1%, First-Person 18.4%, 3D 14.1%, Casual 12%, Atmospheric 11.2%
- #21 Childlike(차일드라이크)
84% matchMostly Positive71% of 35 reviews2021
Dev: Park SungJin
Windows
Use objects not to step on the floor. Do not step on the road outside. Run away from the Guard at school. Run away from the haunted doll.
Why similar: Adventure 30.6%, Casual 19.3%, First-Person 18.2%, Horror 14.7%, 3D 13.2%
- #22 Descend
82% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Josh Green
Windows · Linux
Descend is a faithful depiction of SCP-087.
Why similar: Adventure 28.9%, Horror 25%, Casual 15.9%, First-Person 12.2%, 3D 8.9%
- #23 BREACHED: Follow Me
82% matchNo user reviews2027
Dev: dntbshmdPub: GrimHouse Games
Windows
A first-person psychological horror game with a VHS atmosphere and an Eastern European setting. Explore dark locations, uncover hidden secrets, and discover a story where reality may not be what it seems.
Why similar: Adventure 23.5%, Atmospheric 18.4%, Casual 13.6%, Horror 11.2%, First-Person 9.9%
- #24 Sanguis Luna
81% match6 user reviews17% of 6 reviews2025
Dev: Domynyo SRL
Windows
Sanguis Luna is a first person Horror video game that catapults you into a frightening Mansion. Your main objective is to escape the infested Mansion, finding objects and challenging riddles while exploring incredible scenarios.
Why similar: Investigation 18.5%, Adventure 16.6%, First-Person 14.8%, Horror 11%, 3D 10.8%
- #25 Phantom Incident
81% matchPositive91% of 11 reviews2025
Dev: GZ Storm
Windows
Low poly horror. A paranormal streamer investigates an obscure urban legend referred to as the "Phantom Incident". In documenting the journey, the more he uncovers, the less it makes sense.
Why similar: Horror 19.6%, Adventure 19.6%, Mystery 16.4%, Atmospheric 13.5%, First-Person 8.9%
- #26 Souvenir
80% matchNo user reviews
Dev: WU:REPub: Bitmap Production
Windows · Mac
The 54-year-old protagonist, living solely on memories from the past 10 years, undergoes a year of hypnotherapy with a psychiatrist to recover lost memories from 44 years ago. On January 14th, with no significant progress in the therapy, he encounters ruins and a young girl during hypnosis.
Why similar: Adventure 34.3%, Investigation 24.8%, First-Person 17.5%, 3D 13.6%, Exploration 8.2%
- #27 The Last Crawler
79% match6 user reviews100% of 6 reviews2025
Dev: CratesDiamond
Windows
In The Last Crawler you play as a ventilation repair man named David and you enter the vents of Blackwell Station but everything is not as it seems. The vents are not safe and you must find a new way out before its too late.
Why similar: Adventure 27.4%, Casual 14.5%, First-Person 13.3%, 3D 11.2%, Horror 9.8%
- #28 Perilous Skies
79% matchNo user reviews2024
Dev: Rydiossoftware
Windows
Stranded in a dark, mist-filled forest, your only hope is an old communications tower hidden in hostile terrain. Gather scattered toolkits, brave the fog, and evade the shadows that lurk in wait. Every step brings you closer to rescue—or into the abyss. Will you survive Perilous Skies?
Why similar: Adventure 27.2%, First-Person 16.8%, Casual 14.4%, Horror 12.2%, Atmospheric 11.7%
- #29 Classroom 3B
78% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: SEJUSTUDIO
Windows
Investigate an abandoned Indian school where the truth was buried — literally. Manage a failing power system, monitor live CCTV feeds, and piece together a tragedy through documents, audio logs, and authentic Hindi voice work in this psychological horror investigation.
Why similar: Investigation 28.4%, Horror 17.8%, Adventure 17.3%, Atmospheric 10.9%, First-Person 9.9%
- #30 Late Emergency
77% match7 user reviews71% of 7 reviews2025
Dev: JungaarPub: Veronika Manukjan
Windows
Late Emergency is a horror experience where your goal is to quickly explore an abandoned waterpark after you received an emergency message. The more time you spend there, the more twisted will be the outcome. Get through the area as FAST AS POSSIBLE.
Why similar: First-Person 25.1%, Horror 21.8%, 3D 14.3%, Casual 13.3%, Mystery 10.3%
- #31 The Letter: Classic Edition
77% matchPositive81% of 43 reviews2022
Dev: TreeFall Studios L.L.C.
Windows
The Letter: Classic Edition is the ORIGINAL experience from the classic title "The Letter", with a few changes and additions. Relive the Wii U game that gathered so much hate it became a cult classic. Embark on a creepy narrative driven tale about a boy in search of his missing father.
Why similar: Adventure 24.1%, Investigation 16.4%, First-Person 14.4%, 3D 11.2%, Horror 9.8%
- #32 Recurring Dream
76% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2024
Dev: Grow Now!
Windows
Recurring Dream is a short, atmospheric walking simulator where you revisit a cold, majestic mountain lost in memory and longing. Explore the surreal, dreamlike landscapes as you search for a loved one, unravelling a deeply emotional story.
Why similar: Adventure 25.6%, Casual 13.6%, First-Person 12.4%, 3D 10.4%, Mystery 9.8%
- #33 Eleusis
78% matchMixed57% of 365 reviews2013
Dev: Nocturnal works
Windows
Median: 2.8 hrsMean: 4.1 hrs≥1hr: 86%
Eleusis is a 3d first-person adventure game for Windows developed by Nocturnal Works using the technology of the unreal engine. It takes place in a seemingly abandoned village in Greece where the player character, while trying to seek refuge, finds himself in the center of a whirlwind of mysterious events.
Why similar: Adventure 37.3%, First-Person 20.6%, Horror 19%, Atmospheric 8.1%, Indie 7.5%
- #34 My Friend, the Wickhorn
76% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Dragon Key Studio
Windows
A first-person psychological horror where you care for your cat, maintain an isolated mountain cabin, and uncover the link between your father’s secret past and the ancient curse that has taken hold of your friend.
Why similar: Adventure 22.1%, First-Person 12.7%, Mystery 12.6%, Horror 12.2%, Linear 10.4%
- #35 THE FERRY
75% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Alex OlinkiewiczPub: A.O.Games
Windows
A ferryman. An old but trustworthy cable ferry. A peaceful night job. What could possibly go wrong?
Why similar: Adventure 20.7%, Casual 19.8%, First-Person 14.9%, 3D 12.9%, Horror 10.9%
- #36 Thin Line
74% matchMixed57% of 21 reviews2025
Dev: Zweig Lynn
Windows
A short time before fading away.
Why similar: Horror 25.4%, Adventure 25.2%, First-Person 25.2%, Linear 8.7%, 3D 8.1%
- #37 Departure.
75% matchPositive100% of 13 reviews2022
Dev: Icarus
Windows
Close your eyes, explore your imagination, and make your own fun using the toys scattered around your room. Find solutions and secrets that can help you on your quest to crack the door's five locks and be free of your confinement in this simple, adventure, puzzle solver.
Why similar: Mystery 18.9%, Adventure 17.3%, First-Person 15.4%, Casual 14.9%, Investigation 11.7%
- #38 Where Is Mommy
72% match8 user reviews63% of 8 reviews2026
Dev: Calm Hyena Interactive
Windows
Trapped in a bazaar that twists with every turn, you are a lost child searching for your mother. Watch for subtle anomalies in the shifting environment to survive the loop. In this retro-inspired world, nothing is as it seems. Can you find her before the cycle swallows you whole?
Why similar: Investigation 28%, First-Person 16.1%, Mystery 14.8%, 3D 11.7%, Horror 10.6%
- #39 House
74% match1 user reviews0% of 1 reviews2024
Dev: Yo!Games
Windows
Explore the HOUSE, remember it & spot the changes !
Why similar: Investigation 27%, Horror 14.1%, First-Person 12.8%, Adventure 12.1%, 3D 9.6%
- #40 Escape from MLC
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: MLC Student Run
Windows
Welcome to Escape from MLC, a game created by students of Metropolitan Learning Center. MLC is a school in Northwest Portland, OR. This is a game based inside of MLC.
Why similar: Adventure 34.6%, Casual 18.2%, First-Person 14.7%, 3D 12.9%, Atmospheric 10.2%
- #41 DREAM LOGIC
73% matchVery Positive89% of 406 reviews2022
Dev: Teleopsia Games
Windows
Median: 48 minMean: 2.2 hrs≥1hr: 37%
DREAM LOGIC is a story driven first-person atmospheric horror game which takes place in liminal spaces. Explore various nostalgic, dreamlike, uncanny environments. But don't feel too safe, there's a sneaky creature watching your every move.
Why similar: Adventure 14%, Horror 13.8%, Mystery 13%, Atmospheric 11.5%, First-Person 10.9%
- #42 Victor's Video Vault
73% matchNo user reviews2027
Dev: Stingbot Games
Windows
It's 1995. The video store is alive. When the last customer leaves, the final rental rewrites reality.
Why similar: Investigation 20.3%, Horror 17%, First-Person 14.9%, Mystery 12.9%, Adventure 11.4%
- #43 Forest Curse
71% match7 user reviews43% of 7 reviews2026
Dev: Bell Studio
Windows
Forest Curse is an adventure game with RPG elements. A gripping adventure awaits you in a mysterious and dangerous world. Your goal is to survive and escape this cursed place at any cost.
Why similar: Adventure 28.4%, Casual 18.1%, First-Person 13.3%, 3D 11.6%, Atmospheric 9.2%
- #44 DREADSHELL
72% matchNo user reviews2027
Dev: .HOLOMANstudio
Windows
DREADSHELL is a first-person psychological horror game set in an underground drilling facility. You are sent to investigate missing workers and continue the operation
Why similar: Horror 21.8%, Adventure 21.3%, First-Person 20.9%, Mystery 17.1%, 3D 13.4%
- #45 Project Signal
71% match4 user reviews75% of 4 reviews2025
Dev: AcroGames
Windows
Investigate a wilderness for potential evidence of UFO activity in this nonlinear 3-D horror game. The more you uncover, the more dangerous it gets - as you now may know too much...
Why similar: Adventure 27.2%, Investigation 18.5%, First-Person 17.8%, 3D 13.4%, Atmospheric 11.3%
- #46 Last Respects
71% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2024
Dev: Crimson Moth Games
Windows
Last Respects is a short, single player indie horror game where the player must solve an unexplained murder case and banish a demonic presence.
Why similar: Investigation 20.8%, First-Person 19.4%, Horror 17.3%, Adventure 15.7%, 3D 15.6%
- #47 Echoes From Ciudadela
70% matchNo user reviews67% of 3 reviews2026
Dev: Kronos Interactive
Windows
Wield your Balearic sling in a first-person puzzle narrative adventure through ancient ruins. Uncover a lost civilization and reactivate forgotten machines to reveal the secrets buried beneath Ciudadela.
Why similar: Adventure 22.4%, First-Person 16.3%, Investigation 13.1%, Mystery 11.5%, Atmospheric 10.2%
- #48 Night Trail
70% matchNo user reviews
Dev: IZ Games
Windows
In Night Trail, you play as Adrian Holt, a 30-year-old man drowning in debt, who takes a job as a security guard at the abandoned Night Trail motel.
Why similar: Adventure 29%, 3D 18.6%, Linear 18.6%, First-Person 17.3%, Horror 11.8%
- #49 Anomaly Jobs : Data Center
68% matchPositive82% of 17 reviews2026
Dev: Imbace
Windows
You work the nightshift at Data Center DC4-31. Something is off this time. Spot the anomaly, take the correct exit multiple times in a row and finish your shift.
Why similar: Adventure 18.4%, First-Person 18.2%, Horror 16.4%, 3D 13.5%, Linear 12.9%
- #50 Telly V.'s Final Round
70% matchNo user reviews
Dev: MK Creations
Windows
Hello, dear contestant, and welcome to the Telly V. Show! We're so glad to have you! Today's show will be filled with puzzles, a LOT of rooms, and plenty of mysteries along the way. So, are you ready to play? Your prize awaits you in the Final Round!
Why similar: Adventure 32.2%, Casual 17%, First-Person 14.1%, 3D 12.2%, Horror 11.3%
- #51 Whispers Of The Lost Ticket
69% matchNo user reviews
Dev: AetherVerse Studios
Windows
Whispers of the Lost Ticket is an exploration horror game centered around uncovering the events surrounding Guilded Hollow Carnival through story and event interactions while shadowy forces try to stop you. Uncover the secrets of those who came before you, as the carnival welcomes its final visitor
Why similar: Adventure 28.5%, First-Person 16.2%, Casual 15.1%, 3D 12.3%, Horror 11%
- #52 The Sinkhole
69% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: SolitaryStudios
Windows
Experience claustrophobic cave horror powered by your webcam. In this psychological nightmare, a massive underground sinkhole hides a sinister entity. Ditch the mouse—your real head movements control your view, and your actual hands are used to climb, grab, and scramble through the dark.
Why similar: Mystery 26.2%, Horror 20.3%, Adventure 19.9%, 3D 13.5%, Atmospheric 9.6%
- #53 Beneath the Frost
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Not a Sailor Studios
Windows
Beneath the Frost is a short, single-player, psychological horror game set on a frozen, desolate planet. You take on the role of the sole survivor of a spacecraft crash, using a robot companion to gather parts for an SOS device while uncovering an eerie mystery that suggests they may not be alone.
Why similar: Investigation 25.5%, Mystery 13.3%, First-Person 11.6%, Horror 10.5%, Atmospheric 9.8%
- #54 Don't Remember
68% matchMostly Positive76% of 72 reviews2022
Dev: Boo! Games
Windows
In Don’t Remember, some things are better left forgotten. Fight your amnesia in this atmospheric, first person psychological horror game. Solve the mystery of the old mansion in 1900’s England through the use of your lantern’s various colors and face its hidden grotesque visage.
Why similar: Horror 18.2%, Adventure 15.4%, Investigation 13.8%, Atmospheric 12.5%, First-Person 10.9%
- #55 Shadow of Backrooms
67% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Panuzi
Windows
Explore a dark world full of liminal rooms, abandoned corridors and surreal places. You will feel lost in the backrooms, wandering aimlessly through endless corridors and hoping to find a way out. But beware: you are not alone. How long can you survive? Will you find the exit - or get lost forever?
Why similar: First-Person 19.5%, Adventure 17.5%, Horror 17.2%, 3D 13.2%, Atmospheric 12.5%
- #56 Restcue
67% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Seasonbean Team
Windows
You wake up in your familiar home, only to find yourself completely locked inside. Search for clues, evade an unknown presence, and piece together forgotten memories... In this confined space, the real terror is only just beginning. A intense 30-minute psychological horror experience.
Why similar: Adventure 28.6%, Horror 19.9%, Mystery 13.5%, Atmospheric 9.6%, First-Person 8%
- #57 Clockwise
69% matchMixed65% of 49 reviews2017
Dev: pheenix93
Windows
Median: 3.1 hrsMean: 3.4 hrs≥1hr: 91%
"Clockwise" is an adventure, puzzle, horror game with different playthroughs. It combines the feeling of being watched with the ones of confusion and fear. Will you find a way out of the haunted house?
Why similar: Adventure 40.8%, Horror 16.6%, Mystery 14.1%, First-Person 12.2%, Atmospheric 9.3%
- #58 Fooling Dead
65% matchMixed60% of 30 reviews2026
Dev: Seasonbean Team
Windows
On April Fool’s Day, the protagonist is caught in eerie supernatural events! As you investigate, uncover the truth behind a past tragedy. Explore chilling scenes, solve mysteries, and face unknown fears—can you survive?
Why similar: Adventure 24.9%, Horror 21.5%, Mystery 15.5%, Atmospheric 9.8%, Linear 7.7%
- #59 Long
67% match2 user reviews50% of 2 reviews2023
Dev: Terfilis
Windows
Will you be able to get out of this long corridor? A long road with death on the prowl will stand between you and the exit. There is no other way, you are already inside.
Why similar: Adventure 39%, First-Person 21%, 3D 15.7%, Linear 12.5%, Horror 7.4%
- #60 THE TEMPLE: CH 1
66% match1 user reviews0% of 1 reviews2025
Dev: Artin ShfPub: SmartGames
Windows
Between Dimensions Stands A Haunted Cathedral, Night‑Vision Flickers, Ghosts Lurk & A Monster Awaits Beyond The Portal To Shatter Your Sanity.
Why similar: Adventure 30.2%, First-Person 16.6%, Casual 16%, 3D 12.7%, Horror 11%