Games Like The Pony Factory

Hunt squirrels, staple them to a corpse, and meet god.

Why similar: Dark Humor 26.1%, FPS 16.9%, Horror 13.8%, Comedy 9.1%, Shooter 7.8%

Why You'll Like It: It shares the same unsettling, low-poly, and bizarre horror aesthetic found in The Pony Factory.

An immersive power fantasy simulator with tactical stealth elements set in a sewage infused garbage world

Why similar: FPS 31.5%, Dark Humor 28.1%, Shooter 12.3%, Stylized 10.1%, Surreal 8.9%

Why You'll Like It: This game is the gold standard for surreal, ugly-on-purpose, dark-humor FPS experiences that prioritize atmosphere over polish.

After a sexual mishap, our hero 77p egg finds itself on a quest to find a new wife while the world is overrun by sentient sewage and a milk-obsessed cult. A dumb and crass FPS inspired by the likes of Postal 2, Duke 3D, and Goat Simulator.

Why similar: FPS 32.9%, Comedy 28%, Action 17%, Surreal 9.6%, First-Person 8.8%

Why You'll Like It: An absurdist, low-budget FPS that leans heavily into the same kind of strange, surreal comedy.

HROT is a single-player retro FPS set in a small socialist country neighboring Soviet Union (Czechoslovakia) after an unspecified disaster in 1986. Those times were dark and terrifying and so is the game.

Why similar: FPS 32.9%, Horses 29.1% ★, Shooter 11.6%, Horror 10.1%, First-Person 5.5%

Why You'll Like It: A retro-styled FPS that captures a gritty, Eastern European horror aesthetic through its unique visual design.

Escape the nightmarish human abattoir in this blood-soaked Horror FPS.

Why similar: FPS 32.8%, Horror 18.8%, Shooter 15.3%, Stylized 10.8%, First-Person 7.8%

Why You'll Like It: A direct match for the low-budget, first-person horror shooter genre with a focus on gritty, stylized combat.

POSTAL: Brain Damaged is a new, action-oriented take on the Running With Scissors’ cult game series with throwback graphics, and fast-paced, modern gameplay. Take a wild roller coaster ride through the twisted wonderland encased in the POSTAL DUDE’S messed-up mind.

Why similar: FPS 19.3%, Comedy 17%, Shooter 14%, Stylized 13.5%, Horror 12.9%

Why You'll Like It: A perfect blend of chaotic, fast-paced FPS gameplay and irreverent, dark-humor storytelling.

Fort Oasis is no paradise—it's a decaying nightmare where reality crumbles. The creator of Turbo Overkill unleashes survival-horror stacked with mysteries and monstrosities. Scavenge to craft weapons, while a voice on your walkie-talkie guides you into the island's depths.

Why similar: FPS 33.9%, Horror 25.8%, First-Person 9.5%, Action 7.8%, Surreal 6.8%

Why You'll Like It: A gritty, industrial-themed horror FPS that delivers a tense and visceral experience.

This Strange Realm Of Mine is a First Person Shooter mixed with poetry and psychological horror. Graphic style is 3D mixed with pixel art.

Why similar: FPS 34.6%, Horror 20.1%, Shooter 13.7%, Dark Humor 8.7%, First-Person 7.8%

Why You'll Like It: A surreal, psychological FPS that explores dark themes through a distinct and experimental visual style.

Battle through an onslaught of mystical backwater cultists, possessed militants & even darker forces as you attempt to discover just what lurks beneath the Earth in this retro FPS inspired by the '90s legends.

Why similar: FPS 32.7%, Dark Humor 23.3%, Horror 16.2%, Shooter 13.8%, First-Person 6%

Why You'll Like It: A masterclass in retro FPS design that integrates strong horror elements and a dark, occult atmosphere.

Blast through a cursed nightmare solo or with up to 3 friends. A retro-inspired FPS where looter shooter weapons meets boomer shooter chaos and rogue-lite elements.

Why similar: FPS 41.7%, Shooter 15.9%, Horror 15.8%, First-Person 7.7%, Surreal 5%

Why You'll Like It: A fast-paced, retro-styled shooter that combines intense combat with dark, horror-inspired loot elements.

Play Russian roulette with a 12-gauge shotgun. Four enter. One leaves. Roll the dice with your life. Good luck!

Why similar: Horror 36.2%, FPS 15.8%, First-Person 14.3%, Dark 10.7%, 3D 8.7%

Why You'll Like It: A short, intense, and highly stylized horror game that relies on dark, claustrophobic tension.

A 90's horror inspired first-person game about working the midnight shift at a gas station.

Why similar: FPS 24.3%, Horror 14.9%, Shooter 12.4%, Comedy 12.2%, Funny 8.3%

Why You'll Like It: A first-person horror shooter that utilizes a walking-simulator pace to build dread in a 3D environment.

Live a week in the life of "The POSTAL Dude"; a hapless everyman just trying to check off some chores. Buying milk, returning an overdue library book, getting Gary Coleman's autograph, what could possibly go wrong?

Why similar: Dark Humor 35.9%, Comedy 18.7%, FPS 17.3%, Funny 9.7%, First-Person 7%

Why You'll Like It: The classic benchmark for dark-humor FPS games that thrive on chaos and absurdity.

A first person melee horror game where you use rusty tools to brutalize a gang of serial torturers in the remote Appalachian Forest.

Why similar: Dark Humor 37%, Horror 21.6%, First-Person 8.6%, Combat 8.4%, Surreal 6.9%

Why You'll Like It: A visceral first-person hack-and-slash horror game that shares the gritty, combat-heavy focus of the seed game.

Chicken Feet is a first person survival-stealth horror game about a giant, angry chicken. Descend into the depths of GOOBER laboratories and uncover the horrors that lie beneath the lab's shiny façade.

Why similar: Horror 55.5%, Action 12%, 3D 8.9%, Dark 7.2%, Linear 6.9%

Why You'll Like It: An indie horror title that blends stealth and action with a focus on escaping a terrifying, surreal threat.

Survival Horror in first person where you must manage your ammunition well, explore varied scenarios and face nightmarish beings, while investigating the macabre experiments with children, the result of a mind unhinged by madness and family loss.

Why similar: FPS 30.5%, Horror 18.7%, Shooter 15.3%, Combat 8.4%, First-Person 7.2%

Why You'll Like It: A survival-horror FPS that features a dark, twisted theme and intense combat encounters.

Trapped in a dark, Victorian city consumed by an ancient curse, you must plan your survival and daring escape using nothing but stealth, an arsenal of eccentric weapons, and your wit in this haunting adventure inspired by the immersive sims and survival horror greats of the late 90s and early 2000s.

Why similar: FPS 42.2%, Shooter 16.1%, Resource Management 11.5%, First-Person 10.8%, Dark 5.3%

Why You'll Like It: An atmospheric, stealth-focused horror FPS with a distinct, dark, and Victorian-inspired aesthetic.

Smuggle contraband VHS tapes across the border. Discover the remnants of illicit industry. Prepare for an assassination. This is Paratopic, an atmospheric retro-3D horror adventure through a cursed fever dream.

Why similar: Horror 45.9%, Stylized 19.5%, Surreal 16.7%, Atmospheric 6.6%, First-Person 5.2%

Why You'll Like It: A surreal, low-poly horror experience that excels at creating an unsettling and dreamlike atmosphere.

Prodeus is a first-person shooter of old, re-imagined using modern rendering techniques and technology. Experience the quality you’d expect from a modern AAA game, designed with retro aesthetics and gameplay that invoke the tech-imposed limits of older hardware.

Why similar: FPS 62.2%, Shooter 17.8%, Action 7.2%, Horror 5.9%, First-Person 5.2%

Why You'll Like It: A visceral, gore-filled retro shooter that emphasizes high-octane action and stylized, chunky visuals.

An inconvenient electrical failure turns into an unspeakable nightmare as Dietrich becomes trapped in an abandoned subterranean mining town full of horrid creatures.

Why similar: Horror 57.4%, Action 17.9%, Dark 10.9%, Atmospheric 8.2%, Singleplayer 5.6%

Why You'll Like It: An indie horror shooter that leans into a surreal, dark atmosphere and unconventional combat mechanics.

You are a simple provincial engineer eager to change his worthless life. What could be a better place to start everything anew than Moscow where everyone can find some way to earn for a living? But things there are not as easy as you thought…

Why similar: Dark Humor 25.7%, FPS 23.9%, Comedy 13.3%, Shooter 12.9%, First-Person 6.4%

Why You'll Like It: A straightforward, action-heavy first-person shooter that fits the indie horror-shooter mold.

A short horror game where you pilot a tiny submarine through an ocean of blood on an alien moon.

Why similar: Horror 57.2%, First-Person 13.8%, Atmospheric 9%, 3D 8.9%, Dark 6.3%

Why You'll Like It: A short, claustrophobic, and deeply unsettling horror experience that relies on atmosphere over traditional combat.

Weird west legends meet eldritch horror in BLOOD WEST, an immersive stealth FPS. Become the Undead Gunslinger, doomed to roam the barren lands until he manages to purge their curse, freeing his soul. 3 varied scenarios, perk-based character progression, and 20+ hours of gameplay await you!

Why similar: FPS 40.1%, Horror 22.5%, Shooter 14.8%, First-Person 8.9%, Action 5.3%

Why You'll Like It: A stealth-horror FPS that features a gritty, supernatural aesthetic and challenging, methodical gameplay.

Enter Paradise as Johnny Turbo—half-metal, half-human, all-murder machine. Clean up the streets with a chainsaw leg, 15+ weapons and your hovercar as you battle the rogue AI Syn, rival bounty hunters and cyberpunks aplenty. Apogee’s most outrageous FPS since Duke Nukem 3D. Good hunting, Sir!

Why similar: FPS 55.9%, Shooter 21.1%, Action 8.6%, First-Person 5.7%, Combat 5.7%

Why You'll Like It: A high-octane, stylized FPS that matches the chaotic energy and over-the-top action of the seed game.

First person shooter Psychological horror, which is about sick thought experiments that will be seen thanks to some videotapes and demonstrate what dark is the world now.

Why similar: FPS 32.1%, Horror 27.6%, Shooter 15.4%, First-Person 7.2%, Action 6.1%

Why You'll Like It: A gritty, survival-focused FPS horror game that emphasizes scarcity and intense, close-quarters combat.

A game about hunting rats, feeding them to your family, and going to bed.

Why similar: Horror 30%, Stylized 22.5%, FPS 18.7%, Surreal 7.5%, First-Person 7.4%

Why You'll Like It: A retro-styled horror game that shares the industrial, factory-based setting and unsettling vibe.

Crying Pony is a 2D side-scrolling horror game where the protagonist, Michael, is hunted by the lurking evil in his nightmares. As the nightmare's corruption seeps into reality and even pulls Michael's daughter into its grasp, will he be able to lead them both to escape from the nightmare?

Why similar: Noir 35.1%, Horror 26.5%, Stylized 14.3%, Combat 6.3%, Linear 6.1%

Why You'll Like It: A psychological horror game that shares a thematic link to the seed game through its surreal, horse-related imagery.

A zombie ponies game where you have to survive with a shotgun.

Why similar: FPS 47.1%, Horror 19.4%, Action 11.6%, First-Person 10.9%, 3D 9.8%

80's horror inspired FPS, a nightmarish scene taking place at an abandoned orphanage.

Why similar: FPS 40.7%, Horror 21.7%, First-Person 10.5%, Action 10.2%, 3D 9.3%

Why You'll Like It: An action-adventure title that incorporates exploration and horror elements in a stylized, dark world.

Meet Zortch Maxinum: short order cook, amateur engineer and professional slacker; Bored and tired of her day job she decides to go on a holiday but alas she picks a cheap option: turns out it's a scheme by aliens who capture humans to eat their brains! also this game is a sci-fi horror comedy fps

Why similar: FPS 48.3%, Shooter 17.7%, Horror 12.6%, First-Person 8.2%, Action 6.1%

An FPS horror game set in a surreal, dark and deadly biomechanical world never seen before. Humankind is just a small part of a hostile universe. Want to survive? Discover its secrets.

Why similar: FPS 30.5%, Horror 21.6%, Shooter 13.5%, First-Person 7.3%, Surreal 6.5%

Why You'll Like It: An atmospheric, dark, and biomechanical horror FPS that focuses on a unique, oppressive world design.

Pony Island is a suspense puzzle game in disguise. You are in limbo, trapped in a malevolent and malfunctioning arcade machine devised by the devil himself. It is not a game about ponies.

Why similar: Horses 57.2% ★, Horror 23.1%, Funny 7.2%, Dark 5.6%, Singleplayer 4.9%

A first-person action horror game set in a nightmarish manor infested with zombies, psychotic cultists, and a horde of other horrors. Utilize an assortment of different weapons in a brutal fight for survival as you try to escape from the Nightmare of Decay.

Why similar: FPS 41.9%, Horror 33.3%, Action 9.1%, First-Person 9.1%, Combat 3.9%

Bendy and the Ink Machine® is the first person puzzle action horror game that will forever ruin your childhood love of cartoons.

Why similar: Horror 54.4%, First-Person 15%, Dark 7.6%, Action 6.5%, Singleplayer 6.4%

As the #1 toilet fan, you visit an abandoned toilet factory in search of the legendary golden toilets. However, you're ambushed by the factory's friendly mascot, Lovey Dovey. You're at an extreme disadvantage since the only thing you brought is a rocket launcher. Collect all the toilets then escape!

Why similar: FPS 23.8%, Comedy 20.1%, Shooter 15.5%, Horror 9.4%, Action 7%

You have to find your daddy.

Why You'll Like It: A singleplayer FPS that features a surreal, dark tone and focuses on straightforward, action-oriented gameplay.

Use deduction, murder and trust your luck to eliminate the town council and rule over the helpless cartoon horses in a twisted strategy RPG.

Why similar: Horses 52.6% ★, Dark Humor 28.4%, Horror 14.1%, 3D 4.9%

Something scary is happening with everyone's favorite Saturday morning puppet show, The Friendly Neighborhood! Play as Gordon, a repairman sent to get to the bottom of this disturbing dilemma. Fend off puppets and solve puzzles in this survival horror adventure.

Why similar: FPS 24.6%, Horror 18.4%, Shooter 12.7%, Resource Management 11.3%, Funny 10.3%

Forgive Me Father is a dark retro horror FPS set in a comic book style world inspired by the novels of H.P. Lovecraft. As the only one left with full senses, you begin a journey in search of answers and relief. How long can you last?

Why similar: FPS 42.7%, Shooter 17.1%, Stylized 12.6%, First-Person 7.2%, Action 7.1%

Your first day as the new shepherd in the village… and everything is going wrong. The animals are missing. The villagers are strange. And the truth is far more terrifying.

Why similar: Dark Humor 37.6%, Horror 16.1%, Comedy 14.8%, Funny 10.3%, First-Person 6.6%

Sabotage a cult and their schemes in this Mystery, Horror, FPS. Explore a mansion while massacring the creepy followers and their foul abominations. Find various weapons to slay your enemies with and uncover the cruel secrets of the organization.

Why similar: FPS 28.7%, Shooter 16.2%, Horror 13.2%, Stylized 11%, Action 9.4%

A murderer's only shot at redemption. Shatter hell portals, stack divine relics into devastating builds, and descend deeper into hell until you're strong enough to face Satan himself. A roguelike FPS about salvation through overwhelming holy firepower.

Why similar: FPS 41%, Shooter 23.7%, Action 13.9%, First-Person 11%, 3D 5.8%

Welcome to a world where the entire human population of earth is undergoing a massive de evolution process! The human race has de evolved back into monkeys and are causing an apocalyptic mayhem over the entire earth, and It's only up to you to end this terrorizing madness!

Why similar: Dark Humor 22.3%, FPS 18.2%, Comedy 13.6%, Horror 10.7%, Shooter 9.9%

You've woken up in this magnificent cake factory, but soon realize that a crazy chef is after you… Get ready to bake cakes in this stressful First-person Horror game!

Why similar: Horror 53.9%, First-Person 17.4%, 3D 11.3%, Action 9.9%, Singleplayer 7.5%

The tests went wrong. He has been transformed. It is hostile toward others. You have been assigned the task of killing the horrifying creature. Listen closely as it could be around any corner. (Game includes Remastered + Classic versions)

Why similar: Horror 37.2%, Stylized 14.4%, First-Person 13.3%, Action 12.5%, Dark 8.4%

Brew potions, create monstrosities, and commit atrocities... Fulfill the collector's sick fantasies by experimenting on goblins with wacky potion ingredients that can modify bodies in grotesque ways. If a goblin seems sad that you turned him into an abomination, just drop him into the meatgrinder!

Why similar: Dark Humor 53.6%, Horror 17.6%, Funny 14.6%, First-Person 7.6%, 3D 6.7%

Albert Innovation is an immersive, narrative, atmospheric semi-horror game, where you will attempt to unravel the mysteries of what was once the most brilliant technological innovation company of the olden days. Manipulate machines, run away, and put an end to this nightmare.

Why similar: FPS 28.3%, Horror 26.7%, Linear 9.9%, Dark 8.1%, 3D 7.7%

Emergency Protocol activated: Dark Energy Particle Synthesis failed. Now you – late and alone – must navigate a facility where science and sanity have collapsed. Face entities born from the corruption of dark energy in this atmospheric FPS-horror hybrid, where human ambition meets primal terror.

Why similar: FPS 36.8%, Horror 29.5%, Shooter 11.8%, First-Person 10.9%, 3D 6.8%

It's bake or die at Cakey's Bakery, where human children are the secret ingredient to strange monsters' delicious pastries. Find the recipe for survival to escape the bakery and it's sweet and scary staff!

Why similar: FPS 35.4%, Stylized 15.7%, Horror 14.2%, First-Person 9%, 3D 8.5%

A man living in his new apartment finds himself in the center of something much more sinister.

Why similar: Horror 40.9%, Surreal 11%, First-Person 10.8%, Action 8%, 3D 7.6%

A survival horror spot-the-difference game set in a twisted Hell gameshow. Demons will distract you, torment you, or try to kill you. The Arbiter is your mysterious guide—sometimes helpful, sometimes...not so much. Spot the anomalies or suffer the consequences.

Why similar: FPS 31.8%, Horror 27.5%, Funny 15.7%, Surreal 9.1%, 3D 7.2%

Hell Pie is an obscene 3D platformer that takes bad taste to the next level! Hell Pie sees you grab the horns of Nate, the ‘Demon of Bad Taste’. He is given the honorable task of gathering the disgusting ingredients for Satan’s infamous birthday pie!

Why similar: Dark Humor 43.7%, Comedy 37.2%, 3D 7.4%, Combat 6.1%, Singleplayer 5.6%

Bob and Case just wanted a quiet night… but fate (and a clogged toilet) had other plans. When a clueless friend ignores an important warning and decides to take a dump in a broken toilet, the nightmare begins.

Why similar: Dark Humor 28.2%, Comedy 17.5%, Shooter 17.5%, Horror 9.3%, Action 7.9%

Sam is an addict who ends up in an institution named “Reaching Dreams”, hoping to kick his drug problem and sort out his miserable life. But during the first night, something goes horribly wrong and he gets stuck in an endless nightmare…

Why similar: Horror 80.7%, First-Person 7.8%, Singleplayer 4.8%, Atmospheric 3.4%, Dark 3.2%

Welcome to REVOLVERPUNK! Chambers is a comedic RPG shooter set in the Weird Wild West! Cook the boomstick, fingercatch some bullets and wrangle that fella into your pocket!

Why similar: Horses 37% ★, Dark Humor 16%, FPS 12.3%, Horror 10.2%, Comedy 8.7%

Meat Train is a FPS game where you operate a train thats uses MEAT for FUEL. Explore a wasteland where everything wants you dead, scavenge for weapons and loot. Upgrade the train and attempt to destroy an evil AI megafactory.

Why similar: FPS 32%, Horror 23.9%, Shooter 14.7%, Stylized 10.8%, 3D 6.4%

Workaholic is a frantic rouge-lite FPS where you go on a rampage through a hellish office space as your grasp on reality crumbles.

Why similar: FPS 35.5%, Dark Humor 24.8%, Stylized 12.1%, Action 7.3%, First-Person 6.6%

Single player horror game set in an underground lab. Kill monsters and escape.

Why similar: FPS 35.1%, Dark Humor 33.6%, Shooter 16.7%, First-Person 7.7%, 3D 6.9%

In this singleplayer mascot horror game you're trapped in an abandoned children’s asylum. Solve twisted puzzles with your Ink Blaster, evade its disturbing mascots, and uncover secrets you had long forgotten about. Do you remember?

Why similar: Horror 73.4%, First-Person 14.1%, Atmospheric 7.2%, Singleplayer 5.3%

A dark comedy horror game with a N64 aesthetic.

Why similar: Dark Humor 30.4%, Shooter 18%, Horror 14.1%, Stylized 13%, First-Person 11.7%