- #1 Fitness: Lifestyle
97% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2025
Dev: Nu Scorpii Entertainment
Windows
Fitness: Lifestyle is a simulation game focused on physical transformation and personal improvement. Train your character's body, work out, fight in the arena and achieve a toned body.
Why similar: Sports 36.7%, eSports 35.3% ★, Immersive Sim 11.3%, Simulation 10.1%, Third Person 4.1%
- #2 WATTGAMES
96% matchPositive91% of 11 reviews2025
Dev: TripleScience Software
Windows
Turn your indoor cycling into an adventure! A new revolution in fitness gaming, WATTGAMES is the first-ever indoor cycling game that lets you do battle with fearsome enemies, explore a beautifully crafted world and complete missions through exercise. Ride for your life!
Why similar: Cycling 30.3% ★, eSports 28.5% ★, Sports 24.4%, Action-Adventure 5%, Adventure 4%
- #3 Velo
96% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Yuna Technologies
Windows
Velo is a unique cycling game that combines the thrill of virtual cycling with an engaging story-driven experience. ⚠ Velo requires a physical exercise bicycle connected via Bluetooth to play! ⚠
Why similar: Cycling 35.2% ★, Walking Simulator 17.6%, Bikes 16.5% ★, Sports 12.2%, Exploration 6.3%
- #4 ACL Pro Cornhole
95% matchMixed42% of 19 reviews2023
Dev: FarSight Studios
Windows
Immerse yourself in the most realistic Cornhole simulation ever created with accurately motion captured player movement, detailed 3D modeled environment, official ACL bags, and commentary from legendary Cornhole personalities Trey Ryder and Bernie Nabors.
Why similar: Sports 37.9%, eSports 35.4% ★, Immersive Sim 13.5%, Simulation 13.1%
- #5 Kassei - Road Cycling 2025
94% matchNo user reviews2025
Dev: SE {} KS
Windows
Kassei 25 is a summer sports simulation game. Become a road cycling manager and master every aspect of the discipline - from training plans to team selection to race tactics! Are you ready for a new season?
Why similar: Sports 34.1%, Cycling 29.7% ★, eSports 19% ★, Simulation 9.9%, Immersive Sim 7.3%
- #6 Kassei - Road Cycling
94% match1 user reviews0% of 1 reviews2024
Dev: SE {} KS
Windows
Kassei - Road Cycling is a summer sports simulation game. To win the yellow jersey you have to manage your team optimally: as "directeur sportif" you decide on training plans as well as race tactics. #RoadCyclingTime
Why similar: Sports 34.1%, Cycling 29.7% ★, eSports 19% ★, Simulation 9.9%, Immersive Sim 7.3%
- #7 Kassei - Road Cycling: Next Season
93% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: SE {} KS
Windows
Kassei - Road Cycling: Next Season is a summer sports simulation game. Become one of more than 80 male and female road cycling managers at more than 10 tours and classics - and decide on training plans as well as race tactics! The next season starts here ...
Why similar: Sports 34.4%, Cycling 29.7% ★, eSports 18.7% ★, Simulation 10%, Immersive Sim 7.1%
- #8 Republic of Handball
92% matchNo user reviews2025
Dev: Rus Artur PFA
Windows
"Republic of Handball" is a realistic handball('team handball') video game simulator. Play handball with realistic gameplay. Select your national team and try to win the world cup.
Why similar: Sports 43.6%, eSports 41.1% ★, Simulation 11.3%, 3D 4%
- #9 Wheel World
91% matchVery Positive90% of 710 reviews2025
Dev: MesshofPub: Annapurna Interactive
Windows · Linux
Median: 4.2 hrsMean: 6.6 hrs≥1hr: 77%
Dive into Wheel World as Kat, a rider chosen by ancient cycling spirits. Race elite teams, trick out your bike, and perform the long overdue Great Shift ritual to save a universe on the brink! Your bike is your destiny.
Why similar: Bikes 26.6% ★, Cycling 25.8% ★, Sports 22.8%, Action-Adventure 6.6%, Adventure 4.9%
- #10 Birdminton
91% matchNo user reviews
Dev: MattTheDev
Windows · Mac
A bird-themed badminton game
Why similar: Sports 41.8%, eSports 40.2% ★, Cartoon 13.2%, 3D 4.8%
- #11 Extreme Climbing
90% matchVery Positive93% of 270 reviews2024
Dev: HFRK
Windows · Mac · Linux
Unarmed climbing of world famous buildings: Eiffel Tower, Statue of Liberty, Tokyo Sky Tree Tower, Dubai Tower, Pyramid, Guangzhou Tower, Oriental Pearl TV Tower Tower, CCTV Tower, etc.
Why similar: Sports 40.4%, eSports 27.6% ★, Simulation 11.7%, Action-Adventure 9.4%, Adventure 7.8%
- #12 Skydive Sim - Skydiving Simulator
89% matchMixed62% of 34 reviews2021
Dev: VaxisStudiosPub: AV1 Productions
Windows
SkydiveSim now enables you to experience Skydiving and BaseJumping from your headset. You can choose from Airplane, Helicopter, Balloon or BaseJumps.
Why similar: Sports 39.8%, eSports 38.9% ★, Simulation 14%, 3D 4.6%, Adventure 2.7%
- #13 Pro Cycling Manager 25
87% matchMostly Positive75% of 640 reviews2025
Dev: Cyanide StudioPub: Nacon
Windows
New graphics for an even more realistic simulation. Become a team manager and lead your riders to the top. Choosing sponsors, recruiting riders, managing the race, it's all up to you.
Why similar: Cycling 32.1% ★, Sports 28.3%, Bikes 21.2% ★, Simulation 8.2%, Exploration 4.7%
- #14 Pro Cycling Manager 26
88% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Cyanide StudioPub: Nacon
Windows
Dive into the heart of cycling management with an ever more realistic simulation. From recruitment and staff, to season planning and race strategy, make every decision and lead your team to victory in the sport’s biggest competitions.
Why similar: Sports 36.1%, Cycling 31.5% ★, Bikes 15.9% ★, Simulation 10.5%, 3D 3%
- #15 Surf Park
89% matchNo user reviews2023
Dev: Normal Dynamics
Windows
A surfing game focused on smooth carving turns and realistic airs.
Why similar: Sports 42.6%, Immersive Sim 17.3%, Simulation 15%, Action-Adventure 10.8%, Third Person 6%
- #16 CyberPong AI
86% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2025
Dev: kosafoPub: Bashabeth Games
Windows
Retro style fantasy ping pong game with coachable AI players.
Why similar: eSports 38.8% ★, Sports 24.2%, Immersive Sim 14.1%, Simulation 12.7%, Adventure 5.2%
- #17 Pro Cycling Manager 2024
86% matchMostly Positive75% of 535 reviews2024
Dev: Cyanide StudioPub: Nacon
Windows
Become a sports director, take part in the world's top cycling races and lead your riders to victory. Set race objectives, negotiate contracts, find new sponsors and build your team season after season.
Why similar: Cycling 35.2% ★, Sports 32%, Bikes 17.2% ★, Simulation 5%, 3D 4.4%
- #18 Car Soccer Simulator
84% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2025
Dev: KongratzPub: Kongratz Studio
Windows
Experience high-speed car soccer with true-to-life physics, advanced crash mechanics, and dynamic arenas. Designed for driving wheels, it offers precise handling, skill-based gameplay, and environmental destruction. Compete in ranked matches, unlock rewards, and master the game!
Why similar: eSports 34.1% ★, Sports 24.7%, Runner 24.5%, Third Person 6.7%, Simulation 5.7%
- #19 Quarantine Run
85% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2021
Dev: Darien Mayne
Windows
Quarantine Run is an cinematic story based, endless runner game with multiplayer, where you try to survive the pandemic by running and keeping up to date with the interesting news via Pandemi Radio. The multiplayer game mode is currently a beta, your support will help in the completion of this Game.
Why similar: Runner 24.3%, Sports 20.9%, eSports 16.1% ★, Immersive Sim 11.7%, Post-apocalyptic 9.1%
- #20 Humans vs Tigers
84% matchMixed57% of 14 reviews2022
Dev: KOA BOA
Windows
Your goal is to increase your team of hunters until you reach the tiger. Gather them but be very careful in same time to the very dangerous obstacles that you will encounter in your way.
Why similar: Sports 32.3%, Walking Simulator 20.6%, Action-Adventure 12%, Simulation 10.6%, Exploration 7.2%
- #21 Dirt Bicycle Rider Simulator
83% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2023
Dev: Rokito Games
Windows · Mac
Choose your bike, conquer the town and mountains! Test your skills in Dirt Bicycle Rider Simulator, packed with realistic graphics and exciting missions.
Why similar: Sports 23.7%, Bikes 23.5% ★, Immersive Sim 12.4%, Action-Adventure 9.1%, Simulation 7.8%
- #22 Football Stars Legend 24
82% matchMixed54% of 26 reviews2023
Dev: Yusuf Islam SeyhanPub: Inspector Studios
Windows
Step onto the football field with Football Stars Legend 24, full of exciting football matches, realistic graphics and gripping tactics! Choose your favourite team, feel the fans' enthusiasm and start the match to embrace the victory.
Why similar: eSports 35.9% ★, Sports 35.5%, Simulation 11.9%, Immersive Sim 6.6%, Third Person 5.9%
- #23 Ski Patrol
81% match6 user reviews100% of 6 reviews2024
Dev: Pita
Windows
Immerse yourself in a massive open-world ski resort while tackling objectives such as rescuing injured skiers, mitigating avalanche hazards, and finding hidden locations. Use realistic ski techniques such as parallel turns and hockey stops to navigate freely through the rugged mountain wilderness.
Why similar: Sports 44.5%, Immersive Sim 24.3%, Walking Simulator 20.9%, Simulation 5.5%, 3D 4.8%
- #24 RC Revolution: High Voltage - 免费玩
80% matchVery Positive85% of 113 reviews2024
Dev: Phren Games
Windows
Dive into RC Revolution High Voltage, the exhilarating free version of RC Revolution. Select from three dynamic cars, unlock a fourth, and challenge our AI for a fifth. Customize for style and performance, and get ready for stunt-filled tracks and nitro-fueled speed craze.
Why similar: Sports 35.4%, eSports 31.5% ★, Immersive Sim 11.3%, Action-Adventure 10.2%, Simulation 3.6%
- #25 MAVRIX by Matt Jones
78% matchVery Positive81% of 787 reviews2025
Dev: Third Kind GamesPub: Cascade Interactive
Windows
The ultimate multiplayer open world designed by Pro riders. Discover mountains and trails with limitless control and build your own career. Pull huge tricks or race through the global rankings! Nail challenges to secure sponsorship deals with real world brands. Are you ready?!
Why similar: Bikes 24.6% ★, eSports 24.2% ★, Cycling 24.2% ★, Sports 17.6%, Action-Adventure 5.5%
- #26 HIKE: Beyond the Trails
79% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Para 51 Games
Windows
A world where the trails tell stories. Set out and write your own!
Why similar: Runner 22.4%, Walking Simulator 19.1%, Immersive Sim 12.2%, Cycling 12.1% ★, Action-Adventure 10.6%
- #27 Archery Pro VR
79% matchNo user reviews
Dev: SavySoda
Windows
Archery Pro brings life-like, competitive archery straight to your living room through VR! There’s no need for archery equipment to experience the fun of Olympics style Archery with Archery Pro. Simply pop on your headset and experience all the thrills of real-life archery.
Why similar: Sports 43.3%, eSports 41.4% ★, Simulation 15.3%
- #28 Rooftops & Alleys: The Parkour Game
76% matchOverwhelmingly Positive95% of 6,736 reviews2025
Dev: MLMEDIA
Windows
Median: 1.6 hrsMean: 14.9 hrs≥1hr: 62%
In solo or with your friends, explore in total freedom massive-parkour-ready maps. Uncover hidden spots, time trials, trick challenges, and more! In multiplayer, dive into game modes like TAG, Capture The Flag, and Trick Battles!
Why similar: eSports 33.8% ★, Sports 26.3%, Immersive Sim 12.5%, Simulation 9.1%, Third Person 7.4%
- #29 God s' Margarita: The Lonely Reniat Noc
78% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Petros LalesPub: Sitting Ass Games
Windows · Mac
Βecome the latest hope of humanity! Embody the psyche of Reniat Noc and explore the post-apocalyptic lands of AI Legave. Customize your character with futuristic gadgets, solve real-life puzzles, discover the history that led to your present, and bring life into the future.
Why similar: Runner 19.5%, Walking Simulator 15.6%, Comic Book 14.4%, Immersive Sim 12.4%, Action-Adventure 8.5%
- #30 DownhillVR
77% matchPositive92% of 25 reviews2023
Dev: FiredBy s.r.o.
Windows
DownhillVR is the ultimate virtual reality mountain biking video game that brings the thrill of extreme downhill racing right to your living room. Experience the rush of speeding down challenging tracks and catching air off jaw-dropping jumps, all while immersing yourself in stunning environments.
Why similar: Cycling 26.1% ★, eSports 24.2% ★, Sports 16.8%, Bikes 15.4% ★, Immersive Sim 8.9%
- #31 Esports Team Manager
75% match4 user reviews25% of 4 reviews2025
Dev: The Brain Trust
Windows
Lead your own professional esports team: sign players, play drafts, secure sponsors, and battle through full seasons in this stat-driven sim.
Why similar: eSports 42.5% ★, Sports 34.4%, Simulation 13%, Immersive Sim 10.2%
- #32 VR Basketball Hoops
77% match2 user reviews50% of 2 reviews2021
Dev: Saturn VR
Windows
Attention basketball fanatics! Test your basketball practice and shot techniques in our Virtual reality basketball game - VR Basketball Hoops, a fun way to play Basketball!
Why similar: Sports 37.5%, eSports 36.2% ★, Simulation 12.2%, Immersive Sim 11.2%, 3D 3%
- #33 AboFlah-intelliFinish
76% matchNo user reviews2024
Dev: obada alnakib
Windows
Puzzle game on a difficult level. Start disassembling and assembling puzzles to reach the finish line
Why similar: eSports 33.3% ★, Sports 22.2%, Walking Simulator 16.2%, Immersive Sim 12.6%, Exploration 6.2%
- #34 Penguin Quest
75% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Another Dimension Game Studio
Windows
You’re a perky penguin who must find a suitable new place to live as your current surroundings are over-crowded. You’ve heard news of another flock just over the horizon, but it’s cold out there so watch out that you don’t freeze!
Why similar: Runner 29.4%, Immersive Sim 20.1%, Action-Adventure 15.3%, Adventure 11%, Exploration 10.3%
- #35 Butanooo! Simulator
74% matchMostly Positive72% of 18 reviews2024
Dev: Pigeon-G
Windows
I got you a job delivering butane. You will have to drive the delivery van, pump gas and deliver fast with the forklift. You will have a helper for miscellaneous tasks. Remember to use the nearest bathroom and put your music on the radio. Don't buy anything from beggars. Good luck!
Why similar: Runner 26.2%, Walking Simulator 22.9%, Simulation 15.3%, Action-Adventure 13.3%, Exploration 8.3%
- #36 Tennis Manager 26
74% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Rebound CG
Windows · Mac
Step into the most advanced tennis management experience ever. Run your academy, develop top talent, upgrade your staff and facilities, and dominate the junior and pro circuits. A new chapter begins, are you ready to take control?
Why similar: Sports 38.4%, eSports 35.3% ★, Immersive Sim 10.3%, Simulation 8%, Exploration 5.2%
- #37 Alpha Shark
73% matchPositive80% of 34 reviews2021
Dev: Revmatek
Windows
Ever wanted to be a great white shark? Now you can! Swim, eat, explore, and more! Lurk the margins of our world alone or with friends in this vast coral reef spanning the ocean floor.
Why similar: eSports 38.1% ★, Immersive Sim 14.6%, Action-Adventure 10.8%, Simulation 8.5%, Exploration 7.2%
- #38 Weasel Wes's Cycling Simulator
72% matchNo user reviews2025
Dev: PzenQ
Windows
Weasel Wes's Cycling Simulator is a 2D indoor cycling simulator that connects to your indoor sensors and bike trainers.
Why similar: Cycling 38% ★, Bikes 33.6% ★, Immersive Sim 12.8%, Simulation 8.9%, Walking Simulator 6.7%
- #39 Tour de France 2026
72% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Cyanide StudiosPub: Nacon
Windows
Take on the best international cyclists with one goal in mind: winning the 2026 Tour de France. Conquer legendary mountain passes, launch your sprints at the perfect moment and emerge triumphant on the Champs-Élysées wearing the Yellow Jersey.
Why similar: Sports 36.4%, Bikes 22.1% ★, Cycling 20.2% ★, Simulation 12.7%, Third Person 7.3%
- #40 Forest Jump
73% matchNo user reviews2023
Dev: HYUNPub: MYUNG
Windows
This Game Is Simple. Reach your destination only by jumping and running.
Why similar: Sports 22.9%, Walking Simulator 19.7%, Runner 17.7%, Cartoon 8.3%, Action-Adventure 8.1%
- #41 Sociable Soccer Champions
71% match2 user reviews67% of 2 reviews2025
Dev: Sporty Games UKPub: Tower Studios
Windows
Sociable Soccer Champions is the fastest, most exciting way to recreate the thrill of the world’s most popular sport. Created by legendary designer Jon Hare, it features his signature fast-paced, arcade-style gameplay, ‘couch’ head-to-head matches, and 14,000+ FIFPRO player cards.
Why similar: Sports 39.9%, eSports 36.5% ★, Simulation 13.3%, Third Person 6.4%, 3D 3.9%
- #42 Bat N' Ball
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Octav Studio
Windows
Bat N' Ball VR: Challenge your batting skills against robotic pitchers and compete for the highest score in this fast-paced and realistic virtual reality baseball game.
Why similar: eSports 36.4% ★, Sports 34.9%, Immersive Sim 13.1%, Simulation 12.2%, 3D 3.4%
- #43 RoboLeague
70% matchMostly Positive78% of 32 reviews2025
Dev: bestmaker
Windows · Mac
A competitive 5v5 football game where skill, strategy, and teamwork decide every match. Plan precise plays, master unique abilities, and outsmart opponents in fast-paced, skill-driven matches.
Why similar: Sports 48.7%, eSports 45.8% ★, 3D 5.4%
- #44 电竞俱乐部/ESports Club
73% matchMixed53% of 1,552 reviews2017
Dev: Hangzhou Xinlan Network Technology Co.,Ltd.
Windows
Median: 5.0 hrsMean: 46.5 hrs≥1hr: 83%
ESports Club is a sim game based on electronic sports industry, including most popular game types such as FPS and MOBA. What are you still waiting for? Start your esports career now!
Why similar: eSports 46% ★, Sports 37.8%, Simulation 16.2%
- #45 Mountain Bicycle Rider Simulator
71% matchMostly Negative29% of 14 reviews2023
Dev: Yusuf Islam SeyhanPub: Inspector Studios
Windows
Are you ready to experience the thrill of cycling on snowy mountain peaks? Mountain Bicycle Rider Simulator invites you to an unforgettable adventure with realistic graphics. Now explore and pedal to the top!
Why similar: Bikes 27.2% ★, Cycling 25.3% ★, Sports 21.5%, Third Person 6.7%, Action-Adventure 5.2%
- #46 Ceiling Run
70% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Ceiling Steps
Windows
The ultimate fitness game where real-life running controls your in-game avatar. Sprint in place to race against friends across platforms on virtual tracks. The faster you run, the faster you move in the game. Get fit, have fun, and compete to be the fastest!
Why similar: Sports 41.2%, Runner 21.9%, Walking Simulator 19.7%, Simulation 8.3%, Third Person 5.3%
- #47 Velo Pro Racer
69% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2025
Dev: Velo Pro Racer Ltd
Windows · Mac
Velo Pro Racer®: The real road cycling simulator game designed to put you in the race. Build your own team, design your own kit, manage your own staff and riders, get sponsors and rise to the top of the World Tour!
Why similar: Cycling 30.8% ★, Sports 28.9%, eSports 27.1% ★, Simulation 10.2%, 3D 3%
- #48 Champ at Dawn
70% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2023
Dev: Grey Sekiya
Windows
A game that will take care of your 2 minutes
Why similar: Sports 48.9%, eSports 46.1% ★, 3D 5%
- #49 Earth Legends
69% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Picknicken
Windows · Linux
A physics-driven football adventure where every touch, pass, and strike is yours to control. Experience true freedom on the pitch – just pure football shaped by skill, rivalry, and friendship.
Why similar: Sports 40.9%, eSports 38.7% ★, Action-Adventure 11.5%, Exploration 6.6%, Adventure 2.3%
- #50 Gearhead Karting Simulator - Mechanic & Racing
69% matchMixed62% of 34 reviews2023
Dev: Gearhead StudioPub: Midnight Games
Windows
The ultimate kart racing game with deep customization, realistic physics, and a variety of game modes. Build, tune, and race your way to victory!
Why similar: eSports 29.2% ★, Bikes 22% ★, Sports 20.8%, Immersive Sim 12%, Simulation 6.7%
- #51 NGL Biathlon 2026
66% matchVery Positive93% of 175 reviews2025
Dev: NordicGamesLab
Windows · Mac
Biathlon simulator. Race as your athlete, progress in Career, and compete for the Big Crystal Globe. World Cup tracks and all disciplines, including relays. Career from rookie to legend. Wide choice of skis, poles, and rifles. Feel real biathlon vibes
Why similar: Sports 41.1%, eSports 34.8% ★, Simulation 11.7%, Third Person 5.7%, 3D 3.7%
- #52 SuperCupOnline
68% matchVery Positive87% of 455 reviews2021
Dev: GameHoney
Windows
Online Football Game
Why similar: Sports 47.6%, eSports 46.9% ★, 3D 5.5%
- #53 Dan Sisal's 501 Darts Trainer
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Dan Sisal
Windows
Welcome to Dan Sisal's 501 Darts Trainer! The darts game for when you can't make it to the pub.
Why similar: Sports 45.5%, eSports 26.7% ★, Simulation 13.3%, Immersive Sim 11.6%, 3D 2.9%
- #54 Dream Sports Platform
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Dream Sports PlatformPub: Dream Sports Platform
Windows
Embark on an extraordinary football journey with Dream Sports Platform - an immersive open-world action RPG that goes beyond the football simulator. Progress through levels, shape your character, and unlock rewards that bridge the gap between virtual triumphs and real-world football services.
Why similar: eSports 36.8% ★, Sports 19.1%, Walking Simulator 17.7%, Action-Adventure 10.4%, Third Person 6.4%
- #55 OrbRider
67% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2023
Dev: Orbjeff LLC
Windows · Mac
OrbRider makes indoor cycling fun! You ride and explore up to 7 different tracks and biomes as you take on multiple challenges, gather resources, and unlock new and undiscovered areas. Personal ANT+ USB hardware dongle and ANT+ enabled speed sensor or smart trainer equipment required.
Why similar: Cycling 25.8% ★, Bikes 25.2% ★, Sports 16%, Immersive Sim 10%, Action-Adventure 5.8%
- #56 Blastforge Breach
65% matchVery Positive84% of 118 reviews2025
Dev: Clava STOVE
Windows
In this game, you must defend yourself by firing cannon shots at evil pigs and bats.
Why similar: Sports 43.1%, Comic Book 16.3%, Cartoon 15.4%, Simulation 14.5%, Adventure 10.6%
- #57 Bodybuilder Simulator CO-OP
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Klaps-On
Windows
Our game is a realistic fitness simulator with a co-op mode. Collect trophies, earn money, and shape your physique! Your character dynamically reacts to diet and training, reflecting real physical changes. Take on the challenge with friends and strive for peak fitness!
Why similar: eSports 32.5% ★, Walking Simulator 16%, Sports 15.4%, Immersive Sim 11.8%, Simulation 7%
- #58 Traildown: Downhill Mountain Biking
66% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Petr Šimůnek
Windows
Go as fast as you can, just on edge. Just you and your bike. Experience the maximum passion from riding and try to achieve the best time possible.
Why similar: Cycling 29.4% ★, Bikes 28.1% ★, Sports 20.2%, Immersive Sim 10.2%, Simulation 5.5%