- #1 Rage and Fury
97% matchNo user reviews2027
Dev: EntroOne
Windows · Mac · Linux
Rage and Fury is a fast-paced 2D beat ’em up built like a lost ’90s action movie. Fight through the streets, unleash devastating combos, turn the environment into a weapon, and follow Logan Hunter through a cinematic story packed with action, attitude and humor.
Why similar: Runner 25.1%, 2D Fighter 22.1%, Lore-Rich 12.6%, 2D Platformer 10.9%, Funny 10.2%
- #2 Darby Is Here Forever
96% matchPositive100% of 21 reviews2026
Dev: Gaua Games
Windows
Help little Darby escape from his castle and reclaim his land from the Demon King's claws in this challenging 2d precision platformer. Explore every hidden corner, use your vampiric powers wisely and face the Demon King to get your home back before your family returns from holiday.
Why similar: Vampires 41.1% ★, 2D Platformer 15%, Funny 14.3%, Demons 10.9%, Pixel Graphics 10.6%
- #3 Clappy Cheeks: Lust and Magic
96% matchPositive96% of 25 reviews2026
Dev: NuruNekoPub: Saikey Studios
Windows
"Clappy Cheeks: Lust and Magic" is an erotic game where you jump to fly and xxx. You will hear the clap clap voices of them cheeks as you play. Let's fly deep into myserious castle of vampire queen!
Why similar: Vampires 37.3% ★, Demons 18.3%, Hand-drawn 11.3%, 2D Platformer 8.4%, Pixel Graphics 6%
- #4 Taivas
95% match5 user reviews0% of 5 reviews2020
Dev: F-GamesPub: JTS Development
Windows
Taivas is a mysterious action roguelite set in a world of myth, and a time of magic. The destiny of a Canidae Kingdom rests on the shoulders of a young fox alike boy. His name… Joakim. Use spells and special weapons to explore, destroy and fight your way to the UpWorld, and beyond...
Why similar: Demons 16.1%, Hand-drawn 13.3%, Space 10.2%, 2D Platformer 10.1%, Surreal 10.1%
- #5 Pencil Pursuit
94% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Terrace Vale Gaming
Windows
Outrun the eraser. A hand-drawn runner across 26 notebook pages: flee five stationery villains, topple the WAR MACHINE they bolt together, then turn the chase around in PENCIL REVENGE and claim the page in REDRAW.
Why similar: Runner 27.5%, Score Attack 15%, Hand-drawn 14.9%, 2D Platformer 14.4%, Funny 13.8%
- #6 EndlessCar
94% matchMostly Positive75% of 11 reviews2023
Dev: LIJUN
Windows
The car passes through obstacles to earn points mini-game.
Why similar: 2D Fighter 29.2%, Runner 25.3%, 2D Platformer 12.3%, Casual 9.1%, Action-Adventure 8.9%
- #7 From Shadows
93% matchMixed64% of 64 reviews2017
Dev: Revolt and RebelPub: Klabater
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 3.6 hrsMean: 12.7 hrs≥1hr: 94%
Action-platformer filled to the brim with blood, mayhem, and demons straight from hell! Play solo or with your friends in split-screen, upgrade your beast, and mow down hordes of enemies and their towering lieutenants.
Why similar: Vampires 33.2% ★, 2D Fighter 19.2%, Demons 13.3%, Hand-drawn 10.3%, 2D Platformer 8.7%
- #8 Glitch World
92% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2024
Dev: Radar
Windows
Glitch World is a retro-platform-shooter where the levels change WHILE YOU PLAY! How far will you make it?
Why similar: Runner 23.9%, Funny 14.3%, Demons 13.1%, Surreal 11.9%, 2D Platformer 11.8%
- #9 HerrAnwalt: Lawyers Legacy
91% matchMostly Positive78% of 521 reviews2022
Dev: YannickPub: YGameStudios
Windows
You’re a Lawyer who tries to save students from a crazy headmaster. You need to survive a variety of school lessons and fight the different teachers
Why similar: 2D Fighter 28.3%, Runner 22.2%, Funny 11.7%, 2D Platformer 11.5%, Action-Adventure 8.6%
- #10 FawnRun
91% matchNo user reviews2024
Dev: LN
Windows
The only level 2D casual mini-game there is please keep moving.
Why similar: Runner 31.4%, 2D Platformer 16.7%, Casual 12.6%, Action-Adventure 12.5%, Pixel Graphics 9.1%
- #11 BATS: Bloodsucker Anti-Terror Squad
90% matchPositive100% of 11 reviews2021
Dev: Ritual GamesPub: The MIX Games
Windows
A fast and frantic arcade extravaganza with tons of action and gallons of blood! It's up to Count Bloodvayne and his vampire powers to rescue his BATS teammates from Scorpion Supreme and STING's evil clutches.
Why similar: Vampires 31.6% ★, Demons 16.1%, Score Attack 13.7%, Funny 12.5%, 2D Platformer 9.4%
- #12 Pixel Robot Return
89% matchMostly Negative39% of 18 reviews2022
Dev: Gamesforgames
Windows
Pixel robot is coming back. Destroy enormous robot boss and collect treasures
Why similar: 2D Fighter 32.5%, Runner 24.8%, 2D Platformer 13.1%, Space 9.5%, Surreal 8.9%
- #13 Combo Haven
89% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Alex Priest
Windows · Mac · Linux
Combo Haven is a platform fighter inspired single-player game where your only task is to perform the sickest combos possible. Progress through a variety of levels and compete for high scores. Uncover new mechanics, abilities and characters along the way.
Why similar: 2D Fighter 28.4%, Score Attack 21.3%, 2D Platformer 12.8%, Hand-drawn 12.6%, Action-Adventure 7.8%
- #14 PizzaCat
88% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2026
Dev: Jess Makes Games
Windows · Mac
Ride a slice of pizza through space as PizzaCat. Collect toppings, dodge asteroids, and whatever you do…don’t cheese it.
Why similar: Runner 32.2%, Score Attack 23.6%, Funny 15.4%, Colorful 7.9%, Space 7.7%
- #15 STRIKERS
87% matchPositive100% of 17 reviews2022
Dev: AmadeoxH
Windows
STRIKERS is an indie fighting game where if you get hit once, you lose. Battle using the Heroes and Villains of the multiverse in Arcade mode to unlock skins and lore, or challenge others and see who is a better fighter!
Why similar: 2D Fighter 23.9%, Demons 14.3%, Lore-Rich 14%, Funny 10.9%, Space 10.5%
- #16 Chickey Kong
86% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Raúl Segura Vallejo
Windows
A tribute to 80s arcades. Scale dangerous levels, dodge enemies, and test your reflexes in this challenging pixel-art platformer. For nostalgia lovers only! We'll see you there.
Why similar: Runner 30.4%, 2D Platformer 12.3%, Action-Adventure 12%, Casual 10.7%, Funny 10.1%
- #17 JumpKin
85% match9 user reviews100% of 9 reviews2025
Dev: Umut KAYAPub: Kuark Games
Windows · Mac
Think you're the best pumpkin? Being a pumpkin isn't for everyone. So join the competition with your friends in this addictive 2D platformer. It's time to immerse yourself in the JumpKin challenge!
Why similar: 2D Fighter 30.3%, Hand-drawn 16.2%, 2D Platformer 12.6%, Action-Adventure 9.4%, Colorful 7.3%
- #18 your cattle
86% matchNo user reviews2025
Dev: 疯人院游戏
Windows
An interactive casual game. By utilizing mechanics such as charging, knocking back, stunning, and blink, players can hone their skills in a low-pressure environment.Accompanied by exquisite music and smooth interactions, relieve emotional stress.
Why similar: 2D Fighter 39.9%, 2D Platformer 17.2%, Casual 11.9%, Pixel Graphics 11.4%, 2D 7.2%
- #19 Become an Adventurer
84% match3 user reviews67% of 3 reviews2024
Dev: Marych IvanPub: IVAMAR Games
Windows
Become an Adventurer - Це чудова гра, в якій є багато можливостей. Як досліджувати світ в ролі Авантюриста, виконувати завдання, битися з монстрами. Купити поле, стати фермером, купувати будинки, змагатися на арені і т.д.
Why similar: Vampires 31% ★, 2D Fighter 23.5%, Demons 14.2%, Funny 11.3%, Lore-Rich 9.8%
- #20 Little Dasher!
84% matchPositive100% of 21 reviews2023
Dev: Doğukan Önder
Windows
Little Dasher! is a mini-game that offers an average of 30-45 minutes of enjoyable and challenging platform game experience with fantastic music. Please note that the time depends on your reflexes and abilities.
Why similar: Runner 32.7%, 2D Platformer 17.8%, Pixel Graphics 12%, Casual 10.7%, Funny 7.3%
- #21 We're Party Together!
83% matchPositive87% of 15 reviews2023
Dev: Ev_Nyang
Windows
Easy to understand and simple casual game. Let's play 10 mini-games using WASD and arrow keys and run for a new record!
Why similar: 2D Platformer 21.6%, Score Attack 20.1%, Hand-drawn 15.7%, Casual 12.5%, 2D 10.6%
- #22 Eggstraordinary Goose Chase
82% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Just Games Ltd
Windows · Mac · Linux
Not your everyday goose chase—this time, the goose is on the hunt! Sprint through vibrant levels, dodge obstacles, collect berries, stomp enemies, and take bold risks! Keep running, push your limits, and reclaim what’s yours!
Why similar: Runner 25%, Score Attack 19%, Funny 13.7%, 2D Platformer 11%, Hand-drawn 10.8%
- #23 Friends With Traitors
81% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2025
Dev: Kai John Kutsy-Durbin
Windows · Mac
1 of 4 friends meets the dark truth of getting betrayed by the others
Why similar: 2D Fighter 31.2%, Demons 17.6%, 2D Platformer 12.8%, Funny 10.1%, Action-Adventure 9.7%
- #24 Momoka (wo) Wasshoi
79% matchVery Positive94% of 829 reviews2025
Dev: TOEI ANIMATION Co.,Ltd
Windows
Safely escort the intoxicated person to her couch at home.
Why similar: Runner 35.9%, Funny 21%, 2D Platformer 18.9%, Cute 8.6%, Casual 8%
- #25 Adventure Llama
81% matchVery Positive96% of 53 reviews2020
Dev: Orube Game Studio
Windows
When other Llamas spit at people and eat grass all day, Pablo is different: He explores ancient ruins built by the Inca Llamas of the past! Solve puzzles, avoid traps, and gallop madly to uncover ancient llama treasures!
Why similar: Runner 34.3%, 2D Platformer 19.2%, Funny 13%, Action-Adventure 9.1%, Casual 9%
- #26 Legend Incarnates
79% matchNo user reviews
Dev: StarBlight Studios
Windows · Linux
A momentum based 2D fighter where speed is everything. Chain lightning fast combat and powerful crystilic magic in chaotic battles online or with friends.
Why similar: 2D Fighter 32.3%, Runner 22.4%, 2D Platformer 12.9%, Hand-drawn 12.5%, Casual 9%
- #27 Jelly Forest
80% matchPositive88% of 17 reviews2022
Dev: BobbiDrenPub: khukhrovr
Windows
Help the cube jump over the steep rocks and get as far as possible before he loses all his three hearts
Why similar: Runner 25.6%, Score Attack 20%, Hand-drawn 17%, 2D Platformer 12.6%, Colorful 8.2%
- #28 赛博杀手 Cyberkiller2049
78% match9 user reviews100% of 9 reviews2024
Dev: Finch Games
Windows
Cyberkiller 2049 is a platform-action fast-paced game that battles numerous enemies on destructible platforms. Manipulate the character, kill with one hit, sprint, kill enemies. Picking up bats, remote-controlled bombs. Fight enemies with different abilities.
Why similar: 2D Fighter 23.9%, Runner 18.5%, Pixel Graphics 14.8%, 2D Platformer 13.5%, Funny 9.8%
- #29 Thunderman - Adventures in another realm
77% match8 user reviews100% of 8 reviews2025
Dev: Robson ZImmermannPub: Experia Studio
Windows
Thunderman: Adventures in Another Realm is an exhilarating 2D action-platformer where you embark on an epic journey alongside Kaelan, a young archer chosen as the defender of the universe. To restore peace, you must face dangerous enemies, gather resources to survive.
Why similar: Runner 26.4%, Funny 15.6%, 2D Platformer 12.7%, Action-Adventure 8%, Exploration 7.6%
- #30 Sippin Hot Blickety Block N Bop Those Bad Battle Boys Down To Size Supreme
78% matchPositive100% of 12 reviews2022
Dev: Sippin Hot
Windows
Hop and bop your way to victory against a wild parade of killer blocks in this endless runner!
Why similar: Runner 25.7%, Score Attack 16.8%, Hand-drawn 12.9%, Funny 11.5%, 2D Platformer 11.2%
- #31 Super Frog
75% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Hakimi Game
Windows
Super Frog is a boss-focused side-scrolling action-adventure. A mysterious power warped all frogs of Frog Island into weird monsters. Hero Froggy fights them, gathers abilities and gear to create custom combat styles, and heads to the root of the anomaly.
Why similar: 2D Platformer 20.7%, Hand-drawn 18.8%, Funny 17.1%, Action-Adventure 15.4%, Cute 10.5%
- #32 Wisly and the Chickens!
76% matchPositive100% of 20 reviews2021
Dev: Dynix Studios
Windows · Mac
Wisly and the Chickens! Is an 2D platform runner. The game tells the comical history of the chicken coop revolt against a lovely weasel. Help Wisly to find the cage parts to capture the evil Galinacio and thus to explain to the chickens this big misunderstanding. Let's RUN!
Why similar: Runner 36.2%, Funny 19.7%, 2D Platformer 17.9%, Colorful 8.1%, 2D 7.6%
- #33 RollRift Arena
75% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: leeyobo
Windows
Stop your dice on the higher roll to win each turn — then move, attack, and grab power-ups as the arena collapses ring by ring. Outlast everyone on the last tile. Online ranked PvP, AI battles, local same-keyboard duels, a global leaderboard, and pixel-art character customization.
Why similar: 2D Fighter 36.7%, 2D Platformer 14.9%, Funny 11.5%, Casual 10.3%, Pixel Graphics 8.7%
- #34 Meteor Genocide
76% match3 user reviews0% of 3 reviews2021
Dev: What a game ?
Windows
Our only goal in this 2D space game is to reach the highest score by avoiding the meteor obstacles on our way.
Why similar: Hand-drawn 18.5%, 2D Platformer 16.7%, Score Attack 12.5%, Action-Adventure 12.4%, Casual 11.4%
- #35 Red Cap Adventure
73% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2026
Dev: HUOPIE
Windows
Embark on a surprise-filled fantasy adventure! Traverse lush grasslands, scorching volcanoes, frozen plains, the vast expanse of space, and magical forests. Brave cleverly designed traps and mechanisms, dash through fast-paced levels, and race toward the finish line!
Why similar: Runner 32.3%, 2D Platformer 20.2%, Pixel Graphics 13.3%, Funny 13.1%, Relaxing 6.5%
- #36 Gobyworld
74% matchVery Positive91% of 53 reviews2023
Dev: Lisha Pleasure Industries
Windows · Mac
An absurd point-and-click adventure, where you help Goby, a piece of swallowed gum, in his quest to find freedom beyond the digestive system.
Why similar: Funny 23%, Surreal 20.1%, Pixel Graphics 12.2%, Cute 9.5%, Colorful 9.3%
- #37 Bloody Layne
77% matchNo user reviews2021
Dev: John SchneddiPub: Schneddi Universe
Windows
Layne has been bitten by a vampire has to survive his way to his creator. Decide to become human again or stay a vampire! Will you be good or evil? Find out in Bloody Layne, an RPG action game with fully voiced dialogue (English & German)
Why similar: Vampires 38.8% ★, 2D Fighter 25.6%, Hand-drawn 11.7%, 2D Platformer 10.2%, Action-Adventure 7.9%
- #38 Meowhiss the snake
73% match6 user reviews100% of 6 reviews2024
Dev: GingerSoup Studio
Windows
"Meowhiss the snake" is a cute 2D game whose core gameplay is based on classic Snake, but also combined with some roguelike elements for you to explore. Before losing all the head-body, gear up your character, reach more levels, and get more scores!
Why similar: Runner 29.9%, Score Attack 24.7%, Funny 13.9%, Exploration 8.2%, Colorful 6.8%
- #39 Minipo
74% matchNo user reviews2025
Dev: Kadir Gülağız
Windows
Minipo is a fun and simple platform game designed for children. In the game, you’ll join our character Minipo on exciting adventures across 5 different worlds and 25 unique levels. The main goal is to reach the final level and reunite Minipo with her rabbit friends.
Why similar: Runner 21.9%, 2D Platformer 19.3%, Colorful 10.4%, Funny 10.4%, Casual 10.3%
- #40 Fantasy Boy
73% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Serafini Productions
Windows
Fantasy Boy is a 2D platformer that follows the adventures of Boy. Explore a fantasy world, battle numerous enemies, and most importantly, have FUN!
Why similar: Runner 23.3%, Hand-drawn 17%, Funny 15.8%, 2D Platformer 12.2%, Pixel Graphics 8%
- #41 Panda vs Bugs
72% matchMostly Positive75% of 12 reviews2024
Dev: Pita Game
Windows
The cute panda "Shearer" is playing happily on the bamboo, an army of bugs is climbing up the tree unknowingly, avoid the bugs carefully and use "weapons" to defeat the army of bugs!
Why similar: 2D Platformer 23.5%, Funny 22.9%, Score Attack 18%, Cute 9.8%, Casual 9.1%
- #42 OVERALL THE BALL
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: GENEZ
Windows
Overall The Ball is a party game played locally, from 2 to 4 players. Bounce a giant ball and eat your friends , play as colorful characters, use your abilities to take advantage and score points! Become the master of the arena!
Why similar: 2D Fighter 34.1%, Funny 15.9%, 2D Platformer 15.3%, Score Attack 12.1%, Colorful 8.6%
- #43 Vampire Suplex
71% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: DUMARU Inc.
Windows
Punches won't finish them. Kicks won't either. SUPLEX will! Vampire SUPLEX is an absurd parody of classic 2D fighters. Survive the onslaught, seize your opening, and bring those arrogant bloodsuckers crashing down. One decisive SUPLEX. One spectacular finish.
Why similar: 2D Fighter 31.6%, Vampires 27.9% ★, Funny 9.9%, Casual 8.7%, Colorful 8.5%
- #44 Purry Furry Adventurry
72% match8 user reviews100% of 8 reviews2022
Dev: Crabby Collabby
Windows
Help Kat escape from her loving owner in this cute little endless runner!
Why similar: Runner 31.2%, Funny 17.7%, 2D Platformer 15.6%, Score Attack 11%, Cute 7.3%
- #45 KABENAGURI
71% matchMostly Positive70% of 10 reviews2022
Dev: Tomoki
Windows
This is a game of punching walls.
Why similar: Funny 32.2%, 2D Fighter 22.7%, Score Attack 18.7%, 2D Platformer 9.6%, Casual 8.8%
- #46 The Cake
70% matchPositive100% of 10 reviews2024
Dev: Racjin Co., Ltd.
Windows
Deliver a birthday cake to your beloved daughter! Avoid oncoming passersby and aim for the goal! If the cake collapses when it hits someone, you will die instantly! A casual but highly difficult action game.
Why similar: Score Attack 27.5%, Hand-drawn 25.6%, Funny 18%, Casual 12.2%, 2D Platformer 6.6%
- #47 MAGICAL ANGEL FAIRY HEART_Standard
69% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: NEKOLABPub: UMAI NEKO
Windows
A belt-scrolling action game where the adorable magical girl Fairy Heart battles mysterious enemies to protect the city, featuring smooth animations and the nostalgic charm of classic arcade action games.
Why similar: 2D Fighter 41.6%, 2D Platformer 17.6%, Surreal 13.9%, Casual 12.6%, 2D 7.3%
- #48 The Moon my Destination
67% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2026
Dev: Make it a Triple
Windows · Linux
Get into the flow of running endlessly, climbing a giant blooming stalk with the mooncalf that wants to reach the moon. A relaxing soundtrack helps you forget time as you jump ever upward.
Why similar: Runner 31.2%, Hand-drawn 16%, Score Attack 11.3%, 2D Platformer 10.5%, Relaxing 9.1%
- #49 Element Runner
70% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2022
Dev: CarlPlay
Windows · Mac
Across land, water and clouds! Element Runner is a fun, casual platformer where you can explore worlds filled with grass, water, fire, candy and electricity! Featuring over 8 worlds and 60 levels, this game is a relaxing, completionists dream. Your journey in Element Runner awaits!
Why similar: 2D Fighter 28.6%, Runner 19.8%, 2D Platformer 12.1%, Action-Adventure 9%, Exploration 6.6%
- #50 Nūr
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Hala MohammedPub: Hala M. Dev
Windows · Mac · Linux
Join Nur on her quest to uncover the mystery of her missing parents and reunite with her friends. Experience a game that not only entertains but also touches the heart.
Why similar: Funny 15.2%, 2D Platformer 14.8%, Surreal 12.3%, Hand-drawn 12%, Exploration 9.2%
- #51 The Linda Society
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Kalle MacDonald
Windows
The Linda Society is a bizarro vampire-adventure game. Join Linda Lastname, Sandy Loam, Terror Mary, Cousin Jack, and Pio on their quest to destroy a vile group of anti-vampires known as The Pressure Men.
Why similar: Vampires 45.9% ★, Funny 14.7%, Surreal 14.5%, Hand-drawn 9.6%, Exploration 6.5%
- #52 Samurai`s Way
70% matchNo user reviews2024
Dev: TinC
Windows
In "Samurai`s Way," a 2D runner-clicker by TinC Studio, players guide Kenji, a samurai, through ancient world. The game blends swift action with strategic ability use, facing mythical bosses and upgrading skills in a visually striking world. Embrace the samurai spirit in this fast-paced adventure.
Why similar: 2D Fighter 27.6%, Runner 18.8%, Demons 12.1%, 2D Platformer 11.3%, Action-Adventure 8.3%
- #53 Space Thugs
67% match6 user reviews100% of 6 reviews2025
Dev: DiscoCarGames
Windows
Space Thugs, join the space thugs as they got on an adventure across the universe. Includes strip clubs.
Why similar: Space 23.8%, 2D Fighter 21.3%, Funny 17.1%, 2D Platformer 14.1%, 2D 7.1%
- #54 Magic gems
69% matchMixed61% of 28 reviews2021
Dev: Beneath the Night Productions
Windows
Magic gems game is an unusual game for fans of the genre "three in a row", in which you have to break a combo of gems on your own to complete the level.
Why similar: 2D Fighter 24%, Runner 23.5%, Hand-drawn 14.8%, 2D Platformer 8.1%, Pixel Graphics 7.4%
- #55 Labyrinth : Dracula's lair
67% match4 user reviews100% of 4 reviews2025
Dev: MyceliumGames
Windows · Linux
Trapped in Dracula’s labyrinth, hunted by monsters, armed only with relics — explore, survive, and uncover the path to eternal life, where beyond the fog lie secrets never meant to be found.
Why similar: Vampires 41.2% ★, Demons 20.5%, Score Attack 16.8%, Horror 7.8%, Action-Adventure 7.3%
- #56 Paperman
65% match4 user reviews75% of 4 reviews2026
Dev: Tyoven
Windows
Want to become the new boss of a thriving paper company whose owner mysteriously died? Track down the culprit and catch them to become the new boss. But beware, your adventure will be littered with some tricky obstacles...
Why similar: 2D Fighter 35.4%, 2D Platformer 15.7%, Pixel Graphics 10.7%, Colorful 9.3%, Funny 8.2%
- #57 Balloon Girl
69% match3 user reviews33% of 3 reviews2019
Dev: Nerdvision Games
Windows
Balloon Girl is a 2d flying platformer game where you fly through the dangerous and colorful world.
Why similar: 2D Platformer 23.6%, Pixel Graphics 16.6%, Relaxing 12.2%, Score Attack 11.1%, Funny 11.1%
- #58 Snake 贪吃蛇
66% matchPositive80% of 15 reviews2025
Dev: Stars Sanctuary
Windows
The classic and pure Snake game.
Why similar: Funny 30.1%, Pixel Graphics 21.7%, Casual 19.2%, Relaxing 15.2%, 2D 13.8%