- #1 Tiny Dino
97% matchMostly Positive76% of 49 reviews2025
Dev: Pixfox
Windows
TINY DINO is an idle nurturing game where little dinosaurs accompany you at the bottom of your screen while you work or study. They produce gems for you to earn profits, and you can plant trees and build structures to create a free and lively world for them, growing together with you.
Why similar: Creature Collector 40.4%, Idler 31%, Cute 12.3%, Casual 10.5%, Singleplayer 3.6%
- #2 BirdBalcony
96% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Love7
Windows · Mac
BirdBalcony is a cozy desktop companion where you feed birds, decorate your balcony, and collect letter fragments to uncover hidden stories. With changing time and weather, each visit feels alive—you never know who will come next.
Why similar: Idler 38.4%, Creature Collector 28.8%, Casual 14.8%, Cute 13.8%, Singleplayer 2.6%
- #3 Goobers
96% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2026
Dev: Marzipug
Windows
An idle creature collector game. From common garden-dwellers to elusive, legendary spirits, every Goober is unique. Can you find them all?
Why similar: Creature Collector 34.3%, Idler 29.7%, Casual 18.4%, Cute 12.4%, Indie 5.2%
- #4 Pet Sanctuary
95% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Nick F
Windows
Pet Sanctuary is a relaxing game where you take care of your pets. From feeding them fruit to choosing a favorite outfit, you take care of and nature your chosen pet in this bright and joyful world. Plus, with mini games like Snake and Memory Mountain, you can earn rewards that your pet will love.
Why similar: Creature Collector 35.6%, Idler 28.1%, Casual 18.8%, Cute 14.4%, Singleplayer 3.1%
- #5 Isles of Isvenness
94% match1 user reviews0% of 1 reviews2025
Dev: Kazumi Games Inc.
Windows
A cozy creature-collecting idle game featuring vibrantly handcrafted islands that are freely movable on your screen. Harness elemental aether, grow your creature collection, complete missions, and achieve progression milestones at your own pace for a relaxing and rewarding gameplay experience.
Why similar: Creature Collector 42.1%, Idler 32%, Casual 13%, Cute 8.7%, Singleplayer 2.6%
- #6 Moggmon
94% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Aura Industry, Inc
Windows · Mac · Linux
Moggmon is a relaxing idle monster collecting game where you click an egg, buy lab upgrades, choose Boost Drops, hatch Gen 1 pixel creatures, and chase standard, holo, and prismatic variants in a clean retro collection.
Why similar: Creature Collector 43.1%, Idler 32.6%, Casual 14.2%, Cute 6.6%, Singleplayer 2.1%
- #7 Lunar Farer: Little Flickers
93% matchNo user reviews
Dev: StarvdevGames
Windows
A collection of idle games that sit at the bottom of your screen, different adventures and companions await in the universe of Lunar Farer, where you will see glimpses of it while while you work or relax.
Why similar: Creature Collector 39.3%, Idler 31.8%, Casual 17.4%, Cute 7%, Singleplayer 3.1%
- #8 Little Fish Swims On
92% matchPositive100% of 17 reviews2024
Dev: DeepSeaStudio
Windows
Little Fish Swims is a relaxing and enjoyable idle game with a casual simulated fish tank located at the top of the screen. There are over a thousand types of fish in the game, and you can customize your own fish tank and background skin style.
Why similar: Creature Collector 41.4%, Idler 39.2%, Casual 14.5%, Indie 2.6%, Singleplayer 2.2%
- #9 Fishing Tales: Neko's Journey
91% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: AaronPub: TeamMingo
Windows · Mac
A relaxing idle fishing game focused on companionship, featuring 26 fishing spots and over 200 fish species. Easy to enjoy without much effort. You can place the game anywhere on your screen while studying or working, without it intruding on your tasks.
Why similar: Creature Collector 36.7%, Idler 34%, Casual 17%, Cute 9.6%, Singleplayer 2.7%
- #10 太饿了 So Hungry
91% match2 user reviews0% of 2 reviews2024
Dev: XIAOWUWEI
Windows
《So Hungry》is a casual idle game. Come and collect various animal and plant cards!
Why similar: Creature Collector 35.2%, Idler 33.1%, Casual 18.9%, Cute 8.7%, Singleplayer 2.3%
- #11 Monster Nursery
90% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Mimi
Windows
A relaxing idle monster collection game (with offline progress). Features 200 monster entries and 29 Lo-fi tracks.
Why similar: Creature Collector 32.4%, Idler 30.6%, Casual 18.7%, Cute 14.9%, Singleplayer 1.9%
- #12 Shanhai Ranch
89% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2026
Dev: Banana Peel Studio
Windows
Shanhai Ranch is a desktop idle management game. Collect mythical beasts, assign the five elements, and let them dig treasure, produce resources, and build your ranch on your desktop. Expand storage, upgrade buildings, and grow your own automated beast-running loop.
Why similar: Creature Collector 37.1%, Idler 35%, Casual 12.8%, Cute 12.5%, Singleplayer 1.6%
- #13 Virsamals Companion Console
89% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Unit Golem
Windows
Virsamals Companion Console is a retro game console for your desktop. Go on up to five daily idle adventures to collect and evolve creatures! Then trade encounter records with other players to complete your collection.
Why similar: Creature Collector 41.8%, Idler 39.6%, Casual 16.2%, Singleplayer 2.4%
- #14 Your Cock
87% matchPositive94% of 33 reviews2025
Dev: CrowZ GamesPub: FHNBHJ
Windows
An unremarkable little animal desktop pet, until you read its name.
Why similar: Creature Collector 37.1%, Idler 36.4%, Casual 14.6%, Cute 10.4%, Singleplayer 1.6%
- #15 Desktop Jinja
88% matchNo user reviews2025
Dev: Anisile
Windows
Build a personal shrine on your desktop—pray, draw fortunes, and receive gentle blessings each day.
Why similar: Idler 55.2%, Casual 20%, Cute 18.2%, Singleplayer 4.1%, Indie 2.5%
- #16 Meowmewbug
86% matchPositive95% of 19 reviews2024
Dev: BitBit Official
Windows
" Meowmewbug" is a relaxing and stress-relieving idle game. Tap on the magic circle to summon unique meowmewbugs, collect the paw balls they drop, unlock more styles of scenes, fun features, classic mini-games, and summon even more meowmewbugs. Come and spend the best day with the meowmewbugs!
Why similar: Creature Collector 39.2%, Idler 38.7%, Casual 10.8%, Cute 9.2%, Singleplayer 2.1%
- #17 メダルのなる木
86% matchMixed57% of 14 reviews2025
Dev: あのゲームの作り方
Windows
Enjoy the medal pusher game on your desktop! For those of you who are busy, the Kamo characters will help carry the medals! Use the medals you've collected to earn even more!
Why similar: Idler 52.9%, Casual 22.7%, Cute 15.9%, Singleplayer 6.1%, Indie 2.2%
- #18 CODIT
85% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Sogeum
Windows
An idle desktop pet game featuring 'Mini,' a cute character roaming your screen. Collect items and outfits from Mini's gifts to customize your friend. Interact during your daily tasks to raise affinity and unlock unique reactions. A perfect, healing companion for your desktop!
Why similar: Idler 50.2%, Casual 26.3%, Cute 17%, Singleplayer 4.4%, Indie 2.2%
- #19 Quack & Hatch
84% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2026
Dev: Pedro AnjosPub: Pixel Purrfect
Windows
Breed, hatch, and level up ducks of all rarities on your incremental duck farm! Make your ducks work for food to level them up to unlock rarer breeds with unique traits. Can you hatch the rarest ducks? Start farming now!
Why similar: Creature Collector 41.4%, Idler 34.2%, Casual 10.7%, Cute 9.9%, Indie 2.1%
- #20 Koi Land
84% match8 user reviews100% of 8 reviews2024
Dev: GG.Game
Windows
"Koi Land" is a highly relaxing idle game. Purchase various types of koi fry, raise them over time, and sell them to earn money! Over 40 types of koi , listen to soothing music, and enjoy the sight of colorful koi as they accompany you through pleasant times!
Why similar: Creature Collector 37.3%, Idler 36.7%, Casual 19.3%, Indie 3.7%, Singleplayer 2.9%
- #21 Just a Cat
83% matchNo user reviews
Dev: lonelystar
Windows
Just a Cat is a cute casual idle game about a cat that stays on your screen while you work or relax. Dress him with hats and glasses, watch his reactions, and track mouse clicks and keyboard presses as part of your personal statistics.
Why similar: Idler 50.5%, Casual 27.9%, Cute 17.7%, Singleplayer 4%
- #22 Glassbound
82% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Double Mole
Windows · Mac
Build an otherworldly lab along the bottom of your screen. Invite unique companions to join you. 200+ creatures await summoning and fusion—raise them in bottles and decide their fate: convert to materials, or sacrifice them to darker forces?
Why similar: Creature Collector 39.4%, Idler 38.2%, Casual 14.1%, Cute 5.6%, Indie 1.7%
- #23 FluffyInn
82% matchNo user reviews
Dev: DogeMotor
Windows · Mac
This is a special inn located at the bottom of your computer desktop, where everyone—from staff to customers—is fluffy! Unlock and purchase different facilities to improve customer satisfaction, earn more coins, then become the ultimate manager!
Why similar: Creature Collector 37.3%, Idler 33.8%, Cute 12.8%, Casual 11.6%, Indie 2.4%
- #24 Mothiary
81% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Denver
Windows · Mac · Linux
An idle game about collecting moths.
Why similar: Creature Collector 46%, Idler 36.7%, Casual 10.4%, Cute 5.8%, Singleplayer 1.1%
- #25 slimes!
81% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: zulakgames
Windows
Slimes! brings you dangerous levels of anticipation. With unpredictable bounces, endless cosmetic loot, and many different squishy slimes, you grow your very own slime sanctuary. Collect items, customize your buddy, and watch as the slimes unlock new areas and challenges. It's absolutely sub-slime.
Why similar: Creature Collector 42.6%, Idler 27%, Casual 19.7%, Cute 9.2%, Indie 1.5%
- #26 Lootimals
80% matchMostly Negative35% of 37 reviews2025
Dev: Lootimals
Windows
Lootimals is a chill idle pet collection game where you hatch surprise eggs every 30 minutes. Discover uniquely named creatures across rarity tiers, unlock backgrounds and egg skins, complete collections, and trade in extras for missing pets. No combat, no pressure — just pure collecting bliss.
Why similar: Creature Collector 38.8%, Idler 31%, Casual 19.8%, Cute 8.6%, Singleplayer 1.8%
- #27 Aquanore
78% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2026
Dev: Elerium Studios
Windows
A cozy idle aquarium game: collect, breed, and sell fish, shape your tank with decorations, grow your economy, and relax while your fish earn for you.
Why similar: Creature Collector 39.6%, Idler 31.9%, Casual 16.9%, Cute 10.4%, Singleplayer 1.1%
- #28 Desk Paws
77% matchVery Positive89% of 557 reviews2025
Dev: GinkgoGamesPub: Captcha Games
Windows · Mac
Median: 17.2 hrsMean: 78.0 hrs≥1hr: 88%
Collect over 100 stylish little pets on your desktop! They can freely move along the bottom of your screen, or live in the little houses you've carefully decorated for them. Hmm... or perhaps send them on adventures to earn treats?
Why similar: Creature Collector 38.2%, Idler 34.1%, Cute 13.5%, Casual 11.3%, Singleplayer 2.9%
- #29 Melo's cat cafe
79% match6 user reviews83% of 6 reviews2024
Dev: Melo
Windows
"Melo's Cat Cafe" is the perfect game for players who want to relax in a stress-free environment. Instead of chasing goals, players can simply enjoy spending time with the cats. Observe the cats as they eat and sleep, and find peace of mind in their calm presence.
Why similar: Idler 47.8%, Casual 28.3%, Cute 16.5%, Singleplayer 4.6%, Indie 2.7%
- #30 Check in
79% match6 user reviews83% of 6 reviews2024
Dev: Rescras
Windows
"Check in" is a pure collection-based game where there are no complex operations; completing all challenges simply requires checking in on different dates.
Why similar: Idler 53.1%, Casual 32.3%, Indie 8.2%, Singleplayer 6.4%
- #31 Taskbar Looters
78% matchPositive90% of 10 reviews2025
Dev: B52
Windows
Taskbar Looters is a simple idle game where animal looters collect treasures on your desktop while you focus on other tasks.
Why similar: Idler 52%, Casual 20.8%, Cute 18.9%, Singleplayer 4.2%, Indie 4%
- #32 Fantasy Idle Dungeon
75% matchMixed68% of 575 reviews2025
Dev: Leaves GamesPub: Gamersky Games
Windows
In Fantasy Idle Dungeon, hatch and capture rare Jenin, awaken their legendary skills and talents, and experience the joy of leveling up, evolving, and fusing them. Freely customize your gear, assemble an unbeatable adventure team, and claim glorious victories with effortless idle gameplay!
Why similar: Idler 43.3%, Creature Collector 30.4%, Casual 13.1%, Cute 9.1%, Singleplayer 2.5%
- #33 Hashie
77% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2025
Dev: Stone Coyote Games
Windows
In Hashie, you get to care for a weird, hand-drawn alien hash blob.
Why similar: Creature Collector 49.5%, Idler 37.5%, Casual 10.8%, Singleplayer 2.2%
- #34 Tiny Slime Farm
76% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Chocolate Soft
Windows
A cozy desktop idle game where cute slimes bounce around your tiny farm while you work or study.
Why similar: Creature Collector 37%, Idler 33.6%, Cute 14.6%, Casual 9.3%, Singleplayer 4.1%
- #35 Mermeows: Chill Cat Mermaids
76% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Gemcraft Games
Windows
Welcome to Mermeows: Chill Cat Mermaids – where every splash brings a smile! In this enchanting idle clicker creature collection game, traverse hand-drawn lakes, hatch unique Mermeows, and upgrade serene habitats. Collect pearls and let magical currents carry you into a world of calm strategy.
Why similar: Creature Collector 44.5%, Idler 30.3%, Cute 11.8%, Casual 11.5%, Singleplayer 2%
- #36 Work Beasts
75% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Canary Cartel
Windows · Mac · Linux
Manage your workforce of mystical work beasts! Increase your team productivity in order to complete the most difficult jobs and earn lots of money, after all, the government won't leave you alone if you don't pay your taxes. Oh, don't forget to give your employers a coffee sometimes.
Why similar: Creature Collector 40.6%, Idler 36.9%, Casual 12.5%, Cute 5.4%, Indie 2.8%
- #37 KemonoMix Re
73% matchPositive92% of 12 reviews2026
Dev: Rocket Studio, Inc.
Windows
『Kemono Mix Re』is a exploration, monster-raising simulation game where you nurture local lifeform called 'Kemonos' on a mysterious alien planet. Discover over 60+ Kemono species. Mixing Kemonos together, make your very own Kemono!
Why similar: Creature Collector 62.4%, Cute 19.6%, Casual 14.5%, Singleplayer 3.6%
- #38 Lofi Succubus
74% matchNo user reviews
Dev: SunnyCat
Windows · Linux
A relaxing idle collection game with beautiful girls (supports offline). You are an egg keeper helping the girls hatch monster eggs. 3 beautiful girls + 200 monster eggs + soothing lo-fi music♪
Why similar: Idler 40.6%, Creature Collector 22.4%, Casual 21%, Cute 14.3%, Singleplayer 1.8%
- #39 Fungiculture
74% matchMixed60% of 10 reviews2024
Dev: Inner Realm Studios
Windows
A cute and relaxing mushroom farming idler. Collect a variety of mushrooms, watch and help them grow, then sell them off for more money to buy more packs and discover them all.
Why similar: Idler 50.4%, Casual 27.2%, Cute 16.2%, Singleplayer 3.8%, Indie 2.5%
- #40 Chopikoji Gardens
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Moleman Studios
Windows · Mac · Linux
Chopikoji Gardens is a relaxing creature collector where you can create art, enter contests, and play mini-games with your Chopikojis to earn money and level up your collection, or just sit back and let them do all the hard work for you!
Why similar: Creature Collector 45.8%, Idler 33.2%, Casual 10.7%, Cute 9%, Indie 1.3%
- #41 Space Memory: Parrots
72% matchMixed64% of 11 reviews2025
Dev: Quantum Quiver Games
Windows
Cute, relaxing memory game where you match pairs of adorable parrots in space
Why similar: Creature Collector 51.3%, Casual 27.1%, Cute 17.5%, Singleplayer 4%
- #42 Dino Clicker
73% matchMixed53% of 53 reviews2024
Dev: Polygon Pie
Windows
Tap repeatedly to crack open an ancient egg and collect 9 different dinosaurs, from common to rare and elusive creatures. Try out this addictive clicker game that challenges you to unlock them all through luck and perseverance!
Why similar: Idler 35.4%, Creature Collector 27.9%, Casual 19.3%, Cute 12.3%, Indie 2.8%
- #43 Fantasy Bird Woods
72% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: SouthBoat Games
Windows
Fantasy Bird Woods is a desktop idle game. Observe and guide mystical birds on the right side of your screen. They evolve alongside your work or study without window-switching. Enjoy light interaction and a sense of companionship during breaks with these evolving digital pets.
Why similar: Creature Collector 41.7%, Idler 39.5%, Casual 13.9%, Singleplayer 3.3%, Indie 1.5%
- #44 Cockroach!
70% matchVery Positive99% of 72 reviews2025
Dev: ColaCatGames
Windows
A cockroach crawling around on your computer desktop — and it even bursts with goo when clicked!
Why similar: Creature Collector 39.8%, Idler 35.6%, Cute 11.8%, Casual 8.3%, Singleplayer 2.9%
- #45 Peel a banana
71% match4 user reviews100% of 4 reviews2025
Dev: KaKrno
Windows
Welcome to the simplest yet most oddly satisfying game you'll play today! All you have to do is click to peel a banana layer by layer. Once a banana is fully peeled, it counts as 1 banana. Then it's on to the next one—no breaks, no limits, just endless peeling action!
Why similar: Idler 34.9%, Casual 32.4%, Cute 22.5%, Singleplayer 7.2%, Indie 2.9%
- #46 Sharkarama
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Threeclipse
Windows
Buy sharks, raise them, and sell them for profit, or take control of any shark to hunt fish yourself. Collect 150+ real-world species from dwarf lanternsharks to great whites. Spot rare albinos.
Why similar: Creature Collector 40.4%, Idler 33.7%, Cute 11.4%, Casual 10%, Indie 2.3%
- #47 Musical Slime
68% matchVery Positive98% of 396 reviews2026
Dev: Musical SlimePub: HaHaHaGame
Windows
Ditch the dull, monotonous desktop! Bring home a soft, cuddly slime that grooves in perfect sync with your music, unlock soothing desktop companionship, and enjoy endless player-created music content in the Steam Workshop to swap out whenever you want~
Why similar: Idler 51.4%, Casual 28.3%, Cute 16.2%, Singleplayer 4.1%
- #48 Flutterfield
70% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Onyx Feather Studios
Windows
Flutterfield is a cozy and relaxing idle game. Buy butterflies and raise them in real time, or catch fully grown ones yourself. Unlock, upgrade, and customize habitats while filling your collection with real-life butterfly species!
Why similar: Creature Collector 45.1%, Idler 36.7%, Casual 9.5%, Cute 7.1%, Singleplayer 1.7%
- #49 Moon Fishies
70% matchNo user reviews
Dev: AnionCatPub: AnionCat Studio
Windows
Moonfishies is relaxing desktop fish simulator. Customize your dream aquarium, catch new fish and breed unique hybrids!
Why similar: Creature Collector 40.4%, Idler 37.6%, Casual 10.4%, Cute 7.8%, Indie 2.2%
- #50 Chronime Puzzle: Girls
69% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Quantum Quiver Games
Windows
Chronime Puzzle: Girls is a relaxing puzzle game featuring beautiful steampunk anime-inspired artwork.
Why similar: Creature Collector 52.2%, Casual 27.2%, Cute 15.6%, Singleplayer 3.9%, Indie 1.2%
- #51 Idle Tree Keeper
69% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Torbellino Games
Windows · Mac
Idle Tree Keeper is a relaxing idle/incremental game where you care for a mystical tree. Generate resources, unlock upgrades, evolve, and progress even while offline. Free to play with optional in-game purchases.
Why similar: Idler 50.4%, Casual 27%, Cute 16.3%, Singleplayer 3.9%, Indie 2.4%
- #52 Neon Fantasy: Dogs
71% matchMixed56% of 18 reviews2023
Dev: Quantum Quiver Games
Windows
Neon Fantasy: Dogs is the perfect puzzle game for a fun and rewarding pastime. Collect pictures, develop your attention, and feel like a part of the beautiful neon world.
Why similar: Creature Collector 51.7%, Casual 26.9%, Cute 17.1%, Singleplayer 4.3%
- #53 Koimori
69% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Aurélien Dos Santos
Windows · Mac
Turn your desktop into a living pond with this peaceful idle overlay. Let koi drift around while you work or relax, drop snacks to see them gather, and unlock rare koi patterns as you spend more time with your little friends.
Why similar: Creature Collector 44.7%, Idler 34.5%, Casual 10%, Cute 9.4%, Indie 1.3%
- #54 Alley Cats Idle
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Gremlin On The Screen
Windows
Adopt, collect, and relax with a growing gang of streetwise cats in this cozy idle game. Who will wander into your alley next?
Why similar: Creature Collector 36.9%, Idler 33.1%, Cute 12%, Casual 11.8%, Singleplayer 4.5%
- #55 Synapse Idle
68% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: PAVDUPPub: DEVDUP
Windows · Mac
Grow a 3D neural network from a single neuron. Workers haul energy along radiant paths, buildings amplify every passing signal, and a 100-node skill tree reshapes how your synapse evolves. A calm, incremental idle game about watching complexity bloom — tinted in whatever colors you choose.
Why similar: Idler 64.2%, Casual 26.3%, Singleplayer 6.7%, Indie 2.8%
- #56 Catventure
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: MissingCat
Windows
Catventure is a cozy and relaxing idle game that can sit at the bottom of your screen (or anywhere else), allowing you to enjoy a peaceful adventure during work or a busy day.
Why similar: Idler 51.4%, Casual 30.1%, Cute 14.3%, Singleplayer 4.2%
- #57 CatCat
66% matchPositive95% of 38 reviews2025
Dev: bogy house
Windows · Mac
"CatCat" is a relaxing cat simulation game. Raise different breeds, feed them, and pet them. You can freely change the layout, arrange furniture, and alter wall colors to create a cozy space for you and your cats. There are no goals or pressure; just enjoy a peaceful time together with your cats.
Why similar: Idler 38.9%, Creature Collector 31.1%, Casual 17.1%, Cute 10.4%, Singleplayer 2.5%
- #58 DesktopPets
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: floofnoodles
Windows
A chill, tamagotchi-like idle creature game in the corner of your screen. Raise creatures, unlock 100+ evolutions, and freely customize your room at your own pace!
Why similar: Idler 42.8%, Creature Collector 38.2%, Cute 10.1%, Casual 6.8%, Singleplayer 2.1%
- #59 Strange Zoo
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Pomerania Games
Windows · Linux
Strange Zoo is a game about building an unusual zoo where the animals speak with your voice. Record yourself through your microphone, and alpacas, wolves, and parrots will start repeating your words. Complete quests, place lamps, and lay down blankets to make your animals feel safe and comfortable.
Why similar: Creature Collector 39.6%, Idler 38.6%, Casual 10.5%, Cute 8.2%, Indie 1.9%
- #60 Earned Today
65% matchPositive82% of 11 reviews2026
Dev: Paidakang
Windows
Want to see your earnings tick up every second? Want to feel the rush of money rapidly stacking up on screen? Earned Today brings it to life! Keep your piggy company, earn Carrot Tokens, and collect more piggy styles~
Why similar: Idler 52.4%, Casual 23.2%, Cute 20.6%, Singleplayer 3.8%