- #1 Rhythm Drum 节奏鼓
97% match7 user reviews86% of 7 reviews2025
Dev: SOLARLAKE
Windows
A dynamic rhythm game where players follow the dynamic music beats by tapping the drums with the mouse and keyboard.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 54.8% ★, Rhythm 27.5%, Simulation 8.1%, Atmospheric 6.3%, Indie 1.5%
- #2 Toward Pianist
96% match6 user reviews83% of 6 reviews2024
Dev: woong
Windows
This is a game and simulation that allows anyone to easily play the piano with a keyboard. You can load and play more than 10 classic songs and any song you want as a MIDI file .Try a piano rhythm game you've never experienced before.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 45% ★, Rhythm 28.1%, Simulation 26.4%, Singleplayer 0.5%
- #3 DiscoCat
95% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2026
Dev: LuviaWorks
Windows
✨Let your desktop dance to the beat! DiscoCat is an audio-reactive desktop pet designed to bring life to your workspace. Whether you're coding, writing, or just vibing to music, this cyber-cat captures every audio track from your system and transforms it into vibrant rhythms.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 49.7% ★, Rhythm 24.8%, Simulation 9.9%, Psychedelic 6.1%, Atmospheric 3.8%
- #4 Quantized
94% match2 user reviews50% of 2 reviews2017
Dev: Chris MahoneyPub: Abstractron
Windows
Quantized is an audio reactive, procedurally-generated sensory experience. Play your own local songs to generate a fun, exhilarating musical journey.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 48.4% ★, Simulation 25.9%, Rhythm 22.6%, Indie 3.1%
- #5 Stock Exchange Game
93% matchMixed54% of 13 reviews2025
Dev: BoneApps
Windows · Mac · Linux
Stock market game with trading on the commodity exchange for beginner traders
Why similar: Trading 51%, Simulation 20.4%, Capitalism 12.7%, Economy 9.5%, Minimalist 3.8%
- #6 Tempo Trigger
94% matchNo user reviews2023
Dev: Corn Entertainment, LLC
Windows · Linux
Tempo Trigger is a rhythm and aiming skill game. Players can compete in the leaderboard or create something truly memorable with stream chat.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 51.9% ★, Rhythm 23.3%, Arcade 10.1%, Psychedelic 8.7%, Atmospheric 3.9%
- #7 ASCII-RIFT
91% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2026
Dev: End of Line Club
Windows · Linux
The music is the enemy. Dodge hazards generated directly from the soundtrack in fast, reactive arcade runs. Master precision and score in Chart Mode or survive escalating procedural loops in Rift Mode.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 48.3% ★, Rhythm 27.1%, Arcade 11.5%, Minimalist 4.8%, Action 2.7%
- #8 Ritum Bitum
92% match3 user reviews0% of 3 reviews2021
Dev: Askar Lutfrakhmanov
Windows
Ritum Bitum is a 2-in-1 concept: it is a rhythm game and keyboard simulator. The speed, color and position of the letters are determined by your music. Enjoy music while learning keyboard techniques.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 58.6% ★, Rhythm 30.5%, Arcade 9.1%, Indie 1%, Singleplayer 0.8%
- #9 Blink Atomic Music
91% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2026
Dev: JinCycle
Windows
This is a game where you dodge bullet patterns generated from music using movement and Blink (short warp). Each song lasts about 2 minutes, and there are 9 songs in total.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 49.4% ★, Rhythm 30%, Psychedelic 9.3%, Minimalist 6.4%, 2D 3.4%
- #10 Day Trade Coach
90% matchMixed53% of 15 reviews2026
Dev: Ragnar Beaucoup
Windows
Day Trade Coach is a day trading simulator built for focus. Cut through the noise, master the set-ups that actually work, and build your edge, one trade at a time.
Why similar: Trading 47.7%, Simulation 25.7%, Capitalism 13.3%, Economy 10%, 2D 1.8%
- #11 Music Game
88% matchMixed69% of 35 reviews2025
Dev: BNnnen
Windows
A customisable rhythm game which includes a level editor, Steam Workshop support, automatic level generation and much more!
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 60.9% ★, Rhythm 26.3%, Arcade 6.2%, 2D 2.5%, Atmospheric 2.2%
- #12 Trading Tycoon
89% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Kits Gaming Studio
Windows
Build your fortune in a deep single-player trading simulation. Analyze charts, trade stocks/options/futures, manage risk, unlock powerful skills, and survive a living market shaped by news and market cycles.
Why similar: Trading 52.8%, Simulation 30.9%, Economy 13.1%, 2D 2.4%, Singleplayer 0.8%
- #13 Poverty is a Choice
89% match9 user reviews56% of 9 reviews2018
Dev: Ugliest Horse Studio
Windows
I get it, you are poor and that's humiliating. Stop being poor, idiot.
Why similar: Trading 47.5%, Simulation 31.1%, Capitalism 16.1%, Indie 5.3%
- #14 PUMP IT UP RISE
86% matchVery Positive80% of 774 reviews2026
Dev: ANDAMIRO
Windows
PUMP IT UP RISE is the official PC version of the PUMP IT UP series, the arcade rhythm game franchise loved for over 25 years. Optimized for keyboard, gamepad, Steam Deck, and more, it brings the excitement of arcade-style rhythm action back to you on Steam.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 45.9% ★, Rhythm 34.1%, Arcade 14%, 2D 3.1%, Action 2.4%
- #15 Music Movement
86% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2026
Dev: Jeremie Amano
Windows
A room-scale VR rhythm game that will have you moving and grooving all around with a simple premise: be in the right place at the right time with your hands as you navigate procedurally generated choreography.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 56.4% ★, Rhythm 30%, Arcade 8.2%, Atmospheric 4.2%, Indie 0.8%
- #16 Music95
87% matchMostly Positive78% of 18 reviews2021
Dev: NJ No.1
Windows
Music95 is a special music game. There is no premade beatmaps. Game content is automatically created by player's own music track. So player can immerse in their favorite music. Try it Out!
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 50.9% ★, Rhythm 21.9%, Psychedelic 11.5%, Minimalist 6.3%, Atmospheric 5.6%
- #17 Angel Investor Simulator™
85% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Bigosaur
Windows
Invest into promising startups with sometimes wacky ideas. Help them grow with your team of experts. Capture the market share with quality product, smart pricing and marketing. Cash out big after the IPO. Compete with the other angels and show them who's the boss.
Why similar: Trading 44.6%, Simulation 21.5%, Capitalism 18.4%, Economy 8.7%, Minimalist 4.6%
- #18 Singalongsong
84% matchPositive88% of 16 reviews2024
Dev: 三声三许制作组
Windows
Singalongsong is a simple rhythm game that takes players through her daily life with fun levels, lively hand-drawn animations, and delicate original music.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 49% ★, Rhythm 30.8%, Simulation 13.6%, 2D 3.1%, Action 2.3%
- #19 Beat Shot
84% matchNo user reviews
Dev: the_trap
Windows
Dash and blast your way through rhythmically entranced enemies. Can you keep up with the beat?
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 48.1% ★, Rhythm 23.9%, Psychedelic 9.5%, Roguelite 7.1%, Atmospheric 6.6%
- #20 Project_Khatanga_1989_Incremental
82% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Project_Khatanga_Studio
Windows
Project Katanga 1989 is a retro economic simulation game about buying, storing, tracking, and selling goods across volatile international markets. Manage limited storage, compare currencies, watch shifting prices, and decide when to hold or sell.
Why similar: Trading 44.4%, Capitalism 20.7%, Simulation 18.6%, Economy 12%, 2D 2.8%
- #21 Tempoverdose
82% matchNo user reviews
Dev: VANDERMAESEN GAMES
Windows
Insane Twin Stick Rythmic shooter. Defeat waves of enemies shooting to the beat. Conquer every genre from chill house to hectic breakbeat.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 50.2% ★, Rhythm 24%, Arcade 10.5%, Psychedelic 6.2%, Minimalist 4.7%
- #22 Geo-Duck
81% matchPositive89% of 36 reviews2021
Dev: Your Infamous HarpPub: Your Infamous
Windows · Mac
The rhythm platformer that anyone would have come up with. Featuring a dynamically generated glitch-hop soundtrack. Journey to Nirvana to discover the true meaning of your existence. Traverse 49 Pythonesque levels. You'll never hear the same game twice.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 51.5% ★, Rhythm 19.6%, Psychedelic 12.5%, Arcade 11.1%, Funny 2.5%
- #23 Rhythm Stones
80% matchMostly Positive76% of 25 reviews2022
Dev: MELOVITY
Windows · Mac
Rhythm Stones is a 1 button 3D rhythm game that crosses moving stepping stones.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 51.9% ★, Rhythm 26.8%, Roguelike 9%, Roguelite 8.7%, Indie 1.8%
- #24 异世界杂货铺 skyscraper in Another world
79% matchPositive90% of 20 reviews2023
Dev: one game
Windows
You will play as a businessman, running a grocery store, make money through retail and other methods, and then continue to grow and develop with the goal of becoming the first chamber of commerce on this continent
Why similar: Trading 46.2%, Simulation 14.8%, Roguelite 14.5%, Economy 11.7%, Roguelike 9.5%
- #25 Pulsen
81% matchMostly Positive80% of 64 reviews2015
Dev: 4-Panel Footprint
Windows
Pulsen is a music and rhythm game where you listen to music and move along to the beat. Can you master your timing and groove through the expansive song list and challenging patterns? Hit arrows to the beat of the music, the better your accuracy the better your score!
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 45.1% ★, Rhythm 24.8%, Arcade 11.7%, Simulation 11.4%, Funny 3.7%
- #26 Temp Zero
78% matchVery Positive95% of 171 reviews2022
Dev: Alexandre Kadri
Windows
Temp Zero is a minimalist roguelike which mixes intense action and musical bullet hell. Fight enemies which attack to the beat, choose perks, defeat the final boss, unlock new weapons, spells & soundtracks!
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 42.4% ★, Rhythm 22.8%, Roguelike 10.8%, Arcade 9.8%, Minimalist 6.9%
- #27 Bull Run
78% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Steve Games
Windows · Linux
Trade stocks, short the market, and outsmart AI rivals in this fast-paced stock trading strategy game. Build your portfolio, survive market crashes, ride IPOs, and climb the leaderboards. Do you have what it takes to beat Wall Street?
Why similar: Trading 53.8%, Simulation 31.1%, Economy 13.3%, Indie 1.2%, Singleplayer 0.6%
- #28 Run Turn Die
79% matchPositive84% of 19 reviews2016
Dev: Matthias Magnussen
Windows
Keep the rhythm, turn left and right, how hard can it be?
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 48.5% ★, Rhythm 27.1%, Arcade 13.4%, Minimalist 9.4%, Indie 1.1%
- #29 Car Trader Simulator
77% matchMostly Positive72% of 521 reviews2020
Dev: Live Motion Games
Windows
Median: 3.0 hrsMean: 5.6 hrs≥1hr: 70%
Do you know how to profit from trading cars while maintaining a good reputation? Car Trader Simulator lets you play the role of an American car dealer. Your goal is to get rich. How you do it depends entirely on you.
Why similar: Trading 51.9%, Simulation 19.1%, Economy 9.7%, Capitalism 9.3%, Funny 3.9%
- #30 String Theory
76% matchPositive100% of 15 reviews2025
Dev: ZHANGHAILONGPub: Zhanghailong
Windows
This is a music game where players can practice rhythm skills. Players will practice some basic music structures, and the music will be transformed into attack skills to defeat different enemies.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 55.8% ★, Rhythm 25.3%, Simulation 13.4%, Action 2.3%, 2D 1.9%
- #31 Fishing Time
75% matchMixed59% of 34 reviews2025
Dev: ElJoka
Windows
Fishing Time Is a chill fishing game where you collect rare fish. Every 2 hours, you can catch a fish, which is added to your Steam inventory. There are +140 different fish and 6 different rarity levels! Relax, cast your line, and complete your collection!
Why similar: Trading 32.3%, Simulation 31.8%, Arcade 17.6%, Minimalist 12.2%, 2D 4.2%
- #32 Your Music Puzzle
77% matchPositive90% of 10 reviews2020
Dev: Mighty Fox StudioPub: Mighty Fox Studio
Windows · Linux
A puzzle game, where pieces are generated based on your mp3/wav music. Put the track back into shape using sound as your only clue. Pop, rock, rap, classics - this game works perfectly with all music genres.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 61.7% ★, Rhythm 27.4%, Minimalist 6.5%, 2D 2.9%, Atmospheric 1.1%
- #33 Patrician IV
76% matchMixed56% of 761 reviews2010
Dev: Gaming Minds StudiosPub: Kalypso Media Digital
Windows
Median: 30 minMean: 8.5 hrs≥1hr: 42%
You are a merchant in northern Europe in the late Middle Ages when the Hanseatic League was flourishing. Your goal is to rise to the most successful and influential member of the Hanse, ultimately being elected Elderman, leader of the trading league.
Why similar: Trading 66%, Simulation 12.3%, Economy 10.7%, Capitalism 10.5%, Singleplayer 0.5%
- #34 FUNEX: Stock Market Simulator
73% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: VIREX MEDIA
Windows
FUNEX is the first and only STOCK MARKET SIMULATION which provides REAL ORDER BOOK TRADING to the players. You don't trade fake algoritmic prices on a fake market. Instead, there are 22 AI funds which are actively trading in a REAL SIMULATED STOCK EXCHANGE. Are you ready for REAL CHAOS?
Why similar: Trading 35.7%, Simulation 31.9%, Capitalism 18.2%, Economy 13.3%, Singleplayer 0.9%
- #35 Kaiju
74% matchPositive100% of 15 reviews2022
Dev: Minimal Studios
Windows
Kaiju is a collection of 2D and 3D audio visualizations that uses your system audio to drive its effects in real time.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 51.4% ★, Rhythm 25.2%, Psychedelic 8.5%, Atmospheric 6.9%, Minimalist 6.1%
- #36 Beat Vortex
73% match5 user reviews100% of 5 reviews2025
Dev: Glory Through Gaming
Windows
Discover a new way to experience your music in Beat Vortex, a rhythm game where your favorite songs shape the world. Fly through twisting tunnels that pulse, bend, and react to every beat. You’ll dodge, roll, and flow in sync with the rhythm—chasing high scores or just vibing to the music you love.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 60% ★, Rhythm 26.4%, Arcade 10.3%, Indie 1.6%, Action 1.2%
- #37 16bit Trader
75% matchMixed50% of 2,052 reviews2015
Dev: Forever Entertainment S. A.
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 4.4 hrsMean: 19.8 hrs≥1hr: 96%
Take revenge on your father’s killer!
Why similar: Trading 54.9%, Simulation 35.7%, Economy 5.7%, Indie 3.6%
- #38 RhythmSlinger
74% match3 user reviews67% of 3 reviews2021
Dev: Jacob's Juicy Games Co.
Windows
Shoot with style to YOUR songs! RhythmSlinger is a kinetic trick-based VR rhythm shooter that generates fast-paced levels from .mp3 file
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 57.3% ★, Rhythm 28.8%, Arcade 10.9%, Action 2.8%, Singleplayer 0.3%
- #39 Bunny Beats
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Studio Tapioca
Windows
Bunny Beats is a listening first rhythm learning game with procedurally generated rhythms. Each bunny swings its mochi hammer with a distinct rhythm; master the rhythms on the fly to make the best mochi for the moon goddess!
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 54.8% ★, Rhythm 28.1%, Arcade 12.9%, 2D 2.8%, Indie 1.2%
- #40 O2Jam : The Beginning
71% matchMixed46% of 92 reviews2026
Dev: SuperTurbine Technology Inc.
Windows · Mac
O2Jam : The Beginning is the official PC version based on O2Jam - Music & Game, featuring the entire series collection. Enjoy legendary original tracks, overwhelming note impact, and various key modes! From nostalgic classics to new hits, experience the authentic rhythm action of O2Jam.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 56.3% ★, Rhythm 29.1%, Simulation 4.5%, Atmospheric 4.3%, Funny 2.8%
- #41 Neo Capitalist - Stock Market Survival Simulator
72% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Paper Plane Logic
Windows · Mac
Trade by day. Eat, sleep, and survive by night. Lose everything with a single bad decision. Neo Capitalist is a financial survival roguelite where the richer you get, the harder the system fights back. Play in a realistic stock market simulation or in a dystopian cyber-punk world.
Why similar: Trading 42.9%, Simulation 13.9%, Capitalism 12.7%, Roguelite 9.6%, Economy 9.4%
- #42 Arpsic
72% match4 user reviews80% of 4 reviews2022
Dev: Green RetromanPub: Green Retroman Games
Windows
Arpsic is a casual musical rhythm game. With Arpsic, you can train yourself with intuitive lessons, learn the treble clef, bass clef, and more!
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 52.9% ★, Rhythm 23.1%, Arcade 11.5%, Minimalist 4.9%, Funny 2.9%
- #43 FARTISSIMO
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Sound Toy
Windows
A rhythmic roguelite starring a cute dragon who fights with musical farts! Time your attacks to the beat, defeat enemies for energy coins, and trigger new platforms before the old ones crumble in this fast-paced 3D adventure where standing still means certain doom.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 37.5% ★, Rhythm 34.2%, Roguelike 15.1%, Action 4.8%, Roguelite 4.7%
- #44 Pawn Shop Simulator
70% match7 user reviews88% of 8 reviews2026
Dev: Yacou Games
Windows
Open and manage your pawn shop in Las Vegas! Buy and sell increasingly prestigious items as your business grows, negotiate with your customers, hire seasoned experts to advise you, expand your store, and attract a wealthy clientele to unearth unique items.
Why similar: Trading 51.2%, Simulation 25.6%, Capitalism 16%, Economy 6.1%, Singleplayer 1.1%
- #45 Plant Nursery Simulator
69% matchVery Positive95% of 282 reviews2025
Dev: Robot Assembly
Windows
Run your own cozy Plant Nursery in this relaxing sim. Grow crops, stock shelves, and help customers. Expand with greenhouses, hire staff, and decorate your dream shop. Perfect for fans of wholesome farming and sim games.
Why similar: Trading 46.4%, Simulation 29.4%, Economy 12.1%, Capitalism 11.2%, Singleplayer 0.9%
- #46 Space Warlord Organ Trading Simulator
69% matchVery Positive93% of 865 reviews2021
Dev: Strange Scaffold
Windows
Median: 2.4 hrsMean: 4.7 hrs≥1hr: 71%
Buy, sell, and trade organs in a strange and evolving universe. Dive into the quivering innards of alien capitalism in the sci-fi body horror market tycoon game you didn't know you needed.
Why similar: Trading 34.8%, Simulation 12.1%, Arcade 11.4%, Capitalism 11.4%, Roguelike 11.1%
- #47 Ticker Panic
69% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Leveraged Interactive
Windows
Trade fake stocks through absurd headlines, hype cycles, crashes, liquidity traps, and panic-driven market chaos. Start small, grow your portfolio, and try not to panic.
Why similar: Trading 47.9%, Simulation 16.5%, Capitalism 14.2%, Economy 10.2%, Arcade 6.3%
- #48 Mango Cart
71% match8 user reviews63% of 8 reviews2019
Dev: AkriGames
Windows · Mac · Linux
Mango Cart is the trading game of fruits. Manage your company through the turmoil of the economical and political environment and emerge among your competitors.
Why similar: Trading 46.6%, Simulation 39.6%, Economy 10.6%, Indie 3.2%
- #49 Flipping Beat
70% match1 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2022
Dev: Atzi_ Games
Windows
Flipping Beat is an intense rhythm game where you blow up the beats of adrenaline-pumping music as they fly towards you, surrounded by an abstract world.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 34.7% ★, Rhythm 33.9%, Arcade 14.8%, Atmospheric 6.9%, Action 4.7%
- #50 Crypto Rush
68% matchMostly Negative28% of 25 reviews2024
Dev: Shurmash
Windows
This game is a parody created under the influence of the hype of crypto airdrops in clickers. Click on a coin to mine coins, sell coins for other coins, buy video cards to automate mining. Buy chests for mined coins to try to get new types of coins or get it on market or by exchanging with friends.
Why similar: Trading 56.2%, Simulation 28.7%, Economy 11.6%, 2D 2.9%, Singleplayer 0.7%
- #51 Sound Horizons
67% matchPositive82% of 17 reviews2024
Dev: Itooh
Windows · Linux
Score unique melodies in this minimalist rhythm game. Experience a dynamic music that reacts to your actions, and try to survive until the end.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 50.3% ★, Rhythm 29.2%, Psychedelic 8.1%, Minimalist 6.8%, Atmospheric 3.5%
- #52 Barn Finders
67% matchVery Positive82% of 4,399 reviews2020
Dev: Duality Games
Windows
Median: 7.8 hrsMean: 11.9 hrs≥1hr: 86%
Search for valuable items stashed in abandoned barns. Take part in storage auctions, bid high and buy yourself a chance to find exclusive items hidden in the past.
Why similar: Trading 51.7%, Simulation 26.1%, Economy 11.2%, Atmospheric 5.3%, Funny 2.9%
- #53 The Exchange Manager
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: The Black Swan
Windows
"In this economic strategy game starting in the Great Depression of 1929, buy stocks, take over companies, acquire countries, and shape world history. Compete fiercely against rivals to manipulate UN decisions, invest in the technologies of the era, and build mega projects.
Why similar: Trading 42.1%, Simulation 24.9%, Capitalism 15.4%, Economy 11.1%, Minimalist 3.1%
- #54 Sauna Simulator
67% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: S1NGLE
Windows
Run your own sauna: buy a room, equip it with an oven and start earning money from it. Hire employees, ensure safety and, of course, have fun!
Why similar: Trading 48.5%, Simulation 20%, Capitalism 15.8%, Economy 13.7%, Indie 1.1%
- #55 Melody Flight
68% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2020
Dev: Outside Realm
Windows
Melody Flight is a serene and soaring rhythm game.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 63.3% ★, Rhythm 30.5%, Arcade 3.9%, Indie 1.5%, Singleplayer 0.8%
- #56 City of Beats
66% matchMostly Positive77% of 139 reviews2023
Dev: Torched HillPub: indie.io
Windows
Median: 54 minMean: 8.4 hrs≥1hr: 48%
Shoot. Groove. Loot. Repeat. Cross an ever-changing city skyline, flowing through encounters in tune with the cityscape’s beat. From the weapons you fire, to the enemies you shoot, to the zen-like flow, the only way to win is to become one with the beat.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 42.2% ★, Rhythm 20.7%, Roguelike 10.6%, Arcade 9.5%, Roguelite 8.6%
- #57 Music Producer Tycoon
66% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Harmonia GamesPub: Red Axe Games
Windows
Music Producer Tycoon is a music industry simulation game where you write, produce, and release songs across decades. Use AI tools, manage your studio, collaborate with legends, and build your legacy from a garage to global fame.
Why similar: Music-Based Procedural Generation 55.1% ★, Trading 18.6%, Simulation 16%, Economy 7.4%, Funny 2.8%