- #1 Discovery 2
97% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: noowanda
Windows
Create your own world, block by block. Build solo or together with friends, share your creations with the community, and experience your worlds on desktop or in VR.
Why similar: Voxel 26.4% ★, Sandbox 18.7%, Adventure 12.6%, Simulation 11.9%, Exploration 7.9%
- #2 One Million Worlds
96% match1 user reviews0% of 1 reviews2019
Dev: Richard Tingle
Windows
One Million Worlds is a block world, but unlike other block worlds it's not focused on buildings and architecture but on machines and movement. One Million Worlds is a blockworld with physics which means you can create things that not only look cool but are cool, because they work.
Why similar: Voxel 38.9% ★, Sandbox 19.8%, Open World 9.4%, Building 7.7%, Simulation 7.7%
- #3 Voxel Turf
96% matchVery Positive88% of 578 reviews2017
Dev: L Twigger
Windows · Linux
Median: 3.5 hrsMean: 13.4 hrs≥1hr: 68%
Voxel Turf is a block based urban sandbox. Build cities, blow up buildings, complete missions or fight for territory. Build a real estate empire, or perhaps just drive around and blow stuff up. Its your choice!
Why similar: Voxel 38% ★, Sandbox 20.7%, Simulation 13%, Open World 9.1%, City Builder 8.1%
- #4 Just Your Average Survival Game
95% matchNo user reviews
Dev: CarrotStudios
Windows
"Just Your Average Survival Game" is an experience where you explore an island with a finite amount of resources. Beware of the dark past of the island.
Why similar: Voxel 32.7% ★, Sandbox 19.5%, Exploration 10%, Open World 7.1%, Casual 6.8%
- #5 MakeShift Mayhem
94% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Juan Dos Santos
Windows
A Chaotic co-op adventure about building Makeshift Vehicles to solve puzzles and go Home. Team up with friends and build wild vehicles.
Why similar: Sandbox 18.8%, Simulation 17.7%, Adventure 13.9%, Casual 10.9%, Building 9.4%
- #6 Dragon Ranch
94% matchNo user reviews
Dev: KK-Forge
Windows
Dragon Ranch is a first-person open-world co-op game with touches of exploration. In which you can capture and raise adorable monsters and get the resources they generate to improve your facilities, enter the planet and discover the secrets that await you.
Why similar: Simulation 12.9%, Exploration 12.4%, Adventure 11.3%, Sandbox 10.9%, Colorful 10.7%
- #7 Augmego
93% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Augmego
Windows · Mac
Build a voxel world that feels like you. Create your own space, invite friends to visit and build, and discover what other players are making. Augmego is a social sandbox for small ideas, big builds, and shared moments.
Why similar: Voxel 33.5% ★, Sandbox 19.2%, Building 12.4%, Simulation 8.6%, Exploration 6.8%
- #8 Hero Jumper
92% match2 user reviews50% of 2 reviews2022
Dev: Retr0A
Windows
Hero Jumper is a sandbox game and FPS where you can destroy objects and do whatever you want.
Why similar: Voxel 30% ★, Sandbox 22.9%, Adventure 14.5%, Building 8.9%, First-Person 7.1%
- #9 friends world
91% match4 user reviews75% of 4 reviews2023
Dev: kylacpp
Windows
This is a voxel style sandbox game that focuses on survival. You can do anything inside and destroy any block. and cooperatively survive and fight with friends in a world. If you like playing Minecraft, this is a game you must not miss.
Why similar: Voxel 37.1% ★, Sandbox 18.4%, Building 10.4%, Open World 8.7%, Simulation 8.2%
- #10 Skyscraper Tiles
91% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Super Voxel Games
Windows
Build your city in Skyscraper Tiles and relax in that sandbox game without resource management! Stack soaring towers above the clouds and unleash fleets of flying vehicles. Craft your dream skyline and watch your futuristic metropolis come to life in the sky!
Why similar: Voxel 27% ★, Sandbox 22%, City Builder 14.7%, Building 12.2%, Casual 9.2%
- #11 In Their Footsteps
90% matchNo user reviews
Dev: SwapChainError
Windows
Step into a near infinite world ready to be explored or shaped to your liking. Travel across different biomes searching or digging for resources to craft your items and build bases while trying to survive.
Why similar: Voxel 39.6% ★, Sandbox 21.3%, Open World 9.6%, Building 8.3%, Adventure 7.1%
- #12 360Hexaworld
89% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Dataking Inc.
Windows
Another world 360Hexaworld is a Web 3.0 metaverse world platform
Why similar: Voxel 41.8% ★, Simulation 24.1%, Building 13.1%, Open World 7.7%, Sandbox 6.5%
- #13 Terra Toy
88% matchPositive93% of 15 reviews2023
Dev: frozein
Windows
Terra Toy is a simple, peaceful sandbox game about building a tiny planet! Raise mountains, dig rivers, paint beaches, and plop down trees to create the landscape of your dreams. There are no complicated menus or difficult-to-use tools, just a blank planet and your imagination.
Why similar: Voxel 30.2% ★, Sandbox 18.9%, Building 12.6%, City Builder 11.9%, Simulation 5.6%
- #14 CoreVore
87% matchNo user reviews2027
Dev: WizardingGames
Windows
CoreVore is a first-person voxel mining sandbox. Explore a persistent atlas of destructible planets, scan for rare ore, shape tunnels, deploy machines, and evacuate your cargo before instability turns your route into a trap. Return later—the planet remembers what you changed.
Why similar: Voxel 33.9% ★, Simulation 21.3%, Exploration 9.5%, Sandbox 9.1%, Adventure 8.9%
- #15 Aether Effect
86% matchNo user reviews
Dev: DreamtowardsPub: Elytra Corporation
Windows
Dig, Build, Explore! In this sandbox survival game, venture through a vast procedurally-generated infinite world. Mine resources, construct your homestead, craft and drive vehicles, delve into mining, cultivate, livestock, automated machinery, and uncover the truth behind the world.
Why similar: Voxel 30.3% ★, Sandbox 14.9%, Building 10.4%, City Builder 9.2%, Simulation 8.6%
- #16 Lumber and Plunder
85% matchMixed42% of 19 reviews2025
Dev: Cozy FoxPub: Sailing Fox Studios
Windows
An exploration-focused game set on a remote island said to hide a long-forgotten treasure. Scavenge resources, sell what you find, upgrade your gear, and carve your way through a mysterious forest. Uncover scattered clues, piece together a legend, and conquer the mountain- at your own pace.
Why similar: Sandbox 21.3%, Simulation 20.2%, Adventure 15.7%, Casual 12.3%, Exploration 8.9%
- #17 Crafting Block World
86% matchMixed47% of 55 reviews2019
Dev: IO Games
Windows
Crafting Block World is an adventure with sandbox elements that will help you build your ideal world!
Why similar: Voxel 37.9% ★, Sandbox 17.4%, Simulation 9.8%, Building 8.3%, Open World 5.9%
- #18 YUME ROOF
84% match5 user reviews100% of 5 reviews2026
Dev: Studio Rivi
Windows
In between the busyness of everyday life, a rooftop where nothing happens. YUME ROOF is a cozy sandbox game set on a Japanese rooftop, with no enemies or time limits. Customize the space from morning to night, and enjoy simply being there at your own pace.
Why similar: Voxel 38.3% ★, Sandbox 17.6%, City Builder 12.2%, Simulation 8.2%, Casual 4.9%
- #19 Goblin Keep
84% matchMixed69% of 26 reviews2023
Dev: Black Lake Entertainment
Windows
Voxel World Town Building and Survival game with building tools, combat, destruction, and multiplayer
Why similar: Voxel 26.3% ★, Sandbox 15%, City Builder 11.8%, Building 8.3%, Adventure 6.9%
- #20 Project Create
83% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Norcher Developments
Windows
Gain experience and level up in this voxel sandbox world as you travel through space and time. Craft equipment and recipes to help you survive the treacherous landscape and sculpt it into your own masterpiece!
Why similar: Voxel 32.7% ★, Sandbox 20%, Open World 10.4%, Adventure 7.3%, Building 7.1%
- #21 Runeforge
82% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Aesli
Windows
Design your own weapons, armor, and spells to defeat increasingly difficult enemies in this procedurally generated voxel RPG with your friends. Clear dungeons, gather resources, build bases, tame monsters, catch fish, and grow crops!
Why similar: Voxel 28% ★, Sandbox 16.2%, Building 12%, Open World 10%, Adventure 7.1%
- #22 Reshape
82% match5 user reviews100% of 5 reviews2024
Dev: Nick Serebryanik
Windows
you're the architect of your world. Design without limits, create without boundaries. Your world, your way, unleash your creativity.
Why similar: Sandbox 19.2%, City Builder 15%, Simulation 13.2%, Adventure 9.3%, Building 9%
- #23 Скуф на даче
79% matchVery Positive87% of 728 reviews2025
Dev: KickedMesh
Windows
Median: 42 minMean: 1.8 hrs≥1hr: 37%
A cottage is not just about garden beds! Dacha is primarily a solitude with oneself. Flood the sauna, go mushroom picking, and ride an old bucket over the village potholes in an immersive country simulator.
Why similar: Sandbox 24.9%, Simulation 23.4%, Adventure 17.4%, First-Person 8.5%, Open World 7.9%
- #24 Buildia
81% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Ali Turgut
Windows
Unleash your imagination in Buildia! Build massive structures in this creative voxel-based world using elemental blocks like Lava, Ice, and Forest. With precision controls and a serene atmosphere, Buildia invites you to shape your own world block by block.
Why similar: Voxel 34.2% ★, Sandbox 20%, Simulation 13.2%, Casual 7.1%, Building 7%
- #25 Around The World With Friends
81% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Badev
Windows
Build wacky vehicles and contraptions to overcome environmental challenges in an Online Co-Op experience! Scout out a path in Adventure Mode, or build whatever comes to mind in Sandbox Mode. Either way, you're in for the Adventure of a lifetime, as you're going Around The World With Friends!
Why similar: Sandbox 23%, Simulation 14.5%, Adventure 12%, Exploration 11.8%, Building 11.2%
- #26 Fractoid
80% matchNo user reviews
Dev: De La Guardia Games
Windows
Build with milliblock precision in Fractoid, a multiplayer voxel sandbox designed for creative freedom. Create incredibly detailed structures, collaborate with friends, and help shape the game as it grows through Early Access, with survival mode planned for the future.
Why similar: Voxel 41.2% ★, Sandbox 17.5%, Building 12.1%, Simulation 8.6%, Open World 7.6%
- #27 Lade's Sandbox
79% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2024
Dev: 诺格拉德
Windows
A voxel-based sandbox game
Why similar: Voxel 43.1% ★, Sandbox 14.7%, Building 12.4%, Simulation 11.5%, Casual 8.2%
- #28 Fossil Keeper
78% matchNo user reviews
Dev: A Little More Games
Windows
Dig up and collect fossils from Dinosaurs and other prehistoric creatures, build complete skeletons from them, then display them in your customisable museum! Earn museum donations and renown in order to gain access to more dig sites, unlocking new species for you to collect.
Why similar: Sandbox 20.9%, Simulation 20.1%, Adventure 15.6%, Casual 12.2%, Building 10.7%
- #29 VOXEL ISLE SIMULATOR
76% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2026
Dev: SFH PROD
Windows
Raise an island from the sea, seed it with life, then smite it, flood it, or raise its dead. A voxel god game where tribes you never command learn masonry and gunpowder, forge kingdoms and go to war, and every power you use is written into a history you can click to visit.
Why similar: Voxel 29.4% ★, Sandbox 19.8%, Simulation 18.5%, Casual 11.6%, Colorful 5.8%
- #30 LEGO® Worlds
77% matchMostly Positive78% of 15,661 reviews2017
Dev: TT GamesPub: Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment
Windows
Median: 2.6 hrsMean: 13.4 hrs≥1hr: 71%
Experience a galaxy of Worlds made entirely from LEGO bricks. EXPLORE gigantic landscapes, DISCOVER countless surprises, and CREATE anything you can imagine by building with LEGO bricks.
Why similar: Sandbox 24.1%, Building 17.5%, Open World 13.6%, Voxel 9.2% ★, Adventure 8.6%
- #31 Alterworld
77% matchPositive92% of 12 reviews2024
Dev: Poonpoonza
Windows
Explore the infinite world! Play with the fully destructible voxel terrain! Craft and split items! Build and customize a house or any building! And many more! This is the ultimate sandbox survival game where you can do almost anything you can dream!
Why similar: Sandbox 25.8%, Adventure 15.9%, Building 12.1%, Exploration 10.8%, First-Person 8%
- #32 RealmCraft
78% matchMostly Positive77% of 52 reviews2018
Dev: Tellurion Mobile
Windows
RealmCraft is the original Sandbox Game. Build Cubes & Explore 30+ Blueprint Worlds in 3D. Try to Survive & Use 100+ Types of Blocks to Build Your Unique Town.
Why similar: Voxel 22.4% ★, Sandbox 20.6%, Simulation 12.8%, Building 11.8%, Adventure 8.8%
- #33 Junkman101
76% match9 user reviews78% of 9 reviews2025
Dev: MaryIsHere
Windows · Mac
在一个程序化生成的 2D 像素沙盒世界中探索、挖掘和建造。收集矿物并熔炼,合成物品,升级标签。挑战怪物、发现遗迹,体验自由的冒险与创造之旅。
Why similar: Sandbox 24.7%, Simulation 24.2%, Casual 16.2%, Adventure 11.6%, Building 11.3%
- #34 The Quiet Cold
75% matchNo user reviews
Dev: EliteNinja32
Windows
Gather fuel, build shelter, and keep your fires burning. Warmth keeps you alive, but it may attract roaming Giants. Save downed allies before the cold takes them, or something may rise from their bodies...
Why similar: Voxel 31.3% ★, Sandbox 22.3%, Exploration 11.3%, Open World 7.2%, Adventure 6.3%
- #35 世界岛编辑器
74% matchNo user reviews
Dev: ANTIGames
Windows
通过完全免费的《世界岛·编辑器》,您和您的伙伴可以将脑海中的设计的地图变成现实!游戏支持多人联机建造!将您的构想变成变幻莫测的游戏世界吧! 同时游戏预设了多种模式并且通用于ANTI系列的所有作品,大家可以在游戏中自由的分享哦!
Why similar: Voxel 31.7% ★, Building 11.6%, Simulation 10.5%, Sandbox 10.5%, City Builder 9.1%
- #36 Goat Simulator: Remastered
73% matchVery Positive88% of 1,224 reviews2024
Dev: Coffee Stain StudiosPub: Coffee Stain Publishing
Windows
Median: 2.0 hrsMean: 7.0 hrs≥1hr: 68%
Goat Simulator Remastered is the latest in goat simulation technology. Your favorite chaotic sandbox is back and more beautiful than ever, with updated graphics, every DLC, and more bugs that you can shake a goat at. WASD to rewrite history.
Why similar: Sandbox 22.4%, Simulation 19.2%, Adventure 14%, Casual 10.8%, Exploration 8.3%
- #37 Parkdens
74% matchNo user reviews2028
Dev: HidingDev Games
Windows
Parkdens is a minimalistic and relaxing nature park building game where you can place tiles and choose variety of objects ranging from statues, sitting areas, shelters to bushes, playgrounds, trees etc. to populate the placed tiles.
Why similar: Simulation 24.4%, Sandbox 22.4%, City Builder 18.5%, Casual 15.6%, Building 11.5%
- #38 Clod & Desire
75% matchNo user reviews2025
Dev: Clio Universe Studio
Windows
A landscape park simulator. Dirt. Plants. And way too much emotion.
Why similar: Sandbox 25.4%, Simulation 24.1%, Casual 14.6%, Building 9.2%, 3D 6.5%
- #39 Cities Virtual Reality
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: WireMonkeyGames
Windows
Cities Virtual Reality is a VR city builder. You have a wide range of tools that you can use to build up your city! Play in a relaxing sandbox or play the campaign for a more intense experience.
Why similar: Voxel 29.4% ★, Sandbox 17.7%, City Builder 13.9%, Simulation 12.6%, Building 8.6%
- #40 Voxenvale
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: PixelCat
Windows
Voxenvale is a cozy blocky online realm builder where players jump, build, decorate, and visit each other's cubic worlds.
Why similar: Voxel 41.1% ★, Building 13.2%, Adventure 13%, Sandbox 9.3%, Open World 8.2%
- #41 Infiniterra
72% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: NuclearPhoenix
Windows · Linux
A voxel sandbox focused on atmosphere and contrast. Explore layered worlds, survive eerie nights, and uncover what lies beneath the surface.
Why similar: Voxel 33.7% ★, Sandbox 19.7%, Open World 10.3%, Exploration 9.5%, Simulation 9.1%
- #42 Mewnition
72% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Mewsubi
Windows
A co-op adventure game for 1-16 players, set in a voxel environment teeming with gargantuan beasts and powerful artifacts. Forage for resources, fortify your arenas, and fight fearsome foes as you reshape the world and uncover the truth of how it came to be.
Why similar: Voxel 39.8% ★, Sandbox 21.9%, Adventure 15.5%, Exploration 9.4%, Co-op 5.2%
- #43 Distant Garden
71% matchMostly Positive74% of 50 reviews2024
Dev: Jackson LevinePub: Jackson Levine Software
Windows · Mac · Linux
An exploration and building game inspired by games like "Minecraft", "LSD: Dream Emulator", and more.
Why similar: Voxel 34.3% ★, Sandbox 15.5%, Building 11.7%, Exploration 7.7%, Open World 7.4%
- #44 90° North
71% match2 user reviews0% of 2 reviews2026
Dev: Ambient Games
Windows
Survive a brutal three-day expedition to the North Pole. Gather wood, build shelters, manage cold, and make hard choices. Every decision matters in this intense, minimalist survival journey to the literal edge of the world.
Why similar: Simulation 22.6%, Sandbox 16.4%, Adventure 13.3%, Building 9.5%, Exploration 9.4%
- #45 Digging a Hole... with a Spoon... Escape from Alcatraz
70% matchMixed64% of 33 reviews2026
Dev: Eddaheim
Windows
A simple, darkly funny game about digging your way out of a crumbling Alcatraz knockoff - with nothing but a plastic spoon. Find junk, trade with your toilet buddy, and unlock weird mods to upgrade your spoon. Freedom is waiting!
Why similar: Voxel 30.2% ★, Sandbox 20.2%, Adventure 13.7%, Simulation 13%, Casual 10.8%
- #46 Building Destruction
70% matchMostly Positive75% of 127 reviews2023
Dev: 180°
Windows
Multiplayer sandbox with destructible environment. Destroy different maps, build your own, and play with your friends and other people online
Why similar: Voxel 31.8% ★, Sandbox 21%, Building 14.1%, Simulation 9.9%, First-Person 6.3%
- #47 StarMade
71% matchMixed68% of 2,992 reviews2014
Dev: Schine GmbH
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 1.3 hrsMean: 18.8 hrs≥1hr: 54%
The ultimate space sandbox. Participate in epic fleet battles, form alliances, strive to dominate entire galaxies and harness the universe’s resources for your industrious empire or the destruction of others. Customise your experience, the universe is yours!
Why similar: Voxel 29.3% ★, Sandbox 23.6%, Building 12%, Open World 10.3%, Multiplayer 6%
- #48 Zector 7
69% match7 user reviews57% of 7 reviews2024
Dev: SocksandGoats Studios
Windows
Craft, Build and Fight alongside your friends across this deadly open-world. Use both modern day and sci-fi tech as you Loot, Harvest and Trade for resources, gear and vehicles in order to survive the wasteland.
Why similar: Voxel 18.4% ★, Sandbox 14.6%, Simulation 10.9%, Building 9.9%, Adventure 8.1%
- #49 Long Drive North: Co-Op RV Simulator
68% matchMixed43% of 314 reviews2025
Dev: Mindflair Games LTDPub: Excalibur Publishing
Windows
Join the Early Access journey with this immersive driving-survival game. Explore the harsh American wilderness in the Long Drive North. Drive & repair your trusty RV, scavenge for parts, upgrade your vehicle, hunt & cook to survive; alone or with up to 4 players. SHARED RV MULTIPLAYER NOW AVAILABLE.
Why similar: Voxel 31.4% ★, Sandbox 13.7%, Simulation 7.7%, Open World 7.6%, Co-op 6.9%
- #50 Blox 3D World
70% matchPositive87% of 15 reviews2021
Dev: Appy Monkeys Software Pvt. Ltd.
Windows
Create beautiful worlds with simple clicks, from giant windmills to craggy castles and add animals,humans and birds for an amazing creative experience.A super fun toy with a surprising amount of depth. No goals, no distractions, just a beautiful visual and audio experience for the zen at heart.
Why similar: Voxel 35.3% ★, Sandbox 13.9%, Building 11.4%, Simulation 11.2%, City Builder 10%
- #51 Tokyo Canvas
69% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: kiarina
Windows · Mac
Walk, fly, and defy gravity as you paint Tokyo's 23 wards. Explore, take photos, and enjoy sunsets and stars as your favorite avatar. Share your creations through the Gallery, or paint together with 2–4 players and voice chat. Make Tokyo your own.
Why similar: Sandbox 28%, Simulation 16.3%, Exploration 11.4%, Colorful 8%, 3D 5.7%
- #52 Dig to Escape
69% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Biscoto Gang
Windows
Dig to Escape is a co-op digging game where you search a mysterious island for buried objects. Turn your discoveries into scrap, upgrade your tools and uncover the missing boat motor parts you need to escape. Play alone or dig irresponsibly with your friends.
Why similar: Voxel 23.4% ★, Sandbox 20.5%, Simulation 19.7%, Adventure 14.5%, First-Person 6%
- #53 Hollowstride
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: VixVoid
Windows
Explore, build, and survive in a living, procedural world. Hollowstride is a multiplayer voxel sandbox in early development, offering a moddable foundation for your next great adventure.
Why similar: Voxel 42.6% ★, Sandbox 18.3%, Building 9%, Adventure 8%, Simulation 7%
- #54 Tribal Mischief
68% matchNo user reviews2027
Dev: Tikashu
Windows
A co-op mischievous adventure in the Stone Age.
Why similar: Sandbox 26.3%, Adventure 17.6%, Casual 13.8%, Exploration 11.1%, First-Person 7%
- #55 Drill and Delve
65% matchVery Positive87% of 109 reviews2026
Dev: noOne
Windows
You've been trapped in a mine. You'll need to use your tools to dig your way to the exit in a fully destructible 3D voxel terrain. Manage your oxygen and equipment, and uncover the dark mystery buried deep within the mine.
Why similar: Voxel 31.5% ★, Sandbox 22.6%, Adventure 13.8%, Exploration 10.1%, First-Person 7.5%
- #56 The Architect: Paris
67% matchMostly Positive73% of 235 reviews2021
Dev: Enodo GamesPub: 5PM Studio
Windows
The Architect: Paris is a construction game that allows you to shape the city of Paris into what you want. Destroy, draw, build your own architectural projects, customizing each building carefully or entire districts at once.
Why similar: Sandbox 24.6%, Building 18.6%, City Builder 17%, Simulation 14.3%, Casual 13.3%
- #57 Cube World
67% matchMostly Negative37% of 18,738 reviews2019
Dev: Picroma
Windows
Median: 5.5 hrsMean: 12.3 hrs≥1hr: 78%
Cube World is a voxel-based action RPG with a focus on exploration. It takes place in a procedurally generated fantasy world made up entirely of cubes.
Why similar: Voxel 40% ★, Open World 14.4%, Adventure 9.3%, Sandbox 7.8%, Exploration 7.6%
- #58 Creativerse
67% matchMostly Positive78% of 30,868 reviews2017
Dev: Playful Corp.
Windows
Median: 2.0 hrsMean: 15.5 hrs≥1hr: 63%
A sandbox adventure game as big as your imagination.
Why similar: Voxel 30% ★, Sandbox 14.5%, Building 10.4%, Open World 7.5%, Exploration 6.7%
- #59 Rasvyat Nuclear Power Station
66% matchVery Positive80% of 185 reviews2024
Dev: Thxtnt
Windows
A co-op RBMK reactor simulator, with a detailed control room, realistic physics and authentic sound design
Why similar: Sandbox 27.4%, Simulation 25.8%, Casual 16.3%, First-Person 8.8%, 3D 7.1%