- #1 A Little Faraway
97% matchNo user reviews
Dev: MinMin Works
Windows
Some days, you just need a quiet place to be. Come to a little island far away, where you can wander at your own pace, watch the sky change, and discover little wonders. No rush, no expectations, nothing you need to do. Just a beautiful place to stay awhile.
Why similar: Life Sim 25.2%, Walking Simulator 21.1%, Exploration 9.8%, Relaxing 6.5%, 3D 5.8%
- #2 Zen Quest
96% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Dwarven Brothers
Windows
Zen Quest is a relaxing mindfulness game where you design Zen gardens, learn meditation, partake in mindfulness activities, and explore enchanting spirit worlds.
Why similar: Life Sim 13.7%, Nature 12.9%, Walking Simulator 12.6%, Crafting 11.8%, Fantasy 9.6%
- #3 Ellan: The Lost Soul
96% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Nastro Studios
Windows · Mac · Linux
Ellan is a beautiful first-person atmospheric story adventure where life and death intertwine. Accompanied by a guiding light, travel dream-like worlds to uncover lost answers and confront the illusion of choice. Embark on a transformative path to liberation and Moksha. Ellan awaits your discovery.
Why similar: Walking Simulator 18.3%, Nature 12.2%, Emotional 8.6%, Relaxing 8%, Fantasy 7.8%
- #4 The Wolf Within
95% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Miltos
Windows
An exploration game following a wolf and a spirit on their journey in a mysterious world. Solve ancient puzzles, discover beautiful locations and uncover secrets from another era to bring balance to the world
Why similar: Nature 19.9%, Walking Simulator 17.4%, Magic 14.9%, Exploration 9.2%, Fantasy 8.7%
- #5 Camping Vlog Simulator 2024
94% matchMixed67% of 46 reviews2024
Dev: Fluxinate StudioPub: Tayfun Tuna
Windows
Witness breathtaking sunsets and pitch your tent under starry skies. Record your camping adventures and share them with the world!
Why similar: Nature 20.7%, Walking Simulator 19.4%, Relaxing 11.7%, Life Sim 10.1%, Crafting 10%
- #6 Unpetrified: Echoes of Nature
93% matchVery Positive99% of 67 reviews2025
Dev: Dreamhunt StudioPub: Mindscape
Windows
Be a stone Golem and try to save Nature with the help of an adorable Fox! Reconnect ancient sources of energy in environmental puzzles. Discover secrets from a lost civilization and save animals on an emotional quest in a cozy, colorful world.
Why similar: Walking Simulator 18.5%, Magic 15.6%, Fantasy 8.5%, Relaxing 8.1%, Emotional 7.9%
- #7 After the first station
94% match9 user reviews80% of 10 reviews2021
Dev: Lsgamedev
Windows
After the first station is to create a chill and relaxing landscape for the players to explore. It includes light puzzles and fantasy elements. Let’s embark on a journey into the uncharted realm. 🚂 • • • • • • • •
Why similar: Walking Simulator 25.8%, Magic 13.9%, Exploration 9.6%, Fantasy 8.6%, 3D 7.1%
- #8 Plantiquarian
92% matchPositive87% of 14 reviews2026
Dev: Six Goblins
Windows
Plantiquarian is a First-Person 3D Exploration and Puzzle Game, in which you can collect a myriad of mysterious and magical plants - each with their own quirks and abilities! Consult your trusty Encyclopedia to first find, and then figure out how to uproot each specimen.
Why similar: Walking Simulator 26.6%, Nature 20.5%, Exploration 12.6%, 3D 7.3%, Casual 6.5%
- #9 Blacksmith Village
91% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Dave Studio
Windows · Mac
Let's pay off the debt by running the smithy left behind by my grandfather.
Why similar: Crafting 22.4%, Life Sim 21.5%, Nature 19.1%, Relaxing 9.4%, Fantasy 6.5%
- #10 Potions: A Curious Tale
91% matchVery Positive91% of 391 reviews2024
Dev: Stumbling Cat
Windows · Mac · Linux
Potions: A Curious Tale is an adventure & crafting game where wit is your greatest weapon and combat is not always the answer. Play as Luna, a young witch who overcomes obstacles with the potions she brews, as she gathers items from enchanted lands and conquers devious puzzles on her quest.
Why similar: Life Sim 20.8%, Crafting 20.2%, Magic 17.7%, Fantasy 9.2%, Relaxing 8.4%
- #11 The Long Errand
90% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Ludum Collective
Windows
A cozy fantasy delivery game about carrying things that break. A wizard, a cart that creaks, and a crate of fever draughts that will not survive careless hands.
Why similar: Life Sim 28.5%, Magic 10.9%, Exploration 9.3%, Casual 8.9%, Emotional 7.2%
- #12 Smoking Simulator
89% matchVery Positive84% of 160 reviews2023
Dev: Ghost_RUS Games
Windows
Have you ever wanted to relax and have a good smoke in an atmospheric village? Then you are exactly at the right place - take a drag on your cigarette and go ahead and explore our wonderful world.
Why similar: Life Sim 30%, Walking Simulator 21.9%, Nature 16.7%, Exploration 7.9%, Relaxing 6.4%
- #13 Welehola
89% matchNo user reviews
Dev: CozyNest Games
Windows
Step into the shoes of a wizard student to learn the arcane arts in a magical academy! What sort of witching student life would you live?
Why similar: Life Sim 22.3%, Magic 20.7%, Crafting 19.8%, Nature 13.7%, Exploration 6.7%
- #14 Craft in Peace
88% matchNo user reviews
Dev: TonysCraft
Windows
A relaxing pixel-art survival crafting game. Gather resources, craft tools, and build a thriving settlement step by step. Explore the forest, discover new materials, and create a cozy home for your community.
Why similar: Life Sim 23.3%, Crafting 21%, Magic 15.5%, Nature 13.4%, Relaxing 8.4%
- #15 Aether Brew
87% matchNo user reviews
Dev: GeckWiz
Windows
Inherit a forgotten workshop and master the art of potion making in "Aether Brew"! A cozy, exploration-driven alchemy RPG game where you restore magic and uncover secrets in a mystical world.
Why similar: Life Sim 27.2%, Magic 15.8%, Nature 12.9%, Fantasy 9.4%, Exploration 9.1%
- #16 Magic Regrowth
86% matchPositive100% of 11 reviews2026
Dev: Awesome Alpacas Atelier
Windows
Magic Regrowth is a relaxing incremental game where you restore the magic of floating islands by planting magical trees, bushes, and flowers. Transform forgotten landscapes into vibrant sanctuaries at your own pace, and immerse yourself in a serene and enchanting world.
Why similar: Nature 21.8%, Life Sim 14.1%, Fantasy 13.8%, Relaxing 11.6%, Magic 10.1%
- #17 Fox! Hen! Bag!
85% matchVery Positive95% of 255 reviews2020
Dev: Niflheim
Windows · Mac · Linux
In this short first-person adventure game, you have to bring your friends over to the other mountain by using a tramway car. But beware! Each friend has their own agenda. You have to talk to them to decide which order they should be moved in. Based on a classic riddle.
Why similar: Walking Simulator 24%, Relaxing 12.4%, Fantasy 8.4%, Colorful 8%, Stylized 7.4%
- #18 Mind Your Manas
86% matchNo user reviews2019
Dev: PhatRobit
Windows
Mind Your Manas is a moddable online trading card game.
Why similar: Life Sim 22.6%, Crafting 14.4%, Nature 11.4%, Exploration 7.1%, Emotional 6.9%
- #19 Floraison
84% matchNo user reviews2027
Dev: Sunflower Production
Windows · Mac
Floraison is a cozy narrative game based on the language of flowers. Explore Heimat, meet its curious inhabitants, gather rare plants, and craft emotionally powerful bouquets to help them, shape the story, and convey the message of your choice.
Why similar: Life Sim 19%, Walking Simulator 18.9%, Nature 16.3%, Relaxing 12%, Exploration 11.1%
- #20 Faith Requiem
83% match4 user reviews100% of 4 reviews2025
Dev: Location Unknown
Windows
Walk, interact, and talk with Jesus about why you were about to take your life. Will ralmoke find the will to live again or will this conversation be the final nail in the coffin bring ralmoke to hades?
Why similar: Walking Simulator 24.3%, Nature 11%, Exploration 10.1%, Relaxing 9.9%, Magic 7.7%
- #21 Loverowind
84% matchMixed64% of 97 reviews2021
Dev: Tonguç Bodur
Windows
Loverowind is a very short experience about the wind of spring.
Why similar: Walking Simulator 30.5%, Casual 10.9%, Nature 10.7%, Exploration 10.1%, Emotional 7.6%
- #22 Forage & Brew
82% matchMixed61% of 231 reviews2026
Dev: Forage & BrewPub: Rubika Supinfogame
Windows
Forage & Brew is a game where you play as a Cat witch in her potion workshop. Explore the forest, gather ingredients and brew magical potions in order to help the many clients that will come for your aid. How will you decide to live it out each passing day?
Why similar: Magic 20.5%, Nature 17.1%, Fantasy 11.3%, Life Sim 10%, Relaxing 9.6%
- #23 Raccoon Chronicles
82% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Blue Math
Windows
In the hills by the river is a small village of handful souls. A raccoon walks through them and their past lives discovering their joys and sorrows. Spend your time in an idyllic rustic environment unlocking the villagers' memories and solving environmental puzzles.
Why similar: Nature 25.5%, Walking Simulator 11.2%, Relaxing 9.4%, Stylized 9%, Colorful 8.4%
- #24 Lone Wolf
81% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Tom Black
Windows
A third-person exploration game placed inside of an eye-catching stylized forest. Players control a stunning wolf who was born without a pack and is trying to find a place where he fits in. Along the way, players encounter other animals and secrets which will lead you to uncover your true self.
Why similar: Walking Simulator 26.4%, Nature 12.3%, Exploration 10.9%, Casual 10.1%, Fantasy 7.8%
- #25 Bell & Hoof: The Silent Journey
81% matchMostly Positive76% of 21 reviews2025
Dev: Lilith Guild
Windows
A short walking simulator about a quiet cow, a forgotten chapel, and golden bells. Less than 10 minutes. No enemies. Just peace and hooves, and walking.
Why similar: Walking Simulator 29.8%, Exploration 13.1%, Relaxing 11%, Nature 10.8%, 3D 8.3%
- #26 Flowerbloom Cottage
80% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Cookies and Magic
Windows
Flowerbloom Cottage is a singleplayer simulation game. You take the role of a young witch, who moved to the woods for a school project. Cultivate plants and get in touch with cute wild animals to finish the school project.
Why similar: Crafting 25.1%, Magic 24.4%, Fantasy 13.6%, Exploration 10.5%, Cute 8.2%
- #27 April Grove
79% matchMostly Positive78% of 167 reviews2025
Dev: Colorgrave
Windows
Undertake your new job as a forester in a mystic and peaceful wood. Chop, gather, level up and unravel the expansive forest and its splendor at your own pace, one log at a time!
Why similar: Life Sim 27.9%, Walking Simulator 20.3%, Exploration 10.1%, Relaxing 9.8%, Nature 9.5%
- #28 Mana Circuit
79% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Sayberry Labs
Windows
Arrive at 'Star's Shelter' to find your grandfather missing. Only a mysterious message awaits on his PC. Repair vine-covered Magitech machines and restore the farm with your chatty robot companion, 'Circuit Mk.0'. Follow the digital trail... and you might just find him.
Why similar: Life Sim 23.2%, Crafting 20.1%, Magic 15%, Nature 10.6%, Relaxing 8.7%
- #29 Frutigeropolis: The Promised City
78% matchNo user reviews
Dev: NotTheDarkLord Games
Windows
Step into a surreal city of the old future. Explore environments shaped by the soul of early 2000s design. Slow down inside a world built to be remembered.
Why similar: Walking Simulator 30.5%, Nature 15.9%, Relaxing 11.2%, Exploration 10%, 3D 8.1%
- #30 Pinecone Game
78% matchVery Positive84% of 105 reviews2021
Dev: Frameblade
Windows
Welcome to Pinecone Game, where you can plunge into the wonderful world of throwing pinecones into a well!
Why similar: Nature 25%, Walking Simulator 24.3%, Life Sim 13.9%, Relaxing 11.5%, Casual 10.9%
- #31 Cozy Country
75% matchPositive87% of 31 reviews2026
Dev: Protopop
Windows · Mac
Escape into Cozy Country, a peaceful fantasy landscape creator. Paint forests, place rivers, build a village, add animals, then step inside your world and explore everything you've created. ❤️
Why similar: Walking Simulator 19.5%, Crafting 15.3%, Nature 11%, Emotional 7.3%, Exploration 7.3%
- #32 Arigamma
76% matchNo user reviews
Dev: IllSeeYou
Windows
In this game, we step into the role of Alexandra, our main character. Our goal is to restore the world — to return it to wholeness and stability. For this is a world brimming with danger, where even inanimate objects can come to life and become our allies… or our enemies.
Why similar: Walking Simulator 27.1%, Magic 14.4%, Nature 12.3%, Casual 10.5%, 3D 7.5%
- #33 MY FOX - Desktop Wild Pet
77% matchMostly Positive71% of 49 reviews2021
Dev: 3dm_live_wallpapers
Windows
A relaxing game displayed as wallpaper. Adopt a little fox with whom you will explore the new wild world.
Why similar: Life Sim 23.9%, Walking Simulator 21%, Exploration 7.8%, Magic 7.5%, Casual 5.7%
- #34 Shepherd
77% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2023
Dev: Unherd Of, LLC
Windows
Lead a small herd of sheep through the desert. Ensure their survival by managing their needs. Protect and save them from various environmental hazards, as well as their own silly decisions. Bond with them over the course of your journey by fulfilling their wishes, and be their Shepherd.
Why similar: Life Sim 23.3%, Nature 19.8%, Cute 8.3%, Relaxing 8%, Atmospheric 7.8%
- #35 Furgon Magic Trader
76% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Rise Of WisePub: Rise Of Wise Publisher
Windows
Become a forest alchemist in a traveling van! Grow herbs, collect rare ingredients, create potions on alchemical machines, trade with forest dwellers, and explore new locations. From simple extracts to powerful elixirs
Why similar: Crafting 25.2%, Magic 18.6%, Life Sim 18%, Fantasy 8.2%, Emotional 6.3%
- #36 Vape Simulator
73% matchPositive81% of 26 reviews2025
Dev: Ghost_RUS Games
Windows
Have you dreamed of smoking vape in a charming, cozy town? Just wait for you! Grab your vape and explore this enticing town.
Why similar: Life Sim 32.8%, Walking Simulator 20.9%, Nature 11.8%, Casual 8.3%, Exploration 6.8%
- #37 Island of Giant Trees
74% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: wulongooo
Windows
This is a casual game.where you will take on the role of the protagonist and explore this dream world. The gameplay is very simple, just looking for butterflies.
Why similar: Nature 22.1%, Exploration 13%, Walking Simulator 12.7%, Relaxing 11.7%, First-Person 9.8%
- #38 Lost in Red Valley
75% match9 user reviews44% of 9 reviews2021
Dev: Alex Tyagniryadko
Windows
Lost in Red Valley is a survival game set in feudal Japan. Explore. Craft. Survive! Alone or with friends!
Why similar: Crafting 17.3%, Magic 13.9%, Nature 11%, Emotional 8.1%, Fantasy 8%
- #39 Tree Simulator 2023
73% matchOverwhelmingly Positive95% of 813 reviews2022
Dev: RevmatekPub: Remvatek
Windows
Median: 3.4 hrsMean: 189.1 hrs≥1hr: 78%
It's exactly what it sounds like! Have you ever wanted to be a tree? Do you like odd numbers? How about multiplayer, weather, seasons and more!? Well then this is the game for you! Come on down to a place where you will never want to leaf. Relax and be the best tree you can be. 1-250 players.
Why similar: Life Sim 25.7%, Walking Simulator 22.3%, Nature 11.9%, Exploration 8.2%, Emotional 8.1%
- #40 Fire Dogs
74% matchPositive84% of 43 reviews2022
Dev: ProfourPub: Obliterated Entertainment
Windows · Mac · Linux
Explore the atmospheric retelling of the Korean mythological tale of the Bulgae and their pursuit of the Sun and Moon for their master, the King of Darkness.
Why similar: Walking Simulator 22.1%, Nature 18.2%, Magic 17.1%, Relaxing 10.8%, Fantasy 9.5%
- #41 Side Effect
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: justLukass
Windows · Mac
Let this first person exploration game take you to a waste covered island to fight pollution one garbage at a time. Team up with wild animals, discover hidden stories and defeat monster called pollution once and for all.
Why similar: Walking Simulator 18.9%, Magic 17.8%, Nature 15.9%, Relaxing 8.6%, Exploration 7.2%
- #42 Komo: A Sunlit Journey
72% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Shareru LLC
Windows
A cozy metaverse chat app where you can relax in a gentle, soothing world. Stroll through beautiful nature or gather around a campfire to chat. Set up chairs and tables or pull out food and drinks at your favorite spot. Spend time alone or with others — enjoy your place at your own pace.
Why similar: Walking Simulator 25.5%, Nature 20.1%, Relaxing 11%, Exploration 8.2%, Atmospheric 7%
- #43 Red Panda: The Quiet Path
71% matchMostly Positive73% of 26 reviews2025
Dev: Uberbax-Gaming
Windows
A peaceful third-person adventure where you play as a red panda. Climb trees, roll into a ball, swim, knock down objects, and even fly with a balloon! No combat, no rush — just the forest, atmosphere, and full immersion in nature.
Why similar: Walking Simulator 26.8%, Nature 23%, Emotional 9.2%, Cute 7.7%, Relaxing 7.5%
- #44 Brew & Bottle
71% matchNo user reviews2027
Dev: Bastosha
Windows
A cozy first-person alchemy game where every potion is made by hand. Crack a gem in the mortar, chop, press and stir - then decipher recipes written as riddles and sell what you brew to a village full of customers.
Why similar: Life Sim 26.8%, Crafting 18.4%, Exploration 8.9%, Magic 7.9%, Casual 6.7%
- #45 Our Mountain
72% matchPositive90% of 20 reviews2022
Dev: Rachata SuksereekulPub: Good Monkey
Windows
Charles, a man living a peaceful life in the countryside, is faced with a serious problem that requires him to return to the city on the other side of the valley. With time running out, Charles embarks on a journey through a national park that is rumored to be home to supernatural occurrences.
Why similar: Walking Simulator 24.7%, Nature 21%, Exploration 9.2%, Atmospheric 7.4%, First-Person 6.2%
- #46 ANGEL SPIRIT
70% matchPositive100% of 21 reviews2024
Dev: OP37K
Windows
Embark on a mystical journey as an angelic spirit. Navigate through ten unique atmospheric levels on a quest to unlock magical powers.
Why similar: Walking Simulator 20.8%, Magic 11.6%, Nature 8.5%, Exploration 7.4%, Emotional 7.3%
- #47 Adorable Adventures
67% matchVery Positive94% of 970 reviews2026
Dev: Wild Sheep StudioPub: PQube
Windows
Median: 3.2 hrsMean: 4.3 hrs≥1hr: 83%
Play as Boris, a curious baby boar who must learn how to use his nose to reunite with his family after a forest fire. Explore beautiful landscapes, track scents, and uncover secrets as you slowly reconnect with nature in this cozy animal adventure.
Why similar: Walking Simulator 20.7%, Nature 16.3%, Relaxing 13.2%, Exploration 11.7%, Cute 8.6%
- #48 Puzzle O´Matic
69% match2 user reviews50% of 2 reviews2026
Dev: Avenori Playworks
Windows
Explore a cozy island, take photos of cute creatures and beautiful places, and turn every picture into a handmade jigsaw puzzle you can complete right away or save for later.
Why similar: Walking Simulator 25.8%, Casual 9.4%, Exploration 9.3%, Nature 8.7%, 3D 6.2%
- #49 Picterra
70% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Team SoepSoup
Windows
Explore a colourful world full of interesting flora and fauna to document with your camera and notebook
Why similar: Nature 16.5%, Exploration 13.7%, Casual 13.3%, 3D 9.8%, Colorful 9.4%
- #50 Traversing Traveler
71% matchMostly Positive76% of 17 reviews2021
Dev: Caffinated Cauldron
Windows
Play as an alchemist named Taylor using various potions find your way around and unlock new areas to talk to various townsfolk who wish to see the path between villages restored.
Why similar: Magic 29%, Walking Simulator 19%, Exploration 9.4%, Stylized 9%, Colorful 8.9%
- #51 Spellogger
70% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: BASTI GAMES
Windows
The first ever life-sim RPG where you play as a Wizard Lumberjack! Fell trees with your axe and magic. Explore a quiet world full of secrets, help villagers with their troubles, and steadily grow stronger as you gather resources and take down more trees.
Why similar: Life Sim 24.8%, Crafting 12.8%, Magic 10%, Casual 8.8%, Nature 7.4%
- #52 Shroomer
69% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Trisgram
Windows
In this open-world relaxed VR fantasy, you are Shroomer, a mystical forager tasked with managing a secret enchanted forest. Gather rare fungi and vegetation, craft elixirs, build tools and complete tasks. Handle dangerous mushrooms with special approach or risk being claimed by the forest’s magic.
Why similar: Crafting 18.4%, Magic 16.9%, Nature 14.9%, Life Sim 10.3%, Fantasy 9.7%
- #53 Library Of Lyria
69% matchNo user reviews
Dev: RainLight
Windows
Restore a magical library and turn a ruin into a wonderful, enchanted place that you fill with new life. Craft enchanted books, cater to unique readers and explore a whimsical world in this cozy sandbox, farm and management sim. Uncover ancient secrets and bring forgotten knowledge back to life!
Why similar: Crafting 22%, Magic 16.7%, Nature 14.9%, Fantasy 10.3%, Exploration 7.7%
- #54 My Dear Emma
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Soulven Games
Windows
Exploring beautiful landscapes and local wildlife. Become part of Emma’s story, a young biologist and nature photographer who has decided to start a new life far from the big city. A narrative-driven adventure to relax, feel, and slow down.
Why similar: Walking Simulator 20.9%, Life Sim 13.6%, Nature 12.1%, Crafting 11.4%, Emotional 10.4%
- #55 Dreaming Worlds
67% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Dominik WolffPub: Games by Dominik Wolff
Windows
Dive into the dreaming worlds of the four dream keepers and find out why they don't answer anymore. Rescue the trapped inhabitants of the dream worlds, change the dreams back to good and discover mysterious places and puzzles. But something dark will stand in your way.
Why similar: Walking Simulator 26.6%, Nature 13.1%, Exploration 9.7%, Relaxing 7.6%, Stylized 7.1%
- #56 Magic Wands Workshop
67% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Cleversan GamesPub: Sim Farm S.A.
Windows
A unique wand workshop simulator where you can create amazing combinations of wand elements and test their power! Immerse yourself in the world of magic and match wands to your demanding clients.
Why similar: Crafting 21.2%, Magic 20.9%, Life Sim 19.7%, Relaxing 9.1%, Fantasy 7.2%
- #57 Crabs
66% matchPositive100% of 19 reviews2025
Dev: Breaker Game Studios
Windows
Take care of your very own hermit crab in Crabs! Raise and train your crab to explore the backyard, uncover hidden secrets, and develop new abilities. Keep your crab alive by checking in regularly in this offline idle simulator. Get Crabs and Take Responsibility.
Why similar: Life Sim 24.4%, Walking Simulator 21%, Crafting 11.3%, Stylized 5.6%, Casual 5.5%
- #58 Steinvar
66% matchNo user reviews2027
Dev: Cold Cup Games
Windows
Explore a mysterious, atmospheric world and cleanse creeping corruption using the power of light. Discover secrets, restore lost places, and shape your journey in a story-driven fantasy adventure.
Why similar: Magic 19.3%, Nature 17.6%, Fantasy 11.8%, Emotional 11%, Exploration 9.1%
- #59 Rocky Park
66% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Paltypus
Windows
Do you like rocks? Come to Rocky Park to discover and collect as many as you can! Explore a cozy natural park at your own pace, meet its inhabitants, and let yourself be surprised by the little secrets hidden around every corner.
Why similar: Walking Simulator 31.9%, Exploration 14.1%, Nature 13.5%, Relaxing 11.6%, First-Person 9.4%