- #1 OverDrift Festival
97% matchMostly Positive79% of 1,195 reviews2022
Dev: OverDrift Crew
Windows
Median: 2.3 hrsMean: 6.9 hrs≥1hr: 71%
Become the star on festival of car culture and sports. Drift races and Free Style Drift tours on public roads with traffic. Huge game world, iconic tracks. Unique collection of cars. Wide range of tuning and styling options. Accurate physics: a sense of speed and lateral g-forces.
Why similar: Transportation 19.5% ★, Automobile Sim 17.3%, Racing 15.6%, Driving 14.8%, Open World 8.9%
- #2 TRUEM
96% match4 user reviews75% of 4 reviews2024
Dev: HOLGEAR GAMES
Windows
Dive into the world of TRUEM - a revolutionary racing game with unique cars and realistic physics! Compete on a variety of tracks and become a champion!
Why similar: Transportation 24% ★, Automobile Sim 15%, Driving 13.7%, Racing 13%, Choose Your Own Adventure 7.1%
- #3 CarLife Simulator
96% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Xidon Games
Windows
CarLife Simulator is a realistic car driving simulator with fun and challenges for the driver. Ideal for learning how to drive a car in different conditions, off-road cities, racing tracks for every taste, all this is available in CarLife Simulator.
Why similar: Automobile Sim 19.5%, Racing 17.5%, Driving 17.4%, Transportation 10.9% ★, Choose Your Own Adventure 7.3%
- #4 Truck Driver
95% matchMixed69% of 172 reviews2021
Dev: SOEDESCO
Windows · Mac
Build your career as a Truck Driver! Haul a wide range of cargo and make a name for yourself amongst the local community. Start from the bottom, take on jobs, buy new trucks & parts and become a respected Truck Driver!
Why similar: Transportation 25.4% ★, Racing 17%, Driving 16.6%, Automobile Sim 16.4%, Open World 7.5%
- #5 Bus Bound
94% matchMostly Positive73% of 808 reviews2026
Dev: stillalive studiosPub: Saber Interactive Inc.
Windows
Median: 4.1 hrsMean: 6.6 hrs≥1hr: 84%
Step into the driver’s seat in Bus Bound, the latest title from the creators of Bus Simulator 21. Explore a vibrant city behind the wheel of officially licensed buses, and help transform it into a pedestrian-friendly paradise—one stop at a time.
Why similar: Transportation 30% ★, Driving 21.7%, Automobile Sim 19.3%, Sandbox 7.8%, Racing 7.8%
- #6 Extreme Bus Driver Simulator
94% matchMixed59% of 29 reviews2023
Dev: Rokito Games
Windows · Mac
Are you ready to become an experienced bus driver? Experience the thrill of transporting passengers in a realistic city with Extreme Bus Driver Simulator! Get passengers to their destination on time and safely, earn rewards and customize your bus.
Why similar: Transportation 25.9% ★, Automobile Sim 18.6%, Driving 17.9%, Racing 17.5%, Open World 7.8%
- #7 D96: Kansei
93% matchPositive85% of 13 reviews2024
Dev: Lonely OnePub: Lonely One
Windows
An arcade racing game in an open world that will allow you to experience the atmosphere of night roads, as well as participate in drift competitions. Tune up your car, get behind the wheel and race along the narrow, winding tracks of the drift valley!
Why similar: Transportation 26.1% ★, Driving 17.9%, Automobile Sim 17.5%, Racing 15.3%, Sports 7.9%
- #8 Gridmaster
92% match3 user reviews67% of 3 reviews2023
Dev: GeamGames
Windows
Step into the world of Gridmaster, a high-speed single-player racer. Take on time trials, master the art of drifting, and compete on the leaderboards. As you dominate the road, unlock new cars and tracks to fuel your journey to victory!
Why similar: Driving 23.1%, Automobile Sim 20.9%, Racing 19.9%, Sports 9.4%, Arcade 6.7%
- #9 FSA DRIVING
91% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: AZGamesPub: Aixing Network
Windows
Delivery, trading, racing—showcase your superb driving skills in Nijnait City, modeled after Tianjin. Customize your vehicle, drift through corners, perform stunt drives, and glide over the city with a wingsuit. Explore streets, uncover the fastest routes, and save precious time for your clients.
Why similar: Racing 27.7%, Transportation 19.3% ★, Driving 13.4%, Automobile Sim 11.6%, Open World 10.9%
- #10 TOKYO DRIVE
90% matchNo user reviews2024
Dev: AiTHER SOFT
Windows
"TOKYO DRIVE" is a racing game that uses the location data of actual roads and buildings in Tokyo, Japan (Tokyo's 23 wards).
Why similar: Driving 22%, Racing 21.2%, Automobile Sim 21%, Sports 11.2%, Open World 9.8%
- #11 The Westcoast Drive : Lowrider Simulator
89% match4 user reviews75% of 4 reviews2023
Dev: BlackPanzerYZ
Windows
Experience 1960s American lowrider culture. Customize your ride, hit the streets, and dominate with iconic hydraulics
Why similar: Transportation 19.8% ★, Driving 15%, Automobile Sim 14.3%, Racing 13%, Sports 7.7%
- #12 Drift City Underground
89% matchNo user reviews2023
Dev: Dying Byte®Pub: Heart State Games®
Windows
Driving/Drifting Simulation game with Arcady gameplay and 8 initial cars that can be unlocked, in a open world map with deep car customization and additional skins and roleplay features later on. Brilliant mechanics will make this game enjoyable and stunning graphics will settle for a AAA Indie game
Why similar: Driving 19.8%, Automobile Sim 19.2%, Racing 13.2%, Open World 9.8%, Sandbox 7.8%
- #13 Forza Horizon 6
86% matchVery Positive84% of 86,311 reviews2026
Dev: Playground GamesPub: Xbox Game Studios
Windows
Median: 40.7 hrsMean: 56.7 hrs≥1hr: 99%
Discover the breathtaking landscapes of Japan in over 550 real-world cars and become a racing Legend in Forza Horizon's biggest open world driving adventure yet.
Why similar: Racing 21.4%, Driving 20.6%, Automobile Sim 18.1%, Open World 11.6%, Sports 6.9%
- #14 Car Mechanic: City Driving
88% match5 user reviews0% of 5 reviews2023
Dev: Performance Artist Games
Windows
Customize your own car and go on a serene ride through the city streets!
Why similar: Automobile Sim 23.1%, Driving 21.7%, Racing 17%, Open World 9.8%, Sandbox 9.1%
- #15 Non Stop Driver
87% match5 user reviews40% of 5 reviews2024
Dev: Akif AkdemirPub: Plexus Game
Windows
If you slow down you die, if you speed up you live!
Why similar: Driving 22.5%, Automobile Sim 21.2%, Transportation 16.1% ★, Racing 13.3%, Open World 7.7%
- #16 TrophyRC
86% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Eugene HatskevichPub: Crossbridge Game Studios
Windows
TrophyRC — a scale off-road trial experience. Customize your crawler and conquer challenging obstacle courses. Remember, it's not about speed, but accuracy and precision!
Why similar: Transportation 26.1% ★, Automobile Sim 17.5%, Driving 17.1%, Racing 14.5%, Sandbox 7.2%
- #17 The Slaverian Trucker
84% matchVery Positive85% of 794 reviews2026
Dev: SawyerK Games
Windows
Median: 2.5 hrsMean: 12.1 hrs≥1hr: 70%
The Slaverian Trucker is a Survival/Truck/Life simulator game. Make enough money to survive and expand your wealth in the harsh semi-post apocalyptic lands of Slaveria, doing legal and illegal work, while maintaining, fixing, building, repairing, tuning your trucks, cars and other vehicles.
Why similar: Transportation 29.6% ★, Automobile Sim 21.7%, Driving 20.1%, Open World 10%, Racing 6%
- #18 Forza Motorsport
85% matchMixed51% of 12,595 reviews2023
Dev: Turn 10Pub: Xbox Game Studios
Windows
Median: 20.6 hrsMean: 86.9 hrs≥1hr: 95%
Compete in over 500 cars on 30 world-famous tracks – now featuring the legendary Fujimi Kaido! Play the new 20th Anniversary Tour and obtain special rewards.
Why similar: Automobile Sim 18.9%, Racing 18%, Driving 17.9%, Transportation 14.2% ★, Sports 8.4%
- #19 WorldDrive: Real Open-World Driving Simulator
84% matchMostly Negative35% of 17 reviews2026
Dev: AJ Simulation & Engineering
Windows
Drive the roads you know. WorldDrive recreates real cities and roads at 1:1 scale—starting with a 30 km² region of Poland in Early Access. Free drive, explore, and share the road with realistic AI traffic.
Why similar: Driving 24%, Automobile Sim 21.7%, Racing 17.8%, Sandbox 6%, Simulation 5.7%
- #20 No Roads: 4×4 Off-Road Challenge
83% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2026
Dev: Kevin SmithPub: Pixels Graphic Design, LLC
Windows
A mountain off-road traversal adventure focused on risky shortcuts, dangerous terrain, and finding your own route to the destination.
Why similar: Racing 20.3%, Driving 18.5%, Automobile Sim 15%, Sports 14%, Sandbox 8.8%
- #21 My Truck Game
82% matchVery Positive83% of 251 reviews2022
Dev: Chris
Windows
Physics based, off road truck and bus simulation.
Why similar: Transportation 32.6% ★, Driving 24.7%, Automobile Sim 19.6%, Sandbox 12%, Simulation 6.4%
- #22 Bus Simulator Offroad
82% match5 user reviews20% of 5 reviews2025
Dev: Nitx Games
Windows
master the art of offroad bus driving and take on the most extreme terrains. from steep mountain trails to dense jungle paths, every route challenges your skill and precision. navigate harsh weather, tricky slopes, and rugged roads as you prove yourself as a true offroad driving pro bus driver.
Why similar: Transportation 37.9% ★, Automobile Sim 21.7%, Driving 13.5%, Simulation 7.2%, Realistic 5.9%
- #23 TRUCK SIM USA
81% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Midnight Games
Windows
Are you ready to experience the thrill of being a real truck driver? Immerse yourself in the world of American trucking and showcase your exceptional driving skills. Take on exciting transport missions and deliver various types of cargo to city warehouses.
Why similar: Transportation 24.7% ★, Automobile Sim 22.3%, Driving 17.9%, Open World 7.8%, Realistic 6.1%
- #24 Forza Horizon 5
80% matchVery Positive89% of 277,124 reviews2021
Dev: Playground GamesPub: Xbox Game Studios
Windows
Median: 31.5 hrsMean: 112.3 hrs≥1hr: 98%
Explore the vibrant open world landscapes of Mexico with limitless, fun driving action in the world’s greatest cars.
Why similar: Racing 24.5%, Driving 22.3%, Automobile Sim 17.6%, Open World 12.6%, Realistic 4.8%
- #25 Extreme racing
81% match9 user reviews44% of 9 reviews2021
Dev: PHX games
Windows
Extreme racing is a wonderful racing game in which you will enjoy spending your time and at the same time test your driving skills in a cool racing mode! If you are attracted to the big magical world of speed and off-scale adrenaline, then the game "Extreme racing" is just for you!
Why similar: Racing 26.5%, Transportation 19.3% ★, Automobile Sim 18.1%, Driving 15.7%, Sports 9.9%
- #26 Ridevery
78% matchMixed56% of 18 reviews2023
Dev: Kvass Da Valenki
Windows
In the game you have to become the fastest and most reliable pizza delivery guy, conquering realistic city streets on your high-speed scooter.
Why similar: Driving 28.1%, Automobile Sim 22.6%, Racing 20.9%, Simulation 8.5%, Arcade 5.9%
- #27 Cargo Transportation: Low Poly
79% matchMixed63% of 30 reviews2021
Dev: Laush Dmitriy SergeevichPub: Laush Studio
Windows
Is a game in which the player needs to take all the cargo (boxes, barrels) through obstacles to the finish line
Why similar: Transportation 27.8% ★, Driving 17.5%, Racing 16.6%, Automobile Sim 16.2%, Sports 9.1%
- #28 Apex Point
77% matchVery Positive86% of 1,948 reviews2023
Dev: Apex Studio
Windows
Median: 2.9 hrsMean: 8.9 hrs≥1hr: 67%
Apex Point is an open world game that aims to immerge you into the Japanese car culture by providing a huge variety of customizations and race types so you can choose your own path
Why similar: Automobile Sim 27.8%, Racing 25.6%, Open World 12.6%, Driving 11.2%, Simulation 7.2%
- #29 Tractor Driving Simulator
77% match7 user reviews71% of 7 reviews2025
Dev: Nitx Games
Windows
Be an professional driver by driving the modern tractor on the off-roads tracks in tractor driving simulator. smooth controls and realistic sound effects with Unique camera angles to drive carefully the tractor trolley. Stunning HD graphics with beautiful landscapes on Offroad mountain terrains.
Why similar: Transportation 27.8% ★, Racing 23.7%, Driving 19.3%, Automobile Sim 14.1%, Simulation 4.4%
- #30 CarX Street
76% matchMostly Positive71% of 19,029 reviews2024
Dev: CarX Technologies, LLC
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 7.9 hrsMean: 27.5 hrs≥1hr: 85%
Conquer mountain roads, highways, and city streets. Build your dream car with detailed tuning that unleashes the potential of “CarX Technology”© physics. Take part in thrilling races, enjoying realistic gameplay and dynamic driving.
Why similar: Automobile Sim 18.4%, Driving 18%, Racing 18%, Open World 10.6%, Sports 7.4%
- #31 City Car Driving 2.0
74% matchMixed62% of 927 reviews2026
Dev: Forward Development, Ltd.Pub: Forward Global Group, Ltd.
Windows
Median: 3.3 hrsMean: 4.1 hrs≥1hr: 78%
City Car Driving 2.0 is a driving simulator designed to help novice drivers master driving in a setting as close to reality as possible.
Why similar: Automobile Sim 25.3%, Driving 20.9%, Racing 16.9%, Sandbox 9.4%, Simulation 8.7%
- #32 Motor Town: Behind The Wheel
75% matchVery Positive94% of 9,296 reviews2021
Dev: P3 Games
Windows
Median: 12.7 hrsMean: 46.5 hrs≥1hr: 90%
Enjoy realistic driving in the open world. Relaxing cargo deliveries or driving buses and taxis will give you enough money to buy new cars and parts. You can test your driving skills at the race track. It's all about pure driving pleasure!
Why similar: Transportation 28.2% ★, Driving 20.1%, Automobile Sim 17.8%, Racing 10.7%, Open World 10.3%
- #33 OCEAN CITY RACING
78% matchMostly Negative34% of 693 reviews2014
Dev: OCR Dev Team
Windows
Median: 18 minMean: 7.6 hrs≥1hr: 25%
Popular open-world driving game features an explorable Free Roam Environment, a thrilling Race Mode and a highly addictive Time-Trial Mode.
Why similar: Automobile Sim 27.6%, Racing 27%, Driving 19.7%, Open World 9.7%, Sandbox 5.4%
- #34 JDM: Japanese Drift Master
74% matchMostly Positive76% of 5,856 reviews2025
Dev: Gaming Factory
Windows
Median: 4.8 hrsMean: 10.3 hrs≥1hr: 84%
Discover Japan’s legendary car culture in JDM! Take on challenging mountain roads, visit Japanese legendary drifting spots in licensed JDM cars and immerse in the story about second chances told through manga pages. Explore an open world where every turn invites you to master the art of drift.
Why similar: Racing 21.9%, Driving 20.9%, Open World 11.4%, Automobile Sim 11.1%, Sports 9.4%
- #35 My Hooptie
75% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Mmado
Windows
Fix up your crappy car and build the engine yourself. Make money by selling wood, potatoes, mining ores, or racing. Explore the map, manage survival, Build your story set in America, 2002.
Why similar: Racing 23.1%, Automobile Sim 22.1%, Driving 16.2%, Sandbox 9.1%, Choose Your Own Adventure 8.7%
- #36 inBOX
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: NhnenoPub: Ultimate Games S.A.
Windows
Get up at 4 a.m., fight hunger, fatigue and physiological needs, start the van and deliver packages to backwater villages.
Why similar: Automobile Sim 26.1%, Driving 21.8%, Racing 18.4%, Open World 10.7%, Simulation 7.8%
- #37 Taxi Life: A City Driving Simulator
72% matchMixed62% of 5,471 reviews2024
Dev: SimteractPub: Nacon
Windows
Median: 3.2 hrsMean: 8.6 hrs≥1hr: 79%
Climb into the driver's seat of your car and your business, transport passengers across Barcelona and grow your company! Can you help relieve the transportation challenges of a city that never sleeps?
Why similar: Transportation 23.6% ★, Driving 23.1%, Automobile Sim 19.3%, Open World 10.3%, Realistic 5.8%
- #38 Truck Rally Hyper Hardcore
73% match7 user reviews43% of 7 reviews2022
Dev: AlekseyPub: AlekseyN
Windows
The challenging races that you only know are just the beginning level of this game. Absolutely realistic behavior of the machine. No arcade controls. Using the laws of the real physical world. Only for hardcore players.
Why similar: Transportation 25.2% ★, Driving 21.2%, Racing 19.6%, Automobile Sim 19.4%, Sports 7.6%
- #39 Race Master
72% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Beresnev Games
Windows
Looking for a game that’s easy to pick up but offers real driving challenges, along with endless thrills, unique cars, and fierce rivals? Race Master 3D has it all, with fast-paced, intense races that you can enjoy anytime, anywhere.
Why similar: Racing 33%, Driving 23.2%, Transportation 17% ★, Automobile Sim 12.3%, Arcade 7.5%
- #40 Autos
71% match6 user reviews0% of 6 reviews2024
Dev: Leedo Studio
Windows
Autos is driving game has five modes Racing, Car Park Drift, Truck Challenge, Rally and Transportation Open World Driving.
Why similar: Racing 24.9%, Automobile Sim 16.1%, Transportation 15.2% ★, Driving 13.1%, Sports 13%
- #41 Rodobus Simulador
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: E3D Software
Windows
Rodobus Simulator is a driving simulation game that puts you in control of a bus in a world faithfully represented at real scale. Transport passengers, follow routes, and face challenges like dynamic traffic, weather changes, and a day-night cycle.
Why similar: Transportation 37.6% ★, Driving 22.4%, Automobile Sim 17.3%, Simulation 10.5%, Realistic 8.2%
- #42 Police Air Transporter
73% matchMostly Negative21% of 14 reviews2018
Dev: Fury Games Production
Windows
Some say “Airplanes!” Others say “Cars!” Why choose if you can combine both? Police Air Transporter will help!
Why similar: Automobile Sim 24.6%, Racing 23.8%, Sports 14.4%, Driving 12.8%, Simulation 7.3%
- #43 Transylvania Drift
70% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2025
Dev: Andrasfi Games
Windows
Transylvania Drift is a unique drifting game which takes place in the beautiful region of Transylvania! Take on your opponents with the most iconic cars and show them who owns the Transylvanian roads!
Why similar: Racing 23%, Driving 22.2%, Automobile Sim 15.5%, Open World 12.3%, Arcade 7.6%
- #44 Bus Driving Sim 22
70% matchMixed58% of 470 reviews2023
Dev: Ovilex Software
Windows · Mac
Median: 1.6 hrsMean: 4.5 hrs≥1hr: 63%
Experience what it feels like to be a real bus driver. Simulator featuring realistic physics, a variety of bus models (city buses, electric bus, school bus), three distinct regions to explore (US, Germany, Brazil) and much more. Test your skills in career, drive in freeride or play multiplayer.
Why similar: Transportation 31.5% ★, Automobile Sim 20.9%, Driving 20.6%, Open World 10.3%, Simulation 5.7%
- #45 Oval Racer Series - Sandbox
71% match2 user reviews50% of 2 reviews2021
Dev: Oval Games
Windows
The game will simulate oval circuit racing in the UK, focusing on stock cars, bangers, and hot rods. It will blend realism and fun with accessible gameplay. Players will race across iconic UK tracks, upgrade their cars, and compete in various racing disciplines.
Why similar: Automobile Sim 23.6%, Racing 23.2%, Driving 20.9%, Sports 13.1%, Arcade 7.5%
- #46 Elektronka: Bratislava
69% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Šimon Baran
Windows
Join us for a tram ride around Bratislava in iconic and beloved trams. Test your sense and precision in our simulator where you can try connecting sets and switching turnouts. Tram drivers participated in the development.
Why similar: Transportation 36% ★, Automobile Sim 20.3%, Racing 11.2%, Open World 10.1%, Simulation 8.4%
- #47 Car Constructor
70% matchMixed60% of 97 reviews2021
Dev: Guilty Pleasure Games
Windows
Car Constructor will allow you to build, repair and paint your own car, then check it out on the race track!
Why similar: Racing 22.2%, Automobile Sim 19.1%, Driving 12%, Sports 11.4%, Sandbox 7.7%
- #48 Neon Rush
69% matchNo user reviews2027
Dev: Entertainment Unboxed
Windows
Speed through a neon city in this 2D retro racing game. Outsmart cops and rivals with skillful maneuvers. Immerse yourself in illegal racing, fueled by synthwave beats, and dominate as the underworld's top racer!
Why similar: Driving 22.9%, Automobile Sim 22.2%, Racing 21.5%, Sports 12.5%, Open World 9.6%
- #49 EQDRIVE.IO
69% matchMostly Positive70% of 27 reviews2022
Dev: Realityocean Games
Windows
High precision soft body physics for cars, trucks, airplanes, drones, ships and theme park rides. Supports SteamDeck
Why similar: Automobile Sim 25.4%, Transportation 22.4% ★, Driving 17.5%, Racing 12.7%, Simulation 9.9%
- #50 Speedland
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Team Spirit
Windows · Mac
Explore a vast open world, complete quests, collect items, participate in races to earn cash, build your town, manage finances, upgrade technology, and power-up your vehicles. Challenge other players and compete in events to climb the global leaderboard.
Why similar: Racing 25.1%, Driving 19.8%, Automobile Sim 18.7%, Open World 11%, Sandbox 6.1%
- #51 DriftX
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Creative LabzPub: RIVERSIDE SPORTS
Windows
Master the art of drifting in DriftX, an adrenaline-packed racing game blending realistic physics with arcade-style fun. Drift solo or compete in online lobbies of up to 12 players.
Why similar: Racing 29.1%, Automobile Sim 20.4%, Sports 15.4%, Driving 11.2%, Simulation 7.9%
- #52 Water Truck Simulator
67% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Nitx Games
Windows
Drive a heavy water tanker fill your tank travel through city roads and off-road routes and deliver water safely across challenging missions in Water Truck Simulator. Test your driving skills as you control a mini water tanker truck through traffic.
Why similar: Transportation 31.3% ★, Driving 23.1%, Automobile Sim 18.9%, Open World 6.4%, Arcade 4.8%
- #53 Taxi Simulator
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: AsmodevPub: Ultimate Games S.A.
Windows
Become a taxi driver and experience for yourself the everyday life in such interesting profession. One might think that working behind a taxi wheel is a dull and boring task. But you couldn’t be more wrong! In Taxi Simulator you'll play as a shady rap driver and drive through the wildly urban areas.
Why similar: Automobile Sim 33.5%, Driving 24.1%, Racing 10.5%, Open World 8.7%, Simulation 7.7%
- #54 Extreme Car Drift Simulator
67% matchMostly Positive73% of 33 reviews2023
Dev: Yusuf Islam SeyhanPub: Inspector Studios
Windows
If you want to drift wildly, this game is for you. With the drift game, you can have a great car driving simulation experience.
Why similar: Racing 28.2%, Automobile Sim 18.9%, Sports 15.4%, Driving 13.9%, Simulation 8.1%
- #55 L.A.W Transporter
66% match6 user reviews100% of 6 reviews2024
Dev: Butter Fly Games
Windows
Transport different types of cargo by land, air, and water. Configure your vehicles in various ways—anything is possible. All models and code are created by one autistic man.
Why similar: Transportation 30.4% ★, Automobile Sim 18.1%, Driving 15.8%, Racing 10.4%, Open World 9.2%
- #56 Casual Trucking
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Vladimir SlavPub: Coldwild Games
Windows · Mac · Linux
Drive your truck and deliver the cargo, buy properties and accumulate wealth
Why similar: Transportation 36.1% ★, Driving 26.4%, Automobile Sim 18.8%, Open World 7.2%, Simulation 4.8%