Nodal

Games Like Idle Heroes Saga

60+ similar titles based on shared tags and player behavior. Themes include Idler, Singleplayer, Casual, 2D.

Similar Games

View all 58 recommendations
  1. #1 Heroic Wars
    97% matchNo user reviews2025
    Dev: LodisGame
    Windows

    "Heroic Wars" is an idle game about summoning heroes and battling enemies.

    Why similar: Idler 35%, Card Game 31.7%, Resource Management 10.6%, RPG 9.6%, Casual 6.6%

  2. #2 Idle Taoist Mage Warrior
    96% matchVery Positive84% of 137 reviews2023
    Dev: okyakusama
    Windows

    Are you familiar with the three major professions of warrior, mage, and Taoist. Simple placement gameplay.

    Why similar: Idler 40.3%, Card Game 24.1%, Resource Management 16.4%, RPG 15.1%, 2D 2.1%

  3. #3 Fourth Age: Idle RPG
    96% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Chengdu Chiyue Interactive Entertainment Co., Ltd.
    Windows

    Fourth Age is a fantasy-themed strategy placement card mobile game. As an adventurer, you will summon heroes of different races and occupations, and with their unique exclusive special skills, formulate brain-burning strategies and freely combine schools.

    Why similar: Idler 40.3%, Card Game 33.4%, RPG 22.4%, 2D 4%

  4. #4 CHIPSTACK
    95% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2026
    Dev: Slipgun Studios
    Windows

    A desktop idle casino that runs while you game, queue, browse, or work — earning chips every second. Auto-play blackjack, slots, roulette with your bets and strategies. Plus 3 quick-play games like Video Poker. Toggle card counting, equip powerful mods or play pure, and chase the highest chipstack!

    Why similar: Idler 40.5%, Card Game 33.2%, Casual 11.3%, Resource Management 10.2%, 2D 3.7%

  5. #5 Archmage Idle
    94% matchMixed61% of 103 reviews2026
    Dev: TopCog
    Windows · Mac · Linux

    An idle/incremental RPG where you're an Archmage of a wizard guild. Your skills bolster the frontlines and the supply lines. Every skill multiplies the others, and it all keeps running while you're away.

    Why similar: Idler 49.2%, Resource Management 20.7%, RPG 19.1%, Casual 9.8%, Singleplayer 1.2%

  6. #6 RPG Incremental Idle
    94% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: Inkrementalspel
    Windows · Mac · Linux

    An idle RPG: train 17 skills, master nine weapons, craft your own gear, unlock seven boss-guarded regions, and raise an Estate that works while you sleep — your progress keeps ticking even offline.

    Why similar: Idler 49.9%, RPG 19%, Resource Management 14.5%, Casual 9.8%, 2D 3%

  7. #7 Flowers to the Moon
    92% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Flowers to the Moon
    Windows

    A contemplative idle game set in a soft sci-fi world. Gather flowers around an abandoned spaceport reclaimed by nature, build small insect-inspired drones, and send your harvests to the Moon to watch it slowly bloom.

    Why similar: Idler 73.9%, Casual 16.6%, Indie 5.7%, Singleplayer 3.8%

  8. #8 Idle magic herb
    93% matchMostly Negative35% of 37 reviews2022
    Dev: okyakusama
    Windows

    This game is a hang up game that integrates elements such as cultivating immortals, farming, playing strange things, and collecting cards. Protect the liver and protect the liver.

    Why similar: Idler 48.2%, Card Game 29.9%, RPG 12.2%, Casual 7%, Indie 1.7%

  9. #9 Corner Cards
    91% match7 user reviews71% of 7 reviews2025
    Dev: Miles Lepine
    Windows

    Corner Cards is a relaxing corner-window idle card-collecting game where you open booster packs, complete card sets, and upgrade your booth to attract more customers and fans alike!

    Why similar: Idler 46.9%, Card Game 32.8%, Casual 13.5%, 2D 3.4%, Indie 1.7%

  10. #10 Auto Dungeon:Idle Adventure
    91% matchMostly Negative38% of 49 reviews2026
    Dev: Player
    Windows

    In AutoDungeon, craft your Build, defeat bosses, collect legendary gear, and experience deep interactions between skills, equipment, and talents. Explore 60+ dungeons, challenge legendary bosses. 400+ legendary items, 170+ skills, and gear crafting to build a dungeon-destroying hero.

    Why similar: Idler 79.3%, RPG 10.6%, 2D 5.7%, Singleplayer 2.4%, Indie 2%

  11. #11 Cindervale Idle
    90% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: Smolder Studios
    Windows

    A fantasy idle RPG that respects your time. Master 12 skills and combat, forge legendary gear, and battle through 12 cursed zones and 4 raids — from the Rat Warrens to the Demon Sanctum. Deep systems, passive skill trees, one-click progression, and embers that never die while you're away.

    Why similar: Idler 58.4%, RPG 22.9%, Casual 11.8%, Indie 4.3%, Singleplayer 2.7%

  12. #12 Catventure
    89% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: MissingCat
    Windows

    Catventure is a cozy and relaxing idle game that can sit at the bottom of your screen (or anywhere else), allowing you to enjoy a peaceful adventure during work or a busy day.

    Why similar: Idler 57%, RPG 18.5%, Casual 16.7%, 2D 5.6%, Singleplayer 2.2%

  13. #13 太饿了 So Hungry
    89% match2 user reviews0% of 2 reviews2024
    Dev: XIAOWUWEI
    Windows

    《So Hungry》is a casual idle game. Come and collect various animal and plant cards!

    Why similar: Idler 44.1%, Card Game 36.3%, Casual 12.6%, 2D 4%, Indie 1.5%

  14. #14 Bloobs Adventure Idle
    86% matchVery Positive90% of 661 reviews2026
    Dev: Bloobs_Dev
    Windows
    Median: 40.6 hrsMean: 341.4 hrs≥1hr: 84%

    A massive RuneScape-inspired idle RPG built for long-term progression. Train 24 skills, defeat bosses, collect over 500 souls, and bank offline time to accelerate your progress whenever you choose.

    Why similar: Idler 43.1%, RPG 21.7%, Resource Management 15.3%, Casual 11.7%, Indie 3.3%

  15. #15 Soulstack
    88% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: sshulin
    Windows

    Idle card RPG on a table. Drag cards onto each other to do literally everything. 200+ weapon recipes (only ~40 are worth keeping), 140 pet evolutions, 12 prestige classes. Yet still feels like a Jira and Trello child.

    Why similar: Idler 34.9%, Card Game 31.3%, Resource Management 14.1%, RPG 13.6%, Casual 4.5%

  16. #16 摸鱼修仙
    87% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: 摸鱼工作室
    Windows

    Mo Yu Xiu Xian is a relaxing idle cultivation game. Train offline, refine pills, explore dungeons, collect magic treasures, raise spirit pets, and climb the Heaven Tower. Simple mouse controls, cute chibi art style, beginner friendly. Become an immortal even while slacking off!

    Why similar: Idler 53.6%, RPG 23.3%, Casual 14.6%, 2D 4.9%, Singleplayer 1.8%

  17. #17 Clickstead
    86% matchNo user reviews86% of 7 reviews2026
    Dev: Zettik
    Windows

    A short incremental game about harvesting trees using elements like Fire and Lightning to your advantage. Build your skill tree and rise from Seed to legend.

    Why similar: Idler 59%, Resource Management 23%, Casual 12.3%, 2D 3.1%, Singleplayer 1.5%

  18. #18 All About Luck
    85% matchVery Positive94% of 175 reviews2026
    Dev: Flow Universe
    Windows

    All About Luck is a roguelike auto battler where luck is everything. Build your formation by gacha and test your fortune. No P2W, no grinding — just pulls, rolls, and fate. Crush the boss with god-tier pulls, then ask your friends: Still not cleared it?

    Why similar: Idler 42.6%, Card Game 34.6%, Resource Management 9.4%, Casual 6.1%, Indie 3.4%

  19. #19 鱼自会上钩 EffortlessCatch
    84% match7 user reviews57% of 7 reviews2025
    Dev: JLL
    Windows · Mac

    Cast once, reel in—simple as that.

    Why similar: Idler 37.4%, Card Game 33.7%, Casual 12.5%, Resource Management 12.1%, 2D 3.1%

  20. #20 Surprisingly Fine 2: Wind / Wave
    83% matchMostly Positive75% of 11 reviews2026
    Dev: RoRoKaii Works
    Windows · Linux

    RoRoKaii Works’ Debut: A cozy idle game focused on collecting. No complex strategies—just watch numbers grow as you hone 15 unique skills. With the Mastery System, collect any item 100 times to gain bonus EXP and fuel your journey toward perfection.

    Why similar: Idler 63%, RPG 17.6%, Casual 8.1%, 2D 6%, Singleplayer 2.8%

  21. #21 Ani Idle
    82% matchVery Positive87% of 75 reviews2025
    Dev: Ani Dev
    Windows

    Ani Idle is an Idle-like RPG in which you will have to fight a variety of enemies. Kill them, collect their loot, take a rest, do some quests and craft your gear to become more and more powerful.

    Why similar: Idler 58.9%, RPG 22.2%, Casual 10.8%, 2D 4.7%, Indie 1.7%

  22. #22 Minimal RPG
    82% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Studio Emyr
    Windows

    In Node RPG, take control of a humble cursor embarking on a grand quest! Select from unique classes, overcome tough zones, and enjoy the feeling of always getting stronger in this minimalist RPG incremental adventure.

    Why similar: Idler 56.1%, RPG 21.3%, Casual 11%, Resource Management 6.7%, 2D 3.4%

  23. #23 Idle Kingdom: Magic & Beasts
    81% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: 魔與獸的遠征
    Windows

    歡迎來到充滿魔幻色彩的Q版世界!《放置王國:魔與獸的遠征》是一款融合策略、冒險與養成的奇幻放置類遊戲,帶你踏上守護王國、挑戰未知的史詩旅程。

    Why similar: Idler 53.7%, Card Game 17.7%, RPG 15.6%, Casual 7.9%, 2D 3.6%

  24. #24 Supply Chain Idle
    84% matchMostly Positive80% of 382 reviews2018
    Dev: Upturn Games
    Windows · Mac · Linux

    Build, link and upgrade factories to produce and sell products.

    Why similar: Idler 84.4%, Casual 15.6%

  25. #25 Literally Just A Rock
    81% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: HereMeOutKylePub: Doonamai, LLC
    Windows

    Literally a game that nobody wants. It is just a rock. Do not buy this game, and do not gift this game to your friends for any occasion whatsoever. It is pointless.

    Why similar: Idler 76.9%, Casual 16.7%, Singleplayer 4.1%, Indie 2.3%

  26. #26 The Essence of Thievery
    80% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Wearable Snake Studios
    Windows

    The Essence of Thievery is an incremental game with a focus on exploration, discovery, and travel. Command your thief underlings to discover, steal, and wield the power of Essences to push back the Silent Fog and save the world.

    Why similar: Idler 68%, Resource Management 13.2%, Casual 7%, 2D 5%, Indie 3.4%

  27. #27 Man vs. Gary
    79% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Jaco Stander
    Windows · Mac · Linux

    Row out. Shoot the enormous sea monster. Drown. File the incident report. Do it again, a little angrier each time. A hand-illustrated idle comedy about losing to Gary, a kraken with opinions and a HR complaint, until one day you don't.

    Why similar: Idler 45.2%, RPG 23%, Casual 13.6%, Resource Management 11%, 2D 4.5%

  28. #28 Desktop Jinja
    79% matchNo user reviews2025
    Dev: Anisile
    Windows

    Build a personal shrine on your desktop—pray, draw fortunes, and receive gentle blessings each day.

    Why similar: Idler 74.7%, Casual 13.5%, 2D 6.9%, Singleplayer 2.6%, Indie 2.3%

  29. #29 Cycle Idle RPG
    77% matchMixed70% of 260 reviews2025
    Dev: LeafcutterPub: Leafcutter Studios
    Windows

    An RPG where your character is constantly grinding - even when you're offline!

    Why similar: Idler 70.6%, RPG 26.3%, Singleplayer 3.1%

  30. #30 Bonk
    77% matchMostly Positive80% of 30 reviews2025
    Dev: Charles Johnston
    Windows

    A casual musical idler. Ideal for background sounds while focusing on study or work.

    Why similar: Idler 74.3%, Casual 15.9%, 2D 5.8%, Singleplayer 4%

  31. #31 Pumpking Spice
    78% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2025
    Dev: 7Productions
    Windows

    Guide a playful little ghost through spooky maze. Dodge mischievous bad guys, collect candy dropped by a flying witch, and uncover whether it's a trick or a treat! With vibrant visuals, simple controls, and fun challenges, Pumpkin Spice is perfect for kids and casual gamers alike.

    Why similar: Idler 55.2%, RPG 20.6%, Casual 14.6%, 2D 5.5%, Singleplayer 2.1%

  32. #32 Mors: Idle Reaper
    75% match2 user reviews0% of 2 reviews2026
    Dev: Dopa Games
    Windows

    A dark idle RPG where every Hunt is a gamble. Gather resources, forge your build, risk your reward bank against brutal bosses, claim rare loot, and rebirth stronger. At Level 1000, Amo awaits.

    Why similar: Idler 61.6%, Resource Management 23.5%, Casual 8.7%, Singleplayer 2.8%, Indie 2.4%

  33. #33 Incremental Mass Rewritten
    76% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: Oni Gaming
    Windows

    Watch your mass skyrocket! Incremental Mass Rewritten lets you upgrade, prestige, and unlock cosmic layers of growth. From tiny beginnings to multiverse-scale numbers, it's perfect for anyone who loves exponential progression and optimizing every step of the journey.

    Why similar: Idler 62.9%, Resource Management 24%, Casual 8.2%, 2D 2.6%, Singleplayer 2.2%

  34. #34 dungeon & heros
    78% matchMostly Positive75% of 52 reviews2021
    Dev: 404 game
    Windows

    Dungeon Heroes is an srpg and roguelite game that I personally developed, recruit and develop your team of heroes, in the randomly generated map to explore,collect equipment and soul skills,in the infinite reincarnation to build the strongest team.

    Why similar: Idler 36.4%, Card Game 23.7%, Resource Management 14.1%, Casual 8.4%, RPG 6.8%

  35. #35 Pacifish
    76% matchVery Positive84% of 702 reviews2022
    Dev: Conifer Studios
    Windows

    Pacifish is an incremental fishing management game with several mechanics to interact with and improve. It can be played both idly, or more actively to progress faster.

    Why similar: Idler 58.7%, Resource Management 26.1%, Casual 10.4%, 2D 3.1%, Singleplayer 1.7%

  36. #36 Spinova
    74% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: DZN
    Windows · Mac

    A roguelike deckbuilder with slot-machine mechanics set in a world of Slavic mythology. Build and upgrade your symbols, summon Ancients, swear oaths and choose blessings to squeeze insane multipliers out of every spin and push further with each new run

    Why similar: Idler 42.6%, Card Game 38%, Casual 13.2%, 2D 3.4%, Indie 1.5%

  37. #37 Arcane Forge
    73% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Vayvolt
    Windows

    Early Access: Rebuild the greatest fantasy smithy from the ruins of a fallen empire. Dark fantasy idle RPG with 15 skills, prestige, combat and endzone. 7 pacts playable now, 21 planned across three cycles. Your feedback shapes updates. No pay-to-win. DE/EN.

    Why similar: Idler 51.1%, Resource Management 16.3%, Casual 14.8%, RPG 8.3%, 2D 4.6%

  38. #38 Idle Dragon Realm
    73% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: tianqianwuya
    Windows

    This is an adventure AFK game based on text and images, where you can recruit heroes and collect equipment to defeat the demon king. Cultivate unique custom heroes in the game, create exclusive equipment as the main gameplay, easily place to complete the main storyline, and there is also an endless.

    Why similar: Idler 74.7%, Casual 10%, 2D 7%, Singleplayer 4.7%, Indie 3.6%

  39. #39 Retro Pack Club
    73% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Bozz
    Windows

    Rip open retro card packs and flip every card one at a time. Sell it for cash, or keep it for glory? Binder space is tight, so you can't keep them all. Hunt foils, misprints, glitches, and serial #1 across endless themed sets in this cozy, addictive collecting sim.

    Why similar: Idler 39.6%, Card Game 35.2%, Casual 12.1%, Resource Management 10.5%, Indie 1.4%

  40. #40 无尽的冒险
    71% matchVery Positive93% of 91 reviews2025
    Dev: 水月suigetsu
    Windows

    Endless Adventure is an idle looting RPG. Freely assign stats, craft gear with materials, defeat mighty monsters for resources, grow stronger, and save the world.

    Why similar: Idler 58.6%, RPG 23%, Casual 11.8%, 2D 3.4%, Indie 1.6%

  41. #41 Desk Dino
    72% match5 user reviews100% of 5 reviews2025
    Dev: SimpleDev
    Windows

    Some naughty pixel dinos run around on your computer desktop, being some good accompany while you're working, studying or relaxing. Feed them or play with them, it's on your mark. Don't worry, they won't bite. Enjoy your dino.

    Why similar: Idler 74.3%, Casual 14.2%, 2D 7%, Singleplayer 2.5%, Indie 2.1%

  42. #42 Idle Build RPG
    74% matchMixed56% of 55 reviews2023
    Dev: okyakusama
    Windows

    This game is an idle RPG game. Players only need a few simple operations to enjoy the joy of obtaining top-quality equipment.

    Why similar: Idler 46.1%, Card Game 27.8%, RPG 22.2%, 2D 2.7%, Singleplayer 1.3%

  43. #43 DPS IDLE
    75% matchMixed63% of 798 reviews2021
    Dev: YDKR
    Windows
    Median: 6.3 hrsMean: 123.0 hrs≥1hr: 78%

    Collect cards, upgrade cards, defeat monsters, join guilds and hire heroes. Raise your DPS!

    Why similar: Idler 45%, Card Game 28.7%, Resource Management 14.3%, Casual 5.7%, 2D 2.5%

  44. #44 Multi Idle
    71% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: MCLAMA
    Windows · Mac · Linux

    An idle RPG featuring a large focus on the customization of your play style to make every run unique. Create unbreakable skill combinations and advance your fighter to the point that even boss monsters will fear their strength!

    Why similar: Idler 46.8%, Resource Management 18.8%, RPG 16.9%, Casual 8.3%, 2D 4.1%

  45. #45 Idle Harmony
    71% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Matej Josifov
    Windows

    Build music instead of factories. Unlock notes, compose evolving songs, optimize your melodies, and watch your composition grow.

    Why similar: Idler 58.6%, Resource Management 26.2%, Casual 10.6%, 2D 2.7%, Singleplayer 1.9%

  46. #46 SCRIMBLO SCRAMBLE
    70% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: OBJECT OBSERVER
    Windows

    Put it all on the line in this roulette-themed incremental game where you torment your scrimblos in order to manage and eventually escape hell.

    Why similar: Idler 54.9%, Resource Management 23.3%, Casual 13%, 2D 5%, Singleplayer 2%

  47. #47 Idle: Shuguang's Alchemy Store
    70% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: 曙炚工作室
    Windows

    Welcome to Idle Shuguang's Alchemy Store! This is a lighthearted and relaxing idle management game. You can leave it running in the corner of your screen to keep you company during work and study, allowing you to enjoy the peaceful pleasure of running a shop amid your busy life.

    Why similar: Idler 75.9%, Casual 15.5%, Singleplayer 4.5%, 2D 4.1%

  48. #48 主公請躺好
    67% matchMostly Positive76% of 34 reviews2026
    Dev: 主公请躺好
    Windows

    【主公請躺好】是掛機類卡牌遊戲,玩家可以組建自己的隊伍,遊戲無需操作自動完成挑戰。獲得更高級的裝備和寶物後提升隊伍的實力,挑戰更高難度的BOSS。

    Why similar: Idler 45.4%, Card Game 30%, RPG 11.1%, Casual 8.3%, 2D 3.1%

  49. #49 Molo's Revenge
    70% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2024
    Dev: MelonStudios
    Windows · Mac

    Molo's Revenge is the incremental journey of a mole dragon to avenge his village by doing the thing he does best: Digging.

    Why similar: Idler 73.4%, Casual 14.9%, 2D 6.8%, Singleplayer 2.6%, Indie 2.2%

  50. #50 Synapse Idle
    69% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: PAVDUPPub: DEVDUP
    Windows · Mac

    Grow a 3D neural network from a single neuron. Workers haul energy along radiant paths, buildings amplify every passing signal, and a 100-node skill tree reshapes how your synapse evolves. A calm, incremental idle game about watching complexity bloom — tinted in whatever colors you choose.

    Why similar: Idler 77.9%, Casual 15.9%, Singleplayer 3.8%, Indie 2.3%

  51. #51 ShapeBlast
    68% match2 user reviews50% of 2 reviews2026
    Dev: ShapeBlast
    Windows

    A calm, relaxing, and short idle game. Smash geometric enemies on the battlefield, collect resources, and unlock over 100 in-game talents.

    Why similar: Idler 64.1%, Casual 20.7%, 2D 7.6%, Singleplayer 5.2%, Indie 2.4%

  52. #52 Quantum Break
    69% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: morbo
    Windows

    A casual, incremental game about quantum physics. Break stuff, collect resources and deposit them for more than 300 upgrades! Build a quantum computer, achieve quantum tunneling and potentially save the cats in a box, just don't look inside of it!

    Why similar: Idler 75.7%, Casual 14.6%, 2D 6.4%, Singleplayer 3.3%

  53. #53 Check in
    69% match6 user reviews83% of 6 reviews2024
    Dev: Rescras
    Windows

    "Check in" is a pure collection-based game where there are no complex operations; completing all challenges simply requires checking in on different dates.

    Why similar: Idler 68.2%, Casual 20.7%, Indie 7.2%, Singleplayer 3.8%

  54. #54 Mage Blast
    67% matchNo user reviews2026
    Dev: Frost Owl
    Windows

    Start weak. End legendary. Guide a novice mage to archmage in this incremental game! Unlock abilities that supercharge your progress, crush enemies, forge better gear, and rebuild a magical kingdom.

    Why similar: Idler 53.1%, Resource Management 19.2%, RPG 11.4%, Casual 7%, 2D 5.1%

  55. #55 Rune Legacy Idle
    66% matchMixed57% of 125 reviews2025
    Dev: Mume Games
    Windows

    Rune Legacy Idle is a multiplayer fantasy game featuring idle mechanics. Battle mythical monsters, train various skills, and team up or challenge your friends to duels. Enjoy a never ending idle RPG experience.

    Why similar: Idler 58%, RPG 22.2%, Casual 10.3%, Indie 4.4%, 2D 3.7%

  56. #56 Arcath Tales
    66% match3 user reviews33% of 3 reviews2026
    Dev: R2 Games
    Windows

    A fantasy roguelike RPG with gacha heroes, strategic team building, and endless replayable runs. Explore a world tree, fight monsters, and shape your own build.

    Why similar: Idler 64.3%, RPG 24.1%, Casual 11.6%

  57. #57 Loop Alchemist
    67% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: Mackdumbler
    Windows

    You wake up in an unknown land. Again. Use the experience from every past life and your ever-growing knowledge of alchemy to extend each life through a robust alchemical system. Explore, break through and uncover all the world has to offer in this minimalist RPG distilled down to its purest form

    Why similar: Idler 50.9%, RPG 18.4%, Resource Management 17.3%, Casual 9%, 2D 2.9%

  58. #58 星域商旅
    66% matchNo user reviews
    Dev: 沉默的二刺螈
    Windows

    Combining elements from the Age of Discovery trade, idle combat, strategic choices,character development, engage in trading, technological research, demon hunting, caravan dispatch, town patrols, workshop cultivation, and more to acquire various resources, upgrades, bonuses, challenging the endless

    Why similar: Idler 51.2%, Resource Management 25.1%, RPG 11.2%, Casual 6.7%, 2D 2.9%

Modeli
Idle Heroes Saga cover art

Games Like Idle Heroes Saga

Based on tag similarity + player behavior
Loading graph...