- #1 Green Squares
97% match7 user reviews100% of 7 reviews2023
Dev: Spooky StonePub: Spooky Stone
Windows
Pure Simple Physics Fun. Challenge yourself in a chaotic and colourful time trial where there are green squares, that need to be not green!
Why similar: Idler 27.7%, Sandbox 21.2%, Arcade 14.9%, Minimalist 10.5%, Casual 9.9%
- #2 Play With Your Cat! - A Virtual Toy Box
96% match7 user reviews100% of 7 reviews2025
Dev: Herra Koira Company
Windows
Get ready to Play With Your Cat! This is a virtual toy box that offers you the right tools for virtual play with your pets. It is a simple yet powerful tool built on a university study and designed in a feedback loop with the actual end-users: cats. There are no rules. You create the fun together!
Why similar: Cats 25.5%, Sandbox 21.7%, Minimalist 16.2%, Family Friendly 8.9%, Casual 7.7%
- #3 Tiny Friends Desktop Pet
96% matchMostly Positive70% of 10 reviews2025
Dev: TinyTail Games
Windows
Tiny Friends is an adorable, customizable desktop companion that brings your screen to life with fun interactions and playful charm.Play, interact, and make your screen more fun than ever!
Why similar: Idler 34%, Cats 16.1%, Minimalist 14.2%, Cute 9.7%, Family Friendly 8.5%
- #4 Just a Cat
95% matchNo user reviews
Dev: lonelystar
Windows
Just a Cat is a cute casual idle game about a cat that stays on your screen while you work or relax. Dress him with hats and glasses, watch his reactions, and track mouse clicks and keyboard presses as part of your personal statistics.
Why similar: Idler 42.9%, Minimalist 18.4%, Casual 14.3%, Cute 11.5%, 2D 7.3%
- #5 Fungiculture
94% matchMixed60% of 10 reviews2024
Dev: Inner Realm Studios
Windows
A cute and relaxing mushroom farming idler. Collect a variety of mushrooms, watch and help them grow, then sell them off for more money to buy more packs and discover them all.
Why similar: Idler 40.4%, Cartoony 15.8%, Casual 13.2%, Cute 9.9%, Family Friendly 9%
- #6 Tomokin Monsters
94% match5 user reviews60% of 5 reviews2025
Dev: Tomokin
Windows
Hatch, evolve, collect! Tomokin Monsters is a desktop idler that lives on your screen, running in the background while you work. Feed and play with your monsters to evolve them into their ultimate forms! Can you collect them all?
Why similar: Idler 29.4%, Sandbox 19.4%, Minimalist 10.5%, Cartoony 9.7%, Cute 7.1%
- #7 Animal Sanctuary
93% match3 user reviews33% of 3 reviews2022
Dev: Dysthesia Games
Windows
Create a beautiful nature refuge for all kinds of animals to come and relax in. Give them enough food, water and some toys to play with and see if you can get all the animals to show up!
Why similar: Idler 20.3%, Sandbox 16%, Cute 15.7%, Family Friendly 13.2%, Casual 12.5%
- #8 Heart Idler
92% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Vacantknight5Pub: Vacantknight Studios
Windows
Heart Idler is a clicker/idle game where you start with nothing and build your way up to a vast collection of hearts! Click to generate hearts, invest them in powerful upgrades, and watch your heart count soar. Can you unlock all the upgrades and achieve the ultimate collection of hearts?
Why similar: Idler 37.1%, Arcade 9.8%, Minimalist 9.5%, Cute 8.5%, Cartoony 8.4%
- #9 TitTok 2
91% matchVery Positive85% of 52 reviews2022
Dev: Siberian Mouse
Windows
TitTok 2 - Minimalistic adventure 2D puzzle platformer with cats, explosions and spinning saws! Continuation of the first part. TikTok ≠ TitTok
Why similar: Idler 29.7%, Arcade 16.8%, Casual 12.3%, Minimalist 11.7%, Adventure 11.4%
- #10 Ringbound
90% matchNo user reviews100% of 18 reviews2026
Dev: TheTallLeaf
Windows
Ringbound is an experimental minimalist incremental game.
Why similar: Idler 24.3%, Minimalist 19.6%, Arcade 10.6%, Cute 8%, Colorful 7.4%
- #11 Cover Cat
91% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: ITKING.PRO
Windows
In the physics-based puzzle Cover Cat, you save a kitten from a mischievous water-spraying bottle by hiding it behind various objects. Conceal your fluffy friend behind boxes, platforms, and yarn balls to keep it dry. Use the laws of physics to choose the best hiding spots and protect the cat.
Why similar: Choose Your Own Adventure 20.6%, Arcade 14.9%, Cats 10.5%, Casual 9.7%, Cartoony 9.1%
- #12 Desktop Mark
89% matchVery Positive90% of 90 reviews2023
Dev: coding398
Windows · Linux
Desktop Mark is a simple minigame-centric idler revolving around the silly character of Mark, a smiley that bounces all around your screen. Every so often, Mark hits the corner and prompts you to procrastinate & have some fun with Mark.
Why similar: Minimalist 16.4%, Arcade 15.8%, Idler 14.7%, Cartoony 9.9%, Family Friendly 7.6%
- #13 Desktop Pals 2
89% matchPositive97% of 32 reviews2025
Dev: Bajgar industries
Windows
Desktop Pals 2 is the ultimate desktop companion game, which allows you to share your desktop with a cute companion of your choice!
Why similar: Idler 40.3%, Cats 17.2%, Cartoony 14.5%, Casual 13%, Cute 8%
- #14 GARDEN&BIRD
88% matchPositive93% of 42 reviews2025
Dev: FreezingStudio
Windows
The arrival of birds turned the deserted island into a garden, creating your own unique garden in the sandbox!
Why similar: Idler 32%, Sandbox 22.1%, Nature 10.7%, Cute 9.6%, Casual 6.6%
- #15 Idle Tree Keeper
87% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Torbellino Games
Windows · Mac
Idle Tree Keeper is a relaxing idle/incremental game where you care for a mystical tree. Generate resources, unlock upgrades, evolve, and progress even while offline. Free to play with optional in-game purchases.
Why similar: Idler 42.4%, Casual 13.7%, Nature 11.9%, Cute 10.5%, Colorful 9%
- #16 Idle Fields
86% matchVery Positive81% of 94 reviews2024
Dev: KotieDev
Windows · Linux
Idle Fields is an Idle Skilling Game. Grow crops, cut trees, fish, cook, purchase animals, mine, smith, and decorate your homes! Automate tasks with workers. Unlock all the achievements, level up to become richer, and complete it all!
Why similar: Idler 30%, Sandbox 18.5%, Cartoony 8.7%, Nature 8.6%, Cute 7.1%
- #17 Taskbar Looters
86% match8 user reviews100% of 8 reviews2025
Dev: B52
Windows
Taskbar Looters is a simple idle game where animal looters collect treasures on your desktop while you focus on other tasks.
Why similar: Idler 45.8%, Nature 13.6%, Cute 12.7%, Casual 11.1%, Family Friendly 6.4%
- #18 Deskcat
84% matchPositive100% of 11 reviews2025
Dev: Logobojo
Windows
Deskcat is a cute and lively desktop companion game that brings your computer to life with an adorable animated cat!
Why similar: Idler 39.5%, Cats 14.3%, Cute 11.5%, Family Friendly 11.3%, Colorful 9.5%
- #19 Neko Station
85% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Sunny Syrup StudioPub: Flyhigh Works
Windows
Sit back and relax with Neko Station, a cozy 2D Pixel Art Desktop Idle Game! Manage your very own 'cat train,' decorating it with the perfect furniture to attract a diverse cast of feline customers. Pick them up at various stations and build friendships in this heartwarming adventure.
Why similar: Idler 31.6%, Sandbox 24.3%, Cats 14%, Casual 11.5%, Cute 7.1%
- #20 SphereCats
83% matchPositive94% of 18 reviews2024
Dev: Palomar Games AB
Windows
A merge puzzle game about spherical cats, with a twist. Play the classic suika experience or try new variations every day!
Why similar: Arcade 19.7%, Cats 16.3%, Cute 11.7%, Cartoony 11.5%, Casual 8.8%
- #21 Cheems Bonk
84% matchNo user reviews2025
Dev: Cheems
Windows
Cheems Bonk is a casual single-player zone-denial arcade game. Defeat an endless wave of Evil Cheems.
Why similar: Idler 35.6%, Arcade 18%, Cartoony 13.8%, Minimalist 12.5%, Casual 12.4%
- #22 My Fishing Desktop
82% match7 user reviews100% of 7 reviews2025
Dev: SPRITE!
Windows · Mac · Linux
🎣 Unwind with this cozy idle fishing game. Cast your line, collect unique fish, and customize your character with fun hats. Add relaxing ambient sounds like rain or jungle vibes to set the mood. Perfect for relaxing in the background while you work or chill. 🎣
Why similar: Idler 25.9%, Arcade 13.5%, Minimalist 12%, Nature 7.8%, Cute 7.1%
- #23 Desktop Purrfect
81% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Boon Makes Games
Windows
Your purr-fect desktop companion is here! Get adorable cats that chill at the bottom of your screen, keeping you company while you work, study, play, or relax. Collect toys & furniture to build them a cozy home. Pet, feed, play, or simply enjoy their presence.
Why similar: Idler 30.5%, Cats 26.9%, Sandbox 11.8%, Casual 8.8%, Cute 7.3%
- #24 Flourish
79% matchPositive81% of 37 reviews2026
Dev: FireOwl Games
Windows · Mac · Linux
Find your rhythm in the cycle of the garden: prune to gather, water to renew, and trade your clippings for deep-rooted progression.
Why similar: Idler 43.7%, Nature 18.1%, Minimalist 12.2%, Casual 10.1%, Colorful 6.2%
- #25 Desktop Pet Band
81% matchNo user reviews
Dev: DAMI Planet
Windows · Mac
Welcome to Desktop Pet Band! A relaxing, heartwarming desktop idle collection game with adorable art. Form a cute animal band on your screen, gather fans, level up your stage. Your clicks become the beat of their passion. Raise your little buddies and let them sing—right on your desktop!
Why similar: Idler 34.6%, Cats 14.2%, Cartoony 12.6%, Sandbox 11%, Cute 9.9%
- #26 Mega City Void
82% match8 user reviews0% of 9 reviews2021
Dev: wow wow GamesPub: wow wow Games
Windows
You play the role of a black hole that has penetrated our world. Your task is to absorb as many houses, trees, cars and other objects as possible.
Why similar: Sandbox 24.9%, Arcade 17.8%, Cute 8.9%, Casual 8.8%, Adventure 8.6%
- #27 Banana Chaos Clicker
80% matchNo user reviews
Dev: LunaSmith
Windows
Banana Chaos Clicker — An epic idle sim with resource management, crafting, and creature evolution. Build your empire from monkey to dragon!
Why similar: Idler 41.6%, Sandbox 17.5%, Cats 13.8%, Casual 7.5%, Arcade 6.1%
- #28 CatCat
78% matchPositive95% of 37 reviews2025
Dev: bogy house
Windows · Mac
"CatCat" is a relaxing cat simulation game. Raise different breeds, feed them, and pet them. You can freely change the layout, arrange furniture, and alter wall colors to create a cozy space for you and your cats. There are no goals or pressure; just enjoy a peaceful time together with your cats.
Why similar: Idler 33.9%, Sandbox 25.9%, Cats 15.5%, Casual 9%, Relaxing 8.8%
- #29 Sugar Jar
79% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2024
Dev: Stuffedy
Windows
Sugar Jar' is a cosy, family-friendly game of merging confectionery delights. Perfect for all ages, combine sweets in a jar through colourful, evolving stages. Enjoy a relaxing, joyful experience filled with charming visuals. Begin your sweet merging adventure today!
Why similar: Idler 40.1%, Cartoony 12.9%, Casual 12.5%, Cute 10.8%, Relaxing 10.5%
- #30 GLONK
76% matchVery Positive92% of 292 reviews2025
Dev: Mistical Studios
Windows
A short incremental game about feeding Glonk! Make Glonk bigger, get more money, and explore the skill tree to upgrade your abilities, and get more Glonks!
Why similar: Idler 36.3%, Arcade 17.7%, Cute 8.9%, Minimalist 8.1%, Casual 8.1%
- #31 I Got Hired To Guard The Button That Destroys The Earth
77% matchMixed65% of 40 reviews2025
Dev: Final Offer
Windows
An indie waiting game that is going to test your patience and focus. Become the most successful button guardian on Steam with Steam Leaderboard
Why similar: Idler 32.6%, Arcade 16.4%, Minimalist 12%, Adventure 11.6%, Casual 10.7%
- #32 Don't Miss The Button
77% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Aroktyoe
Windows · Mac · Linux
Don't Miss The Button is a fast-paced clicker game where every click counts. Earn money, upgrade your stats, boost hit chance and combos, and watch the numbers grow. Each run resets, but Steam achievements track your progress. Simple, relaxing, and perfect for short sessions.
Why similar: Idler 36.2%, Arcade 19.8%, Casual 13.6%, Family Friendly 9%, Colorful 6.7%
- #33 Missy's Bugtastic Little Planet
75% matchPositive100% of 12 reviews2026
Dev: mullwave
Windows · Linux
Missy the kitty will hang out with you anywhere on your desktop and catch bugs! She will earn money based on the rarity of what she catches, and you can use that money to buy cosmetics and upgrades, or just see how much money she can make!
Why similar: Idler 41.3%, Cats 16.5%, Nature 10.7%, Casual 10.3%, Cute 10%
- #34 Meow Playground
76% matchPositive93% of 14 reviews2024
Dev: Zhivotech
Windows · Mac · Linux
Meow Playground is an online multiplayer game that lets you play as a cute animal character.
Why similar: Sandbox 21.8%, Choose Your Own Adventure 20.5%, Cats 17.1%, Cute 7.8%, Family Friendly 7.2%
- #35 Hinata in Hot Maze
78% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2021
Dev: DIGITAL ART TEAM
Windows
while traveling, Hinata found a maze and decided to enter it filming everything with her camera, the further she went through it, the hotter it became in it and she had to undress because of the heat, the maze is drawn during its passage
Why similar: Idler 35.3%, Arcade 15.8%, Minimalist 12.1%, Cute 9.5%, 2D 6.1%
- #36 带薪钓鱼(Work...Or Fish?)
74% matchNo user reviews
Dev: 鱼腥味工作室
Windows
“Work... or Fish?” is a cozy idle fishing game that runs on your desktop. The cat took a long vacation to enjoy peaceful fishing—will you join? Shrink the window to fish in secret, upgrade gear, and relax in your own little corner.
Why similar: Idler 35.1%, Cats 23.1%, Casual 8.3%, Nature 7.3%, Cute 6.8%
- #37 Desktop Jinja
75% matchNo user reviews2025
Dev: Anisile
Windows
Build a personal shrine on your desktop—pray, draw fortunes, and receive gentle blessings each day.
Why similar: Idler 56.1%, Cute 14.1%, Casual 12.2%, 2D 9%, Relaxing 8.6%
- #38 Reflectory
74% matchNo user reviews
Dev: FkjahaPub: Fkjaha Games
Windows
An idle incremental game about bouncing balls that lives in the corner of your screen.
Why similar: Idler 38.5%, Minimalist 17.5%, Casual 11.9%, Arcade 8.8%, Relaxing 7.1%
- #39 Bao Bao's™ Cozy Cleaning Services
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Destroyer Doggo
Windows · Mac · Linux
Relax with Bao Bao in this cozy 2D pressure washing sim. Clean pastel environments, chill lo-fi beats, and no stress, just peaceful vibes. Play solo or with up to 3 friends. A peaceful pressure washing game for quiet minds and cozy days.
Why similar: Sandbox 25.3%, Arcade 17.8%, Minimalist 13.5%, Casual 11.9%, Cute 8.1%
- #40 Ocean Cat
73% match5 user reviews80% of 5 reviews2023
Dev: Donghai Art Game Studio
Windows
Ocean Cat is a very fun fishing game. The main character of the game is a cute little cat wearing a diving suit,
Why similar: Idler 32.8%, Arcade 17.7%, Cats 14.4%, Casual 11.7%, Cartoony 10.9%
- #41 Feed the Pets Fall Animals
72% matchNo user reviews
Dev: VolrestPub: Volrest Games
Windows
Feed the Pets Fall Animals — A cute clicker, where you shall feed the pets, and make them happy! Continuation of the Feed the Pets franchise.
Why similar: Idler 25.4%, Minimalist 11.1%, Cats 10.3%, Cartoony 8.6%, Family Friendly 8.6%
- #42 Gav-Gav Odyssey
73% matchPositive86% of 21 reviews2022
Dev: HugePixel
Windows
Three space friends get into an unearthly adventure in which they face a variety of different tasks, which will take a lot of time to solve. Will you be able to exit the game as winners? Then be patient because the game is for those who like to think.
Why similar: Idler 28.2%, Choose Your Own Adventure 19.5%, Minimalist 13.3%, Cartoony 10.4%, Cute 7.8%
- #43 Pop Balloons and Drop People
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Aggroblakh
Windows
A short and colorful incremental game about popping different types of balloons and dropping people of all colors.
Why similar: Idler 33.7%, Minimalist 10.3%, Casual 10.2%, Cartoony 9.6%, Arcade 7.9%
- #44 Pungo
69% matchPositive90% of 21 reviews2025
Dev: White Eyes Studio
Windows · Mac · Linux
Two cats, a ball of yarn, and a duel full of reflexes and fun! Play solo or against a friend, use surprising power-ups, and unlock adorable kittens. With headbutts, belly bumps, and kicks on the court. Will you be the fastest cat? Show your skills in Pungo!
Why similar: Arcade 18.5%, Cats 16.9%, Cartoony 15.3%, Casual 12.2%, Cute 11.3%
- #45 Holiday Farm
71% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2024
Dev: 391SOFT
Windows
A sandbox game that simulates life on a farm. Experience life, growing vegetables, raising animals, diving in mineral water on a happy island.
Why similar: Idler 22.4%, Sandbox 17.8%, Choose Your Own Adventure 16%, Nature 8.8%, Family Friendly 6.8%
- #46 My Littlest Skeleton
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Pixelbark
Windows
My Littlest Skeleton is a cosy and relaxing simulation where you care for your very own little Skeleton chum! Pull your unique Skeleton back from the depths of the Nether Region. Attend to their needs, maintain their furnishings, choose from a variety of environments for your Skeleton to call home.
Why similar: Idler 33.1%, Sandbox 24.5%, Cartoony 13.5%, Casual 8.4%, Cute 8.1%
- #47 Tawako The Forest Hedgehog
72% match6 user reviews100% of 6 reviews2022
Dev: gothSoft
Windows
Help Tawako to go through the forest and collect fruits in this Arkanoid-like game.
Why similar: Idler 23.6%, Casual 15.7%, Family Friendly 15.4%, Nature 13.2%, Arcade 12.7%
- #48 =^.ω.^=
69% matchPositive93% of 40 reviews2026
Dev: Cockroach Studio
Windows
Something will happen in two hours. Do not press the button. Do not press the button. Do not press the button. Do not press the button. Do not press the button. Do not press the button. Do not press the button. Do not press the button. Do not press the button.
Why similar: Idler 43%, Cats 19.1%, Casual 14.1%, Cute 12%, 2D 7.6%
- #49 Bside 中文版
70% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Kotoko Inc.
Windows
Meet your Biibit: your virtual buddy who lives and grows on your desktop. They aren’t here to be controlled, but their autonomous growth might lead you to discover your B side.
Why similar: Idler 29.2%, Sandbox 23.8%, Choose Your Own Adventure 16.1%, Casual 10.6%, Cartoony 8.3%
- #50 Mystopia
69% matchPositive80% of 35 reviews2025
Dev: Last Minute Studios
Windows · Linux
Mystopia is a relaxing creative sandbox game where you build unique little worlds by fulfilling the wishes of charming creatures. Discover hundreds of blocks, brew magical potions and maximize the happiness of your creatures to spread love throughout your worlds! Play in three different game modes.
Why similar: Idler 30.8%, Sandbox 24.3%, Nature 11.1%, Cute 9.1%, Relaxing 7.7%
- #51 Bit Crusher
70% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Tiny Studios
Windows
Roam an open world in your brand new pickup truck, smash stuff into bits, then trade them in for better upgrades, vehicles, and new zones. Explore the island, discover hidden paths and carve your own adventure across the world!
Why similar: Choose Your Own Adventure 22.2%, Arcade 15%, Minimalist 13.6%, Casual 8.4%, Adventure 8.3%
- #52 Desktop Town
68% matchPositive95% of 20 reviews2025
Dev: EdelErde
Windows
Desktop Town is a relaxing idle city builder that runs directly on your desktop. Build and decorate your own tiny town, or watch your little citizens go about their day, while doing your usual tasks on the PC.
Why similar: Idler 33.9%, Sandbox 20.7%, Nature 11.1%, Cute 8.6%, Family Friendly 7.6%
- #53 Fishful Days
70% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: COSMICDUST STUDIO
Windows
"Fishful Days" is a casual idle game. you can buy fish fry and let them grow in the background; once they reach adulthood, they will continuously produce fish for you! You can also buy multiple fish tanks to achieve snowballing growth. It also offers rich fish tank customization features.
Why similar: Idler 38.4%, Cartoony 12.9%, Casual 12.6%, Cute 8.3%, Nature 7.6%
- #54 MyVoiceZoo
67% matchVery Positive94% of 2,555 reviews2025
Dev: TRUSO
Windows
Median: 54 minMean: 1.1 hrs≥1hr: 45%
My Voice Zoo is a unique idle zoo game brought to life with your own voice. Record your sounds through the microphone and turn them into animal calls, creating a one-of-a-kind zoo found nowhere else. Start building your very own zoo, complete only with your voice!
Why similar: Idler 31.8%, Sandbox 23.9%, Cartoony 13.5%, Cute 9.8%, Casual 7.8%
- #55 Arrowburst
67% matchVery Positive83% of 71 reviews2025
Dev: TheTallLeaf
Windows
Arrowburst is a calm, relaxing, short incremental game about bursting squares and upgrading your arrow.
Why similar: Idler 36.1%, Casual 11.4%, Relaxing 10.7%, Atmospheric 9.7%, Minimalist 9.4%
- #56 My Adventure Book
67% matchMostly Positive78% of 27 reviews2025
Dev: Kaser Studio
Windows
Join the amazing adventure! Explore a magical world, solve puzzles, find objects and help local creatures. You will complete this game in 5 minutes!
Why similar: Choose Your Own Adventure 21.4%, Minimalist 14.2%, Cartoony 11.2%, Cute 8.3%, Family Friendly 7.3%
- #57 Screen Cat
66% matchVery Positive93% of 1,853 reviews2025
Dev: Vorh Games
Windows
Median: 4.6 hrsMean: 42.3 hrs≥1hr: 70%
Милый кот на вашем рабочем столе. Он будет мурлыкать, когда вы устали. Он будет охотиться за курсором, когда вы работаете. Он будет спать, пока вы играете.
Why similar: Idler 31.9%, Cats 30.1%, Cute 12.1%, Relaxing 7.4%, Casual 7.3%
- #58 Moonlight Rabbits
68% match8 user reviews100% of 8 reviews2024
Dev: BlackMoon Studios
Windows
Dive into the serene world of Moonlight Rabbits, an idle game where you help adorable rabbits build a tower to the Moon by collecting carrots. Unlock unique rabbits, enjoy relaxing gameplay, and achieve your lunar dreams in this charming adventure!
Why similar: Idler 48.1%, Cute 12.5%, Casual 9.2%, 2D 7.8%, Relaxing 7.6%
- #59 Wish Upon
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Inchworm Games
Windows · Linux
Wish Upon is the debut game from Inchworm Games! It’s ½ part cozy, ½ part art project, ½ part space-frogger-metroidvania-lite that is perhaps way more challenging than we thought it might be...just like math! Head to our website to put YOUR wish into our game.
Why similar: Cats 29.8%, Arcade 11.6%, Cute 11.5%, Casual 9.3%, Cartoony 9%
- #60 Kombat Hamster
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Hamster Corp
Windows
Kombat Hamster is an idle clicker simulation game. Grow your empire to get more hamster coins in the fairest business simulator.
Why similar: Idler 34.3%, Sandbox 13.8%, Arcade 11.8%, Family Friendly 10.7%, Cartoony 9.3%