- #1 Puddle Pals
97% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Frog Spawn Studio
Windows
A cozy-chaotic co-op physics adventure where you play as frogs exploring a giant Aussie backyard. Jump, grapple, swing, stack, and cause playful chaos with toys, wildlife, and backyard contraptions in a sandbox full of silly discoveries.
Why similar: Online Co-Op 24.7%, Sandbox 18.4%, Physics 16.4%, Nature 15.7%, Cute 6.6%
- #2 DAM IT
96% matchNo user reviews
Dev: WYLDERZONE
Windows
DAM IT! is an online co-op physics and destruction game. You and up to 8 friends are mischievous beavers with a simple mission: Destroy the evil corporation that has invaded your forest! Harvest wood, build dams and redirect rivers to create raging floods and wreck the corporations property!
Why similar: Online Co-Op 35.8%, Physics 21.6%, Nature 13.4%, Sandbox 11.8%, Casual 8.4%
- #3 Fire Pit: Throw Things Into The Fire
96% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Manic Hyena
Windows
The world doesn't deserve to exist. Nothing matters anyway. Destroy and burn things alone. Or get your nihilistic friends and throw things into the fire together.
Why similar: Sandbox 29.9%, Physics 22.8%, Online Co-Op 12.4%, First-Person 8.3%, Relaxing 6.9%
- #4 YUME ROOF
95% match4 user reviews100% of 4 reviews2026
Dev: Rivi
Windows
In between the busyness of everyday life, a rooftop where nothing happens. YUME ROOF is a cozy sandbox game set on a Japanese rooftop, with no enemies or time limits. Customize the space from morning to night, and enjoy simply being there at your own pace.
Why similar: Voxel 35.8% ★, Sandbox 21.1%, Cute 9.7%, Relaxing 8.1%, First-Person 5.8%
- #5 Park Ranger Simulator
94% matchMostly Negative21% of 85 reviews2026
Dev: Polygon ArtPub: Aerosoft GmbH
Windows
Manage your own park facility in a huge open world in Park Ranger Simulator. Take on all the tasks that need to be completed as a park ranger - alone or together in cross-platform multiplayer! You have a variety of vehicles and equipment at your disposal to complete the challenges ahead!
Why similar: Online Co-Op 28%, Nature 23.9%, Sandbox 19.9%, First-Person 6.2%, Simulation 5.9%
- #6 Rise Of Transport
94% match9 user reviews56% of 9 reviews2025
Dev: Softdimension Games
Windows
Enjoy the trill of vehicle simulation in this open-world transport RPG game.
Why similar: Online Co-Op 25.2%, Sandbox 21.1%, Physics 19.6%, Nature 13.2%, First-Person 6.4%
- #7 Fox Stories
92% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Wanderstar
Windows
Fox Stories is a co-op sandbox game where you get to be a fox with your friends, wreaking havoc in an open to exploration forest.
Why similar: Online Co-Op 27.9%, Sandbox 20.4%, Physics 18.3%, Nature 17.6%, Cute 7.8%
- #8 One Million Worlds
93% match1 user reviews0% of 1 reviews2019
Dev: Richard Tingle
Windows
One Million Worlds is a block world, but unlike other block worlds it's not focused on buildings and architecture but on machines and movement. One Million Worlds is a blockworld with physics which means you can create things that not only look cool but are cool, because they work.
Why similar: Voxel 41% ★, Sandbox 26.7%, Physics 11.6%, Indie 7.1%, 3D 4.8%
- #9 Landscaper Simulator
91% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Midnight Game Studios
Windows
Lawns are wild. Parks are buried in weeds. Streets are littered. The world needs a hero, and that’s where you come in. As the Landscaper, it’s your job to turn disorder into beauty. With your weed whacker, pressure washer, and trash vacuum, you’ll trim, scrub, and restore every space to perfection.
Why similar: Nature 19%, Sandbox 16.3%, Relaxing 10.9%, First-Person 10.2%, Casual 9.6%
- #10 Voxel Playground
91% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Cydream
Windows
Voxel Playground is a physics-driven voxel sandbox VR game built for VR. In this fully destructible voxel physics world, you can build, craft and shoot against enemies with limitless possibilities.
Why similar: Voxel 39.5% ★, Sandbox 30.6%, Physics 22.9%, Simulation 6.5%, Singleplayer 0.5%
- #11 BlockWorld
90% matchNo user reviews
Dev: 2.0 Studios
Windows
BlockWorld is a Multiplayer Voxel sandbox full of toys and creatures! Powered by the Hazzah Engine, you can go beyond blocks and really build amazing things. Come on in and build worlds with your friends!
Why similar: Voxel 34.1% ★, Online Co-Op 21%, Sandbox 20.5%, Physics 10%, First-Person 7.9%
- #12 Pickup Trash Simulator Remastered
89% matchMixed67% of 12 reviews2024
Dev: Newboon
Windows
Pickup Trash Simulator Is A Game Where You Use Physics To Your Advantage In A Park And Throw Trash Into Your Two Dumpsters! Whether Your Old Or Young Or Super Environment Friendly This Game Is For You.
Why similar: Sandbox 31.2%, Physics 15.8%, Casual 13.9%, Simulation 11.3%, First-Person 10.7%
- #13 What is snowman made of?
89% matchVery Positive88% of 82 reviews2023
Dev: Daniel JenikovskýPub: Ateliér Duchů
Windows
An atmospheric mini game that let's you explore a snowcapped yard in which you build your very own snowman.
Why similar: Sandbox 40.5%, Physics 17.2%, First-Person 13.4%, Casual 10.9%, 3D 10.9%
- #14 Rasvyat Nuclear Power Station
88% matchMostly Positive78% of 141 reviews2024
Dev: Thxtnt
Windows
A co-op RBMK reactor simulator, with a detailed control room, realistic physics and authentic sound design
Why similar: Sandbox 30.8%, Online Co-Op 21.6%, Casual 13.2%, Simulation 10.8%, First-Person 10.4%
- #15 Lade's Sandbox
87% match1 user reviews100% of 1 reviews2024
Dev: 诺格拉德
Windows
A voxel-based sandbox game
Why similar: Voxel 42.2% ★, Sandbox 18.4%, Physics 13.4%, Relaxing 9.2%, Casual 7.3%
- #16 Leaf it in yourself
86% matchNo user reviews
Dev: RequiemGamesStudios
Windows
Leaf it in yourself - is a little Cozy game about collecting shells on a small desert island. Shells — lots of them, beautiful and unique. Scattered across the warm sand, waiting to be found. Discover shells and build your own little collection while enjoying a relaxing atmosphere by the sea.
Why similar: Nature 27.1%, Relaxing 14%, Cute 12.6%, Physics 9.9%, First-Person 9.7%
- #17 Buildia
85% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Ali Turgut
Windows · Linux
Unleash your imagination in Buildia! Build massive structures in this creative voxel-based world using elemental blocks like Lava, Ice, and Forest. With precision controls and a serene atmosphere, Buildia invites you to shape your own world block by block.
Why similar: Voxel 31.9% ★, Sandbox 30.5%, Casual 9.1%, 3D 8.3%, Simulation 7.1%
- #18 Staxel
86% matchMostly Positive79% of 4,816 reviews2019
Dev: PlukitPub: Balor Games
Windows · Mac · Linux
Median: 3.3 hrsMean: 10.6 hrs≥1hr: 82%
Grow your farm, meet the villagers, and join your friends online in building your world.
Why similar: Voxel 25.2% ★, Online Co-Op 19%, Nature 17.5%, Sandbox 17.3%, Cute 7.6%
- #19 Clean Up Earth
84% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Magic Pockets
Windows
A relaxing co-op restoration game where you vacuum waste, rebuild ecosystems, and watch nature return in real time. Play solo, with friends, or in online multiplayer sessions with up to 25 players. Community gameplay can help support real environmental initiatives with no extra spending required.
Why similar: Online Co-Op 31.1%, Nature 21.8%, First-Person 8.6%, Casual 7.3%, Simulation 6.1%
- #20 Ooble Gardens
83% match4 user reviews25% of 4 reviews2025
Dev: Nova Games
Windows
Step into a cozy world and care for playful Oobles in a giant garden pot! Merge, grow and fish offerings to create an endless variety of cozy furniture to decorate the garden with to shape your dream fairy garden!
Why similar: Sandbox 34.7%, Nature 15.4%, Cute 12.1%, Relaxing 10.6%, 3D 9.2%
- #21 Banana Slug Beach
84% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Niad
Windows
Banana Slug Beach is an open world voxel game where everything can be sculpted, even players. Your world evolves over time, reacting to player & bot actions. Play alone, or with friends-- build a world together and try to prevent its collapse!
Why similar: Voxel 32% ★, Nature 22.3%, Physics 17.7%, Online Co-Op 15.4%, First-Person 7.5%
- #22 Bakery Cafe Simulator
82% matchMostly Positive71% of 351 reviews2025
Dev: Meerkatt Studio
Windows
Bake, build, and grow your dream bakery cafe! Create delicious pastries, design your space, and serve customers. Play solo or with friends in online co-op to expand your business and experience the excitement of running a bustling cafe!
Why similar: Online Co-Op 31.1%, Sandbox 22.4%, Physics 15.1%, First-Person 10%, Simulation 6.6%
- #23 Only DWARVES DIG Proper HOLES
82% matchPositive95% of 22 reviews2025
Dev: Antoine Verbeek
Windows
As a Dwarf, it is your duty to dig in the search of a legendary pickaxe. Collect gems, sell and upgrade. All in glorious virtual reality. Family-friendly fun.
Why similar: Voxel 32.6% ★, Sandbox 19.5%, Nature 17.6%, Physics 13.8%, First-Person 5.5%
- #24 Astralyte
81% match3 user reviews33% of 3 reviews2026
Dev: Minvwiz
Windows
Mine rocks, gather materials, and craft crystals in a calm, system-driven world. A relaxing single-player experience focused on mining, progression, and discovery.
Why similar: Sandbox 34.2%, Nature 17.2%, Casual 14.5%, First-Person 9.5%, 3D 8.5%
- #25 Purrrifiers: Cleaning Chaos
80% matchMixed67% of 115 reviews2025
Dev: Rubens GamesPub: FreeMind S.A.
Windows
A chaotic “Goofylike” co-op cleaning sim for up to 4 players. Purr cats, cast spells, clean messes, craft weird tools, and cause trouble in equal measure. Your mission? Make it shine or at least less disgusting.
Why similar: Online Co-Op 29.5%, Sandbox 21.2%, Physics 16.3%, First-Person 9%, Casual 5.6%
- #26 Theme Park Simulator
81% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Team Atiena
Windows
Build, manage, and grow your own theme park in this multiplayer simulator for 1–4 players. Buy rides, serve customers, manage cleanliness, and maximize profits with day and night cycles.
Why similar: Online Co-Op 37.6%, Sandbox 17.5%, Simulation 11.2%, First-Person 10%, Cute 8.5%
- #27 shutterbuds
78% matchMixed40% of 173 reviews2025
Dev: Drunkey Monkey GamesPub: Champlain College
Windows
Explore a National Park with up to 3 of your photojournalist friends. Take jobs from top magazine brands, then hit the trail in search of interesting landmarks and goofy creatures to photograph. Use your pay to buy useful items and cosmetics. You’ll be sure to make the front page in a flash!
Why similar: Online Co-Op 21.8%, Sandbox 20%, Nature 19.2%, Physics 12.8%, Cute 7.3%
- #28 Babbling Brook
77% matchPositive96% of 23 reviews2025
Dev: Some Random Designing
Windows
Sculpt sand to create winding streams through lush forests and rolling meadows. Babbling Brook is a cozy & relaxing indie game about messing around with water and sand. Also, there's a flock of rubber ducks trying to escape to the open sea...
Why similar: Nature 22.2%, Sandbox 20.2%, Physics 19.6%, Relaxing 9.7%, Cute 8%
- #29 Trash Panda
79% matchMixed68% of 40 reviews2023
Dev: Jason LeaverPub: JLeaver Presentations
Windows
A small, chill, low-fi raccoon simulator, where you play as a raccoon roaming neighbourhoods of Toronto making a mess. Knock over trash bins, find power-ups, challenge other raccoons, and get lost.
Why similar: Nature 20.9%, Physics 20.5%, Sandbox 20.5%, Relaxing 8.9%, Cute 7.3%
- #30 Unreal Sandbox
79% match4 user reviews50% of 4 reviews2021
Dev: Blockout22
Windows
Build and play with others with a physics based sandbox created in unreal engine 5
Why similar: Sandbox 33.4%, Online Co-Op 17.9%, Physics 16.8%, Casual 12.8%, First-Person 10.4%
- #31 A Game About Mowing Your Lawn
76% match5 user reviews40% of 5 reviews2025
Dev: Micester
Windows
A simplistic game about mowing your lawn. Harvest grass, sell clippings, upgrade your gear, and experience the beauty and detail.
Why similar: Sandbox 26%, Nature 22.2%, Physics 19.7%, First-Person 6.4%, Relaxing 6%
- #32 vissekom
78% matchPositive88% of 26 reviews2021
Dev: Sokpop Collective
Windows · Mac
Your own digital fish bowl aquarium! Place it somewhere on your screen while working or relaxing, and see your cute aquarium get more fun over time 🤩
Why similar: Sandbox 29.4%, Nature 15.9%, Casual 12.7%, Simulation 10.4%, Cute 8.2%
- #33 Zoo Life Simulator
74% matchMixed54% of 35 reviews2026
Dev: Hiraru
Windows · Linux
Build the zoo of your dreams! In Zoo Life Simulator, play solo or with friends as you care for animals, keep visitors happy, and expand your park in a relaxing and realistic simulation experience.
Why similar: Sandbox 25.8%, Nature 23%, Online Co-Op 18.2%, Casual 6.6%, Simulation 6.2%
- #34 Beaver Creek
75% matchNo user reviews
Dev: We Shall Be Monsters
Windows
A casual, water-physics adventure about a beaver finding a new home. Build dams and gnaw down trees to divert water and re-shape the environment, leaving behind thriving ecosystems. Befriend a variety of animals as they help you on your journey, and survive the stigma of centuries-old trappers.
Why similar: Physics 27.1%, Nature 25.6%, Cute 11.9%, Relaxing 11.2%, Casual 7.3%
- #35 Clod & Desire
76% matchNo user reviews2025
Dev: Clio Universe Studio
Windows
A landscape park simulator. Dirt. Plants. And way too much emotion.
Why similar: Sandbox 32.5%, Nature 15%, Casual 13.3%, Simulation 11.3%, 3D 8.8%
- #36 Giant Bear Rampage! ☢️🐻
77% matchPositive98% of 40 reviews2019
Dev: GameDevMikeyPub: Red Dragon Interactive
Windows
First person Giant Mutant Bear Simulator! Destroy populated towns with physics based destruction and Super Powers! Survive waves of enemies in a low poly destructible world. Play as a Polar Bear, Grizzly and more! Collect mutation points to spend on unlocking new super powers! ᕦʕ •ᴥ•ʔᕤ
Why similar: Nature 20.2%, Physics 19.1%, Sandbox 17.5%, First-Person 9.3%, Cute 7.8%
- #37 Discovery
74% matchNo user reviews
Dev: noowanda
Windows · Mac
Unleash your creativity and create impressive worlds alone or together with your friends. Share your creations with the community or download and rate worlds from other players. Swag GFX and support for VR make your worlds looking breathtaking.
Why similar: Voxel 43.1% ★, Online Co-Op 27.9%, Sandbox 19.6%, First-Person 4.1%, 3D 3.3%
- #38 Primordial Soup
75% matchNo user reviews2024
Dev: Ethan SummersPub: Almost Human Media
Windows
Primordial Soup is a VR experience that's out of this world. A metaphorical and playful encounter with the formation of life, users can create, play with and follow simple creatures that evolve inside this colorful soup.
Why similar: Sandbox 33.1%, Physics 16.9%, Casual 14.1%, First-Person 11.2%, Simulation 7.7%
- #39 P.A.C.K. :: Post Apocalyptic Cleaning Kit
71% matchPositive89% of 28 reviews2025
Dev: Nitrous Butterfly
Windows
Step into the wheels of a robot in this sci-fi cleaning adventure set after the apocalypse. Wash, vacuum, recycle and repair abandoned structures while learning about the ultimate fate of mankind, alone or with friends.
Why similar: Online Co-Op 37.8%, Physics 21.3%, Relaxing 12.4%, First-Person 11%, Simulation 7.1%
- #40 Shroomchitect
73% matchPositive91% of 11 reviews2023
Dev: PUNKCAKE Delicieux
Windows · Mac · Linux
Help shroomies transform a big mushroom into a cozy little home! Care for them, help them garden and build things, relax, and take nice pictures!
Why similar: Voxel 27.2% ★, Nature 20.3%, Sandbox 19.2%, Relaxing 8%, Cute 7.1%
- #41 Finnish Forest
72% matchNo user reviews
Dev: APA Studios
Windows
Finnish Forest is a calm and relaxing game where you collect berries, mushrooms, and more. Enjoy the Finnish nature and do whatever you want.
Why similar: Nature 41.5%, Sandbox 27.4%, Casual 8.6%, Immersive Sim 7%, 3D 6.6%
- #42 Voxelotl Garden
72% matchMostly Positive75% of 12 reviews2024
Dev: ThunderAwesomePub: Battlerock Studios
Windows · Mac
Raise, train, and breed Voxelotl to create the most unique Voxelotl patterns and shapes. Feed them treats to keep them happy and level up their skills in training exercises. Participate in races to test your Voxelotl’s skills. Enjoy spending time with your cute Voxelotl pets!
Why similar: Voxel 39% ★, Nature 16.7%, Cute 10.4%, Casual 6.9%, 3D 6.7%
- #43 You Can't Scare Me
71% matchNo user reviews
Dev: LunaBeat
Windows
Scare or be scared in You Can't Scare Me - the VR haunted house where you can frighten your friends! Set scary traps or transform into terrible monsters to try and scare the living daylights out of your friends. If they scream, you win!
Why similar: Sandbox 40.4%, Online Co-Op 27.7%, 3D 10.9%, Simulation 10.2%, Stylized 6.5%
- #44 AutoCube
73% match3 user reviews100% of 3 reviews2021
Dev: Replayable Games
Windows
Build anything you can imagine in an infinite world with mountains, rivers and forests. Use tools like copy & paste, undo, redo and other building tools to shape the world from your imagination.
Why similar: Voxel 21.3% ★, Nature 18.2%, Online Co-Op 17.8%, Sandbox 13.5%, Relaxing 7.3%
- #45 DrainSim
68% matchVery Positive92% of 1,022 reviews2026
Dev: CodePeas
Windows
Median: 5.9 hrsMean: 6.3 hrs≥1hr: 76%
Dive into DrainSim and seize control of the floods! Clear the city's submerged streets, with a huge range of different tools from rakes to submersible pumps. Embrace the satisfaction of restoring the water flow. Become the city's hero, one drain at a time.
Why similar: Sandbox 21.7%, Nature 17.5%, Physics 15.9%, Relaxing 9.3%, First-Person 9.1%
- #46 Physics Playground
73% matchMostly Positive79% of 14 reviews2022
Dev: Partygamer3000
Windows
Physics Playground is a little indie game in which you can experiment with different cubes, tools, buttons and of course physics.
Why similar: Sandbox 31.4%, Physics 28.3%, Relaxing 11.3%, Casual 8.4%, Simulation 6.6%
- #47 Pocket Garden
70% matchMixed67% of 15 reviews2025
Dev: Just Pocket Games
Windows
Pocket Garden is a super cute little indie game where you can build the coziest gardens and have the best time ever! No worries about resources, fighting, or health. Just sit back, relax, and enjoy!
Why similar: Sandbox 26.8%, Physics 15.1%, Nature 12.3%, Relaxing 10%, Cute 9.5%
- #48 Sandcastle
70% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Bubblebird Studio
Windows · Mac · Linux
On a sun-warmed tropical shore, quietly craft a mighty sandcastle. Carve moats, raise towers and walls, then embellish with driftwood, pebbles, shells and seaweed. Gentle tides, soft surf and a calming color palette turn every build into a peaceful, relaxing moment.
Why similar: Sandbox 33.6%, Physics 18%, Relaxing 10.3%, Casual 10.3%, Simulation 8.8%
- #49 Domino!
71% matchNo user reviews2025
Dev: ResonantCore Games
Windows
Domino! Is a casual domino simulator where you can freely build domino blocks and trackball blocks.
Why similar: Sandbox 29.6%, Casual 11.7%, Simulation 9.6%, Cute 8.6%, 3D 7.6%
- #50 Tiny Terrariums
70% match4 user reviews100% of 4 reviews2024
Dev: Argent Realms
Windows
Build terrariums for forest gnomes to live in, and play around in your creations as any one of the gnomes.
Why similar: Sandbox 27.7%, Nature 22.4%, Relaxing 10.3%, Physics 8.7%, Casual 7.2%
- #51 Tiny Planet
69% matchNo user reviews
Dev: NNStudioz
Windows · Linux
Create your very own tiny planet and place it among the stars in the vast expanse of the universe !
Why similar: Voxel 25.1% ★, Sandbox 24.1%, Nature 16.1%, Relaxing 9.1%, Casual 6.6%
- #52 Island Restoration
69% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Elite Interactive
Windows
A restoration sim where you restore a destroyed world, one island at a time. Clean pollution, rescue wildlife, upgrade your equipment and turn infinite random islands into paradises.
Why similar: Sandbox 22.4%, Nature 22.3%, Relaxing 10.9%, Cute 7.5%, Casual 7.2%
- #53 Soaked
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: Evan Patterson
Windows
Soaked is a multiplayer physics sandbox where you fling frisbees, chuck water balloons, and push players to their doom. Join the playtest today!
Why similar: Online Co-Op 28.2%, Sandbox 25.4%, Physics 22.7%, Cute 8.3%, 3D 6.3%
- #54 Plentiful
68% matchNo user reviews
Dev: GabberGamesPub: Learnia Inc
Windows
Plentiful is a Human Terrarium — Sculpt the land, redirect rivers, and grow food as you nurture your tribe. Guide your people through a perilous Stone Age and protect them from nature’s whims.
Why similar: Voxel 25.7% ★, Sandbox 25%, Nature 24.2%, 3D 5.5%, Simulation 4.5%
- #55 Chaos Playground
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: OneDudeDev
Windows
A physics-driven ragdoll sandbox. Build weird stuff, run crazy experiments, and watch the chaos unfold — no limits, just pure physics.
Why similar: Sandbox 39.2%, Physics 29.6%, Simulation 10.6%, Casual 8.5%, 3D 7.8%
- #56 Wash It
67% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: Andrei Ivashentsev
Windows
Wash It is a relaxing and satisfying cleaning game where you blast away dirt, grime, and chaos. Watch the world shine again as you unwind and get lost in pure cleaning zen.
Why similar: Sandbox 34.1%, Casual 14.3%, Cute 11.9%, Simulation 11.7%, First-Person 9.5%
- #57 Reforj
67% matchNo user reviews
Dev: 4J Studios
Windows
Reclaim the future. Rewrite the past. Reforj the world.
Why similar: Voxel 36.5% ★, Sandbox 22.6%, Physics 17.3%, Nature 15.5%, 3D 5.8%
- #58 Apples Gone Wild Simulator 2025
66% matchNo user reviews
Dev: OnTriggerJoy
Windows
Apples Gone Wild Simulator lets you play mad scientist with apple DNA. Plant mutated apples, grow experimental trees, and uncover delightfully strange traits from musical fruit to apples that stare into your soul.
Why similar: Sandbox 31.9%, Nature 19.4%, Casual 12.3%, Simulation 12.1%, Cute 11.1%
- #59 Autofading_Se disparaître
69% matchNo user reviews2023
Dev: Sporobole
Windows
This work uses virtual reality and non-linear sound composition technologies to poetically explore the presence of human beings in their environment. Immersed in a forest generated by point cloud data, which evolves according to their observational attitude and type of attention they give to it.
Why similar: Nature 30.4%, Physics 13.1%, First-Person 12.6%, Sandbox 10.8%, Simulation 9.1%
- #60 Grass and Cash
66% matchNo user reviews2026
Dev: VirginMage Pub: VirginMage
Windows · Mac · Linux
Bad news: you're in debt. Good news: there's cash buried in the grass. Worse news: you're starting with nail scissors. Start mowing.
Why similar: Sandbox 30.1%, Physics 15%, Relaxing 14.2%, Simulation 12.5%, Indie 9.8%