- #1 Bass Defense: First Memorythms
97% matchPositive86% of 14 reviews2024
Dev: WOMBEX Games
Windows
In Bass Defense's rhythm-based and action-packed 'Soundwave' game mode, you must hit the correct buttons in time with the music to clear your NMYs and save your base with the help of your upgradable power-ups or your sense of rhythm. Try your luck and 5 memorythms in this free episode.
Why similar: Rhythm 18.9%, Music 18.2%, Bullet Time 13.1% ★, Difficult 7.7%, Physics 5.4%
- #2 Fury of Light
96% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Complex Realms
Windows · Linux
Keep your focus and follow the light in this fast-paced action game!
Why similar: Music 32.3%, Rhythm 30.3%, Soundtrack 17.6% ★, Difficult 12.5%, Colorful 3.3%
- #3 Smashometry
96% matchNo user reviews91% of 11 reviews2026
Dev: Ealga Labs
Windows
Smashometry is a single-player arcade game where you must react to constantly changing in-game instructions to smash the correct shape and score points.
Why similar: Rhythm 28.8%, Soundtrack 26.7% ★, Score Attack 19.9%, Difficult 15.5%, Colorful 4.3%
- #4 RiBeat!
95% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Sweet Banana
Windows
RiBeat! is a challenging rhythm-puzzle game where you move to the beat of the music while avoiding obstacles, solving puzzles, and jamming out in musical showdowns. Bob your head to catchy tunes as Muira, the musical frog, embarks on a groovy adventure in a world that syncs with the rhythm!
Why similar: Music 38.5%, Rhythm 33.7%, Difficult 11.3%, Soundtrack 9.8% ★, Action 3.1%
- #5 Rotoscape
94% matchNo user reviews
Dev: N-GON Interactive
Windows · Mac · Linux
A game about rotating shapes. To save the Shapiverse. Rotoscape is a minimalistic fast-paced action puzzle game about rotating shapes with a soundtrack by Geoplex.
Why similar: Soundtrack 31.4% ★, Music 17.8%, Rhythm 17.2%, Score Attack 13.5%, Difficult 10.3%
- #6 ONE BTN BOSSES
94% matchVery Positive82% of 205 reviews2024
Dev: Midnight Munchies
Windows
Median: 36 minMean: 4.0 hrs≥1hr: 34%
It's One Button Bosses, it's all in the name. You have one button. There are big bosses to beat. Push, tap, and bash in the handcrafted campaign or in the roguelike rifts.
Why similar: Soundtrack 25.3% ★, Music 22.1%, Rhythm 22.1%, Bullet Time 12.2% ★, Difficult 10.6%
- #7 Keyboard Maestro Voyage
93% matchPositive80% of 10 reviews2024
Dev: OnozukaPlan
Windows
"Keyboard Maestro Voyage" is a music game using a MIDI keyboard, simulating real performances. Play in sync with flowing notes in this classic-style game. Start quickly by simply choosing a song and sheet music.
Why similar: Music 39.9%, Rhythm 34.2%, Score Attack 17.6%, Sci-fi 3.9%, 3D 2.6%
- #8 Hi On Rhythm
92% matchNo user reviews2024
Dev: Fever Night
Windows
A rhythm game? A bullet-hell? Is there a way to have it all? Then let us get Hi on the Rhythm!!
Why similar: Rhythm 29.9%, Music 29.7%, Difficult 12.1%, PvE 7.1%, Top-Down 6.9%
- #9 PolyTap
91% matchMostly Negative33% of 18 reviews2024
Dev: PolyTapOfficial
Windows
Tap to the rhythm based on the shapes that emerge!
Why similar: Rhythm 45.1%, Music 32.6%, Difficult 16.9%, Action 5.4%
- #10 EZ2ON REBOOT : R
91% matchVery Positive91% of 6,157 reviews2022
Dev: Neonovice Co., Ltd.
Windows
Median: 8.9 hrsMean: 207.9 hrs≥1hr: 93%
EZ2ON REBOOT : R – The latest entry in the beloved rhythm-action franchise is now released on Steam! Revisit the huge collection of classics with remastered audiovisual. Catch up with the freshest new songs and experiences.
Why similar: Rhythm 30.5%, Music 27.3%, Soundtrack 25.8% ★, Difficult 9.2%, Action 2.9%
- #11 Akihabara - Feel the Rhythm Remixed
90% matchMostly Positive70% of 10 reviews2018
Dev: Mårten JonssonPub: JMJ Interactive
Windows · Linux
Intense rhythm and puzzel actions awaits on the streets of Akihabara. Can you feel the beat?
Why similar: Music 34%, Rhythm 33.6%, Soundtrack 32.4% ★
- #12 Jinko
89% matchPositive100% of 40 reviews2024
Dev: Bean Juice Studios
Windows
Jinko is a physics-based musical arcade game where balls fall to the rhythm, and your job is to keep them up! Fight against gravity and time across a variety of unique songs and levels, or challenge yourself in the arcade mode to see how your best score stacks up on the global leaderboard.
Why similar: Music 38.3%, Rhythm 29.6%, Difficult 17.6%, Physics 13.6%, Singleplayer 0.9%
- #13 Twin Horizons
89% match3 user reviews67% of 3 reviews2021
Dev: Exploding Cable Productions
Windows · Mac
You may think this is a simple rhythm action game with the simple controls of tapping and holding the keyboard, but what's that above? Yes, you need to pay attention to those as well! Can you handle the 8-lane madness?
Why similar: Music 41.6%, Rhythm 36.9%, Score Attack 12%, Action 5.3%, 3D 2.6%
- #14 Grid-M
88% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Joh Games
Windows
Grid-M is an action packed grid based Rhythm game featuring an amazing soundtrack. Rise to the top through a welcoming progression system to promoting improvement at all skill levels. Low floor, highest Peak. It time to click to the Grid-M!
Why similar: Rhythm 37.1%, Music 33.1%, Score Attack 12.4%, Sci-fi 7.6%, Action 4.8%
- #15 Rift of the NecroDancer
86% matchOverwhelmingly Positive95% of 5,345 reviews2025
Dev: Brace Yourself GamesPub: Klei Publishing
Windows
Median: 3.5 hrsMean: 9.1 hrs≥1hr: 80%
The NecroDancer's back in an all-new rhythm game! Dragged into a strange new world, Cadence must engage in musical combat with monsters surging through the Rift! Face pulse-pounding Rhythm Rifts where every beat is a battle, all set to an original soundtrack by Danny Baranowsky & friends.
Why similar: Rhythm 57.5%, Music 20.6%, Soundtrack 10.4% ★, Difficult 7.3%, Colorful 2%
- #16 Beatlow
87% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Windfall Studio
Windows · Mac
A fast-paced rhythm game where every mistake costs a life. Hit the right keys in time with the music, survive escalating mutators, upgrade your skills, and push your run as far as possible.
Why similar: Rhythm 39.8%, Music 18.1%, Difficult 15.2%, Soundtrack 12.9% ★, Score Attack 12.8%
- #17 Lumi Trek
86% matchPositive100% of 18 reviews2025
Dev: Gray Muscat
Windows · Mac
Lumi Trek is a unique rhythm platformer where you have to combine the three primary colors of light to overcome obstacles. Change the color of the moving star at the right time, and stay calm when deadly traps appear. It may sound simple, but this challenge will make your hands sweat!
Why similar: Rhythm 33.6%, Music 32.7%, Difficult 13.7%, Score Attack 12.7%, Colorful 3.6%
- #18 Charles the Bee
85% matchVery Positive89% of 57 reviews2024
Dev: Blue Pin StudioPub: Blue Pin Publishing
Windows · Linux
Charles has always dreamed of one day becoming a master dancer. The only thing in his path? The cost! Charles must harvest pollen until he has defeated the biggest and baddest dancers in the world. Can he bee the very best? That no one ever was? It's up to you! 🐝
Why similar: Rhythm 38.2%, Music 36.2%, Score Attack 16.7%, Colorful 5.5%, Action 2.2%
- #19 RaLo
84% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Onefin
Windows · Mac
RaLo is a minimal yet mind-bending drumming game that requires mental agility and precise timing. Hit the correct drums at the right time, but watch out for when you need to do the opposite.
Why similar: Rhythm 30%, Soundtrack 25.2% ★, Music 25.2%, Difficult 11.8%, Score Attack 5.2%
- #20 EAGLE: Special Forces
84% matchNo user reviews2025
Dev: AKIMBO
Windows · Mac
EAGLE: Special Forces — An action-packed shooter featuring lightning-fast shootouts, bombastic music, ricochets, time-slowing, tanks, helicopters, and various enemies, each with their own battle tactics.
Why similar: Bullet Time 31.4% ★, Soundtrack 29.1% ★, Music 14.8%, Difficult 9.1%, Top-Down 7%
- #21 Trigonometric Equations
83% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: dicotraingamestudio
Windows · Mac · Linux
Trigonometric Equations is a strict side-scrolling rhythm game. Solve the trigonometric equations to fly through fleeting points and curves perfectly!
Why similar: Rhythm 31.1%, Music 29%, Soundtrack 19.7% ★, Difficult 12.1%, Colorful 3.8%
- #22 Rhythm Journey
82% matchMostly Positive80% of 114 reviews2022
Dev: MELOVITY
Windows · Mac
Rhythm Journey is a story based, hardcore 2-buttons rhythm game.
Why similar: Rhythm 44.3%, Music 37.6%, Difficult 14.7%, Action 2.5%, Singleplayer 1%
- #23 Groove Coaster
82% matchMixed67% of 1,585 reviews2018
Dev: TAITO CORP.Pub: KOMODO
Windows
Median: 3.3 hrsMean: 7.8 hrs≥1hr: 80%
Riding the rhythmic rails of success from smart phone, into the arcades, now GROOVE COASTER arrives on Steam! Are you ready to ride a roller coaster of sound and light through a universe of music?
Why similar: Rhythm 47.7%, Music 41.8%, Action 5.9%, Difficult 3.8%, Singleplayer 0.7%
- #24 Dash Out
81% matchNo user reviews
Dev: r3nsen
Windows · Linux
A music-based game where you dash through the levels and complete rhythmic challenges
Why similar: Music 39.5%, Rhythm 36.3%, Difficult 14%, Colorful 5.5%, Action 3.7%
- #25 Rhythm Bang
81% match6 user reviews100% of 6 reviews2024
Dev: RiskiVR
Windows · Mac · Linux
Rhythm based aiming game focused around hard electronic music. Aim the blaster with your mouse as it blasts rhythmically to the music, and aim at the falling blocks!
Why similar: Music 50%, Rhythm 42.7%, Colorful 5.9%, Singleplayer 1.4%
- #26 Piano High Score
79% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Bird Bath Games
Windows
Everything you love about rhythm games, brought to your digital piano. Load your own MIDI files, play on real keys, and climb online leaderboards.
Why similar: Rhythm 41%, Music 36.3%, Score Attack 18.8%, Colorful 2.8%, Singleplayer 1.2%
- #27 STUMPER
80% matchPositive85% of 26 reviews2019
Dev: THIRTEENTH FLOORPub: THIRTEENTH FLOOR
Windows
STUMPER presents a new paradigm for experiencing music in VR.Pick up your shields and crash crystals flying through the air to the rhythm.
Why similar: Rhythm 33.2%, Music 32.9%, Soundtrack 29% ★, Action 5%
- #28 AUDICA: Rhythm Shooter
78% matchVery Positive85% of 586 reviews2019
Dev: Harmonix Music Systems, Inc
Windows
Median: 1.9 hrsMean: 6.4 hrs≥1hr: 61%
AUDICA™ is a VR “rhythm shooter” that combines Harmonix’s award-winning music gameplay with precision shooting mechanics and a 33-song soundtrack, all set in a mesmerizing cosmic arena.
Why similar: Rhythm 50.6%, Music 45.5%, Action 3.8%
- #29 KickBeat Steam Edition
79% matchMixed66% of 770 reviews2014
Dev: Zen Studios
Windows
Median: 2.2 hrsMean: 3.8 hrs≥1hr: 88%
From indie pioneers Zen Studios (makers of Pinball FX2 and CastleStorm) comes KickBeat, an innovative rhythm game with a Kung Fu theme, featuring fully 3D characters and high-energy music! You can use your own music to create custom KickBeat tracks, allowing you ultimate replayability!
Why similar: Music 49.6%, Rhythm 44%, Action 6.4%
- #30 SlipDream Resonator
77% matchPositive92% of 12 reviews2023
Dev: Small Brain Games
Windows
SlipDream Resonator is a multi-directional rhythm game with unique twin-stick controls. Inspired by both classic rhythm games and top-down shooters, SlipDream Resonator offers addictive arcade gameplay designed to challenge while featuring eye catching visuals and a heart pumping soundtrack.
Why similar: Rhythm 43.6%, Music 31.3%, Score Attack 9.7%, Action 5.6%, Top-Down 5%
- #31 BIT.TRIP BEAT
78% matchVery Positive80% of 881 reviews2010
Dev: Gaijin Games
Windows · Mac
Median: 1.5 hrsMean: 3.2 hrs≥1hr: 67%
From gameplay to visuals to music and imagination, BIT.TRIP BEAT is inspired by classic games in every way. Get sucked into a whole new world of sight and sound as you juggle beats and ride the vibe in this modern look at the beginning of it all. BIT.
Why similar: Rhythm 47.7%, Music 39.8%, Difficult 8.6%, Action 3.4%, Singleplayer 0.4%
- #32 Flutterdash
77% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Tigura Games
Windows
Flutterdash is a vibrant, fast-paced rhythm game featuring intense built-in levels and custom music auto-generation. Master unique four-directional rhythm mechanics, and challenge your reaction speed using hardcore gameplay modifiers.
Why similar: Rhythm 29%, Music 28.2%, Soundtrack 13.9% ★, Score Attack 12.5%, Difficult 11.4%
- #33 MASH VP! Re:VISION
75% matchVery Positive86% of 417 reviews2025
Dev: AXTORM Co., Ltd.
Windows
[Fusion, Synthesis, Coalescence]"MASH VP! Re:VISION" is a revolutionary rhythm game that “fuses” two lanes and music into a completely new experience.With a variety of tracks, game modes, and a creativity-driven mashup system, it invites you into a new world of music!
Why similar: Rhythm 49.7%, Music 42.9%, Action 5.4%, Singleplayer 2.1%
- #34 Radial Flow
76% matchPositive84% of 19 reviews2022
Dev: Big Reef Games
Windows · Mac · Linux
Flow to the beat of your own music in this punishingly difficult mouse-precision arcade game. Enjoy endless challenge and replayability with over 30 different levels of various difficulties. Includes Steam achievements and leaderboards.
Why similar: Rhythm 43.4%, Difficult 18.1%, Music 16.9%, Score Attack 11.8%, Action 5.3%
- #35 Rhythm Fighter
76% matchVery Positive80% of 454 reviews2020
Dev: echo gamesPub: Coconut Island Games
Windows · Mac
Median: 1.1 hrsMean: 4.9 hrs≥1hr: 54%
This is a Roguelike Horizontal Action game that players need to follow the beat to defeat opponents. Beat to follow, fist to the bone. Face the foe, and dance to kill!
Why similar: Rhythm 39.3%, Music 38.8%, Difficult 15.6%, Action 4.4%, Singleplayer 1.9%
- #36 Relapse
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Hexatunes
Windows
A beginner friendly sheet music rhythm game, with cute characters and a shady organization!
Why similar: Rhythm 49.3%, Music 45.9%, Action 3.9%, Singleplayer 0.9%
- #37 Laserlife
74% matchMostly Positive74% of 119 reviews2015
Dev: Choice Provisions
Windows
Median: 4.5 hrsMean: 4.9 hrs≥1hr: 95%
Remember what it means to be a human in this interactive biography of a dead astronaut found in deep space by future intelligences who have no concept of humankind.
Why similar: Rhythm 51.5%, Music 48.5%
- #38 Intralism
73% matchVery Positive86% of 4,876 reviews2016
Dev: KHB-Soft
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 3.2 hrsMean: 34.6 hrs≥1hr: 86%
Intralism - fast and hard rhythm game. Listen to music and match arcs to the beat. Master all beatmaps or create your own and challenge friends in the online multiplayer. But remember: wrong button - failed try.
Why similar: Music 55.5%, Rhythm 35.6%, Difficult 7.6%, Action 1.3%
- #39 Neon Beats
72% matchOverwhelmingly Positive96% of 6,544 reviews2019
Dev: OKYO GAMES
Windows · Mac
Median: 24 minMean: 3.5 hrs≥1hr: 23%
Beat your best scores in Neon Beats, a 2D platformer game with rhythm based levels!
Why similar: Rhythm 45.3%, Music 39.8%, Difficult 6.8%, Score Attack 6.8%, Singleplayer 1.3%
- #40 The Polynomial - Space of the music
74% matchMostly Positive73% of 499 reviews2010
Dev: Dmytry Lavrov
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 18 minMean: 2.4 hrs≥1hr: 17%
Experience the music in a new way. Feel it pulse around you. The Polynomial is a 3D space shooter with unique, fractal based scenery that animates to the music.
Why similar: Music 48.3%, Rhythm 38.5%, Score Attack 5.2%, Action 4.2%, Colorful 2.9%
- #41 Quaver
71% matchVery Positive92% of 16,461 reviews2022
Dev: Swan
Windows · Mac · Linux
Quaver is a community-driven and open-source competitive rhythm game with two game modes and online leaderboards. Create your own maps, or challenge the world in online multiplayer matches.
Why similar: Rhythm 54.9%, Music 39.5%, Difficult 5.6%
- #42 Synth Riders
72% matchVery Positive92% of 1,638 reviews2019
Dev: Kluge Interactive
Windows
Median: 1.4 hrsMean: 7.8 hrs≥1hr: 59%
Let the music move you in Synth Riders, a dance-action VR rhythm game with custom song support and a thriving multiplayer community!
Why similar: Soundtrack 30.8% ★, Rhythm 29.7%, Music 28.7%, Cyberpunk 4.7%, Action 2.6%
- #43 EasyPianoGame
71% matchMixed68% of 22 reviews2019
Dev: EVT Games
Windows
A rhythm game which uses MIDI files to allow you to play any piano song. Play a large number of patterns with various customizable difficulties and numbers of keys. Songs in MIDI are easy to find, and they are almost always free.
Why similar: Rhythm 45.8%, Music 30.1%, Difficult 18.3%, Action 3.8%, Singleplayer 1.9%
- #44 AudioSurf
70% matchOverwhelmingly Positive96% of 11,066 reviews2008
Dev: Dylan Fitterer
Windows
Median: 2.6 hrsMean: 11.4 hrs≥1hr: 70%
Ride your music. Audiosurf is a music-adapting puzzle racer where you use your own music to create your own experience. The shape, the speed, and the mood of each ride is determined by the song you choose.
Why similar: Music 55.3%, Rhythm 35.9%, Score Attack 6%, Colorful 2.2%, Singleplayer 0.7%
- #45 BOY BEATS WORLD
70% matchPositive100% of 35 reviews2021
Dev: Duckbridge
Windows · Mac · Linux
A whimsical rhythm action adventure where you vibe along to the music and attempt to liberate the last living humans.
Why similar: Rhythm 45.4%, Music 29.3%, Top-Down 11.8%, Sci-fi 9.3%, Action 4.1%
- #46 Twin Edge
70% matchPositive97% of 34 reviews2022
Dev: Filip "Arcy" BiałokozowiczPub: ScoreSpace
Windows · Mac · Linux
Twin Edge is a refreshing circular take on the Rhythm Game genre. Divide your attention evenly between two rotating circles and try not to lose your rhythm!
Why similar: Rhythm 33.8%, Music 33.1%, Difficult 13.7%, Score Attack 12.1%, Action 3.4%
- #47 Echo Rift
68% matchMostly Positive78% of 18 reviews2025
Dev: Project Rock LLC
Windows · Mac
Fight enemies to the beat and bring Rock to the people in this epic rhythm game! Echo Rift is a beat-based combat game where players dance on an arena grid in their fight against the audiocratic elite to bring back music to a silenced world.
Why similar: Rhythm 36.4%, Music 35.9%, Top-Down 8.4%, PvE 7.5%, Colorful 4.3%
- #48 BIT.TRIP CORE
71% matchMixed59% of 156 reviews2012
Dev: Gaijin Games
Windows · Mac
Median: 1.3 hrsMean: 3.1 hrs≥1hr: 64%
Takes the player into unfamiliar territory as they use NES-style controls to blast their way through the barrage of Beats in this rhythm-music adventure.
Why similar: Rhythm 55.5%, Music 36.5%, Action 8%
- #49 Mirth Melody
68% matchVery Positive94% of 509 reviews2024
Dev: Clay Game Studio
Windows
Play as Dodo the duck exploring a beautiful little forest. Strum your favorite guitar and watch as the forest creatures happily vibe along to your music.
Why similar: Music 47.6%, Rhythm 41.6%, Colorful 5.2%, 3D 2.3%, Action 2.1%
- #50 SATANIC PANIC 666
69% matchMostly Positive78% of 160 reviews2021
Dev: deadworld games
Windows
Descend into hell and destroy the cursed tapes with occult music known as †HEAVY METAL† to save our children's souls. On your way you will face Satan himself.
Why similar: Music 28.6%, Rhythm 26.9%, Soundtrack 24.7% ★, Difficult 14.7%, Action 3.8%
- #51 Muse Dash
67% matchVery Positive91% of 120,271 reviews2019
Dev: peroperoPub: hasuhasu
Windows · Mac
Median: 3.6 hrsMean: 34.3 hrs≥1hr: 78%
Paradise of parkour & rhythm game ★★★ — Muse Dash!!
Why similar: Music 47.3%, Rhythm 43.7%, Difficult 4.7%, Colorful 2.2%, Action 1.1%
- #52 Project: Bits
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Heartomics
Windows
Project: Bits (Pronounced Beats) is a complimentary music and rhythm game. It's primary goal functions as a distribution platform for various songs and steps. Listen to the music. Feel the groove. Hit the arrows.
Why similar: Rhythm 51%, Music 49%
- #53 Retro/Grade
69% matchVery Positive84% of 396 reviews2013
Dev: 24 Caret Games
Windows
Median: 2.3 hrsMean: 4.0 hrs≥1hr: 93%
Play a classic Shoot 'Em Up... in reverse!
Why similar: Rhythm 50%, Music 36.1%, Action 8.2%, Sci-fi 5.7%
- #54 Party Pumper
69% matchMostly Positive73% of 33 reviews2019
Dev: Fibrum Limited
Windows
Born in the vibrations of music, Party Pumper is a game about parties and for parties! Player's goal is to entertain the audience by mixing a music samples. Combine this with a dance movements and fun party gadgets action, interact with partygoers crowd and pump the party!
Why similar: Music 51.4%, Rhythm 48.6%
- #55 Notanote
66% matchVery Positive88% of 926 reviews2024
Dev: zzzProject
Windows
Welcome to Notanote!
Why similar: Rhythm 40.4%, Music 38.2%, Difficult 15.7%, Colorful 3.7%, Singleplayer 2%
- #56 DJMAX RESPECT V
67% matchVery Positive89% of 34,062 reviews2020
Dev: NEOWIZ
Windows
Median: 8.6 hrsMean: 65.7 hrs≥1hr: 87%
DJMAX RESPECT V is the latest installment from the creators of the critically acclaimed rhythm game franchise ‘DJMAX.’ Experience tracks from popular artists such as Marshmello, Porter Robinson, and Yukika, exclusive Full HD Music Videos, online multiplayer, new game modes, and more!
Why similar: Rhythm 45.8%, Music 33.4%, Difficult 9.3%, PvE 4.3%, 3D 3%
- #57 McOsu
67% matchVery Positive89% of 6,349 reviews2017
Dev: McKay
Windows · Linux
Median: 36 minMean: 19.8 hrs≥1hr: 42%
A free open-source circle-clicking rhythm game practice client for osu! beatmaps with Virtual Reality support. McOsu is developed separately from and has no direct affiliation with osu! or ppy Pty Ltd.
Why similar: Rhythm 55.8%, Music 36.1%, Difficult 7.6%, Singleplayer 0.6%
- #58 BlasterBeat
66% matchVery Positive80% of 919 reviews2023
Dev: Muted Games
Windows
BlasterBeat is the award-winning PvP rhythm-shooter. Master shooting to a unique variety of tracks in dynamic and innovative gameplay in arenas that shine on the beat.
Why similar: Rhythm 34.2%, Music 30.7%, Score Attack 17.7%, PvE 5.5%, Action 3.8%