- #1 Urban Ascend
97% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: BitQuest Studio
Windows
A casual city builder where growth is constant, production chains expand, citizens thrive, and upgrades push your city toward a bustling metropolis.
Why similar: Grand Strategy 22.9% ★, City Builder 18.2%, Automation 13.5%, Economy 11.8%, Capitalism 11.4%
- #2 Farmer's Shop Simulator: Prologue
96% matchMixed65% of 37 reviews2024
Dev: SleepySealsGames
Windows
Start restoring your old family farm and managing your new shop in this free prologue. Grow your crops, sell your goods, and get the taste of what's to come in the full version. Did we already mention it's free?
Why similar: Trading 21.5% ★, Agriculture 21% ★, Idler 17.9%, Capitalism 13.7%, Economy 11.2%
- #3 CivIdle
96% matchMostly Positive75% of 974 reviews2025
Dev: FishPondPub: Fish Pond Studio
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 3.9 hrsMean: 79.6 hrs≥1hr: 71%
CivIdle is an idle/incremental game that allows you to lead your own civilization through thousands of years from ancient times to the modern era. Expand your territory, explore a vast tech tree, build various wonders, and trade with global players: empire must grow and numbers must go up!
Why similar: Idler 18.7%, Automation 18.5%, Trading 17.1% ★, Grand Strategy 13.6% ★, City Builder 12.4%
- #4 Crony Corp
95% matchMixed57% of 23 reviews2025
Dev: Blarney Bytes
Windows
Build your empire in a competitive world shaped by supply, demand, & shady deals. In Crony Corp, you’ll buy & manufacture goods in a live market that responds to every player’s actions. Trade smart, undercut rivals, bend the rules, and climb the corporate ladder. Just don’t expect fair play.
Why similar: Automation 23.8%, Idler 23%, Economy 16.4%, Capitalism 16%, City Builder 15.7%
- #5 Chests, City, Clicker
94% matchMixed46% of 57 reviews2023
Dev: E-Crew
Windows
The principle is simple, the more time you spend, the richer you will be, you can do nothing and get money, but the decisions you make will allow you to get even more!
Why similar: Trading 22.5% ★, Idler 19.8%, Automation 19.2%, City Builder 18.6%, Building 9.2%
- #6 Food Industry
94% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Evolugame
Windows
Build and expand in agriculture, industry and commerce. Evolve in the food industry sector, and weather the storms by helping your people build the new world.
Why similar: Trading 20.1% ★, Agriculture 19.5% ★, City Builder 17.3%, Automation 17.1%, Economy 9.1%
- #7 KLIKFEST: Medieval
93% matchNo user reviews
Dev: SalmonSnakePub: I'm Digi ry
Windows
KLIKFEST is a medieval clicker game where you develop villages as the king’s advisor. Build mines, craft unique items, and manage resources in a 3-day loop. Early Access focuses on mining, with multiplayer and 14 parts coming. Shape the game with feedback!
Why similar: Trading 16.8% ★, Agriculture 14.9% ★, Automation 14.2%, Hunting 14.1% ★, City Builder 13.2%
- #8 Village Tale
91% matchVery Positive85% of 299 reviews2025
Dev: Knight Owl Games
Windows
Median: 18.1 hrsMean: 22.3 hrs≥1hr: 77%
A relaxing idle village-building simulator nestled in the corner of your screen! Build, Craft, and Trade to guide your village from humble beginnings to a thriving trading hub, it's time to write your own Village Tale!
Why similar: Trading 21% ★, Automation 17.7%, Idler 17.5%, City Builder 15.7%, Building 8%
- #9 Crafting Idle Clicker
92% matchMixed49% of 899 reviews2020
Dev: Bling Bling Games GmbH
Windows
Median: 2.9 hrsMean: 43.1 hrs≥1hr: 70%
Craft a complex production line, earn idle cash and become an industrial tycoon!
Why similar: Grand Strategy 22.4% ★, Idler 19%, Automation 18.7%, Capitalism 8.7%, Economy 8.1%
- #10 Military Incremental Complex
89% matchVery Positive85% of 627 reviews2025
Dev: Space Kraken Studios
Windows
Median: 9.5 hrsMean: 17.2 hrs≥1hr: 93%
Make weapons, make money. An active incremental game where you amass as much money as you can by starting a Military Industrial Complex company. Produce multiple different weapons, research upgrades, manipulate the stock market, and lobby the government for favors.
Why similar: Idler 20.4%, Automation 19.3%, Trading 15.3% ★, Capitalism 14%, Economy 12.5%
- #11 Ranch Mayhem - Active Idler
90% match5 user reviews80% of 5 reviews2024
Dev: Tobias Graski
Windows
Grow, process, sell and use different Crops on dozens of recipes. Get ready to strategically use items and other consumables in this 2D idle adventure.
Why similar: Agriculture 32.5% ★, Idler 29.5%, Automation 25%, Strategy 7%, Casual 2.6%
- #12 Rejuvan
89% matchMostly Positive73% of 11 reviews2024
Dev: Papergod
Windows
Build, make money, create, repeat. Rejuvan is a game about making the most efficient factories on your own little island. Use everything you can think of to maximize profits and keep the narrative on track. Keep in mind that, at certain money thresholds, your experience may unexpectedly change.
Why similar: Automation 26%, City Builder 19%, Grand Strategy 19% ★, Economy 13.1%, Building 11%
- #13 Resource chill
88% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Asfar GAMES
Windows · Linux
A cozy idle automation game about building tiny factories, unlocking upgrades, and relaxing while your machines work overtime. Progress has never been this chill.
Why similar: Idler 20.8%, City Builder 19.4%, Automation 18.1%, Capitalism 10.9%, Economy 9.8%
- #14 StockSim
86% matchNo user reviews
Dev: WTeam
Windows · Mac · Linux
Step into the shoes of a world class trader and navigate the fast-paced world of financial markets. Make strategic decisions, analyze market trends, and watch your portfolio grow. With realistic market simulations and dynamic pricing, every trade counts. Can you beat the market?
Why similar: Trading 29.3% ★, Idler 28.1%, Economy 15.8%, Strategy 11.5%, Capitalism 8.3%
- #15 Beaver Clicker
86% matchMostly Positive79% of 70 reviews2023
Dev: Temmie
Windows · Mac · Linux
Beaver Clicker is an idle game where you collects logs, then using these logs, you can acquire all sorts of sources for these logs, like convincing squirrels, sponsoring school field-trips, or even taming the fungi found in nature itself to help you in your wood collecting journey.
Why similar: Grand Strategy 22.3% ★, Idler 21.1%, Automation 16.7%, Economy 13.5%, Building 9.2%
- #16 Marketplace
84% matchNo user reviews
Dev: ThunderStorm
Windows
Marketplace is an idle/clicker Game, in which your score increases! Everytime score increases there is a chance for you to obtain an item from a Marketplace! Come and join us on our Discord, making marketplace a richer place!
Why similar: Trading 31.1% ★, Idler 22.3%, Capitalism 15.7%, Economy 14.4%, Automation 8.1%
- #17 Grand Ages: Medieval
87% matchMixed48% of 1,970 reviews2015
Dev: Gaming Minds StudiosPub: Kalypso Media Digital
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 4.8 hrsMean: 8.3 hrs≥1hr: 92%
Rise from the humble role of a simple mayor governing a small settlement and rule over all of Europe.
Why similar: Trading 30% ★, Grand Strategy 23.1% ★, City Builder 13.9%, Economy 12.5%, Strategy 11%
- #18 Assembly Planter
85% matchVery Positive91% of 247 reviews2020
Dev: Timon Herzog
Windows
A farming / automation game, that allows you to progress from a poor hard-working farmer with just a few old tools to a lazy rich guy that watches his machines do the work for him while he tries to optimize production.
Why similar: Automation 20%, Agriculture 19.6% ★, City Builder 13.1%, Idler 12.4%, Economy 11.7%
- #19 Stranded Engineers
83% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Virtual Art Division
Windows
Stranded Engineers is a city-building game in which your strategy and economy skills are required. Build large citys on several islands, take care of your resource buildings and make your citizens happy.
Why similar: Grand Strategy 25.6% ★, City Builder 18.1%, Agriculture 17% ★, Automation 17%, Economy 6.9%
- #20 Shop Legends
84% matchMixed44% of 198 reviews2024
Dev: Cloudcade
Windows
Immerse yourself in an Idle Simulation Tycoon RPG like no other, where you are tasked with managing a thriving item shop, crafting legendary gear for customers, commanding mighty heroes to loot rare artifacts & blueprints all while challenging top-ranked shopkeepers in an epic business adventure!
Why similar: Trading 26.8% ★, City Builder 17.2%, Idler 14.6%, Capitalism 11.8%, Economy 11.1%
- #21 Truck Company
82% matchMixed69% of 13 reviews2025
Dev: GameCode
Windows
TruckCompany - is a strategic game in which you develop your transport enterprise, the aim of which is to create a great consortium with other players and compete with others for the title of the best businessmen
Why similar: Grand Strategy 28.4% ★, City Builder 22.2%, Economy 11.6%, Strategy 11.6%, Capitalism 11.5%
- #22 Trading Towns
82% matchMixed65% of 20 reviews2024
Dev: Eternal Games
Windows
Trading Towns is a simple and relaxing economic game in which your goal is to find ways for your town to become wealthy and prosperous.
Why similar: Trading 24.6% ★, Idler 21%, City Builder 19.8%, Economy 16%, Building 10.1%
- #23 Farm BoYS
81% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Telazer
Windows · Mac
In Farm BoYS, you can enjoy the cosy experience of an idle farming game. Plant crops, catch fish and raise animals to grow your farm. Upgrade your workers and buildings, fulfil marketplace orders and uncover surprises as your farm flourishes, even when you’re away.
Why similar: Idler 26.5%, Automation 20.3%, Agriculture 14.6% ★, Trading 14.4% ★, Fishing 12.9% ★
- #24 Feed The Forest
81% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Indoor Sunglasses
Windows · Linux
A short, innocent incremental forest-builder. Unlock snail powers to spread life in a barren desert. Feed the mysterious Forest with juice. And remember: Blood is a type of juice.
Why similar: Automation 19.1%, Idler 18.9%, City Builder 15.4%, Economy 13%, Capitalism 12%
- #25 Desktop Trains
80% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Clirgo GamesPub: Clirgo Interactive
Windows
Turn your taskbar into a railway line! Help Sonya restore the railway after the cataclysm. Transport people and cargo, build new routes, and unlock shiny new trains in this cozy idle game for your desktop!
Why similar: Grand Strategy 27.8% ★, City Builder 20%, Idler 19.7%, Automation 8.7%, Economy 7.2%
- #26 Laser_Inc
79% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Aiden Forsyth
Windows · Mac
A laser-powered factory game where every machine, mirror, and beam can break everything—usually because of you. Build, optimize, and embrace the chaos. If you want to build mega structures with complex networks of unique machines... with flippin lasers then Laser_Inc is for you.
Why similar: Grand Strategy 31.5% ★, Idler 20.8%, Strategy 11.1%, Capitalism 10.8%, Economy 9.5%
- #27 Coins
78% matchMixed55% of 115 reviews2024
Dev: CoinsDev
Windows · Linux
A F2P Coin collecting game. Get Coins to trade and collect!
Why similar: Trading 33.4% ★, Idler 31.1%, Economy 12%, Capitalism 10.2%, Casual 6.8%
- #28 Train Manager
77% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Trophy Games
Windows
Create and manage your own train company. Build routes and transport cargo and passengers all over the world while you expand your fleet of trains. Train Manager is among the most realistic of the simulator genre - so prove yourself and beat your friends and other real life managers.
Why similar: Grand Strategy 24.3% ★, City Builder 18.1%, Automation 16.3%, Capitalism 11%, Economy 9.1%
- #29 Cozy Garden
76% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Frozen Logic Studios
Windows
A relaxing farming sim where you manage adorable creatures that grow crops, gather resources, and build your cozy garden right at the bottom of your screen.
Why similar: Agriculture 20.8% ★, Idler 18.6%, Automation 17.2%, City Builder 17%, Building 8.5%
- #30 My Little Farmies
79% matchMixed55% of 629 reviews2018
Dev: upjers
Windows
Median: 30 minMean: 72.2 hrs≥1hr: 41%
Show your artistic side! Create your own medieval settlement in the My Little Farmies tycoon. Build artisan workshops and production sites. Trade with fruit, vegetables and cereals. Download My Little Farmies now!
Why similar: Agriculture 28% ★, City Builder 22.1%, Trading 18% ★, Economy 10.4%, Building 9.7%
- #31 Astra Industria
75% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Regnum Noctis
Windows · Linux
Astra Industria is a sci-fi factory builder set on colossal player-constructed space megastructures with the addictive growth of incremental games. Extract resources, craft advanced components, and automate deep-space production through a vast tech tree.
Why similar: Automation 21.3%, Trading 16.1% ★, City Builder 14.6%, Capitalism 13.1%, Economy 12.1%
- #32 ACRES
73% matchVery Positive82% of 211 reviews2025
Dev: Jimi Games
Windows
ACRES is a small strategy simulation game about growing crops for evolving market demands. Build a farm, one acre at a time, to create a prosperous enterprise. Upgrade equipment, optimize harvests, and nurture the soil against increasing time pressure. How long can you keep the farm operating?
Why similar: Agriculture 27% ★, Automation 20.8%, Capitalism 13.8%, Economy 12.8%, Building 9.5%
- #33 Cake
75% matchMixed45% of 11 reviews2025
Dev: Just some guyPub: Myself
Windows
A game where you shoot
Why similar: Trading 37.5% ★, Idler 30.5%, Economy 20.6%, Casual 9.6%, Singleplayer 1.8%
- #34 Blockchain Tycoon
78% matchMixed48% of 52 reviews2021
Dev: Wamill
Windows · Mac
Blockchain Tycoon is the cryptocurrency simulation game where you build and manage your own mining operation. Create your own coin, mine it, invest in other coins, upgrade and overclock GPUs or you can just HODL.
Why similar: Trading 28.7% ★, Economy 16.8%, Automation 16.3%, Capitalism 11.8%, Building 7.4%
- #35 Banana 3D
74% matchMixed51% of 51 reviews2024
Dev: Dank MememachinePub: Dank As Publishing
Windows
In this game you click to earn skins to trade with and to collect. You receive a drop every 30 minutes, up to 4 a day. There is a short collection of developer-created skins, with an in-game workshop up-loader for the community to create their own skins for the Steam market.
Why similar: Idler 29.9%, Trading 22.9% ★, Capitalism 18.3%, Economy 13.8%, Casual 9.2%
- #36 Drug Dealer 2049
74% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Nextazio972
Windows
In Drug Dealer 2049, build your cartel, manage production, negotiate with customers, and survive against the police.
Why similar: Trading 24.9% ★, Automation 18.4%, Agriculture 16.5% ★, Idler 13.3%, Economy 9%
- #37 Rise of Industry
76% matchMostly Positive73% of 4,155 reviews2019
Dev: Dapper Penguin StudiosPub: Kasedo Games
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 4.7 hrsMean: 10.8 hrs≥1hr: 80%
Put your entrepreneurial skills to the test in the first title in the ROI series as you create & optimise intricate production lines. As an early 20th-Century industrialist, grow your empire & adapt to an ever-changing business landscape with unexpected events that could lead to boom…or bust.
Why similar: City Builder 21.4%, Trading 20.9% ★, Economy 17.7%, Automation 10.9%, Strategy 8%
- #38 Business Shark
77% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2020
Dev: SmartLife
Windows
You will have to develop your city, watch over expenses, strive for higher tax revenues, meet the needs of your residents by producing the right products for them
Why similar: Grand Strategy 30.2% ★, City Builder 25%, Strategy 15.2%, Building 13.9%, Economy 12.3%
- #39 Trading Tycoon
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Kits Gaming Studio
Windows
Build your fortune in a deep single-player trading simulation. Analyze charts, trade stocks/options/futures, manage risk, unlock powerful skills, and survive a living market shaped by news and market cycles.
Why similar: Trading 42.7% ★, Grand Strategy 31.7% ★, Economy 23.1%, Singleplayer 2.4%
- #40 Desktropolis
72% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Bean Juice Studios
Windows
Desktropolis is an idle city builder that lives quietly on the bottom of your screen while you work, game, or study.
Why similar: Idler 23.2%, City Builder 21.9%, Capitalism 14.7%, Economy 11.2%, Building 10.2%
- #41 Skyline Urban Story
70% matchVery Positive89% of 101 reviews2025
Dev: PandaUpStudio
Windows · Mac
From barren land to towering metropolis, every decision you make shapes the destiny of your city. Industrial flow, global trade, surging land values, and growing wealth, offers deep management gameplay, perfect for players who love strategic city-building and economic simulation.
Why similar: Grand Strategy 26.2% ★, City Builder 25.6%, Economy 17.3%, Building 12.4%, Capitalism 11.8%
- #42 Harve
71% matchMostly Positive78% of 18 reviews2024
Dev: Lunar Studios
Windows
Harve" - Cultivate Life. Thrive. Nurture your digital ecosystem in this captivating, community-driven idle game.
Why similar: Agriculture 24.7% ★, Idler 21.4%, City Builder 19.9%, Economy 14.1%, Building 9.2%
- #43 Gargantua
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Abdullah Furkan DoğanPub: AFD
Windows · Mac · Linux
Build your spaceship-city Gargantua. Forge industries, bend the free market, trade between planets, and defend your growing wealth. Every bullet is bought or produced in a simulated economy where a single mistake can shatter supply chains and trigger interstellar crises. In Gargantua, war is money.
Why similar: City Builder 26.6%, Trading 20% ★, Capitalism 16.3%, Economy 14.4%, Building 11.7%
- #44 Little Harvest
72% matchPositive91% of 22 reviews2023
Dev: Jooz
Windows
Plant, water, and harvest your crops. Expand your land and buy new crops and items!
Why similar: Idler 30%, Automation 24.4%, Agriculture 18.5% ★, Building 12.8%, Strategy 6.6%
- #45 Critter Bonk
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: FluffyFishDev
Windows
A cute incremental clicker where you bonk bugs for profit. Earn money, unlock upgrades, acquire powerful skills, and recruit helpers to automate the bonking until you’re truly unstoppable. Satisfying and Relaxing!
Why similar: Idler 25.1%, Automation 24.8%, Capitalism 17.2%, Economy 15.2%, Strategy 8.5%
- #46 Rise of Industry 2
70% matchMixed67% of 198 reviews2025
Dev: SomaSimPub: Kasedo Games
Windows
Navigate the competitive industrial landscape of vibrant 1980's USA! Make strategic manufacturing decisions, optimize production chains, acquire technologies, and expand your global business network with key contacts. Opportunities await those savvy enough to capitalize on them!
Why similar: Trading 23.6% ★, Agriculture 17% ★, City Builder 13.9%, Economy 11.2%, Capitalism 11.1%
- #47 Stakeholder Game
73% matchMixed41% of 17 reviews2022
Dev: BoneAppsPub: Bone Apps
Windows · Linux
Investment business simulation game. Become the richest billionaire ever! Build your financial empire out of merged companies and increase your capital.
Why similar: Economy 21.9%, City Builder 21.6%, Capitalism 20.1%, Idler 13.4%, Strategy 9.1%
- #48 Blue Chips: economic multiplayer board game
70% matchNo user reviews
Dev: BFG Studio
Windows
Blue Chips is a turn-based strategy board game where you have to survive and attain success in a severe economic world. Try to earn money from trading cryptocurrency, gold, stock exchange and real estate to buy and upgrade your business. Make your opponents bankrupt to become the best.
Why similar: Trading 32.2% ★, Economy 16.5%, City Builder 15.8%, Capitalism 15%, Strategy 7.6%
- #49 Land Of Idyllic Beauty
69% matchVery Positive90% of 218 reviews2024
Dev: Neo
Windows
Welcome to "Land Of Idyllic Beauty" a simulation management game that combines farming, store management, supply chain management, and romance elements. Experience the beauty of the idyllic life, starting from a small plot of farmland, gradually building your agricultural and commercial empire!
Why similar: Fishing 19.6% ★, City Builder 19.2%, Agriculture 17.2% ★, Trading 17.1% ★, Automation 12.8%
- #50 My Tiny Grocery Store - Desktop Idle Supermarket Game
68% matchMostly Positive79% of 19 reviews2026
Dev: Musa GUNGOR
Windows
My Tiny Grocery Store is an idle shopping simulator located in the bottom right corner of your screen that allows you to manage your store while also completing other tasks! Design your store, arrange your shelves, and enjoy earning money.
Why similar: Idler 31.6%, Automation 29.5%, Building 9.4%, Strategy 8.8%, Economy 7.1%
- #51 Industry Giant 4.0
67% matchMostly Negative37% of 545 reviews2025
Dev: Don VS DodoPub: Toplitz Productions
Windows
Build an industrial empire from scratch in Industry Giant 4.0. Produce goods, build up your industries, construct transportation networks, plan production, manage finances, and navigate global events. Become the next business tycoon and write history!
Why similar: Trading 21.6% ★, Automation 17.5%, City Builder 17.5%, Economy 12.6%, Capitalism 10.4%
- #52 Income Roads
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Kiara24
Windows
Road system economic sim. Factorio meets MiniMetro.
Why similar: City Builder 27.5%, Capitalism 15.4%, Economy 13.2%, Building 11.1%, Strategy 10.6%
- #53 岛与工厂 Island And Factories
69% matchMostly Positive71% of 24 reviews2024
Dev: 攀爬者工作室Pub: Gamirror Games
Windows
Set management, strategy, planning, breeding elements as one. Randomly generated islands have different resources, industrialization or agriculture is up to you. Planting crops, breeding animals, mining minerals to obtain low-grade products, factory processing to obtain high-grade products.
Why similar: Agriculture 20.7% ★, Trading 20.2% ★, City Builder 18.3%, Automation 18%, Building 10.9%
- #54 Beer Factory Crew
69% match3 user reviews67% of 3 reviews2024
Dev: Milos Trickovic
Windows
Beer Factory Crew puts you in shoes of a production facility manager. Your goal is to produce finished shipments of beer and sell them. You can manage inventories and work in progress, machine orders, worker assignements and research new items.
Why similar: Automation 18.2%, Grand Strategy 16.9% ★, Idler 16%, City Builder 15.3%, Economy 13.4%
- #55 City Country
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Velikov Brothers
Windows
City Country is a city-building game where you manage resources, population, knowledge. You control various sectors of the city like education, medicine, culture, tourism, trading.
Why similar: Trading 29.5% ★, City Builder 24.3%, Economy 16.3%, Building 9.3%, Inventory Management 5.5%
- #56 Amusement Tycoon
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: BronStudio
Windows
Manage your park in Amusement Tycoon! Build thrilling attractions, manage staff, and delight visitors to create the park of your dreams and achieve success!
Why similar: City Builder 26.4%, Capitalism 16.8%, Economy 15.4%, Grand Strategy 13.4% ★, Building 12.9%
- #57 Money Print Factory 3D Tycoon💸
66% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Obese NinjasPub: Broken Clock
Windows
Greetings, our money hungry player. This is a 3D Clicker Tycoon game where your money making adventure begins. Print money, buy & upgrade machines, and expand your factory. Gain more money, and more money, AND MORE MONEY $$$!
Why similar: Automation 24.6%, Idler 23%, Economy 17.7%, Capitalism 15.9%, Building 9.8%
- #58 Little Lures
65% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2025
Dev: Panda Blade Software
Windows
A casual idle fishing sim that sits quietly at the bottom of your screen while you do other tasks.
Why similar: Idler 31.4%, Automation 28.9%, Fishing 26.2% ★, Management 5.5%, Casual 4.8%
- #59 RoboFarm
66% matchNo user reviews
Dev: InfiniStrategy
Windows · Mac · Linux
Build, automate, and decorate your dream farm! Deploy robot workers, unlock powerful upgrades, and watch your crops thrive while you relax, raising profits to your satisfaction. Save and share your creations, tune in with the music, and experience the world of RoboFarm.
Why similar: Automation 22.5%, Idler 18.4%, Agriculture 14.1% ★, Building 11.8%, Economy 9.5%