Nodal

Games Like Idle: Generators

60+ similar titles based on shared tags and player behavior. Themes include Idler, Incremental, Management, Simulation.

Similar Games

View all 60 recommendations
  1. #1 Idle Ultimate
    97% matchMostly Negative27% of 14 reviews2023
    Dev: PELMENI GAMES
    Windows

    An idle game with endless features and possibilities. Generators, multipliers, prestige system, bets, investments, converters and many more features are waiting for you!

    Why similar: Idler 13.5%, Incremental 12.1%, Economy 11.4%, Management 8.5%, Sandbox 8.2%

  2. #2 Idle: Multipliers
    96% matchMixed52% of 21 reviews2023
    Dev: PELMENI GAMES
    Windows

    An IDLE game for your fun and relaxation. Multipliers based prestige system and various gameplay possibilities

    Why similar: Idler 14.8%, Incremental 13.2%, Sandbox 9.4%, Management 9.2%, Real Time Tactics 7.8%

  3. #3 Simple Multipliers
    96% matchMostly Negative31% of 16 reviews2023
    Dev: PELMENI GAMES
    Windows

    Unique idle game with endless gameplay mechanics. Hardcore goals but fair possibilities to reach them. Use the power of multipliers, create the most powerful income generators and be the best among all players!

    Why similar: Idler 16.5%, Incremental 14.6%, Sandbox 10.7%, Real Time Tactics 9%, Minimalist 6.7%

  4. #4 Idle Percent
    95% match7 user reviews29% of 7 reviews2023
    Dev: Pixel Fox
    Windows

    Every upgrade in this game is a percent which is added to the upgradable value. Your progression is slow at the beginning but with time your income will become higher and higher! Buy prestige and super prestige upgrades to maximize your profit!

    Why similar: Idler 14.2%, Incremental 12.7%, Sandbox 9.4%, Minimalist 8.8%, Economy 8.4%

  5. #5 Ten Seconds Trillion
    94% matchMostly Positive76% of 37 reviews2023
    Dev: PELMENI GAMES
    Windows

    Ten Seconds Trillion is a unique clicker game with simple goals but addictive gameplay. Can you reach one trillion value just by clicking and buying upgrades?

    Why similar: Idler 15.1%, Incremental 14.3%, Economy 11.4%, Sandbox 10.1%, Management 9.5%

  6. #6 Click Click Click
    94% matchMostly Negative32% of 25 reviews2023
    Dev: Pixel Fox
    Windows

    The most simple idle clicker game. Are you able to reach the one octillion value? Buy upgrades and use prestige system to achieve the goal! Fun and relaxation are included

    Why similar: Idler 16.1%, Incremental 15.2%, Sandbox 10.2%, Management 10.1%, Minimalist 7%

  7. #7 Idle Blocks
    93% match8 user reviews38% of 8 reviews2023
    Dev: Pixel Fox
    Windows

    Idle clicker game with simple but really addictive gameplay. Destroy endless blocks and proceed as far as you can. Complex prestige system and upgrades with endless possibilities and pure fun

    Why similar: Idler 14.4%, Incremental 13%, Economy 10.6%, Sandbox 9.6%, Management 6.9%

  8. #8 +1%
    92% match4 user reviews50% of 4 reviews2024
    Dev: IdleClick Games
    Windows

    Idle clicker game with a percentage based math inside. Compound percent is used for all calculations. Slow start, exponential growth and lots of fun!

    Why similar: Idler 16.1%, Incremental 15.2%, Economy 13.8%, Management 10.3%, Minimalist 9.8%

  9. #9 +1x2
    91% match9 user reviews78% of 9 reviews2024
    Dev: roflinka games
    Windows

    A super simple clicker game with finite goal and few hours of fun. Will you be able to complete it in time to make a refund?

    Why similar: Idler 16.9%, Incremental 15.9%, Economy 12.7%, Management 10.5%, Text-Based 8.2%

  10. #10 Idle Tick
    91% match8 user reviews50% of 8 reviews2023
    Dev: Pixel Fox
    Windows

    An idle game with unique gameplay. No boring idleness and infinite clicking. Complex prestige system and various upgrades. Different currencies and deep management. Infinite possibilities and fun!

    Why similar: Idler 15.4%, Incremental 13.8%, Economy 12.7%, Sandbox 10.2%, Management 9.5%

  11. #11 [MULTIPLIERS]
    89% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2026
    Dev: My Little Games
    Windows

    An exponential idle clicker game with 2,000+ upgrades and infinite fun. Multipliers, prestige, perks and many more features!

    Why similar: Idler 21.5%, Incremental 18.3%, Management 12%, Economy 10.9%, Sandbox 8%

  12. #12 The Very Idle Game
    90% match4 user reviews75% of 4 reviews2024
    Dev: roflinka games
    Windows

    The most satisfying idle clicker game in the world

    Why similar: Idler 17.2%, Incremental 15.3%, Economy 11.4%, Sandbox 11.2%, Management 10.1%

  13. #13 [RANDOM]
    88% match1 user reviews0% of 1 reviews2026
    Dev: My Little Games
    Windows

    An idle clicker game with random values and 2,000+ upgrades. Random upgrades, prestige, perks and many more features!

    Why similar: Idler 19.6%, Incremental 16.4%, Economy 11.8%, Management 10.7%, Sandbox 8.7%

  14. #14 Idle Game x100
    89% matchMostly Negative30% of 27 reviews2022
    Dev: PaulArt
    Windows

    Idle game for those who tired of boring and infinite idle games

    Why similar: Idler 15.7%, Incremental 14%, Sandbox 10.3%, Real Time Tactics 9.7%, Management 9.3%

  15. #15 Idle Rect
    86% match3 user reviews0% of 3 reviews2025
    Dev: Lazy Idle Games
    Windows

    Complex idle clicker game with infinite possibilities. Prestige, evolving, limits breaking, perks, bosses, income options, ranking and many more features are available!

    Why similar: Idler 20.5%, Incremental 17%, Sandbox 11.3%, Management 10.2%, Economy 9.8%

  16. #16 Idle Shapes
    87% matchPositive82% of 22 reviews2022
    Dev: PaulArt
    Windows

    Idle game with simple mechanics and addictive gameplay. Buy upgrades and use prestige system to reach the final goal. Every upgrade matters, every prestige purchase is important. No endless goals and infinite boring gameplay. Just pure fun and reachable goals.

    Why similar: Idler 15.7%, Incremental 14.2%, Sandbox 10.4%, Real Time Tactics 8.8%, Management 6.9%

  17. #17 Idle Tiers
    85% match7 user reviews14% of 7 reviews2024
    Dev: IdleClick Games
    Windows

    A real idle game with more than 2000 upgrades and deep management

    Why similar: Idler 17.2%, Incremental 15.4%, Economy 13.3%, Sandbox 11.3%, Management 9%

  18. #18 Idle Income
    83% match9 user reviews44% of 9 reviews2026
    Dev: Trinket Games
    Windows

    400+ upgrades, prestige system, passive mining, unlockable currencies, perks, auto buyers, difficulty tiers and many more features - it's IDLE INCOME!

    Why similar: Idler 18.7%, Incremental 16.4%, Sandbox 12%, Management 10.8%, Economy 9.2%

  19. #19 The Googol Clicker
    86% matchMixed41% of 27 reviews2022
    Dev: PaulArt
    Windows

    Could you reach the googol value which is 1e100? Idle clicker game with simple goals but very addictive gameplay!

    Why similar: Idler 16.9%, Incremental 15.1%, Minimalist 10.5%, Sandbox 9.7%, Management 8.4%

  20. #20 Idle Colors
    82% matchMostly Negative30% of 10 reviews2025
    Dev: Like Idle Games
    Windows

    Strategize with 8 unique currencies, each with upgradable production chains. Master triple prestige systems, evolve your economy, upgrade generators tiers, optimize through conversion, and dominate leaderboards in this deep idle experience.

    Why similar: Idler 16.9%, Incremental 15.1%, Economy 12.8%, Sandbox 10.1%, Management 10.1%

  21. #21 Simple Increment
    84% matchMostly Positive79% of 14 reviews2023
    Dev: PELMENI GAMES
    Windows

    Simple but addictive idle clicker game for those who just wants to relax and have some fun.

    Why similar: Idler 17.5%, Incremental 16.4%, Management 11.2%, Sandbox 10.1%, Economy 9.4%

  22. #22 Progress Bar Deluxe
    81% matchPositive89% of 47 reviews2025
    Dev: Diego Schram Games
    Windows

    Loading, loading, loading… when will it ever be ready? Will you finally see the bar reach 100%? In Progress Bar Deluxe, your mission is simple — fill the ultimate progress bar to 100%! Click, upgrade, and wait as you chase that sweet moment of completion.

    Why similar: Idler 21%, Incremental 20.6%, Economy 18.1%, Management 12.3%, Minimalist 8.7%

  23. #23 Smashing Bottles
    81% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Blue Makes Games
    Windows

    Smashing Bottles is a short and satisfying incremental game where you break bottles to earn money, upgrade your bat, discover new bottles, and cause chaos! Will you smash enough bottles to buy the universe?

    Why similar: Incremental 22.7%, Idler 22.1%, Economy 18.6%, Management 12.8%, Minimalist 6.7%

  24. #24 Loot Loop
    79% matchVery Positive92% of 797 reviews2026
    Dev: BitBrew
    Windows
    Median: 2.8 hrsMean: 3.4 hrs≥1hr: 94%

    Build a party of heroes and send them into dungeons in this short incremental RPG. Fight monsters, collect loot, and unlock upgrades. Fast runs, deep skill tree, zero stress.

    Why similar: Incremental 26%, Idler 23%, Management 13.7%, Minimalist 9.9%, Economy 7.7%

  25. #25 The Billion Clicker
    84% matchMostly Positive72% of 65 reviews2022
    Dev: PaulArt
    Windows

    Could you reach the billion? Idle clicker game with simple goals but very addictive gameplay

    Why similar: Idler 16%, Incremental 14.9%, Sandbox 10.3%, Real Time Tactics 10.1%, Turn-Based Tactics 8.7%

  26. #26 Dunk Cookies
    80% match5 user reviews20% of 5 reviews2026
    Dev: MGR Studio
    Windows

    Break cookies. Dunk them in milk. Repeat. A satisfying incremental game where you crush cookies into a swirling vortex of milk. Upgrade your breaking power, unlock new stats via an expansive skill tree, and discover the ultimate satisfaction of the perfect dunk.

    Why similar: Idler 22.5%, Incremental 21.6%, Economy 19.7%, Management 13.9%, Strategy 5.2%

  27. #27 The Idle
    82% matchMostly Negative31% of 13 reviews2024
    Dev: iclick games
    Windows

    The ultimate idle clicker game with endless possibilities and infinite fun. Passive and active income, seven currencies, interest, bets, prestige, perks and many more features are available!

    Why similar: Idler 16.9%, Incremental 15.1%, Economy 13.3%, Sandbox 11.1%, Management 10.4%

  28. #28 AutoShowRoom
    78% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: haiooohai
    Windows

    AutoShowRoom is a small relaxing incremental game about managing your own car showroom! Collect +100 unique cars from 10 different countries! Tune them to perfection and showcase them in thrilling events! Unlock new models and expand your collection! Build the ulitimate car showroom!

    Why similar: Idler 25.6%, Incremental 20.9%, Economy 14.4%, Management 13.2%, Strategy 8.2%

  29. #29 Pibcremental
    78% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Arcane Cabinet
    Windows

    A cozy, chaotic idle-incremental clicker about growing a civilisation of tiny creatures called Pibbles in a giant tree, set in a post-human world. Gather resources, build wacky structures and play mini-games to push your production to its absolute limits!

    Why similar: Idler 25.1%, Incremental 21.7%, Economy 15.4%, Management 9.8%, Simulation 7.6%

  30. #30 Click Flip
    77% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: Post Jaded Games
    Windows

    Click Flip is a short incremental game about clicking tiles, earning points, buying upgrades, and causing crazy tile combos.

    Why similar: Incremental 24.1%, Idler 23.1%, Economy 19.5%, Management 13.4%, Strategy 5.6%

  31. #31 Idle Worlds
    79% matchMixed40% of 10 reviews2023
    Dev: Pixel Fox
    Windows

    An idle game with unique gameplay features. Travel between 8 different worlds and upgrade local generators to increase your profit. Use unique upgrades system to boost your stats or discover even more interesting prestige system to maximize your profit.

    Why similar: Idler 17.7%, Incremental 15.9%, Sandbox 11.5%, Economy 8.8%, Minimalist 7.1%

  32. #32 Upgrade It
    76% match6 user reviews33% of 6 reviews2025
    Dev: Tip Top Games
    Windows

    An idle game with 99 generators and a deep prestige system. Unlock 1000+ upgrades, automate progress, and complete all challenges. A full release, ready to play!

    Why similar: Idler 23.1%, Incremental 17%, Sandbox 13.5%, Economy 12.8%, Management 11.4%

  33. #33 Goal Idle
    75% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Royue Games
    Windows

    Goal Idle is a relaxing incremental game focused on scoring goals and earning money. Click to shoot balls into the goal, upgrade to better balls, unlock powerful skills, and hire Helpers that auto-score goals. Start with rubber balls and work your way up to golden balls. Satisfying and addictive.

    Why similar: Idler 28.2%, Incremental 23.6%, Minimalist 16.1%, Economy 14.5%, Management 7.5%

  34. #34 Click and Conquer
    73% matchVery Positive93% of 1,988 reviews2025
    Dev: SOCKHOUSE STUDIOS
    Windows · Mac · Linux
    Median: 2.5 hrsMean: 3.9 hrs≥1hr: 93%

    Click and Conquer is a short, relaxing incremental game. Drop bombs through the fog of war, uncover hidden enemies, collect rewards, and spend currency to boost passive income, increase bombing power, and unlock new maps.

    Why similar: Incremental 28.7%, Idler 22.1%, Economy 14.7%, Minimalist 12.3%, Pixel Graphics 6.8%

  35. #35 Idle Cosmos Clicker
    75% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Beyo Games
    Windows

    Idle Cosmos Clicker is a space-themed idle simulation where you grow the universe from asteroids to black holes. Produce, automate, and evolve resources while unlocking planets, stars, and galaxies. A relaxing yet deep incremental experience with endless progression.

    Why similar: Idler 25.1%, Incremental 24.9%, Economy 20%, Management 11.9%, Pixel Graphics 7.5%

  36. #36 Weapon Shop Decillionaire
    77% match7 user reviews86% of 7 reviews2023
    Dev: PERENNIAL HEARTS LLC.
    Windows

    Weapon Shop Decillionaire is an idle game where weapons turn your dreams of wealth into reality. Build and sell equipment, use the profit to enhance it, while mastering strategic weapon placement on your shop's grid. It's time to become a decillionaire, one sword at a time!

    Why similar: Idler 30.5%, Incremental 25.9%, Economy 8.9%, Management 8.5%, Pixel Graphics 8.4%

  37. #37 Monster Flipper
    74% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: NovaScreen
    Windows

    Monster Flipper is a short incremental game where you buy and level monsters, smash them with a giant hammer for gold, and unlock swords and artifacts to automate your progress.

    Why similar: Idler 26.6%, Incremental 21.6%, Economy 18.4%, Management 14.4%, Strategy 7%

  38. #38 Holding Pattern
    72% matchPositive96% of 24 reviews2026
    Dev: Orange Acorn Games
    Windows · Mac

    Holding Pattern is a minimal incremental game about protecting your galaxy from invaders. Defeat enemies, collect cash and purchase powerful moons and abilities! What crazy builds will you discover? Play either incremental or roguelike modes to put your skills to the test!

    Why similar: Incremental 21.8%, Economy 19.6%, Minimalist 16.1%, Idler 15.6%, Management 9.6%

  39. #39 It Takes One Year To Beat This Game
    74% match5 user reviews20% of 5 reviews2025
    Dev: Haha Games
    Windows

    Make one billion clicks and spend years to beat the game or show who is a really pro gamer here

    Why similar: Idler 18.3%, Incremental 17%, Sandbox 12.4%, Minimalist 10.4%, Management 10.1%

  40. #40 Chip Away
    73% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: Domeldor
    Windows

    A roulette game with roguelike progression. Bet, unlock upgrades and face a roulette that changes every run with random modifiers. How much can you earn?

    Why similar: Idler 23%, Incremental 21.9%, Economy 19.7%, Management 13.8%, Strategy 6.2%

  41. #41 Mining and Dwarves
    73% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: Sockhouse Studios
    Windows · Mac · Linux

    An incremental game where you mine rocks, gather ore, and recruit dwarves. Play actively for maximum gains, or idle and let the dwarves do the work.

    Why similar: Incremental 23.2%, Idler 22.6%, Economy 14%, Management 12.1%, Strategy 8.2%

  42. #42 Asciinsion
    72% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: omnipolar studio
    Windows · Mac · Linux

    Immerse yourself in the world of ASCII art. Create works of art from characters. Build factories, upgrade them, and expand your production capacity. Invest in blueprints and reach milestones to earn bonuses. Use the ascension system for additional benefits.

    Why similar: Idler 25.6%, Incremental 25.4%, Minimalist 12.7%, Economy 12.4%, Management 10.9%

  43. #43 EraClicker
    71% matchMixed69% of 13 reviews2025
    Dev: Reard Studio
    Windows

    Incremental game where you travel through time, starting in the Paleolithic and advancing through different eras!

    Why similar: Incremental 29.1%, Idler 28.1%, Economy 15.6%, Management 12.2%, Pixel Graphics 7.2%

  44. #44 CompactO - Idle Game
    76% matchMostly Positive70% of 81 reviews2021
    Dev: Considera Games LLCPub: Considera Core LLC
    Windows

    CompactO is an addicting idle game where you create colorful squares on a plane. Dominate the 3D Realm and infuse your planes into complex shapes to buy tons of upgrades!

    Why similar: Idler 23.6%, Incremental 19.2%, Economy 14%, Management 12.4%, Text-Based 8.1%

  45. #45 Clownless
    71% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: ShotDash
    Windows

    Rebuild the Carnival Planet by growing a tiny circus into an intergalactic spectacle. Hire bizarre performers and generate absurd amounts of Happiness and cosmic wealth.

    Why similar: Idler 27.9%, Incremental 22.7%, Economy 20.7%, Management 14.1%, Simulation 6.2%

  46. #46 Kittens Game
    69% matchVery Positive96% of 51 reviews2026
    Dev: Nuclear Unicorn
    Windows · Linux

    Kittens Game is game where you manage a village of kittens as they acquire resources and unlock new technologies. Build the ultimate civilization and bring them to the space!

    Why similar: Economy 22.5%, Idler 21.7%, Text-Based 14.4%, Incremental 13.9%, Minimalist 13%

  47. #47 Capybara Achievement Clicker
    71% matchPositive100% of 15 reviews2025
    Dev: JosephPub: WeirdCanyon
    Windows

    Capybara Achievement Clicker is a simple incremental and idle game. It features over a hundred easy-to-acquire achievements and a Capybara to click on.

    Why similar: Idler 24.2%, Incremental 21.4%, Sandbox 15.7%, Management 14.5%, Strategy 5.8%

  48. #48 Simultree
    68% matchVery Positive86% of 118 reviews2026
    Dev: PIPAPOUPub: Coduck Studio
    Windows

    Simultree is a short incremental game about monitoring life simulations. You're a scientist who runs life simulations in order to gain points to spend in a big skill tree.

    Why similar: Idler 21.4%, Incremental 20.2%, Economy 14.5%, Management 13.4%, Minimalist 10%

  49. #49 Fireworks Incremental
    70% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: Frajda Games
    Windows

    Launch fireworks, cause explosions and watch the sky light up. Hire new units, unlock buildings and automate your fireworks empire. Watch as the fireworks spectacle grows and the Booms number goes up in this addictive incremental game!

    Why similar: Idler 22.3%, Incremental 19.3%, Economy 17.1%, Management 11.6%, Minimalist 9.1%

  50. #50 More Sushi!
    68% matchVery Positive90% of 155 reviews2025
    Dev: pixelqube
    Windows

    More Sushi! is a short incremental game about running a conveyor belt sushi restaurant. Serve customers, buy upgrades, hire helpers, and unlock new sushi! Pay off the owner's debt, then turn used plates into stars to buy permanent upgrades.

    Why similar: Idler 23.4%, Incremental 23%, Economy 20.1%, Management 14.1%, Minimalist 6.8%

  51. #51 Marble Idle Collectionist
    70% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Mupet
    Windows

    A relaxing incremental game focused on sensorial joy of marbles, soothing sound design, and visually calming simulation. Upgrade systems, earn more marbles, and enjoy collecting all kinds of shiny trinkets.

    Why similar: Idler 28.3%, Incremental 24%, Economy 14.4%, Minimalist 12.3%, Management 9.7%

  52. #52 Click Build Repeat
    69% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: Don Pachi
    Windows

    Click Build Repeat is an incremental game about building and collecting model kits.

    Why similar: Incremental 28.4%, Idler 27.3%, Economy 19.4%, Management 15.4%, Relaxing 5.4%

  53. #53 H.A.M. – Hamster Automated Mining
    68% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: BadElephant Studio
    Windows

    An idle clicker-management hybrid: Exploit your hamsters (yes, humanely, of course) to mine Bitecoins for you. But watch out — they have needs. SO send them to the spa or get some burgers at the inbuild diner and don’t let them unionize!

    Why similar: Idler 34.2%, Incremental 27%, Economy 20.1%, Management 17.8%, 2D 0.9%

  54. #54 Number Factory
    67% matchMixed45% of 47 reviews2025
    Dev: Alerot
    Windows

    Build the ultimate number production empire! Automate generators, unlock powerful upgrades, and prestige for permanent bonuses. Compete on global leaderboards and watch your numbers grow to infinity in this addictive idle incremental game.

    Why similar: Idler 29.7%, Minimalist 15.4%, Incremental 13.8%, Text-Based 10.8%, Economy 7.2%

  55. #55 Now With More Plunk
    67% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: 8-Bit Curls
    Windows

    A Plinko-like incremental where your coins strum harps, hit drums, and eventually create their own master orchestra. Go Plunk it up!

    Why similar: Incremental 28.7%, Idler 27.5%, Minimalist 10.6%, Economy 9.5%, Management 9.4%

  56. #56 (the) Gnorp Apologue
    67% matchOverwhelmingly Positive95% of 9,673 reviews2023
    Dev: MycoPub: (Myco)
    Windows
    Median: 15.5 hrsMean: 27.8 hrs≥1hr: 96%

    (the) Gnorp Apologue is the journey of the gnorps as you guide them towards their goal of delightfully excessive wealth accumulation.

    Why similar: Incremental 33.7%, Idler 22.5%, Economy 15%, Management 10.5%, Minimalist 6.3%

  57. #57 Flippant
    64% matchVery Positive97% of 64 reviews2026
    Dev: vomithog
    Windows

    An abstract incremental game about flipping a coin and maybe some other things too

    Why similar: Incremental 26.6%, Idler 25.3%, Management 11.6%, Simulation 9.7%, Strategy 8.9%

  58. #58 Piñata Go Boom
    65% matchVery Positive92% of 612 reviews2025
    Dev: tissue inu
    Windows · Linux
    Median: 5.1 hrsMean: 5.5 hrs≥1hr: 90%

    A small incremental game about smashing piñatas, collecting toys, and climbing the corporate ladder as you unlock a vast upgrade tree.

    Why similar: Incremental 24.7%, Idler 18.1%, Economy 12.9%, Management 12.6%, Minimalist 9.5%

  59. #59 Monslice
    66% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: zowlf
    Windows

    Monslice is a short incremental game about slicing monsters, collecting resources, expanding your skill tree, and unlocking and buying more monsters!

    Why similar: Incremental 28%, Idler 26.8%, Economy 16.8%, Management 11.6%, Minimalist 5.9%

  60. #60 Totally NOT a Game
    66% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Dreampunch
    Windows · Mac · Linux

    A corporate spreadsheet idle game where you climb the ladder from Intern to C-Suite by generating KPIs, automating busywork, and satisfying a Board that demands exponential results. Totally NOT a Game.

    Why similar: Incremental 29.6%, Idler 28.1%, Economy 23.2%, Strategy 10.2%, Simulation 4.1%

Modeli
Based on tag similarity + player behavior
Loading graph...