- #1 TCG Master Trader
97% matchMostly Positive71% of 78 reviews2025
Dev: DURINKOSU
Windows
Claim a free pack of cards every few hours and expand your collection! Discover hundreds of unique cards with different styles, rarities, and visual effects.
Why similar: Trading Card Game 39.8% ★, Card Game 26.4%, Trading 19.4%, Casual 6.4%, Relaxing 4.8%
- #2 Banana-Shaped
96% matchMixed42% of 65 reviews2024
Dev: SeluGames
Windows
Banana-Shape is a clicker Game, in which you click on the banana shape!Win random banana shapes and grow your collection! Come hang out with us and let's become the kings of banana shapes!
Why similar: Trading Card Game 36.9% ★, Incremental 29.3%, Point & Click 15.1%, Casual 9.2%, Funny 6.2%
- #3 Cats-Shaped
96% matchMostly Negative36% of 56 reviews2024
Dev: SeluGames
Windows
Cats-Shape is a clicker game, in which you click on a cat shape!Earn random cat shapes to grow your collection!Come hang out with us and let's become the kings of cat shapes!
Why similar: Trading Card Game 44.2% ★, Incremental 21.5%, Point & Click 16.5%, Casual 8%, Funny 6.3%
- #4 Click the Chick
95% matchMixed52% of 64 reviews2024
Dev: OWO Games
Windows
The chick hungers for the click! Are you ready to click it and be the clicker of the chick?! Chirp, Chirp, Chirp!
Why similar: Trading Card Game 28.8% ★, Trading 20.5%, Memes 19.5%, Incremental 15.4%, Relaxing 5.4%
- #5 Cards!
94% matchMixed65% of 125 reviews2025
Dev: Good And Bad Games Corp
Windows
A unique collectibe idle clicker game with droppable Steam cards
Why similar: Trading Card Game 49.6% ★, Incremental 23.2%, Card Game 21.6%, Relaxing 4.4%, 2D 1.2%
- #6 Cards, the Universe and Everything
94% matchMostly Positive78% of 276 reviews2025
Dev: Avid Games
Windows
Median: 1.0 hrsMean: 33.7 hrs≥1hr: 52%
Cards, the Universe and Everything is a unique trading card game with almost limitless possibilities: Dinosaurs, Norse gods, blue-footed boobies, Samurai, volcanoes, even the god particle. With the universe’s thingamabobs and endless strategies, are you ready for this gloriously bonkers game?
Why similar: Trading Card Game 27.8% ★, Trading 18.7%, Card Battler 16.9%, Card Game 14%, Tabletop 13.6%
- #7 Car Clicker
93% matchMostly Negative38% of 104 reviews2024
Dev: cem99Pub: online99
Windows
Car Clicker is a clicker Game, in which you click a Car! In Car you click the Car to gain even more Cars! Every 1 and 18 hours, you get dropped a car. Each cars is also made by the community in discord. Come hang out with us and let's grow into something awesome !
Why similar: Incremental 36.1%, Point & Click 30.5%, Casual 16.4%, Relaxing 11.1%, 2D 5.9%
- #8 Lootbawx
92% matchMixed61% of 84 reviews2024
Dev: Gadzoox Gaming
Windows
The ONLY clicker game with wear value on items! Collect and trade unique items by opening a LOOTBAWX! You'll be occasionally awarded loot boxes that are free to open. Join our discord where you can contribute and have some fun.
Why similar: Incremental 58.2%, Point & Click 29.3%, Casual 12.5%
- #9 Fruits
91% matchMixed46% of 84 reviews2024
Dev: Studio Gygax
Windows
You get a fruit every fixed hours of game time, each fruit is different it ranges from rarity, fruit and a multiplier to your basket clicking. You can also chop any unwanted fruit into fruit bits and use those to craft another fruit Each fruits and bits can be traded and sold.
Why similar: Trading 32.1%, Incremental 23.5%, Memes 19.3%, Funny 9.8%, Relaxing 8.3%
- #10 Click Click Bomb
90% matchVery Positive88% of 57 reviews2025
Dev: chucktowski
Windows
A Giant Bomb inspired clicker-incremental game with unlockables and gimmicks to discover. A casual experience, best enjoyed on a second screen at work. Features moreish Match 3-esque mechanics.
Why similar: Parody 26% ★, Incremental 24.9%, Card Game 19.8%, Memes 13.7%, Relaxing 7.6%
- #11 Creature Card Idle
91% matchMostly Positive72% of 174 reviews2019
Dev: Playsaurus
Windows · Linux
Median: 9.2 hrsMean: 41.8 hrs≥1hr: 82%
Creature Card Idle is an incremental game that fuses strategic grid-based gameplay with the thrill of collecting cards. Experience an evolving journey across expansions, each introducing new mechanics and cards. Play for free without microtransactions.
Why similar: Trading Card Game 29.8% ★, Card Battler 18.9%, Incremental 17.1%, Card Game 16.5%, Puzzle 5.9%
- #12 Newton Coin Web3
89% matchVery Positive84% of 180 reviews2025
Dev: Newton Coin Studio
Windows
Newton Coin This is a clicker game. In the game, you need to click on the Coin. You'll get a random Newton - themed gold coin every three hours. With effort and luck, you can continuously expand your gold coin collection!
Why similar: Card Game 67.5%, Casual 23.1%, Strategy 9.4%
- #13 [2.0.3] MEH 🖥️
89% matchMixed53% of 230 reviews2024
Dev: samuel crevier
Windows
Meh is a game where you click on a computer to earn random computers from time to time. Collect them all!
Why similar: 1980s 23.8%, Incremental 20.6%, 1990's 17.8%, Strategy 11.8%, Casual 10%
- #14 I Can't Believe It's Not Gambling
88% matchVery Positive91% of 1,670 reviews2017
Dev: Mutant Entertainment Studios
Windows · Linux
Median: 1.7 hrsMean: 15.8 hrs≥1hr: 63%
Do you love opening loot crates, but hate the tedious gameplay sessions in between? Our marketing department has the game for you! Unbox random items! Get stuff, but not what you really want! Skate legal and ethical lines! Remember kids, its only a video game, so grab your parents credit card!
Why similar: Memes 27.5%, Parody 25.3% ★, Incremental 16.3%, Point & Click 10.4%, Funny 10.3%
- #15 Collectibles!
87% matchMixed48% of 96 reviews2024
Dev: VERY HUGE CORP.
Windows · Linux
Collectibles! — a true paradise for collectors! Collect unique items, share them with friends, and show off your achievements on the leaderboards!
Why similar: Trading 39.1%, Incremental 28.1%, Funny 11.3%, Relaxing 11.2%, Casual 6.5%
- #16 CoinForge
86% matchMixed55% of 55 reviews2024
Dev: Aleksander Dolny
Windows
CoinForge is a clicker game where you generate S-coins! Click to earn S-coins and exchange them. Try to get your S-Coins every day with every 100 Clicks you press. 3 is max per day. It's time to forge fortune with Coin Forge. Join our community on Discord and help shape the game!
Why similar: Incremental 44.7%, Funny 20.6%, Memes 15.4%, Casual 8.1%, 2D 7.6%
- #17 Stocks
86% matchMixed55% of 80 reviews2025
Dev: envymydisease
Windows
A collector simulator and clicker where you earn rare items just by staying in the game. Collect stylized company “stocks,” track their value, join seasonal updates, and profit!
Why similar: Trading Card Game 50.6% ★, Incremental 22.2%, Trading 21.1%, 2D 3.6%, Casual 2.5%
- #18 Diamond
85% matchMixed47% of 57 reviews2024
Dev: DD-Double-D
Windows
Diamond is the NEW interactive clicker game in town! Simply click the diamond and every 15 minutes you will get a diamond with the chance of receiving one of the ultra rare coveted diamonds!
Why similar: Parody 37.7% ★, Point & Click 17.8%, Funny 13.6%, Relaxing 11.3%, Memes 10.2%
- #19 Pizzeria
84% matchMixed57% of 122 reviews2024
Dev: Green Juice Studios
Windows · Linux
Click to eat delicious pizzas, buy powerful upgrades, and become the ultimate pizza master. Seek out exclusive drops to make your collection unique. Can you get them all? Start clicking now and rise to pizza greatness!
Why similar: Memes 26.6%, Incremental 21.9%, Parody 21.5% ★, Funny 10.3%, Relaxing 6.4%
- #20 Peach Clicker
84% matchMixed58% of 88 reviews2024
Dev: Event Horizon Ltd
Windows
You've clicked on so many bananas, but have you clicked on peaches? 🤔 In Peach Clicker you smack a Peach to get even more Peaches! 😍 Every 3 hours, you get a new peach! 🍑 Come smack some peaches with us!
Why similar: Incremental 36.9%, Trading 33.7%, Funny 9.9%, Casual 9.6%, 2D 5.1%
- #21 SPINNERS
83% matchMostly Positive74% of 139 reviews2024
Dev: Bazura Games
Windows
SPINNERS. You get dropped a spinner every 2 hours 5 times per day. Each spinner is also made by the community in Discord. Come hang out with us and let's grow into something fantastic. Compete with friends, win the most unique item and become a spin master!
Why similar: Incremental 39.9%, Point & Click 22.3%, Funny 16.1%, Relaxing 15.5%, 2D 6.1%
- #22 Cum Clicker
82% matchVery Positive88% of 93 reviews2023
Dev: SPRITE!!
Windows
Do you ever fantasize about having a lot of cum? Yes? Well this is your chance! Click cum, collect cum, upgrade cum. Be patient and you will have all the cum you can ever ask for!
Why similar: Incremental 31.9%, Point & Click 21.9%, Memes 13.4%, Strategy 11.6%, Funny 8%
- #23 DPS IDLE
82% matchMixed63% of 803 reviews2021
Dev: YDKR
Windows
Median: 6.3 hrsMean: 125.5 hrs≥1hr: 78%
Collect cards, upgrade cards, defeat monsters, join guilds and hire heroes. Raise your DPS!
Why similar: Trading Card Game 35.6% ★, Incremental 24%, Card Game 20.9%, Card Battler 11.5%, Casual 3.9%
- #24 Banana & Cucumber
81% matchMixed68% of 2,016 reviews2024
Dev: cem99Pub: Bull Games
Windows
Banana & Cucumber is a clicker Game, in which you click a Banana & Cucumber! In Banana & Cucumber you click the Banana & Cucumber to gain even more Banana & Cucumber!
Why similar: Trading Card Game 40.1% ★, Incremental 39.6%, Relaxing 13.9%, Casual 6.3%
- #25 Ducks
81% matchMixed52% of 176 reviews2024
Dev: The Duck Company
Windows
Enter the universe of NFDs (Non-Fungible Ducks)! Click the duck and earn more ducks. Collect as many limited edition and rare ducks as you can!
Why similar: Trading 40.9%, Incremental 27.8%, Point & Click 15.9%, Funny 11%, 2D 4.4%
- #26 FeeBay Simulator
78% matchVery Positive92% of 180 reviews2026
Dev: Lake Country Games
Windows
Flip fake trading cards for real profit in FeeBay Simulator, a comedic marketplace tycoon game. Snipe underpriced cards from clueless and scammy sellers, grade your best pulls, open mystery lots, rip packs and run your own storefront to build a reselling empire.
Why similar: Trading Card Game 35.8% ★, Trading 19.5%, Incremental 15.9%, Parody 14.7% ★, Card Game 10.8%
- #27 Chicken
79% matchMostly Positive70% of 98 reviews2024
Dev: Flavorless Art
Windows
Chicken is a clicker game, in which you click a Chicken! You click the Chicken to gain even more Chickens! Every 3 hour, random chicken drops. A community that's Chickens. All our Chickens are made with community effort and inspiration, come join the fun!
Why similar: Incremental 40.8%, Point & Click 30.9%, Funny 11.4%, Casual 10.5%, 2D 6.4%
- #28 Banana
75% matchVery Positive82% of 97,051 reviews2024
Dev: SkyPub: Banana Game
Windows · Linux
Median: 3.0 hrsMean: 57.8 hrs≥1hr: 68%
Banana is a clicker Game, in which you click a Banana! In Banana you click the Banana to gain even more Bananas! Every 3 hours, you get dropped a banana. Each banana is also made by the community in discord. Come hang out with us and let's grow into something awesome !
Why similar: Incremental 61.9%, Funny 21.8%, Casual 8.3%, 2D 8%
- #29 Phat Phrog Clicker
78% matchMixed62% of 58 reviews2024
Dev: Phat Phrog Studios
Windows
Join the community of Phat Phrog Clicker enthusiasts today and become the ultimate cute creature collector! Earn 28 unique Steam inventory skins, dropping every 30 minutes of gameplay. These skins can be traded or sold on the Steam Marketplace. Can you collect them all?
Why similar: Incremental 38.9%, Point & Click 27.3%, Puzzle 14.6%, Casual 9.3%, 2D 5.6%
- #30 Catwifhat
77% matchMostly Positive80% of 460 reviews2024
Dev: Clawz
Windows
Catwifhat is the first Steam idle clicker where clicking directly drops tradable skins and items. Cats determine your drop pool — collect, craft, level up, and play actively or AFK.
Why similar: Trading 33.1%, Incremental 22.4%, Memes 17.9%, Point & Click 13.2%, Funny 9.8%
- #31 Nuts
77% matchMixed58% of 95 reviews2024
Dev: Nut
Windows
Nuts is the next Strand Type enviroment with a clicker experience, in which you click things! In Nuts you tap the nut to gain even more nuts! Every 2 and 17 hours, your nuts drop. Each nut is made by the community in discord.
Why similar: Incremental 55%, Funny 25.1%, Casual 10.5%, 2D 9.5%
- #32 Heart Clicker
76% matchMixed66% of 176 reviews2024
Dev: Vacantknight5Pub: Vacantknight Studios
Windows
Heart Clicker is a free-to-play clicker/idle game where you start with nothing and build your way up to a vast collection of hearts! Click to generate hearts, invest them in powerful upgrades, and watch your heart count soar.
Why similar: Memes 31.1%, Incremental 29.5%, Relaxing 12.8%, Point & Click 12.5%, Strategy 7%
- #33 Lemon
76% matchMixed65% of 132 reviews2024
Dev: Trash Game Studio
Windows
Welcome to Lemon, the clicker game more addictive than cat videos! Click your way to Lemon glory, gathering Lemons faster than you can say "Lemon counter." Unlock mysterious inventory drops with golden Lemons, magic Lemons. Dive in and may the Lemons be ever in your favor!
Why similar: Incremental 65.2%, Casual 24.5%, 2D 10.3%
- #34 Community Button
74% matchMostly Positive71% of 59 reviews2026
Dev: RecursionSplash
Windows
A global idle clicker where every press feeds one shared worldwide counter. Click, upgrade, hatch pets, unlock auto-clickers, chase rare drops, climb leaderboards, and watch the live heatmap light up as the community pushes the number higher. How high can it go? Will you press it… or watch?
Why similar: Incremental 46.5%, Memes 21.5%, Relaxing 14.1%, Casual 8.9%, Puzzle 6.8%
- #35 Box Clicker
75% matchMixed61% of 172 reviews2024
Dev: NipoBoxPub: NipoBox Publishing
Windows
📦 Box Clicker is a game in which you break Boxes to get more Boxes. And that's just the beginning!
Why similar: Incremental 68.7%, Casual 21.3%, Strategy 10%
- #36 Just Pizza
74% matchMixed62% of 114 reviews2024
Dev: N3mE
Windows · Linux
Welcome to Just Pizza, a game that turns your love for pizza into an exciting and rewarding experience! This game is all about clicking on a pizza to earn more pizzas. The more you click, the more pizzas you get. It’s as simple and fun as that!
Why similar: Parody 32.3% ★, Point & Click 22.4%, Incremental 20.8%, Casual 12.6%, 2D 6.1%
- #37 Click the Button
69% matchVery Positive94% of 4,307 reviews2026
Dev: LoopCap
Windows
Median: 2.4 hrsMean: 3.0 hrs≥1hr: 93%
Click the Button is an incremental game about clicking a button to receive chests that deliver incredible rewards. Improve your skills to become the strongest.
Why similar: Incremental 46.6%, Point & Click 23.4%, Relaxing 13.9%, Casual 11.5%, 2D 4.6%
- #38 Not A Banana: Capybara
73% matchMixed46% of 56 reviews2024
Dev: Katze
Windows · Linux
Hello! Welcome to the wonderful world of capybara clicker! Here you will become a true friend of the capybaras, clicking on the screen and calling the cutest and sometimes special capybaras! Don't forget to keep clicking to attract even more capybaras to you!
Why similar: Memes 31%, Incremental 24.7%, Point & Click 16.7%, Funny 9.9%, Relaxing 9.5%
- #39 Dog
73% matchMixed41% of 82 reviews2024
Dev: Dog Inc.
Windows · Linux
The ultimate idle clicker game! Tap to collect adorable pups, upgrade your canine companions, and build a thriving dog park empire. Earn tradable Steam items every 40 minutes of play. Join thousands in this free, paw-some adventure. Start your doggy journey now!
Why similar: Incremental 51.7%, Point & Click 31.2%, Casual 10.9%, 2D 6.1%
- #40 Clothing Clicker
73% matchMixed53% of 96 reviews2024
Dev: cem99Pub: online99
Windows
Clothing is a clicker Game, in which you click a Clothing! In Clothing you click the Clothing to gain even more Clothings! Every 1 and 18 hours, you get dropped a clothing. Each clothings is also made by the community in discord. Come hang out with us and let's grow into something awesome !
Why similar: Incremental 38.6%, Point & Click 25%, Relaxing 15.8%, Casual 13.9%, 2D 6.6%
- #41 Coconut
71% matchMixed60% of 113 reviews2024
Dev: Sibling Games
Windows
Welcome to Coconut! 🌴✨ Dive into the ultimate coconut-clicking frenzy where the fun never stops. Ready to get your click on?
Why similar: Incremental 46.2%, Point & Click 28.9%, Casual 17.1%, 2D 7.9%
- #42 Banana & Tomato
70% matchMixed64% of 97 reviews2024
Dev: Noex
Windows
Banana & Tomato is a fun clicker game! Click Banamatos, get and collect unique items, play minigames and get even more, click and level up for better rewards, change Banamato skins, earn rare achievements, and much more! Read the full description to learn about all the exciting features!
Why similar: Incremental 44.9%, Point & Click 27.8%, Casual 14.5%, 2D 7.4%, Strategy 5.3%
- #43 Once Upon a Galaxy
68% matchMostly Positive78% of 751 reviews2025
Dev: Million Dreams Games
Windows · Mac
Median: 7.6 hrsMean: 41.8 hrs≥1hr: 74%
ONCE UPON A GALAXY is an easy to learn Card Battler with incredible strategic depth and near infinite fun! Which of your favorite characters from myth and fairy tale will you choose?
Why similar: Trading Card Game 38.7% ★, Card Battler 24.3%, Card Game 15.4%, Funny 6.6%, Strategy 6.2%
- #44 Silly Linguine Cat Simulator Deluxe Online
65% matchOverwhelmingly Positive98% of 3,457 reviews2026
Dev: Brody Seyranian
Windows · Mac
Median: 5.0 hrsMean: 88.6 hrs≥1hr: 71%
Silly Linguine Cat Simulator Deluxe Online is a clicker game where progression is replaced with gambling, where the goal is simply to collect the rarest silly linguine cats.
Why similar: Incremental 57.2%, Funny 31.8%, Casual 11%
- #45 Card Storm Idle
71% matchMixed51% of 111 reviews2023
Dev: Hyperbeam Games
Windows
Card Storm Idle is an incremental game with both idle and active playstyles. Research and craft card deсk to earn as much resource as possible! Build up your power and see how far you can get. Bring the card storm down on monsters!
Why similar: Incremental 22.8%, Card Battler 22.4%, Trading Card Game 21.6% ★, Card Game 20.3%, Strategy 5.9%
- #46 Ananas - Pineapple Idle Game
69% matchMixed51% of 67 reviews2024
Dev: Miro Yang
Windows
Ananas is free Play-to-earn relaxing clicker game where you're gonna get pineapples to trade! Dropped/bought items has their use and have a fair chance to get bought for random value by dev on upcoming live streams, that's where Ananas differs!
Why similar: Incremental 31.5%, Mining 29.4% ★, Point & Click 17%, Relaxing 15.7%, Casual 6.4%
- #47 CGENcore
72% matchMixed54% of 91 reviews2019
Dev: O L Y M P U S
Windows
Become the Crypto Tycoon! The more you click, the richer you get. Your goal is to collect as much Crypto as you can, buy as much tech as you can and conquer the world!
Why similar: Incremental 71.7%, Casual 28.3%
- #48 Cyber-ART
68% matchMostly Positive73% of 55 reviews2025
Dev: Cyber Art Studio
Windows
Cyber-ART is a clicker game. In the game, you need to click on the artworks! You will get a random artwork every three hours, allowing you to continuously expand your art collection!
Why similar: Casual 52.2%, 2D 24.4%, Strategy 23.4%
- #49 Pixel Collector
69% matchMixed65% of 117 reviews2024
Dev: PixelPulseGames
Windows
Collect Pixelart items! Get 1-4 tickets every 2 hours to spin the lucky wheel. Win pixelart items or higher rarity tickets! All items appear in your Steam inventory and are tradable/marketable, making it easier to complete your collections.
Why similar: Trading Card Game 55.8% ★, Incremental 27.1%, Relaxing 9.6%, 2D 4%, Casual 3.5%
- #50 Slap 'em UP!
67% matchMostly Positive70% of 267 reviews2025
Dev: Urnique StudioPub: HaaBiz-X
Windows
Get in on the casual party card game where every hand is a chance to roast your friends! Slap them down with the higher cards, blast them with mocking stickers, or drop emotes they won’t forget. Dress to impress and make your way to the crown. Who’s the real king now?
Why similar: Board Game 24.9%, Tabletop 24.5%, Card Game 24.3%, Funny 11%, Strategy 7.1%
- #51 Jellitito
68% matchMostly Positive74% of 54 reviews2024
Dev: GatoInaryGames
Windows
Get ready for some sweet fun with our antistress Jellitito game! Just clicking to collect amazing skins and exchange them with other players. Build your collection of rare skins! It's simple, addictive, and endlessly enjoyable! Start clicking today!
Why similar: Incremental 50.9%, Point & Click 20.5%, Relaxing 19.9%, Casual 8.7%
- #52 Dig for TCG Cards With Your Friends
67% matchMixed45% of 85 reviews2026
Dev: 3 Rare Devs
Windows
A cozy junkyard card-collecting sim - now with online co-op. Dig through mountains of trash with friends, hunt rare collectible cards, sell your junk for profit, and upgrade your gear.
Why similar: Trading Card Game 40.6% ★, Memes 26.7%, Incremental 19.1%, Relaxing 9.9%, Casual 3.7%
- #53 CryptoClickers: Crypto Idle Game
70% matchMixed64% of 211 reviews2021
Dev: Considera Games LLCPub: Considera Core LLC
Windows · Mac · Linux
CryptoClickers is a complex Incremental Game revolved around Cryptocurrencies that's full of unique game modes, upgrades, challenges, events, and a double layer prestige system!
Why similar: Incremental 40.8%, Memes 29.5%, Point & Click 17%, Strategy 12.6%
- #54 UnnamedGame RPG
70% matchMixed55% of 55 reviews2022
Dev: Weslington
Windows · Mac
Enjoy a semi-AFK RNG-HELL RPG game that is ever expanding, find loot, own, get owned, all in the name of RNG. Climb leaderboards for overall XP, gather money, and become a part of a growing game and community!
Why similar: Incremental 66.1%, Funny 20.6%, Casual 13.3%
- #55 Bread
67% matchMixed56% of 77 reviews2024
Dev: The Royal Bakery
Windows · Linux
The Royal Bakery welcomes you to Bread, a fun simple clicker game. Stay a while, have some fun and click a crumb. Careful too much bread makes you fat.
Why similar: Incremental 33%, Parody 23.9% ★, Trading 17.7%, Memes 13.7%, Casual 5.4%
- #56 Click Me Harder
66% matchMixed66% of 67 reviews2025
Dev: Tegridy Made Games
Windows
Click anime girls, get money, spend it to get more anime girls.
Why similar: Point & Click 31.6%, Memes 31%, Casual 13.2%, Incremental 12.4%, Funny 11.8%
- #57 Top Trumps Turbo
72% matchMostly Negative32% of 225 reviews2015
Dev: Good Day GamesPub: Funbox Media Ltd
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 6 minMean: 39.3 hrs≥1hr: 32%
Top Trumps™ Turbo is a brand new, exclusive fun and exciting Top Trumps™ card game brought to you by Funbox Media. Use the cards and your skills to beat the computer and become the ultimate Top Trumps™ Turbo Champion!
Why similar: Trading Card Game 29.4% ★, Board Game 17%, Tabletop 16.6%, Card Game 15%, 1990's 9.6%