- #1 Pooping Cat
97% matchPositive95% of 42 reviews2025
Dev: Repeater Studio
Windows
Press a key, click your mouse — and POOP! Our adorable kitty leaves a little digital gift just for you. Who wouldn't fall in love with that?
Why similar: Idler 27.1%, Incremental 24.2%, Tabletop 23.4%, Cute 6.8%, Relaxing 6.5%
- #2 Poison Lizard Paradise
96% match6 user reviews100% of 6 reviews2024
Dev: Dドライブ開発部
Windows
A little cute Chiyari-style lizard growing game is here! Grow up fast ✨Grow up a lot! You may be able to meet various kinds of lizards? Let's love the lizards that move around in all directions ‼️
Why similar: God Game 47.6% ★, Idler 28.4%, Simulation 9.2%, Cute 7%, Casual 6.2%
- #3 挂机修仙-宗门飞升
96% matchMixed65% of 31 reviews2025
Dev: The Fat Worker
Windows
A casual idle game of the xianxia genre. 一款修仙类型的挂机休闲小游戏。经营你的宗门,通过修真六艺--炼丹、炼器、阵法、符箓、傀儡、驯兽不断获得资源,助你的宗门不断的晋升品阶。
Why similar: Idler 32.5%, God Game 26% ★, Incremental 23.7%, Simulation 10.7%, Casual 6.6%
- #4 Get to Work! Girls of Gensokyo
95% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Little Tiger Game
Windows
A pixel-art idle fan game set in Gensokyo. Jealous of Kourindou's success, a broke Reimu decides to set up shops on the shrine grounds to make bank! Recruit youkai, gather resources, and build a bustling commercial street in this relaxing Gensokyo management sim.
Why similar: Idler 28.8%, God Game 27.3% ★, Incremental 21%, Simulation 9.5%, Casual 5%
- #5 Lootabox
94% matchNo user reviews
Dev: DevelopingHermit
Windows
Lootabox is an incremental game about the satisfying feeling of opening lootboxes and collecting items.
Why similar: God Game 37.1% ★, Incremental 22.4%, Idler 15.2%, Simulation 11.3%, Casual 5.8%
- #6 Loafing Town
94% matchVery Positive86% of 571 reviews2025
Dev: GoblinZzPub: IndieArk
Windows
Median: 43.0 hrsMean: 114.8 hrs≥1hr: 89%
A relaxing and humorous idle god simulator that stays at the bottom of your screen or on a second monitor while you do other things. With physics-based dragging interactions, it feels just like playing with desk toys.
Why similar: God Game 34.3% ★, Idler 21.7%, Incremental 16.1%, Relaxing 5.7%, Funny 5.4%
- #7 Toilet Paper Idle
93% matchMixed56% of 25 reviews2026
Dev: CHIZ
Windows
Toilet Paper Idle is an incremental game about consuming as much toilet papers as possible with the help of helpers, skills, and upgrades. Discover special types of toilet papers as you progress, and be careful to not clog your toilet!
Why similar: Idler 41.5%, Incremental 31.3%, Simulation 9.3%, Casual 4.9%, Funny 4%
- #8 Merit Pet
92% matchNo user reviews
Dev: BitByDesign
Windows
Merit Pet is a pixel-style idle casual game where you earn karma by tapping a wooden fish. Unlock adorable characters, backgrounds, and mini-games like the lucky wheel and scratch cards. Auto-clicking makes it a perfect companion during work breaks and relaxing moments.
Why similar: Idler 39.6%, Tabletop 31%, Relaxing 7.3%, Casual 5.9%, Funny 5.7%
- #9 Peaceful Farm
91% match2 user reviews67% of 2 reviews2026
Dev: Peaceful Game
Windows
This is a desktop game. You can farm, take care of animals, or go fishing!The farm will dynamically switch between day and night based on your time. In the night,something will changed.
Why similar: Idler 30.5%, Tabletop 24.4%, Incremental 17.9%, Simulation 7.3%, Relaxing 5.1%
- #10 Beer Clicker
91% match1 user reviews0% of 1 reviews2026
Dev: LZQI STUDIOSPub: Lazzqi
Windows
Beer Clicker is a casual idle clicker game where you brew beer, earn bottles, and expand your brewery. Click to produce, unlock upgrades, automate systems, and enjoy satisfying progression at your own pace.
Why similar: God Game 33.2% ★, Idler 29.6%, Incremental 27.8%, Simulation 8.3%, Indie 0.7%
- #11 Cascadium
89% matchMostly Positive76% of 17 reviews2026
Dev: ABoxWithinABox
Windows
A simple idle game where you drop balls plinko-style to make money. Big number make head go brrrr.
Why similar: Idler 36.4%, Incremental 34.6%, Simulation 11.3%, Relaxing 8.5%, Casual 7.5%
- #12 Kill The Skeletons
90% matchMostly Positive73% of 11 reviews2025
Dev: Callibel Studio
Windows
Kill the Skeletons is a unique real-time 3D clicker game where you can fully observe the battlefield as chaos unfolds. Watch thousands of creatures and hundreds of weapons in action while strategically clicking to defeat the skeleton horde.
Why similar: Idler 32.1%, Incremental 30.7%, God Game 27.6% ★, Casual 7.2%, Indie 1.9%
- #13 Zen Men
89% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: The Dancing Dots
Windows
Watch a tiny island society evolve as Zen Men meditate, argue, form policies, chase status, and search for the one true creation myth in a strange, living simulation of belief, jealousy, aging, and history.
Why similar: God Game 45.8% ★, Idler 25%, Simulation 13.3%, Casual 8.4%, Relaxing 4.3%
- #14 Penguin Capitalism Simulator
88% match4 user reviews100% of 4 reviews2026
Dev: TheGameIsFixed
Windows
Games are too stressful ... so I made one that literally plays itself
Why similar: God Game 33.5% ★, Idler 25.6%, Incremental 22.3%, Simulation 5.1%, Funny 3.8%
- #15 When Civilians Dig Holes
87% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Nina Demirjian
Windows · Mac
An incremental game about digging a hole to the other side of the world.
Why similar: Idler 39.7%, Incremental 28.4%, Simulation 12.1%, Casual 7.4%, Funny 4.6%
- #16 Mushies!
86% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Maxwell Prehoda
Windows · Mac · Linux
Create a thriving mushroom village in this cozy incremental adventure. Gather spores, recruit companions, automate your settlement, and unlock powerful upgrades as your fungal home flourishes. How far will you take your shrooms?
Why similar: Idler 30.4%, Incremental 26.5%, Simulation 13.2%, Casual 8.2%, Cute 6.3%
- #17 PolyPine
86% matchVery Positive96% of 399 reviews2025
Dev: Cloudberry PinePub: IndieArk
Windows
A forest simulator where you grow trees and create habitats for animals, plants and insects. Click on animals to make them poop, hunt, dig, cut and twerk! Start with a few basic seeds and attempt to grow a thriving ecosystem.
Why similar: God Game 31.3% ★, Idler 24.3%, Incremental 23.6%, Simulation 7.6%, Relaxing 6%
- #18 许愿岛 Hope Isle
85% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Fireseeds
Windows
This is a "blessing" game designed to bring you good luck, combining idle mechanics, desktop pets, farming, fishing, and homebuilding. On this island born from your wishes, each adorable spirit will accompany you every day, offering sincere prayers for your heart's desires!
Why similar: God Game 46.8% ★, Idler 32.6%, Cute 8.2%, Relaxing 7.8%, Casual 4.1%
- #19 Desktopet
84% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: EnCoreLab
Windows
【More than just a game—it's your desktop "digital hand warmer"】 Too busy working? Is your screen feeling too cold? Shift your gaze to the bottom of your screen— right there on that tiny taskbar, a cozy little felt farm is quietly thriving.
Why similar: Idler 25.6%, Tabletop 25.2%, Incremental 17.1%, Simulation 8.9%, Casual 8.4%
- #20 Lu[Idle]
83% matchMixed64% of 36 reviews2025
Dev: Joshua Sherrard
Windows · Linux
Lu[Idle] is an Incremental game with Idle and Clicker elements as well as pixel art visuals and music.
Why similar: Idler 39.7%, Incremental 34%, Simulation 12.4%, Casual 6%, Pixel Graphics 5.3%
- #21 Quail Game
82% matchPositive100% of 12 reviews2025
Dev: QuailDev
Windows
An idle desktop game about growing and collecting quails. Hatch them, grow them, collect their eggs and repeat!
Why similar: God Game 44.3% ★, Incremental 20.5%, Idler 19.3%, Casual 7.2%, Cute 4.9%
- #22 The Duck Pond
82% matchVery Positive96% of 81 reviews2024
Dev: Quack People
Windows · Mac · Linux
The Duck Pond is a condensed and relaxing idle game, focused on creating a short handcrafted experience with an ending. Throw food to attract different types of duck, read about them in the duckopedia, and maybe you'll discover the epic giga duck!
Why similar: Idler 40%, Incremental 28.8%, Casual 7.7%, Simulation 7.7%, Cute 6.3%
- #23 NGU IDLE
84% matchOverwhelmingly Positive96% of 12,929 reviews2019
Dev: 4G
Windows
Median: 18.8 hrsMean: 640.5 hrs≥1hr: 82%
NGU Idle is a Free To Play Idle game that's full of weird humor, tons of upgrades and hundreds of hours of content! Try out NGU Idle today and experience the joy of Numbers Going Up!
Why similar: Idler 44%, Incremental 37.7%, Funny 6.8%, Simulation 6.4%, Casual 2.4%
- #24 Feed the Greed
81% matchMostly Positive76% of 70 reviews2025
Dev: Elifam
Windows
A short active incremental game. Send skeleton villagers with sacrificial offerings to a growing space rift. Feed the rift in exchange for essence, unlock different offerings and their upgrades - all for the sake of more essence.
Why similar: Idler 32.1%, Incremental 25.6%, God Game 10.6% ★, Simulation 6.9%, Relaxing 6.8%
- #25 Pactum
80% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: NoMiStudio
Windows
Summon angels and demons, fuse them and watch them evolve on a floating island. A calm, relaxing incremental to unwind: upgrade without limits, watch your creatures grow, and enjoy the journey at your own pace.
Why similar: God Game 32.1% ★, Idler 25.4%, Incremental 19.6%, Simulation 5.5%, Cute 4.4%
- #26 That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Tyrant God
78% matchMixed68% of 40 reviews2026
Dev: Lil Sekhmet Games
Windows · Mac · Linux
Slay waves of monsters with your mouse, collect coins, buy permanent upgrades, and grow stronger round after round in a compact incremental action game.
Why similar: Incremental 27%, Idler 26.2%, God Game 20.1% ★, Relaxing 8.7%, Casual 7%
- #27 Forest Fellers
81% match9 user reviews78% of 9 reviews2024
Dev: TheBigBard
Windows
Forest Fellers! A game about Gnomes, Trees, and chopping them. Generate wood as you hire your very own Forest Fellers (Gnomes) to fell forests YOU make. Your Gnomes will grow and level up the more they chop allowing you to get more and more efficient trees for them to take down.
Why similar: Idler 37.4%, Incremental 35.2%, Cute 8.7%, Relaxing 8%, Casual 6.7%
- #28 Click and Spell
79% matchNo user reviews
Dev: rami
Windows
A tiny clicker game that sits on the corner of your screen. Kill monsters, earn gold and buy new spells to level up (even when you're idle). Unlock cosmetics to customize your character. Watch the numbers increase non-stop and become a powerful witch!
Why similar: Idler 34.5%, Incremental 31.8%, Relaxing 7.8%, Casual 7.5%, Simulation 6.9%
- #29 Botanic Bits
79% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2025
Dev: Cakter
Windows
Cut, harvest, and unlock robots to achieve your long-awaited retirement in this incremental game WITHOUT PRESTIGE!!!
Why similar: Idler 37.1%, Incremental 27.7%, Cute 9.7%, Relaxing 9%, Casual 6.4%
- #30 [MULTIPLIERS]
77% match3 user reviews67% of 3 reviews2026
Dev: My Little Games
Windows
An exponential idle clicker game with 2,000+ upgrades and infinite fun. Multipliers, prestige, perks and many more features!
Why similar: Idler 33%, God Game 25.6% ★, Incremental 25.1%, Simulation 8.1%, Relaxing 3.9%
- #31 Apple Tree
78% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Stealfire
Windows · Linux
In Apple Tree, an idle game, plant seeds and wait for fruits to grow. Be patient and watch the miracle unfold. With a serene atmosphere and simple mechanics, it offers a relaxing experience. Whether taking a break or seeking a meditative activity, Apple Tree provides a tranquil escape.
Why similar: God Game 35.8% ★, Idler 24.7%, Incremental 20.7%, Cute 5.8%, Funny 5.5%
- #32 Spincremental
77% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: SincX GG
Windows
Pull the lever, watch the reels, collect the symbols. Buy slot machines, unlock cursors, magnets, and cards that play for you, then upgrade everything through a deep skill tree. A cozy pixel-art incremental about turning one wooden slot into an automated jackpot empire.
Why similar: Idler 33.2%, Incremental 33.1%, Simulation 9.1%, Cute 7.8%, Casual 7.5%
- #33 Idle Pixel Maids
76% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: WhyDuck Studio
Windows
An idle maid café where the maids actually talk back. Watch them work while gold rolls in, then message them on MoChat and get real replies from a small AI model running on your own PC. No internet, no subscription. Decorate the café, recruit all 12 maids, and grow closer every day.
Why similar: Idler 40.3%, Incremental 28.9%, Simulation 9%, Relaxing 5.8%, Cute 5.3%
- #34 The Endless Village
75% matchMixed60% of 15 reviews2026
Dev: R.J. Brontsema
Windows
Automate your growth, uncover a gorgeous city, and chase the ultimate metric: Liveliness. This cozy idle clicker lets you unlock passive income boosts and powerful minigames to rapidly scale your empire. Attract every unique citizen and claim your spot on the global leaderboard!
Why similar: Idler 41.8%, Incremental 29.8%, Simulation 14.2%, Cute 5.7%, Relaxing 5.3%
- #35 Click And Adventure
74% match2 user reviews50% of 2 reviews2025
Dev: day_dream
Windows
"Click and Adventure" is a relaxing, compact click-based idle game. Explore by clicking, consume health points to defeat various monsters, obtain treasure chests, unlock the encyclopedia, increase passive income, upgrade skills, unlock new maps, and defeat new monsters.
Why similar: Idler 38.4%, Incremental 28.5%, Simulation 12.5%, Casual 12.2%, Relaxing 7.7%
- #36 你的小鸡鸡
73% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: hUoFaNPub: weewee
Windows
"Your Little Chick" is a casual desktop game that accompanies you. Your little Chick will move around the screen following your mouse.
Why similar: Idler 35.9%, Incremental 32.4%, Simulation 18.7%, Casual 12%, Singleplayer 1%
- #37 ClickRush
72% match9 user reviews67% of 9 reviews2026
Dev: Broussen GamesPub: Broussen
Windows
ClickRush: Produce infinite clicks! Deploy drones and AI matrices to automate your empire. Take down Real-Time World Bosses with the community, level up your Battle Pass, and unlock celestial bonuses. Dominate the global leaderboard. Get your mouse ready!
Why similar: God Game 31.5% ★, Idler 26.9%, Incremental 23.3%, Simulation 11.6%, Relaxing 2.2%
- #38 Crypto Clicker
76% matchMixed64% of 71 reviews2022
Dev: Hakugei LLC
Windows
Exactly what it sounds like, a clicker game based around crypto.
Why similar: Idler 41.1%, Incremental 39.1%, Relaxing 9.6%, Casual 9.5%, Singleplayer 0.8%
- #39 Y2K Coin Pusher
70% matchMostly Positive75% of 28 reviews2026
Dev: Ink Ribbon Studios
Windows
Enjoy this 2000's inspired coin pusher game with 13 unlockable levels, each corresponding to their own song and vibe, all in delicious PS2 inspired graphics.
Why similar: Idler 36.3%, Incremental 27.9%, Simulation 17%, Casual 11%, Relaxing 7.1%
- #40 Eggcellent Life
73% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2025
Dev: GGOLDBIGPub: IFIDEV
Windows
A Placement And Development Game That Only Requires Mouse Operation And Is Played At The Bottom Of The Screen. It Has A Soft Color Screen And Is Suitable For Easy Play While Working, Harvesting Resources And Raising Chickens.
Why similar: God Game 30.8% ★, Idler 22.3%, Incremental 19.6%, Relaxing 6.8%, Cute 6.2%
- #41 Idle Mall Simulator
71% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: PEGAX Studios
Windows
Build and expand your own shopping mall in this fun idle simulation game. Open new stores, increase your profits, keep customers happy, and turn your mall into a thriving business empire!
Why similar: Idler 46.9%, Incremental 30%, Simulation 17.3%, Casual 3.6%, Indie 1.2%
- #42 KIDNEY STONE Clicker
74% match5 user reviews60% of 5 reviews2023
Dev: Takumi Abe
Windows
KIDNEY STONE Clicker is a Simple Clicker idle game but odd theme. Kidney stones by clicking rapidly on the screen to break them down into smaller pieces. Collect stone for power-ups and make your body healthy.
Why similar: Idler 41.4%, Incremental 39.5%, Casual 9.7%, Relaxing 8.6%, Singleplayer 0.8%
- #43 Golden Clicker
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Klayerama
Windows
A stormy night. A boy alone. A golden button that creates universes… and distorts reality. Lights flicker. Shadows shift. The Watcher sees everything. Each click brings you closer to perfection... or something you can’t undo.
Why similar: God Game 41.7% ★, Idler 20.1%, Incremental 17.5%, Simulation 12.1%, Casual 7.6%
- #44 Garden Eternal
68% matchMixed58% of 12 reviews2026
Dev: Family Milk
Windows
The cozy garden that keeps on growing. Garden Eternal is an idle clicker where you tap a glowing Heart, raise bees & buildings, and draft cards through every season. A calm place, mostly. But the garden keeps its own hours, and not everything that blooms after dark is a flower.
Why similar: Idler 34.6%, Incremental 30.6%, Simulation 11%, Casual 10.2%, Cute 7.2%
- #45 西西弗斯放置(Sisyphus Idle)
67% matchPositive100% of 29 reviews2026
Dev: Lazymangamestudio
Windows
This is a desktop incremental idle game about Sisyphus pushing a boulder. Sisyphus will embark on his fateful, never-ending journey of pushing the stone right on your desktop. Of course, you can also help him choose strategies to grow stronger and reach the peak of Olympus again, faster than before.
Why similar: Idler 35.9%, Incremental 31.8%, Tabletop 16.7%, Casual 10.2%, Pixel Graphics 4.9%
- #46 [RANDOM]
69% match2 user reviews0% of 2 reviews2026
Dev: My Little Games
Windows
An idle clicker game with random values and 2,000+ upgrades. Random upgrades, prestige, perks and many more features!
Why similar: Idler 30.3%, God Game 28.5% ★, Incremental 22.6%, Simulation 9.6%, Relaxing 4.2%
- #47 SquareLife
68% match2 user reviews100% of 2 reviews2026
Dev: Panimu
Windows
Build creatures from a handful of traits and set them loose. Watch them feed, breed, fight, mutate and evolve; simple circles becoming many-sided beasts over generations. Play a free sandbox or escalating campaign goals. Every run is a different living world.
Why similar: God Game 36.5% ★, Idler 33.6%, Simulation 16.9%, Casual 10.8%, Indie 1.2%
- #48 Idle Universe Creator
71% matchNo user reviews2025
Dev: Timothy Bexon
Windows
Compete against others to create a universe in the shortest time in a unique take on the idle game genre. In Idle Universe Creator, your task is to craft atoms to fill an empty universe. Will you recreate our universe or craft brand new ones? What matters is how fast you can reach the target mass.
Why similar: Idler 40.6%, Incremental 36.1%, Casual 11.9%, Relaxing 10.3%, Singleplayer 1.1%
- #49 The Offering
69% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Duskmothgames
Windows
Possess pilgrims and spend their offerings in this incremental shrine defence. Grow the crowd, light the candles, stack the cards. Then hold the plaza when the sun goes down and something walks in from the ruins.
Why similar: God Game 35.6% ★, Idler 28.3%, Incremental 25.9%, Casual 3.7%, Simulation 3.1%
- #50 Happy Cookies
70% match2 user reviews50% of 2 reviews2025
Dev: HUANG YIMING
Windows
Happy Cookies is a click-based simulation business game that can be fully experienced with just the left and right mouse buttons. Players need to decorate the cookies with chips by clicking on the surface of the cookies to make money.
Why similar: Incremental 35.7%, Idler 30%, Simulation 9.7%, Casual 8.9%, Relaxing 5.3%
- #51 Bubble POP IT ASMR
73% matchPositive100% of 15 reviews2021
Dev: Boogygames Studios
Windows
Welcome to Bubble Pop It ASMR, the ultimate sensory experience that combines the satisfying pop of bubbles with the calming effects of ASMR. Get ready to immerse yourself in a world of tactile delight and relaxation as you engage with this unique virtual bubble-popping simulator.
Why similar: Idler 27.5%, Incremental 24.3%, Tabletop 21%, Relaxing 8%, Simulation 7.5%
- #52 Street Light Simulator 2026
69% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Sixgill Studios
Windows
A relaxing ambient simulation where a street lamp reflects you real-world system time. Creating a calm background scene for working, studying, or unwinding.
Why similar: God Game 45.7% ★, Idler 23.6%, Simulation 14.7%, Casual 10.4%, Atmospheric 4.4%
- #53 Downsizing.exe
67% match8 user reviews88% of 8 reviews2026
Dev: RotHeartGamesPub: Midnight Rental Games
Windows
Maximize profit. Minimize humanity. In Downsizing.exe, you are a cog in the dark corporate machine. Approve terminations, automate the grind, and slash costs. How much will you sacrifice for the firm?
Why similar: God Game 37.3% ★, Idler 27.9%, Incremental 25.8%, Casual 4.2%, Simulation 3.9%
- #54 Rogue AI: Idle Domination
66% matchPositive98% of 40 reviews2026
Dev: Nerdook ProductionsPub: Surefire.Games
Windows
A Rogue A.I. simulator that sits at the bottom of your screen. Take over the world while taking care of other tasks!
Why similar: God Game 32.8% ★, Idler 27.7%, Incremental 19.9%, Simulation 7.5%, Cute 4.1%
- #55 GLONK
66% matchVery Positive90% of 349 reviews2025
Dev: Mistical Studios
Windows
Median: 6.2 hrsMean: 7.6 hrs≥1hr: 82%
A short incremental game about feeding Glonk! Make Glonk bigger, get more money, and explore the skill tree to upgrade your abilities, and get more Glonks!
Why similar: Idler 33.8%, Incremental 30.9%, Simulation 7.8%, Cute 7.1%, Casual 6.1%
- #56 Fungus Co.
67% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Imoyokan
Windows
Grow and spread mycelium from spores across a dark substrate in this relaxing incremental.
Why similar: Idler 34%, Incremental 24.8%, God Game 16.4% ★, Simulation 7.4%, Relaxing 7.4%
- #57 Simple Increment
70% matchMostly Positive79% of 14 reviews2023
Dev: PELMENI GAMES
Windows
Simple but addictive idle clicker game for those who just wants to relax and have some fun.
Why similar: God Game 37% ★, Idler 26%, Incremental 21.9%, Simulation 7.5%, Relaxing 4.8%
- #58 Desk Rage
66% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2026
Dev: Pressure Valve StudioPub: IdleCraft Interactive
Windows
A carefully designed desktop pet game. When you open the game, your "little brother" desktop pet pops up and stays on your desktop to keep you company. Unlike other pet games—when you're in a bad mood, you can beat him up, or even summon a monster to eat him.
Why similar: Idler 33.2%, Incremental 24.5%, Tabletop 10.7%, Relaxing 8.9%, Cute 8.4%
- #59 Pasture Palette
66% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Eternal Delta Games
Windows
Pasture Palette is a living art piece where your field becomes the canvas. Shape colors by painting objects, growing flowers, and raising sheep in vibrant hues, as loyal dogs help turn wool into goods and discover the palette hidden in your pasture.
Why similar: Idler 31.6%, Incremental 29.4%, Relaxing 9.2%, Cute 8.1%, Simulation 6.6%