- #1 The Painscreek Killings
97% matchVery Positive91% of 6,420 reviews2017
Dev: EQ Studios
Windows
Median: 5.0 hrsMean: 6.4 hrs≥1hr: 88%
Investigate an infamous cold case in the eerie, abandoned town of Painscreek. Search for evidence, connect the dots and uncover who killed Vivian Roberts. Can you expose the truth behind this town’s dark secrets?
Why similar: Investigation 25.2%, Detective 19.3%, Mystery 16%, Open World 10.7%, Exploration 8%
Why You'll Like It: This game perfectly captures the investigative mystery and exploration elements found in the seed game's darker narrative.
- #2 Horse Tales: Emerald Valley Ranch
96% matchMixed63% of 981 reviews2022
Dev: Aesir InteractivePub: Microids
Windows
Set off on a captivating horseback adventure and discover the mysteries of Emerald Valley!
Why similar: Horses 58.5% ★, Open World 12.8%, Character Customization 11.2%, Exploration 8.4%, Relaxing 7.9%
Why You'll Like It: It provides the core cozy horse-riding and open-world exploration experience that serves as the foundation for the seed game.
- #3 Astride
96% matchMixed52% of 507 reviews2023
Dev: Raidho Games
Windows
Explore Astride, a horse game set in a Scandinavian-inspired environment.
Why similar: Horses 84.3% ★, Open World 7.4%, RPG 4%, Multiplayer 3.2%, Adventure 1.1%
Why You'll Like It: A strong horse simulation game that emphasizes realistic movement and exploration in an open environment.
- #4 The Ranch of Rivershine
94% matchVery Positive94% of 2,332 reviews2025
Dev: Cozy Bee Games
Windows
Median: 2.9 hrsMean: 25.0 hrs≥1hr: 75%
Saddle up and build your own horse ranch! Raise foals, care for your horses and train them as you explore the countryside. Participate in cross country competitions and become your town's champion! Befriend the villagers who'll help you on your adventure at the Ranch of Rivershine!
Why similar: Horses 85.8% ★, Cozy 7%, Character Customization 5%, RPG 2.2%
Why You'll Like It: This game offers a deep, cozy horse-management experience that complements the relaxing side of the seed game.
- #5 The Vanishing of Ethan Carter
95% matchVery Positive88% of 8,977 reviews2014
Dev: The Astronauts
Windows
Median: 3.3 hrsMean: 4.0 hrs≥1hr: 88%
The Vanishing of Ethan Carter is a first-person story-driven mystery. Purchase this game to get both the original and the Unreal Engine 4 remaster called The Vanishing of Ethan Carter Redux.
Why similar: Detective 33.3%, Mystery 26.2%, Exploration 10.9%, Open World 9.5%, Story Rich 7.9%
Why You'll Like It: It offers an atmospheric, story-rich exploration experience that mirrors the investigative tension of uncovering a local tragedy.
- #6 Firewatch
94% matchVery Positive91% of 99,559 reviews2016
Dev: Campo SantoPub: Panic
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 4.4 hrsMean: 13.6 hrs≥1hr: 88%
Firewatch is a single-player first-person mystery set in the Wyoming wilderness, where your only emotional lifeline is the person on the other end of a handheld radio.
Why similar: Mystery 29.2%, Open World 21.1%, Story Rich 20.1%, Exploration 15.2%, Adventure 6.2%
Why You'll Like It: The focus on isolated, narrative-driven exploration in a wilderness setting provides a similar sense of mystery and discovery.
- #7 Unbridled: That Horse Game
93% matchVery Positive86% of 545 reviews2025
Dev: Mind Evotion Games
Windows
Unbridled: That Horse Game is the ultimate horse simulator, giving you the freedom to follow your own dreams and create your own unique story. Experience the freedom of riding, the challenges of horse sports, and the joy of breeding horses - all in a stunning virtual world.
Why similar: Horses 63.1% ★, Open World 11.1%, Character Customization 7.6%, Exploration 6.9%, Multiplayer 6.6%
Why You'll Like It: A realistic horse simulation that focuses on the bond and exploration aspects of equestrian gameplay.
- #8 Call of the Sea
92% matchVery Positive88% of 6,422 reviews2020
Dev: Out of the Blue GamesPub: Raw Fury
Windows
Median: 4.8 hrsMean: 5.8 hrs≥1hr: 75%
Join Norah, a woman plagued by a mysterious illness, in her search for her missing husband in this adventure puzzle game set on a lush island paradise. Immerse yourself in stunning visuals and unlock forbidden secrets in a moving tale of mystery and love.
Why similar: Investigation 24.1%, Female Protagonist 20.7%, Mystery 20%, Story Rich 13.9%, Exploration 10.7%
Why You'll Like It: This title excels at blending beautiful, atmospheric exploration with a compelling, character-driven mystery.
- #9 Rival Stars Horse Racing: Desktop Edition
91% matchVery Positive92% of 5,328 reviews2020
Dev: PikPok
Windows · Mac
Median: 7.5 hrsMean: 21.0 hrs≥1hr: 85%
With stunning, realistic horses, an in-depth breeding system, and a range of exciting game modes, Rival Stars Horse Racing offers horse fans the ultimate racing and riding experience. Take the reins and become an equestrian legend!
Why similar: Horses 49.9% ★, Cozy 33.5%, Character Customization 7.3%, Multiplayer 4.7%, Story Rich 4.6%
Why You'll Like It: It provides a polished horse-focused experience with strong simulation elements and a cozy aesthetic.
- #10 Tales of Rein Ravine
91% matchMostly Positive73% of 1,306 reviews2024
Dev: Maia the Horsegirl
Windows
Tales of Rein Ravine is an indie horse game that aims to challenge its players with unique real-life inspired riding, as well as tell an intriguing equestrian story to a young adult audience.
Why similar: Horses 74.3% ★, Female Protagonist 11.1%, Mystery 8.1%, Exploration 5.4%, Adventure 1.1%
Why You'll Like It: This title focuses on atmospheric, nature-based exploration with a strong emphasis on the horse-riding experience.
- #11 Palia
89% matchVery Positive86% of 44,545 reviews2024
Dev: Singularity 6 Corporation
Windows
Median: 2.0 hrsMean: 26.6 hrs≥1hr: 66%
Discover a welcoming world in Palia, a free-to-play fantasy life sim adventure where you can craft, explore, and create the life and home of your dreams. With nearly endless ways to make Palia your home, you’ll find relaxation and joy in every corner of this vibrant, heartwarming world.
Why similar: Cozy 28.6%, MMORPG 17% ★, Online Co-Op 11.8%, Mystery 9.4%, Multiplayer 8.9%
Why You'll Like It: This cozy, community-driven life simulation offers a relaxing open-world experience for those who enjoy the social aspects of the seed game.
- #12 My Horse: Bonded Spirits
90% matchMixed46% of 168 reviews2024
Dev: Games Incubator
Windows
Build a bond with your horse and gain its trust. Develop yours and the horse’s skills. Discover the surrounding open world. Complete tasks and take part in competitions. Rebuild a run-down stud farm!
Why similar: Horses 66.2% ★, Open World 12.8%, Relaxing 7.2%, Character Customization 6%, Female Protagonist 4.3%
Why You'll Like It: A dedicated horse simulation that focuses on the relationship between the player and their horse in an open world.
- #13 What Remains of Edith Finch
89% matchOverwhelmingly Positive96% of 53,006 reviews2017
Dev: Giant SparrowPub: Annapurna Interactive
Windows
Median: 2.6 hrsMean: 6.2 hrs≥1hr: 88%
What Remains of Edith Finch is a collection of strange tales about a family in Washington state. As Edith, you’ll explore the colossal Finch house, searching for stories as she explores her family history and tries to figure out why she's the last one in her family left alive.
Why similar: Story Rich 27.6%, Mystery 25.4%, Female Protagonist 16.1%, Exploration 14.4%, Psychological Horror 10.7%
Why You'll Like It: Its focus on uncovering the truth behind a family's history through environmental storytelling aligns with the mystery themes of the seed game.
- #14 The Legend of Khiimori
88% matchVery Positive83% of 2,316 reviews2026
Dev: Aesir InteractivePub: Mindscape
Windows
Median: 3.0 hrsMean: 12.0 hrs≥1hr: 72%
Take on the role of a brave courier rider in The Legend of Khiimori! Bond with your horse and tame the open wilds of 13th century Mongolia. Breed and train horses with specialized abilities to explore every aspect of this diverse and fascinating landscape.
Why similar: Horses 66.4% ★, Open World 14.2%, Female Protagonist 9.7%, Exploration 7.9%, Adventure 1.8%
Why You'll Like It: It combines historical horse-riding exploration with an open-world setting that feels expansive and adventurous.
- #15 Wild Indigo Ranch
87% matchMostly Positive70% of 467 reviews2024
Dev: Funday Games
Windows
Wild Indigo Ranch is a cozy cowboy-life RPG for 1-4 players. Start a new life on the prairie, explore the frontier, build the finest ranch in the West, and ride into the sunset.
Why similar: Horses 38.5% ★, Cozy 16.9%, Open World 10.2%, Online Co-Op 8.6%, Relaxing 6.1%
Why You'll Like It: The western setting and focus on exploration and life-simulation provide a similar thematic backdrop to the seed game.
- #16 Luma Island
86% matchVery Positive84% of 12,744 reviews2024
Dev: Feel Free Games
Windows
Median: 9.5 hrsMean: 24.0 hrs≥1hr: 88%
Get ready to explore, farm, fish, mine, craft, and raise magical Lumas as you solve puzzles and embark on quests across Luma Island. Play solo, or team up with friends in 1-4 player online co-op. Choose relaxing Cozy, challenging Adventure, or epic Hero mode to match your mood and playstyle.
Why similar: Cozy 28%, Online Co-Op 14.5%, Open World 11.6%, Character Customization 9.6%, Relaxing 9.2%
Why You'll Like It: A cozy, open-world simulation that encourages exploration and discovery in a relaxing environment.
- #17 Sky: Children of the Light
85% matchVery Positive87% of 25,374 reviews2024
Dev: thatgamecompany
Windows
Median: 1.4 hrsMean: 28.6 hrs≥1hr: 59%
A breathtaking open-world adventure awaits! Explore magical realms, restore lost light, and form wordless bonds with players worldwide. Complete quests and solve puzzles in seasonal events that celebrate kindness, discovery, and heartfelt connection.
Why similar: Cozy 26.8%, Massively Multiplayer 16.2%, Open World 14.9%, Online Co-Op 13.7%, Character Customization 11%
Why You'll Like It: Its emphasis on cozy, social, and atmospheric exploration makes it a great relaxing alternative.
- #18 Draugen
86% matchMostly Positive74% of 2,142 reviews2019
Dev: Red Thread Games
Windows
Median: 3.6 hrsMean: 4.3 hrs≥1hr: 82%
Draugen is a single-player, first-person Fjord Noir mystery set in 1920s Norway. Explore a forgotten coastal village in your search for your missing sister, accompanied by your independent and enigmatic young ward. Norwegian Game of the Year 2019.
Why similar: Detective 23%, Mystery 20.8%, Investigation 16.4%, Psychological Horror 13.8%, Story Rich 11.3%
Why You'll Like It: This atmospheric mystery game captures the feeling of investigating a small, isolated community with a dark secret.
- #19 Everholm
84% matchMostly Positive77% of 386 reviews2024
Dev: Chonky LoafPub: indie.io
Windows
Median: 1.0 hrsMean: 3.8 hrs≥1hr: 51%
Lilly was spirited away to a mysterious island. As her memories fade, everyone seems to know her and her quest for her missing sister. It’s time to establish a homestead, meet your friendly Everfolks, then learn their secrets and solve the mystery of Everholm, in this open-ended minimalist RPG!
Why similar: Cozy 40.5%, Mystery 18.1%, Female Protagonist 16.5%, Exploration 9.5%, RPG 8.2%
Why You'll Like It: This cozy RPG features a mystery-driven plot that fits well with the story-rich nature of the seed game.
- #20 Oxenfree
84% matchVery Positive91% of 12,124 reviews2016
Dev: Night School Studio
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 3.6 hrsMean: 5.4 hrs≥1hr: 88%
Oxenfree is a supernatural thriller about a group of friends who unwittingly open a ghostly rift. You are Alex, and you’ve just brought your new stepbrother Jonas to an overnight island party gone horribly wrong.
Why similar: Mystery 27.8%, Female Protagonist 24.5%, Story Rich 24.4%, Psychological Horror 12.4%, Horror 6.6%
Why You'll Like It: The game's focus on supernatural mystery and character-driven narrative provides a similar psychological intrigue.
- #21 Infinity Nikki
83% matchMixed57% of 10,549 reviews2025
Dev: Infold Games
Windows
Median: 6.3 hrsMean: 65.0 hrs≥1hr: 80%
Embark on a cozy open-world adventure filled with vast landscape, mystical puzzles and unexpected platforming challenges. Dress up not just for style, but to unravel hidden mysteries, interact with a vibrant environment, and experience the freedom to explore at your own pace.
Why similar: Open World 26.9%, Relaxing 19.5%, Character Customization 13.4%, Multiplayer 11.2%, Co-op 11%
Why You'll Like It: Its focus on relaxing, open-world exploration and cute aesthetics provides a similar low-stress gameplay loop.
- #22 Gaucho and the Grassland
82% matchOverwhelmingly Positive97% of 547 reviews2025
Dev: Epopeia Games
Windows
Median: 2.1 hrsMean: 4.4 hrs≥1hr: 79%
LIVE like a LATIN COWBOY as you EXPLORE, HELP others, and bring HARMONY between HUMANS and MYSTICAL BEINGS in a RELAXING COZY ADVENTURE.
Why similar: Horses 50.6% ★, Cozy 22.8%, Relaxing 7.6%, Exploration 6.2%, Character Customization 5.6%
Why You'll Like It: The focus on animal companionship and exploration in a vast, open landscape is a great thematic match.
- #23 Outer Wilds
82% matchOverwhelmingly Positive96% of 108,541 reviews2020
Dev: Mobius DigitalPub: Annapurna Interactive
Windows
Median: 4.7 hrsMean: 16.9 hrs≥1hr: 82%
Named Game of the Year 2019 by Giant Bomb, Polygon, Eurogamer, and The Guardian, Outer Wilds is a critically-acclaimed and award-winning open world mystery about a solar system trapped in an endless time loop.
Why similar: Mystery 26.8%, Open World 21.4%, Exploration 19.7%, Story Rich 14.1%, Psychological Horror 9.8%
Why You'll Like It: While sci-fi, its core loop of exploration and piecing together a deep, ancient mystery is a perfect match for the investigative spirit of the seed game.
- #24 On Your Tail
81% matchVery Positive88% of 415 reviews2024
Dev: Memorable GamesPub: Balor Games
Windows
Median: 4.5 hrsMean: 6.3 hrs≥1hr: 90%
A cozy detective adventure where you play as a vacation-bound writer who stumbles upon an idyllic town plagued by an enigmatic thief. Crack the case in this charming seaside town, build relationships, and unravel secrets in a world full of quirky characters and heartwarming stories.
Why similar: Cozy 23.2%, Investigation 17.5%, Detective 16.2%, Open World 12.3%, Mystery 11.7%
Why You'll Like It: A detective-themed life simulation that blends cozy, small-town vibes with investigative gameplay.
- #25 Hello Kitty Island Adventure
79% matchVery Positive94% of 12,538 reviews2025
Dev: Sunblink
Windows
Median: 9.3 hrsMean: 64.8 hrs≥1hr: 88%
Embark on a cozy, open-world adventure with Hello Kitty and Friends. Befriend beloved characters as you explore and restore a mysterious island, solve ancient puzzles, cook delicious dishes, customize yourself and your cabins, and so much more.
Why similar: Cozy 45.9%, Open World 20.8%, Exploration 9.6%, Relaxing 9.2%, Story Rich 6.4%
Why You'll Like It: A charming, open-world adventure that prioritizes cozy exploration and lighthearted mystery-solving.
- #26 My Little Pony: A Zephyr Heights Mystery
80% matchMixed67% of 206 reviews2024
Dev: Drakhar StudiosPub: Outright Games Ltd.
Windows
Median: 2.1 hrsMean: 9.6 hrs≥1hr: 64%
Take friendship to new heights and tame the chaotic magic that’s turning the world upside down, in a mystery adventure for one or two ponies!
Why similar: Horses 69% ★, Female Protagonist 9.1%, Multiplayer 8.1%, Exploration 7.4%, Co-op 3.5%
Why You'll Like It: This game offers a straightforward mystery-solving adventure that is accessible and fun.
- #27 Demonologist
78% matchVery Positive85% of 24,258 reviews2023
Dev: Clock Wizard Games
Windows
Median: 5.6 hrsMean: 18.2 hrs≥1hr: 89%
Demonologist is a Co-Op horror game that can be played with at least 1 and up to 4 players. Your goal is to identify the type of evil spirit in cursed places and exorcise it using your equipment, either alone or with your team.
Why similar: Investigation 19.7%, Online Co-Op 16.8%, Detective 16.2%, Psychological Horror 13.2%, Mystery 12.4%
Why You'll Like It: For those interested in the psychological horror aspect of the seed game, this provides a more intense investigative experience.
- #28 Project Unknown
78% matchVery Positive83% of 925 reviews2025
Dev: PsychoRavensPub: Nightmare Studios
Windows
Median: 2.1 hrsMean: 4.5 hrs≥1hr: 74%
An online co-op horror game featuring unique playable characters and RPG mechanics. Exorcise ghosts using your special abilities and tools while surviving the supernatural onslaught
Why similar: Investigation 20.8%, Online Co-Op 17.1%, Detective 14.7%, Psychological Horror 13.1%, Mystery 13.1%
Why You'll Like It: This title leans into the psychological horror and investigation elements, offering a more frightening take on the mystery genre.
- #29 Sound of Horses
77% matchVery Positive96% of 299 reviews2025
Dev: Vanilla Sky Productions AB
Windows
Sound of Horses is a story-driven horseback adventure. Begin your journey in the peaceful Homeland and uncover a world of hidden truths and distant echoes of something greater. Create your own rider and horse, explore an open world on horseback, and start your adventure.
Why similar: Horses 49.5% ★, Character Customization 10.1%, Cozy 9.6%, Female Protagonist 9.4%, Open World 9.3%
- #30 Shift At Midnight
76% matchVery Positive88% of 12,524 reviews2026
Dev: Bun MuenPub: Kwalee
Windows
Median: 4.0 hrsMean: 4.6 hrs≥1hr: 95%
An online co-op detective horror for up to 3 players. Work together across randomly generated shifts to investigate your customers, as some are only pretending to be human. Make one mistake, and you’ll be forced to board up, set traps, and hide.
Why similar: Online Co-Op 23.1%, Investigation 18%, Detective 14.5%, Mystery 12%, Multiplayer 9.6%
- #31 Nancy Drew®: Sea of Darkness
81% matchVery Positive93% of 232 reviews2017
Dev: HeR Interactive
Windows
Set a Course for Danger and Discovery!
Why similar: Investigation 25.2%, Detective 21%, Mystery 18.4%, Female Protagonist 14.1%, Exploration 11%
Why You'll Like It: A classic detective game that excels at environmental investigation and uncovering secrets in a remote location.
- #32 DreamWorks Spirit Lucky's Big Adventure
79% matchMostly Positive79% of 55 reviews2021
Dev: AHEARTFULOFGAMESPub: Outright Games Ltd.
Windows
Explore the wild frontier with Lucky’s faithful mustang, Spirit, and best friends, Abigail and Pru. Where will friendship, and a mysterious treasure map lead you?
Why similar: Horses 58.4% ★, Character Customization 9.3%, Female Protagonist 8.8%, Exploration 7.6%, Cozy 6.7%
Why You'll Like It: A wholesome horse-riding adventure that focuses on exploration and family-friendly storytelling.
- #33 My Horse: Bonded Spirits - Prologue
75% matchMixed58% of 226 reviews2024
Dev: Games Incubator
Windows
Median: 42 minMean: 2.1 hrs≥1hr: 33%
The Prologue is just part of the gameplay that awaits you in the full version. Build a bond with your horse and gain its trust. Develop yours and the horse’s skills. Discover the surrounding open world. Complete tasks and take part in competitions. Rebuild a run-down stud farm!
Why similar: Horses 73.6% ★, Open World 16.2%, Relaxing 3.1%, Character Customization 2.9%, Adventure 2.6%
- #34 Nancy Drew®: The Secret of Shadow Ranch
75% matchVery Positive89% of 228 reviews2017
Dev: HeR Interactive
Windows
Take a Wild Ride into Terror and Trickery to Rein in a Ghostly Secret!
Why similar: Horses 42.1% ★, Detective 14.2%, Mystery 12.1%, Investigation 11.4%, Female Protagonist 8.7%
- #35 Strange Horticulture
71% matchVery Positive94% of 16,173 reviews2022
Dev: Bad VikingPub: Iceberg Interactive
Windows · Mac
Median: 4.6 hrsMean: 5.9 hrs≥1hr: 82%
Strange Horticulture is an occult puzzle game in which you play as the proprietor of a local plant store. Find and identify new plants, pet your cat, speak to a coven, or join a cult. Use your collection of powerful plants to influence the story and unravel Undermere’s dark mysteries.
Why similar: Cozy 25.7%, Investigation 19.4%, Detective 17.1%, Mystery 14%, Relaxing 8%
- #36 Riding Out
76% matchMostly Negative36% of 176 reviews2016
Dev: UnexEvo
Windows
Riding Out is a new RPG (role play game) in a world in which everything revolves about horses! Explore the beautiful open world on the back of your horse, together with your friends. Experience exciting quests, build your own stable and create you own jumping courses, dressage competitions and race tracks.
Why similar: Horses 93.1% ★, RPG 6.9%
- #37 On Dark Terms
72% matchMixed68% of 83 reviews2024
Dev: Dimensionless Games
Windows
Explore an online 1-4 player co-op open-world horror RPG where you and your feline companion will investigate a post-apocalyptic world and fight back against the Darkness. Can you find a way to stop it?
Why similar: Investigation 29.3%, Open World 21.3%, Psychological Horror 13%, Detective 11.8%, Multiplayer 10.2%
- #38 Enigma of Fear
68% matchOverwhelmingly Positive97% of 10,353 reviews2024
Dev: Dumativa
Windows
Median: 5.0 hrsMean: 9.7 hrs≥1hr: 85%
Become Mia, a paranormal detective searching for her missing father inside the Perimeter - a place that doesn't exist. Investigate clues like a real detective and unravel the mysteries behind the Enigma of Fear, defeating the terrible monsters who'll try to stop you.
Why similar: Investigation 23.3%, Detective 18.4%, Mystery 15.9%, Open World 11.8%, Female Protagonist 10%
- #39 The Unicorn Princess
74% matchMixed64% of 109 reviews2019
Dev: Caipirinha GamesPub: Toplitz Productions
Windows
Explore the world on horseback and help the inhabitants of your village. Befriend Unica the unicorn and try to save the Dream World by completing all your missions!
Why similar: Horses 76.7% ★, Open World 7.7%, Female Protagonist 6.3%, Relaxing 3.8%, Adventure 3.5%
- #40 Riding Star - Horse Championship!
74% matchMixed68% of 121 reviews2014
Dev: SproingPub: familyplay
Windows
Ride like a world champion! Breathtaking action, challenges in show jumping, dressage and cross country riding are waiting for your talent.
Why similar: Horses 66.3% ★, MMORPG 9.9% ★, Open World 9.2%, Female Protagonist 7.7%, Psychological Horror 4.3%
- #41 Fae Farm
70% matchMostly Positive80% of 3,598 reviews2023
Dev: Phoenix LabsPub: Gambit Digital
Windows
Median: 9.1 hrsMean: 22.0 hrs≥1hr: 87%
Escape to the magical life of your dreams in Fae Farm, a farm sim RPG for 1-4 players. Craft, cultivate, and decorate to grow your homestead, and use spells to explore the enchanted island of Azoria!
Why similar: Cozy 49.8%, Relaxing 15.2%, Co-op 12.5%, Multiplayer 12.2%, RPG 10.3%
- #42 Villagers and Heroes
73% matchMixed61% of 3,462 reviews2014
Dev: Mad Otter Games
Windows
Median: 48 minMean: 12.1 hrs≥1hr: 44%
The Cozy MMO where adventure and home share the same world. Explore a vast fantasy realm, battle monsters, master crafting and gathering, build a home, and grow a village with friends old and new—free to play.
Why similar: MMORPG 24.1% ★, Cozy 21.7%, Massively Multiplayer 12.5%, Open World 11.9%, Online Co-Op 10.3%
- #43 Whispers in the West - Co-op Murder Mystery
71% matchMixed69% of 106 reviews2023
Dev: Infinite Whys
Windows · Mac
Whispers in the West is a point-and-click murder mystery game that supports online co-op for 1-4 players. Each story is an hour-long intriguing mystery waiting to be solved. You can either work solo or team up with your friends to solve the cases. Things may get heated!
Why similar: Detective 22%, Investigation 18.9%, Online Co-Op 18.1%, Mystery 16%, Story Rich 8.2%
- #44 Windstorm: Start of a Great Friendship
73% matchMostly Positive73% of 173 reviews2017
Dev: Aesir InteractivePub: Mindscape
Windows
Median: 3.3 hrsMean: 4.4 hrs≥1hr: 97%
Discover the fascinating story of Mika, a girl known as a horse whisperer, as she tries to befriend the black stallion called Windstorm.
Why similar: Horses 65.6% ★, Open World 13.1%, Female Protagonist 11.1%, Exploration 7.9%, Adventure 2.2%
- #45 My Riding Stables: Life with Horses
73% matchVery Positive88% of 284 reviews2014
Dev: SproingPub: familyplay
Windows
The Riding Stables at Mill Creek are mere ruins, but you are about to change that: stables, riding hall and guesthouse are being renovated and guests will happily pay for their stay...
Why similar: Horses 80.5% ★, Open World 8.7%, Female Protagonist 7.6%, RPG 1.8%, Adventure 1.4%
- #46 MetaPhysical
70% matchVery Positive80% of 408 reviews2023
Dev: Paper Promises Programming
Windows
Median: 9.3 hrsMean: 10.9 hrs≥1hr: 92%
Supernatural phenomena are on the rise. In MetaPhysical you and up to 5 other friends can go on the hunt for eerie creatures to put an end to their sinister activities! Whether it's an ordinary ghost or a demon, your task is to identify the rumbling creature and then finish it off.
Why similar: Detective 25.8%, Online Co-Op 19.5%, Mystery 18.4%, Psychological Horror 15.5%, Character Customization 15.5%
- #47 Friki
72% matchMixed58% of 71 reviews2022
Dev: Wompa Labs
Windows
Friki is an online co-op investigative horror. Solve how these supernatural beings have died, collect evidence to be paid, and survive the dangers that await you.
Why similar: Investigation 21.4%, Detective 19.3%, Online Co-Op 14.6%, Mystery 13%, Psychological Horror 11.4%
- #48 H.I.A: Horror Investigation Agency
70% matchMixed50% of 559 reviews2024
Dev: Kekdot
Windows
H.I.A: Horror Investigation Agency is a fun multiplayer horror game in which you and co-players have to investigate exciting horror cases. Among finding victims and evidence of the horror event that has taken place, you will be faced with jumpscares and scary monsters along your investigation.
Why similar: Investigation 21.2%, Online Co-Op 16.4%, Detective 14.2%, Psychological Horror 12.2%, Character Customization 9%
- #49 Mysterious School
71% matchMostly Negative36% of 1,911 reviews2023
Dev: DuoDuoDog
Windows
Median: 1.4 hrsMean: 3.6 hrs≥1hr: 62%
"Mysterious School" is a horror game that supports multi player online and single player. Why do girls often cry on campus at midnight? What happened to the once famous No.1 middle school? Take your partner, find out the truth that the young girl has become a zombie, and help the girl reincarnate.
Why similar: Massively Multiplayer 22.4%, MMORPG 21.9% ★, Psychological Horror 15%, Mystery 14.7%, Female Protagonist 12.5%
- #50 Harvest Island
69% matchVery Positive84% of 280 reviews2023
Dev: YobobPub: Yobob Games
Windows
Discover your sinister purpose in this horror farming game. Your idyllic farm life can't be trusted. Keep up with the façade as you give your crops to the gods. Explore the ominous island and question everything. You must fake your blissful farming days. Your life depends on it.
Why similar: Cozy 29.1%, Mystery 18.8%, Psychological Horror 15.1%, Exploration 11.3%, Story Rich 11.2%
- #51 Fayburrow
69% matchVery Positive81% of 489 reviews2022
Dev: The Fayburrow TroupePub: The Animation Workshop VIA
Windows
In a world of fairies, a childhood friend suddenly calls Beatrice back to her old hometown. Yet when she arrives, her friend is mysteriously missing.
Why similar: Investigation 23.3%, Detective 22.9%, Mystery 19.3%, Female Protagonist 14.6%, Story Rich 8.6%
- #52 A Day Out
67% matchMostly Positive77% of 751 reviews2024
Dev: KevTheDev
Windows
Median: 2.7 hrsMean: 4.7 hrs≥1hr: 83%
A Day Out is a monster-hunting and case-solving co-op third person shooter. Capture monsters and discover a new supernatural world with your friends!
Why similar: Online Co-Op 26.6%, Mystery 22.9%, Character Customization 17.3%, Horror 7.5%, Multiplayer 7%
- #53 Unicorn Tails
69% matchVery Positive95% of 142 reviews2020
Dev: RavenFist Studios LLC
Windows
Explore Unicorn Tails, a game filled with wonder, whimsy, and mystery where you can create your own unicorn, interact with unicorns and other creatures, solve puzzles, explore deep lore, and live in a fantasy world.
Why similar: Open World 30.9%, RPG 28.9%, Story Rich 13.6%, Exploration 13.5%, Adventure 13%
- #54 Welcome to Elderfield
64% matchVery Positive85% of 2,165 reviews2026
Dev: Chris CotePub: Kwalee
Windows
Median: 4.8 hrsMean: 14.3 hrs≥1hr: 72%
Welcome to Elderfield, a cozy horror RPG with hand-drawn art and dark lofi music. Manage your farm, befriend or romance the locals, investigate mysteries, decorate your home, fight terrifying creatures, fish, cook, seek the Old Gods, die in your sleep, and more... There's lots to do in Elderfield!
Why similar: Mystery 40.4%, Exploration 20.9%, RPG 17.7%, Horror 13.2%, Adventure 7.8%
- #55 Coral Island
66% matchVery Positive89% of 27,716 reviews2023
Dev: Stairway GamesPub: Balor Games
Windows
Median: 14.0 hrsMean: 56.6 hrs≥1hr: 82%
Coral Island is a vibrant, laid-back farm sim reimagined with multiplayer! Experience enchanting island life at your own pace: farm with friends, nurture animals, build relationships, hang out with a diverse cast of characters, and dive into the magical Merfolk Kingdom.
Why similar: Open World 27.7%, Relaxing 25%, Character Customization 24.7%, RPG 10.9%, Multiplayer 8.4%
- #56 Cattle Country
66% matchVery Positive86% of 385 reviews2025
Dev: Castle Pixel, LLC.Pub: Playtonic Friends
Windows · Linux
Howdy partner! Welcome to Cattle Country, the Cozy Cowboy Adventure Life Sim. Become a determined pioneer traveling west to start a new life. Make a home in the mountains, take on bandits, discover dastardly plots, build a farm, develop your town, and make friends with fellow residents.
Why similar: Cozy 45.3%, Character Customization 18.7%, Exploration 14.5%, Relaxing 13%, RPG 8.5%
- #57 Red Dead Online
67% matchVery Positive83% of 69,476 reviews2020
Dev: Rockstar Games
Windows
Median: 14.8 hrsMean: 75.7 hrs≥1hr: 92%
Step into the vibrant, ever-evolving world of Red Dead Online and experience life in frontier America. Chase down bounties, battle outlaw gangs and other players, hunt, fish and trade, search for exotic treasures, run Moonshine, and much more to discover in a world of astounding depth and detail.
Why similar: Horses 49.1% ★, Open World 15.9%, Online Co-Op 8.5%, Multiplayer 7.2%, MMORPG 6.9% ★
- #58 SEVERANCE
66% matchMostly Positive73% of 616 reviews2025
Dev: Sykes Games
Windows
Severance is a 1-5 player paranormal investigation game… with a twist. Use tools and equipment to identify the correct ghost type while a dangerous, violent entity hunts you down. The twist? YOU can become the ghost. Choose Ghost AI, or an asymmetrical mode where a player takes the Ghost role.
Why similar: Investigation 20.1%, Detective 18.6%, Online Co-Op 15.7%, Character Customization 12.8%, Mystery 9.5%
- #59 REKA
65% matchVery Positive82% of 3,496 reviews2024
Dev: Emberstorm EntertainmentPub: Fireshine Games
Windows
Median: 2.0 hrsMean: 4.6 hrs≥1hr: 70%
Channel your inner witch! Build your cozy chicken-legged hut, practice witchcraft, and forage for ingredients in autumnal woodlands. Solve quests & uncover the great mysteries of the legendary witch Baba Jaga…
Why similar: Cozy 31.9%, Open World 17.5%, Character Customization 15.9%, Psychological Horror 13.1%, Exploration 10.3%
