- #1 Beat the Nettles!
97% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Burg Entertainment
Windows
An incremental game where childhood fun becomes a hobby with RPG elements. Beat weeds with a stick, improve your skill tree, and level up your stats. Simple gameplay, development, and nostalgia for childhood battles with plants.
Why similar: Idler 25.4%, Incremental 20.6%, Capitalism 10.2%, Casual 9.7%, Arcade 8.2%
- #2 Marble Idle Collectionist
96% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Mupet
Windows
A relaxing incremental game focused on sensorial joy of marbles, soothing sound design, and visually calming simulation. Upgrade systems, earn more marbles, and enjoy collecting all kinds of shiny trinkets.
Why similar: Idler 29.6%, Incremental 20.8%, Casual 11.6%, Minimalist 7.3%, Economy 7.2%
- #3 Only Driving - Cozy Car Journey
96% matchPositive88% of 17 reviews2026
Dev: Musa GUNGOR
Windows
Only Driving is a idle car driving game that promises incremental increases. As your vehicle moves automatically, you’ll be able to collect coins along the way and increase your kilometers to get new cars and new upgrades. Every kilometer of this journey will enhance your vehicle and make you rest.
Why similar: Idler 26.9%, Incremental 21.8%, Capitalism 14.2%, Casual 10.6%, Relaxing 8.5%
- #4 Everybody Loves a Good Hole
95% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Roovel Studio
Windows
Everybody Loves a Good Hole is a short, satisfying incremental about steering a black hole and swallowing everything in sight. Devour colorful cubes for XP and coins, grow bigger, and pour it all into a deep upgrade tree. Bigger cubes, wilder chaos, just one more run.
Why similar: Idler 25.7%, Incremental 23%, Arcade 10%, Relaxing 7.6%, Economy 6.8%
- #5 Smashing Bottles
94% matchVery Positive85% of 111 reviews2026
Dev: Blue Makes Games
Windows · Mac · Linux
Smashing Bottles is a short and satisfying incremental game where you break bottles to earn money, upgrade your bat, discover new bottles, and cause chaos! Will you smash enough bottles to buy the universe?
Why similar: Idler 27.3%, Incremental 22.8%, Economy 10.5%, Arcade 8.1%, Relaxing 6.1%
- #6 Auto Snakes in Outer Space
94% matchMostly Positive72% of 102 reviews2026
Dev: Old Atlas
Windows
A slow and meditative incremental idler where you manage colorful snakes. Watch them collect food, then spend the food on upgrades and abilities for your colony.
Why similar: Idler 37.2%, Incremental 26.7%, Relaxing 8.2%, Casual 7.5%, Arcade 5.9%
- #7 Now With More Plunk
93% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: 8-Bit Curls
Windows · Mac
A Plinko-like incremental where your coins strum harps, hit drums, and eventually create their own master orchestra. Go Plunk it up!
Why similar: Idler 29.1%, Incremental 25.1%, Arcade 10.1%, Relaxing 8.1%, Casual 7.2%
- #8 Keep Cutting
92% matchNo user reviews
Dev: devug
Windows
A short and satisfying incremental game about cutting endless grass and buying upgrades to clear more.
Why similar: Idler 23.4%, Incremental 23%, Relaxing 9.5%, Casual 7.9%, Minimalist 7.2%
- #9 No More Turtles
91% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: JunkDrawerDev
Windows
No More Turtles is a plastic-producing incremental game. Start cranking grandpa's machine, loot abandoned warehouses, and pollute your way to saving a world overrun by turtles!
Why similar: Incremental 22.9%, Idler 22.4%, Capitalism 9.8%, Casual 8.6%, Relaxing 8.1%
- #10 Clickstead
91% matchNo user reviews86% of 7 reviews2026
Dev: Zettik
Windows
A short incremental game about harvesting trees using elements like Fire and Lightning to your advantage. Build your skill tree and rise from Seed to legend.
Why similar: Idler 37.8%, Incremental 23.4%, Casual 11.2%, Relaxing 7.4%, Resource Management 6.1%
- #11 Imberite Idle
90% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2026
Dev: Chnappi
Windows
Open chests, collect rare structures, and optimize your build to maximize production in this steampunk idle incremental game.
Why similar: Idler 26.2%, Incremental 19.2%, Capitalism 10%, Casual 8%, Arcade 7.9%
- #12 Popotions
89% matchNo user reviews
Dev: NiNauk
Windows
Popotions is a relaxing incremental game about throwing explosive potions. Discover new potions, upgrade them and progress by defeating enemies.
Why similar: Idler 27.5%, Incremental 22.3%, Casual 11%, Relaxing 8.7%, Minimalist 8.1%
- #13 Popcorn Idle
89% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Sashify
Windows
Popcorn Idle is a cozy idle automation game about the simple joy of popping corn. Earn money, buy upgrades, automate and turn up the heat to boost production. Grow bigger numbers, unlock flavors and combine effects. Fill the whole machine with colorful, tasty popcorn, one crunchy pop at a time.
Why similar: Idler 29%, Incremental 20.4%, Relaxing 8.8%, Arcade 7.8%, Capitalism 7.4%
- #14 Trashy Cashy
88% matchNo user reviews66% of 128 reviews2026
Dev: Challenging Games
Windows
A short, 3-6-hour incremental game about building a business by selling trash. Become a partner in the mysterious "Trashy Cashy" franchise. Unpack trash, ship it off, and rake in outrageous profits. Don't ask too many questions. Sounds simple, right?
Why similar: Idler 26%, Incremental 22.2%, Capitalism 14.4%, Economy 9%, Arcade 6.3%
- #15 Potato Dominion Clicker
87% matchNo user reviews
Dev: LoopCraft Games
Windows
Create and expand a massive potato empire, click to earn, unlock upgrades, trigger powerful boosts, and dominate with endless progression.
Why similar: Idler 31.7%, Incremental 21.5%, Casual 8.8%, Arcade 8.6%, Economy 8.4%
- #16 10 Million Bounces
86% matchNo user reviews
Dev: BATTLE LAB
Windows
Start with one ball and grow a mining swarm. Break ore, gain experience, and evolve six ball types with blinking, splitting, fire, and lightning. Rainbow balls learn nearby abilities. Choose where to launch and watch each bounce open new paths.
Why similar: Idler 31.2%, Incremental 26.4%, Arcade 10.9%, Relaxing 8.8%, Casual 7.6%
- #17 It's Chopping Time!
84% matchVery Positive88% of 115 reviews2026
Dev: Alexandre Mailliu
Windows
Summon the mighty power of gods in this fun incremental game about chopping down trees on a secluded island by using the forces of nature: earthquakes, sunbeams, tornadoes, hail, lightning strikes and tidal waves! It's Chopping Time!
Why similar: Idler 29.4%, Incremental 24.2%, Relaxing 9.4%, Capitalism 8%, Casual 7.9%
- #18 Keep on Mining!
86% matchVery Positive93% of 8,439 reviews2025
Dev: EagleEye Games
Windows
Median: 4.7 hrsMean: 6.8 hrs≥1hr: 96%
Keep on Mining! is a short incremental mining game. Mine rocks, gather materials, find artifacts, craft pickaxes and spend your materials on permanent upgrades inside the big skill tree!
Why similar: Incremental 28.6%, Idler 25.7%, Capitalism 10.5%, Relaxing 7.6%, Casual 5.9%
- #19 Spin Power
85% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Tasty Colosseum
Windows
A short incremental building game where everything functions with your Spin Power. Build structures, mine resources, unlock new lands, upgrade yourself inside the big skill tree, automate resource mining to increase your income and awake the mysterious water tank from eternal slumber!
Why similar: Idler 28.6%, Incremental 23.1%, Casual 10.7%, Relaxing 9.1%, Economy 8%
- #20 Click Build Repeat
84% matchMostly Positive74% of 19 reviews2026
Dev: Don Pachi
Windows
Click Build Repeat is an incremental game about building and collecting model kits.
Why similar: Idler 30.4%, Incremental 25.6%, Economy 9.8%, Relaxing 9.7%, Casual 7.2%
- #21 Reap & Repeat
83% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Postwork Games
Windows
Reap & Repeat is a satisfying active incremental game about harvesting an ever-growing ecosystem. Cut plants, earn upgrades, improve your scythe, and make vegetation grow faster, denser, and more valuable as your tiny harvest turns into field-clearing chaos.
Why similar: Incremental 25.9%, Idler 20.1%, Capitalism 13.4%, Casual 9.8%, Relaxing 9.8%
- #22 Coin Pusher For My Wife
82% match1 user reviews0% of 1 reviews2026
Dev: OhneGames
Windows
Coin Pusher For My Wife is my take on the classic coin pusher games found in arcades. I created every level with input from my wife. This game is designed to be a relaxing and cozy game to help take your mind off the crushing reality of having to decide what to eat for dinner.
Why similar: Idler 31.6%, Incremental 15.1%, Casual 14%, Arcade 13.8%, Relaxing 11.7%
- #23 God of Stocks
82% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Obys Byte Games
Windows
An incremental management game about manipulating the market to get filthy rich. Buy low, sell high, chain absurd combos and earn divine blessings from stock market gods. Will you play it safe or risk everything?
Why similar: Idler 26.9%, Incremental 22%, Capitalism 16.3%, Economy 10.5%, Casual 5.5%
- #24 Keep on Mining! - Worlds
81% matchVery Positive80% of 1,930 reviews2026
Dev: EagleEye Games
Windows
Median: 8.1 hrsMean: 11.7 hrs≥1hr: 92%
Keep on Mining! – Worlds is an incremental mining game where you mine rocks, collect resources, and travel through many unique worlds, finding artifacts, crafting pickaxes, and purchasing many permanent upgrades!
Why similar: Incremental 26.9%, Idler 22.8%, Capitalism 10.7%, Casual 8.6%, Relaxing 7.9%
- #25 Black Hole: Farmageddon
81% matchMixed61% of 31 reviews2026
Dev: Obys Byte Games
Windows
A short, chaotic incremental game about growing your black hole as you chase panicked animals across levels with janky physics. Catch them, stack incremental upgrades, and dive into fast runs that always tempt ‘just one more’.
Why similar: Idler 28.8%, Incremental 23.7%, Casual 10.9%, Relaxing 7.5%, Arcade 6.8%
- #26 Digline
79% matchPositive87% of 15 reviews2026
Dev: IDH
Windows
Digline is a relaxing resource-gathering game where you play as a dwarf on a mission to restore a ruined settlement! Collect resources, manage your inventory, craft powerful tools, buy upgrades, and build structures to bring life back to the village!
Why similar: Idler 27.6%, Incremental 19.2%, Capitalism 13.1%, Relaxing 8.4%, Economy 6.9%
- #27 Monslice
78% match8 user reviews50% of 8 reviews2026
Dev: zowlf
Windows
Monslice is a short incremental game about slicing monsters, collecting resources, expanding your skill tree, and unlocking and buying more monsters!
Why similar: Idler 29%, Incremental 25.6%, Casual 9.2%, Economy 8.8%, Arcade 6.8%
- #28 Galaxy Cadet
78% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2026
Dev: Morrowglass Games
Windows
Sci-fi action incremental where you land on dangerous planets, hunt alien creatures, mine rare ores, and extract what you can before supplies run out. Sell your haul, upgrade your gear, and come back stronger in a constant loop of risk, profit, and growth.
Why similar: Idler 26.2%, Incremental 15.5%, Casual 11.9%, Arcade 10.6%, Management 9.1%
- #29 Don't Miss The Button
77% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Aroktyoe
Windows · Mac · Linux
Don't Miss The Button is a fast-paced clicker game where every click counts. Earn money, upgrade your stats, boost hit chance and combos, and watch the numbers grow. Each run resets, but Steam achievements track your progress. Simple, relaxing, and perfect for short sessions.
Why similar: Idler 31.1%, Incremental 25.7%, Casual 13.8%, Arcade 13.6%, Relaxing 6.1%
- #30 Lux Anima
75% matchPositive91% of 22 reviews2026
Dev: Chillfox Games
Windows
A relaxing incremental tower defense where your defenses are flowers. Defeat incoming spirits, grow your garden, collect essence, unlock upgrades, and protect the Sacred Core.
Why similar: Idler 31.5%, Incremental 28.9%, Arcade 11.4%, Casual 10.3%, Relaxing 8.8%
- #31 PETRIVORE
76% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Tiny Badger
Windows
An incremental game that grow a speck into a huge, mutant beast. Pop food in a petri dish, feed your pet, and choose mutations that visibly changes its body. Each play is an evolution into a different pet.
Why similar: Incremental 27.6%, Idler 26.4%, Casual 10.6%, Relaxing 10.4%, Arcade 6.9%
- #32 Particle Collectotron
76% matchNo user reviews2027
Dev: Miorama Games
Windows
Click and collect energy in this short, active incremental. Upgrade your reactor, tune injector payload and trajectories, unlock exotic matter, and push the experiment past its limits.
Why similar: Idler 28.3%, Incremental 23.6%, Arcade 8.9%, Casual 8.2%, Relaxing 7.2%
- #33 Click and Conquer
77% matchVery Positive93% of 2,495 reviews2025
Dev: SOCKHOUSE STUDIOS
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 2.4 hrsMean: 3.9 hrs≥1hr: 91%
Click and Conquer is a short, relaxing incremental game. Drop bombs through the fog of war, uncover hidden enemies, collect rewards, and spend currency to boost passive income, increase bombing power, and unlock new maps.
Why similar: Incremental 28.2%, Idler 25.3%, Minimalist 8%, Economy 8%, Arcade 7.7%
- #34 Compactor Baron
75% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: PiqFocus Interactive
Windows
You're broke and the bills keep coming. Smash scrap into cubes, sell them, pay up. A short active incremental: aim, let the hammer swing, upgrade your tools, go bankrupt on purpose, and build a scrapyard that pays for itself.
Why similar: Idler 30.8%, Incremental 20.9%, Capitalism 15.3%, Arcade 7.2%, Management 6.3%
- #35 One More Core
74% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Indie Souls Studio
Windows · Mac
One More Core is a 3D incremental game where you carve through planets layer by layer with your flagship, gather resources, upgrade your fleet, and keep advancing until you capture the planet's core. Don't forget to refuel… there's one more core to go!
Why similar: Idler 32.2%, Incremental 28%, Arcade 11.1%, Relaxing 9.4%, Casual 7.3%
- #36 OREBELT
74% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: balayaPub: The Bridge Brothers
Windows
Rocks roll in, you crack them open, coins pile up! OREBELT is a cozy idle miner where your little mine slowly grows into a mega factory, from coal and iron to blood diamonds, jade and more.
Why similar: Idler 37.1%, Incremental 24.4%, Capitalism 15.6%, Casual 10.1%, Economy 8.4%
- #37 Pop the Corn: Kernel Clicker
79% match3 user reviews67% of 3 reviews2024
Dev: Jolly Dumpling
Windows
🍿Addictive Popcorn clicker! 🍿A game that makes you feel good. Drop, Pop, and watch your wealth rise, while listening to an assortment of Cool Jazz. Unlock lots of achievements, new Pans, Skies and Upgrades. Try not to get addicted to Golden Popcorn! How much can you Pop?
Why similar: Incremental 38.1%, Idler 24.7%, Casual 10%, Relaxing 9.2%, 3D 7.1%
- #38 Click Click Chicken
73% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: GreenSquid Studios
Windows · Linux
A short incremental game about catching chickens, pigs, cows and sheep.
Why similar: Incremental 27.6%, Idler 24.5%, Casual 13.2%, Relaxing 11.6%, Arcade 6.8%
- #39 Kern
73% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Pollapee
Windows · Mac
It's a tower defence game with a skill tree. Play as the pilot that crash the spaceship in the unknown white space. Defend the spaceship from a horde of enemies through multiple stages while fixing the ship to escape from this place.
Why similar: Idler 38.8%, Incremental 26.3%, Arcade 12.1%, Casual 7.8%, Relaxing 7.7%
- #40 AutoShowRoom
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: haiooohai
Windows
AutoShowRoom is a small relaxing incremental game about managing your own car showroom! Collect +100 unique cars from 10 different countries! Tune them to perfection and showcase them in thrilling events! Unlock new models and expand your collection! Build the ulitimate car showroom!
Why similar: Idler 31.1%, Incremental 21.2%, Capitalism 9.7%, Economy 8.4%, Casual 7.8%
- #41 Dice Breakers
72% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Ferni
Windows
Dice Breakers is an incremental game where you break dice, earn rewards, unlock upgrades and automate your destruction empire in this addictive clicker with prestige progression.
Why similar: Idler 36.6%, Incremental 24.5%, Arcade 11.2%, Casual 7.6%, Relaxing 6.9%
- #42 Orbosis Gloriosis
71% match6 user reviews67% of 6 reviews2026
Dev: russpuppy
Windows · Mac
A physics-based incremental game where you split and merge orbs
Why similar: Incremental 25.8%, Idler 22.4%, Casual 12.5%, Relaxing 10.8%, Arcade 10%
- #43 A Game About Making Numbers Go Up
71% match4 user reviews100% of 4 reviews2026
Dev: Bob Cat Games
Windows
A Game About Making Numbers Go Up? It's Exactly That! Click, hover or idle through this short incremental as you make those numbers go up!
Why similar: Idler 28.5%, Incremental 23.4%, Casual 12.3%, Relaxing 11.3%, Economy 11.1%
- #44 Only Mining - Cozy Digging Game
72% matchMostly Positive76% of 37 reviews2026
Dev: Musa GUNGOR
Windows
Only Mining is a mining and crafting game. In this world, you can mine endlessly and craft armor of various levels. Relax and enjoy the journey as you progress from a very slow miner to a super-fast miner.
Why similar: Idler 27.6%, Incremental 22.4%, Capitalism 12.7%, Casual 10.6%, Relaxing 8.8%
- #45 Arcanatica
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: SUDT Games
Windows
Arcanatica is an incremental game where progress isn’t the main focus, because there isn’t any as such. You must figure out for yourself what happens if you don’t make progress—how long will it take before you give up? Or will progress eventually come, and what will it look like?
Why similar: Idler 22.5%, Incremental 13.1%, Capitalism 11.3%, Arcade 9.7%, Economy 8.6%
- #46 Deep Sea Fish: Hidden World
70% matchMostly Positive74% of 53 reviews2026
Dev: Althea Games
Windows · Mac
A short incremental fishing game where you catch fish, earn gold, and unlock powerful upgrades to explore the deep sea.
Why similar: Idler 25%, Incremental 22.5%, Arcade 11.5%, Casual 11.4%, Capitalism 9.2%
- #47 Peg Cascade
70% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2026
Dev: Starfuel InteractivePub: NineTwo Creations
Windows
Peg Cascade is a neon arcade-idle game of bouncing balls, rising scores, timed clears, prestige runs, and shareable Custom Boards you can build, export, import, and challenge friends to beat.
Why similar: Idler 33.4%, Incremental 29%, Arcade 11.5%, Relaxing 8.9%, Casual 8.7%
- #48 Coin Jar
70% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Justin Allen
Windows · Mac
A physics-based incremental game where you drop coins into a jar and merge them to earn money. Use that money to upgrade your coins and manage ventures that passively earn money and unlock new things to do.
Why similar: Idler 30.6%, Incremental 25.5%, Relaxing 9.8%, Minimalist 8.1%, Capitalism 6.9%
- #49 Pickochet
69% matchMixed69% of 45 reviews2026
Dev: kronPub: Midware Games
Windows
Pickochet is a short, incremental mining game where you mine ore using bouncy ricocheting pickaxes, purchase upgrades, unlock abilities and discover new mining sites.
Why similar: Idler 28.2%, Incremental 20%, Arcade 11.2%, Casual 10.4%, Capitalism 10.1%
- #50 Every Last Bit
69% matchNo user reviews
Dev: QubitGames
Windows · Mac
An incremental arcade game about scanning files by collecting bits, bytes and Gigabytes. Can you collect Every Last Bit?
Why similar: Idler 44.1%, Incremental 30.6%, Casual 8.9%, Arcade 8.5%, Relaxing 5.5%
- #51 PEGGO!
80% matchMixed66% of 105 reviews2021
Dev: Tyler HudsonPub: Tylario
Windows
Become a PEGGO! Quintillionaire in this exciting pachinko incremental game.
Why similar: Idler 31%, Incremental 26.5%, Arcade 10.1%, Casual 9.6%, Relaxing 6.2%
- #52 Snack Smasher
67% matchNo user reviews91% of 11 reviews2026
Dev: Ardblade
Windows
An incremental game all about smashing fruits and snacks! Upgrade your smasher, unlock new power-ups, and enjoy the pleasure of smashing everything in your path!
Why similar: Idler 32.7%, Incremental 26.8%, Arcade 11.2%, Relaxing 8.6%, Casual 7.3%
- #53 Mining Away!
68% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Tiny Knight Games
Windows
Mining Away! is a short incremental game in which you mine ores, collect resources, progress through the vast skill tree, find rare relics, and unlock powerful pickaxes!
Why similar: Idler 26.5%, Incremental 24%, Casual 9.2%, Relaxing 7.9%, Economy 7.3%
- #54 Decrypting Life
68% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Lazarus
Windows
Decrypting Life is a short, nostalgic incremental game where you restore corrupted files to uncover a story from the 2000s
Why similar: Idler 33.7%, Incremental 26.8%, Casual 9.2%, Minimalist 6.5%, Relaxing 6.3%
- #55 Nova Fleet
67% match4 user reviews75% of 4 reviews2026
Dev: Limitless
Windows
A short incremental space game about building and expanding a mining fleet. Destroy asteroids, collect resources, and upgrade your ships to mine faster and extract more with every run.
Why similar: Idler 31.4%, Incremental 25.6%, Casual 12.3%, Arcade 8.4%, Minimalist 7.8%
- #56 A Game About Feeding A Black Hole
67% matchVery Positive88% of 3,544 reviews2025
Dev: AarimousPub: Aarimous and Thornity
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 3.8 hrsMean: 4.5 hrs≥1hr: 93%
A short incremental game about feeding a Black Hole matter by destroying Asteroids, Planets, and Stars.
Why similar: Incremental 37.8%, Idler 20.9%, Relaxing 8.7%, Casual 7.3%, Minimalist 5.9%
- #57 Pibcremental
64% matchVery Positive86% of 364 reviews2026
Dev: Arcane CabinetPub: GrabTheGames
Windows
Median: 5.5 hrsMean: 8.2 hrs≥1hr: 85%
A cozy, chaotic idle-incremental clicker about growing a civilisation of tiny creatures called Pibbles in a giant tree, set in a post-human world.
Why similar: Idler 31.8%, Incremental 22.9%, Economy 8.8%, Casual 6.7%, Colorful 5.1%
- #58 Dunk Cookies
68% match6 user reviews17% of 6 reviews2026
Dev: MGR Studio
Windows
Break cookies. Dunk them in milk. Repeat. A satisfying incremental game where you crush cookies into a swirling vortex of milk. Upgrade your breaking power, unlock new stats via an expansive skill tree, and discover the ultimate satisfaction of the perfect dunk.
Why similar: Idler 28.2%, Incremental 22.5%, Economy 11.7%, Arcade 9.5%, Relaxing 8%
- #59 Shelldiver
66% matchOverwhelmingly Positive99% of 18,200 reviews2025
Dev: Gagonfe
Windows
Median: 3.9 hrsMean: 4.2 hrs≥1hr: 90%
Take a deep breath and dive right into this cozy incremental game about a senior turtle trying to start a business selling jellyfish. Upgrade your equipment, explore biomes, and help your turtly village!
Why similar: Incremental 33.7%, Idler 23.2%, Arcade 8.7%, Relaxing 7.8%, Casual 6.8%
- #60 Slime Reaper
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Ruben Arranz
Windows
Click to kill slimes and gain gold. Then hire adventurers to kill more slimes. Unlock new slime tiers, upgrade your clicks, adventurers and unlock abilities to kill even more slimes. And then prestige to unlock special upgrades!
Why similar: Idler 37.6%, Incremental 25.2%, Casual 10.5%, Relaxing 9.1%, Management 6.2%