- #1 Upgrade It
97% match6 user reviews33% of 6 reviews2025
Dev: Tip Top Games
Windows
An idle game with 99 generators and a deep prestige system. Unlock 1000+ upgrades, automate progress, and complete all challenges. A full release, ready to play!
Why similar: Idler 16.8%, God Game 15.2% ★, Incremental 13.2%, Automation 11.8%, Trading 10.5%
- #2 Execute
96% matchVery Positive91% of 676 reviews2025
Dev: Payne Robinson
Windows
Median: 3.8 hrsMean: 5.6 hrs≥1hr: 90%
Kill everyone in the world with a guillotine… on a cursed Win98 desktop.
Why similar: God Game 17.3% ★, Automation 13.2%, Incremental 12.4%, Idler 11.5%, 1990's 10.3%
- #3 Click to Obsolete
96% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Shaked Yarkony
Windows
A satirical incremental clicker game. Play as a corporate tech CEO automating all human labor. Build server infrastructure, allocate compute to AI, manufacture robot armies, and lobby politicians to reduce global employment from 8 billion to zero.
Why similar: Automation 16.6%, Incremental 14.2%, Idler 13.7%, Capitalism 13%, God Game 8.4% ★
- #4 God of Stocks
95% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Obys Byte Games
Windows
An incremental management game about manipulating the market to get filthy rich. Buy low, sell high, chain absurd combos and earn divine blessings from stock market gods. Will you play it safe or risk everything?
Why similar: Incremental 18.2%, Idler 17.3%, Capitalism 16.8%, God Game 11.7% ★, Economy 11.2%
- #5 Military Incremental Complex
94% matchVery Positive82% of 743 reviews2025
Dev: Space Kraken Studios
Windows
Median: 9.8 hrsMean: 17.5 hrs≥1hr: 90%
Make weapons, make money. An active incremental game where you amass as much money as you can by starting a Military Industrial Complex company. Produce multiple different weapons, research upgrades, manipulate the stock market, and lobby the government for favors.
Why similar: Automation 14.9%, Incremental 12.6%, Idler 12.4%, Capitalism 11.8%, 1990's 9.6%
- #6 MMO98
94% matchMostly Positive70% of 509 reviews2026
Dev: BiteMe Games
Windows · Mac
Median: 2.5 hrsMean: 6.1 hrs≥1hr: 86%
An incremental game where you go from small-scale MMO development studio up to global market domination. Improve your server infrastructure, address the technical challenges of running an MMO, release new games, and become the world's #1 MMO game studio.
Why similar: Incremental 19.3%, Idler 15.9%, Capitalism 13.1%, Economy 6.6%, Automation 6.6%
- #7 ScaMMO
93% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: BiteMe PuppetPub: PuppetDevMaster
Windows
Incremental game where you play as a frustrated rich MMO veteran promising to make the next WoW killer. How far will you get before cashing out?
Why similar: Incremental 16.6%, Idler 16%, Automation 14.5%, God Game 14% ★, Capitalism 11%
- #8 Internet Cafe 98
92% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: GrindWill LabsPub: GrindWill Interactive
Windows
Start with one trash PC and build a packed 1998 internet cafe. Serve customers, upgrade your hardware and network, and research new tech in this retro incremental tycoon.
Why similar: Incremental 17.4%, Idler 16.1%, Capitalism 14.7%, Automation 12.1%, Economy 9.9%
- #9 Beer Clicker
91% match1 user reviews0% of 1 reviews2026
Dev: LZQI STUDIOSPub: Lazzqi
Windows
Beer Clicker is a casual idle clicker game where you brew beer, earn bottles, and expand your brewery. Click to produce, unlock upgrades, automate systems, and enjoy satisfying progression at your own pace.
Why similar: God Game 24% ★, Incremental 21.4%, Automation 21.1%, Idler 19.1%, Management 9.1%
- #10 Critter Bonk
91% matchNo user reviews
Dev: FluffyFishDev
Windows
A cute incremental clicker where you bonk bugs for profit. Earn money, unlock upgrades, acquire powerful skills, and recruit helpers to automate the bonking until you’re truly unstoppable. Satisfying and Relaxing!
Why similar: Automation 20%, Incremental 18.6%, Idler 17%, Capitalism 15.2%, Economy 9.8%
- #11 Grey Market
90% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Carson Games
Windows
A criminal idle tycoon where the market fights back. Every market has real buyers who run out when you flood them and recover when you leave them alone, so where you send product matters as much as how much you make. Build an operation that keeps earning while the game is closed.
Why similar: Idler 19.7%, Incremental 17.7%, Automation 17.1%, Capitalism 12.8%, Trading 9%
- #12 OurClicker
89% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: WaveyGaming Productions
Windows · Mac · Linux
From the creators of OurLife and OurCoven, OurClicker is a brand new clicker game that puts you in charge of an up-and-coming Game Development Studio where all you do is... CLICK!
Why similar: Idler 21.4%, Incremental 18.9%, Automation 16.8%, Capitalism 12.9%, Economy 12.4%
- #13 Karma Keepers
88% matchMostly Positive75% of 55 reviews2026
Dev: yonazdev
Windows · Mac
A chill idle/incremental strategy game where you restore souls, build a Faith economy, automate more of your realm, and rebirth for permanent progress before corruption takes over
Why similar: God Game 23% ★, Automation 18.4%, Idler 16.9%, Incremental 16%, Management 9.1%
- #14 ClickRush
89% match9 user reviews67% of 9 reviews2026
Dev: Broussen GamesPub: Broussen
Windows
ClickRush: Produce infinite clicks! Deploy drones and AI matrices to automate your empire. Take down Real-Time World Bosses with the community, level up your Battle Pass, and unlock celestial bonuses. Dominate the global leaderboard. Get your mouse ready!
Why similar: God Game 22.3% ★, Automation 18.8%, Incremental 17.6%, Idler 17%, Management 9.4%
- #15 Keep On Hashing!: Idle Mining Sim
87% match1 user reviews0% of 1 reviews2026
Dev: Velron Games
Windows
Mine blocks. Earn Bitcoin, Ethereum, Litecoin and Solana. Hire 20 helpers who mine while you sleep. Upgrade rigs from USB sticks to quantum machines. Climb a 22-node skill tree. Overclock everything. Prestige and chase the next zero. It never ends — and you won't want it to.
Why similar: Idler 21.8%, Incremental 18.8%, Automation 15.2%, Capitalism 11.5%, Economy 9.2%
- #16 Last $50
86% matchMostly Positive70% of 20 reviews2026
Dev: Adagio Games
Windows
Build a drug empire with your last $50. Buy production, upgrade it, and hire workers to automate.
Why similar: Automation 22.8%, Incremental 20.4%, Idler 16.3%, Economy 12%, Capitalism 8.8%
- #17 Astra Incrementalia
86% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Studio Deep
Windows
In this short incremental game you're tasked with growing The Company. Purchase planets, unlock specialized space stations, produce millions of resources, and dominate the solar market. How much can you accomplish in a generation?
Why similar: Automation 20.9%, Incremental 18.4%, Idler 17.5%, Capitalism 13.8%, Management 9%
- #18 Padel Tycoon
85% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Santiago Piedras Gonzalez
Windows
Build a padel empire from a single bucket of used balls to the Lunar Major in the world's first padel business game. Buy courts, hire managers to run them and watch the numbers climb across three locations. An idle clicker with 20 businesses, 46 upgrades and an empire that earns while you're away.
Why similar: Automation 22.7%, Idler 20.4%, Capitalism 17.2%, Incremental 12.2%, Economy 11.2%
- #19 The Completionist: 1980-1989
84% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Frosty PopPub: Frosty Pop
Windows · Mac · Linux
Run a scrappy pop culture magazine through the 1980s. Hire writers, editors, and researchers. Manage a Kanban board. Prestige through Volumes. Try not to go broke. Strategic idle sim. Commodore 64 aesthetic. No micro-transactions.
Why similar: Automation 19.4%, Incremental 16.4%, Idler 16%, Capitalism 15.3%, Economy 10.3%
- #20 Downsizing.exe
84% match8 user reviews88% of 8 reviews2026
Dev: RotHeartGamesPub: Midnight Rental Games
Windows
Maximize profit. Minimize humanity. In Downsizing.exe, you are a cog in the dark corporate machine. Approve terminations, automate the grind, and slash costs. How much will you sacrifice for the firm?
Why similar: God Game 27.3% ★, Incremental 20.1%, Idler 18.2%, Capitalism 17.3%, 1990's 6.3%
- #21 Forge Clicker 2
83% match5 user reviews80% of 5 reviews2026
Dev: Diciannovesimo Games
Windows · Mac · Linux
Forge Clicker 2 is a pixel art idle clicker game where you manage your own forge. Tap to gather materials, craft weapons through a forging minigame, sell your creations, and unlock stronger materials, upgrades, and new blades.
Why similar: Incremental 25.2%, Idler 22.6%, Automation 15.8%, Trading 10.5%, Crafting 10.5%
- #22 Monster Flipper
82% matchMostly Positive77% of 47 reviews2026
Dev: NovaScreen
Windows
Monster Flipper is a short incremental game where you buy and level monsters, smash them with a giant hammer for gold, and unlock swords and artifacts to automate your progress.
Why similar: Idler 22.2%, Automation 19.8%, Incremental 19.6%, Economy 12.1%, Management 10.8%
- #23 IT Outage Desk
82% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Games By Solo
Windows · Mac
Start as a help desk technician and build your way to the top. Resolve tickets, hire staff, automate your department, and survive the increasingly absurd chaos of corporate IT in this humorous incremental clicker.
Why similar: Automation 22%, Incremental 20.7%, Idler 18.8%, Capitalism 12.8%, Economy 11.5%
- #24 [MULTIPLIERS]
81% match3 user reviews67% of 3 reviews2026
Dev: My Little Games
Windows
An exponential idle clicker game with 2,000+ upgrades and infinite fun. Multipliers, prestige, perks and many more features!
Why similar: Idler 22.1%, Incremental 20.1%, God Game 19.2% ★, Management 11.2%, Economy 8.8%
- #25 Evil overlord Clicker
81% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: MOTZA GAMES
Windows
Evil Overlord Clicker is a fast, satisfying incremental game where you smash endless walls, farm resources, and grow your dark empire. Recruit and upgrade minions, prestige for permanent buffs, and face tougher walls with unique effects.
Why similar: Incremental 21.2%, Idler 19.2%, Capitalism 16.9%, Automation 15.2%, Economy 10.9%
- #26 Incremental Pain Profit
80% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Zayndev
Windows
Click, topple and profit! Knock over tiny wandering Humans, hire Animals to cause chaos, collect mountains of coins and grow your ridiculous empire. Unlock powerful Rebirth upgrades, defeat Bosses and turn a peaceful board into a glorious mess of falling people.
Why similar: Automation 26%, Capitalism 19.6%, Idler 12.6%, Incremental 11.4%, Economy 9.5%
- #27 Fishing 95
79% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Green Crow DevPub: Green Crow Games
Windows
A relaxing idle fishing desktop companion. Cast your rods, catch fish, upgrade your equipment, and automate your growing fishing business. Build the ultimate fishing empire in a nostalgic '90s-inspired window. Catch. Upgrade. Profit. Repeat.
Why similar: Incremental 17.7%, Idler 17%, 1990's 14.1%, Automation 13.4%, God Game 12.2% ★
- #28 Feed The Forest
79% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Indoor Sunglasses
Windows · Linux
A short, innocent incremental forest-builder. Unlock snail powers to spread life in a barren desert. Feed the mysterious Forest with juice. And remember: Blood is a type of juice.
Why similar: Automation 22.1%, Incremental 19.6%, Idler 18.4%, Capitalism 10.9%, Economy 7.9%
- #29 [RANDOM]
78% match2 user reviews0% of 2 reviews2026
Dev: My Little Games
Windows
An idle clicker game with random values and 2,000+ upgrades. Random upgrades, prestige, perks and many more features!
Why similar: God Game 21.3% ★, Idler 20.2%, Incremental 18%, Management 9.9%, Economy 9.6%
- #30 Apiary in Flow
77% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: AkinoEgo
Windows
Apiary in Flow is an incremental game with automation elements where you place bees inside a hive to build efficient honey-gathering chains. Unlock new bee types and spend your harvest on permanent skill tree upgrades!
Why similar: Automation 27.3%, Incremental 24.1%, Idler 22.7%, Management 6.4%, Economy 5.5%
- #31 Buerokratie Idler: Germany
76% match7 user reviews86% of 7 reviews2026
Dev: AKM Interactive
Windows
Process forms, stamp paperwork, and turn a tiny office into an absurd bureaucracy machine. A satirical idle/clicker game about fictional German-style administration - absolutely not official.
Why similar: Automation 23.8%, Idler 23.5%, Incremental 20.3%, Management 9.6%, Economy 9.6%
- #32 The Rift Machine
77% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Mechayaan
Windows
The Rift Machine is an incremental game where you extract resources from inter-dimensional anomalies. Build modular defenses, research advanced technology, automate complex systems, and scale your operation into an unstoppable anomaly-harvesting engine.
Why similar: Automation 19.1%, Incremental 18.3%, Idler 18%, Management 10.3%, Economy 9.9%
- #33 Planetfall: Endless Wave
76% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Ryan McDougallPub: Highland Forge Games
Windows
Planetfall: Endless Wave is an idle incremental base-defence game with a classic RTS look. Survive endless waves of alien invaders by upgrading turrets, fortifications, and troops as the battlefield grows more hostile with every wave.
Why similar: Incremental 21.9%, Automation 20%, Idler 19.8%, Capitalism 18.8%, Management 10.2%
- #34 Garbage Growth
73% matchVery Positive92% of 340 reviews2026
Dev: apepatrickdev
Windows
Garbage Growth is a short incremental trash game about collecting people's trash, bananas and even babies, to make money and pollute the world even more. Hire rats, grow your pollution, and make everything worse!
Why similar: Automation 24.6%, Idler 22.9%, Incremental 20.4%, Economy 12.2%, Management 8.3%
- #35 A Game About Creating The Universe
75% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Dream Dimension
Windows
An idler game where you get to build up the universe from scratch. You are a part of an advanced space civilization that builds universes.
Why similar: God Game 17.3% ★, Automation 15.6%, Incremental 14.7%, Idler 14.4%, Capitalism 12.4%
- #36 AetherRift
75% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Slade
Windows · Mac · Linux
Place magical constructs around a swirling cosmic rift, chain together exotic energies, and collapse reality to grow stronger in this deep incremental game.
Why similar: Automation 23.2%, Idler 22.2%, Incremental 19.7%, Crafting 12.3%, Management 9.4%
- #37 Infinite Ruins
73% matchMostly Positive75% of 131 reviews2026
Dev: Kileka Games
Windows
An incremental mining game where you manage golems, destroy blocks, unlock upgrades, and descend infinitely in search of ever more valuable resources.
Why similar: Automation 21.6%, Incremental 18.4%, Idler 18.3%, Capitalism 13.9%, Economy 9.3%
- #38 Pyramid Clicker
78% match6 user reviews17% of 6 reviews2024
Dev: DNN
Windows
Pyramid Clicker is a real adventure! Upgrade your perks, buy artifacts that grant incredible bonuses, and experience the power of prestige. This game offers vast opportunities for progression that will keep you hooked for hours on end.
Why similar: Automation 24.8%, Incremental 22.9%, Idler 21.6%, Trading 19.5%, Resource Management 7.7%
- #39 Progress Bar Deluxe
74% matchVery Positive85% of 55 reviews2025
Dev: Diego Schram Games
Windows
Loading, loading, loading… when will it ever be ready? Will you finally see the bar reach 100%? In Progress Bar Deluxe, your mission is simple — fill the ultimate progress bar to 100%! Click, upgrade, and wait as you chase that sweet moment of completion.
Why similar: Incremental 20.3%, Automation 20%, Idler 19.4%, Economy 13.2%, Management 10.2%
- #40 Flower Tower
73% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Pmdk23
Windows
A short, relaxing incremental game about growing flowers, where your garden quietly thrives and blooms on its own.
Why similar: Automation 26.7%, Idler 24%, Incremental 16.8%, Management 6.9%, Capitalism 6.4%
- #41 挂机修仙-宗门飞升
74% matchMixed65% of 31 reviews2025
Dev: The Fat Worker
Windows
A casual idle game of the xianxia genre. 一款修仙类型的挂机休闲小游戏。经营你的宗门,通过修真六艺--炼丹、炼器、阵法、符箓、傀儡、驯兽不断获得资源,助你的宗门不断的晋升品阶。
Why similar: Idler 25.8%, God Game 23.1% ★, Incremental 22.5%, Automation 21.8%, Simulation 4.9%
- #42 Marketfield Idle
72% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Pollikk Studios
Windows · Mac · Linux
Marketfield Idle is all about growing crops, selling goods, cooking recipes, automating production, and prestige into stronger runs in a cozy incremental farming game with 1200+ upgrades, strategy paths, and lots of synergies to discover.
Why similar: Incremental 22.8%, Automation 22.8%, Idler 20.8%, Capitalism 11%, Strategy 7.4%
- #43 Scratch Inc.
71% matchVery Positive91% of 2,102 reviews2025
Dev: Makopaz
Windows · Mac
Build an Empire, From Scratch, in this Scratch Card Idle/Incremental game.
Why similar: Automation 23.8%, Idler 23.1%, Incremental 21%, Capitalism 13.4%, Economy 8.7%
- #44 AutoShowRoom
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: haiooohai
Windows
AutoShowRoom is a small relaxing incremental game about managing your own car showroom! Collect +100 unique cars from 10 different countries! Tune them to perfection and showcase them in thrilling events! Unlock new models and expand your collection! Build the ulitimate car showroom!
Why similar: Idler 23.6%, Incremental 20.6%, Capitalism 11.7%, Management 11%, Economy 10.5%
- #45 Asciinsion
70% matchNo user reviews
Dev: omnipolar studio
Windows · Mac · Linux
Immerse yourself in the world of ASCII art. Create works of art from characters. Build factories, upgrade them, and expand your production capacity. Invest in blueprints and reach milestones to earn bonuses. Use the ascension system for additional benefits.
Why similar: Incremental 23.8%, Idler 22.5%, Automation 13.7%, Management 8.6%, Economy 8.6%
- #46 Idle Baker Boss
72% matchMostly Positive73% of 161 reviews2025
Dev: Doopwee Games
Windows
Grow your bakery franchise and manage bakeries in this cute idle tycoon game with over 150 desserts, 100+ in game awards, daily challenges, skill tree system, events each month with unique desserts and much more...
Why similar: Automation 22.3%, Idler 19%, Incremental 16.9%, Capitalism 14.6%, Management 9.8%
- #47 Idle Energy
70% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Shadow Games Software
Windows
A small game about pushing the world forward, one crank at a time. Sell energy at the Market, build power plants, and climb from a manual workshop through eight eras to star-spanning cosmic civilization. Offline. No microtransactions or ads.
Why similar: Idler 24.9%, Incremental 21.6%, Automation 16.7%, Capitalism 12.6%, Economy 8.1%
- #48 Cosmic Clicker
70% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Gladino
Windows · Linux
Build a cosmic energy empire in this colorful incremental sci-fi game. Click, automate production, unlock technologies, explore distant planets, collect artifacts, raise cosmic pets, and ascend to unlock permanent upgrades.
Why similar: Incremental 22.8%, Automation 22.7%, Idler 20.7%, Economy 11.9%, Resource Management 7.2%
- #49 Kukinta
69% matchNo user reviews
Dev: polylion
Windows
Step into Kukinta, a unique blend of city-building and idle crafting. Assemble resources and refine them into complex goods to develop your island community. Let your strategic skills blossom. In Kukinta, every resource shapes the skyline of your serene retreat.
Why similar: God Game 30.4% ★, Incremental 17%, Idler 16.9%, Capitalism 12%, Crafting 7.7%
- #50 Scrap Yard Idle
68% match2 user reviews0% of 2 reviews2026
Dev: David SecoPub: HeadArrow
Windows
Build your own scrap empire in this incremental idle game. Collect, process, and automate your production chain while optimizing resources and scaling your industrial system.
Why similar: Incremental 24.7%, Automation 23.7%, Management 12.1%, Economy 9.3%, Crafting 8.6%
- #51 Bottle Flip Inc
69% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Gamechill
Windows
An incremental game about flipping bottles, unlocking and upgrading unique abilities, and turning simple bottle flips into increasingly satisfying moments.
Why similar: Incremental 24.6%, Idler 22.4%, Automation 17%, Strategy 8.4%, Economy 6.3%
- #52 Cursor Kingdom
68% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Oba Games
Windows
Create an army of cursor clones by recording your actions. Automate resource gathering, production, and defense while your kingdom grows on its own.
Why similar: Automation 29.7%, Incremental 20%, Idler 18.6%, Management 10.4%, Economy 9.5%
- #53 Hoplings
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Mirrawz
Windows · Linux
CLICK > JUMP > GAIN JUMP BUCKS > BUY UPGRADES > JUMP MORE !!! Hoplings is a hand-crafted pixel art clicker/incremental game that is sure to keep you hopping for more!
Why similar: Automation 26.7%, Incremental 25.2%, Idler 22.8%, Management 11.7%, Strategy 3.6%
- #54 Clout Chaser
68% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Dream Dimension
Windows
Clout Chaser is an idler/incremental game where you chase fame.
Why similar: Incremental 17.4%, Idler 17.1%, Automation 17%, Capitalism 13.2%, Economy 11.4%
- #55 CEO.exe
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Förstly
Windows
An idle game about becoming CEO, played entirely on a simulated 1990s office PC. File paperwork by hand, automate it away, hire the staff who replace you — then scheme your way through the boardroom. Every mechanic is a program on the desktop.
Why similar: Automation 23.3%, Idler 21.2%, Incremental 19.2%, Economy 11.8%, Management 10.3%
- #56 Silicon Architect
67% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: BiteMe Games
Windows · Mac
An incremental hardware engineering game with a Windows XP themed UI. Configure and optimize processor components, build your own CPU, and run automated benchmarks. Harvest telemetry and gather research funding to unlock new hardware, and scale your processing power.
Why similar: Automation 19.3%, Incremental 18.6%, Idler 15%, Capitalism 13.8%, Crafting 9.4%
- #57 Resources Assemble!
66% matchNo user reviews
Dev: lasarevs
Windows · Linux
Build, automate, and expand your factory. Mine resources, craft components, and evolve your systems toward full autonomy and interplanetary production
Why similar: Automation 27.4%, Idler 22.8%, Crafting 13.4%, Management 10.3%, Strategy 7.6%
- #58 Idle Tycoon Manufacturing
66% matchPositive94% of 18 reviews2026
Dev: EragonePub: Eragone Games
Windows · Linux
Lead a monster-run industry ! Recruit, upgrade machines, transform ores, and unlock tech. Get rich by mastering strategy and expanding your industrial empire. Ready to conquer the market ?
Why similar: Automation 22.4%, Capitalism 13.8%, Crafting 11.5%, Incremental 11%, Idler 11%
- #59 Idle Weaponshop
71% matchMixed57% of 84 reviews2024
Dev: Deki
Windows
In Idle Weaponshop, you are handed your very own weapon shop to manage. Design and sell weapons, build up your local community, hire employees, and send adventurers off into danger for fun and profit... all before prestiging to earn powerful bonuses, all so you can do it all over again.
Why similar: Idler 20.8%, Capitalism 20%, Incremental 17.8%, Automation 14.3%, Management 11%
- #60 CapitalismCraft
69% matchPositive95% of 22 reviews2025
Dev: Most Dangerous Games
Windows · Mac
Welcome to the wonderful world of capitalism! Exploit your workers to earn money! Hire managers to crush their spirits and drive them harder, then fire them once you’ve achieved your ends! Be agile, ruthless, merciless, become the richest CEO in the world, winning in rapid clicker management!
Why similar: God Game 31.6% ★, Incremental 18.6%, Capitalism 14.4%, 1990's 12.9%, Idler 5%