- #1 Happy Cookies
78% match2 user reviews50% of 2 reviews2025
Dev: HUANG YIMING
Windows
Happy Cookies is a click-based simulation business game that can be fully experienced with just the left and right mouse buttons. Players need to decorate the cookies with chips by clicking on the surface of the cookies to make money.
Why similar: Clicker 31.9%, Idler 22.5%, Roguelike 12.9%, Roguelite 10.5%, Casual 7.2%
- #2 Timber Rush
69% matchVery Positive85% of 416 reviews2026
Dev: Allerton Apps
Windows · Mac
Median: 5.7 hrsMean: 6.8 hrs≥1hr: 83%
Timber Rush is a fast-paced incremental roguelite where every swing explodes into upgrades, chaos, and massive numbers.
Why similar: Idler 30.7%, Clicker 18.8%, Roguelike 13.1%, Roguelite 12.8%, Relaxing 10%
- #3 ClickShot
70% matchMixed52% of 21 reviews2025
Dev: ApeXPloit Studios
Windows
Lock, Load, Click. A slick clicker game where every click pulls the trigger. Earn shells, unlock wild gun cosmetics, and stack permanent multipliers. Simple to play, hard to quit. Lock, load, and click your way to glory.
Why similar: Clicker 31.3%, Idler 28%, Automation 13.4%, Simulation 6.7%, Casual 6%
- #4 Cascadium
70% matchNo user reviews
Dev: ABoxWithinABox
Windows
A simple idle game where you drop balls plinko-style to make money. Big number make head go brrrr.
Why similar: Clicker 36.4%, Idler 32.2%, Relaxing 9.6%, Simulation 7.8%, Casual 7.1%
- #5 Apple Clicker!
70% matchMostly Positive72% of 383 reviews2024
Dev: Chair Studios
Windows · Mac · Linux
How do you like them apples? Because we have them all! Have time in the game or click the apple to get your favorite apple.
Why similar: Clicker 35.9%, Idler 27.4%, Rhythm 12.8%, Automation 10.4%, Relaxing 6.2%
- #6 Don't kill the fish
69% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2025
Dev: YMY Games
Windows · Linux
Bring home a digital fish, care for your new aquatic buddy in a cozy corner of your screen, and remember, DON'T KILL THE FISH!
Why similar: Rhythm 30.6%, Clicker 25.1%, Idler 24.8%, Relaxing 6.1%, Simulation 3.5%
- #7 Bricknosis
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Mike Make Game
Windows
Break bricks to earn stuff to buy things to break more bricks. Half idle brick breaker, half clicker fidget spinner. Fullscreen it or drag it in a corner.
Why similar: Idler 31%, Clicker 21.9%, Roguelite 10.4%, Relaxing 8.6%, Automation 7%
- #8 Disco Bear
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Efe Berk Ucar
Windows
Disco Bear is a joyful clicker game where you spread good vibes and light up the dance floor!
Why similar: Clicker 37.4%, Idler 35.6%, Relaxing 8.2%, Casual 5.8%, 2D 5.3%
- #9 Elliot's Great Symphony
68% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2025
Dev: Ruisu DesignPub: Gigantic G
Windows
Join Elliot Taylor in a musical roguelike adventure to master a legendary 20-minute symphony and awaken his inspiration.
Why similar: Rhythm 46.6%, Roguelite 19.6%, Roguelike 15.4%, Casual 6.9%, Fantasy 5%
- #10 Fusion Core: Black Hole
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: ThreePlate
Windows · Mac
Experience a satisfying cosmic idle game where you control an all-consuming black hole. Devour thousands of atoms to build your mass and expand your reach. Unleash a Singularity Collapse to reset the universe, harvest rare Antimatter, and purchase permanent upgrades for your core.
Why similar: Clicker 40.2%, Idler 35.3%, Relaxing 10.5%, Casual 7.8%, 2D 5.3%
- #11 Huebound
66% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2026
Dev: Dan Hicks
Windows
Mix light. Discover color. Idle forever. Place geometric nodes, connect them, and watch colored orbs flow through your factory. Combine primaries to create 256 named colors — each one waiting to be discovered.
Why similar: Idler 32%, Roguelite 12.9%, Clicker 12.7%, Relaxing 7.9%, Roguelike 7.6%
- #12 High Risk
65% match2 user reviews50% of 2 reviews2026
Dev: Lutte Games
Windows
An incremental investment game where you’re never safe. You bet your money, sign high-risk contracts, and buy upgrades knowing one bad decision can wipe you out.
Why similar: Clicker 28.2%, Idler 26.9%, Roguelike 16.4%, Roguelite 15.3%, Casual 8.3%
- #13 Nomad Idle
65% matchMixed65% of 848 reviews2025
Dev: The Fox Knocks
Windows
Median: 28.3 hrsMean: 62.7 hrs≥1hr: 97%
Face waves of enemies automatically and create builds by distributing stat points, leveling up equipment, choosing passive skills, summons and more. An idle game about killing hordes of enemies, becoming stronger, and exploring an unfolding storyline. A spin-off of Nomad Survival.
Why similar: Idler 24.2%, Clicker 22.1%, Roguelite 13.2%, Roguelike 10.3%, Auto Battler 8.1%
- #14 Idle Library
63% matchMixed62% of 13 reviews2026
Dev: DaZeSTRAY
Windows
Turn a small reading room into a legendary archive of knowledge in this relaxing idle incremental game featuring research upgrades, prestige progression, and offline growth
Why similar: Clicker 33%, Idler 31.6%, Casual 8.6%, Automation 8%, Colorful 6.6%
- #15 Toilet Paper Idle
65% matchNo user reviews
Dev: CHIZ
Windows
Toilet Paper Idle is an incremental game about consuming as much toilet papers as possible with the help of helpers, skills, and upgrades. Discover special types of toilet papers as you progress, and be careful to not clog your toilet!
Why similar: Idler 40.2%, Clicker 36.1%, Simulation 7.1%, Casual 5.1%, Relaxing 4.4%
- #16 An Incremental Game About Placing Blocks
64% matchNo user reviews
Dev: _Taralis
Windows
A short incremental game about placing blocks and filling spaces.
Why similar: Clicker 34.4%, Idler 30.9%, Automation 8.7%, Relaxing 8.7%, Casual 7.4%
- #17 Maktala: Slime Lootfest
62% matchVery Positive81% of 1,078 reviews2025
Dev: Samharia Studios
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 6.6 hrsMean: 7.1 hrs≥1hr: 94%
An incremental game where you kill hordes of slimes and use their loot to become stronger and farm them. Collect powerful loot, master skills, and uncover tons of content.
Why similar: Clicker 26.1%, Idler 23.2%, Roguelite 13%, Auto Battler 8.2%, Roguelike 7.9%
- #18 Sandfall: Rock Smash
64% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Portly Poet Gaming
Windows
Smash rocks with hammer. Sand falls in cart. Make money. Repeat.
Why similar: Clicker 38.2%, Idler 35.8%, Relaxing 11.6%, Casual 11.6%, Indie 1.9%
- #19 Auto Snakes in Outer Space
62% matchMostly Positive72% of 90 reviews2026
Dev: Old Atlas
Windows
A slow and meditative incremental idler where you manage colorful snakes. Watch them collect food, then spend the food on upgrades and abilities for your colony.
Why similar: Idler 38.8%, Clicker 34.7%, Relaxing 8.8%, Casual 5.8%, Colorful 5.5%
- #20 BAR
64% matchMostly Positive71% of 21 reviews2025
Dev: TechieMay
Windows
Bar is a colorful incremental game with complex gameplay mechanics built around filling the bar. Filling the bar gives you rewards that allow you to fill the bar even faster. Unlock various upgrades to fill the bar at absurd rates.
Why similar: Clicker 24.4%, Idler 23.5%, Roguelite 11.9%, Roguelike 11.8%, Automation 9.7%
- #21 Beat The Odds
64% matchNo user reviews
Dev: LonelyOcelot
Windows
Take your chances against RNG and see how high you can roll. Can you Beat the Odds?
Why similar: Clicker 25.8%, Idler 25.8%, Roguelite 14.5%, Roguelike 13.1%, Relaxing 7.6%
- #22 Idle Universe Creator
66% matchNo user reviews2025
Dev: Timothy Bexon
Windows
Compete against others to create a universe in the shortest time in a unique take on the idle game genre. In Idle Universe Creator, your task is to craft atoms to fill an empty universe. Will you recreate our universe or craft brand new ones? What matters is how fast you can reach the target mass.
Why similar: Clicker 37.4%, Idler 35.3%, Relaxing 11.5%, Casual 11.1%, 2D 3.8%
- #23 Crypto Clicker
67% matchMixed67% of 69 reviews2022
Dev: Hakugei LLC
Windows
Exactly what it sounds like, a clicker game based around crypto.
Why similar: Clicker 40.1%, Idler 35.4%, Relaxing 10.6%, Casual 8.8%, 2D 4.4%
- #24 Click and Spell
64% matchNo user reviews
Dev: rami
Windows
A tiny clicker game that sits on the corner of your screen. Kill monsters, earn gold and buy upgrades to level up (even when you're idle). Unlock cosmetics to customize your character. Watch the numbers increase non-stop and become a powerful witch!
Why similar: Clicker 34.3%, Idler 31.2%, Relaxing 9%, Casual 7.2%, Fantasy 5.2%
- #25 KIDNEY STONE Clicker
67% match3 user reviews50% of 4 reviews2023
Dev: Takumi Abe
Windows
KIDNEY STONE Clicker is a Simple Clicker idle game but odd theme. Kidney stones by clicking rapidly on the screen to break them down into smaller pieces. Collect stone for power-ups and make your body healthy.
Why similar: Clicker 40.4%, Idler 35.6%, Relaxing 9.5%, Casual 8.9%, 2D 4.9%
- #26 Slimazing
64% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Resurrected Studio
Windows
Kill slimes. Collect juice. Upgrade your power. Craft potions and defeat elites and bosses in this juicy incremental roguelite.
Why similar: Idler 31.7%, Clicker 28.5%, Colorful 9.3%, Casual 7%, Roguelike 5.1%
- #27 Revolution Idle
61% matchVery Positive86% of 10,339 reviews2025
Dev: Oni Gaming
Windows
Median: 17.4 hrsMean: 167.7 hrs≥1hr: 83%
Join an experience where each revolution takes you further into the unknown! Revolution Idle challenges you to multiply your accumulators to reach unimaginable heights. Will you manage to reach infinity?
Why similar: Idler 37.9%, Clicker 28.8%, Automation 12.4%, Simulation 6.3%, Casual 5.4%
- #28 Flag Clicker
63% matchMixed64% of 539 reviews2024
Dev: Flag Clicker InteractivePub: Flag Clicker interactive
Windows
Flag is a clicker Game, in which you click a Flag!
Why similar: Clicker 44.1%, Idler 37.4%, Casual 8.5%, 2D 5.5%, Indie 3.6%
- #29 The DvD idle game
62% matchPositive83% of 23 reviews2025
Dev: Cybo3DPub: Extreme Fission
Windows
Remember the old bouncing DvD screensaver? Well now its an idle game, Bounce DvD's all over the screen and increase your profits, and a lot of 2000's technology will come up as shops
Why similar: Idler 33.6%, Clicker 23.4%, Stylized 10.4%, Automation 7.2%, Relaxing 6.3%
- #30 When Civilians Dig Holes
63% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Nina Demirjian
Windows · Mac
An incremental game about digging a hole to the other side of the world.
Why similar: Idler 37.6%, Clicker 32%, Simulation 8.9%, Casual 7.5%, Colorful 5.3%
- #31 Pixel Clicker
63% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: MaxGameDev
Windows
A pixel art-style clicker game where you tap to blast pixels and bosses, upgrade, automate, and travel through diverse biomes, from lush jungles to the far reaches of space, all wrapped in an immersive soundscape. Climb the leaderboard and become the ultimate pixel boss.
Why similar: Clicker 37.8%, Idler 28.7%, Automation 13.5%, Casual 6.1%, Relaxing 5.7%
- #32 The Endless Village
63% matchNo user reviews
Dev: R.J. Brontsema
Windows · Mac · Linux
Automate your growth, uncover a gorgeous city, and chase the ultimate metric: Liveliness. This cozy idle clicker lets you unlock passive income boosts and powerful minigames to rapidly scale your empire. Attract every unique citizen and claim your spot on the global leaderboard!
Why similar: Idler 37.9%, Clicker 32.1%, Simulation 10.1%, Relaxing 6.2%, Colorful 5.3%
- #33 Neuro Clicker
62% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Andrii DanchukPub: Duxastr Studio
Windows · Mac
Neuro Clicker is a casual incremental idle game where you build up a system neuron, collect IQ and coins, unlock powerful upgrades, and deal with chaotic mini-games. As the neuron evolves, Clippy uncovers lost memory fragments and gets closer to remembering who she really is.
Why similar: Clicker 26.3%, Idler 25.2%, Roguelite 13.3%, Casual 7.9%, Automation 7.3%
- #34 Super Stroke The Pants
62% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2025
Dev: Cockroach Studio
Windows
Stroke your special pants! This game is super easy! All you have to do is click and hold! Your score will accumulate and achievements will be unlocked! You are free to keep your score at 100 or become the king of pants! You can enjoy it for the price of a cup of coffee!
Why similar: Clicker 31.6%, Idler 29.7%, Casual 10.1%, Automation 9.3%, Relaxing 7.1%
- #35 Lu[Idle]
62% matchMixed65% of 31 reviews2025
Dev: Joshua Sherrard
Windows · Linux
Lu[Idle] is an Incremental game with Idle and Clicker elements as well as pixel art visuals and music.
Why similar: Clicker 38.3%, Idler 37.5%, Simulation 9.2%, Casual 6.1%, 2D 5.6%
- #36 Meat Outdoors
62% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Light Island
Windows
Clicker game about cooking meat and recruit a variety of helping hands to collect your meat.
Why similar: Clicker 33.5%, Idler 30.3%, Automation 8.9%, Casual 7.1%, Stylized 6.5%
- #37 Christmas Tree Clicker
62% matchNo user reviews
Dev: FenixPub: -
Windows
Get Christmas Tree companion for your Desktop! Earn quintillion Gifts, open thousands of this and find all the Toys to decorate your Dream Christmas Tree in the new gambling Clicker!
Why similar: Clicker 34.8%, Idler 31.6%, Relaxing 7.6%, Casual 7%, Simulation 6.3%
- #38 GRIND MOMO
61% match2 user reviews0% of 2 reviews2025
Dev: BaratazsPub: Baratazs INC
Windows
**Grind Momo** is a **clicker** where you work 💼 by clicking to earn money 💰 and invest in stocks 📈, crypto 🪙, and businesses 🏭. Buy properties 🏠 and vehicles 🚗 to rent, craft items or sell in the market. Use prestige 🔄 for upgrades and unlock bonuses 🎯. Customize 🎨 and grow! 🚀
Why similar: Clicker 41.6%, Idler 36.8%, Casual 8.1%, Colorful 5.6%, 2D 5.6%
- #39 Katakamuna Idle
62% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Hapiwaku
Windows · Mac
Experience cosmic harmony in this Katakamuna-inspired idle game. Gather "Ka," the essence of all existence, and weave the 80 verses of the Katakamuna Utahi. As an idle game, actions automate as you progress, allowing you to create harmony through color and sound, even when offline.
Why similar: Idler 22%, Clicker 20.5%, Roguelike 11.4%, Roguelite 11.4%, Automation 10.7%
- #40 SCRIMBLO SCRAMBLE
61% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: OBJECT OBSERVER
Windows
Put it all on the line in this roulette-themed incremental game where you torment your scrimblos in order to manage and eventually escape hell.
Why similar: Clicker 39.2%, Idler 34.6%, Automation 10.6%, Casual 8.6%, 2D 4.8%
- #41 Shape Sweeper
61% match7 user reviews86% of 7 reviews2025
Dev: Code SwordPub: Half Slice Studio
Windows
Shape Sweeper is a idle game where robotic vacuums collect geometric shapes. Deploy PolyBots, merge them to create more powerful collectors, and build your shape-sweeping empire! Huge amount of tech tree upgrades to select from!
Why similar: Clicker 31.2%, Idler 30.6%, Simulation 7.6%, Colorful 6.8%, Casual 6.5%
- #42 Dopaminer
61% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Otto Development
Windows · Mac
Dopaminer lets you do the most scientifically accurate thing possible: click Synapse bits that reward you with Dopamine. Upgrade your neural rig by stacking upgrades, unlock new tiers, automate progress, and Rewire to prestige. Spend Synapse Points for permanent perks and watch each run accelerate.
Why similar: Clicker 41.5%, Idler 39%, Casual 12.6%, 2D 5.8%, Singleplayer 1%
- #43 Lobstpurr
61% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Goodguy140
Windows · Mac · Linux
This is a clicker game with the following features:UpgradesCustomizationsAnti-Auto ClickerPurr Pass
Why similar: Clicker 43.6%, Idler 38.7%, Casual 9.5%, 2D 4.9%, Indie 2.6%
- #44 Every Last Bit
61% matchNo user reviews
Dev: QubitGames
Windows · Mac
An incremental arcade game about scanning files by collecting bits, bytes and Gigabytes. Can you collect Every Last Bit?
Why similar: Idler 43.2%, Clicker 38.3%, Casual 6.3%, Relaxing 5.7%, 2D 3%
- #45 Coin Hoarder
60% match8 user reviews63% of 8 reviews2025
Dev: JLY Games
Windows
Click, collect, and ascend! Coin Hoarder is an addictive idle/incremental game in the spirit of Cookie Clicker and other greats, with endless upgrades, ascensions, and achievements.
Why similar: Clicker 33.5%, Idler 30.3%, Automation 12.1%, Simulation 8.4%, Casual 7.2%
- #46 Meeple Incremental
61% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Simply Artizan
Windows · Mac · Linux
Roll dice to move Meeples around the board and collect money, skill points, and capsule tickets. Unlock unique skills and minigames, powerful collectibles, and automate dice rolls to increase your income.
Why similar: Clicker 35.8%, Idler 32%, Relaxing 9.7%, Automation 8.7%, Casual 6.9%
- #47 Alchemist's Garden
61% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Lumis Entertainment
Windows · Mac
Relax in Alchemist's Garden, a cozy incremental crafting game. Forage to uncover hidden ingredients across mystical lands. Experiment at your crucible to discover potion recipes, stock your shop's shelves, and watch your potion shop grow!
Why similar: Clicker 36.5%, Idler 32.7%, Crafting 8.8%, Relaxing 6.8%, Casual 5.7%
- #48 Idle Pixel Fantasy
58% matchMostly Positive79% of 761 reviews2025
Dev: Max Ritters
Windows
Median: 6.2 hrsMean: 21.7 hrs≥1hr: 87%
Recruit hard-working helpers and magical creatures that automatically collect gold and crystals. Unlock new levels, invest in stronger units, and work your way up to the powerful dragon boss at the top. A relaxing pixel-style idle clicker!
Why similar: Clicker 36.2%, Idler 33.9%, Automation 13.4%, Casual 6.3%, Fantasy 4.9%
- #49 Pickle Clicker
63% matchVery Positive88% of 1,241 reviews2022
Dev: Shard
Windows
Click pickle, get pickle, spend pickle, get more pickle, and most importantly... Protect pickle from sneaky Poglins!
Why similar: Clicker 42.9%, Idler 40%, 2D 6.3%, Casual 6.3%, Indie 3.3%
- #50 Incrempire
60% matchNo user reviews
Dev: FMGames
Windows · Mac · Linux
Defend. Upgrade. Dominate. A relaxing incremental base-defense game, packed with powerful skills and a deep skill tree.
Why similar: Clicker 24.1%, Idler 23.3%, Roguelite 13.6%, Roguelike 10.1%, Relaxing 8.5%
- #51 Plantastic
60% matchMixed60% of 20 reviews2025
Dev: BlueBathtub
Windows
🌿 Over 30 plant species 🎩 Unlockable hats & accessories to customize ⏳ Idle game for desktop – runs in the background 🎁 Regular drops, items & collecting fun 🌍 Proceeds go towards real tree planting projects 🪴 Perfect for work, study & relaxing sessions
Why similar: Clicker 36.7%, Idler 34.8%, Casual 10.6%, Stylized 6.8%, Colorful 5.9%
- #52 Color Idle
60% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Benjamin StaugaardPub: Benzoft
Windows
Color Idle is a relaxing idle clicker where art paints itself! Click to color pixel art, complete quests, and unlock chapters of unique artwork. Earn gold, ascend for upgrades, recruit drones, and unlock hundreds of achievements as each masterpiece comes to life pixel by pixel.
Why similar: Clicker 29.3%, Idler 28.5%, Relaxing 9.8%, Automation 9.1%, Simulation 7.1%
- #53 挂机修仙-宗门飞升
59% matchMixed68% of 28 reviews2025
Dev: The Fat Worker
Windows
A casual idle game of the xianxia genre. 一款修仙类型的挂机休闲小游戏。经营你的宗门,通过修真六艺--炼丹、炼器、阵法、符箓、傀儡、驯兽不断获得资源,助你的宗门不断的晋升品阶。
Why similar: Idler 35%, Clicker 29.8%, Automation 11.9%, Simulation 8.8%, Casual 7.5%
- #54 Tiny Biomes: Cozy Idle
57% matchVery Positive89% of 177 reviews2026
Dev: Orca Point Studio
Windows
Tiny Biomes is a relaxing idle game where animals peacefully produce resources and you gather wood in a calm harvesting zone. Build small biomes, earn gold, and enjoy steady progression without pressure, timers, or stress. Play at your own pace and unwind.
Why similar: Idler 32.3%, Clicker 28.2%, Relaxing 10.1%, Automation 8.6%, Casual 5.6%
- #55 Cube Foundry
59% matchMixed40% of 43 reviews2026
Dev: Jabran
Windows
In the beginning was the Void. Then came the Click. Forge reality across generators, upgrades, minigames, and infinite NG+ cycles. Draw cards, brew potions, unravel cosmic lore, and ascend through the creation itself. The Architects are watching.
Why similar: Idler 36.3%, Clicker 32.4%, Automation 16.4%, Relaxing 5.6%, Casual 3.2%
- #56 Loop My Crank
59% matchMixed46% of 13 reviews2025
Dev: GameRoom3 Studio
Windows
A ridiculous clicker where cranking handles becomes a cult. Upgrade your cranks, recruit spinners, and embrace the infinite loop. Always spin. Never stop.
Why similar: Clicker 29.9%, Idler 28.5%, Roguelike 16.9%, Casual 8.7%, Relaxing 5.3%
- #57 Click And Adventure
59% match2 user reviews50% of 2 reviews2025
Dev: day_dream
Windows
"Click and Adventure" is a relaxing, compact click-based idle game. Explore by clicking, consume health points to defeat various monsters, obtain treasure chests, unlock the encyclopedia, increase passive income, upgrade skills, unlock new maps, and defeat new monsters.
Why similar: Idler 36.3%, Clicker 32.1%, Casual 12.3%, Relaxing 9.3%, Simulation 9.2%
- #58 Protorogo
59% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2025
Dev: Jeremiah ZagalaPub: Mojogames
Windows
Protorogo is an idle roguelite with a focus on ability synergies and strategy for defeating progressively more difficult waves of enemies.
Why similar: Clicker 21.6%, Idler 19.6%, Roguelite 17.4%, Roguelike 12.3%, Auto Battler 10.9%
- #59 Refence
59% matchMostly Positive79% of 140 reviews2025
Dev: Muurou Tech
Windows · Mac · Linux
Refence is a roguelite based idle defense game, where you can choose heroes and their traits, upgrade your castle, and manage resources to fend off enemies from the Demon Realm who are trying to attack your castle.
Why similar: Idler 23.4%, Clicker 23.2%, Roguelite 15.3%, Roguelike 11.7%, Relaxing 7.4%
- #60 Penguin Ascension
58% matchMixed50% of 10 reviews2026
Dev: noodle
Windows
A cozy pixel-art idle clicker where you click for Fish, buy upgrades, trigger random events, and Rebirth for Golden Krill to unlock permanent prestige boosts and absurd arctic progression.
Why similar: Clicker 33%, Idler 29.9%, Automation 14.1%, Relaxing 6.6%, Simulation 5.8%