- #1 Enemy Metal
97% matchNo user reviews2027
Dev: Jack James
Windows
2.5D Roguelite Shooter with Unique Gameplay, Powerful Weapons and a Killer Soundtrack. Battle the dangerous enemies and defend the planets of the Sunstar System! Gather crystals and destroy turrets to level up and unlock exciting new Starships on each planet!
Why similar: Flight 35.2%, Action Roguelike 22.7%, Bullet Hell 19.1%, Action 7.8%, Shooter 5.6%
- #2 There's Chaos!
96% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2025
Dev: Pathfinders Forge Games
Windows
An action-packed game with roguelike progression. Pilot a combat drone in intense battles, fighting for resources and territory. Collect and fuse enemy weapons to upgrade your arsenal. Survive chaotic 30-minute runs, earn permanent upgrades, and dominate the battlefield!
Why similar: Flight 33.2%, Action Roguelike 18%, Arena Shooter 17.2%, Bullet Hell 16.1%, Action 5.1%
- #3 Kiwi'n
96% matchMostly Negative37% of 19 reviews2024
Dev: G Reason
Windows
Kiwi'n is a clicker Game, in which you click a Kiwi! In Kiwi you click the Kiwi to gain even more Kiwis! Come hang out with us and let's grow into something awesome !
Why similar: Flight 37.5%, Cinematic 23.6%, Action Roguelike 22.4%, Action 15.4%, Indie 1.2%
- #4 Super Space Crystals
95% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Benji FlamingPub: BowlerTech
Windows · Linux
Fly your drone deep into hostile space, engage the enemy, and shatter their Magic Space Crystals to collect Woo-Woo for the war effort! Upgrade your drone with a wide assortment of maneuvering, defensive, and offensive abilities. The Fraternal Brotherhood of Evil Magic Space Robots must be stopped!
Why similar: Bullet Hell 24.7%, Flight 23.2%, Action Roguelike 14.9%, Arena Shooter 14%, Shooter 7.7%
- #5 StarRider
94% matchNo user reviews
Dev: TeamStarDevs
Windows
Star Rider is a Fast-paced 3d flight Action Game with a retro pop Style. Master your pilot skills and special moves to defeat the alien threat. Take on various missions and Stop the alien threat to Earth it's all up to you to be Earth Star Guardian
Why similar: Flight 49.4%, Action 11.4%, Bullet Hell 9.1%, Shooter 8.8%, Combat 8.6%
- #6 Flying Aces: Legend of the Red Baron
94% match2 user reviews0% of 2 reviews2025
Dev: GS2 Games
Windows
Fly over 30 different aircraft and take on dozens of thrilling missions! Knock down enemy zeppelins and observation balloons while dodging hostile fighters.
Why similar: Flight 42.1%, Cinematic 19.2%, Action 17.6%, Shooter 8.5%, Simulation 8.2%
- #7 Strato Supremacy
93% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2023
Dev: BrainFun Games
Windows
Strato Supremacy is a flight combat simulation game where players defeat enemies and destroy cities with different planes and weapons while navigating through randomly generated terrains.
Why similar: Flight 66%, Action 17.7%, Combat 8.4%, 3D 5.5%, Indie 1.4%
- #8 WARHEAD CIRCUS(ウォーヘッド サーカス)
91% matchMostly Positive80% of 15 reviews2025
Dev: Dig Up IndiePub: Sonic Powered Co.,Ltd.
Windows
Dodge! Evade! Slip past! A rogue-like specialized in avoidance. Survive the twisting and turning missile circus!
Why similar: Flight 36.3%, Action Roguelike 24.8%, Bullet Hell 19.6%, Action 8.6%, Shooter 6.2%
- #9 Eurofighter Typhoon
92% matchMostly Negative26% of 238 reviews2014
Dev: Rage SoftwarePub: Funbox Media Ltd
Windows
Median: 6 minMean: 14.0 hrs≥1hr: 19%
In Eurofighter Typhoon, you are flying the famous Eurofighter on top of Iceland to fight against Russian troops which invade the country and prevent the outbreak of World War III. Quickly outnumbered, the ICEFOR has been abandoned by NATO but has been able to deploy a small number of the new Typhoon aircraft.
Why similar: Flight 77.7%, Action 15.6%, Simulation 6.7%
- #10 Extinction Core-2005
91% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Bot and LifePub: RedQueen LLC
Windows
A top-down atompunk bullet-hell where you pilot the aircraft to fight, override, and weaponize Kaiju born from the depths of the Earth.
Why similar: Flight 29.6%, Bullet Hell 18.6%, Action Roguelike 16.5%, Action 8.6%, Shooter 7.2%
- #11 Star Striker
89% matchNo user reviews
Dev: NoNameGames
Windows
Dominate your enemies with modernized familiar arial combat controls. Craft the perfect build to become the most deadly star fighter in the galaxy!
Why similar: Flight 40.3%, Action Roguelike 19.1%, Bullet Hell 10.2%, Shooter 7%, Combat 6.9%
- #12 Super Huey™ III
90% match7 user reviews43% of 7 reviews2020
Dev: WebfootPub: Ziggurat
Windows
Super Huey™ III is a direct sequel to the PC’s first helicopter simulation, featuring tense combat and daring rescues in over 35 dramatic missions! This revamped version of the 2003 classic enhances the original while still packing all the high-flying and explosive action you remember.
Why similar: Flight 56.9%, Action 20.2%, Combat 10.4%, Simulation 8.4%, 3D 3.3%
- #13 Tamageddon
88% match8 user reviews75% of 8 reviews2023
Dev: Malumica
Windows
Battle against an army of balls coming your way in this fast-paced survival roguelike! Pick the right weapons and power-ups as you level up and continue your carnage. Unlock new characters and levels as you grow stronger!
Why similar: Action Roguelike 32.6%, Bullet Hell 28.5%, Action 22.3%, Combat 9.2%, 3D 5%
- #14 Fracture
86% matchPositive100% of 10 reviews2025
Dev: Benkimchi
Windows
FRACTURE is a fast-paced roguelike bullet-hell shooter. Battle enemies and bosses across ever-changing maps, collect items, unlock new ships, and upgrade your ship and weapons!
Why similar: Flight 36.9%, Action Roguelike 23.2%, Bullet Hell 19.8%, Shooter 5.7%, Action 5.6%
- #15 Geometry Waves
87% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Wobi Games
Windows
Shoot your way through waves of enemies and extreme bosses in this Roguelite space shooter. Advance in the ranks, upgrade your ship and unlock new mechanics, ships and mods that will make the game more challanging and interesting.
Why similar: Flight 23.6%, Action Roguelike 21.4%, Arena Shooter 20.7%, Bullet Hell 19.5%, Shooter 6.4%
- #16 Slug Survival
85% match7 user reviews71% of 7 reviews2025
Dev: Dragon Pixel Studios
Windows · Mac
Survive endless waves of mutating slugs in this skill-based top-down shooter. One arena. Evolving enemies. Infinite chaos. Master your aim, earn powerful upgrades, and see how long you can last.
Why similar: Arena Shooter 26.9%, Action Roguelike 24.3%, Bullet Hell 20.5%, Action 9.6%, Shooter 6.1%
- #17 洛希极限 Roche Limit
86% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Safe House Studio
Windows
Roche Limit is a 2D pixel sci-fi action roguelite, blending high-speed aerial combat with ARPG builds. Choose a mecha-girl, build her skills on the battle, and face the cosmic legion. Between runs, bond with the girls for more skill possibles and stories. Prevent cataclysm before the moon falls.
Why similar: Flight 39.1%, Action Roguelike 25%, Bullet Hell 21.1%, Action 8.7%, Futuristic 3.5%
- #18 Boozerker
84% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Weird Crate Games
Windows
You are a Boozerker, reborn as a ghost with one final duty: slay the monsters. Equip powerful weapons and unique items, create fun and insane synergies, and tear through endless waves of enemies.
Why similar: Action Roguelike 29.5%, Arena Shooter 25.8%, Bullet Hell 23%, Action 10.2%, PvE 6.9%
- #19 Drone Arena
84% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: ZEGPub: Designer Dad Games
Windows
Drone Arena is a TPS arena shooter roguelite where you control a Drone wielding weapons at a time to fight off hordes of mechas. Choose from a variety of power-ups and items to create unique builds and survive to the top of the arenas. No checkpoints. Kill, die, learn, repeat.
Why similar: Flight 22.4%, Bullet Hell 22.1%, Action Roguelike 21.7%, Arena Shooter 17.2%, Action 6.9%
- #20 東方菈菈队
83% matchVery Positive96% of 56 reviews2023
Dev: SlimeSmilePub: 雾雨威Channel
Windows
一款东方同人STG射击游戏,魔女罗菈Rola穿越到幻想乡发动圣诞节异变,博丽灵梦发现后大战罗菈Rola!开始紧张刺激的弹幕游戏吧!
Why similar: Flight 52.3%, Bullet Hell 31%, Shooter 9%, Action 5.8%, Indie 1.3%
- #21 Operation Candy Land
82% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Mad Hook
Windows
Candy Land has gone wild! Feral gummy bears, angry lollipops, and sneaky marshmallows are everywhere. Run, shoot, and build crazy towers to survive waves of candy monsters. Fast, silly, chaotic and way harder than it looks!
Why similar: Action Roguelike 32.9%, Bullet Hell 28.9%, Action 22.3%, Colorful 8.1%, 3D 5.5%
- #22 Infinite Incantation
81% matchPositive81% of 43 reviews2023
Dev: Zero Sun Games
Windows
Fight for survival as you battle massive hordes of enemies. Wield powerful spells that you can mutate and evolve to ludicrous strength. Customize your character's stats, elemental affinities, and make upgrades to become the ultimate spell-slinging force of destruction.
Why similar: Bullet Hell 36.8%, Action Roguelike 32.7%, Action 25.1%, Indie 5.4%
- #23 Outrange Strike
80% matchNo user reviews
Dev: NAV Games
Windows
Outrange Strike is a realistic physics-based aerial shooter. Pilot a fighter jet, engage in aerial combat, and support your allies! Control your fighter's energy and AOA, determine missile range, and use decoys to evade missiles.
Why similar: Flight 64.9%, Action 12.1%, Simulation 6.5%, PvE 4%, Combat 3.8%
- #24 Vector Thrust
81% matchMixed48% of 741 reviews2015
Dev: TimeSymmetryPub: Iceberg Interactive
Windows
Median: 4.4 hrsMean: 6.1 hrs≥1hr: 90%
Vector Thrust is a fast-paced single and mulltiplayer combat flight game, using a unique cel shaded art style. The game features 260 fully playable aircraft (through various iterations of over 45 aircraft models).
Why similar: Flight 68.1%, Action 19%, Simulation 9.3%, Indie 3.1%, Singleplayer 0.5%
- #25 Flying Pew Pew
79% matchNo user reviews
Dev: NoName
Windows
The alien hordes have attacked us for no reason. We must throw all our forces to repel our planet from the alien invaders!
Why similar: Flight 24.6%, Action Roguelike 22.9%, Bullet Hell 21.2%, Arena Shooter 16.9%, Action 7.4%
- #26 Dreams of Valhalla
79% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Closed Sum Games LLC
Windows · Linux
Dreams of Valhalla is an action rogue where you battle through the 9 realms in order to obtain eternally glory in Valhalla.
Why similar: Action Roguelike 32.7%, Bullet Hell 28.5%, Action 23.7%, Combat 7.5%, 3D 5%
- #27 Xalvorynthium
78% matchNo user reviews
Dev: D3a1hXSaga Studios
Windows
**Xalvorynthium** is a neon arcade action roguelike shooter where you dodge enemy fire, evolve your weapons, battle bosses, and chase higher scores through escalating waves of sci-fi chaos.
Why similar: Action Roguelike 28.1%, Arena Shooter 24.9%, Bullet Hell 22.5%, Action 9.5%, Shooter 7.2%
- #28 Super Cyber Wave
77% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2026
Dev: Vivtori Studios
Windows · Mac · Linux
Super Cyber Wave is a fast-paced 3D bullet hell where you pilot unlockable characters with unique attack patterns, dodge bullet waves, collect ring-shaped keys, grab power-ups, and survive boss fights across four lethal biomes. Ride the rhythm of an immersive soundtrack.
Why similar: Flight 45.3%, Bullet Hell 25.4%, Action 9.8%, Combat 5.5%, Futuristic 4.5%
- #29 Crimson Broadcast
78% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Scoyroli
Windows
Survive relentless enemy waves by broadcasting on risky frequencies. Upgrade, adapt, and defend your radio station in this post-apocalyptic top-down survival game.
Why similar: Action Roguelike 29.4%, Arena Shooter 25.9%, Bullet Hell 23.7%, Action 10.9%, Futuristic 4.6%
- #30 BuzzLabs
77% matchNo user reviews
Dev: BuzzLabs TeamPub: Silas Lessner
Windows
BuzzLabs is a competitive multiplayer aviation shooter with the cutest and buzziest drones ever! Pick your favorite insect or configure a little mutant from dozens of parts.
Why similar: Flight 42%, Arena Shooter 23.8%, Action 16.3%, Shooter 9%, Colorful 4.8%
- #31 Stardust Protocol
76% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Starzen Interactive
Windows
Between bullet hell, black markets, and star-map strategy, chart a branching route of your own. Combine Scatter, Missile, Homing, and Laser weapons with 100+ items and 30+ random events—each sortie reshapes your build. Balance risk and reward in unknown systems and blaze your trail through the void.
Why similar: Flight 25.3%, Action Roguelike 25.3%, Action 15.5%, Bullet Hell 14.7%, Shooter 8.3%
- #32 Xolotl's Escape
76% matchNo user reviews
Dev: For No Raisin
Windows
Help Xolotl and his friend Steve escape the wrath of the gods in this rogue lite bullet hell shooter with turret defense elements. Utilize a variety of weapons and abilities to evade and survive the waves of enemies. Upgrade your arsenal and see how long you can withstand the divine onslaught.
Why similar: Action Roguelike 25.8%, Arena Shooter 22.8%, Bullet Hell 19.6%, Action 11%, Shooter 8.5%
- #33 Void Reaper
75% matchPositive87% of 15 reviews2024
Dev: BIGX
Windows
Pilot your ship through the Void in 'Void Reaper'. Face diverse enemies, upgrade your ship, and battle bosses to reach the End Boss in this action-packed void odyssey. Can you destroy the Void and save the world?
Why similar: Action Roguelike 28.7%, Arena Shooter 25.8%, Bullet Hell 21.6%, Action 14.2%, Combat 7.9%
- #34 Iron Horde
75% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Falcon Lab
Windows
Immersive jet combat simulator featuring modern fighters, realistic physics, and tactical air-to-air engagements. Engage in intense solo dogfights, survive escalating threats, and dominate the skies.
Why similar: Flight 25.6%, Arena Shooter 21.2%, Cinematic 18.4%, Action 15.4%, Shooter 8%
- #35 Bodacious Blasteroids
74% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Mister Mippy
Windows
Bodacious Blasteroids is a fast paced arcade shooter where firepower is everything. Build a rotating arsenal of devastating weapons and obliterate waves of evolving enemies. Upgrade your weapons into screen-clearing powerhouses and form unique combinations of weapons to score the most points.
Why similar: Action Roguelike 31.5%, Arena Shooter 27.3%, Bullet Hell 24.2%, Action 11.8%, Colorful 4.7%
- #36 Parliament
74% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Bravebird Games
Windows
Play as an owl in the world's first "owl-like". Eat prey, fight predators and grow stronger to fight the fearsome Brown Bear! How long can you survive?
Why similar: Flight 47.6%, Action Roguelike 26.8%, Action 7.7%, PvE 7.5%, Colorful 4.5%
- #37 Deflect Boy
73% matchMostly Positive79% of 19 reviews2024
Dev: Reima Project
Windows
Deflect Boy is a top-down arena shooter, that instead of guns, you only have a shield. Deflect the bullets and combine new skills to create unique deflection powers and survive until the nightmare ends.
Why similar: Bullet Hell 28.8%, Action Roguelike 26.6%, Action 19.9%, Arena Shooter 17.2%, Shooter 7%
- #38 Space way: Echo of the Galaxy
72% match9 user reviews100% of 9 reviews2025
Dev: My general
Windows
In this retro space shooter you will have the opportunity to take control of a space fighter and crush waves of enemies. Show all your agility and reaction!
Why similar: Flight 45.9%, Bullet Hell 24.8%, Action 11.2%, Shooter 7.9%, Futuristic 6.1%
- #39 Plucked
73% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Wrenchy Productions
Windows
A top-down bullet-hell roguelite about a small, heavily armed duck. Pick a weapon, survive the waves, and merge your guns into increasingly stupid firepower while the pond does its best to pluck you. Quack responsibly.
Why similar: Bullet Hell 25.9%, Action Roguelike 25.3%, Action 18.2%, Arena Shooter 16.9%, Shooter 5.5%
- #40 Copter Besieged
72% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: CB Games
Windows
Copter Besieged is a multi-copter survival arena shooter. Realistic multi-copter flight with arcade style weapons, items, powerups and escalating monster waves. Dodge incoming attacks, shoot monsters, collect coins, level up your copter. Or race against your friends ghosts on the flight courses.
Why similar: Flight 34.4%, Arena Shooter 19.6%, Action Roguelike 19%, Bullet Hell 18.4%, Action 4.7%
- #41 Simply Survive
73% matchNo user reviews2025
Dev: Lorenzo St. LucePub: Descent Games
Windows
Simply Survive is a 2D bullet hell survival experience where you the player battle through waves of enemies to just survive as long as possible.
Why similar: Action Roguelike 37.1%, Bullet Hell 30.7%, Action 14.6%, Shooter 10.5%, Combat 6.4%
- #42 Pixel Canyon
71% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2026
Dev: MAXDEMAGE.PL
Windows
Blast through an endless, procedurally generated river canyon in this retro-style arcade shooter. Manage your fuel, graze enemies for energy, and uncover the story of the "Sky Ghosts" squadron. In Pixel Canyon, the river never ends - but your fuel might.
Why similar: Flight 49.8%, Bullet Hell 29.6%, Action 10.4%, Shooter 8.7%, Indie 0.9%
- #43 NIGHT RAIDER
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Spark Endless Studio
Windows
Survive endless dark monsters in this top-down 3D roguelike shooter. Use glowing swords and deadly magic to fight swarms. Auto-aim frees you to move and dodge. Upgrade over 20 skills to build your setup. How long can you live?
Why similar: Action Roguelike 34%, Bullet Hell 29.8%, Action 23%, Combat 7.1%, 3D 5.3%
- #44 Orbital Fighter
69% match6 user reviews83% of 6 reviews2026
Dev: Vantan Game Academy
Windows
Take control of a fighter ship in this space-themed flight action game. Master the game’s signature mechanics—Just Dodge and Just Parry—to suppress the planetary fortress that serves as the rebel army’s stronghold.
Why similar: Flight 67.4%, Action 16.9%, PvE 9.5%, 3D 5.3%, Singleplayer 0.8%
- #45 AIRHOUNDS
70% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Satini Games
Windows
Soar through the sky islands of Alioth and defeat any foe standing in your way using your piloting skills, unique abilities and powerful weapons. Airhounds is an aerial dogfighting rogue-like focused on fast-paced action!
Why similar: Flight 45.1%, Action Roguelike 19.9%, Shooter 6.4%, Action 5.7%, PvE 5.1%
- #46 Fly Hard
70% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Games by Clu
Windows
FLY LOW. FLY FAST. FLY HARD.Jump in the hot seat and get ready for an action-packed roguelike fighter jet thrill ride. Unlock weapons and upgrades to push your aircraft to the limit as you fight through an endless onslaught of enemy aircraft.
Why similar: Flight 47.1%, Action Roguelike 28.3%, Action 8.9%, Shooter 6.9%, Simulation 4.3%
- #47 Cars
69% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Yupu An
Windows
Dive into "How to Train Your Car". It's not just about speed, but mentoring your car to peak performance. Every choice shapes its growth; every race tests your bond. Can you guide your car to ultimate victory?
Why similar: Flight 44.7%, Action Roguelike 25.7%, Action 12.8%, Colorful 5.2%, Combat 5.1%
- #48 Air Gun Fighter
70% match8 user reviews25% of 8 reviews2020
Dev: Pix Arts
Windows · Mac
Realistic Modern Air Combat Game
Why similar: Flight 49.2%, Action 20%, Shooter 9.7%, Simulation 9.5%, Combat 7%
- #49 WingWhiz
68% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Ephesus Studios
Windows
You’re a combat aircraft fighting to survive in a chaos-ruled world where everything is against you. Upgrade your plane, secure power-ups, build combos, and tear apart anything in your way to unlock new worlds. Stay alive and show no mercy!
Why similar: Flight 32.2%, Bullet Hell 19.6%, Action Roguelike 18%, Action 9.5%, Shooter 7.8%
- #50 Cosmo Tales
68% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Bohemia Interactive
Windows
Cosmo Tales is a third person, action adventure inspired by the '70s retro sci-fi aesthetic mixed with modern looks and gameplay. Use the dimension shifting ability to change between realities as you fight your way through the outer space.
Why similar: Flight 41.7%, Action Roguelike 23%, Action 7.5%, Combat 7.1%, Shooter 7%
- #51 Rogue Sky
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Megabit Games
Windows
Master aerial acrobatics and bend time to your will in this arcade-style roguelite, where strategic depth meets intense acrobatic gameplay. Travel through time to unlock powerful synergies with upgrades that turn you into a godlike sky matador. Gear up and rule the sky!
Why similar: Flight 27.7%, Action Roguelike 22.3%, Bullet Hell 17%, Action 8.6%, Futuristic 7.2%
- #52 Skyguard 0: Air arcade
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: WaterproofjammPub: Labal13
Windows
Skyguard is a single player arcade flight combat game with stylized graphics and fast-paced gameplay. Switch between different squadrons, shred enemy in dogfight, engage groups of enemy with multi-lock weapons.
Why similar: Flight 61%, Action 11.1%, Shooter 9.2%, PvE 8.7%, Combat 4.3%
- #53 Squap
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Driftwood Games
Windows
Ready to bounce your way to victory? Well, then this is the game for you: Deploy your weapon and survive the relentless waves of shape-themed enemies. Pick from a wide array of upgrades and utilize them to build up your strength and cause chaos among your foes. HOW LONG CAN YOU LAST?
Why similar: Action Roguelike 27.2%, Arena Shooter 25.2%, Bullet Hell 22.3%, Action 18.3%, Combat 4%
- #54 Overvoid
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Max Style Games
Windows · Mac
Overvoid - is a dark sci-fi third-person space-combat roguelite. You are a starship pilot trapped in an endless cycle across hostile space sectors. Fight relentless enemy waves, experiment with builds, gather resources, and unlock weapons, ships, and modules to break the cycle.
Why similar: Flight 44.8%, Action Roguelike 28.1%, Action 12.8%, Futuristic 4.9%, PvE 4%
- #55 Nano.wars
69% match1 user reviews0% of 1 reviews2020
Dev: Hallid GamesPub: Jason Halliday
Windows
WELCOME! To Nano.wars. A next gen procedual fps action game. Do you have what it takes to become the next Nano.wars Champion? Lets wait and see....
Why similar: Arena Shooter 23.9%, Flight 20.8%, Action 18.7%, Bullet Hell 18.5%, Shooter 9.3%
- #56 X air combat
68% match7 user reviews14% of 7 reviews2021
Dev: Coke Cat Studio
Windows
The player controls the plane to fight the enemy in the sky, and the perspective of the game is third person.
Why similar: Flight 64.2%, Action 18.5%, Shooter 13.8%, Indie 2%, Singleplayer 1.4%
- #57 Wave 43
63% match8 user reviews100% of 8 reviews2026
Dev: Alien Game Studio
Windows
Capture fish. Grow stronger. Break the ocean. Build insane combos and climb the leaderboard.
Why similar: Action Roguelike 26.3%, Arena Shooter 24.3%, Bullet Hell 21.5%, Action 17.7%, Colorful 4.9%