- #1 Feather
97% matchVery Positive82% of 806 reviews2019
Dev: Samurai Punk
Windows · Mac
Median: 1.7 hrsMean: 4.6 hrs≥1hr: 64%
Feather is a multiplayer game about exploration, relaxation and immersion. Transform yourself into a bird, take flight, and enjoy a zen-like, picturesque landscape on your own terms. Swoop, glide, and backflip your way around mysterious locations to uncover hidden paths that only birds can follow!
Why similar: Flight 37.9%, Online Co-Op 10.9%, Open World 9.3%, Sandbox 8.8%, Exploration 8.7%
- #2 Microsoft Flight Simulator X: Steam Edition
96% matchVery Positive87% of 26,468 reviews2014
Dev: Microsoft Game StudiosPub: Xbox Game Studios
Windows
Median: 3.6 hrsMean: 46.5 hrs≥1hr: 71%
Take to the skies in the World’s favourite flight simulator! The multi award winning Microsoft Flight Simulator X lands on Steam for the first time. Take off from anywhere in the world, flying some of the world’s most iconic aircraft to any one of 24,000 destinations.
Why similar: Flight 68.9%, Simulation 11.8%, Open World 9.1%, Multiplayer 4%, First-Person 1.4%
- #3 Fly With Friends
96% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Ace Pilot
Windows
Fly With Friends is a social multiplayer flying game. Relax, explore, and fly...with friends!
Why similar: Flight 50.7%, Online Co-Op 14.2%, Exploration 7.9%, Sandbox 7.3%, Multiplayer 6%
- #4 Bush 1022
95% matchVery Positive99% of 92 reviews2025
Dev: dimitars
Windows · Linux
Fly a bush plane on the moon of a gas giant. Do deliveries, challenges and explore an open world.
Why similar: Flight 55.7%, Open World 13.4%, Exploration 11%, Relaxing 8.1%, Simulation 4.2%
- #5 X-Plane 11
94% matchVery Positive93% of 20,233 reviews2017
Dev: Laminar Research
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 14.9 hrsMean: 161.9 hrs≥1hr: 91%
The future of flight simulation is now! X-Plane 11 is the detailed, realistic, and modern simulator you’ve been waiting for. Intuitive user interface, 3-D cockpits, new effects, 3-D sound, living airports and world-wide scenery.
Why similar: Flight 65.8%, Simulation 13.3%, Open World 9.7%, Multiplayer 4.3%, Sandbox 2.5%
- #6 Cats Fly Helicopters
94% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Flippfly LLC
Windows · Mac · Linux
Cats Fly Helicopters is about creatively completing jobs with your homebuilt helicopters in a quirky simulated city of cats. Upgrade your gear while you meet the needs of residents - but try not to make a mess along the way.
Why similar: Flight 48.6%, Simulation 12.4%, Comedy 8.8%, Open World 7.6%, Action 7.5%
- #7 Coming soon
93% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Martin Chaperot
Windows
Gliderman is an open-world flight game where you play as a little glider trying to explore the randomly generated world around you. Pull off stunts and chase your highscore!
Why similar: Flight 43.7%, Sandbox 10.1%, Simulation 8.9%, Exploration 8.9%, Open World 7.9%
- #8 GravityOptional
92% matchNo user reviews
Dev: BlurryOwl
Windows
A physics-based co-op roguelite about flightless owls, crippling debt, and industrial glue. Pilot a rickety airship through acid storms, harpoon floating garbage, and build makeshift shelters out of stolen bathtubs to protect your cargo. If the package gets wet, you don't get paid.
Why similar: Flight 41.2%, Simulation 13.4%, Sandbox 11.3%, Exploration 9.7%, Online Co-Op 8%
- #9 Retro Flight Simulator 2026
91% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2026
Dev: OH Games Studio
Windows
Take off from airports around the world and explore a retro-styled open world from the cockpit of a passenger jet. Plan routes, use autopilot, fly through changing environments, and land at global destinations in a lightweight single-player flight simulation.
Why similar: Flight 50.8%, Simulation 17.9%, Sandbox 13.4%, Open World 12.5%, 3D 4%
- #10 Coastline Flight Simulator
90% matchMostly Positive73% of 22 reviews2021
Dev: Caipirinha Games GmbHPub: Caipirinha Games GmbH
Windows
Fly with your planes through the huge open world! Transport goods, trade and complete recon missions. Discover all settlements in the coastal landscape, the islands and the desert. Upgrade your planes and paint them in the colors of your choice!
Why similar: Flight 54.8%, Simulation 17.7%, Relaxing 10.6%, Open World 10.2%, 3D 4.2%
- #11 Eurofighter Typhoon
91% matchMostly Negative26% of 239 reviews2014
Dev: Rage SoftwarePub: Funbox Media Ltd
Windows
Median: 6 minMean: 14.0 hrs≥1hr: 19%
In Eurofighter Typhoon, you are flying the famous Eurofighter on top of Iceland to fight against Russian troops which invade the country and prevent the outbreak of World War III. Quickly outnumbered, the ICEFOR has been abandoned by NATO but has been able to deploy a small number of the new Typhoon aircraft.
Why similar: Flight 79.4%, Simulation 12.1%, Action 8.6%
- #12 Bird Go Sky
89% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Pixel-Furnace
Windows · Linux
A relaxed and friendly bird simulation game with co-op multiplayer. Fly around like a bird, build your nest and enjoy diverse environments filled with beautiful locations. Experience bird life and explore together with your friends.
Why similar: Flight 40.8%, Relaxing 9.3%, Exploration 9.3%, Open World 9.2%, Simulation 6.1%
- #13 Vector Thrust
89% matchMixed48% of 742 reviews2015
Dev: TimeSymmetryPub: Iceberg Interactive
Windows
Median: 4.3 hrsMean: 6.1 hrs≥1hr: 90%
Vector Thrust is a fast-paced single and mulltiplayer combat flight game, using a unique cel shaded art style. The game features 260 fully playable aircraft (through various iterations of over 45 aircraft models).
Why similar: Flight 67.2%, Simulation 16.1%, Action 10.1%, Multiplayer 3.6%, Indie 2.3%
- #14 Compass
87% matchPositive83% of 12 reviews2026
Dev: TREBUCHET
Windows
Explore long lost skies in Compass, an open-world piloting adventure about finding your way through uncharted clouds. Maneuver your ship through hazardous floating landscapes, complete challenges with your grapples, upgrade your vessel, and lead the Caravan forward.
Why similar: Flight 47.4%, Exploration 11.2%, Open World 10.6%, Relaxing 9.1%, Simulation 6.3%
- #15 Joy Flight
88% matchMixed69% of 26 reviews2022
Dev: Nic SchubertPub: Tonic Games Australia
Windows
Joy Flight is an open world arcade VR flight game where players will explore, unlock runways with daring landings and complete missions across a large chain of islands! Free to Play
Why similar: Flight 55.6%, Open World 14.6%, Exploration 9.2%, Simulation 8.6%, Action 7%
- #16 Aery - Calm Mind
86% matchVery Positive83% of 88 reviews2021
Dev: EpiXR Games UG
Windows
Aery - Calm Mind is an interactive game experience that is designed to relax your mind and soul. Calm down from the hassle of your daily life, experience the feeling of flying, and immerse yourself into beautiful and atmospheric landscapes.
Why similar: Flight 55.1%, Relaxing 14.8%, Exploration 10.8%, Simulation 8.7%, Colorful 4.1%
- #17 No Panic
86% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Last Bullet Studio
Windows
NO PANIC is a cooperative, high-pressure party game where 2-4 players must communicate, multi-task, and make fast decisions to keep a failing airplane in the air. The game aims to turn stressful situations into fun, memorable moments through controlled chaos, humor, and shared responsibility.
Why similar: Flight 44.6%, Simulation 13.9%, Comedy 11.5%, Action 9.1%, Online Co-Op 7.6%
- #18 Abloom
85% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Nicolas Poumaredes
Windows
Experience a vibrant flight and slide through a dead forest, solve mysteries, and bring life back to a world consumed by a black hole in this atmospheric puzzle game.
Why similar: Flight 50.9%, Relaxing 13.6%, Exploration 12.8%, Open World 8.7%, First-Person 3.9%
- #19 Jet Fighters with Friends 5
84% match5 user reviews100% of 5 reviews2024
Dev: Archor WrightPub: Archor Games
Windows
Jet Fighters with Friends 5 - UFOs are attacking London, Go get 'em! Single Player OR Multiplayer Jet Fighter Game with A.I. UFO Bots. PvP or COOP.
Why similar: Flight 49%, Simulation 16.2%, Online Co-Op 14%, Action 10.7%, Multiplayer 4.1%
- #20 RotorSim: Helicopter Simulator
83% matchPositive100% of 21 reviews2025
Dev: Immaculate Lift Studio
Windows · Linux
Retro-style helicopter simulation built with love and focused on easy to pick up mechanics. Fly around and test your skills with 3 different aircraft in a dynamic, mission-filled world.
Why similar: Flight 63.6%, Simulation 15.7%, Exploration 10.4%, Third Person 6.1%, 3D 3%
- #21 X-Plane 10 Global - 64 Bit
82% matchMostly Positive71% of 1,015 reviews2014
Dev: Laminar ResearchPub: Aerosoft GmbH
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 2.3 hrsMean: 36.7 hrs≥1hr: 68%
X-Plane 10 brings numerous improvements and enhancements for PC, Mac and Linux virtual pilots, unleashing the power of modern systems with its 64 bit processing and multi-core support.
Why similar: Flight 62.9%, Simulation 16.7%, Open World 11.3%, Multiplayer 3.8%, First-Person 1.7%
- #22 Dear Passengers
81% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: FLEXUS
Windows
Play in co-op as the crew of the world’s worst airline. Your plane is falling apart, your cargo is illegal, and passenger safety barely makes the list.
Why similar: Online Co-Op 28.2%, Flight 22.4%, Comedy 17.9%, Multiplayer 8%, Funny 5.7%
- #23 Superflight
81% matchOverwhelmingly Positive96% of 11,574 reviews2017
Dev: GrizzlyGames
Windows
Median: 42 minMean: 13.0 hrs≥1hr: 43%
Superflight is an intense, easy to learn wingsuit game with an infinite number of beautiful procedurally generated maps. A great game to relax for half an hour and chase your latest highscore!
Why similar: Flight 64.3%, Relaxing 15.2%, Open World 5.1%, Exploration 3.9%, Action 3.2%
- #24 Pocket Flight
80% match5 user reviews60% of 5 reviews2026
Dev: Just Pocket Games
Windows · Linux
Fly your own way in Pocket Flight - a cozy endless flight adventure! Explore dynamic biomes, face shifting weather, customize your plane, and take on daily challenges. Relaxing skies, infinite horizons. Ready for takeoff?
Why similar: Flight 52.1%, Open World 13.7%, Relaxing 12.1%, Exploration 7.9%, Simulation 4.2%
- #25 Air Attack 3.0, Aerial Firefighting Game
82% match8 user reviews13% of 8 reviews2019
Dev: ATC Flight Simulator
Windows
Experience the challenge of battling raging wildland fires from the air, from the makers of the flight simulators used to train real air attack pilots.
Why similar: Flight 71.2%, Simulation 23.7%, Action 3.7%, Singleplayer 1.4%
- #26 Jetpack Vacation
78% matchMixed59% of 17 reviews2021
Dev: Tourism InfinityPub: Clique Games
Windows
Prepare to take flight! Explore a tropical paradise with your own handheld jetpacks where you can hang out with other players, score some goals in Jetpack Stadium, or try your hand at target shooting! Pack your virtual bags and get ready for your own Jetpack Vacation!
Why similar: Flight 43%, Open World 11.7%, Relaxing 10.4%, Exploration 10%, Sandbox 8.9%
- #27 F-22 Lightning 3
79% matchMostly Positive70% of 204 reviews2009
Dev: NovaLogic
Windows
Median: 18 minMean: 3.3 hrs≥1hr: 33%
Mass Destruction! Use tactical nuclear weapons to level entire city regions. The most realistic weather environments ever created. Changing weather effects including: rain, snow, hail, and wind. Extreme temperatures affect flight performance. Fly it yourself or let the world's most advanced fighter do it for you!
Why similar: Flight 77.6%, Simulation 22.4%
- #28 Aery - Broken Memories
78% matchMostly Positive73% of 41 reviews2020
Dev: EpiXR Games UG
Windows
You are a little bird that flies smoothly through thoughts, fears, and memories of an unknown person. Experience the feeling of flying, immerse into beautiful and atmospheric landscapes, and enjoy the unique storytelling of the game while getting attached to the lovely main character.
Why similar: Flight 55.7%, Simulation 10.5%, Exploration 7.9%, Action 6.9%, Third Person 4.4%
- #29 Airplane Mode
77% matchMixed66% of 400 reviews2020
Dev: BacronymPub: AMC Games
Windows · Mac
Airplane Mode delivers all the thrills of a real-time, six-hour commercial airline flight—in Coach. At least you've got a window seat. Buckle up.
Why similar: Flight 48.1%, Comedy 15.3%, Simulation 13.9%, Relaxing 11.4%, Funny 4.6%
- #30 Helicopter Simulator
76% matchMixed59% of 179 reviews2020
Dev: Lines Studio
Windows
Helicopter Simulator: Exceptional missions in a detailed environment, creating an atmosphere for an immersive and bluffing experience!
Why similar: Flight 60.4%, Simulation 23%, Open World 15.1%, Indie 1.6%
- #31 SKYSAVIOR Helicopter Services
74% matchVery Positive100% of 62 reviews2025
Dev: Raphael do Amaral de AlbuquerquePub: CÓDIGO JUSTO
Windows · Linux
Save the city from chaos! In the game, the player takes on the role of a helicopter pilot fulfilling objectives transmitted by the operations center.
Why similar: Flight 48.3%, Simulation 9.6%, Exploration 8.8%, Open World 7.1%, Action 6.1%
- #32 RealFlight Trainer Edition
75% matchVery Positive88% of 535 reviews2020
Dev: Horizon Hobby, LLC
Windows
RealFlight Trainer Edition is the perfect way to learn radio control flying on your PC. With 8 aircraft from Horizon Hobby (more are unlockable) and flying lessons from experienced RC pilots, you'll be ready to solo in no time. When you're ready, an upgrade to RealFlight Evolution is also available.
Why similar: Flight 66.5%, Simulation 15.6%, Relaxing 8.7%, First-Person 5.3%, Singleplayer 2.2%
- #33 LAY
75% matchVery Positive85% of 514 reviews2022
Dev: Objectif 3D
Windows
Immerse yourself in this adventure of poetic and contemplative exploration as Elise, a young explorer full of energy. This mysterious world awaits you to overflow with colour and life !
Why similar: Flight 49.5%, Open World 13.7%, Exploration 11%, Relaxing 9.8%, Third Person 6.4%
- #34 Urlaubsflug Simulator – Holiday Flight Simulator
76% matchMixed57% of 163 reviews2017
Dev: Caipirinha GamesPub: SimWare Simulations
Windows
Without doubt flying virtual aircraft from your PC is one of the most interesting simulations – at the same time, it is one with a very steep learning curve. Holiday Flight Simulator, though, makes it especially easy to relive the last holiday trip from the cockpit’s view.
Why similar: Flight 50.3%, Exploration 10.5%, Simulation 10.4%, Relaxing 8.7%, Open World 6.8%
- #35 The Confidential Disclosure
74% matchNo user reviews
Dev: isontheedgePub: Lambisgoia Games
Windows · Mac · Linux
Pilot a UFO over an infinite voxel world that curves like a tiny planet. Abduct, destroy and uncover what humanity hid — while the army, the police and the men in black hunt you across a living, fully destructible sandbox.
Why similar: Flight 41.3%, Simulation 13.5%, Sandbox 11.5%, Exploration 9.7%, Comedy 8.6%
- #36 Banana Airways
73% matchNo user reviews2027
Dev: Eggscape Entertainment Inc.
Windows
Chaotic co-op for 1-4 players. You're the crew of the world's worst low-cost airline. Repair engines out on the wing, dodge storms, keep the plane in the air, and somehow keep the passengers happy while they keep asking for coffee. It's complete chaos with friends, and that's exactly the point.
Why similar: Flight 41.1%, Online Co-Op 21.4%, Comedy 15.2%, Multiplayer 4%, Funny 3.8%
- #37 Fluid Flight
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Frakk
Windows
Fluid Flight is an RC flight simulator with a unique flight model. It is currently a work in progress.
Why similar: Flight 61.1%, Simulation 20%, Sandbox 12.3%, 3D 3.9%, Singleplayer 1.5%
- #38 Launch President
72% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Kenji TomitaPub: Kanazawa Racing
Windows
President Launcher is a simple physics-based sandbox game created purely for fun. Tap the launch button to send the president flying into the air, and use sliders to adjust gravity and launch power. There are no goals or rules—just experiment the unpredictable, over-the-top physics simulation.
Why similar: Flight 63.4%, Open World 15.5%, Action 13.6%, Colorful 5.8%, Singleplayer 1.7%
- #39 Copoka
73% matchMostly Positive79% of 266 reviews2017
Dev: Inaccurate InteractivePub: Guru Games
Windows
Median: 2.6 hrsMean: 3.3 hrs≥1hr: 85%
Copoka is an open-world exploratory indie game where you play as a bird flying around a city looking for twigs to build your nest.
Why similar: Flight 57.6%, Open World 14.6%, Exploration 12.6%, Simulation 8.8%, Atmospheric 3.9%
- #40 Isle of the Eagle
71% match6 user reviews67% of 6 reviews2025
Dev: More K Games LLC
Windows
A beautiful open world/exploration eagle simulator game that takes place in Alaska! Fly from island to island with incredibly fun and realistic flying controls! Complete mini quests! Unlock special abilities! Discover Treasure! Controllers supported: PS5, Xbox, or PC Keyboard.
Why similar: Flight 49.2%, Open World 14.2%, Relaxing 11.1%, Exploration 10.1%, Simulation 8.7%
- #41 Aery - A Journey Beyond Time
72% matchVery Positive82% of 71 reviews2021
Dev: EpiXR Games UG
Windows
In Aery – A Journey Beyond Time you are in the role of a flying god-like creature which observes the world and their inhabitants while they grow and evolve through time. Are you ready to explore time itself?
Why similar: Flight 50.8%, Exploration 11.9%, Simulation 11.1%, Relaxing 10.2%, Action 4.9%
- #42 AER Memories of Old
71% matchVery Positive86% of 7,716 reviews2017
Dev: Forgotten KeyPub: Daedalic Entertainment
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 3.2 hrsMean: 5.9 hrs≥1hr: 83%
Transform into a bird and fly to explore and experience a vibrant world of floating islands in the sky. Venture down into lost ancient ruins where each step leads you closer to the end of the world.
Why similar: Flight 43.3%, Open World 15.8%, Exploration 14.8%, Relaxing 13.2%, Third Person 4.1%
- #43 Aery - Heaven & Hell
70% matchPositive100% of 11 reviews2023
Dev: EpiXR Games UG
Windows
Discover the passions and fears of the human race as a flying god-like creature.
Why similar: Flight 59.7%, Relaxing 13%, Simulation 11.3%, Exploration 11%, Atmospheric 3.2%
- #44 Wingsuit: Romsdalen
68% match4 user reviews100% of 4 reviews2026
Dev: Ninja Whale Studios
Windows
Feel the rush of Norway’s Romsdalen Valley in this intense action sports game. Pilot a high-performance wingsuit through challenging exits, daring stunts and vast mountain landscapes. Are you ready to hit the slopes?
Why similar: Flight 46.4%, Online Co-Op 16.8%, Open World 13.1%, Simulation 8.1%, Multiplayer 4.6%
- #45 The Bird's Realm 3
69% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2022
Dev: BlueFireArtsPub: BlueFireArts_Dev
Windows
This is another simple calm open world bird flying simulator! There are no goals or quests, just simply flying around this large island in a sandbox open world to kill time. Find glowing eggs to unlock a bird.
Why similar: Flight 63.7%, Sandbox 16.8%, Open World 12.3%, 3D 5%, Singleplayer 2.3%
- #46 InnerSpace
70% matchMixed61% of 355 reviews2018
Dev: PolyKnight GamesPub: Aspyr
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 3.4 hrsMean: 4.7 hrs≥1hr: 90%
Soar through virgin skies and dive into lost oceans as you hunt for the ancient gods of the Inverse, a forsaken realm of inside-out planets. Created by a small team of seven developers and originally funded on Kickstarter, InnerSpace is a bright, colorful exploration flying game with no horizons.
Why similar: Flight 53.8%, Exploration 13.7%, Open World 13.1%, Relaxing 11.6%, Colorful 2.4%
- #47 Horse Riding Classic
66% matchVery Positive98% of 122 reviews2026
Dev: Juice Cube
Windows
Experience the classic majesty of soaring through the skies on Horseback. Collect over 99 Apples hidden throughout a Handcrafted 3-Dimensional World, push technology to its limit and Breed the Ultimate Horse, and destroy The Glue Factory and Save Horse Kind.
Why similar: Flight 32.6%, Comedy 12.9%, Open World 10.5%, Relaxing 7.9%, Exploration 7.6%
- #48 CurryKitten FPV Simulator
68% matchVery Positive82% of 60 reviews2020
Dev: Wayne AndrewsPub: CurryKitten
Windows · Mac · Linux
Take charge of a powerful and acrobatic quadcopter and learn to fly it around the mountainous landscape. Rip through the partly-constructed building site, bash into the beach ball, chase cars, or fly up close and personal with an AI plane. Play it solo, or online with friends.
Why similar: Flight 51.6%, Simulation 25.3%, Action 15.2%, Multiplayer 6.3%, Indie 1.6%
- #49 Thunder Helix
67% matchVery Positive97% of 129 reviews2024
Dev: David Walters
Windows
Pilot deadly helicopter gunships, battle enemy forces and complete dangerous missions within a thrilling desert warzone!
Why similar: Flight 66%, Simulation 19.4%, Action 8.8%, 3D 4.6%, Indie 1.3%
- #50 Project Red Sun
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: AOA Studios
Windows
Project Red Sun is a combat flight action game that has you fighting across the world as a heroic ace against corporate armies who will spare no expense in trying to take you down. With specialized jets and weaponry, dogfight aces, airships, and more in a campaign packed with arcade gameplay.
Why similar: Flight 71.8%, Simulation 14.9%, Action 7.1%, 3D 4.8%, Singleplayer 1.4%
- #51 White Memories
66% match7 user reviews57% of 7 reviews2026
Dev: POSTITANIKPub: IAD3D
Windows
Take the mantle of a postman who refuses to give up his job, even after death. Clinging to your last memory, take off into the world of the forgotten to deliver your letters to the ghosts that are stuck there, allowing them to reach the afterlife. Protect your mail from those who are pursuing you.
Why similar: Flight 66.9%, Exploration 13%, Action 6%, Third Person 5.2%, 3D 3.4%
- #52 MiG-29 Fulcrum
69% matchVery Positive89% of 111 reviews2009
Dev: NovaLogic
Windows
Median: 12 minMean: 3.1 hrs≥1hr: 27%
The Mikoyan-Gurevich MiG-29 Fulcrum is one of the world's most maneuverable and toughest fighter jets and has often been compared to its closest Western counterpart, the F-16. Innovations unique to the aircraft allow MiG pilots to perform remarkable moves like the Tailslide and Cobra maneuvers.
Why similar: Flight 72.5%, Simulation 27.5%
- #53 Lakehopper
64% matchVery Positive88% of 473 reviews2026
Dev: Photon Games
Windows · Linux
Take flight in a seaplane flight simulator through a rugged world where you are responsible for the care and maintenance of your plane. Deliver cargo between far-flung communities in a flooded landscape that challenges your piloting skills! Fix your plane and keep flying!
Why similar: Flight 56.4%, Simulation 13%, Exploration 10.2%, Open World 8.3%, Sandbox 6.7%
- #54 F-16 Multirole Fighter
68% matchVery Positive85% of 144 reviews2009
Dev: NovaLogic
Windows
Median: 24 minMean: 4.2 hrs≥1hr: 41%
With innovative technologies such as fly-by-wire controls, sophisticated systems for night and all-weather operations and the ability to carry a variety of weapons, the F-16 continually proves to be the workhorse of the USAF. Victorious in all of its air-to-air engagements, the awesome reputation of the F-16 is undisputed.
Why similar: Flight 71.9%, Simulation 28.1%