60+ similar titles based on shared tags and player behavior. Themes include Atmospheric, Adventure, Dark, Mystery.
WRAIN is a single-player cosmic adventure where your end is just the beginning. Solve intricate puzzles to appease Death, gain forbidden knowledge, and unravel the dark secrets of a mysterious island. Tread carefully—or else you may become another lost voice in the chorus of the damned.
Deadly Rehearsal
The rehearsal must be flawless. Every sound, every light timed perfectly. You are one of the best stage manager's after all. Failure is not an option. The play is cursed... and it demands perfection.
un/FRAGMENT.
A short 10 minute visual novel about being a fragment in the universe and trying to find a way out of the ****.
The rehearsal must be flawless. Every sound, every light timed perfectly. You are one of the best stage manager's after all. Failure is not an option. The play is cursed... and it demands perfection.
Why similar: Lovecraftian 17%, Philosophical 15.9%, Supernatural 15.2%, Cinematic 13%, Dark 7.9%
A short 10 minute visual novel about being a fragment in the universe and trying to find a way out of the ****.
Why similar: Philosophical 22.8%, Supernatural 18.1%, Dark 15.3%, Surreal 13.7%, Mystery 9.7%
Wander the halls of an eerie 1920s mansion as haunting visions torment you and the line between reality and nightmare begins to blur. Step into the role of grieving widow Eleanor Hartfield and uncover the chilling truth behind your husband’s mysterious death.
Why similar: Supernatural 26.3%, Mystery 16%, Dark 12.6%, Cinematic 11.7%, Exploration 8.1%
Dream the riddle. Question the village. Choose who drowns. A poetic folk-horror game about divine messages, guilty villagers, ritual games, and the terrible cost of keeping a place safe.
Why similar: Lovecraftian 21.6%, Surreal 12%, Mystery 11.1%, Dark 10.8%, Multiple Endings 9.3%
Journey to the far corners of the Earth and unearth ancient horrors in this Lovecraftian narrative puzzle adventure and sequel to 2020’s critically acclaimed Call of the Sea.
Why similar: Lovecraftian 26.5%, Supernatural 13.2%, Mystery 11.3%, Dark 9.4%, Puzzle 8.7%
Hell Dive is a first-person horror game where you are a Maritime Operative alone aboard a submarine. Sent on a mission to revive an abandoned deep-sea colony, you uncover dark secrets as terrifying and deadly horrors await in its depths
Why similar: Lovecraftian 23.6%, Philosophical 18.5%, Cinematic 14.4%, Supernatural 13.1%, Dark 8.1%
Venture into the Tuscan village of Pietralba to solve the mystery of your brother’s disappearance. Uncover the dark secrets buried within the marble quarries and your own family's past.
Why similar: Lovecraftian 16.2%, Supernatural 15.7%, Cinematic 12.6%, Dark 11.2%, Mystery 10.5%
Explore a desecrated cathedral to find your missing wife in this psychological horror adventure. Uncover the dark truth behind the Elohim, solve ancient puzzles, and survive a chilling journey where faith and reality collide. The Bible was mistranslated; the truth is much darker
Why similar: Supernatural 20.7%, Lovecraftian 17.9%, Dark 11.7%, Mystery 11.3%, Cinematic 9.8%
Heralded by a comet, seen as a harbinger of doom, the Black Death arrived in Florence in 1348. Wander through the woods to escape the plague, face various riddles and encounter mysterious creatures.
Why similar: Lovecraftian 21.9%, Dark 16.1%, Supernatural 13%, Puzzle 8.8%, Mystery 7.3%
Stranded on a desolate island with Earth's remaining researchers, you investigate a strange celestial body. The day before departure, your only means of transportation gets mysteriously damaged, leaving you stranded. Is someone sabotaging the team, or is there something more sinister going on…
Why similar: Lovecraftian 20.3%, Philosophical 16.1%, Dark 11.8%, Surreal 9.7%, Mystery 8.5%
A Light Touch is a puzzle adventure game where you play as a guiding light, protecting a small chick from danger. Together you solve puzzles and explore a mysterious world consumed by darkness. Can you uncover its secrets and restore light to the world?
Why similar: Dark 20.8%, Cinematic 19.3%, Puzzle 10.5%, Mystery 9%, Atmospheric 8.4%
Your daughter vanished. You did nothing. In Ajgal, descend into a world shaped by guilt, memory, and flesh—where redemption costs more than blood, and silence always comes back.
Why similar: Supernatural 21.1%, Lovecraftian 20%, Dark 14.1%, Mystery 11.3%, Surreal 11.3%
The Night Is Long is a short first-person horror game where a grieving man follows a ghostly vision into an abandoned mansion. Uncover dark secrets, survive atmospheric horrors, and face your past through exploration, puzzles, and subtle scares.
Why similar: Lovecraftian 31.7%, Supernatural 14.5%, Surreal 10.5%, Puzzle 8.6%, Exploration 8.5%
The Initiative was a Welsh government facility that was mysteriously abandoned in the 60s, with rumours of terrifying supernatural threats lurking inside. Will you take the plunge?
Why similar: Supernatural 24.6%, Lovecraftian 23.6%, Surreal 11.8%, Dark 11.1%, Mystery 9.6%
Trapped in your teacher's home, your only defense against the dark is a flickering candle. Unearth a family’s twisted history and solve puzzles in this Lovecraftian nightmare to find a way out. But be warned: Something else is lurking in the shadows ... and a voice is pleading for your help.
Why similar: Lovecraftian 27.2%, Supernatural 21.9%, Dark 11.7%, Puzzle 8%, Mystery 7.1%
In a melancholic first person narrative puzzle game, you are the Memory Chef of a mysterious restaurant for lost souls. Explore their memories, solve story driven and logic based puzzles, uncover deep regrets, and serve their final meal to bring them peace.
Why similar: Philosophical 17.6%, Supernatural 17.5%, Mystery 12.8%, Puzzle 8.8%, Dark 8.3%
The Great Deer is a point-n-click adventure game where you play as an intrepid explorer searching for an artefact of great value. Journey into an ancient and long forgotten temple, discover the secrets within, and uncover the dark truth behind a sinister ritual taking place within its walls.
Why similar: Lovecraftian 17.2%, Supernatural 14.5%, Mystery 11.8%, Surreal 10.5%, Dark 8.9%
Step aboard Grimrail, a story-rich psychological horror immersive-sim set on a purgatorial train. Using a cosmic radio fused to your wrist, tune into the memories of the past, confront or avoid abominations, and harness powerful eldritch abilities to navigate this liminal nightmare world.
Why similar: Lovecraftian 20.5%, Cinematic 11.9%, Surreal 11%, Dark 10.1%, Mystery 10%
A short, slow psychological horror game. You wake up somewhere and a voice tells you what to do. You can listen or not. Nothing jumps out at you. If you want something to shoot, this isn't it. If you've ever felt like your computer knows a little too much about you, it might be.
Why similar: Lovecraftian 15.3%, Philosophical 10.6%, Dark 10.1%, Supernatural 8.9%, Adventure 8.8%
Hitchhiker is a mystery game set along lost highways, where your goal is to solve the puzzle of your own backstory.
Why similar: Philosophical 21.3%, Mystery 15.7%, Dark 15.7%, Surreal 9.7%, Dialogue Heavy 8.6%
A computer engineer arrives in a remote mountain village, where tech failures and missing residents put him face to face with an unsettling force lurking behind the screen.
Why similar: Supernatural 20.4%, Surreal 11.8%, Mystery 10.8%, Dark 10.6%, Multiple Endings 8.2%
The Billy Midnight Show is a top-down pixel art cosmic horror game set within the literary universe of Nocturn Infernum, in which you must survive a television host and his macabre show while searching for your family.
Why similar: Lovecraftian 22.1%, Supernatural 18.3%, Dark Humor 14.6%, Dark 10.6%, Surreal 9.9%
Have you ever had such a gaming experience? Filled with wild screams, even mocking the developers, yet moved to tears by the end. Perhaps this game is one of those! Why? The truth lies at the last subway station.
Why similar: Philosophical 20.8%, Cinematic 19.2%, Supernatural 17.1%, Surreal 12%, Mystery 9.4%
Welcome to Bilge Junction, population 8: a dying town on the arctic highway. With the promise of a cheap roof over your head, you ran from your problems and wound up here. But winter's setting in, and the fire keeps burning. A storm is on its way.
Why similar: Lovecraftian 23.7%, Supernatural 22.7%, Philosophical 13.1%, Surreal 10.8%, Dark Humor 10.7%
A psychological horror spin-off of the acclaimed game Claire. You play as Deacon, a man searching for his missing father, but the deeper you dug, the darker the truths you uncovered, secrets you wish you’d never found, and that will haunt you forever.
Why similar: Supernatural 28.6%, Cinematic 14.8%, Puzzle 10.4%, Dark 9.9%, Atmospheric 7.5%
Welcome to Purgatory, Alchemist. Your task is simple: inspect transmutations, weigh each ingredient, and judge those who dare reshape reality. The rules are absolute. Follow them well, and in time, you may even find your place among us.
Why similar: Dark 26.2%, Supernatural 23.5%, Multiple Endings 12.1%, Puzzle 11.9%, Mystery 10.8%
Embark on this Lovecraft-inspired tale and discover the mysteries that await you on this island. Explore the island, solve challenging puzzles, and most importantly: try not to lose your sanity.
Why similar: Lovecraftian 35.4%, Puzzle 11.6%, Mystery 11.3%, Supernatural 9.7%, Story Rich 6.9%
Emir, who has an interest in mysterious events, steps alone into the abandoned apartment known as "Apartment No 129" to trace the trail of a paranormal event that occurred in 2009 and shook the country. However, he will find himself in an unexpected confrontation within this horror apartment.
Why similar: Supernatural 18.9%, Cinematic 17.2%, Philosophical 15.7%, Mystery 11.4%, Dark 8%
The rules do not lie. The guests who obeyed them are still in the ledger, and nowhere else. An inn on the border of the afterlife; each night, another rule. Lower your eyes, cover your ears, judge what slips in. Some nights, what comes wears the name of a thing the rules describe. Obey, or doubt.
Why similar: Supernatural 29.5%, Dark 14.8%, Mystery 13.9%, Surreal 9.7%, Puzzle 7.7%
Survive a relentless descent into a bio-organic nightmare. As a member of specialized tactical unit, navigate a decaying dimension to locate a vanished squad. Engage in high-stakes combat where every shadow hides an unspeakable horror. The veil is thinning - will you make it out?
Why similar: Lovecraftian 22.3%, Supernatural 18.2%, Cinematic 13.7%, Surreal 11.3%, Dark 10%
Still Ridge is a retro-style point-and-click adventure game set in a West Virginia town. Guide Omar Fletcher, a dream traveling therapist, as he investigates a murder he witnessed in his dreams. Navigate the nightmares of Still Ridge's citizens to uncover the mystery of the secluded mountain town.
Why similar: Philosophical 16.3%, Supernatural 15.8%, Dark 15.6%, Surreal 14.7%, Mystery 11.1%
Get lost in a deliciously dark horror anthology. Inspired by Shudder’s Creepshow series, this point-and-click adventure has gone all kinds of wrong.
Why similar: Dark Comedy 22.8%, Supernatural 21.6%, Dialogue Heavy 10.1%, Dark 9.6%, Dark Humor 8.9%
Transit is a dark narrative adventure starring a sarcastic sock puppet in a world looping itself to death. Ride midnight trains through collapsing timelines, free traumatised souls, and search for your sister lost inside the loop.
Why similar: Dark Comedy 16.7%, Cinematic 15.6%, Mystery 12.4%, Supernatural 11%, Exploration 8.1%
Investigate an abandoned trading post, explore its surroundings and solve the terrible mystery it holds. The Whisperer is a short story-driven point & click game set in Lower Canada at the beginning of the 19th century.
Why similar: Lovecraftian 29.5%, Dark 14.2%, Mystery 11.5%, Supernatural 11.4%, Story Rich 7.8%
Step into the unsettling world of The Blackwood Legacy, a first-person puzzle horror game set in the eerie halls of Blackwood Manor. Solve intricate puzzles, unveil long-held secrets, and decipher the mystery surrounding your father's disappearance.
Why similar: Supernatural 33.9%, Mystery 18.2%, Puzzle 10.7%, Dark 8.4%, Stylized 8.3%
Nabte is a first-person horror game set in Mexico, 1926. Trapped inside a psychiatric institution, Remedios must find a way out without fighting back, while unexplained symptoms begin to worsen the deeper she goes.
Why similar: Lovecraftian 18.8%, Supernatural 15.2%, Dark 11.9%, Puzzle 10.8%, Exploration 8.4%
An urban legend says there are alligators living in the sewers of New York. Go down there… and see for yourself. A 90s-style comedy horror game featuring classic single-voice VHS dubbing.
Why similar: Dark Comedy 25.8%, Dark Humor 19.3%, Supernatural 19.2%, Cinematic 12.6%, Dark 9.6%
You're the maintenance man for an apartment complex that has mysteriously been transported to the middle of the ocean. Woodrot is a surreal adventure game about getting to know your neighbors who all seem to blame themselves for their recent relocation.
Why similar: Philosophical 14.1%, Surreal 14.1%, Mystery 11.8%, Dark 10.7%, Dark Humor 9.6%
Vesperis is a first-person horror game that takes players on a journey filled with mystery and fear. Explore a chilling environment, solve puzzles, and uncover the secrets hidden within. Immerse yourself in a story full of dark secrets and horrors lurking beneath history.
Why similar: Supernatural 26.7%, Dark 14.7%, Cinematic 14.1%, Mystery 12.2%, Exploration 7.8%
Welcome to "Waking Tides," a small but captivating atmospheric adventure game that thrives on experimentation. Delve into a world where augmented reality extends your gameplay, seamlessly blurring the lines between reality and fantasy.
Why similar: Lovecraftian 27.5%, Cinematic 17.1%, Dark 14.9%, Mystery 11.6%, Surreal 5.8%
Scauage is a short horror experience where you play as a scavenger looting an abandoned house, uncovering its dark secrets and collecting hidden treasures while facing what lurks within.
Why similar: Supernatural 21.9%, Lovecraftian 21.7%, Dark 12.1%, Mystery 9.9%, Multiple Endings 7.2%
The shadow of Frank Stone looms over Cedar Hills, a town forever altered by his violent past. As a group of young friends are about to discover, Stone’s blood-soaked legacy cuts deep, leaving scars across families, generations, and the very fabric of reality itself.
Why similar: Lovecraftian 18%, Cinematic 15.7%, Supernatural 14.5%, Dark 11.6%, Multiple Endings 11.6%
From Lee Petty and Double Fine Productions, Keeper is an atmospheric puzzle adventure in which a long-forgotten lighthouse is awakened and, joined by a spirited seabird, it embarks upon a heartening tale of unlikely companionship, and an unexpected journey into realms beyond understanding
Why similar: Cinematic 22.8%, Philosophical 14.7%, Surreal 13.7%, Puzzle 9.7%, Atmospheric 7.6%
You are a stranger, cast into the darkness of ancient mysteries. As a rabbit, you wander a world where nightmares lurk and rituals are part of an unfathomable game. Survive and follow the voice’s call—but remember: the true will of these powers is forever beyond your understanding.
Why similar: Lovecraftian 22.1%, Supernatural 18.1%, Dark 13%, Surreal 11.1%, Cinematic 7.4%
Alex wakes up at his grandmother’s, left alone in a silent house. Unsure where his family is, he begins to uncover a dark mystery in an attempt to escape. Facing his fear in an endless nightmare, Alex must survive the dead of night, a cursed forest, and paranormal activities before daylight arrives.
Why similar: Lovecraftian 24.5%, Supernatural 18.6%, Dark 15.7%, Mystery 11.8%, Story Rich 6.2%
The Sojourn is a first-person puzzle game set in an immersive colour-drenched world of light and darkness. Think your way through dozens of puzzles as you traverse parallel worlds, awaken mysterious artifacts and overcome challenging obstacles on an unforgettable journey.
Why similar: Philosophical 20.3%, Dark 13%, Surreal 12%, Mystery 11.9%, Puzzle 9.7%
A first-person supernatural horror inspired by the legends of Bhangarh Fort. Explore India’s most haunted place, uncover your brother’s disappearance, and survive the ancient curse that still haunts the ruins.
Why similar: Supernatural 36.1%, Dark 13.9%, Multiple Endings 9.6%, Exploration 7.3%, Atmospheric 6.9%
Water Delivery is a first person, horror experience where you play as a water delivery boy. Ride along in the delivery truck from house to house. Deliver filled water jugs, find and return empty jugs, and collect all the payments. Will you be able to finish your final route of the evening?
Why similar: Supernatural 23.4%, Dark 13.1%, Mystery 12.8%, Surreal 10.8%, Multiple Endings 8.9%
When the last thread becomes entangled, their song will be heard.
Why similar: Lovecraftian 23.1%, Philosophical 19.4%, Dark Humor 14.7%, Dark 14.1%, Surreal 12.4%
Fend off spirits by ripping your spirit off your body. Explore a glitched haunted house. Recall twisted memories. Get out alive.
Why similar: Supernatural 22.1%, Lovecraftian 18.2%, Dark Comedy 15.7%, Dark 8.5%, Puzzle 8.2%
Step into a liminal, cosmic horror experience set in an abandoned amusement park. Uncover the haunting narrative behind its twisted rides and empty tunnels to discover what lurks within a reality that shouldn't exist…
Why similar: Lovecraftian 32.2%, Dark 17.4%, Mystery 12.1%, Surreal 7.7%, Atmospheric 6.1%
Growing My Grandpa! is a Cronenberg-inspired point-and-click adventure game with virtual pet elements that puts a heavy emphasis on exploration and lore.
Why similar: Supernatural 20.3%, Philosophical 19.4%, Lovecraftian 15.1%, Dark 14.9%, Dialogue Heavy 6.7%
An otherworldly being has trapped you in their mysterious extradimensional prison. Explore a home ripped from time, activate the signals, and follow them to free that which binds you in this surreal first-person non-linear puzzle game.
Why similar: Supernatural 23.3%, Mystery 16.3%, Surreal 15%, Puzzle 10.1%, Exploration 8%
Inner Voices is a dark, non-linear adventure game with a pinch of horror, inspired by works of H. P. Lovecraft and E. A. Poe. Find your way through a procedurally generated maze of rooms and solve the mystery of your past.
Why similar: Lovecraftian 29.2%, Dark 14.4%, Surreal 9.9%, Multiple Endings 9%, Mystery 8.1%
Raw April Day is a hand-drawn Mystery Point-And-Click game where you solve enigmatic puzzles, engage in soul-searching branching dialogue with colorful characters and piece together the clues for why your husband went missing in a surreal and mystifying Victorian complex.
Why similar: Dark Humor 14.5%, Cinematic 12.5%, Mystery 11.5%, Surreal 11.1%, Dialogue Heavy 11.1%
In the 1930's, Samuel, a man with occult beliefs is contacted by S. Stenfield, an elderly man desperate for the suicide of Alice, his daughter. Through a voodoo ritual, Samuel enters a world that only the dead can access. There he will try to recover Alice's soul... But nothing is what it seems.
Why similar: Lovecraftian 22.8%, Cinematic 20.9%, Supernatural 14.7%, Dark 11.3%, Mystery 9.7%
You're driving away on a forest road, late at night, under a heavy storm. Your car breaks down. Luckily, there might be a gas station nearby. But a misfortune never comes alone. The storm has brought something else, something otherworldly that oddly smells of spilled diesel oil.
Why similar: Lovecraftian 18.9%, Dark 17.4%, Surreal 14.5%, Cinematic 12.3%, Mystery 9.1%
You've got a new babysitting job, and things are taking a turn for the weird. Feed him, read him a bedtime story, and try not to fall into his dreams. How long can you stay in control?
Why similar: Lovecraftian 22.3%, Supernatural 18.7%, Dark Comedy 18.5%, Dark Humor 13%, Surreal 10.6%
