- #1 Severed Lands
97% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Severed Lands
Windows
Severed Lands is an open-world sandbox MMORPG featuring crafting, base-building, a player-driven economy, full-loot, and sieges. Flourish as warriors, merchants or seasoned professionals. Severed Lands provides the freedom to pursue your desired goals and discover the optimal path to attain them.
Why similar: MMORPG 30.7% ★, Massively Multiplayer 14.7%, Sandbox 11.3%, Base Building 10.4%, Survival 10%
- #2 Canvas Legacy
96% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Lantto Games
Windows · Mac · Linux
Canvas Legacy is a sandbox MMORPG with a fully player-driven economy, featuring open-world housing where all shops are run by players. Explore dungeons, fight bosses, participate in Kingdom wars and even become King yourself. Or just build your dream house and paint nice things.
Why similar: MMORPG 36.8% ★, Sandbox 12.5%, Base Building 12.1%, Massively Multiplayer 11.6%, PvP 5.3%
- #3 Mithrall
96% matchNo user reviews2027
Dev: Mithrall Industries
Windows
Mithrall is a Massive sandbox survival game with epic battles, dynamic exploration & real-time conquest. Shape the world, forge your legacy, and dominate in servers of up to 15,000 players in a living, breathing dwarven realm of war, trade, and ancient power.
Why similar: MMORPG 30.3% ★, Massively Multiplayer 14.5%, Base Building 12.1%, Sandbox 10.1%, PvP 7.4%
- #4 Albion Online
95% matchMostly Positive79% of 92,384 reviews2018
Dev: Sandbox Interactive GmbH
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 3.5 hrsMean: 83.5 hrs≥1hr: 73%
Albion Online is a fantasy sandbox MMORPG featuring a player-driven economy, classless combat system, and intense PvP battles. Explore a vast open world full of danger and opportunity. Grow your wealth, forge alliances, and leave your mark on the world of Albion.
Why similar: MMORPG 43.8% ★, Massively Multiplayer 15.4%, Sandbox 10%, Open World 7.2%, Survival 6.2%
- #5 Fallen Mankind MMO
93% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Mikko Hämäläinen
Windows
Good morning, loner. Welcome to hell. In Fallen Mankind MMO, Explore The Zone, survive deadly anomalies, and choose your path among three factions. Build bases, battle players, face horrors, and uncover secrets in a hardcore, open-world MMO inspired by STALKER and survival classics.
Why similar: MMORPG 32.7% ★, Sandbox 13.6%, Base Building 12.1%, PvP 8.9%, PvE 8.5%
- #6 Wandaria
92% matchNo user reviews
Dev: JDL Studio
Windows
In Wandaria, use magic to survive against creatures, rivals, and world dangers. Build, cultivate, and explore mysterious lands. Form alliances or defend your domain. Magic is your greatest weapon.
Why similar: MMORPG 17.1% ★, Massively Multiplayer 16.7%, Base Building 13.6%, Survival 11.3%, Sandbox 10%
- #7 Starting Life In Another World Naked
91% matchMixed67% of 12 reviews2022
Dev: AsGLeague Studios
Windows
You will venture into a world much like ours before you are "taken" to another world, a fantasy world. You are the hero of this new world, but sadly you start off with nothing. You must survive and build your way to defeating the Demon King; that's why you were summoned in the first place.
Why similar: MMORPG 29.3% ★, Base Building 12.8%, Survival 11.2%, Sandbox 11%, PvP 5.6%
- #8 DAWN OF ARBA
91% matchNo user reviews
Dev: No Clue
Windows
Become a new adventurer in a massive online multiplayer adventure. Explore the new Dawn emerging over the horizon of a new world, ARBA. Although beautiful at first sight, ARBA's history harbors a hidden secret and a much deeper and dangerous truth.
Why similar: MMORPG 25.2% ★, Massively Multiplayer 12.9%, Sandbox 11.2%, Survival 10.8%, Base Building 9.8%
- #9 Myth of Empires: Conquest
90% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Angela GamePub: Zavod NGG
Windows
Myth of Empires: Завоевания is a grand MMO survival sandbox with a living world where everything depends on you. Build settlements, raise armies, wage wars, or develop the economy — every choice leaves its mark on history.
Why similar: MMORPG 29.9% ★, Sandbox 15.3%, Survival 12.6%, Massively Multiplayer 11.8%, Base Building 9%
- #10 Neden
89% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Asobiholic Co.,Ltd
Windows
Play in a virtual world by creating your own character in a tons of different game modes with your friends. Join the Neden community.
Why similar: MMORPG 28% ★, Massively Multiplayer 14.8%, Sandbox 11.9%, Base Building 11.3%, Survival 9.9%
- #11 Spire Horizon Online
89% matchMixed67% of 353 reviews2024
Dev: Mendoka
Windows
Spire Horizon Online is an MMORPG where players become skeleton adventurers on a quest to find their capybara friend. Choose from a variety of classes, battle numerous monsters, and explore diverse regions.
Why similar: MMORPG 37.8% ★, Massively Multiplayer 18.5%, PvP 6.4%, PvE 6.3%, Action RPG 6.2%
- #12 Rise of Agon
88% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Big Picture Games
Windows
Rise of Agon is a fantasy MMORPG with fast paced, competitive first person combat, a vast and seamless open world and a game focused on risk vs reward. Join battles of thousands of players in an open PvP environment where player skill and group strategy determines the outcome.
Why similar: MMORPG 40.2% ★, Massively Multiplayer 23.2%, PvE 7.8%, PvP 7.6%, Open World 5.8%
- #13 Infinigama
87% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Anton Vatchenko
Windows
Explore a universe of diverse worlds. Jump between adventures, trade, craft, and meet other players. Each world offers unique challenges, while a shared economy and evolving environments let your actions ripple across the entire connected universe.
Why similar: MMORPG 39.2% ★, Massively Multiplayer 12.6%, Base Building 11.3%, RPG 8.9%, PvP 6.7%
- #14 Mortal Online
86% matchMixed52% of 2,959 reviews2015
Dev: Star Vault AB
Windows
Median: 54 minMean: 20.9 hrs≥1hr: 47%
Mortal Online is a first-person medieval fantasy MMORPG, set in a huge, open, unforgiving world. Choose your race, choose your playstyle, choose a profession, choose where to place your loyalties - if you have any...
Why similar: MMORPG 26.1% ★, Massively Multiplayer 21.3%, Sandbox 15%, Survival 10.5%, Open World 8.5%
- #15 Inferna
86% matchMixed62% of 2,217 reviews2019
Dev: INFERNA UG (haftungsbeschränkt)
Windows · Mac
Median: 54 minMean: 4.0 hrs≥1hr: 48%
Classic free-to-play open-world MMORPG with grind, PvP, and a risky upgrade system up to +10. Level 1–100 with no resets. 33 maps. Crossplay for PC & mobile (Android beta).
Why similar: MMORPG 37.3% ★, Massively Multiplayer 16.8%, Sandbox 9.2%, PvP 6.5%, PvE 6.2%
- #16 Life is Feudal: Arden
84% matchMixed41% of 867 reviews2025
Dev: LTG
Windows
Median: 3.4 hrsMean: 28.1 hrs≥1hr: 75%
Life is Feudal: Arden is a new free-to-play open-world MMORPG set in the Middle Ages, built on the foundation of Life is Feudal: MMO. Engage in thrilling PvP combat, navigate political intrigue, master a variety of professions and craft unique items. Forge your own path to power and greatness!
Why similar: MMORPG 35.3% ★, Sandbox 13.4%, Base Building 10.1%, Survival 8.3%, Massively Multiplayer 6.4%
- #17 Dark and Light
85% matchMixed52% of 11,821 reviews2017
Dev: Snail Games USA
Windows
Median: 8.2 hrsMean: 49.2 hrs≥1hr: 84%
Dark and Light is a vast sandbox survival RPG set in a world dominated by powerful elemental forces. Find your way in a meticulously crafted world, featuring breathtaking landscapes, a wide variety of mythical creatures, and limitless possibility to craft, build, and unlock dozens of powerful weapons, spells, and skills.
Why similar: MMORPG 22.3% ★, Massively Multiplayer 19.4%, Survival 15.1%, Sandbox 14%, Open World 8%
- #18 Tales Of Shadowland
84% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Uzmi Games
Windows
Experience the freedom of a classic RPG within a cutting-edge, free-to-play, open-world, multiplayer online experience. Explore, fight, collect, build, and conquer alongside your friends, and against your enemies, without any pay-to-win elements, all while immersing yourself in the story of Eurone.
Why similar: MMORPG 31.7% ★, Massively Multiplayer 14.4%, Sandbox 10.6%, PvE 6.9%, PvP 6.1%
- #19 Wurm Online
83% matchMixed63% of 2,546 reviews2020
Dev: Code Club AB
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 54 minMean: 39.3 hrs≥1hr: 47%
A sandbox MMORPG that has pushed the boundaries on what it means to be open world and stood the test of time. Dig, mine, shape the world around you and make your lasting mark!
Why similar: MMORPG 30.5% ★, Massively Multiplayer 19.9%, Sandbox 18.2%, RPG 6.6%, Survival 6.1%
- #20 Rogalia
82% matchMostly Positive70% of 534 reviews2018
Dev: TatriX
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 4.0 hrsMean: 21.0 hrs≥1hr: 70%
Rogalia is the sandbox with fantasy open world, meal-based character leveling, nice graphics and cozy atmosphere.
Why similar: MMORPG 28.7% ★, Massively Multiplayer 25.8%, Sandbox 14.2%, Survival 11.4%, Open World 6.3%
- #21 HuaBing
82% matchMostly Negative38% of 24 reviews2023
Dev: Dust Studio
Windows
Pictorial Pie is a large multi-person online role-playing game in the Xianxia sandbox. With the growth of martial arts, the construction of the Zongmen and the Cave, and the free PVP battle, dangers and opportunities can be seen everywhere.
Why similar: MMORPG 37.6% ★, Sandbox 14%, Survival 8.5%, Base Building 7.9%, RPG 6.3%
- #22 Throne and Liberty
80% matchMixed67% of 68,409 reviews2024
Dev: NCPub: Amazon Game Studios
Windows
Median: 4.8 hrsMean: 77.8 hrs≥1hr: 78%
Throne and Liberty captures the essence of classic MMORPGs while introducing new gameplay elements, depth and excitement at every turn. Gather your guild, prepare for battle, and set forth for throne... and liberty!
Why similar: MMORPG 47.9% ★, Massively Multiplayer 16.9%, PvP 7.3%, Open World 6.8%, PvE 6.2%
- #23 Knight Online
81% matchMixed51% of 11,219 reviews2016
Dev: Noah SystemPub: NTTGame
Windows
Median: 48 minMean: 164.9 hrs≥1hr: 47%
The Great Battle between Karus and El Morad has arrived to Steam! Pledge allegiance to one of the Nations and put your skills to the test in one of the best PvP system in the MMORPG universe!
Why similar: MMORPG 56% ★, Massively Multiplayer 19.5%, PvP 6.6%, Survival 4.7%, Open World 4.5%
- #24 Wild Terra Online
81% matchMixed60% of 1,842 reviews2017
Dev: Juvty Worlds
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 6.5 hrsMean: 9.8 hrs≥1hr: 84%
Wild Terra Online is a sandbox RPG, in a completely player-controlled medieval world. You will have to survive in a forest full of predators, build a shelter and improve your crafts skills, tame animals and fight for treasures. You can become anyone and do whatever you want!
Why similar: MMORPG 21.1% ★, Massively Multiplayer 20.1%, Sandbox 14.9%, Survival 13%, Base Building 8.5%
- #25 Irehon
79% matchNo user reviews
Dev: ReMouse Games
Windows · Mac
Action MMORPG game in a fantasy setting. Explore the world, craft your weapon and equipment, engage in fights with other players and unravel the secrets of this strange world with your friends.
Why similar: MMORPG 46.8% ★, Massively Multiplayer 12.3%, PvP 7.7%, Open World 7.6%, Fantasy 5.1%
- #26 DIElectric World
79% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Andrey Larionenko
Windows
DIElectric World is an MMO sandbox RPG set on a mysterious planet where modern technology has failed. Build thriving settlements, transform the environment, master professions, survive a living world shaped by the seasons, and uncover the secrets of the enigmatic mineral Keplerite.
Why similar: MMORPG 37.6% ★, Base Building 13.8%, Sandbox 13.5%, Massively Multiplayer 11.6%, Exploration 5.7%
- #27 Legends of Aria Eternal
78% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Emergent Worlds
Windows
Legends of Aria Eternal is a sandbox MMORPG where players shape the world. Now with faster skill gains, a reworked prestige and enchanting system, full in-game knowledge base, and powerful new tools to run your own custom server.
Why similar: MMORPG 37% ★, Massively Multiplayer 13.8%, Sandbox 11.7%, PvP 8.5%, PvE 8.4%
- #28 New World: Aeternum
78% matchMixed67% of 296,710 reviews2021
Dev: Amazon Game Studios
Windows
Median: 58.9 hrsMean: 196.9 hrs≥1hr: 98%
Experience a thrilling action RPG set on the supernatural island of Aeternum. Forge your destiny on an adventure filled with danger and opportunity.
Why similar: MMORPG 43.3% ★, Massively Multiplayer 20.3%, Open World 8.1%, PvP 6.9%, PvE 6.3%
- #29 Persist Online
77% matchNo user reviews
Dev: CipSoft GmbH
Windows · Mac · Linux
Persist Online is an MMORPG with zombies, so you better grab yourself a gun. Level up in an unforgiving open world where you can enter every building. Form a deadly team with friends to claim what’s not yours. Take your loot to the Safehouse and craft perfect gear. Some survive. The best persist!
Why similar: MMORPG 36.1% ★, Massively Multiplayer 16.6%, Sandbox 11.5%, PvP 9.6%, Survival 7.1%
- #30 Runes of Magic
77% matchMixed69% of 1,528 reviews2018
Dev: Runewaker EntertainmentPub: Gameforge 4D GmbH
Windows
Median: 1.0 hrsMean: 40.0 hrs≥1hr: 51%
Start your heroic saga today in a world full of magic and excitement: Choose your race, build a home and discover the fantastic world of Taborea in the classic free-to-play MMO!
Why similar: MMORPG 47.2% ★, Massively Multiplayer 20.9%, RPG 6.3%, PvP 5.3%, Action RPG 4.4%
- #31 RPG MO
76% matchMostly Positive79% of 2,950 reviews2015
Dev: Marxnet
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 54 minMean: 22.8 hrs≥1hr: 48%
RPG MO is a nostalgic MMORPG that reminds of Ultima and Runescape Classic.
Why similar: MMORPG 46.7% ★, Massively Multiplayer 21%, Sandbox 8.5%, RPG 8.1%, Open World 4.9%
- #32 depthminer
74% matchNo user reviews
Dev: George Cowden (Art, Programming, Producer)Pub: Lobodious
Windows
Burn down the server in this upcoming survival mmo
Why similar: MMORPG 27.6% ★, Massively Multiplayer 17.5%, Base Building 14.1%, Survival 12%, PvP 8.8%
- #33 Grace Online
73% matchMostly Negative21% of 24 reviews2023
Dev: wichtv ltd
Windows
Grace Online is a 3D fantasy MMORPG featuring an immersive experience that allows the players to forge their own paths through exploration and discovery.
Why similar: MMORPG 31.7% ★, Massively Multiplayer 14.5%, Sandbox 11.8%, PvP 7.9%, PvE 7.4%
- #34 Crownless
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: HolyTrinityGames
Windows
Forge your path in Crownless, an indie-fantasy MMORPG with many roads to explore. Discover dangerous worlds, experience meaningful progression, and engage with the community along your journey!
Why similar: MMORPG 41.5% ★, Massively Multiplayer 23.9%, PvP 8.6%, PvE 8.5%, RPG 6.8%
- #35 Ryzom
74% matchMixed70% of 534 reviews2016
Dev: Winch Gate Property Limited
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 36 minMean: 12.0 hrs≥1hr: 42%
Enter a unique science fantasy MMORPG and dive into a unique organic living world !
Why similar: MMORPG 34.2% ★, Massively Multiplayer 15.5%, Sandbox 11.6%, PvP 6.4%, Action RPG 6.3%
- #36 Might of Spells®
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Nucate
Windows
An sandbox open-world MMORPG that brings back the nostalgic charm of the top-down view, offering demanding and engaging gameplay with modern graphics and pure, straightforward PvP, where combat, free from excessive visual effects, allows players to focus on the true dynamics of battle.
Why similar: MMORPG 40.7% ★, Massively Multiplayer 16.3%, Sandbox 12%, Base Building 11.4%, Open World 5.9%
- #37 Leafling Reborn
72% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Celtaria
Windows · Mac · Linux
2D Pixel Art MMORPG passion project reboot of Leafling Online. Fight, craft, socialize, and explore a beautiful and deep open world. Free-to-play now and forever with NO pay-to-win.
Why similar: MMORPG 30.1% ★, Sandbox 15.4%, Massively Multiplayer 12.3%, PvP 9.2%, PvE 9.2%
- #38 Dark Continent
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Armagan
Windows
A fast-paced action MMORPG where every strike is aimed and every dodge matters. Take on epic bosses, experience responsive real-time combat, and enjoy full control—no tab-targeting, no auto-play, and no Pay2Win.
Why similar: MMORPG 35.8% ★, Massively Multiplayer 14.6%, PvP 8.9%, PvE 8.4%, Action RPG 7.9%
- #39 Xsyon - Prelude
71% matchMostly Positive73% of 369 reviews2014
Dev: Notorious Games
Windows
Xsyon is a player driven apocalyptic fantasy sandbox MMORPG, set in a living and evolving environment. Players create the world they want to live in as they form tribes, construct towns, shape landscapes, create quests, hunt, farm, gather, build societies and develop a New World.
Why similar: MMORPG 28.1% ★, Base Building 13.8%, Sandbox 12.3%, Survival 11.3%, Open World 5.8%
- #40 Anseion - Fantasy MMORPG
70% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: pheXion
Windows
Get ready for a journey to the world of Anseion, an immersive 2D MMORPG. Choose your faction: good or evil. Fight against players and monsters, explore the fascinating world, collect items and create your own. Make a unique character. Participate in events and faction battles, increase your rank.
Why similar: MMORPG 35.2% ★, Massively Multiplayer 17.2%, PvP 7.4%, Action RPG 7%, PvE 6.8%
- #41 Neverwinter
70% matchMostly Positive77% of 39,549 reviews2013
Dev: Cryptic StudiosPub: Arc Games
Windows
Median: 6.3 hrsMean: 40.6 hrs≥1hr: 83%
Neverwinter is a free, action MMORPG based on the acclaimed Dungeons & Dragons fantasy roleplaying game. Epic stories, action combat and classic roleplaying await those heroes courageous enough to enter the fantastic world of Neverwinter!
Why similar: MMORPG 54.7% ★, Massively Multiplayer 19.2%, RPG 6.8%, Open World 4.5%, Fantasy 4.2%
- #42 Shroud of the Avatar: Forsaken Virtues
71% matchMixed53% of 3,162 reviews2018
Dev: Catnip Games
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 3.3 hrsMean: 150.8 hrs≥1hr: 72%
SHROUD OF THE AVATAR: FORSAKEN VIRTUES is a multiplayer fantasy RPG that sets the player on a path filled with peril and tough choices as they explore a persistent realm that can be shared with other Avatars. It is the spiritual successor to Richard Garriott’s Ultima games.
Why similar: MMORPG 34.9% ★, Massively Multiplayer 16.4%, Sandbox 13.1%, PvP 6.9%, PvE 6.7%
- #43 Turf Battles
69% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Eonic Games
Windows
Become a legend as you amass PK Points, conquer & defend islands/turfs from enemy players for valuable rewards, and progress through the game in all of its PvE and PvP glory.
Why similar: MMORPG 35.8% ★, Massively Multiplayer 17.1%, PvP 9.7%, PvE 8.1%, Action RPG 6.6%
- #44 Pixel Heroes
69% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Screaming E! Studio
Windows
Pixel Heroes is a new and coming Free-To-Play MMORPG. Explore the unexplored, grow your stats and build allies so you together can defeat the great terrors of Uzoria.
Why similar: MMORPG 48.4% ★, Massively Multiplayer 14.3%, Fantasy 6.4%, Exploration 6.2%, PvE 6.1%
- #45 Stars Reach
69% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Playable Worlds, Inc.
Windows
Explore a living galaxy in Stars Reach. Discover new planets, build settlements, and shape environments that react to everything you do. Players work together to transform untamed worlds into thriving civilizations across a single shared universe.
Why similar: MMORPG 35% ★, Base Building 15.2%, Massively Multiplayer 13.3%, Sandbox 10.4%, PvE 7.5%
- #46 Echofall
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Echo Studios
Windows
A fun filled shooter game with multiple game modes, single player and multiplayer action. Hop into Ravenquest today and experience what the newest FPS has to offer.
Why similar: MMORPG 47.8% ★, Massively Multiplayer 21.6%, PvP 8%, Exploration 7.4%, PvE 6.3%
- #47 Undawn
68% matchMixed54% of 6,593 reviews2023
Dev: Lightspeed StudiosPub: Level Infinite
Windows
Median: 1.3 hrsMean: 40.9 hrs≥1hr: 56%
Explore, adapt, and survive in Undawn, a free-to-play open-world survival RPG for mobile and PC developed by LightSpeed Studios and published by Level Infinite. Embark on an adventure with other survivors four years after a worldwide disaster where hordes of infected roam a shattered world.
Why similar: MMORPG 33.5% ★, Massively Multiplayer 17.4%, Survival 13.1%, Sandbox 9%, Open World 7%
- #48 Haven & Hearth
66% matchMostly Positive73% of 991 reviews2024
Dev: Seatribe
Windows · Mac · Linux
A free-to-play MMORPG with crafting, building, landscaping, foraging, hunting, fishing, a dash of poetry, and open PvP combat,
Why similar: MMORPG 31.1% ★, Sandbox 11.7%, Base Building 11.1%, Massively Multiplayer 10.9%, Survival 9.8%
- #49 MythicMonsterOutlaws
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: BestGameStudios
Windows
Skip the grind and dive into an MMO focused entirely on skill-based PvP and PvE combat. Unlock weapons and skills to expand your build variety, not your power. Competitive leaderboards, instanced raids, and fast-paced arenas—mythic combat starts the moment you create a character.
Why similar: MMORPG 45.7% ★, Massively Multiplayer 27.5%, PvE 8.3%, PvP 8.2%, Action RPG 4.4%
- #50 The Elder Scrolls® Online
67% matchVery Positive81% of 160,716 reviews2017
Dev: ZeniMax Online StudiosPub: Bethesda Softworks
Windows · Mac
Median: 17.8 hrsMean: 176.9 hrs≥1hr: 96%
Every legend starts somewhere and in The Elder Scrolls Online, it starts with you. Join millions of players in an online, fantasy RPG set in a vast living Elder Scrolls world.
Why similar: MMORPG 42.1% ★, Massively Multiplayer 16.3%, RPG 7%, Open World 6.9%, Exploration 6.2%
- #51 EverQuest II
67% matchMostly Positive79% of 2,899 reviews2011
Dev: Darkpaw GamesPub: Daybreak Game Company
Windows
Median: 2.8 hrsMean: 43.0 hrs≥1hr: 72%
EverQuest® II is a deep fantasy MMORPG with over two decades of content, a thriving world, and ongoing expansions that keep Norrath growing. Create your hero and adventure through a massively rich, ever-evolving universe.
Why similar: MMORPG 48.4% ★, Massively Multiplayer 24.9%, RPG 8.1%, Open World 4.5%, Fantasy 4.5%
- #52 KhanII M
65% matchMostly Negative22% of 18 reviews2026
Dev: CDOT
Windows
The legendary MMORPG returns. KHAN 2 M brings back the classic experience with modern systems—story content, seasonal battle pass, events, and a challenging tower climb filled with escalating rewards.
Why similar: MMORPG 38.4% ★, Massively Multiplayer 18.3%, RPG 9.9%, Action RPG 9.4%, PvE 5.6%