Games Like Hummelier 2

The darkness surrounding the Odyssey Coffee House is undeniable, but what’s the connection behind these unusual occurrences? Who’s the culprit? Dark Brew is a mystery/thriller cafe simulator set amongst the stars. Play as Leon the racoon, and manage the coffee house while talking to patrons.

Why similar: Shop Keeper 27.6% ★, Mystery 10.9%, Emotional 9.5%, Dark 9.4%, Story Rich 7.9%

Run a night-shift bakery inside a quarantine zone. Every customer looks human at first. Check their symptoms, fill the report, and make the call — bread, medicine, or the knife. Keep your supplies stocked and beware what waits outside the glass.

Why similar: Shop Keeper 33.3% ★, Psychological Horror 14.1%, Life Sim 13.6%, Choices Matter 11.9%, Mystery 9.6%

Maybe you didn’t do it… but you watched. The Sin of Fabien is a psychological horror experience woven around guilt, denial, and silence, where every choice reshapes the world and the story. Each decision brings you closer to the truth… or pulls you further away from it forever.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 17%, Dark 13.1%, Choices Matter 12.6%, Emotional 10.6%, Story Rich 9.1%

Congratulations! You're hired as a new waterer in Black Kiwa. Water the plants, and we'll pay you 30 G per hour. You'll never find any other job this generous. No, we're not hiding anything from you. If you just follow the work protocols and stay out of trouble, everything will be fine.

Why similar: Multiple Endings 16.1%, Psychological Horror 15.8%, Mystery 13.3%, Choices Matter 12.8%, Story Rich 10.6%

James is trapped in an unknown mansion. As he desperately searches for a way out, he finds that his wife, Mary is trapped there as well. Lurking in the darkness is a monster that’s hunting you. Untangle the riddles that bar your path, and uncover the truth behind this deathly nightmare.

Why similar: Emotional 12.5%, Psychological Horror 12.3%, Multiple Endings 10.7%, Choices Matter 10.5%, Mystery 8.9%

Paper Lily is an RPG horror game in which you can solve puzzles in different ways. Explore a hidden world, meet strange characters, and guide Lacie as she attempts to find answers about her unusual condition.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 19%, Multiple Endings 11.5%, Pixel Graphics 11.4%, Choices Matter 11%, Story Rich 10%

Michael Longhurst had just survived a terrible ordeal at Hartown Park. Two months later, he returns with his partner, Ethan. As they try and uncover the cursed history of the Longhurst Family.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 14.5%, Choices Matter 12.2%, Multiple Endings 11.5%, Emotional 10.7%, Top-Down 9.6%

Project Kat is a short, unconventional RPG horror game in which there is always another way. Solve puzzles, make friends (or not), and guide Kat as she attempts to uncover the mystery behind a strange golden letter.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 18.8%, Multiple Endings 11.7%, Choices Matter 11.4%, Pixel Graphics 10.6%, Story Rich 9.3%

Take a night shift job in a place that runs on habit, not purpose. Restock shelves, take deliveries, clean the mess, and try to make it till morning. Not everything feels right and you’re never quite alone. Something waits in the dark.

Why similar: Shop Keeper 27.3% ★, Life Sim 14.3%, Psychological Horror 11.6%, Multiple Endings 10.1%, Choices Matter 10%

Rose must escape the Cursed Mansion - a demonic space that preys and feeds on fear and despair. In this horror RPG you'll solve puzzles and learn the mansion’s history. Mystery, malignant spirits, and misery everywhere. Cursed Mansion brings an eerie atmosphere which leaves one with goosebumps.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 14%, Multiple Endings 13.5%, Choices Matter 13%, Dark 11.3%, Mystery 10.7%

Follow Sybil in her pursuit for survival, having to sacrifice everything - her culture, her identity, her values - to achieve a single objective: escape from a place that is constantly trying to kill her. A short game about persecution and identity.

Why similar: Emotional 19.4%, Multiple Endings 16.8%, Dark 14.1%, Story Rich 11.4%, Choices Matter 10%

May Campbell moved to the island of Cassiopeia years ago to live with her grandfather. Now, she tries to survive day by day in a rotting world. Solve puzzles, uncover truths, and help May see tomorrow's daylight in this strange narrative-driven exploration/puzzle game.

Why similar: Emotional 17.4%, Multiple Endings 16.9%, Story Rich 10.6%, Atmospheric 9.2%, Pixel Graphics 8.2%

Death, redemption, distortion, love, and... you are the reason.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 19.8%, Emotional 16.5%, Dark 13.7%, Story Rich 11.1%, Mystery 9.5%

A completely self-contained portable version of one of the highest user-rated games. Built on an entirely new engine with new UI, support for Steam Deck, & more. Features world-bending puzzles, intriguing denizens, surreal environments, and a captivating story about the truth of the game's reality.

Why similar: Multiple Endings 16.5%, Choices Matter 16.2%, Story Rich 12.9%, Pixel Graphics 10.9%, Emotional 8.3%

"GUROBU" is a story-driven, 2D horror game about haunted apartments, ghosts of the past, and a murder mystery.

Why similar: Choices Matter 13.3%, Multiple Endings 13.1%, Psychological Horror 12.8%, Dark 10.9%, Emotional 10.8%

In a creaky old tavern, in a forgotten corner of the video-game universe, a storm is raging. An anonymous caller suggests that there is a murder plot. Six video game protagonists are the only plausible suspects...

Why similar: Psychological Horror 20.2%, Mystery 16.3%, Story Rich 13.4%, Dark 11.1%, Pixel Graphics 8.7%

Shop Crush is a mysterious shop-owner simulator with psychological horror elements set in the early 2000s.

Why similar: Shop Keeper 30.8% ★, Psychological Horror 14.4%, Emotional 13.9%, Life Sim 12.3%, Choices Matter 7.5%

Njuma is a 2D narrative driven pixel game with multiple endings. Be the difference your family needs as they draw their final breath.

Why similar: Dark 18.9%, Choices Matter 18.5%, Pixel Graphics 15.9%, Multiple Endings 14.7%, Mystery 9.7%

DONT OPEN is a PSX-style horror game about routine that falls apart before your eyes. A normal shift at a taco bar, an empty stairwell, and a persistent knock on the door that's impossible to ignore. Based on real events.

Why similar: Shop Keeper 38.1% ★, Life Sim 19%, Psychological Horror 10.9%, Multiple Endings 8.2%, Choices Matter 7.4%

You play as Hicha — a shut-in girl whose only reason to live is her virtual avatar, Virai. Help her escape the depressive nightmare before it consumes her completely.

Why similar: Life Sim 19.8%, Psychological Horror 18.6%, Multiple Endings 12.1%, Choices Matter 11.6%, Story Rich 10.2%

Suddenly, you found yourself in a strange world. "You must take this egg to the West Tower." The story begins when a large creature who claims to be the king gives you an egg. You must see with your own eyes what happens when you take the egg to the west tower.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 21.3%, Multiple Endings 17.7%, Pixel Graphics 16.1%, Choices Matter 9.5%, Story Rich 8.5%

Alex is desperate. To save his sick mother, he takes a job at Marilyn's trendy cat cafe. But five years ago, his father died here among others. Serve coffee, follow the rules, and survive the night shift to uncover the dark truth behind the cafe's perfect image.

Why similar: Shop Keeper 40.4% ★, Life Sim 19.9%, Psychological Horror 10.3%, Multiple Endings 8.3%, Exploration 7.3%

Step into a world where dreams and reality mix. You find yourself in a dream-like world, and explore a different traumatic experience each day. Your choice determines if the boy accepts these moments and moves on, or stays in the past.

Why similar: Emotional 15.1%, Choices Matter 13.9%, Dark 13.6%, Multiple Endings 13.1%, Psychological Horror 12.2%

No Sleep for Sole is a surreal survival horror game about mental illness and abuse. You play as a young boy named Sole who stays awake at night to protect himself from the monsters he sees around his home.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 17.9%, Emotional 15.3%, Multiple Endings 14.7%, Choices Matter 13.7%, Dark 12.2%

STIGMA is a truly small indie game. It is a psychological detective horror focused on atmosphere and mystery. Uncover the haunting narrative of an old house and its forgotten past.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 18.4%, Choices Matter 14.8%, Multiple Endings 14.7%, Emotional 14.4%, Mystery 11.7%

The world ended long ago. Humanity didn’t. What remains is a fragile society sustained by fear and distrust. Faro is a psychological horror visual novel set on a sunless planet, where you guide four survivors as cosmic horrors linger and every decision erodes the trust holding them together.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 18.7%, Dark 18.2%, Story Rich 15%, Pixel Graphics 13.5%, Mystery 12.8%

Navigate Corinne through a realm of pixel horrors, surrounded by neighbors that are turning into bloodthirsty monsters. Discover the secrets of this twisted dimension before it's too late for Corinne and her friends.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 25.1%, Story Rich 13.4%, Pixel Graphics 11.2%, Choices Matter 10.1%, Emotional 9.6%

AquaDark is a first-person horror game with management elements set in the ‘80s. As an aquapark owner, players have to serve customers, sell wares, record everything, and solve the mystery behind strange events in the aquapark.

Why similar: Emotional 17%, Life Sim 17%, Dark 15.6%, Choices Matter 13%, Story Rich 10.2%

Your Personality plays the game! Help strange spirits solve their Unfinished Business... or leave them to Despair. In this highly-branching narrative adventure you'll only see about 1/3 of the full story in each playthrough, but the end is whenever you want it to be.

Why similar: Emotional 16.8%, Psychological Horror 15.5%, Choices Matter 14.5%, Multiple Endings 14.3%, Story Rich 10.1%

Claude, a high school student, pays a visit to his classmate Emma. He stumbles upon a strange knife in the attic, and both are thrown into an otherworldly realm, haunted by ghosts. Now they must find a way to restore the house to its original form, and seal back the rampaging ghosts.

Why similar: Choices Matter 23.3%, Multiple Endings 21.1%, Story Rich 13.2%, Emotional 8.7%, Psychological Horror 7.5%

You stand before a pit at the city's heart, then your gaze drifts to a deeper void, one you fear even more. Wield your invention to unravel mysteries, reclaim lost memories, strengthen your skills, and battle nightmare-born horrors in this multi-ending RPG.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 18.4%, Emotional 13.5%, Choices Matter 12.2%, Multiple Endings 11.5%, Mystery 11.4%

After quitting her dead-end job, Fiona starts over on a farm and becomes the immortal herald of a dead god. Make friends, fight through horrors and pay your debt in this nightmarish life sim RPG.

Why similar: Life Sim 20.6%, Psychological Horror 20%, Multiple Endings 12.5%, Story Rich 11.2%, Pixel Graphics 11%

Trapped in a shifting, surreal world shaped by grief, uncover Sezhar's identity and survive the psychological horror of The Void. Explore haunting environments, question reality, and face a presence that remembers you… even if you don’t.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 17%, Emotional 15.8%, Mystery 12.2%, Dark 11.3%, Choices Matter 10.4%

Dreamed Away is an emotional action-adventure RPG with psychological horror elements. Play as Théo, a boy lost in a dark, mysterious world. Explore a unique reality, duel against darkness in a unique, fast paced combat system and mind your choices.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 16.1%, Choices Matter 14.1%, Multiple Endings 13.9%, Emotional 11.1%, Story Rich 10.3%

As always, another ordinary day riding the train home. Yet what awaits beyond the door is a world of chaos, far removed from common sense. Your phone suddenly begins ringing like mad...

Why similar: Psychological Horror 17.1%, Choices Matter 12.3%, Multiple Endings 12%, Top-Down 11.8%, Story Rich 8.9%

Kids are going missing in the Copple Doe Town over the last 10 years and nobody has any clue about the kidnapper. Will Ume be able to find out who is behind these disappearances or she will be the next victim?

Why similar: Emotional 17.4%, Dark 14%, Psychological Horror 12.4%, Top-Down 11.1%, Mystery 10.9%

A short Japanese-style horror game in which you explore a ryokan where the proprietress is trapped and sever the forces that bind her.

Why similar: Emotional 20.1%, Psychological Horror 20.1%, Mystery 13.1%, Multiple Endings 11.9%, Dark 11.7%

Explore an abandoned hospital, solve puzzles, and uncover a nonlinear story where your choices have consequences. A hardcore psychological horror game in pixel art.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 25.9%, Multiple Endings 16.5%, Choices Matter 13.5%, Story Rich 12.9%, Puzzle 6.6%

Descend into terror in this first-person psychological horror experience as you follow your lost kitten into an ancient pirate crypt. Explore, shoot and dig for clues…literally, while unravelling a chilling mystery, all in a desperate bid to rescue your helplessly curious pet from this dark tomb.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 21.4%, Dark 14.3%, Mystery 12.9%, Choices Matter 11.1%, Multiple Endings 10.9%

A new virus is turning people into brain eating machines, etc. You know the rest. A cure has been found and all the infected people are now normal humans again. What is the problem then? Their skin color is still green. Play as an Ex-Zombie.

Why similar: Emotional 15.6%, Choices Matter 15%, Multiple Endings 14.6%, Dark 13.2%, Story Rich 10.8%

A stately, huge, beautiful mansion... Where is this?Opened the door of the mansion with a nervous heart, and the moment , I knew there was no turning back.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 17.8%, Multiple Endings 15.4%, Emotional 12.6%, Story Rich 10.6%, Top-Down 9.5%

You will explore a mysterious world with the little fairy, Sir Leonardo. An adventure awaits where you'll meet companions, fight wicked enemies, and uncover the secrets of a world in crisis. The end of the story is in your hands.

Why similar: Choices Matter 16.6%, Multiple Endings 15.9%, Top-Down 13.2%, Pixel Graphics 11.7%, Mystery 10.8%

This place is his little hell. After everything that was done, he will spend as much time here as his personal devil wishes. The only problem is that his brain turned completely to mush. He doesn’t remember what happened. He doesn’t even remember his own name.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 24.9%, Dark 18.4%, Multiple Endings 16.3%, Mystery 15.5%, Story Rich 12.5%

Enter the vanishing cabin and discover its secrets and magic, while avoiding ghastly entities.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 14.8%, Multiple Endings 13.9%, Choices Matter 13.8%, Mystery 13.5%, Dark 9.2%

Play as five human heroes in this pacifist 2D RPG taking place in a world where some friendly (and not so friendly) angels conduct balance and harmony together... and where your only instruments for fighting are words and melodies.

Why similar: Emotional 18.5%, Choices Matter 17.1%, Multiple Endings 16.8%, Story Rich 12.4%, Pixel Graphics 11.5%

A text-driven psychological horror visual novel. You wake up in a strange living room. Two silent men stand beside you. On the wall, blood writes: “Confess your sins, and you shall be redeemed.” Every choice changes the ending. Over 80,000 words in the base game, plus 4 standalone character DLCs.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 19.7%, Mystery 14.7%, Choices Matter 12.1%, Multiple Endings 11.8%, Emotional 10.9%

"Penniless Chef" is a game where you run and grow your own restaurant. Run and grow your restaurant, and get to know the villagers!

Why similar: Shop Keeper 44.7% ★, Life Sim 21.8%, Multiple Endings 11.5%, Top-Down 9.9%, Pixel Graphics 4.8%

You wake up on a red chair in the waiting room of a closed psychiatric hospital. You know this place. Clothes that aren't yours. A file with your name you don't remember reading. Your heartbeat rises. The memories come back. Not all of them want to be remembered. St. Mary's, 1985.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 17.9%, Dark 11.1%, Multiple Endings 11%, Choices Matter 10.3%, Mystery 10.3%

You awaken in an unfamiliar location with unfamiliar people and are surrounded by mystery. Will you be able to solve the puzzle and uncover why you are here in this sci-fi/mystery/puzzle visual novel? The future hangs in the balance.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 14%, Multiple Endings 14%, Emotional 12.9%, Choices Matter 12.7%, Mystery 12.1%

'UNCULT' is a Adventure where the protagonist, the daughter of a cult leader, suffers from amnesia after an accident in a fanatical pseudo-religious group. Now, she must piece together her obscured past, facing numerous challenges and uncovering the truth. Your decisions will shape her destiny.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 15.9%, Multiple Endings 13.7%, Choices Matter 13%, Mystery 11.6%, Emotional 9.8%

A horror adventure that tasks you with detecting the Unseen to escape the facility's labyrinths alive.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 17.6%, Emotional 14.8%, Multiple Endings 14%, Top-Down 10%, Story Rich 9.9%

The Doll Shop is a hand-drawn narrative game – part romance, part horror – set in the Japanese countryside. Play as a young dollmaker who reunites with his childhood friend in an eerie snowbound village. Will you dare confess your secret?

Why similar: Emotional 18.8%, Psychological Horror 14.5%, Multiple Endings 13.8%, Mystery 12.7%, Choices Matter 11.9%

A short, single-sitting VHS-style psychological horror game. Work the night shift at a remote gas station, return home to uncover disturbing clues, and reach one of three endings.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 19.6%, Multiple Endings 16.4%, Mystery 14%, Choices Matter 12%, Dark 10.8%

You used to help the hollow maid take care of herself. This time, she's missing & the front-facing UI has disappeared, giving way to a whole new environment. Find your friend.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 18.3%, Emotional 16.6%, Multiple Endings 15.5%, Choices Matter 12%, Dark 10.6%

SVETIK is a dark top-down RPG where your only source of light is a living being. Svetik remembers your words, changes over time, and may leave you in complete darkness. Can you restore the sun if the light itself stops trusting you?

Why similar: Emotional 17.8%, Choices Matter 14.6%, Dark 10.7%, Story Rich 10.4%, Multiple Endings 9.9%

This is a pixel style puzzle game, including a certain micro-horror elements. Truth is blind love. Retrieve your memory and escape from this horrible hospital.

Why similar: Emotional 19.4%, Psychological Horror 18.4%, Mystery 11.6%, Pixel Graphics 10.2%, Story Rich 10.1%

Your two best friends just broke up, its up to you to figure out why and whose fault it is. Good thing you’re a detective!

Why similar: Psychological Horror 22.3%, Dark 15.8%, Choices Matter 15.6%, Emotional 14.2%, Story Rich 10.1%

A psychological-horror puzzle game where after 16 years in prison for a murder you don't remember, you're back at your family's manor as schizophrenia distorts your reality. Manage, or harness, your mental hallucinations to uncover the truth. Will it vindicate you? Or confirm your darkest fears...

Why similar: Psychological Horror 24.6%, Mystery 13.2%, Story Rich 12.8%, Dark 12.5%, Emotional 9.5%

High School Dirty Secrets is a horror/puzzle adventure where Kasuga wakes up locked inside her high school with no memory of how she got there. As she searches for a way out, strange and unsettling events unfold, leading her to uncover dark secrets hidden within the school's walls.

Why similar: Psychological Horror 17.9%, Multiple Endings 14.7%, Dark 14.4%, Choices Matter 12.9%, Mystery 12.1%