Nodal

Games Like Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven

60+ similar titles based on shared tags and player behavior. Themes include Horror, Multiple Endings, Choices Matter, Dark Comedy.

Similar Games

View all 59 recommendations
  1. #1 While We Wait Here
    97% matchVery Positive89% of 2,418 reviews2024
    Dev: Bad Vices Games
    Windows · Mac
    Median: 2.7 hrsMean: 3.6 hrs≥1hr: 86%

    Share thoughts and hot food with your last ever clients, as you wait for the world to end.

    Why similar: Choose Your Own Adventure 18.6%, Horror 13.2%, Multiple Endings 12.5%, Walking Simulator 11.4%, Funny 9.7%

  2. #2 DEVIL'S WAY: BOHEMIAN
    96% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: Rose Game Studio
    Windows

    DEVIL'S WAY: BOHEMIAN is the sequel to the DEVIL'S WAY series, set in a sinister dystopia. It's back with various mini-games and longer playtime.

    Why similar: Dark Humor 16.7%, Dark Comedy 16%, Choose Your Own Adventure 10.3%, Multiple Endings 10%, Funny 8.6%

  3. #3 Scary Game
    96% matchVery Positive91% of 947 reviews2025
    Dev: KanGames
    Windows

    You open your eyes in a dark, unfamiliar room; each door drags you into a new chamber filled with absurd surprises and dark comedy. Will you manage to escape, or will you continue to star in this black comedy?

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 37.7%, Dark Humor 17.9%, Horror 15.8%, Funny 13%, Comedy 4.9%

  4. #4 アパシー殺人クラブ
    94% matchMostly Positive76% of 21 reviews2024
    Dev: SHANNON
    Windows

    『部活動の時間です。さあ、人殺しをはじめてください』 一癖も二癖もある強者ぞろいの巨大コミュニティ、それが鳴神学園。 そこには、ありとあらゆる部活動が存在し、到底常識では考えられない特殊な闇の倶楽部がある。その一つが殺人クラブだ。

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 27.1%, Dark Humor 19.9%, Choose Your Own Adventure 18.7%, Multiple Endings 16%, Horror 7.7%

  5. #5 Happy Birthday: With Sergio Spellbound
    94% matchPositive100% of 16 reviews2024
    Dev: Lazer Genu
    Windows

    Better than a birthday card. Use the Steam gift system to deliver this birthday present to your friends. The amazing Sergio Spellbound will ensure they have the magical birthday adventure of a lifetime. They will Point&Click their way to BIRTHDAY GLORY. If they’re lucky, they may even survive …

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 17.7%, Dark Humor 13.8%, Multiple Endings 11.7%, Interactive Fiction 10.5%, Choose Your Own Adventure 8.8%

  6. #6 The Christmas Cackler
    93% matchVery Positive98% of 55 reviews2025
    Dev: MyGrandfather Games
    Windows

    The Christmas Cackler is a first-person Christmas-themed Comedic Horror game where you play as little Jimmy, lying in bed on the night before Christmas, trying to finish drawing his mother's present and avoid getting grabbed by the Christmas Cackler!

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 34.5%, Horror 16.8%, Funny 10.4%, Interactive Fiction 8.5%, Comedy 6.8%

  7. #7 Negative Nancy
    92% matchVery Positive94% of 118 reviews2021
    Dev: FEEDPub: Effort Star
    Windows · Mac

    Negative Nancy is a choose your “no” adventure for people who have had enough. An interactive sitcom where you can only say “no” (or nothing at all). Your choices control the story.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 28.7%, Dark Humor 13.6%, Multiple Endings 13.1%, Funny 11%, Interactive Fiction 10.4%

  8. #8 Feeding The Velociraptors
    91% matchNo user reviews100% of 2 reviews2026
    Dev: workHate Inc
    Windows

    Explore a raptor-infested compound in classic retro horror style. Gather "evidence" to shift blame of your crimes. Survive in the courtroom of your few remaining peers. Do not accept any responsibility. Do not try to escape.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 32.3%, Choose Your Own Adventure 13.3%, Multiple Endings 12.8%, Horror 12.8%, Interactive Fiction 10.9%

  9. #9 Lich Clicker
    91% match6 user reviews83% of 6 reviews2023
    Dev: KnotHorn Studio
    Windows

    Collect souls. Choose your path. Find true love or doom the world. The choice is yours in this simple clicker game with a branching storyline. Can you find all five fully voiced endings?

    Why similar: Dark Humor 18.8%, Choose Your Own Adventure 17.6%, Dark Comedy 17%, Multiple Endings 12.9%, Funny 10.9%

  10. #10 I.T. Never Ends
    89% matchPositive97% of 39 reviews2026
    Dev: Dadbod Games
    Windows · Linux

    The printer is bleeding, the Wi-Fi is haunted, and Ticket #666 just came in. As the latest hire for a company run by cosmic horrors, your job is simple: Swipe to survive. Make binary decisions to survive the night shift in this dark comedy desktop simulator. I.T truly never ends.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 22%, Choose Your Own Adventure 14.9%, Dark Humor 14.1%, Multiple Endings 10.2%, Horror 8.4%

  11. #11 Scary Game 2: The Mad Shepherd
    89% matchVery Positive91% of 1,320 reviews2026
    Dev: KanGames
    Windows
    Median: 48 minMean: 1.7 hrs≥1hr: 35%

    Your first day as the new shepherd in the village… and everything is going wrong. The animals are missing. The villagers are strange. And the truth is far more terrifying.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 30.4%, Dark Humor 19.1%, Horror 11.8%, Walking Simulator 11.8%, Funny 11.5%

  12. #12 Dark Nights with Poe and Munro
    90% matchMostly Positive75% of 492 reviews2020
    Dev: D'Avekki Studios Ltd
    Windows · Mac · Linux
    Median: 4.7 hrsMean: 6.0 hrs≥1hr: 94%

    Guide local radio hosts Poe and Munro through six TV-like episodes of supernatural strangeness and sizzling on-screen chemistry. From the creators of The Infectious Madness of Doctor Dekker and The Shapeshifting Detective.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 21.7%, Choose Your Own Adventure 15.8%, Dark Humor 11.7%, Multiple Endings 10.1%, Interactive Fiction 9.8%

  13. #13 Mutual Assured Destruction Simulator
    88% matchPositive89% of 19 reviews2024
    Dev: Black Void Media
    Windows

    A short and surreal dark comedy-horror narrative game.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 27.5%, Choose Your Own Adventure 16.9%, Dark Humor 13.9%, Horror 12.2%, Interactive Fiction 11.5%

  14. #14 Killer Frequency
    87% matchVery Positive93% of 6,117 reviews2023
    Dev: Team17
    Windows
    Median: 4.1 hrsMean: 5.0 hrs≥1hr: 76%

    Killer Frequency is a first-person horror puzzle game set in 1987, that puts you in the role of a late-night radio talk show host in small town America whose callers are being stalked by a mysterious killer.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 22.8%, Horror 12.7%, Interactive Fiction 11%, Walking Simulator 10.5%, Multiple Endings 9.2%

  15. #15 PLEASE STOP CRYING: TERRIBLE TWOS
    86% matchPositive100% of 13 reviews2025
    Dev: Konrad PawlikowskiPub: Cloudless Studio
    Windows

    PLEASE STOP CRYING: Terrible Twos is a lighthearted horror game about a father yet again struggling to keep up with his baby at a restaurant.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 38.7%, Horror 20.1%, Funny 12.4%, Walking Simulator 10.2%, Multiple Endings 6%

  16. #16 Our Dirge
    86% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Radi8on
    Windows

    It's June 2023 in Columbus, Ohio -- 10 years since Neal and Jack graduated, and 8 years since they last spoke. Follow two once-best friends' reluctant descent through classrooms and memories in Our Dirge, a game about growing up in a certain place & time, and making up for the time we lost.

    Why similar: Dark Humor 16.4%, Horror 14.8%, Funny 12.4%, Walking Simulator 12.3%, Interactive Fiction 10.1%

  17. #17 I AM MILK
    85% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: DARKFIELD GAMESPub: DARKFIELD
    Windows · Mac

    I AM MILK is a surreal, branching audio-first narrative game played through headphones with one button. Make split-second choices as a 21:30 minute story unfolds in real time, leading to more than 40 endings. DARKFIELD’s award-winning 3D sound transports you into the middle of this strange world.

    Why similar: Choose Your Own Adventure 22%, Interactive Fiction 16.2%, Dark Humor 14.7%, Multiple Endings 13.6%, Choices Matter 10.2%

  18. #18 A Very British Summer
    84% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2025
    Dev: The Dead Bunny Show
    Windows

    A darkly comic life-sim where players manage a small-town doctor’s daily life, solving puzzles to treat patients, navigating village activities, and choosing whether to follow the law or indulge in crime and chaos on the path to fortune.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 21.4%, Choose Your Own Adventure 15.8%, Dark Humor 13.4%, Interactive Fiction 10%, Horror 9.5%

  19. #19 The Company
    84% match5 user reviews100% of 5 reviews2026
    Dev: Crawler Games
    Windows

    The Company wants you productive. The Company wants you calm. The Company wants you compliant.

    Why similar: Choose Your Own Adventure 19.9%, Walking Simulator 15.5%, Interactive Fiction 14%, Horror 10.8%, Psychological Horror 9.7%

  20. #20 TOY BOX
    83% matchVery Positive86% of 50 reviews2024
    Dev: DEADline Studios
    Windows · Mac · Linux

    A pull-apart puzzle visual novel whose fragments stitch the story together.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 24.9%, Choose Your Own Adventure 18.4%, Horror 12.2%, Interactive Fiction 11.7%, Multiple Endings 9.5%

  21. #21 Bear With Me: The Pizza Chronicles (Prequel)
    82% match7 user reviews100% of 7 reviews2026
    Dev: Klemen Vrhovšek
    Windows · Linux

    You and your friend hear a scream in the woods, run toward it, and meet a very angry bear. One choice decides everything. Will you run, panic, throw a rock, or order pizza? Discover all 14 endings in this fully voice-acted dark comedy.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 34.2%, Choose Your Own Adventure 16.4%, Multiple Endings 16.1%, Choices Matter 12.1%, Funny 5.6%

  22. #22 Kindergarten 3
    80% matchVery Positive94% of 1,848 reviews2025
    Dev: Con Man GamesPub: SmashGames
    Windows · Mac · Linux
    Median: 6.9 hrsMean: 7.9 hrs≥1hr: 83%

    Kindergarten 3 is the long awaited threequel to the Kindergarten series! Explore a new school with old and new friends...and new ways to get ruthlessly murdered.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 28%, Dark Humor 18.3%, Choose Your Own Adventure 17%, Interactive Fiction 10.6%, Funny 10.3%

  23. #23 Clarence Goes to the F&#%ING Store
    82% matchPositive100% of 16 reviews2021
    Dev: Bad Gremlin Studios
    Windows

    An absurdist comedy choose-your-own-adventure game featuring a massive cast of bizarre characters, notebook-doodle visuals, and 7 crazy endings! As you embark on your quest to go to the store, the denizens of this zany town will seek your help with their insane problems.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 34.9%, Choose Your Own Adventure 23.1%, Funny 12.7%, Multiple Endings 11.8%, Choices Matter 9.3%

  24. #24 Confessional Simulator
    81% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: null.exePub: Subconscious Games
    Windows

    You're the new priest at St. Augustine's. Sinners kneel on the other side of the screen and tell you everything. Forgive them and your Faith grows. Work the guilt and the donations roll in. Push it too far and the Bishop starts listening. A voiced dark comedy about other people's sins.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 36%, Funny 12.3%, Multiple Endings 12.2%, Choose Your Own Adventure 11.8%, Choices Matter 10.4%

  25. #25 Sir Bucket
    81% match5 user reviews100% of 5 reviews2024
    Dev: Christian KielPub: FatLadGames
    Windows

    Sir Bucket is a choose-your-own-adventure game set in a fantasy world with over 30 different endings. Explore the world and have your story told by a wisecracking narrator.

    Why similar: Choose Your Own Adventure 21.6%, Dark Humor 14.5%, Walking Simulator 12.8%, Interactive Fiction 12.8%, Multiple Endings 11.4%

  26. #26 Presidential Psychologist
    79% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2025
    Dev: BRB Drama
    Windows · Mac

    You're not a real psychologist. He's not a sane president. Welcome to the most unhinged therapy session ever held in office.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 25.1%, Dark Humor 16.8%, Choose Your Own Adventure 13.2%, Multiple Endings 12.2%, Interactive Fiction 9.4%

  27. #27 Invasion of The Halloween Fiends
    78% matchVery Positive96% of 119 reviews2024
    Dev: MyGrandfather Games
    Windows

    Invasion of The Halloween Fiends is a First-Person Retro horror game that takes place on Halloween Night. Strangers keep visiting you looking for candy. Some of them may not be so friendly. Will you be able to survive Halloween Night?

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 29.9%, Horror 14.3%, Thriller 12.1%, 1990's 11.8%, Walking Simulator 10.8%

  28. #28 LustyVerse: ShackBang
    79% matchMixed53% of 87 reviews2023
    Dev: Inceton games
    Windows · Mac · Linux

    A trip to a cabin in the woods takes one guy and four hot girls trough an unexpected week filled with all kinds of twists and turns, where fun doesn't always promise a happy ending.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 23.7%, Dark Humor 18.2%, Horror 15.7%, Choose Your Own Adventure 14.3%, Story Rich 7%

  29. #29 67 Minutes in Heaven
    77% matchVery Positive87% of 115 reviews2026
    Dev: One Flow ManPub: Treestyle Studios
    Windows

    Your neighbor invites you on a double date, setting you up with the new girl from out of town. After sneaking into an abandoned house, your neighbor suggests everyone play a game, 67 Minutes in Heaven.

    Why similar: Choose Your Own Adventure 22.1%, Walking Simulator 16.5%, Interactive Fiction 16.2%, Dark Humor 12.8%, Horror 11.6%

  30. #30 Trapped with Jester
    77% matchVery Positive94% of 1,576 reviews2022
    Dev: AntaPub: Neoclassic Games
    Windows · Mac · Linux

    An unusual horror-themed Visual Novel about waking up in a carriage with a stranger… Whatever could go wrong?

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 21.1%, Choose Your Own Adventure 18.3%, Dark Humor 13.9%, Interactive Fiction 11.5%, Horror 11.2%

  31. #31 WTF Is Wrong With You?
    78% matchVery Positive93% of 363 reviews2021
    Dev: Randumb Studios
    Windows

    Have you ever wondered WTF Is Wrong With You? Well, so have we... Let's find out together, shall we?

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 23.9%, Choose Your Own Adventure 15.1%, Dark Humor 14.9%, Multiple Endings 11.4%, Funny 9.1%

  32. #32 Angel Wings: Endless Night
    76% matchVery Positive85% of 67 reviews2024
    Dev: RumR Design
    Windows

    Trapped in a haunted mansion with only your wits and an unlikely ally at your side, what will it take to survive this endless nightmare?

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 28%, Choose Your Own Adventure 13.5%, Multiple Endings 10.4%, Horror 10.2%, Interactive Fiction 9.5%

  33. #33 I Did It ALL for the COOKIE!
    76% matchPositive89% of 18 reviews2024
    Dev: Paul RodenburgPub: Rodenburg Films Ltd
    Windows · Mac

    You are hanging out at a festive Christmas party when your eyes discover the most perfect Christmas confectionery ever! You must have it!... but someone already has it! What will you be willing to do, to get your Christmas wish?

    Why similar: Choose Your Own Adventure 25.8%, Multiple Endings 16.6%, Funny 14.1%, Dark Humor 11.7%, Interactive Fiction 10.1%

  34. #34 Contra Spem Spero
    75% matchPositive92% of 25 reviews2025
    Dev: DADZINGO
    Windows · Linux

    Contra Spem Spero is a text-based horror adventure with visual novel elements. Not every road leads out. You are lost deep in a twisted place — a forest one can only hope to escape.

    Why similar: Choose Your Own Adventure 22.5%, Horror 19.3%, Choices Matter 10.6%, Interactive Fiction 10.1%, Dark Humor 10%

  35. #35 Lost Diskettes Vol.1
    75% matchVery Positive88% of 85 reviews2024
    Dev: Puko
    Windows

    This is a collection of short and experimental horror experiences, focused on surreal and bizarre plots.

    Why similar: Choose Your Own Adventure 19.9%, Horror 18.3%, Multiple Endings 15.3%, Choices Matter 11%, 1990's 8.7%

  36. #36 OXENFREE II: Lost Signals
    74% matchVery Positive88% of 2,068 reviews2023
    Dev: Night School StudioPub: Netflix
    Windows · Mac
    Median: 6.0 hrsMean: 11.2 hrs≥1hr: 72%

    Five years after the events of OXENFREE, Riley returns to her hometown of Camena to investigate mysterious radio signals. What she finds is more than she bargained for.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 20%, Choose Your Own Adventure 14.2%, Thriller 12.3%, Horror 10%, Walking Simulator 9.1%

  37. #37 The Trials - Chapter Two
    72% matchNo user reviews100% of 2 reviews2026
    Dev: Hama Studios
    Windows

    A classic 90s choose your own adventure style horror visual novel. Escape the horrors hunting you, make decisions, forge your own path. An original complete story with multiple endings. Choose your own play style with a Text Adventure Mode, sound effects, and an ambient soundtrack.

    Why similar: Choose Your Own Adventure 27.7%, Multiple Endings 16.3%, Choices Matter 12.1%, Horror 10.6%, 1990's 10.6%

  38. #38 Error Found
    73% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: YourAdHerePub: Ad Studios
    Windows · Mac · Linux

    ERROR FOUND is a genre-redefining psychological horror game that takes place in a seemingly normal clicker game. When a previously normal game gets hijacked by a character, players are forced to find the truth within the game and make decisions that will forever impact their gameplay.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 22.9%, Choose Your Own Adventure 16.9%, Multiple Endings 15.6%, Dark Humor 12.8%, Choices Matter 10.3%

  39. #39 After School Murder Club!!
    74% matchVery Positive86% of 98 reviews2021
    Dev: Rabbit, Deer, You
    Windows

    In this short comedy visual novel, you're an unpopular transfer student who begins a new life at a Japanese high school. You quickly get drafted into the school's most secret after-school club... but could it be that the seemingly innocent members of the Murder Club are hiding a dark secret?!

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 23.2%, Choose Your Own Adventure 17.8%, Dark Humor 14%, Multiple Endings 12.2%, Choices Matter 8.6%

  40. #40 The Untitled Show
    73% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Joe Highton
    Windows · Linux

    The Untitled Show is a first person narrative driven game set in the 1980's about a man named Martin in a warehouse late at night and a story that stays on script or not, whether you choose to or not.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 25.6%, Choose Your Own Adventure 20.4%, Dark Humor 15.8%, Multiple Endings 9.8%, Funny 9.7%

  41. #41 Survivor Dieland
    73% matchVery Positive95% of 234 reviews2021
    Dev: Randumb Studios
    Windows

    You're gonna get yourself killed being out here all by your lonesome... There's monsters on this island! Besides, It's not always the beasts you should be afraid of... Beasts are easy to predict. They just want to kill and eat you. Humans are much harder... They'll pretend to be your friend first...

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 21.8%, Choose Your Own Adventure 16.8%, Dark Humor 13.6%, Multiple Endings 12.2%, Funny 9.7%

  42. #42 Dawn After Dusk
    71% match5 user reviews80% of 5 reviews2025
    Dev: Alexis Clay
    Windows

    Asylum simulator. An interactive fiction about schizophrenia and finding meaning after near-death, with Disco Elysium-style mechanics.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 20.9%, Choose Your Own Adventure 20.7%, Interactive Fiction 17.1%, Dark Humor 12.3%, Choices Matter 9.5%

  43. #43 Moth Lake: A Horror Story
    72% matchVery Positive83% of 114 reviews2022
    Dev: Stefano Mazzotta (Il Sui)Pub: Sui Arts
    Windows

    This is the story of Moth Lake, a small town that, behind its peaceful facade, hides a terrible secret. Only a group of teenagers, with a difficult life, will reveal what has been hidden for generations.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 24.1%, Dark Humor 16.1%, Choose Your Own Adventure 13.9%, Horror 12.4%, Funny 10.3%

  44. #44 Normal Person
    70% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Dexter ManningPub: Manning Media
    Windows

    Normal Person is a single player horror, first person Visual Novel where your choices matter! Will you be able to escape or will you be stuck in a limbo with the man who claims to be a "Normal person"

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 37.6%, Choose Your Own Adventure 17.2%, Horror 15.7%, Choices Matter 12.5%, Psychological Horror 9.9%

  45. #45 Gloomscape
    70% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Lachrymose Games
    Windows

    Step into the eerie and mysterious world of Gloomscape! With your trusty mood ring and sense of adventure, you’ll craft, explore, and strategize your way through this bizarre world. But beware - ghastly creatures lurk around every corner.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 22.6%, Choose Your Own Adventure 15.1%, Dark Humor 13.9%, Horror 10%, Interactive Fiction 9.8%

  46. #46 PHARMA INC SIMULATOR - Ethics not included.
    70% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: The Extremely Tiny Game Studio
    Windows · Mac

    Build your own pharma empire—on fair play or greed. Face the consequences of every decision in this darkly humorous, satirical sim: set market prices, manage production, boost your brand, make tough choices... and see where they take you.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 27.1%, Choose Your Own Adventure 18.3%, Dark Humor 16.4%, Multiple Endings 15%, Interactive Fiction 11.5%

  47. #47 Shadows of Betrayal
    69% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2025
    Dev: JayzonBHPub: JayzonBH Games
    Windows · Mac · Linux

    Recent high school graduates gather at a remote cabin for a celebration. What begins as a night of laughter spirals into a tense mystery full of secrets, twists, and chilling choices. Who will survive? Navigate friendships, and uncover the multi-layered mystery in Shadows of Betrayal.

    Why similar: Choose Your Own Adventure 28.4%, Interactive Fiction 17.3%, Horror 12.4%, Thriller 11.7%, Choices Matter 11%

  48. #48 AI Confidential
    69% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Critical Wit
    Windows · Linux

    Artificial Intelligence, Real Problems: You are Makenzy Turner, an affable RoboTechnician employed by AI megacorp, Indelligent Solutions. With your trusty assistant ARI, use high-tech tools and old-fashioned empathy to mend everything from broken parts to broken hearts.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 23.8%, Choose Your Own Adventure 16.5%, Dark Humor 14.1%, Funny 11%, Multiple Endings 10.7%

  49. #49 Ostera : The curse of...
    69% matchPositive91% of 34 reviews2025
    Dev: Profits Troll Studio
    Windows

    Welcome to Ostera: The curse of... Join the Adventure! Shape Your Destiny, Kiss Rats, and Slap Kids!

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 23.5%, Choose Your Own Adventure 18.6%, Dark Humor 17.4%, Interactive Fiction 10.2%, Funny 9.2%

  50. #50 Fhtagn! - Tales of the Creeping Madness
    71% matchVery Positive96% of 52 reviews2018
    Dev: Design Imps
    Windows

    Fhtagn! - Tales of the Creeping Madness is a text based adventure game, where choices matter. There's couch co-op and just a hint of betrayal. Play as one of four cultists intent on releasing the Ancient One!

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 20%, Choose Your Own Adventure 15.2%, Dark Humor 12.6%, Horror 9.6%, Multiple Endings 9.1%

  51. #51 PLEASE STOP CRYING
    68% matchVery Positive94% of 105 reviews2024
    Dev: Konrad PawlikowskiPub: Cloudless Studio
    Windows

    PLEASE STOP CRYING is a lighthearted horror game about a father taking on housework and babysitting all at once.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 38%, Horror 23.1%, Funny 18%, Multiple Endings 17%, Casual 3.9%

  52. #52 NO LOVE
    71% match7 user reviews86% of 7 reviews2019
    Dev: Wallace Lovecraft
    Windows

    A hard scifi, fantasy, hand-drawn RPG with a unique original story that’s mainly about the characters and delves into topics regarding the human condition from the perspective of one person, Wallace Lovecraft.

    Why similar: Choose Your Own Adventure 19.9%, Dark Humor 17.3%, Funny 13%, Horror 9.5%, Interactive Fiction 9.4%

  53. #53 Mass of Consumption
    67% match2 user reviews50% of 2 reviews2025
    Dev: Wayward Woyrm Games
    Windows

    The church is impatient. The church is hungry. The church is willing to do anything to get you back.

    Why similar: Choose Your Own Adventure 28.4%, Horror 23.8%, Interactive Fiction 17.4%, Multiple Endings 12.2%, Choices Matter 9.2%

  54. #54 I Have Bingo But Cannot Scream
    68% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: MyGrandfather Games
    Windows

    I Have Bingo But Cannot Scream is a First Person Horror Comedy about working at a bingo hall one night when the old people go ballistic! The player must try to escape before the nearly dead make them fully dead.

    Why similar: Dark Humor 23.9%, Horror 18.5%, Funny 14.2%, Walking Simulator 14%, Interactive Fiction 7.6%

  55. #55 Crococo
    66% matchVery Positive88% of 171 reviews2026
    Dev: REVVALUTION Studio
    Windows

    An urban legend says there are alligators living in the sewers of New York. Go down there… and see for yourself. A 90s-style comedy horror game featuring classic single-voice VHS dubbing.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 34%, Dark Humor 22.5%, Funny 13.1%, Horror 12.6%, Walking Simulator 8%

  56. #56 Creepy Support
    65% matchVery Positive90% of 124 reviews2026
    Dev: Squirrel Melting
    Windows

    Save people from terrible paranormal dangers as a support operator of a secret SCP-like organization! Ask questions, give advice and watch the consequences of your choices... multiple endings in each story ;-)

    Why similar: Choose Your Own Adventure 20.4%, Dark Humor 18.2%, Multiple Endings 13.4%, Horror 12.7%, Interactive Fiction 12.7%

  57. #57 Gordy
    66% matchVery Positive93% of 54 reviews2025
    Dev: MyGrandfather Games
    Windows

    Meet Gordy your very own Feral Human companion. The two of you have become best friends as you wander the woods creating memories of friendship and love amongst the beauty of nature. I really hope nothing bad happens.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 27%, Dark Humor 15.8%, Walking Simulator 15%, Interactive Fiction 14.9%, Horror 10.5%

  58. #58 SHUT IN
    68% matchVery Positive90% of 111 reviews2020
    Dev: Cael O'SullivanPub: Hidden Track
    Windows · Mac

    SHUT IN is a dark comedy/psychological horror adventure game which explores depression and isolation by trapping you inside your own house. Explore a hostile home, solve puzzles, and withstand sarcasm from a rude and unreliable narrator. Idiot.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 34%, Dark Humor 17.3%, Horror 15.4%, Funny 10.8%, Multiple Endings 10.1%

  59. #59 Sympathy for the Wicked: Hindsight
    66% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: zeenhil
    Windows

    Hindsight is a Visual Novel with themes of romance and horror, in which the player takes control of three key individuals at different points in time, and must help them to survive their trials in order to truly understand their stories.

    Why similar: Dark Comedy 27.9%, Multiple Endings 17.6%, Dark Humor 16.3%, Horror 15.6%, Psychological Horror 9.7%

Modeli
Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven cover art

Games Like Only Good Babysitters Go To Heaven

Based on tag similarity + player behavior
Loading graph...