- #1 Spray to Grail
97% matchNo user reviews
Dev: EllipseHead
Windows
Spray-paint sneakers layer by layer, finish fast orders, and turn a scrappy bootleg studio into a rare-drop machine. Unlock wild grails, upgrade your gear, fill your collection wall, and chase the perfect pair in this juicy incremental game.
Why similar: Collectathon 24.4%, Incremental 23.1%, Idler 19.4%, Crafting 9%, Simulation 7.8%
- #2 Palimpsest Idle
96% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Studio J3L
Windows
An idle ARPG inked on parchment. Tap to fight, drag loot out of 35 zones, summon weapons that swing on their own, and Ascend for permanent power. Deep builds, six rarities, a real crafting forge. No ads, no microtransactions, no timers — buy it once, play it offline.
Why similar: Idler 20.9%, Incremental 19.7%, Automation 15.1%, Management 10%, Crafting 9.9%
- #3 Your Lil' Cow
96% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Somia Games
Windows
Handle your cow—the world's most "straight" bovine. Your Lil' Cow is a cute, pixel-art desktop companion that lives for your touch. Drag to build momentum, trigger explosive "Milking Frenzies," and spend your hard-earned milk on gacha draws to collect a wide variety of cute accessories.
Why similar: Incremental 20.1%, Collectathon 19.8%, Idler 17.6%, Simulation 16.6%, Life Sim 7.3%
- #4 Ever Flip
94% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: TMA Forge
Windows
Ever Flip is an incremental coin-flipping game where streaks from 50% coin flips unlock bigger rewards and growing automation.
Why similar: Collectathon 20.8%, Incremental 18.9%, Idler 18.3%, Automation 13.8%, Simulation 11%
- #5 Catch The Beaukes
95% match3 user reviews67% of 3 reviews2024
Dev: Milan RaijmakersPub: Novixx Systems
Windows
In Catch The Beaukes, Beaukes (spheres) fall from the sky, and you need to collect them to earn money. Then you can upgrade things so you earn even more!
Why similar: Collectathon 26.9%, Incremental 25.8%, Simulation 24.1%, Idler 20.3%, 3D 2.6%
- #6 Aura Farmer 67
94% match1 user reviews0% of 1 reviews2026
Dev: saBOR Gamedev
Windows
A humorous incremental clicker about farming Aura, buying absurd upgrades, and turning an ordinary gym-goer into a cosmic entity. Click, automate your farm, rebirth stronger, and keep progressing even while you are offline.
Why similar: Incremental 26.2%, Idler 21.5%, Collectathon 17%, Simulation 10.5%, Management 8.1%
- #7 Scratchers
93% matchMixed58% of 590 reviews2025
Dev: muffler
Windows
Median: 2.0 hrsMean: 3.5 hrs≥1hr: 87%
Scratchers is an incremental game where you scratch cards to earn cash, unlock upgrades, and hire little scratchers to do the scratching for you. Discover rare cards, and optimize your earnings as you climb to scratcher supremacy!
Why similar: Incremental 27.6%, Idler 19%, Simulation 14.9%, Management 12.5%, Collectathon 11%
- #8 Bumper to Billions
91% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Happy Distractions Studio
Windows
An incremental game about processing vehicles through a toll road.
Why similar: Idler 25.7%, Incremental 23.7%, Automation 18%, Simulation 14%, Management 12.7%
- #9 gate2up
92% matchNo user reviews2025
Dev: Gensou
Windows
This is a simple idle clicker game. Grow your item collection using points and strive to reach the ultimate goal of 99,999,999 points!
Why similar: Incremental 31.2%, Idler 25.2%, Collectathon 23.1%, Automation 11.9%, Casual 4.9%
- #10 Aluminium City
91% match4 user reviews100% of 4 reviews2026
Dev: Hadamant
Windows
Incremental clicker/idle and narrative game where you crush empty cans, sell the aluminum, upgrade your equipment, and buy factories and automatic presses to automate the process. Discover what happened to your wife and son as you try to save Aluminum City from an evil villain.
Why similar: Incremental 24.2%, Idler 20.3%, Automation 16.7%, Simulation 10.2%, Life Sim 6.9%
- #11 Void Fragment
90% matchNo user reviews
Dev: AnxiGames
Windows
The Void needs to grow. An idle incremental game where you feed a Void with Mana and Essences. Collect Void Fragments to upgrade the spirits, so they can continue feeding the Void even more.
Why similar: Collectathon 21%, Incremental 19.6%, Idler 16.8%, Automation 14.2%, Management 10.6%
- #12 Pebble Idle Island
89% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Flying Lantern
Windows
A relaxing idle clicker game where you collect pebbles on a serene tropical island. Manually gather stones or build an automated workforce of hardworking birds, crabs, and hermit crabs to stack your nest high, unlock upgrades, collect cute cosmetics, and travel to brand new islands.
Why similar: Idler 27.5%, Incremental 20.1%, Simulation 18.8%, Point & Click 10.1%, Automation 9.5%
- #13 Professional Chef
88% matchPositive80% of 25 reviews2026
Dev: Eracu Studios
Windows · Mac · Linux
Transform simple ingredients into delicious dishes in Professional Chef. Buy, cook, sell, upgrade, and unlock new recipes. Optimize your processes, master every detail, and rise to culinary excellence in this engaging idle cooking experience!
Why similar: Incremental 25.9%, Idler 21.3%, Automation 17.4%, Simulation 12.7%, Point & Click 8.1%
- #14 Idle Sushi Bar Tycoon
89% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Urban Isotope
Windows · Mac
Serve costumers fresh sushi and earn money to improve your restaurants.
Why similar: Idler 21.6%, Simulation 13.7%, Management 13%, Incremental 12.7%, Cooking 10.4%
- #15 Planetary Inc.
87% match6 user reviews83% of 6 reviews2026
Dev: Alexsander Faria
Windows
A short incremental game about building a career by destroying planets, meeting corporate goals, and investing in profitable — and maybe not so ethical — ventures.
Why similar: Collectathon 24.7%, Idler 22.9%, Incremental 20.9%, Simulation 10.7%, Management 9.6%
- #16 Atomic Synthesis
86% match1 user reviews67% of 3 reviews2026
Dev: Joe Doe Studio
Windows
A game about collecting, upgrading, and discovery, using the periodic table as a basis. Start with gathering Hydrogen and use the Atomic Synthesizer's automatic conversion system to generate energy and use it to stabilize the machine back to working at a 100% efficiency.
Why similar: Collectathon 25.5%, Idler 19.4%, Simulation 14.3%, Automation 12%, Casual 9.1%
- #17 LaVonne's Lemons Idle
86% matchMixed64% of 36 reviews2026
Dev: LaVonne
Windows
Grow an ultimate empire in LaVonne's Lemons Idle! Click your way from a single citrus to deep cosmic automation. Unearth ancient Artifacts, build out the Endless Research Lab, "feed" (click) your screen pet monkey, and prestige into the stars in this deeply strategic resource management clicker!
Why similar: Idler 27.3%, Incremental 26%, Simulation 15.6%, Management 13.7%, Automation 9.2%
- #18 Last $50
85% matchMostly Positive70% of 20 reviews2026
Dev: Adagio Games
Windows
Build a drug empire with your last $50. Buy production, upgrade it, and hire workers to automate.
Why similar: Incremental 23.9%, Idler 17.5%, Automation 17.1%, Management 9.3%, Simulation 9%
- #19 Bacteria Buster
84% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2026
Dev: 程序员小灰
Windows
Bacteria Buster is a fast-paced petri-dish cleanup game. Swat bacteria, upgrade your tools, deploy six Nano Robots, and develop four automatic Medicines. Clear a 200-stage campaign, face Super Bacteria and Bacteria Kings, then carry your progress into 1,000 stages of Endless Mode.
Why similar: Idler 24.5%, Incremental 21.6%, Automation 19%, Simulation 16.5%, Point & Click 7.7%
- #20 Miner Clicker
83% matchMostly Positive71% of 21 reviews2025
Dev: Steldrift
Windows
Miner Clicker is a short idle indie game where you have to click to mine. Click to gather resources, reach new depths, and buy upgrades to dig faster and deeper! Who knows what you might find at the bottom of the mine!
Why similar: Idler 23.1%, Incremental 22.9%, Simulation 16.5%, Automation 12.3%, Point & Click 11%
- #21 Cyber Shard Clicker
82% matchMixed69% of 29 reviews2025
Dev: Overaction Game Studio
Windows · Mac · Linux
Cyber Shard Clicker is a short incremental game. Break down geometric shapes representing hostile cyber attacks against Vault Inc., gather data shards, upgrade your hacking skills, and spend your data shards to unlock permanent boosts in the vast skill tree to push your cyber assault even further!
Why similar: Incremental 17.9%, Idler 16.9%, Collectathon 16.5%, Automation 13.6%, Management 9.6%
- #22 Idle Plant Game
84% matchMixed53% of 101 reviews2023
Dev: FootoftheHare
Windows
Idle Plant Game, an idle and offline progress or clicker plant simulation!
Why similar: Incremental 29%, Idler 23.1%, Automation 13.4%, Simulation 13.1%, Management 9.8%
- #23 AetherRift
81% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Slade
Windows · Mac · Linux
Place magical constructs around a swirling cosmic rift, chain together exotic energies, and collapse reality to grow stronger in this deep incremental game.
Why similar: Idler 22.6%, Incremental 21.9%, Automation 16.5%, Management 11%, Crafting 10.8%
- #24 Croissant
82% matchMixed65% of 153 reviews2024
Dev: Limsod Games
Windows
Croissant is a clicker game, click the Croissant to gain even more Croissant and become the best in the leaderboard! By spending time on the game, or by clicking on the Croissant, you can obtain skins. Collect them or trade them to expand your collection.
Why similar: Incremental 22.8%, Idler 20.6%, Collectathon 18.2%, Simulation 11.9%, Management 11.3%
- #25 OreMania
80% matchMostly Positive71% of 17 reviews2025
Dev: Gomashio
Windows
Ore Mania is a mining game where you dig, collect, and earn by exhibiting ores and gems. Use pickaxes and bombs to dig deeper underground, strengthen your gear with the resources you find, and discover rare and valuable ores.
Why similar: Incremental 19.8%, Collectathon 19.1%, Simulation 19%, Idler 13.8%, Point & Click 9.5%
- #26 Rubber Duck
79% match5 user reviews60% of 5 reviews2026
Dev: dot dot dot
Windows
Ever had to spend your working hours staring at screen clicking and pretending in order to gain for living? Now you've a Rubber Duck that can make your (and my) miserable working day much more fun!
Why similar: Incremental 32%, Idler 27.7%, Collectathon 16.3%, Simulation 6.9%, Crafting 6.8%
- #27 Buerokratie Idler: Germany
78% match8 user reviews75% of 8 reviews2026
Dev: AKM Interactive
Windows
Process forms, stamp paperwork, and turn a tiny office into an absurd bureaucracy machine. A satirical idle/clicker game about fictional German-style administration - absolutely not official.
Why similar: Idler 24.3%, Incremental 22.9%, Automation 17.2%, Simulation 12.5%, Management 11.3%
- #28 AI Clicker
79% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Afk Pixel Studio
Windows
Click Your Way to World Domination (Or Doom)! Welcome to AI Clicker, the only game where mindless clicking actually makes you smarter… or creates a future where AI replaces you!
Why similar: Incremental 27.1%, Idler 22.5%, Collectathon 17.2%, Management 12.2%, Casual 7.1%
- #29 Clickerite
78% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Bugguri
Windows
Clickerite is an incremental mining game where you must collect materials, craft powerful tools, and battle evil monsters in a cube-dimensional world!
Why similar: Incremental 22%, Idler 19.3%, Automation 16.3%, Crafting 11.1%, Management 10.8%
- #30 Monslice
77% match8 user reviews50% of 8 reviews2026
Dev: zowlf
Windows
Monslice is a short incremental game about slicing monsters, collecting resources, expanding your skill tree, and unlocking and buying more monsters!
Why similar: Incremental 27.8%, Collectathon 22.7%, Idler 22.4%, Management 10.2%, Casual 7.1%
- #31 Oh Shear!
77% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Gullfrazie Games
Windows · Mac
Grab your shears and build a cozy wool empire! Oh Shear! is a relaxing incremental game about managing a colorful flock of sheep. Upgrade your tools, automate the pasture, and master the skill tree. Sit back, relax, and enjoy the 'shear satisfaction' of numbers going up!
Why similar: Incremental 25.9%, Idler 21.4%, Simulation 16.4%, Management 13.5%, Automation 11.7%
- #32 Fuck the Ocean
76% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: EO4 Games
Windows · Mac · Linux
One wet sock. A wildly unreasonable response. Fill puddles, lakes and entire oceans with sand, garden gnomes and increasingly ridiculous machinery in this simple, funny incremental game.
Why similar: Incremental 29.8%, Idler 25.3%, Simulation 18.5%, Automation 12.2%, Casual 7.6%
- #33 Nodes
81% matchMixed61% of 46 reviews2022
Dev: Damaged Axons
Windows
Node production simulator. Purchase nodes to produce resources, so you can advance in the technology tree and build yourself a large production line. This game will satisfy your need for incremental simulators with the large amount of content.
Why similar: Simulation 23.1%, Incremental 21%, Management 16.4%, Idler 16.2%, Automation 12.2%
- #34 挂机修仙-宗门飞升
75% matchMixed66% of 32 reviews2025
Dev: The Fat Worker
Windows
A casual idle game of the xianxia genre. 一款修仙类型的挂机休闲小游戏。经营你的宗门,通过修真六艺--炼丹、炼器、阵法、符箓、傀儡、驯兽不断获得资源,助你的宗门不断的晋升品阶。
Why similar: Idler 26.2%, Incremental 24.9%, Simulation 18.3%, Automation 15.5%, Casual 7.7%
- #35 Happy Cats Market
75% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Satoshi Onishi
Windows
From a slice of bread to a parade of cats! Click food, trigger satisfying chains, and combine feline talents in a cozy pixel-art incremental game. Explore five growing shops, meet 88 cats, and celebrate around the campfire to earn lasting upgrades.
Why similar: Collectathon 26.7%, Incremental 26.5%, Idler 20.6%, Point & Click 8.7%, Automation 6.3%
- #36 ClickShot
76% matchMixed48% of 27 reviews2025
Dev: ApeXPloit Studios
Windows
Lock, Load, Click. A slick clicker game where every click pulls the trigger. Earn shells, unlock wild gun cosmetics, and stack permanent multipliers. Simple to play, hard to quit. Lock, load, and click your way to glory.
Why similar: Incremental 29.7%, Idler 24.3%, Automation 19.7%, Simulation 16%, Casual 7.1%
- #37 OshiYa
74% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: JourneyBit
Windows · Linux
Fill trains, upgrade your station and collect train cards. An active clicker with no ads, real-money shop or subscription.
Why similar: Incremental 28.2%, Collectathon 18%, Simulation 17.6%, Idler 15.8%, Casual 7.3%
- #38 Flippant
72% matchVery Positive96% of 207 reviews2026
Dev: vomithog
Windows
An abstract incremental game about flipping a coin and maybe some other things too
Why similar: Incremental 26.5%, Idler 21.7%, Simulation 16.9%, Automation 11.9%, Management 9.8%
- #39 Detectimental
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Riverstorm
Windows
A metal detecting incremental game! Use your metal detector to find treasures hidden in the sand. The closer you move towards a treasure, the faster your blinker will beep. Make sure to recruit some crabs to help you out.
Why similar: Incremental 24%, Collectathon 21.5%, Automation 16.6%, Idler 16.6%, Simulation 11.1%
- #40 Chicken Fren
73% matchMostly Positive79% of 97 reviews2026
Dev: Iron Cock Studios
Windows
Chicken Fren is a desktop pet that struts across your screen while you work or play. Every mouse click and keypress is a chance to spawn an egg: crack the egg to reveal hats and cosmetics ranging from common to legendary. Collect items, equip them, or trade them on the Steam Marketplace!
Why similar: Incremental 32%, Collectathon 29.1%, Idler 26%, Casual 8.3%, Relaxing 3.2%
- #41 Taskbar Armory
73% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Recoil MojoPub: Mojo Games
Windows
Your workday. Their adventure. A free cozy idle game that lives on your taskbar. Run a dwarven forge while you work or browse—mine ore, craft weapons, decorate your shop, and send heroes on expeditions for gems, relics and rare loot.
Why similar: Idler 22.3%, Incremental 21.2%, Automation 16.3%, Crafting 10.8%, Management 9.4%
- #42 Late-Night Ramen
72% matchNo user reviews
Dev: mooncellar
Windows · Mac
Run a cozy late-night ramen shop covering a portion of your screen. Perfect your recipes, decorate your shop, serve hot steaming ramen, and enjoy peaceful late-night vibes.
Why similar: Incremental 24.2%, Idler 21.1%, Simulation 20.3%, Casual 8.8%, Management 7.5%
- #43 Grandpa Needs Fish
71% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Armored Cat
Windows
Grandpa Needs Fish is a cozy idle clicker game where fortune rides the waves. You are Abraham and you have one mission: catch as many fish as possible. Every cast brings new rewards and every upgrade makes you stronger. Hover, catch, upgrade, and repeat in this satisfying idle incremental adventure.
Why similar: Idler 20.7%, Incremental 20.4%, Automation 16.1%, Collectathon 11%, Simulation 9.9%
- #44 Toothpick Museum
71% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: BHD_Games
Windows
You are the curator of the Toothpick Museum. The day before opening, your exhibits shattered! Carefully pick up the scattered toothpicks, avoid getting pricked, and rebuild the museum's masterpiece before the doors open!
Why similar: Incremental 22.6%, Collectathon 21%, Simulation 15.8%, Life Sim 13%, Point & Click 11.3%
- #45 Mr. "Bargain Expert" 捡漏王
70% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Cheese Meow
Windows
Play as an antique shop owner in this incremental idle management game. Buy low and sell high, appraise and acquire valuable antiques, hire employees to automate the business, expand into new branches, build your own antique empire, and collect rare treasures.
Why similar: Idler 24.4%, Incremental 22.8%, Automation 17.4%, Simulation 13.4%, Point & Click 8.1%
- #46 LaVonne's Bouncing Idle
69% matchMixed55% of 22 reviews2026
Dev: LaVonne
Windows
A satisfying physics-based idle game where you deploy an army of neon bouncing balls to obliterate geometric blocks. Buy crazy upgraded balls, level up your lab, and watch the numbers scale into infinity.
Why similar: Incremental 28.1%, Simulation 25.5%, Idler 24.1%, Casual 11.1%, Automation 6.6%
- #47 Meat Outdoors
71% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Light Island
Windows
Clicker game about cooking meat and recruit a variety of helping hands to collect your meat.
Why similar: Incremental 29.6%, Idler 23.9%, Automation 11.4%, Point & Click 8.9%, Casual 7.8%
- #48 Desktop Cat Clicker
69% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Klaqstudio
Windows
What if a cozy desktop game met an idle clicker? In Desktop Cat Clicker, cats wander across your taskbar, earn points from every click as you work, play, or relax. Collect new cats to unlock unique bonuses and grow your peaceful cat empire over time.
Why similar: Incremental 27.3%, Idler 22.7%, Collectathon 18.5%, Simulation 11.5%, Management 9.7%
- #49 Idle Baker Boss
70% matchMostly Positive72% of 163 reviews2025
Dev: Doopwee Games
Windows
Grow your bakery franchise and manage bakeries in this cute idle tycoon game with over 150 desserts, 100+ in game awards, daily challenges, skill tree system, events each month with unique desserts and much more...
Why similar: Collectathon 18.6%, Incremental 16.8%, Idler 16.2%, Automation 13%, Management 8.6%
- #50 Desktop Pet Band
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: DAMI Planet
Windows
Welcome to Desktop Pet Band! A relaxing, heartwarming desktop idle collection game with adorable art. Form a cute animal band on your screen, gather fans, level up your stage. Your clicks become the beat of their passion. Raise your little buddies and let them sing—right on your desktop!
Why similar: Idler 24%, Incremental 21.4%, Collectathon 21.3%, Simulation 7.3%, Life Sim 7%
- #51 Clickbait Tycoon
67% match5 user reviews100% of 5 reviews2026
Dev: FrostyVoid Inc.
Windows · Mac · Linux
Build a clickbait media empire in pixel-art 1980s New York. Publish outrageous stories, hire outrage algorithms, battle editors-turned-monsters raise Pocket Pals, and sell out - again and again - until you own the news. And the weather.
Why similar: Idler 30.5%, Incremental 28.1%, Simulation 21%, Management 11%, Casual 7.8%
- #52 CAPTAIN STARONE
74% matchPositive93% of 14 reviews2022
Dev: Marumittu GamesPub: Flyhigh Works
Windows
Became the hero " Captain StarONE " in this game blending action and ‘inaction’. You set your strategies and combos, then multitask as the game carries out your attacks. Watch the battles unfold and be ready to jump back in to guide our hero!
Why similar: Incremental 30.3%, Collectathon 23.9%, Idler 23.2%, Automation 9.2%, Casual 7.6%
- #53 Capybara Achievement Clicker
70% matchPositive100% of 19 reviews2025
Dev: JosephPub: WeirdCanyon
Windows
Capybara Achievement Clicker is a simple incremental and idle game. It features over a hundred easy-to-acquire achievements and a Capybara to click on.
Why similar: Incremental 22.3%, Idler 21.6%, Automation 16.7%, Management 13.4%, Simulation 8.6%
- #54 Block Clicker
67% match4 user reviews100% of 4 reviews2026
Dev: MaCoGAME
Windows
Break blocks, collect resources, and grow your mining empire in this satisfying clicker game featuring powerful upgrades, automation systems, consumables, missions, achievements, and a prestige system to push your progress even further.
Why similar: Automation 21.7%, Idler 19.4%, Collectathon 17.6%, Point & Click 12.6%, Incremental 11.6%
- #55 Void Core
68% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Badgertainment
Windows
A short incremental game where you control a black hole. Devour matter, unlock upgrades, and combine talents to grow stronger. Automate your gains and push toward the ultimate Collapse.
Why similar: Idler 23.7%, Incremental 22.4%, Automation 14.9%, Management 12.4%, Simulation 10.4%
- #56 Desk Rage
67% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2026
Dev: Pressure Valve StudioPub: IdleCraft Interactive
Windows
A carefully designed desktop pet game. When you open the game, your "little brother" desktop pet pops up and stays on your desktop to keep you company. Unlike other pet games—when you're in a bad mood, you can beat him up, or even summon a monster to eat him.
Why similar: Idler 23.6%, Incremental 22.6%, Collectathon 21.1%, Simulation 9%, Point & Click 8.7%
- #57 Coin Hoarder
68% match8 user reviews63% of 8 reviews2025
Dev: JLY Games
Windows
Click, collect, and ascend! Coin Hoarder is an addictive idle/incremental game in the spirit of Cookie Clicker and other greats, with endless upgrades, ascensions, and achievements.
Why similar: Incremental 28.6%, Idler 23.7%, Simulation 17.9%, Automation 16%, Casual 7.7%
- #58 Flower Tower
66% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Pmdk23
Windows
A short, relaxing incremental game about growing flowers, where your garden quietly thrives and blooms on its own.
Why similar: Idler 25.1%, Automation 19.5%, Incremental 19.2%, Simulation 14.4%, Management 8.3%
- #59 Spirit Gems
66% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Recoil MojoPub: Mojo Games
Windows
A cozy desktop idle game with 100 adorable spirits, 120 gemstone heirlooms and five magical gardens. Grow an enchanted elven workshop along your taskbar, befriend curious creatures and build a beautiful collection while you work, browse or play.
Why similar: Idler 21.1%, Collectathon 20.3%, Incremental 20.2%, Automation 13.7%, Management 8.2%
- #60 LORED
66% matchVery Positive80% of 239 reviews2025
Dev: Dillon Simpson
Windows · Linux
An idle game about collecting cancer with quirky stickfigures!
Why similar: Collectathon 20.1%, Incremental 18.8%, Idler 17.8%, Automation 14.4%, Crafting 9.9%